๐ Lecture 5 โ Some Basic Concepts and Definitions
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces foundational concepts in change management, focusing on organizational learning, learning organizations, and various types of change. It provides essential definitions and frameworks that help managers understand how organizations adapt, learn, and transform in response to internal and external pressures.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers Organizational Learning (OL) including single and double loop learning, the Learning Organisation (LO) with Peter Senge's five disciplines, the learning cycle and unlearning concepts, strategic change versus process change, adaptive versus generative change, Schein's typology of change (natural evolutionary, planned & managed, unplanned revolutionary), and logical incrementalism as a change management approach.
๐ Lecture Summary
Organizational Learning (OL)
This refers to the continuous improvement of existing approaches and processes of adaptation to change, leading to new goals and/or approaches. In other words, Organizational Learning can be viewed as the organization's detection and correction of error, where error is mismatch between the organizationโs intentions and what really happened (Argyris 1989).
Single loop learning is defined as the organizationโs ability to perceive deviation from performance and to โfixโ them (refers to diagnostic management control system). This is something pre-programmed and content specific.
Double loop learning (more sophisticated) emphasises that organization must review the underlying assumption that created the problem to be โfixedโ in the first place, and seek and adapt a better assumptions for future performance. This entails questioning and adjustment of policies and objectives, and is process-oriented.
๐ Definition โ Single loop learning: The organization's ability to detect deviations from performance and correct them without questioning underlying assumptions. ๐ Definition โ Double loop learning: A more sophisticated learning process where organizations review and change the underlying assumptions that created the problem in the first place. ๐ Example: In single loop learning, if sales targets are missed, the organization might increase advertising spending. In double loop learning, the organization would question whether the sales target itself is realistic or whether the product strategy needs fundamental rethinking.
Learning Organisation (LO)
Peter Senge, the author of Fifth Discipline gave the concept which essentially means that just like individuals, Organizations also tend to learn. A Learning Organisation is one where people continually expand their capacity to create the results they truly desire, where new and expansive patterns of thinking are nurtured, where collective aspiration is set free, and where people are continually learning how to learn together.
The five disciplines are:
- Systems thinking
- Personal mastery - skills, values and competence
- Mental models - are deeply ingrained assumptions, or even pictures or images that influence how we understand the world and how we take action
- Shared vision โ common aspiration/objective
- Team Learning โ dialogue and thinking together
๐ Definition โ Learning Organisation: An organization where people continually expand their capacity to create results they desire, where new thinking patterns are nurtured, and people learn how to learn together.
๐ก Why this matters: Senge's five disciplines provide a comprehensive framework for building organizations that can adapt and thrive in changing environments, rather than merely reacting to problems.
Learning Cycle
Includes the following stages: planning, execution of plans, assessment of progress, revision of plans.
Un-learn
Schein believes in unlearning for change to occur: the organisation must unlearn previous beliefs, be open to new inputs, and re-learn new assumptions and behaviour.
๐ Definition โ Unlearning: The process of discarding previous beliefs, assumptions, and behaviors to make way for new learning and adaptation.
Strategic Change
The concept is broader in its scope; Strategic Change is change that is driven by โstrategyโ and โenvironmental forcesโ, and is tied closely to the organizationโs ability to achieve its goals. For e.g. merger, acquisition, down-sizing, acquisition, joint venture. Or in other words it is the role and impact of environmental forces like government, societal, technological or political changes is decisive which an organization has to bear and incorporate in its strategic output.
๐ Definition โ Strategic Change: Broad-scope change driven by strategy and environmental forces, tied to the organization's ability to achieve its goals.
Process Change
The focus is within organization changes, narrower in scope, and is confined to a particular unit, division or function of the organisation. Process Change relates to basically an examination and adjustment of organizational or managerial processes. Nadler & Tushman identified this as โTuningโ meant to increase efficiency.
๐ Definition โ Process Change: Narrower-scope change focused on internal organizational or managerial processes within a specific unit, division, or function.
Adaptive Change
Adaptive changes are incremental and evolutionary in nature, analogous to the concept of โworking in the systemโ โ more directed towards changes and management on day-to-day organizational transactions.
๐ Definition โ Adaptive Change: Incremental, evolutionary changes that work within the existing system to manage day-to-day organizational transactions.
Generative Change
Generative Changes which likely entail a quantum break through, generates essentially new ways of doing things. Revolutionary in nature and also referred as transformation โWorking on the system.โ
๐ Definition โ Generative Change: Revolutionary, quantum breakthrough changes that create fundamentally new ways of doing things; also known as transformation.
๐ก Why this matters: The distinction between adaptive and generative change helps managers understand when incremental adjustments are sufficient versus when fundamental transformation is required for organizational survival.
Scheinโs Typology
-
Natural Evolutionary: Something which is all the time going on in an organization. This is known as learning process occurring in organization taking place knowingly and unknowingly. This refers to environmental adaptation, synonymous with evolutionary change, may be progressive leading to growth and development or regressive or degenerating one leading to organization illness or death.
-
Planned & Managed Change: As the name suggests, this type of change means one can control the direction of change and learning. Learning can be controlled. Managers can stabilize the processes that need to be stabilised, even organization culture can be changed and managed. So one can change and stabilize some ways of working.
-
Unplanned Revolutionary Change: Refers to impact of turbulent and unstable environment which creates disequilibrium and high uncertainty for organizationsโ strategy and structure.
๐ Definition โ Natural Evolutionary Change: Ongoing learning process occurring knowingly and unknowingly in organizations; environmental adaptation that can be progressive or regressive. ๐ Definition โ Planned & Managed Change: Change where managers can control direction, stabilize processes, and even change organizational culture. ๐ Definition โ Unplanned Revolutionary Change: Change resulting from turbulent, unstable environments causing disequilibrium and high uncertainty.
Logical Incrementalism
A concept which gained wide currency in designing and managing change, articulated by J. B. Quinn. Logical Incrementalism acknowledges that change management is complex and time-consuming where internal and external forces exert significant pressures to resist change. Keeping this in view, the logical incrementalism process focuses on the evolution of the change as broad goals are more narrowly defined and adapted.
The process comprises of the following stages:
- Change is considered as a general concern โ a vaguely felt awareness of an issue or opportunity
- Broadcasting of a general idea without details โ the idea is floated for reactions pro and con, and for refinements of change plan or idea.
- Formal development of a change plan
- Use of a crisis or opportunity to stimulate implementation of the change plan. For example, retirement of a senior manager or a sudden loss of market share can facilitate rapid acceptance and implementation of the change plan
- Adaptation of the plan as implementation progresses.
This approach has its advocates and critics. Many top level managers consider it appropriate to bring successful change in organization by floating an idea early on, a leader can improve the quality of information generated before decisions are made and can overcome emotional and political barriers. While the critics of logical incrementalism see this as disjointed, garbage-can approach, or as managerial muddling. These complaints are valid if change plans are unclear or poorly formulated.
๐ Definition โ Logical Incrementalism: A change management approach where broad goals are progressively narrowed and adapted through a series of stages, allowing for evolution of the change plan.
๐ก Why this matters: Logical incrementalism provides a practical middle ground between rigid top-down planning and chaotic unplanned change, allowing managers to test ideas and build consensus gradually.
โญ Key Takeaways
Students must remember the distinction between single loop learning (fixing errors without questioning assumptions) and double loop learning (changing underlying assumptions). Senge's five disciplines of a learning organisationโsystems thinking, personal mastery, mental models, shared vision, and team learningโform a complete framework. The three types of change in Schein's typologyโnatural evolutionary, planned & managed, and unplanned revolutionaryโexplain different change contexts. Strategic change differs from process change in scope and focus. Logical incrementalism involves five stages from vague awareness to adaptation, and while it has critics who see it as muddling, many managers find it effective for overcoming resistance.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the key difference between single loop learning and double loop learning?
- Name Peter Senge's five disciplines of a learning organisation.
- According to Schein, what must occur before new learning can take place in an organization?
- How does strategic change differ from process change in terms of scope?
- What are the five stages of the logical incrementalism process as articulated by J.B. Quinn?
๐ Lecture 6 โ Transactional vs. Transformational Leadership
๐ Overview: This lecture distinguishes between transactional and transformational leadership approaches, exploring how organizations operate differently under each model. It further examines various types of organizational change (first-order, second-order, middle-order, micro, and mega changes), the concepts of human and social capital, four types of organizational culture, organization development (OD), and the idea of the organizational meme. Understanding these distinctions is crucial for managing change effectively in different organizational contexts.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by contrasting transactional (bureaucratic, contract-based) and transformational (inspirational, role-model based) leadership styles. It then defines continuous (first-order) and discontinuous (second-order) change, introduces middle-order change, and distinguishes between micro-changes and mega-changes. The concepts of human capital (individual knowledge and skills) and social capital (linkages and networks) are explained. Four types of organizational culture (power, role, task/achievement, person/support) are described. Finally, Organization Development (OD) is introduced as a system-wide change process, and the concept of the organizational meme (imitative learning) is defined.
๐ Lecture Summary
Transactional
This refers to an approach based strictly on legal contract or agreement and job-description, with no concern for employees or managers beyond these contractual terms. It is considered a bureaucratic or mechanistic way of organizational life, a fragmented approach followed by most developed world states, whose societies are known as litigious societies.
Transformational
In this approach, organizational life goes beyond legality and bureaucratic values. Effective organizations have inspirational leadership, where leaders are role models and focus on learning and grooming followers. Individuals feel involved because of the humane concern of their leaders and become more productive. Unlike the transactional style, this is considered an organic, holistic, and more comprehensive approach. Asiatic management is considered transformational, while Western management is more transactional. ๐ Example: A teacher's role should not be bound merely by a legal contract limited to the classroom; he should be an overall role model, inspiring leadership and ethical values.
Continuous or First-order change
This is change that occurs in a stable system that itself remains unchanged. These variations are necessary for business to grow and thrive in a competitive environment. Evolution theories describe these first-order changes. The natural selection mechanism views the entry and exit of firms as the primary method of evolution. In other words, this refers to gradual changes, such as refining existing processes and procedures within a particular stage of the organizational life cycle. ๐ก Why this matters: This change is incremental and does not alter the core structure of the organization.
Discontinuous or second-order change
This is change that occurs when fundamental properties or the system itself has changed. Examples include the fall of communism or revolutionary changes in technology, competition, and socio-economic conditions in sectors like telecommunication, banking, and electronics. This change leads to the restructuring of industries and changes the bases of competition. A change of stage on the organizational life cycle is a discontinuous change. Quantum change is perceived as better for making organizations a High Performing Organization (HPO).
Middle order change
This is defined as a compromise between first and second-order change. The magnitude of change is greater than first-order, yet it neither affects the critical success factors nor is strategic in nature.
Micro-changes
This classification refers to differences in degree, such as modifications, improvements, enhancements, and upgrades.
Mega-changes
These refer to differences in kindโa structural change, for example, when implementing a new system.
Human Capital
This concept asks whether learning (knowledge creation) is a personal/individual phenomenon or a social/collective phenomenon. Human capital refers to the full range of knowledge, skills, and abilities an individual can use to produce a given set of outcomes. At the upper echelon, managers can scan the environment, solve problems, and seize opportunities. ๐ Definition โ Firm-specific human capital: Knowledge of oneโs own operation, strengths, weaknesses, tacit knowledge, operational personnel, and communication styles. ๐ Definition โ General human capital: Knowledge of and about the larger environment, competitors, suppliers, customers, stakeholders, and dealing with human capital.
Social capital
This refers to the linkages between social actors, the strengths of those linkages, and the resources that flow from them (networking). The key dimensions include: ๐ Definition โ Structural: Relationship pattern among actors. ๐ Definition โ Relational: Trust, norms, obligations, ethics that flow through the relationship. ๐ Definition โ Cognitive: Shared beliefs and languages. ๐ก Why this matters: This includes linkages between upper echelon and the Board of Directors (BOD) for information, advice, and trust. A key question is: what if an organization has human capital minus social capital, or vice-versa?
Four types of organisational change
-
Power culture: Individuals are told what to do. Power is exercised by leaders to change behaviour. Extraneous pressures to perform a role and extrinsic motivation are focussed.
-
Role culture: Individuals act within the limits of their job-description. ๐ Example: Stenographers in the public sector refuse to learn or do a job like fax or e-mail as it is not in their job-description, a narrower interpretation of a job.
-
Task/ achievement culture: Individuals act in a suitable way to complete tasks. People are motivated intrinsically (by autonomy and a sense of satisfaction).
-
Person/Support culture: Individuals use their own initiative.
Organisation Development
OD is a system-wide process of data collection, diagnosis, action planning, intervention, and evaluation aimed at:
- Enhancing congruence between organisation structure, process, strategy, people, and culture.
- Developing new and creative organizational solutions.
- Developing the organization's self-renewal capacity.
The difference between OD and change management is overlapping. However, OD essentially deals with internal aspects of an organization, while change management is broader in scope, concerning both internal and external aspects.
Organisational meme
๐ Definition โ Organisational meme: Any of the core elements of organisational culture (like basic assumptions, norms, standards, symbolic systems) that can be transferred by imitation from one human mind to the next. It is the replicating or copying behaviour, a fundamental way of learning from child psychology. ๐ Example: Students getting admissions in popular subjects (medical, engineering, IT) just because of imitating behaviour. This is also known as the band wagon effect or mass movement. In consumer behaviour, it is known as lifestyle or fashion. Benchmarking at the organisational level represents mimicry, especially when an industry leader does something new and others follow. Even states follow other states' successful economic policies like export promotion, FDI, or trade-liberalisation. Scholars have differing opinions; some believe in its efficacy, while others argue the process could be imperfect, leading to genetic distortion in transferring knowledge.
โญ Key Takeaways
The lecture draws a sharp contrast between transactional (bureaucratic, contract-driven) and transformational (inspirational, holistic) leadership, emphasizing that effective change requires the latter. It is critical to distinguish between continuous (first-order) change, which refines existing systems, and discontinuous (second-order) change, which fundamentally alters the system itself. For exam purposes, remember that human capital is individual knowledge and skills, while social capital consists of the relationships and networks that enable resource flow. Finally, the four types of organizational culture (power, role, task, person) and the concept of the organizational meme as imitative learning are essential frameworks for understanding how change is received and propagated within organizations.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- Compare and contrast transactional and transformational leadership styles.
- Define and provide an original example for both first-order (continuous) and second-order (discontinuous) change.
- What is the difference between human capital and social capital? Why must an organization have both?
- Name and describe the four types of organizational culture as presented in the lecture.
- What is an "organizational meme"? Provide an example of how it manifests in an organizational context (e.g., through benchmarking).
๐ Lecture 21 โ Theories of Change in Organisations
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces the concept of theoretical pluralism in management and presents Van de Ven & Poole's influential framework of four fundamental theories of organizational change. Understanding these theories is crucial because organizations are complex systems where multiple forces interact, and no single theory can fully explain how and why change occurs.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by explaining theoretical pluralism and the "management theory jungle" before presenting four distinct theories of organizational change: life cycle, teleological, dialectical, and evolutionary theories. These theories collectively provide a comprehensive framework for understanding the different mechanisms and motors of change in organizations, serving both normative and inductive research functions.
๐ Lecture Summary
Theoretical Pluralism
Before discussing theories of change, we must first understand theoretical pluralism โ a term widely popular in western society meaning to satisfy differing interests and needs of a cross-section of society. In management, pluralism refers to the simultaneous acceptance of differing and multiple explanations of reality. Koontz referred to this situation as the management theory jungle, where there is a problem of too much conflicting, overlapping, alternative, and varying theories of a single phenomenon in management literature related to motivation, leadership, decision-making, and MBO (Management by Objectives). This leads to fragmentation and compartmentalisation of perspectives, resulting in the persistence of the problem of theoretical divide โ whether these theories exist as isolated lines of research, nullify each other, support each other, or reinforce each other. Therefore, we must understand the different explanatory theories stated below.
๐ Definition โ Theoretical Pluralism: The simultaneous acceptance of differing and multiple explanations of reality in management theory. ๐ Definition โ Management Theory Jungle: Koontz's term describing the problematic situation of too many conflicting, overlapping, alternative, and varying theories for a single management phenomenon.
Four Theories of Organizational Change (Van de Ven & Poole)
These theories, narrated by Van de Ven & Poole in their article published in the Academy of Management Review, attempt to give a comprehensive picture of various theories on organization change โ ranging from child development to evolutionary biology, incorporating various concepts, as organisation life is a complex phenomenon with interplay and juxtaposition of multiple contrasting forces. They categorised various theories into a set of four theories which are:
- Life cycle theories
- Teleological theories
- Dialectical theories
- Evolutionary theories
This is a significant framework that gives a parsimonious and prudent explanation of organization change. The framework serves a normative function and provides useful standards to evaluate the form, completeness and tightness of specific developmental theories. The framework supports inductive research by identifying characteristics of the four motors and the conditions under which they operate.
๐ Definition โ Life Cycle Theories: Theories that explain change as an immanent process following a prescribed sequence of stages or phases. ๐ Definition โ Teleological Theories: Theories that explain change as a purposeful movement toward a desired end state or goal. ๐ Definition โ Dialectical Theories: Theories that explain change as emerging from the confrontation between opposing forces or viewpoints. ๐ Definition โ Evolutionary Theories: Theories that explain change as a cumulative process of variation, selection, and retention.
โญ Key Takeaways
The most critical point is that organizational change cannot be explained by a single theory because organizational life is complex with interplay and juxtaposition of multiple contrasting forces. Van de Ven & Poole's framework of four theories โ life cycle, teleological, dialectical, and evolutionary โ provides a parsimonious and prudent explanation of organization change. This framework serves both a normative function (evaluating the form and completeness of developmental theories) and supports inductive research (identifying conditions under which each motor operates). Students must remember that theoretical pluralism leads to the management theory jungle, making it essential to understand how different theories relate to each other rather than treating them as isolated explanations.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is theoretical pluralism, and how does it relate to what Koontz called the "management theory jungle"?
- What are the four theories of organizational change identified by Van de Ven & Poole?
- What function does Van de Ven & Poole's framework serve in evaluating developmental theories?
- How does the framework support inductive research according to the lecture?
- Why does the lecture emphasize that no single theory can fully explain organizational change?
๐ Lecture 8 โ Life Cycle Theory
๐ Overview: Life cycle theory is one of the most common explanatory frameworks in change management, using the metaphor of organic growth to describe organizational development from initiation to termination. This lecture explains how organizations, like living organisms, progress through predictable stages of birth, growth, maturity, decline, and death, and explores the practical applications of this theory in organizational contexts, particularly in Pakistan.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the foundational concepts of life cycle theory including its definition from Van de Ven and Poole, characteristics of life cycle progression, prescribed versus constructive modes of change, Hollman's three-phase model of organizational change (Missionary, Modification, Maturity), Miller & Freisen's four-stage model, Baird & Meshoulam's four stages of international organizational life cycle (Organization Initiation, Functional Growth, Controlled Growth, Strategic Integration), and the concept of organizational death or extinction.
๐ Lecture Summary
Life Cycle Theory
Life cycle theory is one of the most common explanation theories in change management literature. It uses a metaphor of organic growth to explain organizational development in an entity from its initiation to its termination. The entity may mean an individual's job, a work group, a programme, strategy, product, or the overall organization. Like individuals, organizations also have a life, mean age and stage, and associated characteristics like birth, growth, maturity, decline and death โ exhibiting certain traits at a particular stage of their life. In the context of Pakistani organizations, multinationals have evolved as excellent high performing organizations because they have a perpetual life and have overcome Product Life Cycle (PLC) or Organization Life Cycle (OLC).
According to this theory, "Change is imminent; that is the developing entity has within it an underlying form, logic, program or code that regulates the process of change and moves the entity from a given point of departure toward a subsequent end that is prefigured in the present state." Similarly, according to Van de Ven and Poole, "External environmental events and processes can influence how the entity expresses itself, but are always mediated by the immanent logic, rules, or programs that govern the entity's development."
๐ Definition โ Life Cycle Theory: A change management theory that uses the metaphor of organic growth to explain organizational development through predictable, sequential stages from initiation to termination, governed by an internal program or code.
Characteristics of a Life Cycle Theory
-
The progression (order + sequence) of change events in this model is a unitary sequence (follows a single sequence of stages or phases) and is cumulative (earlier stage traits are retained in later stages).
-
There is such a progression to the final end state which is pre-figured and requires a specific historical sequence of events.
-
Each of these events contributes a piece to the final product, occurs in a prescribed order, and sets the stage for the next. Each stage of development is seen as a necessary precursor of succeeding stages.
The author referred to Nisbet who worked on the philosophy of developmentalism, stating, "Organization development is driven by some genetic code or pre-figured program within the developing entity." Rogers is quoted as positing five stages of innovation: need recognition, research on problem, development of idea into useful form, commercialisation, and diffusion and adoption.
Unit of Change and Mode of Change
Life cycle theories explain development in terms of institutional rules or programs that require developmental activities to progress in a prescribed sequence. For example, in International Business, the specific application in context of product development and marketing is known as International Product Life Cycle (IPLC). This depicts how a product having birth in a Western country like USA receives growth, goes international, reaches maturity, and eventually declines in the form of importing the same product from external economies.
Unit of Change: Life cycle theories operate on a single entity, where development is a function of potentials immanent within the entity โ environment and other entities are considered secondary.
Mode of change: It is important to know the sequence of change events is prescribed by either probabilistic or deterministic laws. There are two modes of change: prescribed mode and constructive mode.
๐ Definition โ Prescribed Mode: A mode of change that channels the development of entities in a pre-specified direction. Watzlawick termed this as first-order change, routinized or pre-established programme. Variation is first-order change.
๐ Definition โ Constructive Mode: A constructive mode of change generates unprecedented novel forms, often discontinuous and unpredictable departures from the past. Watzlawick termed this as second-order change, as it breaks with the past basic assumption or framework.
๐ก Why this matters: Life cycle (and evolutionary) theory operates in a prescribed modality, meaning change follows predictable, pre-programmed patterns rather than creating entirely novel forms.
Hollman's Three-Phase Model of Organizational Change
According to Hollman, organizational change such as MBO (Management by Objectives) can be best understood by viewing change as systematically moving through distinct developmental stages rather than as either an evolutionary or revolutionary process. This developmental process consists of three phases or life cycles: Missionary, Modification, and Maturity.
Missionary phase: When an organizational member goes through MBO training programme, reads a book or article, or is in a business education programme and tries to introduce the same in his own organization with at least one high-level sponsor in the organization (may be politically driven to seek legitimacy and credibility).
Modification Phase: After birth, the problem of acceptance arises primarily from three sources:
- Interpersonal (lack of support, hostility, learning new terminology, skills and values, altering superior-subordinate relationships)
- Organizational (authority-responsibility pattern, budgetary allocations, training/procedural revision needed)
- Environmental (government regulation or competitive pressure)
Out of such pressures, a customized version emerges through negotiating and bargaining amongst multiple forces.
Maturity phase: When the change introduced becomes organizational routine, or when the new programme gets merged with the existing organization processes and loses its unique and special status as a management tool in organizational processes like budgetary allocation or compensation mechanism. This is considered the death phase of change in one sense. Failure can occur, and death can occur at any stage on the missionary-maturity continuum.
Applications and Additional Models
Applications of Life Cycle Theory:
- Viable time-oriented framework used by organizations to diagnose, evaluate, and adjust new programmes (like MBO)
- Evolution of MNCs: How MNCs evolve themselves (Sales agent, regular export, franchise/license, Wholly Owned subsidiary)
- Though many consider OLC as static and deterministic, some consider strategic choices at each stage can affect (shorten or prolong) the development, rate, and direction of OLC stage
- Introduction of new technology or application of new managerial concepts in an organization (e.g., MBO can be examined in terms of its introduction, growth, and effectiveness)
Miller & Freisen (1984) came up with a similar four-stage model:
- Birth
- Growth
- Maturity
- Revival
Baird & Meshoulam's Four Stages of International OLC
It is important to note that OLC for a domestic firm is distinct from OLC for an international firm.
Stage 1: Organization Initiation A typical start-up organization survives on the basis of strong entrepreneurship skills and values. Management and leadership are informal in nature, and managed on the basis of convenience. The organization at this stage offers a limited range of highly specialized products to restricted markets. Management culture remains ethnocentric, and the objective is short-term survival within the domestic market.
Stage 2: Functional Growth Once the organization maintains its existence, it starts to look for diversification. The firm looks for new export markets. Informal ways of management are replaced by formalisation by focusing on functional and technical specialization and production efficiency. Managerial confidence of the firm begins to increase owing to dynamic growth.
Stage 3: Controlled Growth The firm's overseas market moves into the maturity phase, with its focus on efficient structure and management practices. The firm now wants to control its overseas market through tight operations so as to achieve economies of scale in production and other functional areas.
Stage 4: Strategic Integration The firm now seeks greater integration with local markets through localisation and adaptation of resources. Moreover, synergy is sought to optimise operations through network and interdependencies of resources and responsibilities across subsidiaries. Ethnocentrism is replaced by polycentrism and geocentrism, resulting in increasing influence of foreigners and evolution of a universal management character.
Organizational Death or Extinction
Organizational death occurs when an organization values stability too much and avoids uncertainty and risk-taking. This means the organization is unable to innovate and has an incapacity to appraise its own performance. It believes in stable programming and is reluctant to deviate. All this happens when executives have a narrow and parochial view of external reality, and resistance to change is very high. Therefore, either the organization's inability for adaptation or the hostility of the environment leads the organization to extinction. For example, sick units in the textile sector boom under government support and collapse with the withdrawal of concessions and subsidies.
๐ Definition โ Organizational Death/Extinction: The termination of an organization that occurs when it values stability excessively, avoids uncertainty and risk-taking, cannot innovate, and has a narrow view of external reality coupled with high resistance to change.
โญ Key Takeaways
Students must remember that life cycle theory explains change as a pre-programmed, sequential progression through predictable stages from birth to death, governed by an internal code or logic within the entity itself. The two modes of changeโprescribed mode (first-order, routinized) and constructive mode (second-order, novel)โare critical for understanding how organizations either follow predictable paths or break from past frameworks. Hollman's three phases (Missionary, Modification, Maturity) provide a practical framework for understanding how management tools like MBO are introduced, adapted, and eventually institutionalized or die. The distinction between domestic and international OLC models (especially Baird & Meshoulam's four stages) is essential for analyzing multinational corporations, where ethnocentrism gradually gives way to polycentrism and geocentrism. Finally, organizational death results from excessive stability orientation, risk avoidance, and parochial executive thinking, making adaptation and innovation essential for organizational survival.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three main characteristics of life cycle theory's progression of change events?
- What is the difference between prescribed mode (first-order change) and constructive mode (second-order change) as defined by Watzlawick?
- According to Hollman, what are the three phases of organizational change using MBO as an example, and what happens in each phase?
- Describe Baird & Meshoulam's four stages of international organizational life cycle and how ethnocentrism changes across these stages.
- What factors lead to organizational death or extinction according to life cycle theory?
๐ Lecture 9 โ Teleological Theories of Change
๐ Overview: This lecture explores teleological theories of change, which posit that human actions are purposive and directed toward goals. It explains how organizations and individuals set, implement, and revise objectives as the primary driver of change, and discusses the implications for management practices and organizational development.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
Teleological theories emphasize purposive, goal-directed action as the final cause guiding organizational movement. The theory underlies functionalism, strategic planning, and adaptive learning. Key concepts include goal formulation, implementation, evaluation, and modification in a repetitive cycle. The lecture covers the unit and mode of change, applications in management systems, the importance of shared vision, and limitations related to subjectivity and mechanistic assumptions.
๐ Lecture Summary
Teleological theories of Change
According to this theory, human actions are purposive; goal is the final cause for guiding movement of an entity. This underlies other organization theories like functionalism, decision-making, adaptive learning & model of strategic planning and goal setting. By this theory, development of an organizational entity proceeds toward a goal or end state. The entity is purposeful and adaptive by itself or interaction with others. The entity constructs an envisioned state, takes action to reach it, and monitors the progress. Therefore development process entails the repetitive sequence of goal formulation, implementation, evaluation and modification of goals.
Individuals or organisations who are sufficiently like-minded strive to act as a single collective entity. Therefore, the question is why to have organisation in the first case? Its answers lie in the fact that it is the commonality and convergence of purpose which binds individuals and organizations. Hence task oriented-ness pre-dominates (technocratization). This is perhaps one such structural difference between managers in developed and developing countries. But unlike life-cycle theory, teleology doesnโt prescribe necessary sequence of events.
Some teleological models incorporate the systems theory assumption of equi-finality (multiple effective ways to achieve a goal). In this theory there is no prefigured rule, logically necessary direction or set sequence of stages. Teleology stresses the purposiveness of the actor and within organisationโs environment and resources constraints
Unit of change
Change processes go on at many organizational levels, including the individual, group, organisation, industry and on other population as well
Mode of Change
Teleological and dialectical motors incorporate a constructive mode of change and development (2nd order change). By this very nature teleological processes tend to diverge from the current order. Because goals can be changed at the will of an entity and can be attained in many ways, therefore this may result in unpredictability and discontinuity
Application:
New management system like MBO, ISO certification, introduction of new software, quality drives in organisations are all considered part of teleological approach to change management. Focus in this approach is on goals or objective setting process or phenomenon in an entity. So the case in point is how do we set goals? How do we arrive at our decisions? What our objectives or ends are? Are these in continuity or in discontinuity with the past objectives of an entity? All these dimensions relate with ends and means debate. Good and quality objectives with legitimate and effective means for an entity are always difficult to arrive at. Another issue with objective setting is whether goals are rationally formulated? Rationality, of course is bound by time and space, the concept of bounded rationality earlier propounded by Herbert Simon. Visionary is the one who can see things at distant, that is, he can give stretch to time and space. So when we say vision ought to be shared by members of the organization For example whether this vision is shared by senior executives and the managers in succession (change of CEO). Hence change of managers or CEO is meaningless if there is no meaningful qualitative change in objectives of organization. One can apply the same for developing nations like Pakistan. For instance take the context of history of Pakistan. A Pre-1947 objectives of colonisers was to extract revenue and control us through the design of strong bureaucratic institutions. After independence this objective ought to have been revised and replaced by the objectives of growth & development (Constitution is a written objective of a nation). This never happened as bureaucratic institutions remain oriented towards control and revenue like the objective of colonisers. Similarly objectives of governing elite whether or not get changed by the change in personalities, law, system or party change. Similarly in case of organisation we have to see mission, vision, objectives, plans, target, what is known as hierarchy of intent truly reflects organization performance or just a rhetoric. Therefore the need to have an organization is โto attain our goalsโ and for the attainment of goals organizations at time becomes autocratic in behaviour. For that matter, the very first goal being survival or โSelf-preservationโ all factor of generation-growth-maturity in organisms are considered to be in line with self-preserving. Therefore, behaviour in organisation becomes purposive.
Limitations:
Though the tautological theory has good explanatory power yet it is not without its limitations. Two such stand very obvious. One is that the element of subjectivity is ignored in this kind of explanation. Human behaviour is not as subjective as explains for all and sundry behaviour. Second this is considered too much mechanistic, ignoring the organic dynamism of nature.
โญ Key Takeaways
Teleological theories of change center on the idea that organizations and individuals are goal-directed, with change emerging from the repetitive cycle of goal formulation, implementation, evaluation, and modification. Unlike life-cycle theories, teleology does not prescribe a fixed sequence of stages and allows for equi-finalityโmultiple paths to the same goal. The mode of change is constructive and tends toward second-order change, creating unpredictability and discontinuity. Applications include MBO, ISO certification, and quality drives, but the approach has limitations: it ignores subjectivity in human behavior and is considered too mechanistic, overlooking organic dynamism.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the central assumption of teleological theories of change regarding human actions?
- How does teleological theory differ from life-cycle theory in terms of prescribed sequence?
- What does the concept of "equi-finality" mean in the context of teleological change?
- Name two management systems that are considered applications of the teleological approach to change management.
- What are the two main limitations of teleological theory?