📘 Lecture 16 — Greiner’s Model of Organisational Evolution and Revolution
📖 Overview: This lecture introduces Greiner’s model, which explains why and how organizations fail to grow by focusing on internal dynamics rather than external market forces. It posits that an organization’s future success is determined more by its history and internal structure than by outside opportunities, challenging traditional strategy-structure perspectives. The model identifies five key dimensions that interact over time to create a dynamic picture of organizational growth, comprising alternating periods of evolution and revolution.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the core assumptions of Greiner’s model, contrasting his emphasis on structure over strategy with Chandler’s strategy-structure perspective. It defines the key terms evolution and revolution as prolonged growth and substantial turmoil, respectively. The five essential dimensions for building a model of organization development are then introduced: age of the organisation, size of the organisation, stages of evolution, stages of revolution, and growth rate of the industry. Each dimension is explained, highlighting how problems and solutions change as organizations grow in size and age, with evolution as quiet growth and revolution as turbulent crisis periods.
📝 Lecture Summary
LESSON # 16 GREINER’S MODEL OF ORGANISATIONAL EVOLUTION AND REVOLUTION
The model explains why and how organizations are unable to grow, and suggests how organisations ought to grow. It is based on certain assumptions about the organization. The first assumption is that organisations are rigid, bureaucratic, control-centric, and centralised entities. Second, organisations fail to see that their future success lies within their own organisation and also fail to assess their evolving states of development. Therefore, the inability of a management to understand its organisation development problems can result in the organisation becoming frozen in its present stage of evolution (failure to evolve) regardless of market opportunities.
Greiner’s proposition is that the future of an organisation may be less determined by outside forces than by the organisation’s history. Therefore, to him, internal dynamics of organisation structure play a critical and decisive role in shaping organisation strategy. This view comes closer to the recently popular management paradigm of Resource Based View (RBV) of strategy formulation. According to this view, each firm has a unique combination and configuration of its resources which leads to inimitable competitive advantage.
This position confronts Alfred Chandler, who gave the concept of strategy and structure perspective in business management. Chandler proposed that outside market opportunities determine an organisation’s strategy, which in turn determines company’s structure. So Greiner emphasises structure over strategy while Chandler focuses strategy over structure. Greiner seems also influenced by European psychologists, for whom individual behaviour is determined primarily by previous events and experiences. Hence the analogy of individual development is coined with organisational development.
Before discussing the model, two terms are defined: evolution and revolution. Evolution is used to describe a prolonged period of growth where no major upheaval occurs in organisation practices. Revolution is used to describe those periods of substantial turmoil in organisational life. Each evolutionary period creates its own revolution as the organisation progresses through developmental phases. For instance, centralised practices eventually lead to demand for decentralisation. Moreover, the nature of management’s solution to each evolutionary period determines whether the organisation will move forward into the next stage of evolutionary growth.
According to Greiner, five key dimensions emerge as essential for building a model of organisation development:
- Age of the organisation
- Size of the organisation
- Stages of Evolution
- Stages of Revolution
- Growth rate of the industry
Each dimension influences the other over time; when all five elements begin to interact, a more comprehensive and dynamic picture of organisational growth emerges.
🔑 Definition — Evolution: A prolonged period of growth where no major upheaval occurs in organisation practices. 🔑 Definition — Revolution: Periods of substantial turmoil in organisational life. 🔑 Definition — Resource Based View (RBV): A strategy formulation paradigm where each firm has a unique combination and configuration of its resources which leads to inimitable competitive advantage.
💡 Why this matters: Greiner’s model directly challenges the dominant strategy-structure view by arguing that internal historical dynamics—not external opportunities—primarily determine organizational growth and survival.
1. Age of the organisation
It is the foremost and essential dimension of organisation development. It is clear that the same organisation practices are not maintained throughout a long span of time. The most basic point is that management problems and practices are rooted in time. MBO (Management by Objectives) a decade back had different meanings than today. The passage of time also contributes to the institutionalisation of managerial attitude. As a result, employee behaviour becomes not only more predictable but also more difficult to change when attitudes are outdated. For example, Parkinson’s law of expansion means work tends to expand over time.
🔑 Definition — Parkinson’s law of expansion: Work tends to expand over time.
2. Size of the organisation
Organisation’s problems and solutions to such problems tend to change markedly as the number of employees and sales volume increases. Thus time is not the only determinant of structure; in fact, organisations that do not grow in size can retain many of the same management issues and practices over lengthy periods. Very typical problems of increased size are problems of coordination and communication, emergence of new functions, levels in the management hierarchy, and jobs becoming inter-related.
3. Stage of Evolution
The term seems to describe a quieter period in organisation history with modest adjustments necessary for maintaining growth under the overall same pattern of management. With the increase in size and time, a phenomenon becomes evident which is “prolonged growth”. Evolution is equated with continuous and prolonged growth. According to Greiner, most growing organisations do not expand two years and then retreat for one year; rather, those that survive crises usually enjoy four to eight years of continuous growth without a major setback or severe internal disruption.
4. Stages of Revolution
Smooth evolution is not inevitable for long. In other words, organisation growth cannot be assumed linear. For example, many case histories of Fortune 500 listed companies reveal that companies had periods of substantial turbulence spaced between periods of evolution. Turbulent times leading to severe upheaval of management practices means revolution or period of revolution.
Traditional management practices appropriate for smaller size and earlier times are brought under scrutiny by frustrated top managers and disillusioned lower-level managers. Many organisations fail during such a crisis—unable to abandon past practices, they have to wind-up or compromise to lower levels of growth.
The critical task for management in each revolutionary period is to find a new set of organisation practices that will become the basis for managing the next period of evolutionary growth. Interestingly, the new practices sow their own seeds of decay and lead to another revolution.
Therefore, management sees something a solution in one time period becomes a major problem later. For example, at individual level, the same situation can be identified as a success trap, meaning success has its own trap which generates single-variable-mindedness type of thinking in individuals.
🔑 Definition — Success trap: A situation where success generates single-variable-mindedness type of thinking in individuals, meaning what was once a solution becomes a major problem later.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Greiner’s model emphasizes that an organization’s internal structure and history—not just external market forces—determine its growth trajectory, directly challenging Chandler’s strategy-structure view. Organizations experience alternating phases of evolution (4–8 years of quiet, prolonged growth) and revolution (periods of substantial turmoil), and the management’s solution to each revolutionary crisis determines whether the organization progresses to the next evolutionary stage. Five key dimensions—age, size, stages of evolution, stages of revolution, and industry growth rate—interact dynamically to shape organizational development. A critical insight is that solutions adopted in one phase sow the seeds of future crises (the success trap), meaning traditional practices that worked for smaller/younger organizations become major problems later. The model is rooted in the Resource Based View, focusing on internal resources as the source of inimitable competitive advantage.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two key assumptions underlying Greiner’s model of organisational evolution and revolution?
- How does Greiner’s view of structure vs. strategy differ from Alfred Chandler’s perspective?
- According to Greiner, how long do most growing organizations typically enjoy continuous growth without major setbacks?
- What is the critical task for management in each revolutionary period, and why do new practices eventually lead to another revolution?
- What is the “success trap” and how does it relate to Greiner’s model of organisational development?
📘 Lecture 17 — Growth Rate of the Industry
📖 Overview: This lecture explains how an organization's growth is tied to its industry's market environment, with faster-growing industries experiencing more rapid phases of evolution and revolution. It introduces Greiner's five phases of growth, where each evolutionary period is defined by a dominant management style, and each revolutionary period by a crisis that must be resolved for continued growth. Understanding these phases helps managers anticipate challenges and adapt their leadership style to sustain organizational development.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by explaining how the growth rate of an industry influences the speed at which organizations experience phases of evolution and revolution. It then introduces Greiner's five phases of growth, noting that each phase is both an effect of the previous phase and a cause for the next. The lecture details Phase 1: Creativity, including the Leadership Crisis; Phase 2: Direction, including the Autonomy Crisis; and Phase 3: Delegation, including the Control Crisis. Each phase is described with its characteristic management style, organizational traits, and the specific revolutionary crisis that triggers the next phase.
📝 Lecture Summary
GROWTH RATE OF THE INDUSTRY
The speed at which an organization experiences phases of evolution and revolution is closely related to the market environment of its industry. Different industries (e.g., computers, automobiles, banking) have different growth rates. Evolution can be prolonged, and revolutions can be delayed. Revolution seems much more severe and difficult to resolve when the market environment is poor or declining. Marginal organizations seem to do better when the market environment is good or improving.
💡 Why this matters: The industry's growth rate directly determines how quickly a company will encounter each phase of growth and crisis, affecting strategic planning and managerial responses.
Greiner identified five phases of growth – each phase of growth is marked by evolutionary progress and a revolutionary period (or crisis). Each evolutionary period is characterized by the dominant management style used to achieve growth, while each revolutionary period is characterized by the dominant management problem. Companies in faster-growing industries tend to experience all five phases more rapidly, while those in slower-growing industries encounter only two or three phases over many years.
It is also important to note that each phase is both an effect of the previous phase and a cause for the next phase. For example, a directive management style in one phase may lead to an autonomy crisis (revolution) and eventually be followed by delegation.
The principal implication of each phase is that management actions are narrowly prescribed if growth is to occur. So an organization experiencing a crisis of autonomy cannot return to a directive management style for a solution – it must adopt a new style of delegation in order to move ahead.
PHASE 1: CREATIVITY
At the birth stage, emphasis is on creating both a product and a market. The characteristics of the period of creative evolution are:
- Founders are usually technically or entrepreneurially driven and disdain management activities.
- Communication is frequent and informal.
- Long hours of work are rewarded by modest salaries.
- Control comes from market feedback; management acts quickly as the customer reacts.
- A leadership crisis occurs as individualistic and creative activities help the organization to take off.
1. Leadership Crisis
As the company grows, it needs larger production, specialized knowledge about efficiencies of manufacturing, marketing, finance, or capital, and therefore an increased number of professional people in all functional areas. All this cannot be managed at an informal level. Formalization, proceduralism, and bureaucratization come into play for better financial and managerial control. Founders find themselves with unwanted managerial responsibilities. They still try to act in the past ways. Owners enter into conflict with managers. This issue is cited as agency theory in corporate governance and strategic management courses. At this point, a crisis of leadership occurs – the first revolution. Founders often hate to step aside even though they are probably temperamentally unsuited to be managers. The developmental choice for the founder is to choose a strong manager and step aside for perpetual growth, or select a weak manager and compromise on growth.
🔑 Definition — Agency Theory: The conflict of interest that arises between owners (principals) and managers (agents) as organizations grow and require professional management. 📌 Example: A founder who built a company through creative, hands-on work now faces conflicts with professional managers who want to introduce formal systems, budgets, and hierarchical structures. The founder must choose between hiring a strong CEO to lead growth or keeping weak managers and limiting the company's expansion.
PHASE 2: DIRECTION
Those who survive by installing strong and capable managers usually embark on a period of sustained growth under able and directive leadership. The traits of this evolutionary period are:
- Functional organizational structure – specialization and division of labour.
- Systems and sub-systems get developed – accounting for inventory and purchasing.
- Budgets and work & job standards are adopted.
- Communication becomes more formal and impersonal as a hierarchy of title and position builds.
- Lower and upper level conflict becomes obvious as the organization grows and has more layers of hierarchy.
- Lower level employees feel restricted by cumbersome procedures and a centralized hierarchy.
- Lower level managers have more direct knowledge of the market and machinery than do the leaders at the top (who govern through paperwork from the office).
2. Autonomy Crisis
Thus the second revolution is imminent as a crisis develops from the demand for greater autonomy on the part of lower-level managers. Yet it is difficult for top managers who were so successful in developing systems, being directive, and staying responsible to give up authority. Moreover, lower level managers are not accustomed to making decisions for themselves. As a result, numerous companies flounder during this revolutionary period by adhering to centralized methods while lower level managers become disenchanted and leave the organization (turnover rate increases).
🔑 Definition — Autonomy Crisis: The revolutionary period where lower-level managers demand greater decision-making freedom, creating conflict with top managers who are reluctant to delegate authority. 📌 Example: A growing company with a centralized hierarchy and formal procedures finds that its plant managers and regional sales managers, who have direct customer and market knowledge, feel stifled by top-down directives. These managers begin leaving the company, causing high turnover, because top executives refuse to grant them autonomy.
PHASE 3: DELEGATION
The next era of growth evolves from the successful application of a decentralized organizational structure, which exhibits the following characteristics:
- More responsibility is given to the managers of plants and market territories.
- Profit centres, incentives, and bonuses are used to motivate managers.
- Top executives at headquarters restrain themselves to managing by exception based on periodic reports from the field.
- Management now focuses on making new acquisitions which can be added to the corporation as decentralized units.
- Communication from the top is infrequent, usually by correspondence, telephone, or brief field visits.
Of course, now IT has made this communication fast, easier, and effective. The delegation proves useful for gaining expansion through motivation of lower level managers, by giving them authority and incentives, to penetrate larger markets, respond faster to customers, and develop newer and effective managerial practices.
3. Control Crisis
Top executives sense they are losing control over a highly diversified field of operations (owing to power-politics, upward mobility of lower level managers, fear of replacement, etc.). Autonomous managers prefer to run their own shows without coordinating plans, resources, technology, and manpower. The revolution becomes obvious when top management seeks to regain control over the total company. One solution is re-centralization, which usually fails because the company's operations have become too diverse and vast. The other solution is to evolve special coordination techniques.
🔑 Definition — Control Crisis: The revolutionary period where top management feels they are losing control over diverse, autonomous field operations, and autonomous managers resist coordination. 🔑 Definition — Managing by Exception: A management practice where top executives only intervene when performance reports show significant deviations from planned targets. 📌 Example: A company that successfully decentralized into profit centres now finds that regional managers refuse to share resources, coordinate plans, or standardize technology across units. Top management's attempt to re-centralize fails because the business is too large and complex. The solution must involve new coordination mechanisms rather than reverting to central control.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The speed at which organizations evolve and face revolutions is directly tied to their industry's growth rate, with faster-growing industries moving through all five phases more rapidly. Each of Greiner's phases consists of an evolutionary period (defined by a dominant management style) followed by a revolutionary crisis (defined by a dominant management problem). The three phases covered in this lecture are Creativity (leading to a Leadership Crisis), Direction (leading to an Autonomy Crisis), and Delegation (leading to a Control Crisis). A critical lesson is that management cannot solve a revolutionary crisis by reverting to the previous phase's management style; instead, it must adopt the next phase's approach to achieve continued growth. The key crises to remember are: the Leadership Crisis (founders must step aside for professional managers), the Autonomy Crisis (top managers must delegate to lower-level managers), and the Control Crisis (top management must develop coordination techniques rather than re-centralize).
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What is the relationship between an industry's growth rate and the speed at which an organization experiences Greiner's phases?
- Describe the characteristics of the evolutionary period in Phase 1 (Creativity). What triggers the first revolutionary crisis?
- Explain the Autonomy Crisis. Why is it difficult for both top managers and lower-level managers to resolve?
- What management style characterizes Phase 3 (Delegation)? What specific organizational structures and practices support this phase?
- Why does re-centralization typically fail as a solution to the Control Crisis, and what alternative approach must management adopt?
📘 Lecture 18 — Phase 4: Coordination
📖 Overview: This lecture continues the exploration of Greiner's model of organizational growth, detailing Phase 4 (Coordination) and Phase 5 (Collaboration). It explains how organizations use formal systems to achieve greater coordination, the resulting "Red Tape Crisis," and how collaboration through teams and interpersonal skills can overcome this crisis. This matters because it maps the predictable patterns of organizational evolution and revolution that managers must navigate for sustainable growth.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers Phase 4 (Coordination), characterized by formal systems, product-group mergers, and staff managers; the "Red Tape Crisis," where procedures overshadow problem-solving and differentiation exceeds integration; Phase 5 (Collaboration), which emphasizes spontaneity, team-based action, and social control; the crisis of this phase for mature multinationals; and the perpetual cycle of evolution and revolution.
📝 Lecture Summary
PHASE 4: COORDINATION
This evolutionary phase is characterized by the use of formal systems for achieving greater coordination, with top executives taking responsibility for initiating and administering new systems. For example, decentralized units are merged into product groups, formal planning procedures are established and intensely reviewed. Other features include: numerous staff managers hired at headquarters (HQ) to initiate company-wide programs of control and review for line managers; capital expenditure decisions are carefully made; each product group is treated as an investment centre where return on investment (ROI) is an important criterion for funds allocation; stock options and profit-sharing schemes are used to encourage identity with the firm as a whole. HQ-subsidiary dynamics (HQ-branch relationship) come to play as a factor in organization growth or performance.
🔑 Definition — Staff Managers: Managers hired at headquarters to initiate company-wide programs of control and review for line managers. 📐 Formula: ROI (Return on Investment) = (Net Profit / Investment Cost) × 100 → Used to evaluate the profitability of an investment centre. 📌 Example: A product group is treated as an investment centre; if it generates a net profit of $200,000 on an investment of $1,000,000, the ROI is 20%, influencing funds allocation decisions.
💡 Why this matters: Coordination phase systems can become rigid, leading to the next crisis.
4. Red Tape Crisis
The Red Tape Crisis arises from a lack of confidence and trust between line and staff, and between HQ and field. Systems, programs, and procedures go beyond their utility and become ends in themselves. Line managers resent heavy direction by staffs who are unaware of local conditions. Staffs, on the other hand, complain about uncooperative and uninformed line managers. Therefore, procedure takes precedence over problem solving, and innovation is dampened.
Lawrence & Lorsch highlighted this in their study as the problem of differentiation and integration. As organizations become large, vertical and horizontal differentiation becomes pronounced. The problem at this stage is: the higher the differentiation, the higher will be the need for integration.
🔑 Definition — Differentiation and Integration: Differentiation is the division of an organization into specialized units (vertical and horizontal). Integration is the coordination required to unite these units. The crisis occurs when differentiation outpaces the organization's capacity for integration.
PHASE 5: COLLABORATION
To overcome the crisis of red tape, strong interpersonal collaboration is suggested in this phase. The difference between Phase 4 (Coordination) and Phase 5 (Collaboration) is that the Coordination phase was managed more through formal systems and institutional procedures, while Phase 5 (Collaboration) emphasizes greater spontaneity in managerial actions through teams and the skilful confrontation of interpersonal differences.
Social control and self-discipline take over from formal control. This transition is very difficult for those who create and believe in formal methods of report and answers. This phase evolution builds a more flexible and behavioural approach to management. Features include: focus on problem-solving quickly through team-thinking and team-actions; teams are combined across functions; HQ staff experts are reduced in numbers and combined in cross-functional teams to consult (not to direct) field units; formal systems and procedures are simplified to focus on tasks; conferences of key managers are held on major organizational issues; reliance on educational and training programs for conflict-resolution and better teamwork; real-time information systems are integrated into daily decision-making; rewards are geared more towards team performance than individual achievement; experiments with new practices are tolerated and encouraged.
🔑 Definition — Social Control and Self-Discipline: A form of control where employees regulate their own behavior based on shared values, norms, and team expectations, replacing external, formal controls.
The Crisis
What will be the revolution in this stage of evolution? Many large and mature multinationals (MNCs) are in this phase. Whatever the answer is, the sole focus is that each evolutionary period culminates into a revolutionary period, which is short, spasmodic, and transformative for the existing managerial system, and the processes are never-ending and perpetual.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The critical concepts from this lecture are: (1) Phase 4 (Coordination) relies on formal systems, staff managers, and investment centres with ROI criteria, but it inevitably leads to the "Red Tape Crisis" where procedures stifle innovation. (2) The Red Tape Crisis is rooted in the problem of differentiation and integration—as organizations become more specialized, the need for effective coordination increases. (3) Phase 5 (Collaboration) overcomes this crisis by shifting from formal control to social control and self-discipline, emphasizing team-based problem-solving and cross-functional collaboration. (4) The transition from formal to behavioral management is difficult but essential for continued growth. (5) The cycle of evolution (gradual growth) followed by revolution (transformative crisis) is perpetual, and each phase contains the seeds of its own crisis.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the key features of Phase 4 (Coordination), and what crisis does it typically lead to?
- Explain the problem of "differentiation and integration" as identified by Lawrence & Lorsch in the context of the Red Tape Crisis.
- What is the fundamental difference between Phase 4 (Coordination) and Phase 5 (Collaboration) in how they manage organizational activities?
- What replaces formal control in Phase 5 (Collaboration), and what makes this transition difficult?
- What is the ultimate message of Greiner's model regarding the relationship between evolutionary and revolutionary periods in organizations?
📘 Lecture 19 — Organisation Ecology
📖 Overview: This lecture introduces the population ecology school of thought in change management, which argues that environmental selection rather than internal adaptation primarily determines organizational survival. It explores the critical role of structural inertia in constraining organizational change and examines the debate between adaptation and selection perspectives in organization theory.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the population ecology model of change management, focusing on three central issues: the role of structural inertia in constraining adaptation, the classification of organizational species, and the salience of the environment in determining organizational survival. It examines internal structural arrangements and external factors that generate inertial pressures, including sunk costs, communication barriers, internal politics, institutional norms, government and industry barriers, bounded rationality, and social legitimacy. The lecture also discusses the paradox of population ecology research methodology and the relationship between organizational size and structural inertia.
📝 Lecture Summary
Leading Proponents and Core Concepts
Leading proponents of the organization ecology school of thought are Glenn and Carroll, and Hannan and Freeman. In this theory, the population of organizations is taken as a unit of analysis rather than a single organization. The dominant theme of population ecology is that the effects of an organization's environment are critical in the organization's survival and performance, believing that forces internal to the organization are less important. Principally, population ecologists think that organizations do not change and adapt; they consider that each time a new organization is born after a significant level of change. Pfeffer and Salancik published their work as "The external control of organizations," leading to the analogy of natural selection processes as determining some aspects of organization. Miller and Mintzberg referred to "the survival of organizational forms as being encouraged by Darwinian forces" (e.g., Weberian organization dominance of functional structure).
Three issues are considered central in the population ecology model of change management:
- Role of structural inertia in constraining adaptation
- The classification of organizational species
- The salience of the environment in determining organizational survival
1. Structural Inertia
Population ecology models of organization-environment relationship are considered alternative to the dominant adaptation perspective. Though there are a variety of ecological perspectives, they all focus on the selection phenomenon. The attribute patterns in nature are attributed to the action processes. Astley and Van de Ven highlighted this adaptation versus selection as a central debate in organization theory (OT). Selection of new or changed organization forms occurs as a result of environmental constraints, and inertia is referred to as an explanation for the lack of adaptive change. Therefore, structural inertia limits the ability of an organization to change. Hanna and Freeman identified a number of processes that generate inertial pressures both from internal structural arrangements and from environmental constraints.
A. Internal Structural Arrangements
One of the biggest inhibiting factors for organizational change is sunk cost. Sunk cost of the firm, which means broadly any amount of time, money, and efforts (plant & equipment or cost of R&D and trained personnel), develops a restraining force within an entity to freely look for alternative options. Structural arrangements refer to the rules and resources which an organization deploys manifesting its commitment levels. A communication structure in an organization like barriers and misperception amongst various players at vertical and horizontal levels also facilitates inertial process. Internal politics for vested interests amongst organizational members acts as a restraining force. The existing institutional norms — rules and regulations — remain status quo oriented to inhibit organizational change.
🔑 Definition — Sunk Cost: Any amount of time, money, and efforts (such as plant & equipment or cost of R&D and trained personnel) that develops a restraining force within an entity to freely look for alternative options.
B. External Factors
Not only internal factors inhibit change, but at times external factors like government and industry create barriers in smooth and consistent change management process. For instance, there may be a very high cost associated with a firm's decision to enter or exit any particular industry or market. Bounded rationality, a concept given by Herbert Simon, means managers are rationalizing not rational, meaning thereby that decisions on the part of managers are always bounded by constraints like time, space, cost, and information. Therefore, the choice of decision makers to go for alternative options is extremely limited. Another relevant concept is of social legitimacy, which imposes restriction in the decision outcome for change or status quo. Managers will go for such decisions which are considered legitimate and acceptable by society or by the members of the organization socially. Most of the time, society is slow to recognize and accept change, and more often it is conservative to accept change. So what happens practically is that organizations try to initiate change but then do not intend to go for complete transformation. Miller and Freisen identified this kind of response to environmental changes as sluggish adaptation. Miller also used the term adaptive rigidities caused by the avoidance of uncertainties, and the fragmentation of the political coalition and its goals cushion organizations from the need for adaptation. All these issues of structural inertia (and in a way with organization adaptation phenomenon as well) explain the relative superiority of natural selection process over adaptation in the survival of organization.
🔑 Definition — Bounded Rationality: A concept given by Herbert Simon meaning managers are rationalizing not rational, meaning decisions are always bounded by constraints like time, space, cost, and information. 🔑 Definition — Social Legitimacy: A restriction in the decision outcome for change or status quo where managers will go for decisions considered legitimate and acceptable by society or by organizational members socially. 🔑 Definition — Adaptive Rigidities: A term used by Miller caused by the avoidance of uncertainties, and the fragmentation of the political coalition and its goals that cushion organizations from the need for adaptation.
Environmental Selection and Its Implications
Therefore, population ecologists believe that environmental selection replaces adaptation as the vehicle of change. Hannan and Freeman formulated a theory well supported by empirical evidence that "stronger the inertial pressures, lower the adaptive flexibility and the more likely that the logic of environmental selection is appropriate." Hence the proposition is that the survival of organizations is determined by environmental variations.
💡 Why this matters: This perspective directly challenges the traditional view of management's role in organizational success. If environmental selection is dominant, then management practices, governance, and organizational structure have significantly less impact on survival than previously thought.
By implications, we see population ecologists maintain a lesser role for management, wise governance, organization structure, and benchmarked managerial practices. There is a paradox in this thinking. The paradox with population ecology is that methodologically, the study deals with small organizations with simple organization structures which were free from issues of sunk cost and politics (non-chain small restaurant in 18 cities of California State). External constraints were not strong either. The paradox is that inertia is, somewhat, largely a phenomenon associated with the complex department structures of large organizations.
To Astley and van de Ven, "Natural selection model fits small, powerless organizations operating in environment with dispersed resources better than large well connected organizations operating in environment with concentrated resources." For Aldrich, the structural inertia depends on the size of organizations. The larger an organization, the greater the structural inertia and the more control the organization can exercise over the environment (in real life, large organizations seem quite powerful to shape or influence environment). Another scholar empirically says "the few organizations that survive infancy owe their above average longevity to wise governance."
📌 Example: The population ecology study focused on non-chain small restaurants in 18 cities of California State — organizations with simple structures, free from issues of sunk cost and politics, with weak external constraints.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The population ecology perspective fundamentally challenges adaptation-based change management by arguing that environmental selection, not managerial adaptation, primarily determines organizational survival. Structural inertia, generated by both internal factors (sunk costs, communication barriers, internal politics, institutional norms) and external factors (government barriers, bounded rationality, social legitimacy), severely constrains an organization's ability to change. However, a critical paradox exists: population ecology research was conducted on small, simple organizations that lack the complex inertia of large organizations, yet the theory's conclusions are often applied broadly. The structural inertia actually depends on organizational size — larger organizations exhibit greater inertia but also possess more power to shape their environment. The central debate remains whether natural selection or strategic adaptation better explains organizational survival and change.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three central issues in the population ecology model of change management?
- Explain how sunk costs and internal politics create structural inertia in organizations.
- Define bounded rationality and explain how it limits managers' decision-making options for change.
- What is the paradox of population ecology research regarding organizational size and structural inertia?
- According to population ecologists, why does environmental selection replace adaptation as the vehicle of organizational change?
📘 Lecture 20 — Classification of Organizational Species
📖 Overview: This lecture explores the population ecology perspective on organizations, drawing analogies from biology to understand how organizational forms emerge, survive, or die. It examines how environments differentially affect various organizational species, the relationship between adaptation and selection, and the determinants of organizational founding and mortality rates.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers classification of organizational species by examining what characterizes an organizational form (specie) through formal structure, activity patterns, and normative order. It explores the extent of environmental selection, emphasizing that environments are subjectively perceived by different organizations. The relationship between adaptation and selection is discussed, along with determinants of vital rates including competition, institutional constraints, government roles, and social embeddedness.
📝 Lecture Summary
Classification of Organizational Species
Like biology, organizational ecology emphasizes population within a species as the unit of analysis. The key question is what characterizes an organizational form (specie). Hannan and Freeman state, "An organization form is a blue print for organizational action, for transforming inputs into outputs." This blueprint can be inferred by examining:
- Formal structure — written rules of operations
- Pattern of activity — what actually gets done by whom
- Normative order — ways of organizing defined as right and proper by members and relevant environmental sectors
Ulrich defines form as a "legally defined entity" with a population of firms consisting of similar competencies, structures, and strategies. Organization form can also be determined according to criteria such as technology, industry grouping, and product.
🔑 Definition — Organizational form (specie): A blueprint for organizational action that transforms inputs into outputs, inferred through formal structure, activity patterns, and normative order.
Extent of Environmental Selection
The population ecology model stresses that the environment determines the distribution and form of organizations through selection. The environment in a biological sense is not an objective phenomenon. Biologists refer to the environmental niche — the environment perceived by an ANT is clearly different from that perceived by an ELEPHANT. Minor changes may spell the demise of a population of ANTS but go unnoticed by an ELEPHANT.
Similarly, the environmental niches inhabited by SMALL and LARGE organizations are subjectively different. Different species (organizations) perceive and experience the environment differently. Environments are multidimensional and complex, not similar for all types of organizations. While the ecological approach suggests focusing on common fate with respect to environmental variation, the reality is that environment differs for different organizations.
💡 Why this matters: This subjective perception of environment means a change that devastates small businesses may barely affect large corporations, and vice versa — managers must understand their organization's specific niche.
The key question is: What is the effect of changes in environment on the mortality of population? Individual organization mortality may occur from accident, incompetence, or rational choice. Distinction should be made when owners arbitrarily decide to close down for personal or economic reasons. Owners also set the tone for level of growth and profitability.
Another scholar discussed vital rates of founding and mortality (entries and exit) and the process of founding and mortality. The thrust of organizational ecology should investigate how social environment shapes:
- Rates of creation and death of organizational forms
- Rates of organizational founding and mortality
- Rates of change in organization forms
What is more important for further research is the relationship between adaptation and selection, and determinants of vital rates.
🔑 Definition — Environmental niche: The specific environment as perceived and experienced by a particular organizational species, which differs subjectively between small and large organizations.
🔑 Definition — Vital rates: The rates of founding (entry) and mortality (exit) of organizations within a population.
Relationship between Adaptation and Selection
An empirical study by Carroll found that the timing of executive succession was an important factor in organizational survival. In a biological sense, adaptability is an individual behavioral phenomenon. Penning stressed the role of adaptation: "Organization will maneuver themselves in their environment, so as to acquire optimum external control and will shift their disposition whenever environmental conditions dictate."
To Penning, the entrepreneur is a "volitional individual" who enters an environment and makes strategic choices that ensure the best transactions with the environment.
Determinants of Vital Rates
Vital rates means death rates and founding rates of an organization. This leads to the study of both large organizations and entrepreneurship and small businesses. Possible determinants of organizational death and inception include:
- Role of competition
- Institutional constraints
- Role of government (e.g., subsidy, tax exemption given by US government to Chrysler automobiles thrice in its history)
- Type of product or industry becoming obsolete
What causes death of an organization? The immediate factor could be attributed to consistent sales decline or poor financial performance as the most obvious indicator. However, going deeper reveals these indicators as symptoms, not problems.
Consider organizations that are socially embedded and inter-linked through alliances and networks. Examples include:
- Keiretsu in Japan
- Chaebol in Korea
- Big family-based conglomerates in countries like Pakistan
In these contexts, social identities and ties are more important than technically or transaction-driven relationships. When social ties (death of a network) cease to be effective, it hastens the death of an organization. Similarly, if a central or lynchpin organization is forcibly closed, reorganized, or dissolved, constituent organizations will face a drift.
The big issue in ecology school is: Are diversified organizations (un-related diversification) or huge conglomerates that dominate international business equally affected by environment or laws of natural selection?
🔑 Definition — Social embeddedness: The inter-linking of organizations through social ties, alliances, and networks where social identities matter more than purely technical or transactional relationships.
⭐ Key Takeaways
This lecture establishes that organizations can be classified as species based on their formal structure, activity patterns, and normative order. The environment is subjectively perceived — small and large organizations inhabit different environmental niches and are affected differently by environmental changes. The population ecology approach focuses on vital rates (founding and mortality) and how social environment shapes these rates. The relationship between adaptation (strategic choice by entrepreneurs) and selection (environmental forces) remains a critical area for research. Social embeddedness through networks and alliances can significantly influence organizational survival, with the death of key network organizations hastening the demise of connected organizations.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- According to Hannan and Freeman, what three elements can reveal an organization's "blueprint" (form)?
- How does the concept of "environmental niche" explain why small and large organizations perceive environmental changes differently?
- What are the three dimensions of organization that social environment shapes according to the population ecology model?
- Name at least four determinants of organizational death and inception discussed in the lecture.
- Why might indicators like sales decline or poor financial performance be symptoms rather than root causes of organizational death, particularly in socially embedded business contexts like Keiretsu or Chaebol?