🧠 Quick Revision Questions
-
What are the five core job dimensions in Hackman and Oldham's model, and which three combine to determine job meaningfulness?
-
How does the Motivation Potential Score (MPS) formula work, and what happens if autonomy or job feedback scores near zero?
-
What are the four organizational systems that can constrain job enrichment implementation, and give an example of each?
-
What is the difference between job rotation and job enlargement, and how does each relate to the core job dimensions?
-
What are the three task design elements necessary for creating self-managed work teams, and how do they contribute to team effectiveness?
📘 Lecture 39 — Performance Management
📖 Overview: This lecture explores performance management as an integrated process of defining, assessing, and reinforcing employee work behaviors and outcomes. It covers the three core components—goal setting, performance appraisal, and reward systems—and explains how these practices align with business strategy, workplace technology, and employee involvement to drive organizational performance.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture presents a model of performance management showing how goal setting, performance appraisal, and reward systems jointly influence performance within the context of business strategy, workplace technology, and employee involvement. It then examines goal setting in depth, including characteristics, application stages, the goal-setting model, and Management by Objectives (MBO). Performance appraisal is covered with traditional versus high-involvement approaches, application stages, and design criteria. Finally, reward systems are discussed, including how rewards affect performance based on value expectancy theory and six key factors for effective rewards.
📝 Lecture Summary
A Model of Performance Management
Performance management is an integrated process of defining, assessing, and reinforcing employee work behaviors and outcomes. Organizations with a well-developed performance management process often outperform those without this element of organization design. Performance management includes practices and methods for goal setting, performance appraisal, and reward systems. These practices jointly influence the performance of individuals and work groups. Goal setting specifies the kinds of performances desired; performance appraisal assesses those outcomes; reward systems provide the reinforces to ensure desired outcomes are repeated.
Three contextual factors determine how these practices affect work performance: business strategy, workplace technology, and employee involvement. High levels of work performance tend to occur when goal setting, performance appraisal, and reward systems are aligned jointly with these contextual factors.
Business strategy defines the goals and objectives needed for an organization to compete successfully, and performance management focuses, assesses, and reinforces member work behaviors toward those objectives. Workplace technology affects whether performance management practices should be based on the individual or the group. When technology is low in interdependence and work is designed for individual jobs, goal setting, performance appraisal, and reward systems should aim at individual work behaviors. Conversely, when technology is highly interdependent and work is designed for groups, performance management should aim at group behaviors. The level of employee involvement determines the nature of performance management practices—in bureaucratic organizations, practices should be formalized and administered by management; in high-involvement situations, performance management should be heavily participative.
💡 Why this matters: The alignment of performance management practices with contextual factors ensures that work behaviors are strategically driven, appropriately targeted at individuals or groups, and matched to the organization's level of employee involvement.
Goal Setting
OD in Practice: Big Hairy Audacious Goals Employees at General Electric aim at "stretch goals" —encouraging employee teams to try for huge gains in productivity and quality even though, at the outset, it is unclear how they will get there. At other companies, these are called BHAG – big hairy audacious goals. One major goal GE is striving for is called Six Sigma—a statistical term for 3.4 defects per million products, translating to near-perfect manufacturing. GE began implementing Six Sigma in the mid-1990s, borrowed from Motorola via AlliedSignal. Currently, GE is running at three to four Sigma level, and the gap between that and a six level costs GE between $8 billion and $12 billion a year in lost productivity and inefficiencies. Last year, GE spent $600 million on Six Sigma projects.
Goal setting involves managers and subordinates in jointly establishing and clarifying employee goals. In some cases, such as management by objectives (MBO), it can also facilitate employee counseling and support. Goal setting affects performance in several ways: it influences what people think and do by focusing their behavior, motivates people to put forth effort to reach difficult goals, and prompts persistence over time.
Characteristics of Goal Setting:
Challenging goals produce better performance: Goals are only effective if they are difficult and challenging. Increasing the difficulty of employee goals, also known as "stretch goals," can increase perceived challenge and enhance effort expended.
Specific hard goals are better than "do your best" goals: When given specific goals, workers perform higher than when they are simply told to "do their best" or receive no guidance.
People may abandon goals if too hard: People must be able to attain or at least approach goals; otherwise, they will view the goal as impossible, become discouraged, and may abandon it.
Participation in setting goals increases commitment and attainment: Employees are more committed to self-set goals than to goals assigned by a manager. It gives them ownership.
Feedback and goals improve performance: Information about performance outcomes, whether a goal was met or not, should be included, along with information about how to adjust.
Individual differences tend not to affect goal setting: Goal-setting programs are successful regardless of education and position—production workers, clerical workers, maintenance workers, and managers can all use goal setting successfully.
Goal-setting in teams deserves special consideration: Setting difficult individual goals for an interdependent team task will likely result in poorer performance than when a team goal is set.
Support of management is critical: Leaders should maintain optimism, supervisors should encourage goal acceptance, help improve skills, and give timely feedback.
Application Stages:
- Diagnosis: Thorough diagnosis of the job, work group, employee needs, and the three contextual factors (business strategy, workplace technology, employee involvement).
- Preparation for goal setting: Prepares managers and employees by increasing interaction and communication, and offering formal training in goal-setting methods.
- Setting of goals: Challenging goals are established and methods for goal measurement are clarified.
- Review: The goal-setting process is assessed so modifications can be made if necessary.
Goal-Setting Model: Goals can be established in a variety of ways, with the best being joint participation between employee and supervisor. Goal commitment can be achieved through trust in upper management, support by management, effective reward and incentive systems, and sometimes competition. Resistance to goal acceptance can be overcome by providing special training, rewards and incentives, and participation in setting goals.
Goals should be specific, measurable, and compatible with goals formulated at higher levels of the organization. For example, Bell Canada's telephone operators are required to answer calls within 23 seconds, and Federal Express customer agents are expected to answer customer questions within 140 seconds.
🔑 Definition — Stretch Goals: Goals that encourage employees to try for huge gains in productivity and quality even when it is unclear how they will get there.
📐 Formula: Six Sigma = 3.4 defects per million products
📌 Example: GE currently operates at three to four Sigma level. The gap between that and Six Sigma costs GE between $8 billion and $12 billion per year. GE spent $600 million on Six Sigma projects in one year.
Management by Objectives
MBO is a specific technique used by organizations to set goals. It is a process aimed at the integration of individual and organization goals. MBO may be defined as a system of management set up to help in planning, organizing, problem-solving, motivating, and other important managerial activities. It involves the participation of subordinates and their managers in setting and clarifying goals.
A leading MBO consultant defines it as a process whereby the superior and subordinate managers of an organization jointly identify common goals, define each individual's major areas of responsibility in terms of results expected, and use these measures as guides for operating the unit and assessing the contribution of each member.
MBO approaches goal-setting on the assumption that people have higher-level needs for competence and achievement, and want to satisfy these needs in their work.
Steps in MBO Process:
- Work group involvement: Members of the primary work group define overall group and individual goals and establish action plans.
- Joint manager-subordinate goal setting: Attention is given to job duties and responsibilities of individual role incumbents.
- Establishment of action plans for goals: The subordinate develops action plans for goal accomplishment.
- Establishment of criteria, or yardsticks, of success: Manager and subordinate agree on success criteria. This is the most important step—arriving at joint understanding and agreement.
- Review and recycle: Three stages—subordinate reviews progress, manager discusses work plans, and general discussion covers future ambitions.
- Maintenance of records: Working documents may be forwarded to a third party, but evidence suggests MBO suffers when papers are reviewed regularly by a third party.
Criticism of MBO: Implementing MBO is expensive and time-consuming, and usually entails great effort. Use has traditionally been limited to managerial and professional employees. Some programs encounter difficulties because management does not recognize that proper implementation requires improved managerial skills. Critics question whether joint goal-setting among unequals is possible. MBO may be too quantitative, and communication may become top-down instead of open. There is a danger that MBO will focus only on certain aspects of the job and ignore other areas.
🔑 Definition — MBO: A system of management that helps in planning, organizing, problem-solving, and motivating through joint participation of subordinates and managers in setting and clarifying goals.
📌 Example: Bell Canada's telephone operators were required to answer calls within 23 seconds; Federal Express customer agents were expected to answer questions within 140 seconds. Both goals were considered very difficult when initially set but employees eventually met and exceeded them.
Performance Appraisal
Performance appraisal is a feedback system that involves the direct evaluation of individual or work group performance by a supervisor, manager, or peers. Most organizations have some kind of evaluation system used for performance feedback, pay administration, and counseling and developing employees. One survey found 90 percent used performance appraisal to determine merit pay increases, 87 percent used it to review performance, and 79 percent used it as an opportunity to set goals for the next period.
However, abundant evidence indicates organizations do a poor job appraising employees—32 percent of managers surveyed rated their performance appraisal process as very ineffective.
The Performance Appraisal Process: The lecture contrasts traditional bureaucratic approaches with newer, high-involvement approaches across five elements:
- Purpose: Traditional focuses on organizational/legal needs; newer focuses on developmental and integrative needs.
- Appraiser: Traditional uses supervisor/managers; newer includes appraisee, co-workers, and others (360-degree feedback).
- Role of appraisee: Traditional is passive recipient; newer is active participant.
- Measurement: Traditional is subjective, concerned with validity; newer includes both objective and subjective measures.
- Training: Traditional is periodic, fixed, administratively driven; newer is dynamic, timely, employee or work-driven.
360-degree feedback expands the appraiser role beyond managers to include multiple raters. This broader approach is used more for member development than for compensation purposes. It provides different views of performance and can lead to a more comprehensive assessment.
Application Stages:
- Select the right people: Include human resources staff, legal representatives, senior management, and system users.
- Diagnose the current situation: Assess contextual factors, current practices, satisfaction, work design, and existing goal-setting and reward systems.
- Establish the system's purposes and objectives: Potential purposes include rewards, career planning, human resources planning, and performance improvement.
- Design the performance appraisal system: Include choices about appraiser, involvement, measurement, and feedback frequency. Criteria include:
- Timeliness: Information should precede performance evaluation.
- Accuracy: Inaccurate data prevents determining if performance meets targets.
- Acceptance: Participation in goal-setting ensures commitment.
- Understanding: Information must be understood to have problem-solving value.
- Critical control points: Information must align with business strategy, performance, and rewards.
- Economic feasibility: Benefits should exceed costs.
- Experiment with implementation: Use a pilot test before system-wide implementation.
- Evaluate and monitor the system: Track user satisfaction and legal defensibility.
🔑 Definition — Performance Appraisal: A feedback system involving direct evaluation of individual or work group performance by a supervisor, manager, or peers.
🔑 Definition — 360-Degree Feedback: A performance appraisal approach that expands the appraiser role beyond managers to include multiple raters such as the appraisee, co-workers, and others having direct exposure to the employee's performance.
Reward Systems
Organizational rewards are powerful incentives for improving employee and work group performance. OD traditionally has relied on intrinsic rewards (enriched jobs, opportunities for decision making) to motivate performance. More recently, OD practitioners have expanded to include extrinsic rewards (pay, stock options, bonuses, gain sharing, promotions, benefits). Both intrinsic and extrinsic rewards can enhance performance and satisfaction.
How Rewards Affect Performance: The most popular model describing the relationship between rewards and performance is value expectancy theory. This model posits that employees will expend effort to achieve performance goals that they believe will lead to outcomes they value. Ongoing motivation depends on the extent to which attaining desired performance goals results in valued outcomes.
Based on value expectancy theory, the ability of rewards to motivate desired behavior depends on six factors:
- Availability: Rewards must be not only desired but also available. Too little of a desired reward is no reward at all.
- Timeliness: Rewards should be given in a timely manner.
- Performance contingency: Rewards should be closely linked with particular performances. Forty percent of employees nationwide believe there is no linkage between pay and performance.
- Durability: Intrinsic rewards tend to last longer than extrinsic rewards.
- Equity: Internal equity concerns comparison of personal rewards to those holding similar jobs in the organization. External equity concerns comparison of rewards with those of other organizations in the same labor market.
- Visibility: Organization members must be able to see who is getting the rewards.
🔑 Definition — Value Expectancy Theory: A model positing that employees will expend effort to achieve performance goals they believe will lead to outcomes they value.
🔑 Definition — Intrinsic Rewards: Rewards derived from the work itself, such as enriched jobs and opportunities for decision making.
🔑 Definition — Extrinsic Rewards: External rewards such as pay, stock options, bonuses, gain sharing, promotions, and benefits.
📌 Example: Merit increases in 1988 were concentrated between 4 and 5 percent nationwide—almost everyone, regardless of performance level, got about the same raise, showing poor performance contingency.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Performance management is an integrated process combining goal setting, performance appraisal, and reward systems that must be aligned with business strategy, workplace technology, and employee involvement. Goal setting is most effective when goals are specific, challenging, participative, and supported by feedback and management—with stretch goals like Six Sigma producing dramatic improvements. MBO provides a structured six-step process for integrating individual and organizational goals but faces criticism for being expensive, time-consuming, and potentially top-down in practice. Performance appraisal is evolving from traditional bureaucratic approaches toward high-involvement models featuring 360-degree feedback, active participant roles, and multiple measurement methods. Reward systems are most effective when they are available, timely, performance-contingent, durable, equitable, and visible—principles derived from value expectancy theory.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three components of performance management, and how do they interact with the three contextual factors?
- What are the six characteristics of effective goal setting, and what problem can arise when setting goals for interdependent teams?
- What are the six steps in the MBO process, and why is step 4 (establishment of success criteria) considered the most important?
- How do traditional and high-involvement performance appraisal approaches differ across the five elements (purpose, appraiser, role of appraisee, measurement, and training)?
- What are the six factors that determine a reward system's ability to motivate desired behavior according to value expectancy theory?