📘 Lecture 26 — Evaluating and Institutionalizing Organization Development Interventions
📖 Overview: This lecture focuses on how to properly evaluate OD interventions through careful measurement and research design. It covers the selection of appropriate variables, design of good measures, and the use of quasi-experimental designs to determine whether interventions actually produced observed results. Understanding these evaluation methods is critical for OD practitioners to demonstrate accountability and justify resource allocation.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers selecting variables for OD evaluation that derive from underlying theory, measuring both intervention and outcome variables rather than outcomes alone, designing good measures with operational definitions, reliability, and validity. It then discusses research design focusing on internal and external validity, quasi-experimental designs with longitudinal measurement and comparison groups, the three types of perceptual change (alpha, beta, gamma), and concludes with the Farm Bank case study examining MIS implementation challenges.
📝 Lecture Summary
Selecting Variables
Ideally, the variables measured in OD evaluation should derive from the theory or conceptual model underlying the intervention. The model should incorporate the key features of the intervention as well as its expected results. For example, the job-level diagnostic model proposes several major features of work: task variety, feedback, and autonomy. The theory argues that high levels of these elements can be expected to result in high levels of work quality and satisfaction. The strength of this relationship varies with the degree of employee growth need: the higher the need, the more that job enrichment produces positive results.
Measuring both intervention and outcome variables is necessary for implementation and evaluation feedback. Unfortunately, there has been a tendency in OD to measure only outcome variables while neglecting intervention variables altogether. It generally is assumed that the intervention has been implemented and attention is directed to its impact on organizational outcomes. As argued earlier, implementing OD interventions generally takes considerable time and learning. It must be empirically determined that the intervention has been implemented; it cannot simply be assumed. Implementation feedback serves this purpose by guiding the implementation process and helping to interpret outcome data.
🔑 Definition — Intervention variables: The specific organizational changes needed to implement particular interventions, derived from the conceptual framework underlying the OD intervention.
🔑 Definition — Outcome variables: The expected results from particular change programs, such as job satisfaction, intrinsic motivation, organizational commitment, absenteeism, turnover, and productivity.
📌 Example: A negligible change in measures of performance and satisfaction could mean that the wrong intervention has been chosen, that the correct intervention has not been implemented effectively, or that the wrong variables have been measured. Measurement of the intervention variables helps determine the correct interpretation of outcome measures.
Designing Good Measures
Each measurement method has advantages and disadvantages linked to how operationally defined, reliable, and valid a measurement is.
1. Operational definition: A good measure is operationally defined; it specifies the empirical data needed, how they will be collected, and most importantly, how they will be converted from data to information. Macy and Mirvis developed operational definitions for behavioral outcomes consisting of specific computational rules to construct measures for each behavior. Most behaviors are reported as rates adjusted for the number of employees and for possible incidents of behavior, making comparison across different situations and time periods possible.
🔑 Definition — Operational definition: Precise guidelines about what characteristics of the situation are to be observed and how they are to be used, telling OD practitioners and the client system exactly how diagnostic, intervention, and outcome variables will be measured.
2. Reliability: Reliability concerns the extent to which a measure represents the "true" value of a variable; that is, how accurately the operational definition translates data into information. For example, the number of cars leaving an assembly line is highly reliable as a measure of plant productivity. However, when people rate their job satisfaction on a scale of 1 to 5, events like arguments with supervisors or accidents can sway responses, making the "true" satisfaction score difficult to discern.
OD practitioners can improve reliability in four ways:
- Rigorously and operationally define chosen variables
- Use multiple methods (questionnaires, interviews, observation, unobtrusive measures) to triangulate on dimensions
- Use multiple items on a questionnaire to measure the same variable
- Use standardized instruments that are already available
📌 Example: In the Job Diagnostic Survey, the intervention variable "autonomy" has the following operational definition: the average of respondents' answers to three questions measured on a seven-point scale:
- The job permits me to decide on my own how to go about doing the work.
- The job denies me any chance to use my personal initiative or judgment in carrying out the work. (Reverse scored)
- The job gives me considerable opportunity for independence and freedom in how I do the work.
3. Validity: Validity concerns the extent to which a measure actually reflects the variable it is intended to reflect. For example, the number of cars leaving an assembly line might be a reliable measure of plant productivity but may not be valid because it doesn't account for production costs.
OD practitioners can increase validity by:
- Using face validity or content validity by asking colleagues and clients if a proposed measure represents a particular variable
- Using multiple measures of the same variable to assess criterion or convergent validity
- Demonstrating discriminated validity when the proposed measure does not correlate with measures it should not correlate with
- Establishing predictive validity when the variable accurately forecasts another variable over time
🔑 Definition — Face validity/Content validity: When experts and clients agree that the measure reflects the variable of interest, increasing confidence in the measure's validity.
🔑 Definition — Criterion validity/Convergent validity: When several different measures of the same variable correlate highly with each other, especially if one or more have been validated in prior research.
🔑 Definition — Predictive validity: Demonstrated when the variable of interest accurately forecasts another variable over time.
📌 Example: A measure of team cohesion can be said to be valid if it accurately predicts improvements in team performance in the future.
💡 Why this matters: Presenting proposed measures to colleagues and clients for evaluation prior to measurement builds ownership and commitment to the data-collection process and improves the likelihood that the client system will find the data meaningful.
Research Design
The key issue in research design is internal validity — whether the intervention did in fact produce the observed results. External validity is the secondary question of whether the intervention would work similarly in other situations. Internal validity is the essential minimum requirement for assessing OD interventions because unless managers can have confidence that the outcomes are the result of the intervention, they have no rational basis for making decisions about accountability and resource allocation.
Assessing internal validity involves testing a hypothesis that specific organizational changes lead to certain outcomes, and rejecting alternative hypotheses or rival explanations. For example, if a job enrichment program appears to increase employee performance, other possible explanations like new technology, improved raw materials, or new employees must be eliminated.
OD interventions present unique challenges for evaluation: they are complex with interrelated changes, they are long-term projects where other factors may emerge, and they are applied to existing work units rather than randomized groups.
Quasi-experimental research designs are used because they allow evaluators to rule out many rival explanations while being less rigorous than randomized experimental designs. The three most powerful features are:
- Longitudinal measurement — measuring results repeatedly over relatively long time periods, ideally starting before the change program is implemented
- Comparison unit — comparing results in the intervention situation with another similar situation where no change has taken place
- Statistical analysis — using statistical methods to rule out the possibility that results are caused by random error or chance
📌 Example: Table 10 shows monthly absenteeism rates for an intervention group and comparison group. The intervention group showed 5.1% absenteeism in December, but after the intervention started in January, absenteeism dropped to 4.6%, then 4.0%, 3.9%, and 3.5% over the next four months. The comparison group remained stable around 2.5% throughout. Statistical analysis suggested the downward shift was not attributable to chance variation.
Unobtrusive measures collected from company records are especially useful because they do not interact with the intervention and affect the results. Obtrusive measures like questionnaires and interviews are reactive and can sensitize people to the intervention. Multiple measures should be applied to minimize measurement and intervention interactions.
The Three Types of Perceptual Change
Alpha Change concerns a difference that occurs along some relatively stable dimension of reality. This is typically a comparative measure before and after an intervention. If comparative measures of perceived employee discretion show an increase after a job enrichment program, and this represents alpha change, it can be assumed that the program actually increased employee perceptions of discretion.
🔑 Definition — Alpha change: A change along some relatively stable dimension of reality, measured before and after an intervention.
Beta Change occurs when the basis for judging the nature of a variable changes. Team members may view trust very differently after a team-building intervention. Their basis for judging the nature of trust changed, rather than their perception of a simple increase or decrease along a stable continuum.
🔑 Definition — Beta change: A change in the basis for judging a variable, rather than a simple increase or decrease along a stable continuum.
📌 Example: Before-and-after measures of perceived employee discretion can decrease after a job enrichment program. The first measure reflects the individual's belief about ability to move around in the immediate work area. During implementation, the employee learns that discretion is not limited to the immediate work area. At the second measurement, the employee uses this new recalibrated understanding and rates discretion as lower than before.
Gamma Change involves fundamentally redefining the measure as a result of an OD intervention. The framework within which a phenomenon is viewed changes. A major change in perspective or frame of reference occurs.
🔑 Definition — Gamma change: A fundamental redefinition of a measure where the framework within which a phenomenon is viewed changes completely.
📌 Example: After a team-building intervention, team members might conclude that trust was not a relevant variable. They might believe that clarity and responsibility were the relevant factors and their improvement as a team had nothing to do with trust. The term "discretion" may originally refer to ability to move about the department, but after the intervention, discretion might be defined as the ability to make decisions about work rules and schedules.
💡 Why this matters: Potent OD interventions may produce both beta and gamma changes, severely complicating interpretations of findings reporting change or no change. Heavy reliance on questionnaires should be balanced by using other measures like interviews and unobtrusive records.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical concept from this lecture is that effective OD evaluation requires measuring both intervention and outcome variables — never assume an intervention has been implemented, it must be empirically verified. Good measures must be operationally defined, reliable (accurate representation of true values), and valid (actually measuring what they intend to measure). Quasi-experimental designs with longitudinal measurement, comparison groups, and statistical analysis provide the most practical way to establish internal validity in field settings. A crucial insight is that perceptual measures can show three different types of change — alpha (actual change along a stable dimension), beta (recalibration of the measurement scale), and gamma (fundamental redefinition of the concept) — and failing to distinguish these can lead to completely wrong conclusions about intervention effectiveness.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- Why is it problematic to measure only outcome variables while neglecting intervention variables in OD evaluation?
- What are the four ways OD practitioners can improve the reliability of their measures?
- What is the difference between internal validity and external validity in OD research design?
- How does beta change differ from alpha change when using perceptual measures?
- What three features make quasi-experimental designs particularly powerful for assessing OD changes?
📘 Lecture 27 — Evaluating and Institutionalizing Organization Development Interventions
📖 Overview: This lecture examines how organizational changes from OD interventions become permanent parts of an organization's normal functioning. It presents a comprehensive framework identifying the factors, processes, and indicators that determine whether change programs are successfully institutionalized, which is critical for ensuring that OD efforts have lasting impact.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the concept of institutionalizing OD interventions, including Lewin's three-stage change model of unfreezing, moving, and refreezing. It presents a detailed institutionalization framework examining organization characteristics (congruence, stability of environment and technology, unionization) and intervention characteristics (goal specificity, programmability, level of change target, internal support, sponsorship). The lecture also explores five institutionalization processes (socialization, commitment, reward allocation, diffusion, sensing and calibration) and five indicators of institutionalization (knowledge, performance, preferences, normative consensus, value consensus).
📝 Lecture Summary
Institutionalizing Interventions
Once a change has been implemented and proven effective, attention shifts to institutionalizing the changes—making them a permanent part of the organization's normal functioning. Lewin described change as occurring in three stages: unfreezing, moving, and refreezing. Institutionalizing an OD intervention concerns the refreezing stage. It involves the long-term persistence of organizational changes; to the extent that changes persist, they can be said to be institutionalized. Such changes are not dependent on any one person but exist as part of the organization's culture, meaning numerous others share norms about the appropriateness of the changes.
How planned changes become institutionalized has not received much attention in OD literature. Rapidly changing environments have led to admonitions to "change constantly," "change before you have to," and "if it's not broke, fix it anyway." This context has challenged the utility of institutionalization—why make any change permanent if it may require changing again soon? However, these admonitions have also resulted in institutionalization concepts being applied in new ways, where change itself has become the focus of institutionalization. Total quality management, organizational learning, integrated strategic change, and self-design interventions all aim at enhancing the organization's capability for change.
💡 Why this matters: In modern dynamic environments, institutionalizing the capacity for ongoing change is more valuable than institutionalizing any single change.
Institutionalization Framework
Figure 37 presents a framework identifying organization and intervention characteristics and institutionalization processes affecting the degree to which change programs are institutionalized. The model shows that two key antecedents—organization characteristics and intervention characteristics—affect different institutionalization processes operating in organizations. These processes, in turn, affect various indicators of institutionalization. The model also shows that organization characteristics can influence intervention characteristics.
Organization Characteristics
Three key dimensions of an organization can affect intervention characteristics and institutionalization processes:
-
Congruence: This is the degree to which an intervention is perceived as being in harmony with the organization's managerial philosophy, strategy, and structure; its current environment; and other changes taking place. When an intervention is congruent with these dimensions, the probability of institutionalization improves. Congruence facilitates persistence by making it easier to gain member commitment and diffuse the intervention to wider segments. Conversely, participative interventions applied in highly bureaucratic organizations with formalized structures and autocratic managerial styles are not perceived as congruent.
-
Stability of environment and technology: This involves the degree to which the organization's environment and technology are changing. Unless the change target is buffered from these changes or the changes are dealt with directly by the change program, achieving long-term intervention stability may be difficult. For example, decreased demand for products can lead to personnel reductions that change group composition. Conversely, increased demand can bring new members on board faster than they can be socialized effectively.
-
Unionization: Diffusion of interventions may be more difficult in unionized settings, especially if changes affect union contract issues such as salary, fringe benefits, job design, and employee flexibility. A rigid union contract can make it difficult to merge job classifications. However, unions can be a powerful force for promoting change when a good relationship exists between union and management.
Intervention Characteristics
Five major features of OD interventions can affect institutionalization processes:
-
Goal specificity: This involves the extent to which intervention goals are specific rather than broad. Specificity of goals helps direct socializing activities (training, orienting new members) to particular behaviors and helps operationalize new behaviors so rewards can be clearly linked. An intervention aimed only at increasing product quality is more focused and readily operationalized than one intended to improve quality, quantity, safety, absenteeism, and employee development simultaneously.
-
Programmability: This involves the degree to which changes can be programmed or specified clearly in advance to enable socialization, commitment, and reward allocation. Job enrichment specifies three targets of change: employee discretion, task variety, and feedback, allowing the change program to be planned and designed to promote those specific features.
-
Level of change target: This concerns whether the change target is the total organization, a department, or a small work group. Departmental and group changes are susceptible to countervailing forces from others in the organization, but can be institutionalized within a department that successfully insulates itself as a subculture. Targeting wider segments can create shared beliefs about the intervention's value, promoting consensus, but can also become mired in political resistance from the "not invented here" syndrome or powerful opposing constituencies.
-
Internal support: This refers to the degree to which there is an internal support system to guide the change process, typically provided by an internal consultant who can gain commitment and help members implement changes. External consultants also provide support, especially temporarily during early implementation. In high-involvement organization interventions, external consultants bring expertise on organizational design and train members, while internal consultants help members relate to other units, resolve conflicts, and legitimize change activities.
-
Sponsorship: This concerns the presence of a powerful sponsor who can initiate, allocate, and legitimize resources for the intervention. Sponsors must come from high enough levels to control resources and must have visibility and power to nurture the intervention. Many OD interventions persisted for years then collapsed abruptly when the sponsor left. Middle managers have withdrawn support when top management excluded them from the change program.
Institutionalization Processes
Five institutionalization processes can directly affect the degree to which OD interventions are institutionalized:
-
Socialization: This concerns the transmission of information about beliefs, preferences, norms, and values regarding the intervention. A continual process of socialization is necessary to promote persistence, as organization members must focus attention on the evolving nature of the intervention and communicate this information to other employees, especially new members. Employee involvement programs often include initial transmission of information, retraining of existing participants, and training of new members.
-
Commitment: This binds people to behaviors associated with the intervention, including initial commitment and recommitment over time. Opportunities for commitment should allow people to select necessary behaviors freely, explicitly, and publicly. Commitment should derive from several organizational levels including directly involved employees and middle and upper managers. In early employee involvement programs, attention was directed at gaining workers' commitment but middle managers were often ignored, resulting in considerable management resistance.
-
Reward allocation: This involves linking rewards to the new behaviors required by an intervention. Organizational rewards enhance persistence in two ways. First, a combination of intrinsic rewards (internal rewards from challenge, development, and accomplishment) and extrinsic rewards (money, for increased contributions) can reinforce new behaviors. Intrinsic rewards provide opportunities that sustain motivation, while extrinsic rewards further reinforce behavior. Second, new behaviors persist to the extent that rewards are perceived as equitable by employees. Many employee involvement programs fail because employees feel their increased contributions are unfairly rewarded, especially when interventions rely exclusively on intrinsic rewards.
-
Diffusion: This refers to transferring interventions from one system to another. Diffusion facilitates institutionalization by providing a wider organizational base to support new behaviors. Many interventions fail because they run counter to the values and norms of the larger organization, which rejects the changes and pressures the change target to revert. Diffusion to other organizational units reduces this counter-implementation force and tends to lock in behaviors by providing normative consensus from other parts of the organization. The act of transmitting institutionalized behaviors to other systems reinforces commitment.
-
Sensing and calibration: This involves detecting deviations from desired intervention behaviors and taking corrective action. Institutionalized behaviors invariably encounter destabilizing forces such as environmental changes, new technologies, and departmental pressures. Sensing mechanisms, such as implementation feedback, provide information about deviations and initiate corrective actions. For example, if high job discretion from a job enrichment intervention does not persist, information about this problem might initiate renewed socialization or commitment efforts.
Indicators of Institutionalization
Institutionalization is not all-or-nothing but reflects degrees of persistence. Five indicators show the extent of an intervention's persistence:
-
Knowledge: This involves the extent to which organization members have knowledge of the behaviors associated with an intervention—whether members know enough to perform the behaviors and recognize the consequences. Job enrichment includes new behaviors such as performing greater task variety, analyzing task performance information, and making decisions about work methods.
-
Performance: This concerns the degree to which intervention behaviors are actually performed, measured by counting the proportion of relevant people performing the behaviors (e.g., 60% of employees performing job enrichment behaviors) or the frequency with which new behaviors are performed.
-
Preferences: This involves the degree to which organization members privately accept the organizational changes, as opposed to acceptance based on organizational sanctions or group pressures. Private acceptance is reflected in people's positive attitudes toward changes, measured by the direction and intensity of those attitudes across work unit members.
-
Normative consensus: This focuses on the extent to which people agree about the appropriateness of the organizational changes, reflecting how fully changes have become part of the organization's normative structure. Changes persist to the degree members feel they should support them.
-
Value consensus: This is concerned with social consensus on values relevant to the organizational changes. Values are beliefs about how people ought or ought not to behave—abstractions from more specific norms. Job enrichment is based on values promoting employee self-control and responsibility; different behaviors would persist to the extent that employees widely share these values.
These five indicators follow a specific developmental order: knowledge → performance → preferences → norms → values. People must first understand new behaviors before performing them effectively. Performance generates rewards and punishments that affect preferences. As individuals come to prefer changes, normative consensus develops. Finally, normative agreement reflecting particular values produces value consensus. Whenever a later indicator is present, all previous ones are automatically included. An OD intervention is fully institutionalized only when all five factors are present.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The successful institutionalization of OD interventions depends on three interconnected components: organization characteristics (congruence, stability, unionization), intervention characteristics (goal specificity, programmability, level of change target, internal support, sponsorship), and institutionalization processes (socialization, commitment, reward allocation, diffusion, sensing and calibration). The five institutionalization indicators follow a developmental sequence from knowledge to value consensus, and a change is fully institutionalized only when all five are present. Crucially, modern OD recognizes that change capability itself can and should be institutionalized, not just specific changes. The presence of a powerful sponsor and equitable reward systems are particularly critical for long-term persistence.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three stages of change according to Lewin, and which stage corresponds to institutionalization?
- How do organization characteristics (congruence, stability, unionization) affect the institutionalization of OD interventions?
- What are the five intervention characteristics that influence institutionalization processes, and why is sponsorship particularly important?
- Describe the five institutionalization processes and explain how reward allocation works through both intrinsic and extrinsic rewards.
- What is the developmental order of the five indicators of institutionalization, and why must all five be present for full institutionalization?
📘 Lecture 28 — Process Interventions: Interpersonal and Group Process Approaches
📖 Overview: This lecture explores process interventions as a core OD skill used to help work groups become more aware of how they operate and solve their own problems. It covers four major interpersonal and group dynamics interventions—T-groups, process consultation, third-party intervention, and team building—with detailed focus on T-groups and process consultation. Understanding these approaches is essential for OD practitioners who must help groups diagnose and improve their internal processes.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the definition and purpose of process interventions, followed by four types of interventions targeting interpersonal relationships and group dynamics: T-groups (including goals, objectives, and application stages), process consultation (including philosophy, group processes, communications analysis, and the Johari Window), with emphasis on how these interventions help group members assess interactions and develop more effective working relationships. The lecture distinguishes process consultation from team building and explains the role of disclosure and feedback in improving communication.
📝 Lecture Summary
Process Interventions: Interpersonal and Group Process Approaches
Process interventions are an OD skill used by OD practitioners, whether managers or OD professionals, to help work groups become more effective. The purpose of process interventions is to help the work group become more aware of the way it operates and the way its members work with one another. The work group uses this knowledge to develop its own problem-solving ability. Process interventions aim at helping the work group become more aware of its own processes, including the way it operates, and uses this knowledge to solve its own problems.
The manager practicing process intervention observes individuals and teams in action and helps them learn to diagnose and solve their own problems. The manager refrains from telling them how to solve their problems but instead asks questions, focuses their attention on how they are working together, teaches or provides resources where necessary, and listens. One of the major advantages is that teams become more independent to solve problems.
💡 Why this matters: Process interventions shift the role of the manager from problem-solver to facilitator, empowering teams to develop lasting problem-solving capabilities rather than becoming dependent on external direction.
Interpersonal Relationships and Group Dynamics
Change programs relating to interpersonal relations and group dynamics are among the earliest ones devised in OD and represent attempts to improve people's working relationships with one another. The interventions are aimed at helping group members assess their interactions and devise more effective ways of working together. These interventions represent a basic skill requirement for an OD practitioner.
Interpersonal relationships and group dynamics involve four types of interventions:
- T-group
- Process consultation
- Third-party intervention
- Team building
1. T-Groups
As discussed earlier, sensitivity training, or the T-group, is an early forerunner of modern OD interventions. Its direct use in OD has lessened considerably. The National Training Laboratories (NTL) and UCLA are among the few remaining organizations that offer T-groups on a regular basis. OD practitioners often attend T-groups to improve their own functioning. For example, T-groups can help OD practitioners become more aware of how others perceive them and thus increase their effectiveness with client systems. In addition, OD practitioners often recommend that organization members attend a T-group to learn how their behaviors affect others and to develop more effective ways of relating to people.
What Are the Goals?
T-groups traditionally are designed to provide members with experiential learning about group dynamics, leadership, and interpersonal relations. The basic T-group consists of ten to fifteen strangers who meet with a professional trainer to explore the social dynamics that emerge from their interactions. Modifications of this basic design have generally moved in two directions:
-
The first path has used T-group methods to help individuals gain deeper personal understanding and development. This intrapersonal focus is typically called an encounter group or a personal-growth group. It generally is considered outside the boundaries of OD and should be conducted only by professionally trained clinicians.
-
The second direction uses T-group techniques to explore group dynamics and member relationships within an intact work group. Considerable training in T-group methods and group dynamics should be acquired before trying these interventions. This group focus has led to the OD intervention called team building, which is discussed later.
Extensive review of the literature reveals that there are six overall objectives common to most T-groups:
-
Increased understanding, insight, and self-awareness about one's own behavior and its impact on others, including the ways in which others interpret one's behavior.
-
Increased understanding and sensitivity about the behavior of others, including better interpretation of both verbal and nonverbal clues, which increases awareness and understanding of what other people are thinking and feeling.
-
Better understanding and awareness of group and inter-group processes, both those that facilitate and those that inhibit group functioning.
-
Increased diagnostic skills in interpersonal and inter-group situations. Accomplishing the first three objectives provides the basic tools for accomplishing the fourth objective.
-
Increased ability to transform learning into action so that real-life interventions will be successful in increasing member satisfaction, output, or effectiveness.
-
Improvement in individuals' ability to analyze their own interpersonal behavior as well as to learn how to help themselves and others with whom they come in contact, achieve more satisfying, rewarding, and effective interpersonal relationships.
These goals seem to meet many T-group applications, although any one training program may emphasize one goal more than the others. One trainer may emphasize understanding group process as applied to organizations; another may focus on group process as a way of developing individuals' understanding of themselves and others; and a third trainer may concentrate primarily on interpersonal and intrapersonal learning.
Application Stages
Application 4 illustrates the activities occurring in a typical unstructured strangers T-group, one of the most popular approaches.
🔑 Definition — Unstructured Strangers T-group: A T-group session where participants who have not previously known one another meet with a trainer who makes a brief and ambiguous statement and then lapses into silence, creating a leadership and agenda void that the group must fill.
A typical T-group session for strangers might consist of five or six T-groups of ten to fifteen members who have signed up for a session conducted by the National Training Laboratories, UCLA's Ojai program, a university, or a similar organization. The T-group sessions may be combined with cognitive learning, such as brief lectures on general theory, designed exercises, or management games.
Each T-group comprises people who have not previously known one another. If several people from the same organization attend, they are put into different T-groups. At the beginning of the training session, the trainer makes a brief and ambiguous statement about either his or her role or some ground rules and lapses into silence. Because the trainer has not taken a leadership role or provided goals for the group, a dilemma of leadership and agenda is created. The group must work out its own methods to proceed further; it must fill the void left by the lack of a leader or of group objectives.
As the group fills the void, the individuals' behaviors become the "here-and-now" basic data for the learning experiences. As the group struggles with procedure, individual members try out different behaviors and roles, many of which are unsuccessful. One T-group member might make a number of direct, forceful, and unsuccessful attempts to take over the leadership role, trying first one style, then another. Finally, he or she conspicuously withdraws from the group, falls silent, and appears to be thinking about other things. Group members might observe that this person has two basic styles of working with others; when one style is unsuccessful, he or she adopts the other—withdrawal.
As appropriate, the trainer will make an "intervention", an observation or comment about the group, its behavior, or the activities that are taking place. The type and nature of the intervention will vary, depending on the purpose of the laboratory and the trainer's own style. Usually, the trainer encourages individuals to understand what is going on in the group, their own feelings and behaviors, and the impact their behavior has on themselves and others. The primary emphasis is on the here-and-now experience, rather than on anecdotes or "back at the ranch" experiences.
The emphasis on openness and leveling in a supportive and caring environment enables the participants to gain insight into their own and others' feelings and behaviors. A better understanding of group dynamics also can make them more productive individuals.
2. Process Consultation
Process consultation (PC) is a general framework for carrying out helping relationships. It is oriented to helping managers, employees, and groups assess and improve processes, such as communication, interpersonal relations, decision making, and task performance. Schein argues that effective consultants and managers should be good helpers, aiding others in getting things done and in achieving the goals they have set. Thus, PC is more a philosophy than a set of techniques aimed at performing this helping relationship. The philosophy ensures that those who are receiving the help own their problems, gain the skills and expertise to diagnose them, and solve them themselves. Thus, it is an approach to helping people and groups help themselves.
🔑 Definition — Process Consultation: "The creation of a relationship that permits the client to perceive, understand, and act on the process events that occur in (her/his) internal and external environment in order to improve the situation as defined by the client." — Schein
The process consultant does not offer expert help in the form of solutions to problems, as in the doctor-patient model. Rather, the process consultant works to develop relationships, observes groups and people in action, helps them diagnose the way they are carrying out tasks, and helps them learn how to be more effective.
In the OD literature, team building is not clearly differentiated from process consultation. This confusion exists because most team building includes process consultation—helping the group diagnose and understand its own internal processes. However, process consultation is a more general approach to helping relationships than is team building. Team building focuses explicitly on helping groups perform tasks and solve problems more effectively. Process consultation, on the other hand, is concerned with establishing effective helping relationships in organizations. It is seen as key to effective management and consultation and can be applied to any helping relationship, from subordinate development to interpersonal relationships to group development. Thus, team building consists of process consultation plus other, more task-oriented interventions.
Group Process
Process consultation deals primarily with five important interpersonal and group processes:
- Communications
- The functional roles of group members
- The ways in which the group solves problems and makes decisions
- Group norms development
- The use of leadership and authority
Communications
One of the process consultant's areas of interest is the nature and style of communication at both the overt and covert levels.
At the overt level, communication issues involve who talks to whom, for how long, and how often. One method for describing group communication is to keep a time log of how often and to whom people talk. For example, at an hour-long meeting conducted by a manager, the longest anyone other than the manager got to speak was one minute, and that minute was allotted to the assistant manager. Rather than telling the manager that he is cutting people off, the consultant can give descriptive feedback by citing the number of times others tried to talk and the amount of time they were given. The consultant must make certain that the feedback is descriptive and not evaluative (good or bad), unless the individual or group is ready for evaluative feedback.
By keeping a time log, the consultant also can note who talks and who interrupts. Frequently, certain people are perceived as being quiet, when in fact they have tried to say something and have been interrupted. Such interruptions are one of the most effective ways of reducing communications and decreasing participation in a meeting.
Body language and other nonverbal behavior also can be a highly informative method for understanding communication processes. For example, at another meeting conducted by a manager, the animated discussion at the start of the meeting was interrupted by the second-in-command, who said, "This is a problem-solving meeting, not a gripe session." As the manager continued to talk, the fourteen other members present assumed expressions of concentration. Within twenty-five minutes, all of them had folded their arms and were leaning backward, a sure sign that they were blocking out or shutting off the message. Within ten seconds of the manager's subsequent statement, "We are interested in getting your ideas," those present unfolded their arms and began to lean forward, a clear nonverbal sign that they were involved once again.
The manager uses several techniques to analyze the communications processes in a work group:
-
Observe: How often and how long does each member talk during a group discussion? These observations can be easily recorded on paper and referred to later when analyzing group behavior. It is also useful to keep a record of who talks to whom.
-
Identify: Who are the most influential listeners in the group? Noticing eye contact between members can give insights on the communication processes. Sometimes one person, and perhaps not even the person who speaks most frequently, is the one focused on by others as they speak.
-
Interruptions: Who interrupts whom? Is there a pattern in the interruptions? What are the apparent effects of the interruptions?
The manager will probably share this information with the group to enable the members to better understand how they communicate with one another. Feedback may be given intermittently during the meeting or at the conclusion of the meeting. The purpose of feedback is to enable group members to learn about the way they communicate with one another.
At the covert or hidden level of communication, sometimes one thing is said but another meant, thus giving a double message. Luft has described this phenomenon in what is called the Johari Window.
🔑 Definition — Johari Window: A model developed by Luft that describes four cells representing different levels of self-awareness and communication between individuals and others.
Figure 38, a diagram of the Johari Window, shows that:
-
Cell 1 (Open/Public Area): Some personal issues are perceived by both the individual and others.
-
Cell 2 (Hidden/Closed Area): Other people are aware of their own issues, but they conceal them from others. People with certain feelings about themselves or others in the work group may not share with others unless they feel safe and protected; by not revealing reactions they feel might be hurtful or impolite, they lessen the degree of communication.
-
Cell 3 (Blind Area): This comprises personal issues that are unknown to the individual but that are communicated clearly to others. For example, an individual may shout, "I'm not angry," as he or she slams a fist on the table, or say, "I'm not embarrassed at all," as he or she blushes scarlet. Typically, cell-3 communication conveys double messages.
📌 Example: One manager who made frequent business trips invariably told his staff to function as a team and to make decisions in his absence. The staff, however, consistently refused to do this because it was clear to them, and to the process consultant, that the manager was really saying, "Go ahead as a team and make decisions in my absence, but be absolutely certain they are the exact decisions I would make if I were here." Only after the manager participated in several meetings in which he received feedback was he able to understand that he was sending a double message. Thereafter, he tried both to accept decisions made by others and to use management by objectives with his staff and with individual managers.
- Cell 4 (Unknown Area): Represents those personal aspects that are unknown to either the individual or others. Because such areas are outside the realm of the process consultant and the group, focus is typically on the other three cells.
The consultant can encourage individuals to be more open with others about their views, opinions, concerns, and emotions, thus reducing cell 2. Further, the consultant can help individuals give feedback to others, thus reducing cell 3. Reducing the size of these two cells helps improve the communication process by enlarging cell 1, the "self" that is open to both the individual and others.
Disclosure and Feedback of Johari Window
As indicated in the Figure, movement along the vertical and horizontal dimensions enables individuals to change their interpersonal styles by increasing the amount of communication in the public or shared area.
🔑 Definition — Disclosure: The process of enlarging the public area vertically by reducing the closed area, involving open disclosure of one's feelings, thoughts, and candid feedback to others.
To enlarge the public area, a person may move vertically by reducing the closed area. As a person behaves less defensively and becomes more open, trusting, and risk taking, others will tend to react with increased openness and trust. This process, termed disclosure, involves the open disclosure of one's feelings, thoughts, and candid feedback to others. The openness of communication leads more to open and congruent relationships.
🔑 Definition — Feedback: The behavioral process used to enlarge the public area horizontally, allowing us to reduce the blind area.
The only way to become aware of our blind spots is for others to give information or feedback about our behavior. The blind area can only be reduced with the help and cooperation of others, and this requires a willingness to invite and accept such feedback.
Almost every organization finds that poor communication is the most important problem preventing organizational effectiveness.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Process interventions represent a fundamental OD approach where the practitioner helps groups become aware of their own processes and develop self-sufficient problem-solving capabilities rather than providing direct solutions. T-groups provide experiential learning about group dynamics and interpersonal relations, with six core objectives ranging from self-awareness to the ability to transform learning into action, and are typically conducted with strangers in unstructured settings where a trainer's ambiguous opening creates a leadership void that participants must fill. Process consultation is a philosophy-based helping relationship where the consultant observes, diagnoses, and helps groups understand five key processes—communications, functional roles, problem-solving, norms, and leadership—while ensuring clients own their problems and solutions. The Johari Window is a crucial diagnostic tool that reveals four communication cells (open, hidden, blind, unknown) and demonstrates how disclosure reduces the hidden area and feedback reduces the blind area, ultimately enlarging the open/public area to improve organizational communication.