๐ Lecture 31 โ Strategic Change (Continued)
๐ Overview: This lecture continues the discussion of the Strategic Organizational Change (SOC) Model, focusing on key variables that configure change. It explains how changes in strategy impact organizational design, technology, management practices, and culture, and introduces different approaches to implementing strategic change.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the remaining variables of the SOC model including organizational design and technology, management practices and organization culture, and the SOC process. It also discusses the distinction between Organizational Development (OD) models and Behavior Modification (BM) interventions, and concludes with the role of leadership in strategic organizational change.
๐ Lecture Summary
Strategic Change (Continued)
This lesson continues the previous theme discussing the Strategic Organizational Change (SOC) Model. Previously, the lecture opened discussion on SOC by highlighting key variables that configure change, starting with restructuring of vision, mission, goals, and the whole strategy of the organization. Whenever restructuring of the organization occurs as a result of change, it produces a strategic reorientation or resetting of direction for the organization.
1. Organizational design and technology
An important note is that whenever there is change in organizational strategy, that instantly changes the organization design and follows a new technological logic. The change processes progress better only when the organizational structure is 'organic' rather than 'mechanistic'.
Organizational design consists of decisions about:
- Formal structures
- Processes
- Systems
- Roles
- Relationships
For instance, two scenarios exist for change in strategy and organization design:
- Change in strategy (goals and objectives of growth or technology acquisition) will lead to change in structure โ functional, divisional or matrix structures, hierarchical levels, degree of centralization and delegation, formal planning and control systems, job specialization, education and training.
- Flexibility of structure is an important variable comprising flow of information, performance-reward linkage, and recruitment. For incorporating any change in organizational strategy, the organization must have a flexible or organic unit.
Broadly, there are two sets of organizational design: (a) Tangible Designs: Functional Design, Divisional Design, Matrix Design (b) Intangible Designs: Hierarchical Levels, Degree of Centralization, Control systems and Formal Planning, Job Specialization
Flow of Information: If the organization goes for a growth strategy, the nature of information flow could not be control-oriented or bureaucratic with only top-to-bottom arrangement. The top-to-bottom information flow arrangement is historically the oldest, practiced until the 1960s, 70s, and early 80s in consonance with the OD model. It is a highly conservative, single channel and mechanistic approach. Modern research revealed that information intrudes from multiple channels and its sources cannot be restricted to limited top executives. Therefore modern structures believe in information sharing and consultancy, valued as a critical success factor. The Knowledge Management Paradigm is an example of highly successful, real-time models that believe in lower level and more operational segments of information.
Performance-Reward Linkage: To implement a revised strategy, it is necessary to account for the micro-level structure by creating the performance-reward linkage and other motivational tools. The reason for this linkage is the direct relationship of organizational productivity with motivation or incentives.
Recruitment: Two sorts of policies are normally practiced:
- Hire from within โ best fit when the organization is quite conservative or cultural sensitivities are involved. This makes the organizational structure stagnant in terms of learning, mechanistic, and more bureaucratic.
- Hire from without (from market or industry) โ opens horizon of creativity, new values, and styles. Structure-strategy compatibility depends on choices which possess both advantages and disadvantages.
Extent of readiness: Technology plays a decisive role in the design of job. It is important to see how people use technology and are willing to learn newer production technologies โ because readiness for change depends on this. Extents of technology promotion depend on how people are socially linked to each other and to the technical system of an organization.
๐ Definition โ Organic Structure: A flexible organizational structure that enables better change processes through open information flow, performance-linked rewards, and adaptable recruitment policies.
3. Management Practices and Organization Culture
Day-to-day practices must be conducive for making the organization's mission and vision effective. Routines, procedures, rules, principles, and SOPs, and how people do work provide a connect to the organization's long-term efficacy and health. There will be system disconnect if practices are not related with the mission of the organization. If people are unable to give meanings to rules and regulations and larger goals, they become least motivated and there will be no perceived linkage between performance and reward.
The imperative is to strike an appropriate relationship amongst three variables of job design: authority, responsibility, and accountability. Failure to do so can lead to either over-organization or under-organization. Authority but not accountability is often built into job-design, which is problematic.
Unwritten rules, conventions, and other psychologically implied things or organization culture can cause distrust and anarchy because of lack of trust-deficit, indiscipline, and intolerance for ambiguity, which leads to culture-strategy compatibility.
SOC Process
Two types of models exist within the context of strategic change:
- OD models
- Behavioural modifications
1. OD Model (Organizational Development): OD is a distinct area within organizational science that focuses on planned and controlled change of organizations in desired directions. OD attempts to change an organization as a totality by changing the organization's structure, technology, people, and/or tasks. It is based on a closed system and focuses on internal aspects, mostly ignoring external environmental studies. One popular model is Kurt Lewin's model and force field analysis.
๐ Definition โ Organizational Development (OD): A systematic approach to planned and controlled organizational change that focuses on internal aspects of structure, technology, people, and tasks.
2. Behavior Modification (BM) Intervention: The BM intervention is the normative essence of the wider concepts of motivation, reward, learning, and organizational culture (Wilson, 1992). It is an attempt to understand and reduce complex change processes in organizations to explicit rules, procedures, and strategic actions to deal with all possible contingencies. This school of thought has its roots in behavior modification practices.
Leadership and Strategic Organizational Change
It is leadership which mediates between the two change management models. Leadership is the only element that can bridge the gap between desired change and the behavior aspect of the organization. According to Hitt, โsenior management must articulate a clear vision of the future โidealโ organization in order to successfully implement organizational change.โ
Leadership is also responsible for the creation of an organizational identity (who we are? and for what we exist), which leads to building organizational commitment, culminating in better organization communication. By and large, change management or organizational transformation is considered the responsibility of senior leadership.
โญ Key Takeaways
The lecture establishes that strategic change fundamentally alters organizational design, requiring movement from mechanistic to organic structures that support flexible information flow, performance-reward linkages, and adaptive recruitment policies. Management practices must align with organizational mission and culture, while properly balancing authority, responsibility, and accountability in job design. Two distinct approaches to implementing strategic change exist: the OD model (focused on planned internal change) and the Behavior Modification model (focused on explicit rules and contingencies). Crucially, leadership serves as the mediating force that bridges these models, articulating vision and creating organizational identity to drive successful transformation.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three components of a flexible or organic structure that Prof. Stevens suggested for incorporating change in organizational strategy?
- Explain the difference between tangible and intangible organizational designs, providing examples of each.
- What is the difference between hiring from within versus hiring from without, and what are the strategic implications of each policy?
- How does the OD model of change differ from the Behavior Modification (BM) intervention approach?
- According to Hitt, what is the primary role of senior management in successfully implementing organizational change?
๐ Lecture 32 โ Determinants of a Successful Change Management
๐ Overview: This lecture examines the key determinants that lead to successful or failed change management implementation in organizations. It explores three broad categoriesโenvironmental, structural, and management orientationโthat influence change outcomes, and concludes with Nadler's requirements for organizational change. Understanding these factors helps managers design and execute change strategies effectively while avoiding common pitfalls.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers three major determinants of successful change management: environmental alignment (focusing on customer needs), structural compatibility (ensuring structure matches strategy), and management orientation (emphasizing entrepreneurship, realistic goal attainment, sticking to core business, single values, and employee consensus). It then examines the same three factors as determinants of failure, including technological gaps, inadequate controls, and indecisive leadership. Finally, Nadler's three requirements for organizational change are presented: motivating change, managing the transition, and shaping political dynamics.
๐ Lecture Summary
Determinants of a Successful Change Management
This lesson discusses what key factors an organization must manage effectively to implement a change plan successfully. According to one author, there are three crucial determinants: Environmental, Structural, and Management Orientation. The general tendency is that environmental alignment is at the top, structural alignment in the middle, and management orientation at the lower end. The key point is that management orientation must align with organizational structure, which must be compatible with the strategic change plan, and this strategy must always relate to the environment.
Environmental
During change, the organization must focus on the needs and wants of the customer. If customer needs change, it is imperative for the organization to change its products and strategies accordingly. Change in environment will be coupled with:
- change in product line
- change in services
- development of a new product
- targeting customers in other marketplaces
- better quality
The organization must move around the customer during the change process because the customer is considered the 'sovereign' or 'King'โthe most prominent actor in the external environment.
๐ก Why this matters: Customer-centricity is not optional during change; it is a fundamental requirement for survival and relevance.
Structural
The structure of the organization must be compatible with the strategy. This is a common and typical flaw when there is strategy-structure incompatibility. However, there is no single universal prescription about the nature of structure and its compatibility with strategy. Different scenarios exist for structures like functional, divisional, or matrix structures corresponding to strategy.
For example, in a divisional structure, the intensity of control as a determinant should be either loose or tight depending on the situation:
- Loose in the sense of autonomy
- Tight in the sense of setting high performance goals
Control depends on strategic requirements and changes in strategy. A conclusive statement from research about successful organizations is:
โHighly successful organizations operate with simple and appropriate structure with adequate staff instead of empire building.โ
High Performance Organizations (HPOs) are those that perform constantly in every environmental scenario. Studies on Fortune 500 companies (e.g., Tom Peters and Waterman's 'In search of excellence') show that HPOs always tend to adapt their structure to the organization's mission and vision (strategy).
Management Orientation
At the management orientation level, several variables are crucial for successful change implementation:
a) Successful organizations encourage entrepreneurship and risk-taking at divisional levels and reward innovation at multiple tiers of hierarchy. Organizations that promote control, loyalty, and obedience may get short-term results, but in the long run, these factors do not give lasting outcomes. Researches show organizations believing in innovation, risk-taking, and entrepreneurship are more successful.
b) Successful organizations believe in a realistic rather than idealistic approach. The statement "Goal attainment is preferred over paralysis through analysis of alternatives" means action that ensures goal attainment is encouraged instead of over-analysis. Many companies spend more resources on strategy-making and analysis than on implementation, which is too idealistic rather than realistic.
c) Sticking to one's knitting means living around the core of the business as defined by the mission statement. This balance is lost when organizations attain success and see attractive alternatives, potentially deviating from their core. The author gives preference for related diversification over unrelated diversification, though this is not universal.
d) Stress upon a single valueโminimizing cost and satisfying the unique needs of the customer. The focus should be on a single dominant value rather than multiple values. For example, if an organization's production system is based on quality/differentiation, it should retain that specialty rather than go for cost leadership.
e) Successful organizations seek consensus of employeesโagreement over performance goals. The question is how to make organizations more participative at all levels. The OD model attributes are very compatible with this kind of change strategy, creating an environment of participation, empowerment, and delegation.
๐ Definition โ Sticking to one's knitting: Remaining focused on the core area of the business as defined by the mission statement, rather than being distracted by attractive alternatives.
Determinants of a Failure in Organizational Change
The same three factors (environmental, structural, and management orientation) can also cause failure.
Environmental
Change in technology is crucial. When technology advances, consumer patterns change, and organizations must change their technological configuration to match customers' needs. Other related variables that can cause failure include:
- Gap between new and existing technological skill levels
- Organization culture not being learning-oriented
- Financial resource unavailability for technology upgradation
Change in government policies (subsidies, cutbacks) may cause failure. Organizations should not be dependent on government but pursue internal development. Dependency on a single supplier should be avoided; a diversified vendor portfolio is needed. Similarly, reliance on a single customer is dangerous.
Structural
Inadequate control mechanisms and inability to sense change result in poor product quality and loss of customers.
Management Orientation
Indecisive leadership (half-hearted) leads to a tendency to overanalyze data or adopt a 'wait-and-see' attitude, causing the firm to lose ground to competitors and exacerbate internal problems. The basic concern is the quality of leadership in facilitating structure design and its role as an intermediary of new or changed strategy.
Nadler's Requirements for Organization Change
Nadler, a well-known figure in management research, recommended three prerequisites for installing change:
-
Motivating Change (attitude to behavioural change approach) โ focuses on two methods:
- Persuasion/Cognitive/Emotional method (based on psychotherapy)
- Rational/Intellectual method (based on cost-and-benefit analysis) Managers get motivated through these ways and means.
-
Managing the Transition โ Managers must develop switching skills to acquire skills and values of newer systems, processes, technologies, and strategies. During transition, managers and organizations must bear the burden of both older and newer systems. Achieving harmony and smooth progression from one system to another is extremely difficult.
-
Shaping the Political Dynamics of Change โ When change occurs, politics emerge automatically because change creates winners and losers. Winners and losers engage in organizational conflict. A dominant condition of interest is required for conflict resolution.
Though it appears simplistic, analysis shows that environmental factors are more likely to pose potential threats to an organization's well-being, while structural factors are an organization's major means of achieving success or coping with threats.
๐ Definition โ Switching skills: The ability of managers to develop and acquire the skills and values needed for newer systems, processes, technologies, and strategies during organizational transition.
โญ Key Takeaways
The three determinants (environmental, structural, and management orientation) apply equally to both success and failure in change management. Environmental alignment requires constant customer focus and adapting to technological changes. Structural compatibility means ensuring the organization's structure matches its strategy, with control mechanisms adjusted appropriately. Management orientation must encourage entrepreneurship, realistic goal attainment, sticking to core business, single value focus, and employee consensus. Nadler's three requirementsโmotivating change, managing transition, and shaping political dynamicsโprovide a practical framework for implementing change while recognizing that winners and losers naturally emerge. Finally, environmental factors pose the greatest threats, but structural factors are the primary means for achieving success.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three broad categories of determinants for successful change management, and how are they aligned in order of priority?
- Why is customer focus considered fundamental in the environmental determinant of change management?
- What does "sticking to one's knitting" mean, and why is related diversification preferred over unrelated diversification?
- What are the three requirements Nadler identifies for organizational change, and what does managing the transition involve?
- How can the same three factors (environmental, structural, management orientation) lead to both success and failure in change management?
๐ Lecture 33 โ Higgins 08 S Model โ An Adaptation from Watermanโs Seven S Model
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces the Higgins 8-S framework, an adaptation of the McKinsey 7-S model originally developed by Peters and Waterman in 1982. The model emphasizes cross-functional thinking and the alignment of key organizational factors with strategy to achieve successful strategy execution, which is considered just as important as strategy formulation.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture presents Higgins' 8-S model, which includes Strategy, Structure, Systems and Processes, Style (leadership/management style), Staff, Resources, Shared Values (organizational culture), and Strategic Performance. Each S is explained in detail, focusing on how they must all be aligned for optimal strategic performance, with special attention to the hierarchical nature of strategy, structural components, systemic practices like internal customer philosophy and cross-functionalism, and the holistic integration of all factors for successful change management.
๐ Lecture Summary
1. Strategy
Strategy involves the hierarchy of strategic intent, including corporate, business, and functional level strategies formulated after scenario evaluation through SWOT analysis. Strategy refers to the plan of action that defines how an organization will achieve its goals. At the corporate level, strategy defines what businesses the firm is in or should be inโfor instance, an organization may divest from loss-making businesses and invest in those with growth potential. At the business level, strategy describes how a firm will compete in a particular business, with relative differentiation and relative low cost being two generic strategies, alongside new product development, innovation in R&D, or market capture. Functional strategies support the business strategy in areas like marketing, finance, operations, HR, R&D, and logistics, and must be aligned with the business strategy. Process strategies cut across functions to integrate organizational processes for greater effectiveness and efficiency. Strategy formulation considers strengths (core competencies and capabilities), weaknesses, threats, and opportunities.
๐ Definition โ Strategy: A plan of action aimed at gaining a sustainable advantage over competitors, defined at corporate, business, and functional levels.
๐ Example: An organization with multiple businesses estimates growth potential in some and losses in others, then divests from loss-making units and invests in those with growth potential.
๐ก Why this matters: All strategies must be aligned at intra and inter levels for optimal strategic performanceโa distinct aspect of this model that is often overlooked in other implementation models.
2. Structure
The structure of an organization consists of five parts: (1) jobs, (2) the authority to do those jobs, (3) the grouping of jobs in a logical fashion into departments or divisions, (4) the manager's span of control, and (5) the mechanisms of coordination. The first four parts are normally shown in an organization chart, while coordination is described in operating policies and procedures. Major issues include the choice of organizing principle (product vs. function, or product vs. geography) and how to delegate authority (centralization vs. decentralization, or mechanistic vs. organic structures).
๐ Definition โ Structure: The arrangement of jobs, authority, grouping, span of control, and coordination mechanisms within an organization.
๐ Example: Rivalry between marketing and production departments creates ethnocentricity or conflict, but structural harmony can be achieved through policies promoting internal customer philosophy and cross-functionalism.
3. Systems and Processes
Organizational systems and processes are designed to get things done on a day-to-day basis. These include sub-systems like strategic planning, information systems, capital budgeting, manufacturing processes, reward systems, quality-control systems, and performance measurement systems. The key point is that strategic change must be compatible with day-to-day practices. Two key practices for dealing with this are:
- Internal Customer Philosophy โ One department should treat another as an internal customer to promote inter-departmental harmonious relationships, as suggested by ISO-9000 standards.
- Cross-Functionalism โ This emphasizes interaction and cooperation among specialized functional units for organizational stability and cohesion. One technique to promote this is job rotation.
๐ Definition โ Internal Customer Philosophy: The practice of treating other departments within the same organization as customers to promote harmonious inter-departmental relationships.
๐ Definition โ Cross-Functionalism: A managerial philosophy emphasizing interaction and cooperation among specialized functional units according to their role in the organization.
4. Style (leadership/management style)
Style refers to the consistent pattern of behavior exhibited by leaders or managers when relating to subordinates and other employees. Major issues include how leaders present, communicate, and control people or situations, and how effective the decision-making process is. Four leadership styles are identified:
- Authoritarian Style
- Consultative Style
- Consensus-oriented Style
- Democratic Style
Another important consideration is whether a leader relates to subordinates through transaction-oriented relationships (short-term, professional phenomena) or transformational-oriented relationships (long-term, progressive phenomena).
๐ Definition โ Style: The consistent pattern of behavior exhibited by leaders/managers when relating to subordinates and other employees.
5. Staff
Staff refers to the number and types of employees with specific individual and group competencies that the firm needs to meet its strategic purposes. Staffing means filling positions in the organization structure. The main issue is how to create an appropriate Management Inventory or Human Asset in an organization that can be synergized with strategic change or strategic intent.
๐ Definition โ Staff: The number and types of employees with the competencies needed to meet an organization's strategic purposes.
6. Resources
Resources refer to the extent to which the organization has adequate resources to achieve its strategyโpeople (staff), technology, and money are the three most critical. Resources may include funding for divisions such as R&D, technology like software, or systems for knowledge management and organizational learning. Another major concern is the extent to which the organization leverages its resources. Resource-strategy compatibility is highly desirable.
๐ Definition โ Resources: The assets (people, technology, money) an organization needs to achieve its strategy, with emphasis on leveraging them effectively.
7. Shared Values (organizational culture)
Shared values are the values shared by members of the organization that make it different from other organizations. Managing values and cultural artifacts is critical to successfully leading organizational change. This operates at an intangible level and has significant impact on the working environment of an organization.
๐ Definition โ Shared Values: The collective values held by organization members that differentiate the organization from others, operating at an intangible but impactful level.
8. Strategic Performance
Strategic performance is a derivative of the other seven S's. It is possessed by an organization as a whole, or for profit-based parts of the whole. Performance can be measured at any level. Financial performance measurements are critical barometers, but the expanded balanced scorecard approach is now considered best. Because most organizations and business units are structured along functional lines (marketing, operations, finance, HR, R&D, information, logistics), cross-functional execution issues are sometimes overlooked when strategy is changed. The important thing is that strategic change operates at a holistic level integrating different functional areas.
๐ Definition โ Strategic Performance: The overall performance of an organization resulting from the alignment of all seven other S factors, measured holistically across functional areas.
๐ Formula: Strategic Performance = f(Strategy, Structure, Systems, Style, Staff, Resources, Shared Values)
โญ Key Takeaways
The Higgins 8-S model is an adaptation of the McKinsey 7-S framework that emphasizes cross-functional alignment for successful strategy execution. Strategy exists at three hierarchical levelsโcorporate, business, and functionalโand all must be aligned internally and with other S factors. Structure has five components (jobs, authority, grouping, span of control, coordination) that must support strategic goals, while systems and processes must be compatible with day-to-day operations through internal customer philosophy and cross-functionalism. Leadership style (authoritarian, consultative, consensus, or democratic) and the nature of relationships (transactional vs. transformational) significantly impact change implementation. The ultimate goal is strategic performance, which is a holistic derivative of all seven other factors and is best measured using the balanced scorecard approach.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the eight components of Higgins' 8-S model, and how do they differ from the original McKinsey 7-S model?
- Explain the three levels of strategy (corporate, business, functional) and provide an example of each.
- What are the five parts of organizational structure according to Higgins?
- Describe the two systemic practices (internal customer philosophy and cross-functionalism) that promote inter-departmental harmony.
- How is strategic performance defined, and why is the balanced scorecard approach considered superior to financial performance measurements alone?
๐ Lecture 34 โ Implementation and Strategic Change: Constraining Forces in the Implementation of Strategic Change (Case Study of XYZ Company)
๐ Overview: This lecture identifies and explains the key constraining forces that hinder the successful implementation of strategic change in organizations. It emphasizes that while strategic formulation can produce extraordinary visions, implementation often fails due to various systemic, structural, strategic, and procedural barriers. The lecture uses generic scenarios and a case study approach to analyze these real-world challenges.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture systematically categorizes the variables that hamper the execution of strategic change into four main groups: Systems (misdirected reward systems, oppressive control, inflexible budgeting, arbitrary cost allocation, rigid planning); Structures (too many hierarchical levels, narrow span of control, responsibility without authority, top-down management, restricted communication, lack of accountability, bloated staff functions); Strategic Direction (absence of innovation goals, no formal entrepreneurship strategy, no vision from top, lack of senior commitment, no entrepreneurial role model); and Policies and Procedures (long approval cycles, excessive documentation, over-reliance on rules, unrealistic performance criteria).
๐ Lecture Summary
Systems
Organizational systems often fail to support strategic change due to several critical flaws.
(a) Misdirected reward and evaluation The link between performance and reward systems is crucial for executing strategic change, especially at the operational level. Many organizations lack suitable criteria for performance evaluation across different hierarchical levels, leading to inequity and conflict. Some companies, like Ford Company, address this by linking rewards to long-term objectives using stock grants tied to 5-year goals, measuring not just return on equity but also customer satisfaction, employee involvement, and product quality, with performance compared against competitors.
(b) Oppressive control systems An oppressive control system is tightly managed with a high element of exploitation. Controls are divided into two types: tangible controls (visible, like budgets and financial analyses for policies, wages, costs) and intangible controls (invisible, based on relationships, leadership, culture, and learning). Success in change implementation requires equal control over invisibles as with visibles. The modern organization model, originating with Pierre S. Du Pont and Alfred P. Sloan at General Motors, emphasized centralized staff and decentralized operations, but new technology and workforce demands call for a new organization based on information.
(c) Inflexible budgeting systems Budgeting is the formulation of plans for a future period in numerical terms. The greatest danger in budgets is inflexibility, as reducing plans to numbers gives them a misleading definiteness. Events can make a budget obsolete soon after it is formulated, and if managers must stay within this "straitjacket," the budget's usefulness is nullified, especially for long periods in advance.
(d) Arbitrary cost allocation systems This variable relates to whether cost allocation is based on a rational basis or an emotional, political, or professional basis. Arbitrary decision-making, limited to a few political elites, leads strategic change toward failure. A rational approach is cost-benefit analysis, which seeks the best ratio of benefits and costs by comparing alternatives in terms of overall advantages.
(e) Overly Rigid, formal planning system Planning involves selecting missions and objectives and the actions to achieve them. While planning bridges the gap from where we are to where we want to go, a flexible planning system is essential to avoid stagnation. Planning and controlling are inseparable, as plans furnish the standards of control. Efficient control depends on flexible planning and a decentralized structure.
Structures
Structural issues within an organization can severely constrain strategic change implementation.
(a) Too many hierarchical levels When an organization has too many levels, it often serves itself rather than its target customers. Three main problems arise:
- It is an expensive option
- It complicates the communication process
- It complicates planning and control systems
Consultant Lyndall Urwick found the ideal number of subordinates for all superior authorities to be four, with up to eight or twelve at the lowest level. In contrast, public sector organizations in some societies can have 6 managerial levels (vs. 3-4 in Western models) and 16 non-managerial levels (vs. 6-8), leading to mal-governance and least development.
(b) Overly narrow span of control The span of management deals with the number of subordinates a manager can effectively supervise. The ideal depends on factors like vision, strategic change, hierarchical levels, planning, training, technology, delegation, communication, and culture. The classical school prescribes 3-7 subordinates at top levels, while operational-management theorists support an open-ended approach. A wide span has few levels, forcing delegation and clear policies but risking loss of control. A narrow span allows close supervision but has many levels, high costs, and excessive distance between top and bottom.
๐ Advantages of Narrow Span: Close supervision, close control, fast communication between subordinates and superiors. ๐ Disadvantages of Narrow Span: Many levels of management, high costs, superiors get too involved, excessive distance between lowest and top level. ๐ Advantages of Wide Span: Superiors are forced to delegate, clear policies must be made. ๐ Disadvantages of Wide Span: Danger of superior's loss of control, requires exceptional quality of managers, subordinates must be carefully selected, tendency of overloaded superiors to become decision bottlenecks.
(c) Responsibility without authority An authority-responsibility mismatch is a major hindrance to managerial success, often a structural phenomenon rather than an individualistic one. In many cases, managers are assumed to be responsible without having appropriate authority, often due to geographical dispersion between authority and responsibility structures. There must be an equilibrium between a manager's functional authority and perceived responsibility.
(d) Top down management system This is the most traditional style where management flows from higher to lower levels in the hierarchy, often found in organizations with an authoritarian atmosphere. Strategy, goals, and objectives are retained at the top, with middle managers acting as operators. Information is often lost or distorted as it comes down the chain of command. ๐ก Why this matters: The consequences include unmotivated employees, mechanistic environment, stagnant efficiency, and poor coordination.
(e) Restricted communication channels Traditional structures assume top management is the most informed. Modern research argues that middle and operational level managers are more informed as they receive information from multiple channels (backward, forward, and hierarchical). An open-ended organization is more intelligent and interactive with its environment.
(f) Lack of accountability Accountability works at two levels: extraneous (organization held accountable to individuals, groups, government, society) and intra-organizational (checks that hold individuals, departments, and business levels accountable). The objective is to generate morality from within the organization. J. O. McKinsey concluded that enterprises should periodically make a "management audit" appraising all aspects in light of present and probable future environment.
(g) Bloated (over-fed) staff functions Line functions have a direct impact on accomplishing enterprise objectives (e.g., production, sales). Staff functions help line persons work effectively (e.g., purchasing, accounting, personnel). The organization must differentiate between line and staff authorities and form an appropriate model to avoid overlapping and over-feeding.
Strategic Direction
A lack of clear strategic direction creates powerful constraints on change implementation.
(a) Absence of innovation goals Innovation means the creation and usage of ideas. Organizations fostering innovation are characterized by appreciating and rewarding new ideas, developing tolerance for failure, operating with few simple rules, encouraging information sharing, and keeping divisions small. James Brian Quinn found successful companies listen to customers and establish teams that search for creative alternatives. Peter Drucker suggests innovation requires systematic, rational work. Success stories like Johnson & Johnson, Hewlett-Packard, and Merck show innovation is a matter of survival.
(b) No formal strategy for entrepreneurship An intrapreneur focuses on innovation and creativity within the organizational environment, while an entrepreneur does similar things outside. Progressive companies like IBM or 3M consciously develop an environment that promotes entrepreneurship within the company. Organizations with entrepreneurial attributes (ability to see opportunity, risk-taking, commitment to innovation) are progressive, dynamic, and long-lasting.
(c) No vision from the top If the top executive is visionless, the organization suffers immobility and lacks strategic direction for long-term survival. As the quotation states, "fish stings from the head." A leader must know how to form a plan that constitutes a standard and ordinate it to the vision of the organization.
(d) Lack of commitment from senior executives Senior executives must be committed and incorporate the organization's objectives, mission, and purpose. A survey of CEOs in Fortune 500 enterprises indicated they spend little time with lower-level employees. Professor Henry Mintzberg interpreted this as showing "management by walking around" is not prevalent, yet managers could obtain great information through it.
(e) No entrepreneurial role-model at the top In a learning environment, lower-level employees learn from middle and top-level management. Without role models, the organization suffers asymmetry, communication gaps, and leadership vacuum.
Policies and Procedures
Flawed policies and procedures create practical obstacles to implementing change.
(a) Long complex approval cycles In public sector organizations, approval of a document may require dozens of signatures. This old and classical system creates problems of efficiency, effectiveness, and disorder in organizational outcomes.
(b) Extension documentation requirements (even problem with iso-9000) Over-documentation affects efficiency and effectiveness, even at the international level with ISO certifications that require excessive documentation. This creates an abnormality by overly relying on visibles rather than invisibles, leading to a mechanistic and spiritless structure. Every organization should determine its own formality and informality levels.
(c) Over-reliance on established rules of thumb This means over-reliance on past patterns, experiences, norms, and conventions. This approach creates hindrance to value-addition and creativity, making an organization a stagnant body.
(d) Un-realistic performance criteria Unachievable or unrealistic performance criteria create a constraint during implementation of strategic change and cause de-motivation in organizations.
โญ Key Takeaways
The successful implementation of strategic change is often blocked by systemic issues like misdirected rewards, oppressive controls, and inflexible budgets. Structurally, organizations must avoid excessive hierarchies, ensure proper authority-responsibility balance, and move away from purely top-down management to foster open communication and accountability. Strategic direction requires clear vision, commitment from senior executives, and a formal strategy for both innovation and entrepreneurship. Finally, policies and procedures must be streamlined, with realistic performance criteria, to avoid the inefficiencies of complex approvals, over-documentation, and rigid adherence to past rules. A student must remember that these four categoriesโSystems, Structures, Strategic Direction, and Policiesโrepresent the key forces that must be managed for successful change implementation.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four main categories of constraining forces in the implementation of strategic change, as outlined in this lecture?
- Explain the difference between tangible and intangible control systems and why both are important for change implementation.
- What are the three specific problems associated with having too many hierarchical levels in an organization?
- According to the lecture, what is the difference between an intrapreneur and an entrepreneur, and why is a formal strategy for entrepreneurship important?
- List four characteristics of organizations that successfully foster innovation.