📘 Lecture 34 — Restructuring Organizations
📖 Overview: This lecture examines techno-structural interventions, focusing on how organizations can restructure themselves from rigid bureaucracies to leaner, more flexible forms. It covers traditional structural designs—functional, self-contained-unit, and matrix—as well as newer integrative forms like process-based structures, along with downsizing and reengineering as key restructuring approaches.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by explaining the pressures driving organizational restructuring, including global competition and technological change. It then provides a detailed analysis of five structural designs: functional organization, self-contained-unit organization, matrix organization, and process-based structures. For each structure, the lecture discusses advantages, disadvantages, and contingency factors that determine when each form is most appropriate. The topics of downsizing (reducing personnel through layoffs, redesign, and outsourcing) and reengineering (radically redesigning core work processes) are also introduced as key techno-structural interventions.
📝 Lecture Summary
Structural Design
Organization structure describes how the overall work of the organization is divided into subunits and how these subunits are coordinated for task completion. It is a key feature of an organization’s strategic orientation. Based on a contingency perspective (Figure 41), organization structures should be designed to fit with at least five factors: the environment, organization size, technology, organization strategy, and worldwide operations. Organization effectiveness depends on the extent to which its structures are responsive to these contingencies.
Organizations traditionally have structured themselves into one of three forms: functional departments that are task specialized; self-contained units oriented to specific products, customers, or regions; or matrix structures that combine both functional specialization and self-containment. More recent innovations include process-based structures designed around core work processes, and network-based structures that link the organization to interdependent organizations.
💡 Why this matters: The choice of organizational structure directly impacts how efficiently work gets done, how information flows, and how adaptable the organization is to changing conditions.
The Functional Organization
Perhaps the most widely used organizational structure, the functional structure (Figure 42) subdivides the organization into units such as engineering, research, operations, human resources, finance, and marketing. It is based on early management theories regarding specialization, line and staff relations, span of control, authority, and responsibility. Major functional subunits are staffed by specialists, and it is considered easier to manage specialists if they are grouped together under the same head who has training in that discipline.
On the positive side, functional structures promote specialization of skills and resources by grouping people who perform similar work. This facilitates communication within departments and allows specialists to share expertise, enhancing career development within the specialty. The functional structure reduces duplication of services because it makes the best use of people and resources.
On the negative side, functional structures tend to promote routine tasks with a limited orientation. Department members focus on their own tasks rather than the organization’s total task, which can lead to conflict across departments when each group tries to maximize its own performance. Coordination and scheduling among departments can be difficult when each emphasizes its own perspective.
🔑 Definition — Functional structure: An organizational form that groups activities by specialized functions (e.g., engineering, marketing, finance), with departments staffed by specialists in those disciplines.
📐 Contingency: Functional structure works best in small-to-medium-sized firms with stable environments, routine technologies, interdependence within functions, and goals emphasizing efficiency and technical quality.
📌 Example: A manufacturing company with separate departments for engineering, production, sales, and accounting. Each department head is a specialist in that area, and engineers communicate primarily with other engineers, while salespeople communicate with other salespeople.
The Self-Contained-Unit Organization
The self-contained-unit structure (also called product or divisional structure) groups organizational activities on the basis of products, services, customers, or geography. All or most resources necessary to accomplish a specific objective are set up as a self-contained unit headed by a product or division manager. For example, General Electric has plants specializing in jet engines and others producing household appliances, each reporting to a division vice president rather than a manufacturing vice president.
These structures recognize key interdependencies and coordinate resources toward an overall outcome. This strong outcome orientation ensures departmental accountability and promotes cohesion among those contributing to the product. Self-contained units provide employees with opportunities for learning new skills and are well suited for developing general managers.
Disadvantages include potentially inefficient use of specialized skills, specialists feeling isolated from professional colleagues, promotion of allegiance to department rather than organization objectives, and multiple demands on people creating stress.
🔑 Definition — Self-contained-unit structure: An organizational form that groups activities by product, service, customer, or geography, with each unit containing most resources needed to accomplish its specific objective.
📐 Contingency: Self-contained-unit structure works best in large organizations with unstable and uncertain environments, technological interdependence across functions, and goals of product specialization and innovation.
📌 Example: A large corporation like Procter & Gamble organizing into divisions such as Beauty, Grooming, Health Care, and Fabric & Home Care, each with its own research, manufacturing, and marketing resources.
The Matrix Organization
The matrix organization superimposes the lateral structure of a product or project coordinator on the vertical functional structure (Figure 44). It evolved in the aerospace industry where changing customer demands and technological conditions required managers to focus on lateral relationships between functions. Matrix organizations contain three unique roles: the top manager who heads and balances the dual chains of command, the matrix bosses (functional and product/area) who share subordinates, and the two-boss managers who report to different matrix bosses.
For example, all engineers may be in one engineering department reporting to an engineering manager, but these same engineers may be assigned to different projects and report to a project manager while working on that project. Each engineer may have to work under several managers.
On the positive side, this structure allows multiple orientations, specialized functional knowledge applied to all projects, quick implementation of new projects by using people flexibly, and consistency among departments and projects through communication among managers.
On the negative side, matrix organizations can be difficult to manage, requiring heavy managerial costs and support. There may be role ambiguity and conflict, and overall performance may suffer from power conflicts between functional and project structures.
🔑 Definition — Matrix organization: An organizational form that combines functional and product/project structures by superimposing a lateral reporting structure on a vertical functional structure, creating dual reporting relationships.
📐 Contingency: Matrix structures are appropriate under three conditions: (1) outside pressures for dual focus (customer demands and technical sophistication), (2) need for high information processing capacity, and (3) pressures for shared resources.
📌 Example: An aerospace company where engineers belong to an engineering department but are assigned to specific projects (e.g., Project A, Project B). Each engineer reports to both an engineering manager and a project manager.
Process-Based Structures
Process-based structures form multidisciplinary teams around core processes such as product development, order fulfillment, sales generation, and customer support. As shown in Figure 45, these structures emphasize lateral rather than vertical relationships. All functions necessary to produce a product or service are placed in a common unit managed by a "process owner." There are few hierarchical levels, and the senior executive team is small.
Process-based structures eliminate many hierarchical and departmental boundaries that impede task coordination, reduce costs of managing across departments, and enable organizations to focus resources on serving customers.
Key features include:
- Processes drive structure: Organized around three to five key processes, each governed by a process owner with clear performance goals.
- Work adds value: Work is simplified by eliminating nonessential tasks and enriched by combining tasks so teams perform whole processes.
- Teams are fundamental: Self-managing teams manage everything from task execution to strategic planning.
- Customers define performance: Customer satisfaction is the primary goal.
- Teams are rewarded for performance: Appraisal systems focus on team performance against customer satisfaction goals.
- Teams are tightly linked to suppliers and customers
- Team members are well informed and trained
The main advantage is intense focus on meeting customer needs, resulting in dramatic improvements in speed, efficiency, and customer satisfaction. Process-based structures remove layers of management, improve information flow, and increase flexibility.
Major disadvantages include difficulty of change, need for radical shifts in mindsets and skills, potential duplication of scarce resources, slower decision making in unskilled teams, and risk of misidentifying critical processes.
🔑 Definition — Process-based structure: An organizational form that organizes work around core business processes using multidisciplinary, self-managing teams, with few hierarchical levels and a focus on customer satisfaction.
📐 Contingency: Process-based structures are appropriate for highly uncertain environments with rapidly changing customer demands and market conditions, non-routine and highly interdependent technologies, and customer-oriented goals.
📌 Example: A company like 3M or Xerox organizing around core processes such as "order fulfillment" or "product development" rather than functional departments, with teams responsible for the entire process from start to finish.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Organizational restructuring is driven by global competition and rapid environmental changes, forcing organizations to move from rigid bureaucracies to leaner, more flexible structures. Five major structural designs exist, each with specific advantages, disadvantages, and contingency factors: functional structures suit stable environments and routine technologies; self-contained-unit structures fit uncertain conditions and large organizations; matrix structures work when there is dual focus, high information processing needs, and shared resources; and process-based structures are best for rapidly changing environments with customer-oriented goals. The choice of structure must align with environmental conditions, organization size, technology, strategy, and global operations. Downsizing and reengineering are complementary interventions that reduce costs and radically redesign work processes, respectively, and must be aligned with organizational strategy for success.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five contingency factors that influence structural design according to the lecture?
- What are the three unique roles found in every matrix organization, and what is the primary challenge for the "two-boss manager"?
- Under what three conditions is a matrix structure most appropriate, and what happens if any of these conditions is not met?
- What are the key features that characterize process-based structures, and what is the primary risk if critical processes are misidentified?
- Compare the disadvantages of functional structures and self-contained-unit structures—what is the fundamental trade-off between specialization and outcome orientation?
📘 Lecture 35 — Network-Based Structures: Restructuring Organizations
📖 Overview: This lecture examines three major restructuring interventions in organizations: network-based structures, downsizing, and reengineering. It explains how organizations can fundamentally redesign their structures, reduce their size, or radically transform their business processes to achieve improved performance and adaptability in dynamic environments.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers four types of network structures (internal market, vertical market, inter-market, and opportunity networks), their characteristics including vertical desegregation and brokers, advantages and disadvantages of network forms, downsizing interventions including four major causes and five application stages, the results and effectiveness of downsizing, and reengineering as a radical redesign of business processes with its own application stages and guidelines.
📝 Lecture Summary
Network-Based Structures
A network-based structure manages the diverse, complex, and dynamic relationships among multiple organizations or units, each specializing in a particular business function or task. Networks can be classified into four basic types:
- Internal market network: A single organization establishes each subunit as an independent profit center allowed to buy and sell services from each other and from the external market. Example: Asea Brown Boveri's (ABB) fifty worldwide businesses with forty-five hundred profit centers.
- Vertical market network: Multiple organizations linked to a focal organization coordinating resource movement from raw materials to end consumer. Example: Nike manufacturing shoes in different plants and distributing through retail outlets.
- Inter-market network: Alliances among organizations in different markets, exemplified by Japanese keiretsu and Korean chaebol.
- Opportunity network: The most advanced form—a temporary constellation of organizations brought together to pursue a single purpose, then disbanded.
These types are distinguished by whether they are single or multiple organizations, single or multiple industry, and stable or temporary. The network structure redraws organizational boundaries and links separate business units to facilitate task interaction. Network organizations use strategic alliances, joint ventures, R&D consortia, licensing agreements, and wholly owned subsidiaries.
🔑 Definition — Network-based structure: A structure that manages diverse, complex, and dynamic relationships among multiple organizations or units, each specializing in a particular business function or task.
💡 Why this matters: Understanding the four network types helps organizations choose the right structural form for their strategic needs—whether stable internal coordination or temporary external partnerships.
Characteristics of Network Structures:
-
Vertical desegregation: Breaking up business functions (production, marketing, distribution) into separate organizations performing specialized work. Recent disintermediation—replacement of whole steps in the value chain by information technology, especially the Internet—has fueled network development.
-
Brokers: Organizations that locate and assemble member organizations. The broker may play a central role (subcontracting) or specialize in linking equal partners.
-
Coordinating mechanisms: Networks are not controlled by hierarchy but by three categories:
- Informal relationships: Interpersonal relationships with well-developed partnerships; conflicts resolved through reciprocity; trust built over time
- Formal contracts: Ownership control, licensing arrangements, purchase agreements
- Market mechanisms: Spot payments, performance accountability, information systems
Advantages and Disadvantages:
| Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|
| Highly flexible and adaptive | Managing lateral relations is difficult |
| Creates "best-of-the-best" organization | Motivating members to relinquish autonomy is troublesome |
| Each organization leverages distinctive competency | Sustaining membership and benefits is problematic |
| Permits rapid global expansion | May expose proprietary knowledge/technology |
| Can produce synergistic results |
Contingencies: Networks suit highly complex and uncertain environments, organizations of all sizes, goals of specialization and innovation, highly uncertain technologies, and worldwide operations.
The major problem with network organizations is managing such complex structures—they are essentially matrix organizations extending beyond single firms but lacking authority to resolve conflicts. Skills in managing lateral relations across boundaries are critical.
Downsizing
Downsizing refers to interventions aimed at reducing the size of the organization, typically by decreasing employees through layoffs, attrition, redeployment, or early retirement, or by reducing units or managerial levels through divestiture, outsourcing, reorganization, or delayering.
An important consequence has been the rise of the contingent workforce—less expensive temporary or permanent part-time workers often hired by organizations that just laid off thousands. A study by the American Management Association found nearly a third of 720 firms had rehired terminated employees as independent contractors because downsizings weren't matched by workload reduction.
🔑 Definition — Downsizing: Interventions aimed at reducing organization size through decreasing employees or organizational units/managerial levels.
Four Major Conditions Leading to Downsizing:
- Mergers and acquisitions—one in nine job cuts during 1998 resulted from integration of two organizations
- Organization decline from loss of revenues, market share, and technological/industrial change
- Implementation of new organizational structures—network structures often involve outsourcing non-core work
- Beliefs and social pressures that smaller is better—but Hamel and Prahalad warned about "corporate anorexia" where organizations downsize for their own sake without thinking about future growth
Application Stages of Downsizing:
1. Clarify the organization's strategy: Leaders specify corporate strategy and communicate how downsizing relates to it—downsizing is not a goal but a restructuring process for achieving strategic objectives. Provide opportunities for members to voice concerns and obtain counseling.
2. Assess downsizing options and make relevant choices: Table 17 describes three primary downsizing methods:
| Downsizing Tactic | Characteristics | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Workforce reduction | Aimed at headcount reduction; short-term; fosters transition | Attrition, transfer, retirement incentives, buyout packages, layoffs |
| Organization redesign | Aimed at organization change; moderate-term; fosters transition and potential transformation | Eliminate functions, merge units, eliminate layers, eliminate products, redesign tasks |
| Systemic redesign | Aimed at culture change; long-term; fosters transformation | Change responsibility, involve all constituents, foster continuous improvement, simplification |
📌 Example: Case, a heavy construction equipment manufacturer, eliminated money-losing product lines, narrowed remaining product lines, shifted production to outside vendors, restructured debt, and spun off most of its 250 stores, leading to closing five plants and payroll reductions of almost 35%.
Organizations often choose layoffs because they can be implemented quickly, but this produces a climate of fear and defensiveness. Employee participation in decisions can help create urgency for alternatives and increase perceptions of fairness.
3. Implement the changes: Successful implementation is characterized by:
- Downsizing controlled from the top down
- Identifying and targeting specific areas of inefficiency and high cost
- Linking specific actions to strategy
- Communicating frequently using a variety of media
4. Address the needs of survivors and those who leave: "Survivor syndrome" involves self-absorbed and risk-averse behaviors—survivors are preoccupied with whether additional layoffs will occur, guilt over receiving pay while coworkers struggle, and uncertainty about career advancement. Organizations can address this through communication about vision and strategy, training and development, and promoting greater involvement in decision making. For those laid off, methods include outplacement counseling, personal and family counseling, severance packages, office support for job searches, relocation services, and job retraining.
5. Follow through with growth plans: Implement an organization renewal and growth process. Failure to move quickly to implement growth plans is a key determinant of ineffective downsizing. Only 44% of downsized companies shared growth plans with employees; only 34% told employees how they would fit into the new strategy.
Results of Downsizing:
The empirical research is mostly negative. The National Research Council concluded downsizing has "proven to be, by and large, a failure." Key findings:
- Fewer than half of firms met cost targets
- Only 22% achieved expected productivity gains
- About 80% needed to rehire some terminated people
- Fewer than 33% reported profits increased as expected
- Only 21% achieved satisfactory shareholder return on investment
- Individual problems include increased stress and illness, loss of self-esteem, reduced trust and loyalty, marriage and family disruptions
Financial performance studies also show negative results. In 210 companies announcing layoffs, financial performance increases in the first year were not followed by improvements in the next year. Stock prices increased on announcement day but then began a steady decline.
However, these results must be interpreted cautiously because:
- Survey respondents (HR specialists) may view downsizing negatively
- Studies may include biased samples of poorly managed firms
- Disappointing results may reflect poor implementation rather than downsizing itself
Companies that implemented effectively scored significantly higher on performance measures. Success may depend as much on how effectively the intervention is applied as on the size of layoffs.
Reengineering
Reengineering is the fundamental rethinking and radical redesign of business processes to achieve dramatic improvements in performance. It transforms how organizations traditionally produce and deliver goods and services. Unlike incremental approaches like total quality management, reengineering radically alters the status quo to produce dramatic increases in performance.
🔑 Definition — Reengineering: The fundamental rethinking and radical redesign of business processes to achieve dramatic improvements in performance.
Reengineering frequently takes advantage of new information technology—teleconferencing, expert systems, shared databases, wireless communication—to break out of traditional ways of thinking about work. The most popular software system, SAP, allows firms to standardize information systems by processing data across tasks and integrating information flow.
📌 Example: At IBM Credit, an integrated information system with expert systems technology enables one employee to handle all stages of the credit-delivery process, eliminating handoffs, delays, and errors from the traditional sequential work design.
Reengineering is associated with downsizing, the shift from functional to process-based structures, and work design. It results in new jobs or teams emphasizing multifunctional tasks, results-oriented feedback, and employee empowerment. However, reengineering has failed to apply attention to individual differences in people's reactions to work.
Application Stages of Reengineering:
1. Prepare the organization: Clarify and assess the organization's context, including competitive environment, strategy, and objectives. Establish the need for reengineering and the strategic direction.
2. Specify organization strategy and objectives: Business strategy determines the focus of reengineering and guides decisions about essential business processes. Communicate clearly why reengineering is necessary and the direction it will take. Senior executives must demonstrate unwavering support.
📌 Example: GTE Telephone Operations executives determined deregulation would spread to the local network, presenting a competitive challenge. They set dramatic goals of doubling revenues while halving costs and reducing product development time by 75%.
3. Fundamentally rethink the way work gets done: This involves three activities:
a. Identify and analyze core business processes: Core processes transform inputs into valued outputs. Assess through process mapping listing different activities required to deliver products or services. Analysis can include assigning costs to major phases using process-based accounting (rather than traditional cost accounting by categories of expense).
📌 Example: At Dana Corporation, traditional accounting showed salaries and fringe benefits accounting for 82% of costs, suggesting workforce downsizing. Process-based accounting revealed 44% of costs involved expediting, resolving, and reissuing orders—reworking deficient orders.
Business processes can be assessed in terms of value-added activities—the amount of value contributed to a product or service by a particular step. Organizations often engage in processes with little or no added value.
📌 Example: At a Denver hospital, employees checked a pump that circulated oxygen every shift—eight years after a new pump with fault-protection equipment had been installed that no longer required physical inspection. The habit remained, draining resources.
b. Define performance objectives: Set challenging performance goals derived from customer requirements or benchmarks of best practices.
📌 Example: Andersen Windows had 28,000 products in 1991 growing to 86,000. Pressure for "batch of one" resulted in 20% of shipments with order discrepancies. They set targets for ease of ordering, manufacturing, and delivery, selling interactive computerized catalogues. By 1995, new sales tripled at some locations, products increased to 188,000, and fewer than 1 in 200 shipments had discrepancies.
c. Design new processes: Start with a clean sheet of paper addressing "If we were starting this company today, what processes would we need?" Follow these guidelines:
- Begin and end with customer needs and wants
- Simplify by combining and eliminating steps
- Use "best of what is" in current process
- Attend to both technical and social aspects
- Do not be constrained by past practice
- Identify critical information required at each step
- Perform activities in their most natural order
- Assume work gets done right the first time
- Listen to people who do the work
Implement "early wins" or "quick hits"—obvious redundancies and inefficiencies that can be changed immediately to generate momentum.
4. Restructure the organization around the new business processes: Change the organization's structure to support new business processes, resulting in process-based structures. Implement new information and measurement systems shifting from measuring behaviors (absenteeism, grievances) to assessing outcomes (productivity, customer satisfaction, cost savings). Information technology is a key driver because it can drastically reduce cost and time of integrating and coordinating business processes.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts from this lecture are: (1) Network-based structures come in four types—internal market, vertical market, inter-market, and opportunity networks—each with different configurations of single/multiple organizations, single/multiple industries, and stable/temporary arrangements, and they rely on vertical desegregation, brokers, and three coordinating mechanisms (informal relationships, contracts, market mechanisms). (2) Downsizing interventions have five application stages—clarify strategy, assess options (workforce reduction, organization redesign, systemic redesign), implement changes, address survivor and leaver needs, and follow through with growth plans—and the research overwhelmingly shows negative results unless implemented effectively. (3) Reengineering is a radical redesign of business processes using four application stages—prepare, specify strategy, rethink work (identify core processes, define objectives, design new processes), and restructure around new processes—and it benefits from process-based accounting, value-added analysis, and information technology like SAP. (4) All three interventions share the theme that implementation quality matters more than the intervention itself. (5) Survivor syndrome and corporate anorexia are critical negative consequences that must be managed through communication, participation, and growth planning.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
-
What are the four types of network structures, and how do they differ in terms of single/multiple organizations, single/multiple industries, and stable/temporary characteristics?
-
Describe the three coordinating mechanisms used in network organizations and explain how they replace hierarchical control.
-
What are the five application stages of downsizing, and what specific tactics are available under workforce reduction, organization redesign, and systemic redesign approaches?
-
What is "survivor syndrome" and what specific communication and support strategies can organizations use to address it during downsizing?
-
What are the four application stages of reengineering, and what guidelines should be followed when designing new business processes?
📘 Lecture 36 — Employee Involvement
📖 Overview: This lecture examines Employee Involvement (EI) as a set of practices and philosophies that enhance participation, commitment, and productivity by moving decision-making downward in organizations. It covers the four key elements of EI, how EI affects productivity, and three major applications: parallel structures, cooperative union-management projects, and total quality management.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with a working definition of Employee Involvement, detailing its four key elements: power, information, knowledge and skills, and rewards. It then explores how EI affects productivity through improved communication, motivation, and capabilities. The major applications discussed include parallel structures (with application stages), cooperative union-management projects, quality circles, high-involvement organizations, and total quality management. A case study of a Work-Out session at General Electric Medical Systems and a union-management cooperation program at GTE California illustrate practical implementation.
📝 Lecture Summary
Employee Involvement: What is it?
Employee involvement is the current label for practices and philosophies that began with the quality-of-work-life movement in the late 1950s. The phrase "quality of work life" originally stressed the poor quality of life at the workplace. EI seeks to increase members' input into decisions that affect organization performance and employee well-being.
A Working Definition of Employee Involvement
Employee involvement is described in terms of four key elements that promote worker involvement:
-
Power: Providing people with enough authority to make work-related decisions covering issues such as work methods, task assignments, performance outcomes, customer service, and employee selection. The amount of power can vary from simply asking for input, to joint decision-making, to employees making decisions themselves.
-
Information: Timely access to relevant information is vital to making effective decisions. Organizations can promote EI by ensuring necessary information flows freely to those with decision authority, including data about operating results, business plans, competitive conditions, new technologies, and work methods.
-
Knowledge and skills: Employee involvement contributes to organizational effectiveness only to the extent that employees have the requisite skills and knowledge to make good decisions. Organizations can facilitate EI by providing training and development programs for improving members' knowledge and skills.
-
Rewards: Because people generally do things for which they are recognized, rewards can have a powerful effect on getting people involved. Internal rewards include feelings of self-worth and accomplishment; external rewards include pay and promotions linked to performance outcomes.
💡 Why this matters: These four elements are interdependent and must be changed together to obtain positive results. If members are given more power but lack information or knowledge, the value of involvement is negligible. Similarly, increasing power, information, and knowledge without linking rewards to performance gives members little incentive to improve.
How Employee Involvement Affects Productivity
Research has found a consistent relationship between EI practices and productivity measures such as financial performance, customer satisfaction, labor hours, and waste rates. The traditional view that satisfaction causes productivity is too simplistic.
EI practices improve productivity in at least three ways:
- Improved communication and coordination among employees and departments
- Improved employee motivation, particularly when satisfying important individual needs — motivation translates to performance when people have necessary skills and the work situation allows productivity to be affected
- Improved capabilities of employees through skill training in group problem solving and communication
Secondary effects include increased employee well-being and satisfaction, which can attract and retain good employees. Higher levels of EI produce correspondingly higher levels of performance.
Employee Involvement Applications
Three major EI applications vary in the amount of power, information, knowledge and skills, and rewards moved downward through the organization: parallel structures (least involvement), high-involvement organizations, and total quality management (most involvement).
Parallel Structures
Parallel structures involve members in resolving ill-defined, complex problems and build adaptability into bureaucratic organizations. Also known as "collateral structures," "dualistic structures," or "shadow structures," they operate in conjunction with the formal organization, providing an alternative setting to address problems free from formal constraints.
Parallel structures fall at the lower end of the EI scale — member participation is typically restricted to making proposals and suggestions, with implementation decisions reserved for management. They are most appropriate for organizations with little history of employee participation, top-down management styles, and bureaucratic cultures.
Application Stages:
- Define the purpose and scope — involves defining purpose and initial expectations; organizational diagnosis helps clarify specific problems
- Form a steering committee — composed of acknowledged leaders of various functions; performs tasks including refining scope, developing vision, guiding creation, establishing linkage mechanisms, creating problem-solving groups, and ensuring senior management support
- Communicate with organization members — effectiveness depends on high member involvement; communicating purpose, procedures, and rewards promotes participation
- Form employee problem-solving groups — primary means of accomplishing purpose; involves selecting members representing appropriate hierarchical levels, expertise, functions, and constituencies; providing training; and offering facilitation
- Address the problems and issues — groups use an action research process: diagnose problems, plan solutions, implement and evaluate
- Implement and evaluate the changes — involves implementing organizational changes, assessing results, and providing feedback to help the organization learn to adapt and innovate
🔑 Definition — Parallel Structure: A structure that operates alongside the formal organization, providing members with an alternative setting to address problems and propose innovative solutions free from formal constraints.
📐 Formula: Parallel Structures = Formal Organization + Collateral Structure → Alternative Problem-Solving Setting
📌 Example: A Work-Out session at General Electric Medical Systems (GEMS) involved about 50 employees and managers gathering for a five-day session. Teams engaged in "bureaucracy busting" by identifying CRAP (Critical Review Appraisals) — needless approvals, policies, meetings, and reports that stifled productivity. Senior managers were not part of these discussions. At the end, managers made instant, on-the-spot decisions about each idea (approved, rejected with reasons, or need more data). The session ended with close to 100 written contracts to implement new processes or drop unnecessary work.
Cooperative Union-Management Projects
Cooperative union-management projects are one of the oldest EI applications of parallel structures, associated with the original QWL movement. They have a long history in Scandinavian countries but are relatively new to OD in the United States.
Structural characteristics:
- Steering committee: Top-level labor-management committee serving as the basic planning center, comprising key representatives from management and unions
- Multiple-level committees: Working committees at plant, department, and shop-floor levels dealing with day-to-day activities
- Ad hoc committees: Established for specific tasks with a limited lifetime, initiated to bring about change toward a particular goal
- External consultants: Third-party facilitators offering guidance, assistance, and problem-solving and teamwork training
- External researchers: Brought in to assess overall results, keeping evaluation separate from consulting
📌 Example — GTE California (GTEC): In response to the court-ordered breakup of AT&T, GTEC and the Communications Workers of America embarked on a cooperative union-management project. A steering committee established a parallel structure with three area coordinating committees, support committees, and EI teams staffed with both union and management personnel. All 26,000 employees attended a two-hour orientation. A three-day training program was conducted for supervisors and union officials (trained separately for two days, together on the third). EI team members attended five-day training in meeting-management skills, problem-solving techniques, and group dynamics. One team worked for over two years to simplify field employee time reporting, producing savings of more than $3 million. Between 1987 and 1988, the program produced net savings of more than $1 million. By 1991, GTEC surpassed its competition in customer satisfaction measures.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Employee Involvement is defined by four interdependent elements—power, information, knowledge and skills, and rewards—that must be moved downward together for positive results. EI improves productivity through three mechanisms: improved communication and coordination, enhanced motivation, and increased employee capabilities. Parallel structures are the lowest level of EI involvement, most suitable for organizations with no history of participation, and follow six implementation stages from defining purpose to evaluating changes. Cooperative union-management projects represent the oldest EI application and require steering committees, multiple-level committees, ad hoc committees, and external consultants to function effectively. The case studies of GE Medical Systems Work-Out and GTE California demonstrate that successful EI implementation requires systematic training, clear communication, management commitment to instant decision-making, and a focus on both quality-of-work-life and productivity objectives.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four key elements of Employee Involvement, and why must they be changed together?
- Explain three ways EI interventions can improve productivity, according to the lecture.
- What are the six application stages for implementing parallel structures?
- What structural characteristics are common to cooperative union-management projects?
- How did GTE California's EI program demonstrate the importance of modifying focus from quality-of-work-life issues to productivity-related changes?