📘 Lecture 35 — Implementation and Strategic Change: Constraining Forces in the Implementation of Strategic Change (Case Study of XYZ Company) (Continued)
📖 Overview: This lecture continues the discussion of constraining forces in the implementation of strategic change, focusing on two intangible variables: people and culture. It explores how human traits, behaviors, and organizational values can create significant resistance to change implementation, and concludes with additional reasons why implementing strategic change is so difficult, drawing on the work of author Alex Miller.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the intangible constraining forces in strategic change implementation, specifically seven people-related factors (fear of failure, resistance to change, parochial bias, turf protection, short-term orientation, complacency, and inappropriate talent/skills) and five culture-related factors (ill-defined values, lack of consensus, lack of fit, values conflicting with entrepreneurial requirements, and non-egalitarian values). It then examines additional reasons for implementation difficulty, including the organization’s immune system, numerous complex variables, interconnectedness of elements, and the need to change everything at once.
📝 Lecture Summary
People
The matter under discussion is how to manage people. It is the people who at the action level can make change implementation either a success or failure. So, people’s traits, psyches, attitudes, behaviors, and their orientation must be analyzed, particularly at lower levels where masses of people are directly involved in change orientation and execution.
(a) Fear of failure – non performance and humiliation
It is a general tendency that whenever a change program or plan is introduced in an organization and is perceived negatively by a greater majority of managers as against established patterns, norms, and conventions, then the resistance level will be quite high. One reason for higher resistance towards a change plan has been the perceived threat of non-performance, which acts as a source of failure associated with humiliation. Here, an innovative organizational structure provides some remedies. For instance, it allows failure to occur. This also means that the organization culture is not geared towards learning.
(b) Resistance to change – non comfort zone
Again, the fear of change leads individuals or groups from a comfort zone to a non-comfort zone where learning about new values, new technologies, new patterns, or fears about unknowns produce resistance. This resistance to change can cause considerable loss of efficiency in organizations. In fact, if an organization goes for successful execution of strategic change, then strategists should go for removing this phenomenon. Therefore, there must be the introduction of a learning oriented culture or entrepreneurship-like attributes in the organizational environment.
(c) Parochial bias – ethnocentrisms
Parochialism, provincialism, or ethnocentrisms means to interpret things or developments on a self-reference basis. Again, there is a tendency among individuals or groups that they perceive changes narrowly and un-sophisticatedly. At the organizational level where we have different hierarchies, groups, departments, and divisions, parochialism is dangerous for the health of the organization. Under such situations, management consultants and strategists must work to explore the dominant interpretation of change acceptability and ensure that the benefits of that change should be for large masses with minimized costs.
(d) Turf protection – hiding behaviour
Turf protection means favouritism or protection of individuals or a group or groups who have some vested interest with the change process. For instance, the protection for those ones: (1) who are non-performers, or (2) may be for those who are loyalists toward change initiators. The turf protection, therefore, leads an organization towards failure in change implementation. In the context of developing countries, for instance, where we have seen a more personalized style of management, the turf protection culture is more prominent and highly lucrative.
(e) Short-term orientation
Short term orientation means short-sightedness. Earlier in the strategic direction variable we have discussed that leaders who have a short-term view in respect of time often go for immediate calculations instead of long-term or deferred gratifications. This is a myopic view of organizing and such behaviour is actually associated with individual psyche. The same behaviour also matters from an organizational perspective. Organizations that go for immediate calculations suffer losses in the long run. Contrarily, organizations that go for deferred attitude may be at a deficit in the short term but in the long run they are more lucrative. In cross-cultural terms, for instance, traditional Asiatic peoples such as Japanese, Chinese, or Malays have had long-term behaviour then other Asiatic ones. In reality, we have also seen them more developed and rich.
💡 Why this matters: Short-term orientation creates a myopic view that prioritizes immediate gains over sustainable, long-term strategic success. Understanding this bias helps strategists design change programs that reward patience and delayed gratification.
(f) Complacency – satisficing behaviour
It is generally observed that the people who are involved in the change process are more satisficing and complacent than those who actually are not involved. Therefore, complacent people are those who retain their energies at a certain level which may be appropriately below the maximizing level. In general, the behaviour of employees is satisficing rather than toward maximizing. One thing that produces such a scenario is organization structure and design. If an organization structure is decentralized and the behaviour of employees is complacent towards objective setting and achieving, then it goes for maximizing behaviour. On the other hand, in organizations based on a centralized structure, the normal behaviour of employees is not complacent and is based on a ‘wait-and-see’ strategy. Therefore, this is satisficing behaviour instead of maximizing because of the least involvement of employees. The complacency concept is actually studied under the domain of Management by Objective (MBO) in both Management and Change Management disciplines. It is normally used as a tool for avoiding resistance and conflicts.
(g) Inappropriate talent/ skills
If an organization wants to avoid resistance, then they should be appropriately equipped with the requisite level of skills, knowledge, and aptitude. It is based on learning behaviour or on a learning culture in an organization. Here, organization strategists can play an important role in the change implementation process by determining the required skills and aptitudes and how these can be acquired. This is crucial for change implementation and for achieving the desired level of productivity.
Culture
(a) Ill-defined values or preferences and priorities
Managers, often top managers, sometimes cannot create the climate for the enterprise. Sometimes, this is because they have been unable to define and prioritize the values and preferences in the organization. The values and preferences of the organization depend on the values and preferences of the top management because their values influence the direction of the firm. Also, sometimes top management has conceived the values and preferences but is unable to share them with the bottom of the organization. That makes implementation difficult and can create conflict in organizations. So, why are values, preferences, and priorities important? Because:
- Values can be thought of as forming an ideology that permeates every day decisions.
- In successful organizations, value-driven corporate leaders serve as role models and are a symbol to the external environment.
- The organization culture created by corporate leaders can result in managerial functions being carried out in quite different ways.
(b) Lack of consensus over priorities
This concept has already been discussed in our previous sessions: there must be consensus over priorities, goals, and objectives formulation. Because people interpret and differ on organization goals and objectives both in qualitative or quantitative terms, and also give meanings to events on a self-reference basis. If consensus lacks, then naturally conflict is bound to occur.
(c) Lack of fit
The point here is that there must be a fit or balance between organizational culture and the newly formulated strategy. For instance, in Higgins 8-S model, the first 7 Ss: Strategy, Structure, Systems and Processes, Style (leadership/management style), Staff, ReSources, and Shared Values (organizational culture) are derived from Waterman’s model, and the 8th S derived by Higgins is Strategic Performance. So what does Strategic Performance actually mean? The complementarity or alignment of all seven variables is given in the connotation of the strategic performance variable. If there is some misfit between any of these variables, then there could be resistance in the organization against desired change.
(d) Values that conflict with entrepreneurial requirement
Sometimes an organization bases itself on such values which may be contrary to the values of an entrepreneurial or progressive organization. Such kinds of organizations normally have the following attributes:
- risk averting rather than risk taking attitude
- fearful about failure
- non innovative
- introvert personality
- least progressive thinking
For coping with such problems, the organization should move to transform the attitudes and behaviours of its people so that it is in the best interest of the organization to have entrepreneurial-like values or behaviour. So values and strategies should be compatible with each other.
(e) Non-egalitarian values (elitist-orientation)
Egalitarianism means believing in equality or maintaining, relating to, or being based on a belief that all people are, in principle, equal and should enjoy equal social, political, and economic rights and opportunities. In organizational contexts, there should be very little gap between leader and follower, or between bosses and subordinates. Therefore, such kinds of organizations are considered very progressive and long lasting. We can also find similar attributes in the context of economies. For instance, in economies where the gap between rich and poor is wider, such economies are very less progressive, least growth oriented, and have a high degree of power distance. We can see such characterization especially in agrarian societies.
Similarly, non-egalitarianism, or in other words hierarchy and power differentiation in organizations, also affects the change implementation process. If an organization is based on non-egalitarian kind of behaviour, then it creates a moral deficit in actions which are vital for successful change implementation. In these organizations, the element of resistance is rather high as against those organizations which are egalitarian.
Why implementing strategic change is so difficult?
The author Alex Miller has cited some further variables which can cause constraints in the implementation of a revised change strategy.
Organization Immune system
It is the tendency of the human system that the human system seeks homeostasis and equilibrium. In every organization, there is an immune system which is working for the achievement of a comfort zone. In other words, the human system desires a world which could be more stable, more predictable, and more controllable. The same spirit is also working behind the base of scientific knowledge, as it is struggling for achieving certainty, reliability, and predictability. And the same spirit is working behind the social sciences, as they are also struggling for predicting various kinds of human behaviour so that appropriate controllability could be achieved. Therefore, on the basis of this knowledge which a management paradigm manifests, the desired level of policies, actions, and processes has been designed.
But when a change occurs, firstly it creates a kind of disequilibrium and unstable environment. At second place, a resistance against this is emerged which is again a human system or immune system phenomenon that makes the implementation process so difficult. So to overcome such resistance, one should associate different kinds of incentives or packages that could lead people to change their existing perceptual patterns and toward the next level of equilibrium.
💡 Why this matters: The organization’s immune system actively resists change to maintain stability. Effective change management must account for this natural tendency and provide incentives to help people move to a new equilibrium.
Numerous complex variables are at work
It means in organizations where simultaneously numerous complex variables are working interactively, any intervention in one field or domain does not yield results. Why has Miller said this? Because commonly, a number of strategists or even scholars associate a whole change process with one or two apparent variables that, according to them, bring a successful change in organizations. For instance, you have often heard a common sentence from a number of intellectuals on television that if education could improve, then all problems related to development could be solved. Another one says that if the political structure could effectively be solved, then all problems will be automatically solved. And so on and so forth. But in real life, many variables are interconnected with each other and form a complex system. Similarly, in organizational perspectives, management consultants often suggest that training is the most important component for dealing with approximately all sorts of managerial problems. This training paradigm was more popular during the 60s, 70s, and even in the 80s. And in the 90s, the technology paradigm was considered vital for all sorts of managerial hindrances and could go for efficiency and competitive advantages.
Interconnectedness of various elements
As Alex Miller said metaphorically: “Organization is like a woven fabric or sweater – if you pull one string or single thread, you run the danger of unraveling the whole.”
The change management in an organization is a difficult process. It is because strategists normally consider a single variable instead of the holistic view of the organization. For instance, what should be the ramifications for other departments or for the culture of the organization when an organization goes for introducing new technology? So, these kinds of issues or linkages must properly be addressed or analyzed when an organization goes for a change because the organization is just like a woven fabric.
The Need to change everything at once
The phenomenon that ‘change should be happened overnight’ is the most basic reason behind many change program failures. There are two schools of thought about change implementation patterns. One is the incremental or gradual school of thought and the other is the radical school of thought.
The first school of thought believes that if the change pattern is incremental or gradual, then it is more effective, efficient, and long lasting. As Mintzberg (1987) argued that many strategic changes are actually emergent strategies, or those that evolve incrementally over a long period of time. The second school of thought believes that people already conceive gradual changes into their day-to-day businesses, which is a continuous learning phenomenon in organizations. So, any gradual changes have very little impact on the overall results of the organizations. The real change could only be achieved through large-scale transformational or radical patterns which are based on shock-therapy or to compel people’s mobility from comfort zone to non-comfort zone. The Japanese, for instance, normally believe in incrementalism while the Russian believe in radicalism in the context of change management patterns.
💡 Why this matters: Choosing between incremental and radical change is a critical strategic decision. This lecture highlights that there is no single “right” approach; the choice depends on organizational context, culture, and the urgency of the change required.
⭐ Key Takeaways
A student must remember that the success or failure of strategic change implementation is heavily dependent on two intangible variables: people and culture. People-related constraints include fear of failure, resistance to change (moving from comfort to non-comfort zones), parochial bias (ethnocentrism), turf protection, short-term orientation, complacency (satisficing behaviour), and inappropriate talent/skills. Culture-related constraints include ill-defined values, lack of consensus on priorities, lack of fit between culture and strategy, values conflicting with entrepreneurial requirements, and non-egalitarian (elitist) values. Finally, implementing strategic change is inherently difficult because of the organization’s immune system (seeking homeostasis), the presence of numerous complex and interconnected variables, and the debate between incremental versus radical approaches to change.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the seven people-related factors that can constrain the implementation of strategic change?
- Explain the concept of “turf protection” and why it is particularly problematic in developing countries.
- How does a decentralized vs. centralized organizational structure influence employee complacency (satisficing vs. maximizing behaviour)?
- According to Alex Miller, what does the “organization immune system” refer to, and why does it make change implementation difficult?
- Contrast the two schools of thought (incremental vs. radical) regarding change implementation patterns, and name which country is associated with each approach.
📘 Lecture 36 — Why Implementing Strategic Change is so Difficult?
📖 Overview: This lecture explores why strategic change implementation often fails, examining the final two variables of resistance from Alex Miller's framework. It then contrasts participative versus unilateral change implementation approaches and introduces a change typology framework for matching implementation methods to change types. Understanding these dynamics helps managers select appropriate implementation strategies based on the nature of the change required.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the significance of the strategic change implementation process, explaining why failures are often attributed to implementation rather than strategy itself. It examines activity-centered change versus transformation-centered change, and the focus on quantity versus qualitative outcomes. Two broad implementation approaches are contrasted: participative approaches (comparable to OD models) and unilateral approaches (comparable to behavioral modification models). The lecture introduces change typology distinguishing technical-structural from behavioral-social change, presents Lawrence's and Leavitt's frameworks, and concludes with key contingencies in change types including strategy-style matching and personality determinants.
📝 Lecture Summary
Why Implementing Strategic Change is so Difficult?
The lecture continues discussing the remaining two variables from Alex Miller's six generic dynamics of resistance to strategy implementation. The first four variables covered in the previous lesson were: numerous complex variables at work, organization immune system, interconnectedness of various elements, and the need to change everything at once.
Significance of the Strategic Change Implementation Process
The weakness of many change results is often attributed to failures in the implementation process rather than strategy itself (Beer et al 1990). This quotation indicates a post-implementation phenomenon where organizations engage in blame games directed toward the implementation process rather than strategic change itself.
One problem is that research has long been characterized by the search for the one best way to implement change (Dunphy & Griffiths 1998). This quotation describes a dilemma: change management research mostly works around searching for a universal solution or roadmap for implementing change but is unable to deliver it. The school of thought asserting that management is a universal phenomenon remains quite predominant.
Activity Centered Change
Activity centered change is one of the dominant reasons for failure in the implementation of change programs. This failure largely depends upon the difference between the real nature of change and the perceptual nature of change in terms of execution. In other words, change programs should be transformation centered rather than activity centered. For instance, a change program's outcome demands the transformation-centered approach but it is mostly executed through an activity-centered approach. Such appraisal is a typical fallacy that culminates into the failure of a change program or strategy.
For example, an organization introduces a training program for the purpose of behavioral modification or values transformation. The imperative in this training program is the transformation of behaviors or values rather than measuring success on activity-centered factors such as: the way it is organized, how many participants attended it, etc. What happens is that the training program, which is a means to achieve certain ends (of values transformation), becomes an end in itself.
💡 Why this matters: Managers often confuse means with ends—celebrating that training occurred (activity) rather than whether behaviors actually changed (transformation).
Focus on Quantity or Numbers
Sometimes called the revenue-centric approach, this variable focuses on numbers. From a change management perspective, the results of any change program could be measured in terms of numerical values rather than on the basis of desired characteristics. In corporate organizations context, for instance, budgets setting is based on numeric rather than on objectives. So, it is imperative for organizations to focus on both qualitative and quantitative aspects while going through policy making.
Change Implementation Approaches
Two broad categories of implementation approaches are:
- Participative Approach
- Unilateral Approach
Participative Approaches
The participative approach is the most famous approach in today's business environment. It is comparable to the organization development (OD) model that focuses on planned and controlled change of organizations in desired directions. The fundamental assumption behind OD structure and participative change implementation approach is the same: attitudinal change. Both use the same techniques for attitudinal change, like:
- Sensitivity training
- Teams building
- Participation
- Job-redesign
Participation is also a means of recognition. It satisfies the need for affiliation and acceptance, which is the third need in Maslow's hierarchy. In general, people are not motivated by being consulted but by being "in to the act." Hence the key mechanism of attitudinal change in this method is the generation of support among the workforce, which leads to empowerment of people by being them in the act. As a consequence, the right kind of participation yields both motivation and knowledge valuable for successful change implementation and enterprise success.
Unilateral Approach
The unilateral approach is a unilateral type of change comparable with the Behavioral Modification (BM) model. The BM model is an extension of wider concepts such as motivation, rewards, learning, and organizational culture. It attempts to understand and reduce complex change processes in organizations to explicit rules, procedures, and strategic actions to deal with all possible contingencies including legal compliance.
The philosophy of unilateral approach or traditional way of management is based on actions rather than on attitudes. If actions go right, then automatically attitudes and behaviors go right. It is sometimes called the classical school of bureaucratic approach. Unilateral approach is measured through outward actions and focuses on process design or redesign, job redesign, restructuring—particularly the restructuring of authority, communication, and work rules. It is a typical top-down phenomenon. As for legal compliance, technology is another means for achieving the unilateral approach because it is considered universal. For instance, managers have a tendency to rely on technology in order to enhance productivity and efficiency in organizations. On the other hand, the modern participative approach is based on attitudes—attitudinal change will lead to change in behaviors and actions automatically.
Change Typology
Before implementation process deployment, some issues need to be addressed—for instance, at what circumstances which kind of change implementation approach is valid. However, it depends upon industry and nature and size of the organizations. But before going for comparison, we must differentiate between change classifications:
- Technical-Structural
- Behavioral–Social
Focus of Unilateral Change
The successes experienced by the workforce from forced changes will ultimately lead to workforce satisfaction and support. In forced change, there is an element of push or threat from top to down that makes people comply with all policies and procedures. People get experiences, support, and ultimately satisfaction from forced compliance by senior executives. Also, people mechanize themselves according to certain actions which are now standards until the next level of standards is introduced.
The unilateral approach has the following indicators:
- Prescriptive — there is an element of consultation
- Control — this is planned or contingent change
- Authority — force used for changing people's behaviors that leads eventually to attitudinal change
This approach tends to be top-down, procedural, focused on resource allocation, and follows authority lines. Those who believe in unilateral approach argue that participation brings chaos and disorder because it is abstractive in nature and cannot be measurable. Successful change results can only be achieved through work itself instead of participatory and empowerment-oriented organization culture. Advocates argue that participation and culture things are too abstract to enhance productivity.
On the other hand, people who believe in the participative approach argue that it focuses on consultation or consensus-oriented techniques that change values, attitudes, skills, and ultimately cause a change in behavior, which is a permanent phenomenon. Because employees are involved, they develop an ownership of the change plan initiated, which gets translated into commitment and motivation to make the change work.
Comparison
In comparison, change effectiveness or successful implementation is contingent upon the interaction between types of change and techniques of change. Lawrence first observed the distinction between technical and social aspects of change:
🔑 Definition — Technical Change: The technical aspect of change involves making measurable modifications to the physical routines of the job.
🔑 Definition — Social Change: Social change refers to the modification of established relationships.
Lawrence concludes that technical change could be introduced without social change if the social relations were accustomed to change. This means technical change can only be introduced when there is frequent change in social relations in the organization. Otherwise, if the rate of change in social relationships is static or well established, then change could not be easily introduced. Nonetheless, a change may be primarily technical but can create social effects that may impact the outcome of change. Therefore, the imperative is that the type of change (technical-structural or behavioral-social) should correspond to the corresponding technique of change. Lawrence describes social relationships as essentially based on "give and take" or two-way relationships, while on the other hand, the technical approach is unilateral in nature. That is why he advocated participation as the one best method for introducing change because it corresponds to social relationships.
Similarly, another author Leavitt expanded the technical-social framework by adding a third category: structural change. According to him:
- Technical change means change in actions measurement, computers, and in communication systems
- Social change means change in large set of goals established around people
- Structural change means change in empowered work force, collaborative work arrangements, and in matching personal fulfillments to organizational needs
As a third variable, the purpose of structural change is to enhance organization performance through design and redesign of organization structure, which means redesigning areas of responsibility, authority, decentralizing profit centers, and reorganizing workflow.
Yet another scholar, Michael Beer, gave a single category of change instead of two or three—that is the change in knowledge which automatically leads to an attitudinal change instead of structural, technical, and social change.
Key Contingencies in Change Types
- Strategy-style (leadership attributes) matching theory in effective implementation
- Personality is the primary determinant and background of the manager (socio-psyche orientation) for what manager does. (Managers cannot alter their behavior to suit a situation)
Research on both types of contingencies—strategy-style or personality—has linked them to the locus of control, which is helpful in strategy execution like that of product innovation or differentiation strategy. In overall analysis, the issue is how to lower resistance and increase support for the change program or plan. Therefore, some key lessons are: first, to identify or diagnose the type or nature of change program; and second, the implementation method should be contingent upon types of change (Dunphy & Stace 1990).
⭐ Key Takeaways
The primary reason change implementation fails is the confusion between activity-centered and transformation-centered approaches—managers often measure success by activities completed rather than actual behavioral or value transformation achieved. A second critical insight is that implementation approaches must match the type of change: unilateral (action-based, top-down) approaches suit technical-structural changes, while participative (attitude-based, consensus-oriented) approaches suit behavioral-social changes requiring relationship modification. Lawrence's framework demonstrates that technical change can be introduced without social change only when social relationships are already accustomed to change, but Leavitt's addition of structural change as a third category highlights the importance of designing authority, responsibility, and workflow. The fundamental debate between unilateral and participative approaches centers on whether changing actions first leads to attitude change (unilateral) or changing attitudes first leads to behavioral change (participative), with the correct choice depending on the nature of the change required. Finally, successful implementation depends on diagnosing the type of change first, then selecting the contingent implementation method rather than searching for one universal best approach.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
-
What is the difference between activity-centered change and transformation-centered change, and why does this distinction matter for implementation success?
-
According to Lawrence's framework, under what conditions can technical change be introduced without social change?
-
What are the three indicators of the unilateral approach, and how do they relate to modifying objective or formal aspects of the workplace?
-
How did Leavitt expand Lawrence's technical-social framework, and what is the purpose of the third category he added?
-
What are the two key contingencies in change types that determine effective implementation, and what is the overarching lesson for selecting implementation methods?
📘 Lecture 37 — Implementation Approaches
📖 Overview: This lecture examines how to lower resistance and increase support for change programmes by matching implementation methods to the type and scale of change. It explores four major theses of implementation—Logical Incrementalism, Radical/Transformative Change, Punctuated Equilibrium Model, and OD Models—with a particular focus on incrementalism and the contrast between planned and emergent change management approaches.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the contingency between change type and implementation method, differentiating between technical-structural versus behavioural-social changes and unilateral versus shared techniques. It then examines Logical Incrementalism of Quinn, its attributes and advantages, followed by a detailed comparison of Planned Change Management versus Emergent Change Management, including Bullock and Batten's four-phase model and critiques of each approach. Finally, it discusses disjointed incrementalism and its application to structural change.
📝 Lecture Summary
Implementation Approaches
In overall analysis of implementation process, the issue is how to lower resistance and increase support for the change programme or plan. Key lesson is to identify or diagnose the type or nature of change programme. Implementation method is contingent upon type of change (Dunphy & Stace 1990).
The size and scale of change is contingent upon unilateral or shared techniques of change. Therefore, what is required is to have a match of the two in case the change strategy is effective. This means that for smaller changes, consultation and consensus methods are considered effective so as to lower resistance and raise support. By the same token, large scale changes like structural, job-redesign, policy & process, top down unilateral method is more effective than participative techniques.
The rationale for structural changes is that participation is too distant for individual interests and support is unlikely to be generated, and hence participation is considered unnecessary for such type of changes.
The technical-structural or behavioural-social type of change is contingent upon unilateral or shared technique of change (matching the type with method). Implementation of technical/structural change requires more directive and less participative method as workforce dislike changes such as downsizing and reorganization.
Within the context of implementation of change plan or strategies, we come across four different theses of implementation which are:
- Logical Incrementalism of Quinn
- Radical or Transformative change
- Punctuated Equilibrium Model (Tushman & Romanelli's Model)
- OD Models
1. Incrementalism
The concept is rooted in Lindblom's (1959) concept of muddling through – who down plays the concept of rational and comprehensive change within organizations. He deemphasized planning school and argued that most organizations are heavily built upon their past actions in determining their future direction. These past actions serve as the basis of the organization's future. Since organizational and decision maker's resources are limited, the most economic actions are those that are minor variations from the current state. Hence most change is considered as an extension of organization's history, or a series of successive limited comparisons to previous actions. Quinn identified this as logical incrementalism.
🔑 Definition — Logical Incrementalism: A concept where effective managers move the organization forward in small, logical steps; values evolutionary rather than revolutionary change, and order rather than disorder.
The concept of logical incrementalism remained a frequently cited concept, especially 1980s. Its leading proponent Quinn believes in planned change and orderly transition. He was thoroughly against radical change in strategy and in organizational directions, systems or central processes. He believes that effective manager is the one who moves the organization forward in small, logical steps. He thinks that incremental change increases confidence amongst employees, and reduces organizational dependence on outsiders to provide momentum for strategic change. Therefore he values evolutionary rather than a revolutionary change; and an order rather than disorder.
Attributes of incremental change:
- Consensus and collaboration style of leadership and management is required for incremental change instead of conflict and power oriented approach.
- Similarly, the use of expert authority and persuasiveness of data is considered more effective rather than of positional authority or emotionality of charismatic leadership.
- Incrementalism is perhaps the most suitable for the environment of stability and of continuity, as illustrated during the 1970s and 1980s.
- For Mintzberg, a renowned management strategist, strategy emerges over time through a continuing process of organizational actions and learning as it seeks to cope with and adapt to its environment. To him, the complex and dynamic nature of the organization's environment, often coupled with the diffusion in the organization of its knowledge base for strategy making, precludes deliberate control; strategy making must above all take the form of a process of learning over time, in which, at the limit, formulation and implementation become indistinguishable. His paradigm of emergent strategy comes closer to incrementalist view of strategy implementation as it erodes the distinction between formulation and implementation.
- Similarly for planning school, incremental change is the method by which change can be implemented best by top management while for learning school it is the method organization learns from its interaction with environment.
- Ansoff, another famous strategist, says in his book The New Corporate Strategy, "Firms and other organizations which are not subjected to strategic shocks do nevertheless go through discontinuous strategic changes. This occurs through step-by-step accumulation of incremental changes which over a long period of time, add up to transformation of culture, power structure and competence." Therefore the effective and planned change management means minimizing political and cultural resistance in an organization through incremental change.
Therefore, what is obvious is that incremental change can also be transformational in nature over a period of time. Incremental change reduces the resistance within the organization for strategic changes, which is considered the reason and effectiveness of incremental strategy.
Planned Change Management versus Emergent Change Management
By reviewing more than 30 models of planned change, Bullock and Batten (1985) developed a four-phase model of planned change that splits the process into exploration, planning, action and integration. According to Burnes (2004), this is a highly applicable model for most change situations. The model looks at the processes of change, which describe the methods employed to move an organization from one state to another, and the phases of change, which describe the stages an organization must go through to achieve successful change implementation.
Although the planned approach to change is long established and held to be highly effective, it has come under increasing criticism since the early 1980s.
First criticism: It is suggested that the approach's emphasis is on small-scale and incremental change, and it is, therefore, not applicable to situations that require rapid and transformational change.
Second criticism: The planned approach is based on the assumptions that organizations operate under constant conditions, and that they can move in a pre-planned manner from one stable state to another. These assumptions are questioned by several authors who argue that the current fast-changing environment increasingly weakens this theory. Moreover, it is suggested that organizational change is more an open-ended and continuous process than a set of pre-identified discrete and self-contained events. By attempting to lay down timetables, objectives and methods in advance, it is suggested that the process of change becomes too dependent on senior managers, who in many instances do not have a full understanding of the consequences of their actions.
Third criticism: The approach of planned change ignores situations where more directive approaches are required. This can be a situation of crisis, which requires major and rapid change, and does not allow scope for widespread consultation or involvement.
Fourth criticism: The critics argue that the planned approach to change presumes that all stakeholders in a change project are willing and interested in implementing it, and that a common agreement can be reached. This presumption clearly ignores organizational politics and conflict, and assumes these can be easily identified and resolved.
In response to this criticism of the planned approach to organizational change, the emergent approach has gained ground. Rather than seeing change to be top down driven, the emergent approach tends to see change driven from the bottom up. The approach suggests change to be so rapid that it is impossible for senior managers effectively to identify, plan and implement the necessary organizational responses. Therefore, the responsibility for organizational change has to become increasingly devolved.
The emergent approach to change emphasizes that change should not be perceived as a series of linear events within a given period of time, but as a continuous, open-ended process of adaptation to changing circumstances and conditions. The emergent approach stresses the unpredictable nature of change, and views it as a process that develops through the relationship of a multitude of variables within an organization. Apart from only being a method of changing organizational practices and structures, change is also perceived as a process of learning.
According to the advocates of the emergent approach, it is the uncertainty of both the external and internal environment that makes this approach more pertinent than the planned approach. To cope with the complexity and uncertainty of the environment, it is suggested that organizations need to become open learning systems where strategy development and change emerges from the way a company as a whole acquires, interprets and processes information about the environment. The approach stresses a promotion of 'extensive and in-depth understanding of strategy, structure, systems, people, style and culture, and how these can function either as sources of inertia that can block change, or alternatively, as levers to encourage an effective change process'.
Furthermore, Burnes argues, 'successful change is less dependent on detailed plans and projections than on reaching an understanding of the complexity of the issues concerned and identifying the range of available options.' It can, therefore, be suggested that the emergent approach to change is more concerned with change readiness and facilitating for change than to provide specific pre-planned steps for each change project and initiative.
This strategy of disjointed incrementalism may have much to recommend it. It reduces political obstacles to changes and avoids irresolvable arguments about complex goals and values. The focus is on patching things up and dealing with obvious problems as they arise. There generally is less disagreement surrounding the choice of methods for handling disasters. Also, the risk of ruin or great loss tends to be reduced by making incremental moves instead of far-reaching ones. Incrementalism allows the organization to learn from its previous actions and still be in a position to remedy them. Finally, cognitive strain is reduced by dealing with manageable facts of reality, by focusing on bottlenecks, and by choosing from a short list of well-tried expedients for dealing with them.
Unfortunately, the applicability of this approach to the realm of structural change has not been considered. It may be reasonable to suggest, however, that incremental and piecemeal strategies might offer as many political, economic, risk reduction, and cognitive advantages for changing structures as they do for modifying policies. For example, small structural adjustments that respond to specific and pressing problems are likely to cause least dissension and conflict. Also, they are more reversible, cheaper and are less disruptive than extensive changes. They, therefore, are less risky. If small changes do not work out the organization's survival probably will not be threatened. Finally, small structural changes are less taxing to the imaginations and cognitive capacities of the executives. They do not require lengthy periods of analysis or complex or elaborate master plans.
The strategy of disjointed incrementalism is consistent with the views of those who see organizations as loosely coupled systems (Aldrich, 1979; Weick, 1969). It is maintained that different subunits of the organization can change independently without importantly influencing the other subunits. Therefore, it may be that many elements of structure can be changed locally and that much adaptation to the environment can be effected independently by organizational subunits.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical lesson from this lecture is that the choice of implementation method must match the type and scale of change: small-scale changes benefit from participative, consensus-based approaches while large-scale structural changes require more directive, unilateral methods. Quinn's logical incrementalism advocates moving organizations forward in small, logical steps to reduce resistance, increase confidence, and enable learning over time—yet these incremental changes can accumulate into transformation. The planned approach to change (Bullock & Batten's four phases: exploration, planning, action, integration) has been increasingly criticized for assuming stability and ignoring politics, leading to the rise of the emergent approach which views change as continuous, bottom-up, open-ended adaptation driven by uncertainty and learning. Finally, disjointed incrementalism offers political, economic, risk-reduction, and cognitive advantages even for structural changes, especially when organizations are viewed as loosely coupled systems.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- According to Dunphy and Stace, what determines whether a unilateral or shared technique of change is appropriate?
- What are the four main attributes of incremental change as described by Quinn and other theorists?
- What are the four phases in Bullock and Batten's model of planned change?
- List the four major criticisms of the planned approach to change.
- How does the emergent approach differ from the planned approach in terms of direction of change (top-down vs. bottom-up), perception of environment, and attitude toward detailed plans?