📘 Lecture 1 — Course Orientation
📖 Overview: This lecture serves as an introduction to the Change Management course (MGMT625), setting expectations, objectives, and the foundational framework for learning. It emphasizes the importance of mastering the subject's vocabulary, identifying credible reading materials, and developing critical analytical and writing skills to succeed in the course and apply change management concepts in real-world organizational contexts.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with norms setting and course expectations, requiring a solid grasp of prerequisite management subjects. It outlines the course objectives: to understand change management literature, analyze the phenomenon of change, and build analytical skills. It then details the subject's vocabulary, recommends key books and articles, and provides a criterion for identifying credible research. The lecture also covers the examination perspective, emphasizing the need for analysis, evaluation, and application over rote memory. It describes the subject's broad scope, from individual learning to organizational survival in a changing environment, and concludes by exploring the fundamental reasons for studying change management, citing leading experts and defining change through the dimensions of knowledge, skills, and attitude.
📝 Lecture Summary
Norms Setting & Course Expectations
The first sessions establish norms, including course expectations and scope. For this advanced course, a strong understanding of prerequisite subjects—Principles of Management, Human Resources Management, and Organization Behavior—is essential. Students are expected to be interactive, seeking clarification and providing regular feedback.
Course Objectives
The lecture outlines three core objectives:
- To develop a significant understanding of change-management literature, including conceptual frameworks, theories, typologies, strategies, and techniques.
- To understand the change-management phenomenon, especially how managers successfully manage change in an organization.
- To build and develop students' analytical and applied management skills in the context of business organizations.
Learning the Subject's Vocabulary
Every discipline has its own vocabulary and terminology. As change management is more related to social behavior than fields like medicine or engineering, it is imperative to not only learn this vocabulary but also to develop the ability to express everyday phenomena using it.
Reading Material
The lecture recommends key books and articles for the course. Books:
- Understanding Organizations (1976) and Gods of Management (1995) by Charles Handy.
- Organization Culture and Leadership by Edgar Schein.
- Change Management: A Guide to Effective Implementation by Robert Paton & McCalman.
Articles: The lecture emphasizes relying on research articles over books and provides a criterion to identify credible material:
- Know the author, their qualifications, and affiliation.
- Assess the quality of the publication (journal reputation and impact, e.g., Academy of Management Review, Journal of Management Studies).
- Check the citation of the article or its references.
💡 Why this matters: Students must learn to differentiate academically sound material from "junk." The Journal of Change Management is specifically recommended. A good starting point is Chapter 1 of Koontz's text on management, Chapter 17 of Robbins' Organizational Behaviour, and Frederick Luthan's book on managing diversity and organization culture. Other leading authors to consult include Chris Argyris, Edgar Schein, D. Schon, Peter Senge, Karl Weick, Peter Drucker, Hannan & Freeman, Quinn, James March, Herbert Simon, Michael Beer, and Nohria. The HEC's digital library (via J-Stor, Springer Link) provides access.
Examination & Assessment Perspective
Students must demonstrate four key skills:
- Knowledge & Understanding: Of terms and definitions.
- Analysis: Differentiating and distinguishing concepts, making valid generalizations and inferences.
- Evaluation: Comprehending, evaluating, and synthesizing differing and competing ideas, models, and explanations.
- Application: Applying generalizations and theories in specific organizational and national contexts. The skills most valued are analysis, application, and evaluation, not just memory. A key caution is to note the level of analysis (individual, group, business, organization, or nation) and the organization's type (public/corporate, small/medium/large). Students are also advised to develop four learning skills: Listening, Reading, Speaking, and Writing, with writing skills being of utmost value for exams. The recommended article for this is ‘Managing Oneself’ by Peter Drucker (HBR, March-April 1999).
Important Instruction
Students must read the original text or articles by the referred authors and not merely rely on video lectures and handouts. Reading original articles is mandatory, and repetition is essential for effective learning.
Scope of the Subject
Change management has an integrated nature, relating to Strategic Management, Organization Development, Training, Knowledge Management, and Organizational Learning. Its application is pervasive:
- Individual perspective: Learning means change in knowledge, skills, and attitude (KSA). Individuals must manage changes in their personal and professional lives.
- Organization perspective: The perpetual concern of management is to enhance productivity. This requires managing change at two levels:
- External environmental level: Managing change relations with government policies, technology, customer preferences, and societal expectations.
- Internal managerial level: Responding to extraneous changes, which may lead to restructuring, downsizing, decentralization, or developing new products and markets.
Why to Study Change Management?
The lecture uses quotes from leading experts to explain the importance of the subject.
🔑 Definition — Rate of Change (Alvin Toffler): The vastly accelerated pace of change that most people and organizations are unprepared for. 📐 Formula/Concept: Change = Rate/Pace + Quality/Quantity → impacts on Individuals and Organizations → leads to Unpreparedness.
🔑 Definition — Motivation Process (Charles Handy): The process by which individuals can be influenced and their behavior predicted by changing its components. 📐 Formula/Concept: Understand Motivation → Change Components → Influence Behavior → Control and Predict → Enhance Productivity. 📌 Example: The focus of management is how to control, predict, and motivate human behavior for productivity enhancement.
🔑 Definition — Learning for Change (Edgar Schein): Two types of learning: one creates stability and culture, and another enables organizations to innovate. Change takes place by reconciliation between internal and external forces. 📐 Formula/Concept: Learning in Stable Organizations ≠ Learning in Changing/Innovative Organizations. Change = Reconciliation between Internal Environment and External Environment.
🔑 Definition — Individual Change (KSA Model): Change at the individual level involves change in three dimensions: Knowledge, Skills, and Attitude. 📌 Example:
- Knowledge changes by reading an article or listening to a lecture.
- Skills are built through repetition and practice (e.g., mathematics, accounting, IT).
- Attitude is the most crucial dimension—transforming an unwilling person to a willing one, and transforming a group's behavior from non-willing to willing.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The lecture establishes that this is an advanced course requiring a strong foundation in core management subjects. A primary objective is to learn and apply the specialized vocabulary of change management to analyze and describe real-world phenomena. Students must prioritize credible research articles and develop higher-order skills of analysis, evaluation, and application over simple memorization for exams. The study of change management is critical because of the accelerating pace of change, and it is fundamentally about understanding and influencing individual and organizational behavior, defined through changes in knowledge, skills, and attitude.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three prerequisite courses required for a good understanding of this Change Management course?
- List the four key skills students are expected to demonstrate from an examination and assessment perspective.
- What is the three-part criterion provided to identify credible and authentic research articles?
- According to the lecture, what are the two levels at which an organization must manage change?
- Explain the three dimensions of change at the individual level, and provide an example for each.
📘 Lecture 2 — Benefits and Significance of Change Management
📖 Overview: This lecture explores why change management is critically important for both individuals and organizations. It details the key benefits from an organizational perspective—understanding the environment, strategy formation, employee development, technology, and globalization—and establishes the relationship between traditional management, strategic management, and change management using frameworks like McKinsey’s 7-S Model and the five dimensions of organizational change.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by outlining five key benefits of change management for organizations, including understanding the external environment, strategy formulation, employee performance, technology integration, and globalization. It then explains the relationship of management with change management by examining traditional management functions (planning, organizing, directing, controlling), strategic management domains, and the McKinsey Seven S-Framework. Finally, it provides an overview of the subject through five organizational dimensions: strategy, process, structure, culture, and politics.
📝 Lecture Summary
Benefits and Significance
The subject of change management holds tremendous importance for both individuals and organizations. From the organization’s perspective, there are five major benefits:
-
Understanding environment (society, government, customers): Organizations must understand, assess, and gauge the dynamics of their external environment to establish appropriate relationships with actors like government, customers, and society. Managers who understand change management can better prepare for environmental shifts.
-
Objectives, strategy formulation & implementation (to develop competitive advantage): This is consequent upon knowing the impact of external change on internal dynamics. The foremost goal is objective setting and seeking competitive advantage.
-
Employees (trained, high performing work practices, reliable organisation): Employees are the recipients of change plans. A perpetual concern of senior managers is making the organization highly reliable, requiring employees to be trained and high-performing in today’s hyper-competitive world.
-
Technology Issues: Technology is the engine of growth. The greatest challenge for contemporary organizations is the acquisition and integration of technology into strategy, structure, and process. Top managers worry about avoiding obsolescence and coping with changing information and communication technologies that influence production and consumption behavior.
-
Globalization: The management of international economic and political forces—internationalisation and globalisation—is crucial. No organization or nation can stay independent of international events. Supra-national institutions (e.g., WTO, ISO) are becoming more assertive over nation states on political and social issues like child labor and gender issues, decisively influencing organizations in the developing world.
💡 Why this matters: These five benefits show that change management is not optional but essential for organizational survival and competitiveness in a rapidly evolving global environment.
The Relationship of Management with Change-Management
Change management is a subject with a cross-cutting theme, applicable across various traditional functional areas: marketing (new product/market development), production (new technology/skills), finance (budgetary allocations, revisions, cost-cutting), and HR (behavioural modification, knowledge, skills, and values).
Traditional management domain
Change can be viewed through traditional management functions (PODC techniques):
- Planning: Setting objectives, implementing policies, decision-making
- Organizing: Formal/informal organisation, departmentation, hierarchy, authority-responsibility relationship, span of control
- Directing: Leading, leadership styles, motivation theories
- Controlling: Direct & formal control, indirect & informal control
Strategic management domain
Within the strategic domain, there are two concerns:
- Strategy formulation: Formulating mission, vision, and objectives after environmental assessment
- Strategy implementation: Organisation structure, culture, and politics
The whole focus is the development and sustenance of competitive advantage at multiple levels: functional, business, corporate, and societal.
McKinsey Seven S-Framework
One of the leading management consultants widely quoted in literature has seven dimensions for change to make an organization highly productive:
- Strategy – sustained competitive advantage
- Structure – who reports to whom; how work is divided
- System – operations & core processes
- Style – leadership style
- Staff – employees/human resources
- Shared values – beliefs, mindsets
- Skills – capabilities and competencies
Overview of the subject
Within the overall context of management, the subject can be understood by focusing on five organizational dimensions:
- Strategy
- Process
- Structure
- Culture
- Politics
1. Organisation has an articulated purpose or objective There is constant questioning, verifying, changing, and re-defining of organization objectives through interaction with the environment. Once objectives are revised, they lead to modifications in structure and managerial processes. For example, when an organization survives the entrepreneurial problem, it must achieve growth by solving market development, engineering (producing at higher levels without compromising quality), and administrative problems (managing roles and relationships with more employees). Even larger organizations like MNCs engage in Strategic Renewal—defining and renegotiating their objectives.
2. Organisation process Process refers to the transformation of input to output (e.g., production converting raw material to finished goods). These processes are often technology-driven. There are two types of changes:
- Total Quality Management (TQM): Change on a continuous, gradual, incremental basis—working ‘with in the system’
- Business Process Restructuring (BPR): Drastic, structural, fundamental change—working ‘on the system’
Other organizational processes include decision making, objective setting, communicating, controlling, and coordinating.
3. Organisation structure Structure refers to how authority and responsibility are distributed across the organization. The authority pattern shows who reports to whom and who is accountable. Dimensions include:
- Departmentation or task grouping
- Hierarchy layers
- Span of control
- Extent of formalization (bureaucratic vs. participative)
Structural change may mean change in one or more of these dimensions. Modern organizations increasingly want flatter structures (instead of taller), decentralized, participative, and empowered, as these are considered more productive and creative.
4. Organisation Culture Culture includes:
- Values, beliefs, and mindset of a manager at work
- Cognitive style (thought process)
- Personality (MBTI)
- Behaviour
Hofstede Model of cultural dimensions:
- Individualism – Collectivism
- Masculinity – Feminism
- Power Distance – Low or High
- Uncertainty Avoidance – Low or High
- Time orientation – Low or High
5. Organisation Politics
- Changes have political consequences
- Change disturbs power-distribution in organisation
- Organisations are like governments
- Managers have interests and groupings
Therefore, power may enable or resist change.
⭐ Key Takeaways
- Organizations must understand five key benefits of change management: environment, strategy, employees, technology, and globalization—all of which are critical for survival and competitive advantage.
- Change management is a cross-cutting subject that integrates with all functional areas (marketing, production, finance, HR) and both traditional management (PODC) and strategic management domains.
- The McKinsey 7-S Framework identifies seven interdependent dimensions (strategy, structure, systems, style, staff, shared values, skills) that must be aligned for successful organizational change.
- Organizational change can be understood through five dimensions: strategy, process (TQM vs. BPR), structure (flatter, decentralized), culture (Hofstede’s model), and politics (power dynamics enable or resist change).
- Change inherently involves political dynamics—it disturbs power distribution, and managers’ interests and groupings can either enable or resist transformation.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five benefits of change management from an organizational perspective?
- How does change management relate to each traditional management function (planning, organizing, directing, controlling)?
- What are the seven components of McKinsey’s 7-S Framework, and why are they interdependent?
- What is the difference between Total Quality Management (TQM) and Business Process Restructuring (BPR)?
- According to Hofstede’s model, what are the five cultural dimensions that affect organizational change?
📘 Lecture 3 — Kurt Lewin Model: Assumptions and Implications
📖 Overview: This lecture explores Kurt Lewin's foundational model of planned change, focusing on its underlying assumptions about human motivation and conflict. It explains the three-stage process of Unfreeze, Change, and Refreeze, detailing how each stage functions at individual, organizational, and societal levels. Understanding this model is critical because it provides a framework for diagnosing why many change efforts fail and how to systematically manage transitions.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the core assumptions of Lewin's model, including the tendency for performance to regress and the concept of "force field" analysis. It then outlines three fundamental types of conflict individuals face. The main body of the lecture is devoted to explaining the three stages of change: Unfreeze (with its attributes and Schein's characteristics), Change (including identification and internalization mechanisms), and Refreeze (focusing on institutionalization and reinforcement). Finally, the lecture applies the model to societal, organizational, and individual levels of analysis.
📝 Lecture Summary
LESSON # 3 — KURT LEWIN MODEL: ASSUMPTIONS AND IMPLICATIONS
Theories and models are always based on some set of assumptions. This model too has some basic assumptions which are as under:
- An Individual or group performance is prone to regression unless some measures are taken to institutionalise the improved performance level.
- There is a tension in person whenever a psychological need or intent exists, and the tension is released when the need or intention is fulfilled.
- This tension may be positive or negative, and under conflict situation this is identified as "force field". Hence the term is known as force field analysis so as to evaluate the tension between positive or facilitating forces and negative or constraining forces the given change plan.
Further to him there are three fundamental types of conflict.
- Approach-Approach Conflict: Individuals stand mid-way between two positive goals of approximately equal strengths; for e.g. individual has to choose between two good systems, so which one to buy.
- Avoidance-Avoidance Conflict: Individuals find themselves between two approximately equal negative goals; for e.g. if an individual has to make a choice between two things which he dislikes, that is a choice of lesser evil.
- Approach-Avoidance Conflict: Individuals are equally exposed to opposing positive and negative forces.
These assumptions about motivation process and conflict typology in human nature lead Lewin to propose three staged model of a planned change management process.
- Unfreeze
- Change
- Refreeze
Stage 1: Unfreeze the current equilibrium
Before going for change in first stage we have to create tension amongst the recipient of change that some thing is not good in the on-going system. This is to create emotional stir up which is to break the shell of complacency and self righteousness amongst the subject of change. The reason is to break the personal defences and group norms psychologically before actually going for change.
In the words of Edgar Schein this stage consists of the following attributes:
- The physical removal of the individuals being changed from the accustomed routines, sources of information and social relationships
- The undermining and destruction of all social support.
- Demeaning and humiliating experience to help individual. Being changed to see their old attitude or behaviour as unworthy and thus motivated to change. The lecture gives an example of ragging of new entrants from military training, where new entrants are deliberately targeted for their existing behaviour, norms and identity to acquire new ways of thinking.
- The consistent linking of reward with willingness to change and of punishment with unwillingness to change. Old behaviour is punished and new or desired behaviour is to be rewarded. There would not be any meaningful change if the change targets perceive no linkage of reward and the desired behaviour, or if the old behaviour and norms are continued to be rewarded.
For Schein, the Unfreeze stage must be simultaneously coupled with the following characteristics:
- Disconfirmation of expectation
- Induction of learning anxiety if the disconfirming data are accepted as valid and relevant. If one thinks he has already perfect knowledge and stays confident, no need for change is felt. This is also known as mind blockage when people refuse to accept new or changed reality.
- Provision of psychological safety that converts anxiety into motivation to change. If anxiety gets converted into fear, it will create resistance for change. Therefore anxiety should be strong enough to be a source of motivation for change.
💡 Why this matters: This point is critical because if we admit something with ourselves as wrong we will lose effectiveness, self efficacy, self-esteem or even our identity. Therefore, in order to learn one has to be humble. Learning will be lower for individuals with higher self esteem and vice versa.
Two types of change:
- Action level or Symbolic
- Belief or Cognitive
Comparatively speaking, change in beliefs or belief system (cognitive restructuring) brings in more sustainable and meaningful change than symbolic and action type of change. Shock therapy in psychology is one such technique for changing belief of a patient. The concept of punishment is also a kind of shock therapeutic technique for behavioural modification. In management, if an organization is going into deficit, the fear or shock of close down or job-cuts may motivate individuals and groups to change. While action level or symbolic change is short lived and reflects mere compliance in outward actions.
In order to unfreeze mental programming is good for reducing resistance. A very simple and powerful technique for motivating for change is to induce reward for performer and no reward or punishment for non-performer. This is perhaps one very good reason for change efforts to meet failure in a typical public sector organisation because senior executives fail to cultivate or make people perceive such linkage to exist. In public sector organizations, all managers (good or bad) get same increment, promotion or other benefits based on seniority.
2. Change Movement
This means a movement from existing to the desired form. It is a state of transition or transformation which depicts neither an old state nor a new state of affairs. This is very critical stage as it may either go backward (in case of failure) or forward. According to one author the time or stage in transition is known as "crazy period". Generally in this phase individuals and organizations try to cope up simultaneously both systems: existing and the desired one. The transition process is usually not very smooth, neat and clean process rather entails upheavals.
Important thing is to follow the desired objectives or system consistently. Ambiguity and parallel work of old and new has to be tolerated. Initial productivity of new system is considered to be lower than the previous system.
The process occurs through two mechanisms:
i) Identification – When role models are there in the environment, for e.g. individuals who can easily follow the footsteps of role model. In context of organisation the popular term is benchmarking – following the best practices of the industry leaders. Nations also tend to identify other nations as their model for economic or socio-political development.
ii) Internalisation – Knowledge exists most of the time at external level. The most critical aspect is how to internalise knowledge. Here internalisation refers to the behavioural aspect of the recipient. According to one version, only that is considered to be knowledge which is part of one's behaviour (reflected in action). Therefore knowledge of good practices is not enough unless good practices are practiced. Movement from one stage to another stage is initiated by trigger event and manager's personalisation of trigger.
3. Refreeze
Once the new objective or desired state of affairs has been achieved, the problem with this phase is to institutionalise the new system so that people might not revert back to the older ways of doing things. The purpose in this phase is to stabilise new learning. This can be done through behavioural reinforcement. In this stage again the effectiveness of performance–reward linkage is considered to be the part of enabling environment. New behaviour is to be internalised.
Important note: Effects of many training programmes and lectures are short lived when a person returns to the environment that does not reinforce. Hence continuous and intermittent reinforcement is needed. An example from real life is that Pakistanis are known as highly productive abroad but back in their own society they are known as work shruggers – the difference is on account of enabling environment. Therefore in order to refreeze the new behaviour, system or equilibrium we have to provide enabling environment.
Application
The model can be applied to all three levels to explain change management phenomenon: societal, organizational and individual.
At societal level: Our society in overall analysis is in transition phase. Older things, system and traditions have been unfrozen, but we have yet to learn the dynamics of new systems as the productivity of newly learned behaviour is at lower level than the traditional system. The society is in transition from agrarian to industrial, rural to urban and traditional to modern. Members of such a society face a situation of role overload and role conflict.
At organizational level: Example of organization undergoing automation programme. First thing is to unfreeze the mindset of managers by creating dissatisfaction about the existing system. Creating discomfort about lower level of productivity, creating sense of urgency and instilling fear of lagging behind in competition are various techniques for unfreezing. During the second phase, automation leads to multiple problems of learning, training, jobs and position displacements, hiring of computer technologist, budgetary allocations etc. At this stage it seems that previous system was better. Key to successful transformation lies in staying consistent, learning from mistake and tolerating ambiguity. Finally in refreeze stage, people get accustomed to newer system as learners and performers are rewarded.
At individual level: Individuals undergo through the same stages when they have to learn new knowledge, skills or values. First in unfreezing stage resolving intra-individual conflict or tension, envisioning the desired state and dissatisfaction with existing levels of knowledge, skills or values. Second is to take actual steps and moving into crazy period or transition phase which is demanding. Once success is achieved, individuals need to programme, internalise or refreeze the newly learnt values.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical concept from this lecture is that change is a three-stage process, not a single event, and failure at any stage—especially the first—can doom the entire effort. The Unfreeze stage requires creating genuine dissatisfaction with the status quo, breaking psychological defenses, and establishing a clear performance-reward linkage, which is why public sector organizations often fail at change. The Change stage is a chaotic "crazy period" where productivity drops, requiring tolerance of ambiguity and the use of identification (role models/benchmarking) and internalization (making knowledge part of behaviour) mechanisms. The Refreeze stage is about institutionalizing new behaviours through continuous reinforcement and creating an enabling environment, without which learning is quickly lost. Finally, the model is universally applicable at individual, organizational, and societal levels, with societies in transition experiencing the same "crazy period" dynamics as organizations undergoing automation.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three fundamental types of conflict according to Kurt Lewin, and can you give a management example for each?
- Explain Schein's four attributes of the Unfreeze stage and why the performance-reward linkage is considered critical in this stage.
- What is the "crazy period" in the Change Movement stage, and why is initial productivity of a new system typically lower than the previous system?
- What is the difference between "Identification" and "Internalization" as mechanisms for change, and why is internalization considered more sustainable?
- Why does the lecture argue that training programmes are often short-lived, and what does the example of Pakistanis' productivity at home versus abroad illustrate about the Refreeze stage?
📘 Lecture 4 — Implications of Kurt Lewin Model
📖 Overview: This lecture examines the six key implications of Kurt Lewin's change model, explaining how change can be managed and directed, why resistance is inevitable, and how context shapes behaviour. It also provides a critical evaluation of the model's limitations and compares it with other change management frameworks.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers six implications of Kurt Lewin's model: change as a directed and managed process, recognition that change will be resisted, overcoming resistance through leadership, the importance of sequence in change, the relationship between attitude and behaviour change, and how context influences behaviour through the formula B = f(P × E). It then presents a critical look at five assumptions of the model (linearity, progressive state, mechanistic, goal, and separateness) and concludes with comparisons to other change management models.
📝 Lecture Summary
Implications of Kurt Lewin Model
1. Change can be directed, managed and controlled (Learning is a choice behaviour) Not everything is pre-ordained or predetermined. The modern scientific approach assumes that tools and methods used for creating scientific knowledge can also be applied to social domains. Therefore, abstract social disciplines such as entrepreneurship, leadership, management, and organizational culture can be taught and learned from a scientific approach. Learning is now considered not a function of gene or inheritance but a matter of aptitude and interest. Hence, social behaviour can be managed like a thermostat or control valve to achieve desired outcomes, using financial and non-financial techniques to motivate individuals and groups.
2. Explicit recognition that change will be resisted There are significant benefits to categorical acceptance, admission, or recognition of variables under research. Research involves identifying critical variables that play influential roles in causing phenomena. Once we recognise that resistance to change is a distinct phenomenon for study, we can also study how to overcome this resistance. This reflects the Western academic technique of bifurcating and focusing in a specialised manner to create new subjects and disciplines—essentially, division of labour in academics.
💡 Why this matters: Recognising resistance as a separate, study-worthy phenomenon allows change managers to develop targeted strategies to address it, rather than treating it as an unexpected obstacle.
3. The resistance can be overcome through management and good leadership Knowing that resistance is a critical variable makes it imperative to understand what type of leadership and management style will overcome what type of resistance. Consequently, change management literature largely focuses on participative decision making, employee involvement, delegation, decentralization, and team building for managing organizational transformation and strategic management programmes.
4. Sequence of event also matters The model depicts that the change management process has a sequence. To manage planned change, we must know what should come first, which stage follows another, and how to identify which change management stage we are in—similar to a life cycle approach.
5. Change attitude – behaviour will follow There is a distinction between attitude and behaviour. Attitude is more comprehensive than behaviour, including cognitive and action orientation, while behaviour is defined only in action perspective. According to this approach, to achieve meaningful change we must first change attitude—change in cognition leads to behavioural change. An alternate approach is to change action first, which eventually leads to attitudinal change. The former method is democratic in spirit, while the latter is autocratic in nature.
From a methodological perspective, the dominant paradigm of Western social sciences targets action as the source of data and evidence because intent cannot be measured. From an Islamic perspective, intent (Niyyat) matters most, not action (Amal), as the hadith states: "Actions depend upon intents." This is closer to the recently researched concept of equi-finality, meaning different actions can be taken or multiple practices can exist to reach the same intent effectively.
6. Change the context – behaviour will follow [B = f (P × E)] Environmental forces play a decisive role in shaping behaviour. Change in behaviour is due to a particular context or situation. This relies on the contingency school of management, which holds that organizational efficiency and effectiveness are contingent upon environmental factors—different for different organizations. These factors include size, type of industry, technology, etc.
🔑 Definition — Contingency School of Management: The approach that organizational efficiency and effectiveness depend on (are contingent upon) environmental factors, meaning no single management approach works for all organizations.
If environmental or contextual factors are so powerful and decisive in explaining change or stability, does that mean the individual organization has little or no role, priority, discretion, or strategy in deciding for change? This leads to debates between fatalism vs. determinism, the role of individual vs. institution, and the universal vs. cultural perspectives of management. Context comprises multiple facets: Historical, Social, Political, Geographical, and Cultural context.
A Critical Look
No human knowledge is foolproof. Though Kurt Lewin's model is widely quoted and respected, it has attracted criticism.
1. Linearity assumption Change is assumed to be linear, while in real life it is seldom linear. Reality is often non-linear or curvilinear. There may be ups and downs, and change management is not as neat and sequential as described in the model, directly progressing toward goals or an end state.
2. Progressive state assumption Change makes a direct progression, meaning the future state is always better than the present state. This assumption may not hold valid, especially according to human, organizational, and national life cycle theory-based explanations.
3. Mechanistic assumption This is based on cause and effect relationships among factors considered stimuli for change. It is excessively deterministic in its implications, meaning there is little or no role for unforeseen and emergent events.
4. Goal assumption Change movement is directed toward a specific end-state, while in real life it may be haphazard. People are not always purposive and task-oriented for every movement. People may value leisure, relationship, spiritual and cultural being, or they may like change for the sake of change—due to lifestyle or social pressure, not need-specific reasons. Similarly, people may want to change because emotional or psychological aspects are dominant.
5. Separateness assumption Change movement is planned and managed by people who stay apart from the system, while real life operates in relative terms—diagnosis and implementation occur by remaining within the system. There are biases and ethnocentrism involved in all stages of the change management process.
📐 Formula (for comparison): Beckhard & Harris (1977) Three Stages: Current State → Transition State → Future State 📐 Formula: Kanter et al. Three Phases: Change Strategists → Change Implementers → Change Recipients 📐 Formula: Grimley & Prochaska et al. Four Stages: Pre-contemplation → Contemplation → Action → Maintenance 📐 Formula: Lynn A. Isabella’s Model: Anticipation → Confirmation → Culmination → Aftermath
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical aspects to remember from this lecture are the six implications of Lewin's model: change can be directed and managed, resistance is inevitable and must be explicitly recognised, resistance can be overcome through participative leadership, sequence in change processes matters, changing attitude leads to behavioural change (though the alternative also works), and behaviour is a function of person and environment (B = f[P × E]). Additionally, students must remember the five criticisms of the model—linearity, progressive state, mechanistic, goal, and separateness assumptions—and understand that despite these weaknesses, the model has had seminal influence on change management literature, with subsequent models by Beckhard & Harris, Kanter, Prochaska, and Isabella all verifying similar three or four-stage progression patterns.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between changing attitude first versus changing behaviour first, and which approach is democratic versus autocratic?
- What does the formula B = f(P × E) mean, and what debate does it lead to regarding individual agency versus environmental determinism?
- List and explain the five assumptions of Kurt Lewin's model that have been criticised.
- How does the Islamic concept of intent (Niyyat) relate to the Western focus on action in measuring change?
- Compare the stages of change in Lewin's model with those proposed by Beckhard & Harris, Kanter at al., and Prochaska et al.