π Lecture 21 β Footnotes to Organisational Change
π Overview: This lecture explores James March's influential "footnotes to organizational change," which emphasize the prosaic, routine nature of most organizational change rather than dramatic transformations. It explains why change is both continual and difficult to control, and introduces six basic perspectives for interpreting organizational action as routine adaptive systems.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture presents James March's five footnotes on organizational change, which highlight the relationship between change and adaptive behavior and the prosaic nature of change. It then discusses stable processes of change, explaining that organizations are remarkably adaptive rather than rigid, and that most change results from routine processes. The lecture concludes by introducing six basic perspectives for interpreting organizational action: rule following, problem solving, learning, conflict, contagion, and regeneration.
π Lecture Summary
Foot Notes to Organisational Change
The leading management scholar James March's study dealt with the leading attribute of organizational change. He suggested five footnotes on organization change as they emphasize the relation between change and adaptive behavior which highlights the prosaic nature of change.
Footnote 1: Organizations are continually changing, routinely, easily and responsively, but change within them cannot be controlled arbitrarily. Organizations rarely do exactly what they are told to do.
Footnote 2: Changes in organizations depend on a few stable processes. Theories of change emphasize either the stability of the processes or the changes they produce, but serious understandings of organizations require attention to both.
Footnote 3: Different theories of change are in fact different ways to depict different theories of action. Most changes in organization reflect simple responses to demographic, economic, social and political forces. What we identify as PEST analyses are connected with different parts of environment.
Footnote 4: Although organizational response to environmental events is broadly adaptive and mostly routine-based, the response takes place in a confusing world. As a result, prosaic (characterless) processes sometimes have surprising outcomes.
Footnote 5: Adaptation to changing environment involves an interplay of rationality and foolishness. Organization foolishness is not maintained as conscious strategy, but embedded in such organizational anomalies as slack, managerial incentives, symbolic action, ambiguity and loose coupling.
Stable Processes of Change
One view is that change fails not because organizations are rigid and inflexible but they are impressively imaginative. According to Aldrich, in most organizations failure occurs early in life when organizations are small and flexible, not later. There is considerable level of stability in organization and organizations are remarkably adaptive as enduring institutions, respond to volatile environments easily, though not optimally.
π‘ Why this matters: We are inclined to look for the most dramatic explanations for change, which is our common mistake. Most changes in organizations result neither from organizational processes or forces, nor from uncommon imagination but from relatively stable, routine processes that relate organization to their environments. Many of the most stable procedures in an organization are procedures for responding to economic, social and political contexts. The routine processes of organizational adaptation are little complex, and a theory of change must take into account how these processes can produce unusual patterns of action. Therefore, theory of organization change should not be different from a theory of ordinary action.
Research on organization as routine adaptive systems emphasizes six (06) basic perspectives for interpreting organization action:
1. Rule Following
Application of standard operating procedures (SOPs), duties, obligation, roles, rules, and criteria evolve through competition and survival, and those followed by organizations that survive, grow and multiply come to dominate the pool of procedures.
π Definition β Rule Following: The perspective that organizational action stems from the application of standard operating procedures, duties, roles, and rules that have evolved through competition and survival.
2. Problem Solving
Action can be seen as problem solving. The underlying process involves choosing among alternatives by using some decision rule that compares alternatives in terms of their expected consequences. It is the rational actor model which prevails in organizations. Managers make rational choice under certain conditions of risk and cost-benefit analyses.
π Definition β Problem Solving: The rational actor model where organizational action involves choosing among alternatives by comparing their expected consequences using decision rules, risk assessment, and cost-benefit analysis.
3. Learning
Action can be seen as stemming from past learning. The underlying process is one in which an organization is conditioned through trial and error to repeat behaviour that has been successful in the past, and to avoid that has been unsuccessful. Learning is what can be identified as experiential in nature.
π Definition β Learning: The perspective that organizational action results from past experiential learning, where organizations repeat successful behaviors and avoid unsuccessful ones through trial and error.
4. Conflict
Action can be seen as resulting from conflicting among individuals or groups representing diverse interests. The underlying process is one of confrontation, bargaining and coalition, in which outcomes depend on the initial preferences of actors weighted by their power. Edgar Schein talked of negotiated order to exist in context of organization. Changes result from shifts in the mobilization or in the resources managers' control. This change is again a negotiated one by different members of organization who want to adjust policies as per their understanding view and influence in organization. This model is the one based on politics. Members of organization interact in a political manner and change results in a politically negotiated settlement amongst them. Another view relates to the pecking order in organization β explains the existence of hierarchical or top down order in organizations.
π Definition β Conflict: The political perspective where organizational action results from confrontation, bargaining, and coalition among individuals or groups with diverse interests, with outcomes depending on preferences weighted by power, leading to a negotiated order.
5. Contagion
Action can be seen as spreading from one organization to another. The underlying process is one in which variations in contact among organizations and in the attractiveness of the behaviour or beliefs being imitated affect the rate and pattern of spread.
π Definition β Contagion: The perspective that organizational action spreads from one organization to another through imitation, influenced by contact among organizations and the attractiveness of the behavior or beliefs being imitated.
6. Regeneration
Action can be seen as resulting from the intentions and competencies of organization actors. Turnover in organization introduces new members with different attitudes, abilities and goals. This resembles organization life cycle approach and is quite like birth, growth, maturity and decline.
π Definition β Regeneration: The perspective that organizational action results from the intentions and competencies of actors, with turnover introducing new members who bring different attitudes, abilities and goals, resembling an organizational life cycle of birth, growth, maturity, and decline.
An organization uses rules, problem-solving, learning, conflict, contagion, and regeneration to cope with its environment and actively adapt to it. The processes are conservative β that is, they tend to maintain stable relations, sustain existing rules, and reduce differences among organizations. The above six processes are neither esoteric (mysterious), complicated nor mutually exclusive.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical takeaway from this lecture is that organizational change is fundamentally prosaic and routine-based, not dramatic or revolutionary β organizations change continually and easily but cannot be controlled arbitrarily. Students must remember James March's five footnotes, especially that change depends on stable processes and that routine procedures for responding to the environment are the real drivers of change. The six perspectives for interpreting organizational action (rule following, problem solving, learning, conflict, contagion, and regeneration) are neither esoteric nor mutually exclusive, but represent different ways organizations routinely adapt. A key insight is that our common mistake is looking for dramatic explanations when most change results from ordinary, stable processes. Finally, adaptation involves both rationality and foolishness, where organizational anomalies like slack, ambiguity, and loose coupling play important roles.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
-
According to James March, what is the "prosaic nature" of organizational change, and why is it important to understand this?
-
What does March mean when he says "organizations rarely do exactly what they are told to do" in Footnote 1?
-
How does Aldrich's view about organizational failure (occurring early in life when organizations are small and flexible) challenge common assumptions about change?
-
Explain how the "Conflict" perspective differs from the "Problem Solving" perspective in interpreting organizational action. What does Edgar Schein's concept of "negotiated order" add?
-
What does March mean by "organization foolishness" in Footnote 5, and how do slack, managerial incentives, symbolic action, ambiguity, and loose coupling contribute to adaptation?
π Lecture 22 β SOME COMPLEXITIES OF CHANGE
π Overview: This lecture explores the inherent complexities that make organizational change difficult in real-life settings. It moves beyond simple change models to examine five key phenomena that create unanticipated outcomes and complications in change processes, helping students understand why change often fails or produces unexpected results.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture examines five major complexities of organizational change: unanticipated consequences of ordinary action including competency multiplier effects and superstitious learning; solution-driven problems where organizations seek solutions before fully understanding problems; the tendency for both innovations and organizations to be transformed during the innovation process; the endogenous nature of created environment where organizations influence their own environment; and the interaction among system requirements of individuals, organizations, and environments.
π Lecture Summary
SOME COMPLEXITIES OF CHANGE
The lecture presents six factors that are closer to real-life organizational dynamics and demonstrate the complexities of routines. The interaction amongst these five phenomena makes change complex:
- Unanticipated Consequences of Ordinary Action
- Solution Driven Problems
- The Tendency for Innovation - And Organizations to Be Transformed During the Process of Innovation
- The Endogenous Nature of Created Environment
- The Interaction amongst System Requirements of Individuals, Organizations and Environments
1. Unanticipated Consequences of Ordinary Action
First, the rate of adaptation may be inconsistent with the rate of change of environment. Unless an environment is perfectly stable, an organization cannot learn appropriately. This means organizations always lag behind environment. Where an environment changes quickly relative to the rate of organization adaptation, the process of adaptation can easily lose its sense to be sensible and relevant. At times organizations anticipate ahead of time. An example is a sugar firm in Pakistan that launched a product as liquid sugar β the idea seemed too fine and advanced but failed miserably given the cultural context of Pakistani society. Similarly, some products that are technologically too advanced are also liable to fail because they are ahead of time.
Therefore, it is possible for an anticipatory process (problem-solving) to result in changes that outrun the environment and thereby become unintelligent. Second, the causal structure (cause and effect as seems obvious to us externally) may be different from that implicit in the process. While changing through following and imitating, we tend to focus external effects and ignore causal links which are benign or hidden. Since we have an incomplete picture or false model of causality, eventually change can result in unanticipated outcomes. Third, concurrent or parallel processes (changes at times stay parallel) that appear to carry sense may combine to produce joint outcomes that are not intended by any one, and counter the interests motivating the individual action. For example, the retention of a manual system besides going for the automated (new) one.
Examples β Competency Multiplier
Organizations have procedures to involve relevant people in processes such as decision-making, planning, budgeting or the like. Individuals vary in their knowledge, skills and interests about a problem. Initial participation rates vary and participating individuals turn out to be slightly more competent than others. This induces them to become even more competent. Before long, the de facto composition of the group can change dramatically (than initially conceived). More generally, organizations learn from experience, repeating actions that are successful. As a result they gain greater experience in areas of success than in areas of failures. The sensibleness of such specialization depends on the learning rate and rate of change in environment. The process can easily lead to misplaced specialization if there are infrequent, major shifts in the environment (increased specialization leads to increased dependence and hence organization is vulnerable to change).
Another example of unexpected outcome from organizational routines is related with satisficing behavior of individuals and organizations. According to March and Simon, organizations seek alternatives that will satisfy target goals rather than look for the alternative with the highest possible value. Satisficing organizations can be viewed as organizations that try to maximize the probability of achieving targets. But it is not necessary to assume that satisficing organizations will follow decision rules that are risk-avoiding in good times and risk-seeking in bad times. For example, organizations facing bad times will follow riskier means and riskier strategies, thus simultaneously increasing the chances of their survival through the present crisis and reducing their life expectancy simultaneously.
As a result, organization efforts to survive in fact speed up the process of failure. Risk-seeking behavior transformation needs some qualification, experience and mindset to manage risk which was never cultivated earlier in organizations. Second, most of the time organizations exhibit risk-avoiding behavior by their very nature. Because if organization goals vary with organization performance and performance of comparable organizations, then most organizations will be termed reasonably good most of the time.
Another example identified is of performance criteria. An organization measures the performance of its participants. Common criteria for business firms are to reward their managers on the basis of calculation of profits earned by different parts of the organization. The performance-reward linkage is to be made precise and visible for organizational control purposes as well. However this practice may lead to ignoring long-term consequences for organization since it is more efficient in short term because efforts are devoted to accounts rather than to performance. This may lead the participants to manipulation and maneuvering in organization.
Superstitious Learning
Organizations learn from their experience, repeating actions associated with good outcomes and avoiding actions associated with bad outcomes (learning by association phenomenon or conditioning). This is successful in a stable world. But the world is not so simple and stable all the time β experiential learning can result in superstitious learning. An example reported is of pilots. The trainers reward pilots who make good landings and punish pilots who make bad ones. They observe that pilots who are punished generally improve on subsequent landings, while pilots who are praised generally do worse. Thus they learn that negative reinforcement works better than positive one. The learning is natural but the experience is a confounded one. Students who perform better in preliminary examinations and get rewarded well will tend to perform mediocre in subsequent examinations as against those who perform average in preliminary examinations and improve more in subsequent examinations. These examples illustrate the variation in behavior generated by adaptive processes in typical organization conditions which can lead to surprising outcomes.
2. Solution Driven Problems
Good examples for solution driven problems exist in our society. For instance, go to a doctor and you will find a long, comprehensive multi-dimensional prescription at hand. The solution is already with him without even listening appropriately to his patient. If you go to a computer technologist for problem solving with software or system, the solution presented will be to reconfigure the whole system/window. In office meetings, bosses or heads of departments or organizations frequently come up with statements starting with "you all". All such scenarios refer to the tendency to have a generalized solution in advance.
According to Cyert and March, "There is ample evidence that when organization performance fails to meet objectives, it searches for new solutions, that is new ways of doing things β changes often seem to be driven less by problems than by solutions." Why is this so? Because organizations face a large number of problems of about equal importance, but only a few solutions. Thus the chance of a solution to a particular or unique problem is small. Consequently organizations scan for solutions rather than problems, and match any solution found with some relevant problem.
Second reason is that the linkage between individual solutions and individual problems is often difficult to make unambiguously, especially when causality and technology are ambiguous. Therefore what we observe will be predicted by knowledge of solutions than by knowledge of problems. Imperatively, professionals change their procedures and introduce new technologies because they have knowledge of it. An organization that is modern adopts new things because that is what being modern means. When a major stimulus for change comes from a sense of competence, problems are created in order to solve them, and solutions and opportunities stimulate awareness of previously un-salient or unnoticed problems or preferences.
3. The Tendency for Innovation - And Organisations to Be Transformed During the Process of Innovation
It is observed that both innovations and organizations tend to be transformed during the process of innovation. Different and multiple meanings exist for the intended change in the organization, and hence the standardization of meanings of change is a problem owing to inappropriate strategy or poor analysis. It is also a common problem that change policy or program gets started with some intent and eventually ends up with something else because of the fundamental ways in which changes are transformed by the process of change. Organizations also get transformed in the process. Organizations develop and redefine goals while adapting to environmental pressure; minor changes can lead to larger ones, and initial intent can be entirely lost.
4. The Endogenous Nature of Created Environment
A general assumption is that organizations take action due to environmental pressure, and that environment is not influenced by organizational actions. But organizations create environment as well, and the resulting complications are significant. For example, action of one competitor becomes an environment of another, therefore each competitor determines its own environment. For example, an executive of a leading shoe firm revealed why their firm does not charge higher prices despite producing a quality product of international standards β because this will become an industry standard and other competitors will follow without delivering the same quality. This type of behavior is in line with corporate social responsibility.
Hence adaptation is not learning about a fixed environment but is to deal with continuously changing conditions. Therefore organizations are quite capable of influencing and creating their own environment by the way they interpret and act in a confusing world. So what happens practically is that small signals out of routine or adaptive processes get echoed back to organization (through environment) in an amplified manner, and hence may result in changing organization simultaneously and endogenously.
π‘ Why this matters: This concept challenges the traditional view that organizations merely react to environmental changes. Instead, organizations actively shape their environments through their actions and interpretations, creating a dynamic feedback loop.
5. The Interaction amongst System Requirements of Individuals, Organizations and Environments
Though this is oversimplification, nonetheless, it is possible to see an organization as an intermeshing of three systems: individuals, collection of individuals (which is organization), and environment (which is collection of organizations). Conflicts might exist in the demands of these three. While classical literature focuses on making individual and organization demands compatible, in the analysis of organization change it seems that individuals in organization and organizations themselves have different requirements in the collection of organizations (which is environment). The question is how to place all three in equilibrium. Finally, organization is a complex combination of activities, purposes and meanings.
Even impressive integration of formal organization should not, however, obscure the many ways in which organization is loosely coupled. Behavior is loosely coupled with intentions, and intentions are loosely coupled with actions; actions in one part of the organization are loosely coupled with actions in another part; actions of today are loosely coupled with actions of tomorrow. Such loose coupling does not appear to be avoidable. These do not relate to theory but pertain to adaptive process of change.
π Definition β Satisficing: Organizations seek alternatives that will satisfy target goals rather than look for the alternative with the highest possible value. (March and Simon) π Definition β Superstitious Learning: When experiential learning leads to incorrect cause-effect conclusions because the environment is not stable and simple, causing organizations to repeat actions that coincidentally followed good outcomes. π Definition β Solution Driven Problems: The tendency for organizations to search for solutions first and then match them with problems, rather than analyzing problems to find appropriate solutions. π Definition β Loose Coupling: The phenomenon where organizational elements (behavior with intentions, intentions with actions, actions in different parts, current actions with future actions) are not tightly connected.
β Key Takeaways
The rate of organization adaptation is often inconsistent with the rate of environmental change, causing organizations to either lag behind or outrun their environments. Ordinary organizational routines β including competency development, satisficing behavior, performance measurement, and experiential learning β can produce unanticipated consequences, including superstitious learning where incorrect cause-effect conclusions are drawn. Organizations frequently exhibit solution-driven problem solving where generalized solutions are matched to problems rather than problems being thoroughly analyzed first. Both innovations and organizations are transformed during the change process, with initial intent often being lost. Organizations actively create their own environments through their actions, creating feedback loops, and the three systems of individual, organization, and environment have conflicting requirements that are loosely coupled rather than perfectly integrated.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five phenomena that make organizational change complex according to this lecture?
- What is the "competency multiplier" effect and how can it lead to misplaced specialization in organizations?
- Explain superstitious learning using the pilots' landing example β why is the learning considered "superstitious"?
- According to Cyert and March, why are organizational changes often driven more by solutions than by problems?
- What does "endogenous nature of created environment" mean, and how does the shoe firm example illustrate this concept?