📘 Lecture 40 — Developing and Assisting Members
📖 Overview: This lecture presents three human resources management interventions concerned with developing and assisting the well-being of organization members: career planning and development, workforce diversity management, and wellness interventions. It explores how organizations must adapt to changing career needs, technological shifts, global competition, and evolving social contracts between employers and employees.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers career planning and development interventions including the four career stages (establishment, advancement, maintenance, withdrawal), career planning resources and processes, career development interventions such as realistic job previews, job pathing, performance feedback and coaching, assessment centers, mentoring, developmental training, work-life balance planning, job rotation, dual-career accommodations, consultative roles, and phased retirement. It also addresses organization decline and career halt issues, workforce diversity challenges, and wellness interventions including employee assistance and stress management programs.
📝 Lecture Summary
Career Planning and Development Interventions
Career planning and development have received increased attention as employees seek more control over their work lives. With organizations downsizing and restructuring, there is less trust in organizations to provide job security. Employees are taking active roles in planning their careers, particularly women, mid-career employees, and college recruits. Organizations are becoming more reliant on their intellectual capital, and providing career development opportunities helps recruit and retain skilled workers. Companies like General Electric, Xerox, Intel, and Cisco Systems have adopted these programs to improve work quality, performance, employee retention, and respond to equal employment legislation.
🔑 Definition — Career Planning: The process of individuals choosing occupations, organizations, and positions at each stage of their careers, involving assessing interests, capabilities, values, and goals.
🔑 Definition — Career Development: Organizational practices that help employees attain their career objectives, including skill training, performance feedback, coaching, job rotation, mentoring, and continuing education.
📌 Example: Many companies experience turnover costs among recent college graduates reaching 50 percent after five years. Career planning and development programs help attract and retain such highly talented employees.
Career Stages
A career consists of a sequence of work-related positions occupied during a lifetime. Today, careers are defined more holistically, including attitudes and experiences. People may move horizontally through different functional areas and still have successful careers without upward promotion.
The four distinct career stages are:
-
Establishment stage (ages 21-26): The outset of a career where people are uncertain about their competence and dependent on others for guidance and feedback. They make initial choices about committing to a specific career, organization, and job.
-
Advancement stage (ages 26-40): Employees become independent contributors concerned with achieving and advancing. They need less guidance and develop closer ties with colleagues, while clarifying long-term career options.
-
Maintenance stage (ages 40-60): Involves leveling off and holding onto career successes. Some help less-experienced subordinates, while others experiencing dissatisfaction may face "midlife crisis," reappraising circumstances and redirecting efforts.
-
Withdrawal stage (ages 60+): Concerned with leaving a career, letting go of organizational attachments, and preparing for retirement. Major contributions involve imparting knowledge and experience to others.
💡 Why this matters: These stages provide insight about personal and career issues people face at different phases. Employees go through phases at different rates and experience issues differently—one person may see maintenance as a positive opportunity to develop others, while another experiences it as stressful leveling off.
Career Planning
Career planning involves setting individual career objectives through assessing interests, capabilities, values, and goals; examining alternative careers; making decisions affecting current jobs; and planning how to progress. The four career stages can be used to make career planning more effective.
Career planning resources include:
- Communication about career opportunities and resources
- Workshops to encourage assessment of interests and abilities
- Career counseling by managers or HR personnel
- Self-development materials (books, videotapes, other media)
- Assessment programs testing vocational interests, aptitudes, and abilities
📍 Table 19: Career Stages and Career Planning Issues
- Establishment: What are alternative occupations? What are my interests and capabilities? How do I get work accomplished? Am I performing as expected?
- Advancement: Am I advancing as expected? What long-term options are available? How do I get more exposure and visibility? How do I integrate career choices with personal life?
- Maintenance: How do I help others become established? Should I reassess myself and redirect my action?
- Withdrawal: What are my interests outside work? What postretirement options exist? How can I be financially secure?
📌 Application 9 — Career Planning Centers at Pacific Bell: Pacific Bell operates ten career centers with reference libraries, job posting systems, and computerized career-life planning programs. Employees can make confidential appointments with career development specialists who help answer: "Who am I? How am I seen? Where do I want to go? How do I get there?" The centers were created in response to strategic changes, changing work environments, and shifting employee values including lower loyalty and fewer upward advancement opportunities.
Career Development
Career development helps individuals achieve their career objectives through organizational practices including skill training, performance feedback, coaching, job rotation, mentoring, and continuing education. These interventions can be linked to different career stages.
📍 Table 20: Career Development Interventions
| Intervention | Career Stage | Purpose | Intended Outcomes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Realistic job preview | Establishment, Advancement | Provide accurate work expectations | Reduce turnover, training costs; Increase commitment, satisfaction |
| Job pathing | Establishment, Advancement | Provide sequence of work assignments to career objective | Reduce turnover; Build organizational knowledge |
| Performance feedback and coaching | Establishment, Advancement | Provide knowledge about career progress | Increase productivity, satisfaction; Monitor HR development |
| Assessment centers | Establishment, Advancement | Select and develop for managerial/technical jobs | Increase person-job fit; Identify high-potential candidates |
| Mentoring | Establishment, Advancement, Maintenance | Link less-experienced with more-experienced members | Increase satisfaction, motivation |
| Developmental training | Establishment, Advancement, Maintenance | Provide education for career goals | Increase organizational capability |
| Work-life balance planning | Establishment, Advancement, Maintenance | Balance work and personal goals | Improve quality of life; Increase productivity |
| Job rotation and challenging assignments | Advancement, Maintenance | Provide interesting work | Increase satisfaction; Maintain motivation |
| Dual-career accommodations | Advancement, Maintenance | Assist members with significant others to find satisfying work | Attract and retain high-quality members |
| Consultative roles | Maintenance, Withdrawal | Fill productive roles later in careers | Increase problem-solving capacity, satisfaction |
| Phased retirement | Withdrawal | Assist moving into retirement | Increase satisfaction; Lower stress during transition |
Career development interventions traditionally focus on younger employees with longer contribution periods. However, as the workforce ages, organizations must increasingly address career needs of older employees, recognizing and rewarding their contributions.
Realistic Job Preview
This intervention provides members with realistic expectations about the job during recruitment. It provides information about whether the job is consistent with their needs and career plans. Research shows people may develop unrealistic expectations and suffer reality shock when those expectations are not fulfilled, leading to turnover or disgruntled, unmotivated employees.
📌 Application 10 — Realistic Job Preview at Nissan: Nissan's preemployment program at its Smyrna, Tennessee plant involves job seekers working up to 360 unpaid hours doing assembly exercises. Participants get realistic expectations about the demanding work, while Nissan screens candidates. One participant noted: "It gave me a chance to see what Nissan expected of me without their having to make a commitment to me or me to them."
Job Pathing
This intervention provides members with a carefully developed sequence of work assignments leading to a career objective. It helps employees in establishment and advancement stages develop skills, knowledge, and competencies by performing jobs requiring new abilities. Research suggests employees receiving challenging assignments early in their careers perform better in later jobs.
🔑 Definition — Job Pathing: A gradual stretching of people's talents by moving them through selected jobs of increasing challenge and responsibility.
📌 Example: A Los Angeles bank used job pathing to prepare employees to become branch managers through a sequence including teller, loan officer, credit manager, and commercial loan manager positions.
Performance Feedback and Coaching
One of the most effective interventions during establishment and advancement phases includes feedback about job performance and coaching to improve performance. Employees need continual feedback about goal achievement and support to improve. Companies like Intel and Monsanto separate career development aspects of performance appraisal from salary review to ensure career needs receive equal attention.
Assessment Centers
Traditionally designed to select and develop employees with high potential for managerial jobs, assessment centers have been extended to career development and selection for new work designs like self-managing teams. Participants spend two to three days on site, receiving comprehensive interviews, tests, and participating in individual and group exercises simulating managerial work.
📌 Application 11 — Assessment Center at Hamilton-Standard: United Technologies' division created an assessment center to select employees for a high-involvement work design with self-managed teams. Activities included information sessions, technical and business interviews, tests measuring generic work skills and social competence, and team-consensus exercises building model airplanes. All hiring decisions were made by group consensus, allowing the division to hire and retain a talented cross-functional workforce with certified skills in over fifty-two areas.
Mentoring
Mentoring is a powerful intervention establishing a close link between an experienced manager and a less experienced member. For those in establishment stage, mentors guide and sponsor careers. For older employees in maintenance stage, mentoring provides opportunities to share knowledge. Research shows about two-thirds of top executives had mentors during early career stages, and those with mentors received more compensation, had more advanced degrees, and were more satisfied with their careers.
📌 Example: Boeing's divisions pair high-potential members with corporate managers who volunteer as mentors, helping employees gain skills, experience, and visibility necessary for advancement.
Developmental Training
This intervention helps employees gain skills for training and coaching others, including workshops on human relations, communications, active listening, and mentoring. Many organizations offer tuition reimbursement programs for advanced degrees. Programs typically target mid-career managers who have good technical skills but limited coaching experience.
Work-Life Balance Planning
This relatively new intervention helps employees better integrate and balance work and home life. Restructuring, downsizing, and global competition have contributed to longer work hours and more stress. Programs include flexible hours, job sharing, day care, and interventions like middlaning—a legitimate alternative career track that acknowledges choices about living life in the "fast lane."
🔑 Definition — Middlaning: An intervention helping people redesign their work and income-generating activities so more time and energy are available for family and personal needs, involving education in work addiction, guilt, and anxiety; skill development in work contract negotiation; and exploration of alternative career options.
Job Rotation and Challenging Assignments
These interventions provide employees with experience and visibility needed for career advancement or the challenge needed to revitalize a stagnant career at maintenance stage. Unlike job pathing, job rotation is less planned and may not be promotion-oriented.
Companies identify "comers" (managers under 40 with top management potential) and "hipos" (high-potential candidates) and provide cross-divisional job experiences. Some firms create fallback positions—jobs identified before transfer that employees can return to without negative consequences if transfers don't work out.
For maintenance stage employees, research suggests rotating workers to challenging jobs at three-year intervals prevents loss of job motivation. "Plateaued employees" (those with little chance of further advancement) can have satisfying careers if they accept their new role and are given challenging assignments with high performance standards.
Dual-Career Accommodations
These practices help employees cope with dual careers where both the employee and spouse pursue full-time careers. The U.S. Department of Labor reports over 80 percent of marriages involve dual careers. The biggest problem involves job transfers during advancement stage.
Common accommodations include recognition of dual-career problems, help with relocation, flexible working hours, counseling, family daycare centers, improved career planning, and policies making it easier for two family members to work in the same organization. Some companies establish cooperative arrangements with other firms to share job opportunities for dual-career couples.
Consultative Roles
These provide late-career employees with opportunities to apply their wisdom and knowledge to help others develop and solve organizational problems. Unlike mentoring, consultative roles are not focused on guiding younger employees' careers but on helping others deal with complex problems or projects.
📌 Example: A large aluminum forging manufacturer temporarily assigned an old-line production manager nearing retirement to consult with salespeople and estimators about bidding on new business. The consultant applied years of forging experience to help them make more accurate estimates, and the pre-retirement manager felt he made a significant contribution—something he hadn't experienced for years.
Phased Retirement
This provides older employees with an effective way of withdrawing from the organization through various forms of part-time work. Employees gradually devote less time to the organization and more to leisure pursuits. It lessens the reality shock often experienced by those who retire all at once and helps employees grow accustomed to leisure life while withdrawing emotionally from the organization.
📌 Example: IBM offers tuition rebates for courses on any topic taken within three years of retirement, and many pre-retirees have used this program to prepare for second careers.
Organization Decline and Career Halt
Decreasing demand, mergers, acquisitions, and restructuring have resulted in layoffs, reduced job opportunities, and severe career disruptions. People experience career halt, resulting in increased personal stress, financial and family disruption, and loss of self-esteem.
Methods for managing layoffs and premature career halts include:
- Equitable layoff policies spread throughout organizational ranks
- Keeping people informed about problems and layoff possibilities
- Setting realistic expectations rather than excessive hope
- Generous relocation and transfer policies
- Helping people find new jobs through outplacement services and retraining
- Treating people with dignity and respect
💡 Why this matters: OD practitioners are likely to become increasingly involved in helping people manage career dislocation and halt as organization decline, downsizing, and restructuring continue.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The four career stages—establishment, advancement, maintenance, and withdrawal—provide a developmental framework for understanding the unique concerns, needs, and challenges employees face at different career phases. Career planning involves individuals setting objectives while career development involves organizational practices to help employees achieve those plans, and these must be integrated with corporate business objectives for effectiveness. Key career development interventions include realistic job previews, job pathing, performance feedback and coaching, assessment centers, mentoring, developmental training, work-life balance planning, job rotation, dual-career accommodations, consultative roles, and phased retirement, each relevant to specific career stages. Organizations must address workforce diversity through appropriate management perspectives and strategic responses, and implement wellness interventions like employee assistance and stress management programs to address social trends including fitness, drug abuse, and work-life balance. In the context of organization decline, layoffs, and career halt, equitable policies, open communication, realistic expectations, and dignified treatment of employees are essential human resources practices.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
-
What are the four career stages, and what are the age ranges and primary concerns associated with each stage?
-
How does career planning differ from career development, and what resources are commonly used in career planning programs?
-
According to Table 20, which career development interventions apply to the withdrawal stage, and why has the OD field been relatively lax in developing methods for older employees?
-
What is "reality shock" in the context of realistic job previews, and how do organizations like Nissan help prevent it?
-
What is the difference between job pathing and job rotation, and how do "fallback positions" help employees in the advancement stage?
📘 Lecture 41 — Developing and Assisting Members
📖 Overview: This lecture examines how organizations can design human resources systems to address workforce diversity across multiple dimensions, including age, gender, disability, culture, and sexual orientation. It also explores employee wellness interventions, particularly Employee Assistance Programs (EAPs) and stress management programs, which help organizations maintain a productive workforce by supporting employees' physical and psychological wellbeing.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers two major areas: workforce diversity interventions including a framework for managing diversity, the five dimensions of workforce diversity (age, gender, disability, culture and values, sexual orientation) with corresponding OD interventions; and employee wellness interventions including Employee Assistance Programs (EAPs) with their three-component model and implementation steps, and stress management programs covering occupational stressors, individual differences, diagnosis methods, and intervention techniques for alleviating stress.
📝 Lecture Summary
Workforce Diversity Interventions
Several profound trends are shaping labor markets. Contemporary workforce characteristics differ radically from twenty years ago. Employees represent every ethnic background; range from highly educated to illiterate; vary in age from eighteen to eighty; may appear healthy or have a terminal illness; may be single parents or part of dual-income, divorced, same-sex, or traditional families; and may be physically or mentally challenged. Workforce diversity is more than a euphemism for cultural or ethnic differences—such a definition is too narrow. Diversity results from people who bring different resources and perspectives to the workplace and who have distinctive needs, preferences, expectations, and lifestyles.
Organizations must design human resources systems that account for these differences to attract and retain a productive workforce and turn diversity into a competitive advantage.
Diversity Framework
A general framework for managing diversity is presented. First, an organization's diversity approach is a function of internal and external pressures for and against diversity. Pro-diversity forces argue that organization performance is enhanced when workforce diversity is embraced as an opportunity. Diversity is often discouraged by those who fear that too many perspectives, beliefs, values, and attitudes dilute concerted action.
Second, management's perspective and priorities regarding diversity can range from resistance to active learning and from marginal to strategic. Organizations can resist diversity by implementing only legally mandated policies such as affirmative action, equal employment opportunity, or Americans with Disabilities Act requirements. A learning and strategic perspective can lead management to view diversity as a source of competitive advantage.
Third, within management's priorities, the organization's strategic responses can range from reactive to proactive. Diversity efforts at Texaco and Denny's had little momentum until embarrassing race-based events forced a response.
Fourth, the organization's implementation style can range from episodic to systemic. A diversity approach will be most effective when strategic responses and implementation style fit with management's intent and internal/external pressures.
Only 5 percent of over 1,400 companies surveyed thought they were doing a "very good job" of managing diversity. Organizations like MBNA Corporation, Lockheed Martin, St. Paul Companies, Levi Strauss, Procter & Gamble, Monsanto, and Wisconsin Electric are taking bolder steps—adopting learning perspectives and systemically weaving diversity-friendly values into the cultural fabric.
Age
The average age of the U.S. workforce is rising. Between 1998 and 2008, workers aged 25-54 will grow 5.5 percent, and the 55+ category is expected to increase almost 48 percent. This results from the baby boom between 1946 and 1964. Organizations face a predominantly middle-aged and older workforce with average ages over forty.
Older workers place heavy demands on healthcare, are less mobile, and have fewer career advancement opportunities. This requires specialized work designs accounting for physical capabilities, career development using their experience, and benefit plans accommodating medical and psychological needs. Younger workers require more challenging jobs, advancement opportunities, and enriched quality of work life.
OD interventions include work design, wellness programs, career planning and development, and reward systems. At Builder's Emporium, the store clerk job was redesigned to eliminate heavy lifting by assigning night crews to replenish shelves and emphasizing sales ability over strength.
🔑 Definition — Workforce Diversity (Age dimension): The range of age-related differences in the workforce requiring differentiated HR practices for older workers (healthcare, mobility, security) and younger workers (challenge, autonomy, advancement). 💡 Why this matters: Age diversity requires organizations to simultaneously accommodate different career stages, physical capabilities, and motivational needs within the same workforce.
Gender
By 2008, almost 48 percent of the U.S. workforce will be women, representing more than half of new entrants between 1998 and 2008. Three-quarters of working women are in their childbearing years, and more than half of all mothers work. Healthcare costs will increase, and demands for child care, maternity/paternity leaves, and flexible working arrangements will pressure work systems.
Work design, reward systems, and career development are important interventions. Jobs can be modified to accommodate working mothers. Organizations like Digital Equipment, Steelcase, and Hewlett-Packard have instituted job sharing, by which two people perform tasks associated with one job, allowing female employees to pursue both family and work careers.
Reward system interventions, especially fringe benefits, can offer special leaves, child-care options, flexible working hours, and health/wellness benefits. Organizations like Polaroid, Hoechst Celanese, and Ameritech have instituted job pathing, challenging assignments, and mentoring programs to retain key female members.
📐 Formula — Job Sharing: Two people performing the tasks associated with one job → Allows employees to balance family and work careers 📌 Example: Digital Equipment, Steelcase, and Hewlett-Packard implemented job sharing to allow female employees to pursue both family and work careers simultaneously.
Disability
The workforce of the twenty-first century comprises people with various physical and mental disabilities. The high school dropout rate remained above 4 percent through the 1990s, and approximately 21 percent of the population over age 16 have only rudimentary reading and writing skills. In 1990, the federal Americans with Disabilities Act banned discrimination based on physical or mental disability in hiring and promotion and required organizations to modify physical plants and office buildings.
The productivity of disabled workers often surprises managers; training is required to increase awareness. OD interventions include work design, career planning and development, and performance management. Traditional job design can simplify work for physically handicapped workers. Career tracks need to be developed for these workers.
Performance management interventions including goal setting, monitoring, and coaching are important. At Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Florida, a supervisor learned sign language to communicate with a deaf employee whose productivity was low but quality was high. Two other deaf employees were transferred to that supervisor's department; over two years, the deaf workers' performance improved 1,000 percent with no loss in quality.
📌 Example: At Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Florida, a supervisor learned sign language to communicate with deaf employees. Over two years, the deaf workers' performance improved 1,000 percent with no loss in quality.
Culture and Values
Different cultures represent a variety of values, work ethics, and norms. Not all cultures want the same things from work. Management practices must align with cultural values and support both career and family orientations. English is a second language for many people, and jobs must be adjusted accordingly.
Several planned change interventions can be used: employee involvement, reward systems, and career planning and development. Employee involvement practices can be adapted to needs for participation. People from Scandinavia are more likely to respond to high-involvement policies; Latin American cultures view participation with reservation.
Reward systems can focus on increasing flexibility. Flexible working hours enable employees to meet personal obligations without sacrificing organizational objectives. Work locations can be varied—Pacific Telesis, Eddie Bauer, and Marriott allow telecommuting. Floating holidays allow people from different cultures to match religious and family occasions with work schedules.
Child-care and dependent-care assistance support different lifestyles. At Stride Rite Corporation, the Stride Rite Intergenerational Day Care Center houses 55 children (ages 15 months to 6 years) and 24 elders (over 60 years old). The center was established after a survey found 25 percent of employees provided elder care and 13 percent anticipated doing so within five years.
📌 Example: Stride Rite's Intergenerational Day Care Center serves both children (15 months to 6 years) and elders (over 60), established after a survey revealed 25% of employees provided elder care.
Sexual Orientation
Diversity in sexual and affectional orientation, including gay, lesbian, and bisexual individuals, increasingly affects organizational HR thinking. The primary implication is discrimination. When strong emotional reactions interact with gender, culture, and values trends, the likelihood of overt and unconscious discrimination is high.
The most frequent intervention is education and training, which increases members' awareness and decreases overt discrimination. Human resources practices regarding Equal Employment Opportunity (EEO) and fringe benefits can address sexual orientation parity. Some organizations have modified EEO statements to address sexual orientation. Firms like Advanced Micro Devices, Fujitsu, Ben & Jerry's, and Dow Chemical have communicated that hiring, promotion, and transfer decisions cannot be made regarding sexual orientation.
Organizations increasingly offer domestic-partner benefit plans. Companies like Microsoft, Apple, Lotus Development Corporation, and Inprise Borland have extended healthcare and other benefits to same-sex partners. A 1992 Newsweek poll found 78 percent of respondents favored extending benefits to domestic partners of lesbians and gay men.
A national survey revealed 75 percent of firms either have or plan to begin diversity efforts. Diversity interventions are especially prevalent in large organizations with diversity-friendly senior management and HR policies.
Employee Wellness Interventions
Organizations have become increasingly aware of the relationship between employee wellness and productivity. Stress-related ailments cost industry more than $200 billion per year globally. In the United Kingdom, stress and stress-related illness cost £12 billion each year. Employee assistance programs (EAPs) and stress management interventions have grown as organizations take more responsibility for employee welfare.
EAPs are primarily reactive efforts that identify, refer, and treat employee problems (drug abuse, marital difficulties, depression) affecting worker performance. Stress management, both proactive and reactive, helps employees alleviate or cope with negative consequences of stress at work.
Employee Assistance Programs
The 1992 National Household Survey on Drug Abuse reported that 66.5 percent of current illicit drug users aged 18+ were working full- or part-time. Alcohol and drug use costs U.S. business an estimated $102 billion per year in lost productivity, accidents, and turnover. Britain's Royal College of Psychiatrists suggested up to 30 percent of British employees would experience mental health problems, with 115 million workdays lost yearly from depression.
EAPs help identify, refer, and treat workers whose personal problems affect their performance. Started in the 1940s to combat alcoholism, these programs have expanded to deal with emotional, family, marital, and financial problems, and more recently, drug abuse.
Central to the underlying philosophy: although the organization has no right to interfere in employees' private lives, it does have a right to impose work performance standards and establish sanctions when these are not met. Anyone whose work performance is impaired due to a personal problem is eligible for admission.
Research has demonstrated that EAPs can positively affect absenteeism, turnover, and job performance. At AT&T, 59 employees close to losing their jobs were enrolled in an EAP and successfully returned to work; hiring replacements would have been more costly.
🔑 Definition — Employee Assistance Program (EAP): A reactive organizational intervention that identifies, refers, and treats employees whose personal problems (e.g., drug abuse, marital difficulties, depression) affect their work performance.
The Employee Assistance Program Model
Figure 56 displays three components of a typical EAP:
- Identification and Referral: Entry into the program through formal or informal referral. Formal referral involves identifying employees with performance problems and getting them to consider entering the EAP. Informal referral occurs when an employee initiates admission even though performance problems may not exist or may not have been detected.
Organizational activities supporting this step include: a written policy with clear procedures; top management and HR publicly supporting the EAP with good publicity; training and development equipping supervisors to identify and document performance problems; and safeguarding confidentiality of employees using the program.
- EAP Office: The program office accepts an employee, provides problem evaluation and initial counseling, refers the employee to treatment resources and agencies, monitors progress during treatment, and reintegrates the employee into the workforce. In some large organizations, counseling and treatment resources are located in-house. In most EAPs, the employee is referred to outside agencies contracting with the organization.
Good management is required. The program's relationship to disciplinary procedures must be clear. Maintaining confidential records about treatment is essential.
- Treatment: Resources include inpatient and outpatient care, social services, and self-help groups. Resources tapped by EAPs vary from program to program.
Implementing an Employee Assistance Program
Seven steps in establishing an EAP:
-
Develop an EAP policy and procedure: Establish specific guidelines concerning the EAP and its availability. Include policies on confidentiality, disciplinary procedures, communication, training, and program philosophy. Use senior management and union involvement.
-
Select and train a program coordinator: Designate a person responsible for overall coordination of program activities—training, publicity, evaluation, troubleshooting, and ongoing support.
-
Obtain employee/union support: Meet with key representatives for input on significant features; review policy/procedural components; share endorsements from other organizations.
-
Publicize the program: Communicate the EAP's availability and increase employee awareness of procedures, resources, and benefits. Both formal and informal referrals assume awareness of its existence.
-
Establish relationships with healthcare providers and insurers: Review health insurance policies for mental health and chemical dependency coverage. Summarize information for EAP users. Interview, screen, and select potential providers.
-
Schedule EAP training: Ensure training methods and materials are up-to-date and accurate. Include role plays for handling difficult employees and methods for referring workers.
-
Continually administer and manage the plan: Develop a plan for reviewing program effectiveness—auditing procedures, measuring user satisfaction, determining whether to add or delete treatment options. Provide ongoing staff training on changing legal requirements, new treatment options, and organizational changes.
Stress Management Programs
Concern about managing dysfunction caused by stress is growing. Stress is linked to hypertension, heart attacks, diabetes, asthma, chronic pain, allergies, headache, backache, skin disorders, cancer, immune system weakness, alcoholism, and drug abuse. One study reported one in three workers thought about quitting due to stress; one in two said job stress reduced productivity; one in five took sick leave because of stress in the preceding month.
Each employee suffering from a stress-related illness loses an average of 16 workdays per year. The Research Triangle Institute estimated annual cost to the U.S. economy from stress-related disorders at $187 billion.
Stress management is often facilitated by psychologists, physicians, and health professionals specializing in work stress. There has been a growing tendency to include stress management as part of larger OD efforts.
🔑 Definition — Stress: The reaction of people to their environments, involving both physiological and psychological responses to environmental conditions, causing people to change or adjust their behaviors.
Definition and Model
Stress involves the fit of people's needs, abilities, and expectations with environmental demands, changes, and opportunities. A good person-environment fit results in positive reactions to stress; a poor fit leads to negative consequences. Stress is generally positive at moderate levels, contributing to effective motivation, innovation, and learning. For example, a promotion is a stressful event experienced positively.
Stress can be dysfunctional when excessively high (or low) or persisting over a long period. It can overpower coping abilities, causing physical and emotional exhaustion. A boss who is excessively demanding and unsupportive can cause subordinates undue tension, anxiety, and dissatisfaction, leading to withdrawal behaviors, ailments like headaches and high blood pressure, and lowered performance.
📐 Formula — Person-Environment Fit: Good fit → positive reactions to stress; Poor fit → negative stress consequences (anxiety, poor decision making, increased blood pressure, low productivity)
Figure 57 presents a stress model showing that almost any dimension of the organization can cause negative stress. Virtually all OD interventions can play a role in stress management.
Occupational Stressors
Figure 57 identifies several organizational sources of stress including structure, role on the job, physical environment, and relationships. Extensive research has focused on three key organizational sources: work overload, role conflict, and role ambiguity.
Work overload can be a persistent source of stress, especially among managers processing complex information. Quantitative overload consists of having too much to do in a given time period. Qualitative overload refers to having work too difficult for one's abilities. Both too much and too little work can have negative consequences. When workload balances with people's abilities, stress has a positive impact; when workload exceeds abilities (overload) or fails to challenge (underload), people experience stress negatively.
A role is defined as the sum total of expectations that the individual and significant others have about how the person should perform a specific job. Problems arise when there is role ambiguity (the person doesn't clearly understand what others expect) or role conflict (the employee receives contradictory expectations that cannot be satisfied simultaneously).
Role ambiguity and conflict are prevalent in organizations, especially among managerial jobs. Managerial job descriptions are typically so general that it's difficult to know precisely what is expected. Role ambiguity and conflict can cause severe stress, resulting in increased tension, dissatisfaction, withdrawal, and reduced commitment and trust.
🔑 Definition — Role: The sum total of expectations that the individual and significant others have about how the person should perform a specific job.
Individual Differences
Figure 57 identifies individual differences affecting responses to occupational stressors: hardiness, social support, age, education, occupation, race, negative affectivity, and Type A behavior pattern.
Type A behavior is characterized by impatience, competitiveness, and hostility. Type A personalities invest long hours working under tight deadlines, putting themselves under extreme time pressure. Type B personalities are less hurried, aggressive, and hostile.
Extensive research shows Type A people are especially prone to stress. A longitudinal study of 3,500 men found Type As had twice as much heart disease, five times as many second heart attacks, and twice as many fatal heart attacks as Type Bs. Researchers explain Type A susceptibility in terms of inability to deal with uncertainty. One study showed 60 percent of managers were clearly Type A and only 12 percent were distinctly Type B.
🔑 Definition — Type A Behavior Pattern: A personality pattern characterized by impatience, competitiveness, and hostility; individuals invest long hours working under tight deadlines and try to do more work in less time. 🔑 Definition — Type B Behavior Pattern: A personality pattern characterized by being less hurried, aggressive, and hostile than Type A personalities.
Diagnosis and Awareness of Stress and Its Causes
This preventive approach starts with diagnosis of the current situation, including employees' self-awareness of their stress and its sources. Two methods for diagnosing stress:
-
Charting Stressors: Identifying organizational and personal stressors operating in a particular situation, guided by a conceptual model. Data is collected through questionnaires and interviews. Standardized instruments measure work overload, role conflict and ambiguity, promotional issues, opportunities for participation, managerial support, and communication. Specific instruments measure individual differences like hardiness, social support, and Type A/B behavior. It's necessary to measure stress consequences such as subjective moods, performance, job satisfaction, absenteeism, blood pressure, and cholesterol level.
-
Health Profiling: Aimed at identifying stress symptoms for corrective action. Starts with a questionnaire asking for medical history, personal habits, current health, and vital signs (blood pressure, cholesterol, triglyceride levels). Information is analyzed by computer to calculate the individual's health profile, comparing characteristics with an average person of the same gender, age, and race. The profile identifies future health prospects and indicates how risks can be reduced.
Alleviating Stressors and Coping with Stress
Interventions fall into two groups: those aimed at changing organizational conditions causing stress and those directed at helping people cope better. Two methods for alleviating stressful conditions:
-
Role Clarification: A systematic process for revealing others' expectations and arriving at consensus about activities constituting a particular role. Methods include Job Expectation Technique (JET) and Role Analysis Technique (RAT). Steps: (a) Identify relevant people and bring them together away from the organization; (b) Role holder discusses perceived job duties and responsibilities while others comment; (c) When consensus is reached, the role holder writes a description distributed to all participants; (d) Participants periodically check whether the role is being performed as intended.
-
Supportive Relationships: Establishing trusting and genuinely positive relationships among employees including bosses, subordinates, and peers. Supportive relationships can buffer people from stress. A study of managers at AT&T undergoing turmoil from corporate breakup showed that employees under considerable stress but with supportive bosses suffered half as much illness, depression, impaired sexual performance, and obesity as employees with unsupportive bosses.
Two interventions aimed at helping people cope more positively:
-
Stress Inoculation Training: Programs to help employees acquire skills and knowledge to cope positively with stressors. Participants learn stress warning signals (difficulty making decisions, disrupted sleeping/eating, greater frequency of headaches), then develop concrete coping plans. A coping self-statement procedure involves verbalizing questions or statements addressing four stages: Preparation ("What am I going to do about these stressors?"), Confrontation ("I must relax and stay in control."), Coping ("I must focus on the present set of stressors."), and Self-reinforcement ("I handled it well.").
-
Health Facilities: Organizations provide facilities for coping with stress. Elaborate exercise facilities are maintained by Xerox, Weyerhaeuser, and PepsiCo. Over 500 companies (Exxon, Mobil, Chase Manhattan Bank) operate cardiovascular fitness programs. Companies like McDonald's and Equitable Life Assurance Society provide biofeedback facilities where managers take relaxation breaks using devices to monitor respiration and heart rate. Some companies provide time for meditation; others have stay-well programs encouraging healthy diets and lifestyles.
📌 Example: A study of AT&T managers during corporate breakup found that those with supportive bosses suffered half as much illness, depression, impaired sexual performance, and obesity as those with unsupportive bosses.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Workforce diversity is a multi-dimensional concept encompassing age, gender, disability, culture and values, and sexual orientation—each requiring tailored OD interventions rather than a one-size-fits-all approach. The framework for managing diversity emphasizes that effective implementation requires alignment between management's perspective (from resistance to strategic learning) and the organization's implementation style (from episodic to systemic). Employee Assistance Programs follow a three-component model (identification/referral, EAP office, treatment) and require seven implementation steps focusing on policy development, training, communication, and confidentiality. Stress management requires understanding occupational stressors (work overload, role conflict, role ambiguity) and individual differences (Type A/B behavior patterns), followed by diagnosis through charting stressors or health profiling, and intervention through role clarification, supportive relationships, stress inoculation training, or health facilities. Organizations must recognize that wellness interventions are not optional additions but strategic necessities that directly impact productivity, turnover, and healthcare costs.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
-
What are the five dimensions of workforce diversity discussed in this lecture, and what specific OD interventions are recommended for each dimension?
-
Describe the four components of the framework for managing diversity in organizations, explaining how each component influences the overall diversity approach.
-
What are the three components of a typical Employee Assistance Program (EAP), and how do formal and informal referrals differ in the identification and referral process?
-
What are the key differences between Type A and Type B behavior patterns, and how do these differences affect how individuals respond to occupational stressors?
-
Identify and explain at least four of the seven steps for implementing an Employee Assistance Program, and discuss why each step is critical for program success.
📘 Lecture 42 — Organization and Environment Relationships
📖 Overview: This lecture explores how organizations, as open systems, must relate to their environments to acquire resources and deliver valued outputs. It provides a comprehensive framework for understanding environmental types, dimensions, and organizational responses, culminating in three key interventions: integrated strategic change, transorganizational development, and mergers and acquisitions. Understanding these concepts is critical for managers who need to navigate external constraints and leverage environmental opportunities.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with an organization and environment framework describing environmental types (general, task, and enacted environments) and environmental dimensions (information uncertainty and resource dependence). It then covers three classes of organizational responses: administrative, competitive, and collective responses. The remainder of the lecture details three specific interventions: integrated strategic change (ISC), transorganizational development (TD), and mergers and acquisitions (M&As), including their stages, applications, and the roles of change agents in each.
📝 Lecture Summary
Organization and Environment Framework
Organizations are open systems that must relate to their environments by acquiring resources and delivering valued products or services. An organization's strategy—how it acquires resources and delivers outputs—is shaped by environmental features. Organizations can devise responses from internal administrative responses (creating special units to scan the environment) to external collective responses (forming strategic alliances).
Environments can be described in two ways. First, there are different types of environments consisting of specific components or forces—organizations must understand these, select appropriate parts to respond to, and develop effective relationships. For example, a manufacturing firm must understand raw materials markets, labor markets, customer segments, and production technology alternatives. Second, useful dimensions capture the nature of organizational environments—some are rapidly changing and complex, requiring different responses than stable, simple environments.
💡 Why this matters: The framework establishes that organizations are dependent on their environments and must manage external constraints and contingencies while taking advantage of opportunities through methods like political lobbying, advertising, and public relations.
Environmental Types
The general environment consists of all external forces that can influence an organization, categorized into technological, legal and regulatory, political, economic, social, and ecological components. Each force can affect the organization in both direct and indirect ways—for example, economic recessions directly impact product demand, while general environment forces can affect organizations indirectly through linkages between external agents (e.g., a supplier's labor dispute affecting raw material availability).
The task environment consists of specific individuals and organizations that interact directly with the organization and can affect goal achievement: customers, suppliers, competitors, producers of substitute products or services, labor unions, financial institutions, and so on. These direct relationships are the medium through which organizations and environments mutually influence one another.
The enacted environment consists of the organization's perception and representation of its general and task environments. Environments must be perceived before they can influence decisions about how to respond. Only the enacted environment can affect which organizational responses are chosen, while general and task environments influence whether those responses are successful or ineffective.
🔑 Definition — General environment: all external forces that can influence an organization, categorized into technological, legal/regulatory, political, economic, social, and ecological components. 🔑 Definition — Task environment: specific individuals and organizations that interact directly with the organization and can affect goal achievement. 🔑 Definition — Enacted environment: the organization's perception and representation of its general and task environments.
Environmental Dimensions
One perspective views environments as information flows and suggests organizations need to process information to relate to their environments. The key dimension is information uncertainty, or the degree to which environmental information is ambiguous. Organizations seek to remove uncertainty so they know how to transact with the environment—for example, using focus groups and surveys to discern customer needs. The greater the uncertainty, the more information processing is required.
Another perspective views environments as consisting of resources for which organizations compete. The key dimension is resource dependence, or the degree to which an organization relies on other organizations for resources. Organizations seek to manage critical sources of resource dependence while remaining autonomous—for example, contracting with several suppliers to avoid over-dependence on one vendor.
These two dimensions can be combined to show the degree to which organizations are constrained by their environments. Organizations have the most freedom when both information uncertainty and resource dependence are low—U.S. automotive manufacturers in the 1950s faced these conditions. Organizations are more constrained as both dimensions increase—financial institutions, high-technology firms, and health-care facilities face unprecedented amounts of both.
🔑 Definition — Information uncertainty: the degree to which environmental information is ambiguous. 🔑 Definition — Resource dependence: the degree to which an organization relies on other organizations for resources.
Organizational Responses
Organizations employ methods to influence and respond to their environments, buffer their technology from external disruptions, and link themselves to sources of information and resources. Three classes of responses are described: administrative, competitive, and collective.
Administrative Responses include the formation or clarification of the organization's mission; the development of objectives, policies, and budgets; or the creation of scanning units. These can be proactive or reactive and aim at defining the organization's purpose and key tasks in relation to particular environments. An effective mission clearly differentiates the organization from others in its competitive environment—for example, 3M's core purpose is to "solve unsolved problems innovatively." Scanning units (market research, regulatory relations departments) include specialists who scan particular parts of the environment, interpret relevant information, and communicate it to decision makers.
Competitive Responses seek to enhance the organization's performance by establishing a competitive advantage over rivals. To sustain competitive advantage, organizations must achieve an external position or perform internally in ways that are unique, valuable, and difficult to imitate.
- Uniqueness: Organizations must identify the bundle of resources and processes that make them distinct—financial resources, reputational resources, technological resources, and human resources. Processes and capabilities that are unique are called distinctive competencies and represent the cornerstone of competitive advantage.
- Value: Competitive advantage is achieved when resources and processes deliver outputs that warrant a higher-than-average price or are exceptionally low in cost. Mercedes automobiles are valuable because perceived benefits exceed price; Chevrolet automobiles are valuable because they provide basic transportation at a low price.
- Imitability: Sustainable competitive advantage is achieved when unique and valuable resources and processes are difficult to mimic. Organizations can protect advantage by making it difficult for competitors to identify their distinctive competence, aggressively pursuing opportunities, or retaining key human resources through attractive compensation.
🔑 Definition — Distinctive competencies: processes and capabilities that are unique to the organization and represent the cornerstone of competitive advantage.
Collective Responses help control interdependencies among organizations and include bargaining, contracting, coopting, and creating joint ventures, federations, strategic alliances, and consortia. Contemporary organizations increasingly turn to these arrangements for sharing resources for large-scale R&D, spreading innovation risks, applying diverse expertise, and overcoming barriers to entry into foreign markets. Major barriers in the United States include organizations' drive to act autonomously and government policies discouraging coordination, while Japanese policies promote cooperation among organizations.
💡 Why this matters: The three interventions discussed—integrated strategic change, transorganizational development, and mergers and acquisitions—derive from this framework and help organizations assess their environments and make appropriate responses.
Integrated Strategic Change
Integrated Strategic Change (ISC) is a recent intervention that brings an OD perspective to traditional strategic planning, developed in response to complaints that good business strategies often are not implemented. Traditional strategic planning artificially separates strategic thinking from operational actions and ignores contributions that planned change processes can make to implementation. In the traditional process, participation is limited to top management, resulting in little understanding of the need for change and little ownership of new behaviors.
Key Features:
- The relevant unit of analysis is the organization's strategic orientation comprising its strategy and organization design, considered as an integrated whole.
- Creating the strategic plan, gaining commitment, planning implementation, and executing it are treated as one integrated process.
- Individuals and groups throughout the organization are integrated into analysis, planning, and implementation to create a more achievable plan and maintain strategic focus.
Application Stages:
-
Performing the strategic analysis: Begins with diagnosis of the organization's readiness for change and its current strategy and organization (S1/O1). The most important indicator of readiness is senior management's willingness and ability to carry out strategic change. Understanding current strategy and organization design involves examining the organization's industry, current financial performance, and effectiveness. Strategic analysis actively involves organization members through search conferences, employee focus groups, and interviews.
-
Exercising strategic choice: A new strategic orientation must be designed. Strategic analysis may reveal misfits among environment, strategic orientation, and performance. Senior management formulates visions for the future and broadly defines two or three alternative sets of objectives and strategies. This step determines the content or "what" of strategic change—the desired strategy (S2) defines products/services to offer and markets to serve, while the desired organization design (O2) specifies structures and processes necessary to support the new strategy.
-
Designing the strategic change plan: A comprehensive agenda for moving from current (S1/O1) to future (S2/O2) strategic orientation. The change plan describes types, magnitude, and schedule of change activities, costs, and how changes will be implemented given power and political issues, organizational culture, and current ability to implement change.
-
Implementing the strategic change plan: Draws heavily on knowledge of motivation, group dynamics, and change processes. Requires senior managers to champion change elements, initiate action, allocate resources, set high but achievable goals, provide feedback, hold people accountable, institutionalize changes, and solve problems as they arise.
🔑 Definition — Strategic orientation: comprising the organization's strategy and organization design, considered as an integrated whole.
Transorganizational Development
Transorganizational development (TD) is a form of planned change aimed at helping organizations develop collective and collaborative strategies with other organizations. Many tasks facing organizations today are too complex for a single organization—for example, Sematech involved many large organizations (Intel, AT&T, IBM, Xerox, Motorola) to improve U.S. semiconductor industry competitiveness.
Transorganizational systems (TSs) are groups of organizations that have joined together for a common purpose, including licensing agreements, strategic alliances, joint ventures, and public-private partnerships. TSs are under organized: relationships among member organizations are loosely coupled; leadership and power are dispersed among autonomous organizations; commitment and membership are tenuous as member organizations act to maintain their autonomy while jointly performing.
Application Stages:
-
Identification stage: Identifying potential member organizations of the TS. Change agents work with initiating organizations to clarify their own goals, explore alternatives to collaboration, understand the tradeoff between loss of autonomy and value of collaboration, and specify criteria for membership. Key stakeholders who can affect creation and subsequent performance of the TS are identified as possible members.
-
Convention stage: Bringing potential members together to assess whether creating a TS is desirable and feasible. Face-to-face meetings enable exploration of motivations and perceptions of the joint task. Change agents may need to structure and manage interactions to facilitate airing of differences and arriving at consensus.
-
Organization stage: When the convention stage results in a decision to create a TS, members establish structures and mechanisms that promote communication and interaction. This may involve creating a coordinating council, developing rules and operating procedures, and voluminous contracting about members' contributions and returns.
-
Evaluation stage: Assessing how the TS is performing through feedback data including performance outcomes, member satisfactions, and indicators of how well members are interacting jointly. This may signal the need to return to previous stages for necessary corrections.
Roles and Skills of the Change Agent: Because TSs are under organized, change agents need to play activist roles in creating and developing them—providing leadership and direction, educating potential members about benefits, and structuring face-to-face encounters. Because TSs are composed of multiple organizations, change agents must maintain a neutral role, treating all members alike and working on behalf of the total system. Skills needed include political competence (to understand and resolve conflicts of interest) and networking skills (to manage lateral relations among autonomous organizations).
🔑 Definition — Transorganizational systems (TSs): groups of organizations that have joined together for a common purpose, existing intermediately between single organizations and societal systems.
Mergers and Acquisitions
Mergers and acquisitions (M&As) involve the combination of two organizations. Merger refers to the integration of two previously independent organizations into a completely new organization; acquisition involves the purchase of one organization by another for integration into the acquiring organization. M&As are distinct from TSs because at least one organization ceases to exist.
M&A Rationale: Reasons include diversification or vertical integration; gaining access to global markets, technology, or other resources; and achieving operational efficiencies, improved innovation, or resource sharing. M&As are preferred when internal development is too slow or when alliances or joint ventures do not offer sufficient control over key resources.
Application Stages:
Pre-combination Phase:
-
Search for and select candidate: Developing screening criteria, agreeing on a first-choice candidate, assessing regulatory compliance, establishing initial contacts, and formulating a letter of intent. OD practitioners can add value by encouraging screening criteria that include managerial, organizational, and cultural components as well as technical and financial aspects.
-
Create an M&A team: Senior leaders appoint a team to establish the business case, oversee due diligence, and develop a merger integration plan. OD practitioners can facilitate team formation through human process interventions and help establish clear goals and leadership structure.
-
Establish the business case: Developing a prima facie case that combining the two organizations will result in competitive advantage exceeding their separate advantages. This includes specifying the strategic vision, competitive strategy, and systems integration potential.
-
Perform a due diligence assessment: Evaluating whether the two organizations actually have the managerial, technical, and financial resources each assumes the other possesses. Attention to cultural features of M&As is becoming more prevalent due to evidence that culture clashes can ruin expected financial gains.
-
Develop merger integration plans: Specifying how the two organizations will be combined—integration objectives, scope and timing, organization design criteria, Day 1 requirements, and responsibility assignments.
Legal Combination Phase: Involves legal and financial aspects—settling deal terms, registering with regulatory agencies, communicating with shareholders, and filing legal documents.
Operational Combination Phase:
- Day 1 activities: Communications and actions that officially start implementation—announcements about key executives, headquarters location, task structure, and layoff areas.
- Operational and technical integration activities: Physical moves, structural changes, work designs, and procedures to accomplish strategic objectives and expected cost savings.
- Cultural integration activities: Building new values and norms—encouraging members from both organizations to solve business problems together.
Practical suggestions: implement sooner rather than later, communicate clearly and in a timely fashion, have members from both organizations work together to solve implementation problems, and continually assess the implementation process.
🔑 Definition — Merger: integration of two previously independent organizations into a completely new organization. 🔑 Definition — Acquisition: purchase of one organization by another for integration into the acquiring organization.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Organizations are open systems that must manage three environmental types (general, task, and enacted) and two key dimensions (information uncertainty and resource dependence) to determine appropriate responses. Three classes of organizational responses exist—administrative (mission, objectives, scanning units), competitive (uniqueness, value, imitability), and collective (strategic alliances, joint ventures, consortia)—and organizations can use combinations of these to navigate environmental constraints. Integrated Strategic Change is a highly participative process that integrates strategy and organization design across four stages (strategic analysis, strategic choice, change plan design, and implementation) to overcome traditional implementation failures. Transorganizational Development helps multiple organizations collaborate through four stages (identification, convention, organization, evaluation) despite the inherent challenges of under-organized multi-organization systems. Mergers and Acquisitions involve complex three-phase processes where cultural integration and change management are as critical as financial and legal considerations for success.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three types of organizational environments described in the lecture, and how do they differ from one another?
- Explain how information uncertainty and resource dependence combine to determine the degree of environmental constraint on an organization.
- What are the three criteria for achieving sustainable competitive advantage through competitive responses, and what does each criterion mean?
- List the four stages of Integrated Strategic Change (ISC) and briefly describe what happens in each stage.
- What are the major differences between Transorganizational Development (TD) and Mergers and Acquisitions (M&As) in terms of organizational outcomes and change agent roles?