🧠 Quick Revision Questions
-
What are the four types of interventions related to interpersonal relationships and group dynamics discussed in this lecture?
-
What are the six overall objectives common to most T-groups, and which two objectives are achieved through the first three?
-
How does process consultation differ from the doctor-patient model of consulting, and why is it considered more a philosophy than a set of techniques?
-
What are the four cells of the Johari Window, and how do the processes of disclosure and feedback reduce cells 2 and 3 respectively?
-
What five interpersonal and group processes does process consultation primarily deal with, and what specific techniques can a manager use to analyze communications processes in a work group?
📘 Lecture 29 — Functional Roles of Group Members
📖 Overview: This lecture examines the critical interpersonal and group processes that process consultants must understand to help groups function effectively. It covers the functional roles group members play, group problem-solving and decision-making processes, group norms and growth, leadership dynamics, and specific interventions for individuals and groups. The lecture also discusses when process consultation is appropriate and reviews research on its effectiveness.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers five main interpersonal and group processes: functional roles of group members (task-related activities and group-maintenance actions), group problem solving and decision making (including the importance of not prematurely rejecting ideas), group norms and growth (explicit and implicit standards of behavior), leadership and authority (understanding leadership styles and their impact), and basic process interventions (individual and group interventions). It also addresses when process consultation is appropriate, results of process consultation, and includes a detailed application case study (Application 5: Process Consultation at Action Company).
📝 Lecture Summary
Functional Roles of Group Members:
The process consultant must be keenly aware of the different roles individual members take on in a group. Upon entering and remaining in a group, the individual must determine a self-identity, influence, and power that will satisfy personal needs while working to accomplish group goals. Preoccupation with individual needs or power struggles can severely reduce the effectiveness of a group. Unless the individual can expose and share those personal needs to some degree, the group is unlikely to be productive. Therefore, the process consultant must help the group confront and work through these needs. Emotions are facts, but frequently they are regarded as side issues to be avoided. Whenever an individual, usually the leader, says to the group, “Let’s stick with the facts,” it can be a sign that the emotional needs of group members are not being satisfied and are being disregarded as irrelevant.
Two other functions need to be performed if a group is to be effective: (1) task-related activities, such as giving and seeking information and elaborating, coordinating, and evaluating activities; and (2) group-maintenance actions, directed toward holding the group together as a cohesive team, including encouraging, harmonizing, compromising, setting standards, and observing. Most ineffective groups perform little group maintenance, and this is a primary reason for bringing in a process consultant.
The process consultant can help by suggesting that some part of each meeting be reserved for examining these functions and periodically assessing the feelings of the group’s members. As Schein points out, however, the basic purpose of the process consultant is not to take on the role of expert but to help the group share in its own diagnosis and do a better job in learning to diagnose its own processes: “It is important that the process consultant encourage the group not only to allocate time for diagnosis but to take the lead itself in trying to articulate and understand its own processes.” Otherwise, the group may default and become dependent on the supposed expert. In short, the consultant’s role is to make comments and to assist with diagnosis, but the emphasis should be on facilitating the group’s understanding and articulation of its own processes.
💡 Why this matters: The distinction between task and maintenance functions is fundamental; many groups fail because they focus only on task completion and neglect the emotional and relational glue that keeps the team cohesive.
Group Problem Solving and Decision Making:
To be effective, a group must be able to identify problems, examine alternatives, and make decisions. The first part of this process is the most important. Groups often fail to distinguish between problems (either task-related or interpersonal) and symptoms. Once the group identifies the problem, a process consultant can help the group analyze its approach, restrain the group from reacting too quickly and making a premature diagnosis, or suggest additional options.
📌 Example: A consultant was asked to process a group’s actions during a three-hour meeting that had been taped. The tapes revealed that premature rejection of a suggestion had severely retarded the group’s process. After one member’s suggestion at the beginning of the meeting was quickly rejected by the manager, he repeated his suggestion several times in the next hour. Each time his suggestion was rejected quickly. During the second hour, this member became quite negative, opposing most of the other ideas offered. Finally, toward the end of the second hour, he brought up his proposal again. At that time, it was thoroughly discussed and then rejected for reasons that the member accepted. During the third hour, this person was one of the most productive members of the group, offering constructive ideas. However, it was not until his first suggestion had been thoroughly discussed (even though it was finally rejected) that he was able to become a truly constructive member of the group.
Once the problem has been identified, a decision must be made. One way of making decisions is to ignore a suggestion (e.g., when one person makes a suggestion, someone else offers another before the first has been discussed). A second method is to give decision-making power to the person in authority. Sometimes decisions are made by minority rule, the leader arriving at a decision and turning for agreement to several people who will comply. Frequently, silence is regarded as consent. Decisions also can be made by majority rule, consensus, or unanimous consent.
The process consultant can help the group understand how it makes its decisions and the consequences of each decision process, as well as help diagnose which type of decision process may be the most effective in a given situation. Decision by unanimous consent or consensus, for example, may be ideal in some circumstances but too time-consuming or costly in other situations.
Group Norms and Growth:
Especially if a group of people works together over a period of time, it develops group norms or standards of behavior about what is good or bad, allowed or forbidden, right or wrong. There may be an explicit norm that group members are free to express their ideas and feelings, whereas the implicit norm is that one does not contradict the ideas or suggestions of certain group members (usually the more powerful ones). The process consultant can be very helpful in assisting the group to understand and articulate its own norms and to determine whether those norms are helpful or dysfunctional. By understanding its norms and recognizing which ones are helpful, the group can grow and deal realistically with its environment, make optimum use of its own resources, and learn from its own experiences.
Leadership and Authority:
A process consultant needs to understand processes of leadership and how different leadership styles can help or hinder a group’s functioning. In addition, the consultant can help the leader adjust her or his style to fit the situation. An important step in that process is for the leader to gain a better understanding of his or her own behavior and the group’s reaction to that behavior. It also is important that the leader become aware of alternative behaviors. For example, after gaining a better understanding of his or her assumptions about human behavior, the leader may do a better job of testing and perhaps changing those assumptions.
Basic Process Interventions:
For each of the five interpersonal and group processes described above, a variety of interventions may be used. In broad terms, these are aimed at making individuals and groups more effective.
Individual Interventions: These interventions are designed to help people be more effective or to increase the information they have about their “blind spot” in the Johari Window. Before process consultants can give individual feedback, they first must observe relevant events, ask questions to understand the issues fully, and make certain that the feedback is given to the client in a usable manner. The following are guidelines for effective feedback:
- The giver and receiver must have consensus on the receiver’s goals.
- The giver should emphasize description and appreciation.
- The giver should be concrete and specific.
- Both giver and receiver must have constructive motives.
- The giver should not withhold negative feedback if it is relevant.
- The giver should own his or her observations, feelings, and judgments.
- Feedback should be timed to when the giver and receiver are ready.
Group Interventions: These interventions are aimed at the process, content, or structure of the group.
Process interventions sensitize the group to its own internal processes and generate interest in analyzing those processes. Interventions include comments, questions, or observations about:
- Relationships between and among group members
- Problem solving and decision making
- The identity and purpose of the group
Content interventions help the group determine what it works on. They include comments, questions, or observations about:
- Group membership
- Agenda setting, review, and testing procedures
- Interpersonal issues
- Conceptual inputs on task-related topics
Structural interventions help the group examine the stable and recurring methods it uses to accomplish tasks. They include comments, questions, or observations about:
- Methods for dealing with external issues, such as inputs, resources, and customers
- Methods for determining goals, developing strategies, accomplishing work, assigning responsibility, monitoring progress, and addressing problems
- Relationships to authority, formal rules, and levels of intimacy
When Is Process Consultation Appropriate?
Process consultation, a general model for helping relationships, has wide applicability in organizations. Because PC helps people and groups own their problems and diagnose and resolve them, it is most applicable in the following circumstances:
- The client has a problem but does not know its source or how to resolve it.
- The client is unsure of what kind of help or consultation is available.
- The nature of the problem is such that the client would benefit from involvement in its diagnosis.
- The client is motivated by goals that the consultant can accept, and the consultant has some capacity to enter into a helping relationship directed at reaching those goals.
- The client ultimately knows what interventions are most applicable.
- The client is capable of learning how to assess and resolve her or his own problem.
Results of Process Consultation:
Although process consultation is an important part of organization development and has been widely practiced over the past thirty-five years, only a modest amount of research addresses its effect on improving the ability of groups to accomplish work. The few studies that have been conducted have produced little hard evidence of effectiveness. Research findings on process consultation are unclear, especially because the findings relate to task performance.
A number of difficulties arise in trying to measure performance improvements as a result of process consultation. One problem is that most process consultation is conducted with groups performing mental tasks (e.g., decision making); the outcomes of such tasks are difficult to evaluate. A second difficulty occurs because in many cases process consultation is combined with other interventions in an ongoing OD program. Isolating the impact of process consultation from other interventions is difficult.
Kaplan’s review of process consultation studies underscored the problems of measuring performance effects. It examined published studies in three categories: (1) reports where process intervention is the causal variable but performance is measured inadequately or not at all, (2) reports where performance is measured but process consultation is not isolated as the independent variable, and (3) research where process consultation is isolated as the causal variable and performance is adequately measured. The review suggests that process consultation has positive effects on participants, according to self-reports of greater personal involvement, higher mutual influence, group effectiveness, and similar variables. However, very little, if any, research clearly demonstrates that objective task effectiveness was increased.
Application 5: Process Consultation at Action Company:
This application, a story often told by Ed Schein and documented in several of his books about process consultation and culture, involves the senior management team of an organization that he worked with over several years. It illustrates several principles of process consultation, such as accessing your ignorance, always trying to be helpful, and understanding that errors are the prime source of learning.
The Action Company was a large and innovative high-technology organization. One salient feature of their executive committee meetings was long and loud discussions. Members interrupted each other constantly, often got into shouting matches, drifted off the subject, and moved from one agenda point to another without any clear sense of what had been decided. Initially, the process consultant made several interventions as an “expert” consultant. For example, he would ask the group to consider the consequences of interrupting each other repeatedly. This had the effect of communicating his belief that their process was “bad” and interfered with the group’s task and effectiveness. The group invariably responded with agreement and a resolution to do better, but within ten minutes was back to the same pattern.
As the consultant reflected, he noticed that he was imposing on the group his own beliefs about what an ideal team should look like. This group was clearly on a different path. Over time, he discovered that the group had a different set of shared assumptions driving their behaviors. In short, the group was trying to arrive at the “truth.” Their assumption was that truth was revealed in ideas and actions that could withstand argument and debate. If an idea could survive intense scrutiny, it must be true and worth pursuing.
Once he understood this basic premise, the process consultant asked himself what he could do that would be more helpful to the group. His answer was to work within the group’s assumptions rather than imposing his beliefs on them. Two kinds of interventions grew out of this insight. First, he went to the flipchart and wrote down the main ideas as they came out. These ideas, incomplete or undeveloped because the presenter had been interrupted, led to the second kind of intervention. Instead of punishing the group for its “bad” behavior, he looked for opportunities to turn the conversation back over to the person with the idea. For example, he would say, “John, you were trying to make a point. Did we get all of that?” The combination of these two interventions focused the group on ideas that were not on the flipchart and helped them navigate through their complex agenda. Ideas that were about to be lost were written down, resurrected, and given a fair chance.
The lesson was clear: Until the process consultant understood what the group really was trying to do, he could not focus on the right processes nor did he know how to intervene helpfully. He had to sense what the primary task was and where the group was getting stuck (incomplete idea formulation and too-quick evaluation) before he could determine what kind of intervention would be “facilitative.”
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical thing to remember is that effective groups need both task-related activities (getting the work done) and group-maintenance actions (keeping the team cohesive), and most ineffective groups neglect the latter. The process consultant’s role is not to be an expert who fixes problems, but to facilitate the group’s own diagnosis and understanding of its processes. The case of the prematurely rejected suggestion powerfully demonstrates that ideas must be thoroughly discussed even if ultimately rejected, or the member will become unproductive. The Action Company case teaches that imposing one’s own beliefs about “ideal” group behavior can backfire—the consultant must discover the group’s own assumptions (e.g., that truth emerges through debate) and work within them. Finally, research shows PC improves participants’ perceptions (feeling more involved, influential) but has little hard evidence of improving objective task performance, partly because mental tasks are hard to measure and PC is often mixed with other interventions.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two key functions that must be performed for a group to be effective, and which one do ineffective groups typically neglect?
- In the example of the three-hour meeting, why did the member become negative in the second hour and productive only in the third hour?
- What is the difference between explicit norms and implicit norms in a group? Give an example of each.
- List at least three of the seven guidelines for effective individual feedback given by a process consultant.
- According to the Action Company case study, what was the group’s shared assumption about how truth is revealed, and how did the consultant adjust his interventions once he understood this?
📘 Lecture 30 — Third-Party Interventions
📖 Overview: This lecture examines how third-party interventions help resolve interpersonal conflicts that arise between two or more people within the same organization. It presents an episodic model of conflict that explains how conflicts cycle through latent and overt stages, and explores strategies for controlling and resolving conflict, including Walton's framework for facilitating productive dialogue between disputants.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the nature and sources of conflict in organizations, differentiating between substantive and interpersonal conflicts. It presents an episodic model of conflict showing how conflicts cycle through latent and overt stages, identifies four control strategies for conflict resolution, and examines Walton's factors and tactical choices for facilitating the conflict resolution process. An application case study at Balt Healthcare Corporation illustrates the challenges of implementing these interventions in practice.
📝 Lecture Summary
Third-Party Interventions
Third-party intervention focuses on conflicts arising between two or more people within the same organization. Conflict is inherent in groups and organizations and can arise from a variety of sources, including differences in personality, task orientation, and perceptions among group members, as well as competition for scarce resources. It is important to emphasize that conflict is neither good nor bad per se — conflict can enhance motivation and innovation and lead to greater understanding of ideas and views. On the other hand, it can prevent people from working together constructively, destroying necessary task interactions among group members. Consequently, third-party intervention is used primarily in situations in which conflict significantly disrupts necessary task interactions and work relationships among members.
Third-party intervention varies considerably depending on the kind of issues underlying the conflict. Conflict can arise over substantive issues, such as work methods, pay rates, and conditions of employment; or it can emerge from interpersonal issues, such as personalities and misperceptions. When applied to substantive issues, conflict resolution interventions often involve resolving labor-management disputes through arbitration and mediation. These methods require considerable training and expertise in law and labor relations and generally are not considered part of OD practice. When conflict involves interpersonal issues, however, OD has developed approaches that help control and resolve it. These third-party interventions help the parties interact with each other directly, facilitating their diagnosis of the conflict and how to resolve it.
Third-party consultation interventions cannot resolve all interpersonal conflicts in organizations, nor should they. Many times, interpersonal conflicts are not severe or disruptive enough to warrant attention. At other times, they simply may burn themselves out. Managers tend to control the process and outcomes of conflict resolution actively when they are under heavy time pressures, when the disputants are not expected to work together in the future, and when the resolution of the dispute has a broad impact on the organization.
An Episodic Model of Conflict
Interpersonal conflict often occurs in iterative, cyclical stages known as "episodes." At times, issues underlying a conflict are latent and do not present any manifest problems for the parties. Then something triggers the conflict and brings it into the open. For example, a violent disagreement or frank confrontation can unleash conflictual behavior. Because of the negative consequences of that behavior, the unresolved disagreement usually becomes latent again. And again, something triggers the conflict, making it overt, and so the cycle continues with the next conflict episode.
Conflict has both costs and benefits to the antagonists and to those in contact with them. Unresolved conflict can proliferate and expand. An interpersonal conflict may be concealed under a cause or issue that serves to make the conflict appear more legitimate. Frequently, the overt conflict is only a symptom of a deeper problem.
The episode model identifies four strategies for conflict resolution. The first three attempt to control the conflict and only the last approach tries to change the basic issues underlying it:
-
Prevent the ignition of conflict by arriving at a clear understanding of the triggering factors and thereafter avoiding or blunting them when the symptoms occur. For example, if conflict between research and production managers is always triggered by new product introductions, then senior management can warn them that conflict will not be tolerated during the introduction. However, this approach may merely drive the conflict underground until it explodes.
-
Set limits on the form of the conflict. Conflict can be constrained by informal gatherings before a formal meeting, exploration of other options, or setting rules and procedures specifying the conditions under which the parties can interact. For example, a rule can be instituted that union officials can attempt to resolve grievances with management only at weekly grievance meetings.
-
Help the parties cope differently with the consequences of the conflict. The third-party consultant may work with the people involved to devise coping techniques, such as reducing their dependence on the relationship, ventilating their feelings to friends, and developing additional sources of emotional support.
-
Eliminate or resolve the basic issues causing the conflict. As Walton points out, "There is little to be said about this objective because it is the most obvious and straightforward, although it is often the most difficult to achieve."
Facilitating the Conflict Resolution Process
Walton has identified a number of factors and tactical choices that can facilitate the use of the episode model in resolving the underlying causes of conflict. The following ingredients can help third-party consultants achieve productive dialogue between the disputants so that they examine their differences and change their perceptions and behaviors:
- Mutual motivation to resolve the conflict
- Equality of power between the parties
- Coordinated attempts to confront the conflict
- Relevant phasing of the stages of identifying differences and of searching for integrative solutions
- Open and clear forms of communication
- Productive levels of tension and stress
Among the tactical choices identified by Walton are those having to do with diagnosis, the context of the third-party intervention, and the role of the consultant. One tactic is the gathering of data, usually through preliminary interviewing. Group-process observations can also be used. Data gathering provides some understanding of the nature and type of conflict, the personality and conflict styles of the individuals involved, the issues and attendant pressures, and the participants' readiness to work together to resolve the conflict.
The context in which the intervention occurs is also important: consideration of the neutrality of the meeting area, the formality of the setting, the appropriateness of the time for the meeting (a meeting should not be started until a time has been agreed on to conclude or adjourn), and the careful selection of those who should attend.
The third-party consultant must decide on an appropriate role to assume in resolving conflict. Facilitating dialogue of interpersonal issues might include initiating the agenda for the meeting, acting as a referee, reflecting and restating the issues and differing perceptions, giving feedback and receiving comments, helping individuals diagnose the issues, providing suggestions or recommendations, and helping the parties diagnose the underlying problem.
The third-party consultant must develop considerable skill at diagnosis, intervention, and follow-up. The third-party intervener must be highly sensitive to his or her own feelings and to those of others. He or she must recognize that some tension and conflict are inevitable and that although there can be an optimum amount and degree of conflict, too much conflict can be dysfunctional. Finally, she or he must have professional expertise in third-party intervention and must be seen by the parties as neutral or unbiased regarding the issues and outcomes of the conflict resolution.
Application 6: Conflict Management at Balt Healthcare Corporation
This case describes a conflict between Pete and Dan, two managers in an IT department at Balt Healthcare Corporation. Pete was the general manager with a traditional, formal management style where communication traveled vertically through the hierarchy. Dan had recently been assigned to operate a small experimental group charged with developing e-commerce solutions, using a management style that stressed open communication and collaboration. Senior management believed Pete's operational expertise would complement Dan's design strengths.
The trouble started almost immediately. Although Pete had agreed to work with Dan, his support was lukewarm. They had a history of conflict with pent-up animosity. Operationally, Pete refused to assign resources and made it complicated for Dan to access hardware. Dan became increasingly frustrated and complained to the highest levels of management.
Dan consulted Marilyn, the vice president for information services. She requested assistance from the human resources manager and an OD specialist. The OD specialist met with Pete and Dan separately and identified that different styles and differences in work processes (routine development vs. creative, unpredictable work) were contributing to the problem. The OD specialist recommended several strategies including direct confrontation, purchasing additional hardware, and mandating cooperation. Marilyn chose to facilitate a direct process but did not follow through — she never met with Pete and Dan at the same time and began supporting Pete while criticizing Dan. Dan felt sabotaged, took a leave of absence, and eventually left the organization. Pete stayed on, the organization lost respect for Marilyn's ability to address conflict, and productivity and morale suffered.
💡 Why this matters: This case demonstrates how even well-intentioned third-party interventions can fail when the intervener lacks follow-through, sends inconsistent messages, or loses neutrality — violating the key principles of effective third-party intervention.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Third-party intervention is used when interpersonal conflict significantly disrupts necessary task interactions and work relationships. Conflict episodes cycle through latent and overt stages, triggered by specific events, and the episodic model identifies four strategies: preventing ignition, limiting conflict form, helping parties cope, and resolving underlying issues. Walton's framework emphasizes mutual motivation, equal power, coordinated confrontation, and productive tension levels for effective conflict resolution. The third-party consultant must remain neutral, gather diagnostic data through interviews, carefully manage the intervention context, and choose an appropriate facilitative role. The Balt Healthcare case shows that failure to follow through on agreements, inconsistent communication, and loss of neutrality by the intervener can worsen conflicts and damage the entire organization.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What distinguishes substantive conflicts from interpersonal conflicts in organizations, and which type is typically addressed by OD third-party interventions?
- What are the four strategies for conflict resolution identified in the episodic model of conflict, and which one attempts to change the basic underlying issues?
- According to Walton, what six factors can help third-party consultants achieve productive dialogue between disputants?
- What are the three categories of tactical choices identified by Walton for third-party intervention, and what does each involve?
- What key mistakes did Marilyn make in handling the conflict between Pete and Dan at Balt Healthcare Corporation, and how did these violate the principles of effective third-party intervention?
📘 Lecture 31 — Team Building: Interpersonal and Group Process Approaches
📖 Overview: This lecture explores the concept of team building as an organizational development technique, examining how teams function, the nature of interdependence in teams, and the processes involved in developing effective teams. It provides frameworks for understanding team dynamics through sports analogies and discusses the specific activities and processes that help teams improve their communication, cooperation, and overall effectiveness.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers definitions of teams and teamwork, the concept of interdependence in teams illustrated through sports analogies (cricket, football, basketball), the need for team building in organizational contexts, different types of work teams, team-building activities classified into three categories (individual-focused, group operation-focused, and organization relationship-focused), and the team building process itself. A case study of Starbucks demonstrates the practical application of team principles.
📝 Lecture Summary
Introduction: Defining Teams and Teamwork
A team is defined as a group of individuals with complementary skills who depend upon one another to accomplish a common purpose or set of performance goals for which they hold themselves mutually accountable. Teamwork is work done when members subordinate their personal prominence for the good of the team. Members of effective teams are open and honest with one another, exhibit support and trust, demonstrate a high degree of cooperation and collaboration, reach decisions by consensus, maintain open communication channels, and show strong commitment to the team's goals.
Many organizations are implementing team-based programs to increase productivity, with almost 80% of all companies having some type of team-based employee involvement program. Developing teams is necessary because technology and market demands are compelling manufacturers to make their products faster, cheaper, and better.
Understanding Interdependence
The coordination of individual effort into task accomplishment is most important when team members are interdependent. Interdependence refers to situations where one person's performance is contingent upon how someone else performs.
🔑 Definition — Interdependence: Situations where one person's performance is contingent upon how someone else performs.
Understanding teamwork can be illustrated through sports parallels:
Cricket represents pooled interdependence where team member contributions are somewhat independent of one another. Players are separated on a large field, not all actively involved in every play, and they come to bat one at a time.
Football involves sequential interdependence. A flow of players and first downs are required to score. Players are closer to each other than in cricket, with a greater degree of interdependence. Players are grouped functionally (offense and defense), and unlike cricket, all players on the field are involved in every play.
Basketball exhibits the highest degree of interdependence. Players are closely grouped together and the team moves together on the court. Every player may contact any other player, and roles or functions are less defined than in football. All players are involved in offense, defense, and trying to score.
💡 Why this matters: Organizations frequently use sport teams as a model. Some organizations require close teamwork similar to basketball, whereas others require team involvement similar to cricket.
OD in Practice: Starbucks Case Study
Howard Schultz, founder and chairperson of Starbucks Coffee Company, emphasizes words like "collaborative," "teams," "empowerment," "empathize," and "vision." Starbucks has over 7,500 stores in 36 countries, with over 25 million people visiting each week.
Starbucks' six-point mission statement prioritizes: "Provide a great work environment and treat each other with respect and dignity." The overriding company philosophy is "Leave no one behind." New employees receive 24 hours of in-store training, higher-than-average salaries, and benefit packages. All employees working more than 20 hours a week receive stock options and full health-care benefits.
In employee surveys, Starbucks shows an 82% job-satisfaction rate compared to a 50% rate for all employees, and has the lowest employee turnover rate of any restaurant or fast-food company. Starbucks looks for people who are "adaptable, self-motivated, passionate, creative team players."
Need for Team Building
Work teams may be of two basic types:
- Natural work team — people come together because they do related jobs or because of the structure of the organization's design
- Temporary task team — groups meet for limited periods to work on a specific project or problem and disband after they solve it
Teams or work groups often have difficulty operating effectively. Problems that inhibit effective operation include lack of clear objectives, interpersonal differences or conflicts, ineffective communication, difficulty in reaching group decisions, and inappropriate power and authority levels in the group.
🔑 Definition — Team Building: A broad range of planned activities that help groups improve the way they accomplish tasks and help group members enhance interpersonal and problem-solving skills.
Team-Building Activities
A team is a group of interdependent people who share a common purpose, have common work methods, and hold each other accountable. The nature of interdependence varies, creating different types of teams: groups reporting to the same supervisor, groups with common organizational goals, temporary groups for specific one-time tasks, groups with interdependent work roles, and groups with no formal links but collective purpose.
Factors affecting outcomes of team-building activities include the length of time allocated, the team's willingness to examine its operations, how long the team has been working together, and the team's permanence.
Team-building activities can be classified into three categories:
- Activities relevant to one or more individuals
- Activities specific to the group's operation and behavior
- Activities affecting the group's relationship with the rest of the organization
Activities Relevant to One or More Individuals
People come into groups with varying needs for achievement, inclusion, influence, and belonging. Team-building efforts result in members gaining a better understanding of how authority, inclusion, emotions, control, and power affect problem solving and group processes. This information gives group members a choice about their level of involvement, commitment, and investment.
📌 Example: In one team, the leader had predetermined actions for discussion items. During team building, members expressed frustration about their inability to influence decision making. The boss indicated willingness to be challenged about preconceived decisions, and team members expressed increased willingness to engage in problem-solving discussions and trust in the leader.
Activities Oriented to the Group's Operation and Behavior
The most common focus of team-building activities is behavior related to task performance and group process. In an effective team, task behavior and group process must be integrated with each other and with the needs of members.
Team-building activities often begin by clarifying the team's purpose, priorities, goals, and objectives. Groups examine communication patterns, effective use of time, planning mechanisms, workload distribution, and problem-solving techniques. As teams mature, they broaden diagnostic efforts to include interpersonal styles and their impact on other members.
Throughout this process, group norms become clearer, the team becomes more willing to take risks, and team members become more capable of facing difficulties within both the team and the larger organization. A spirit of openness, trust, and risk taking develops.
Activities Affecting the Group's Relationship with the Rest of the Organization
As the team gains better self-understanding, it focuses on its role within the organization. The team may need to clarify its organizational role and consider how this role can be improved or modified. Sometimes the team recognizes a need for more collaboration with other parts of the organization.
As the team becomes more cohesive, it usually exerts a stronger influence on other subsystems. Since team building can have negative effects in this area, the process consultant must help the group understand its role within the organization, develop diagnostic skills, and examine alternative action plans so that inter-group tensions and conflicts do not expand.
Team Building Process
Managing a team involves more than supervising people. Managers must bring a divergent group of people together to work on a common project. Since no one person can possess all the knowledge necessary to analyze and solve today's complex problems, teams are used to bring together required expertise.
The nature of work groups makes team development interventions probably the single most important and widely used OD activity.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical understanding from this lecture is that teams operate on different types of interdependence—pooled (cricket-like), sequential (football-like), or reciprocal (basketball-like)—and organizations must match their team structure to their work requirements. Team building is a planned intervention that enhances communication, cooperation, and cohesiveness, and it involves three interrelated categories of activities: individual-focused, group operation-focused, and organization relationship-focused. The Starbucks case demonstrates that successful team cultures require commitment from leadership, investment in employee well-being, and a clear philosophy that prioritizes team values. Effective team building requires understanding that as teams become more cohesive, they must maintain healthy relationships with the larger organization to avoid dysfunctional isolation.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three types of interdependence illustrated by cricket, football, and basketball, and how do they differ?
- What are the two basic types of work teams, and what distinguishes them from each other?
- What are the three categories of team-building activities, and what does each focus on?
- What specific practices at Starbucks contribute to its high employee satisfaction and low turnover rates?
- What potential negative effect can occur when a team becomes very cohesive, and how can this be prevented?