๐ Lecture 16 โ Selection of the News
๐ Overview: This lecture defines what news is and explores the core qualities and elements that make an event newsworthy. It is essential for understanding the foundational principles of news selection, which guide journalists in deciding which stories to cover and why some events receive more attention than others.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining news and listing its qualities, then introduces the twelve factors of newsworthiness. Each factorโincluding timeliness, proximity, exceptional quality, possible future impact, prominence, conflict, the number of people involved or affected, consequence, human interest, pathos, shock value, and titillation componentโis explained with examples to illustrate how they determine news value. The session emphasizes that these factors often overlap and combine to elevate a story's importance.
๐ Lecture Summary
What is News?
News is something new, fresh, unusual, unique, strange, and exclusive. It can be defined as an accurate fact or idea that will interest a large number of viewers. In a news story, strangeness, abnormality, unexpectedness, and nearness of an event all add to interest. The American College Dictionary defines news as "A report of any recent event or situation and as the report of event published in a newspaper." According to Lord Northcliffe, "if a dog bites a man it is no news but if a man bites a dog itโs news." News is a communication between human beings from the earliest period of human civilization. It is information about an event, a development plan, or the movement of important persons, as it is said, "big names make big news."
Qualities of News
The qualities of news include: Accurate, Balanced, Truthful, Recent, Exact, Perfect, Objective, Impartial, Unbiased, Disinclined, Concise, Short, Brief, To the point, and Clear.
Elements of News
The elements of news include: Timeliness/Immediacy, Proximity, Consequence, Prominence, Suspense, Mystery, Oddity, Conflict, Progress, Action, Interest, and Human Emotions.
News and Documentary Production โ Twelve Factors in Newsworthiness
Those involved in broadcast news must understand 12 factors that constitute news value, or newsworthiness: Timeliness, Proximity, Exceptional quality, Possible future impact, Prominence, Conflict, The number of people involved or affected, Consequence, Human interest, Pathos, Shock value, and Titillation component.
-
Timeliness: News is what's new. An afternoon raid on a rock cocaine house may warrant a live ENG report during the 6 p.m. news. However, tomorrow, unless there are major new developments, the same story will probably not be important enough to mention.
-
Proximity: If 15 people are killed in your hometown, your local TV station will undoubtedly consider it news. But if 15 people are killed in Manzanillo, Montserrat, Moyobamba, or some other distant place you've never heard of, it will probably pass without notice. But there are exceptions.
-
Exceptional quality: One exception centers on how the people died. If the people in Manzanillo were killed because of a bus or car accident, this would not be nearly as newsworthy as if they died from an earthquake or stings from "killer bees," feared insects that have now invaded the United States. Exceptional quality refers to how uncommon an event is. A man getting a job as a music conductor is not newsโunless that man is blind.
-
Possible future impact: The killer bee example illustrates another news element: possible future impact. The fact that the killer bees are now in the United States and may eventually be a threat to people watching the news makes the story much more newsworthy. A mundane burglary of an office in the Watergate Hotel in Washington, DC, was hardly news until two reporters named Woodward and Bernstein saw the implications and the possible future impact. Eventually, the story behind this seemingly common burglary brought down a U.S. President.
-
Prominence: The 15 deaths in Manzanillo might also go by unnoticed by the local media unless someone prominent was on the busโpossibly a movie star or a well-known politician. If a U.S. Supreme Court Justice gets married, it's news; if John Smith, your next-door neighbor, gets married, it probably isn't.
-
Conflict: Conflict in its many forms has long held the interest of observers. The conflict may be physical or emotional. It can be open, overt conflict, such as a civil uprising against police authority, or it may be ideological conflict between political candidates. The conflict could be as simple as a person standing on his principles and spending a year fighting city hall over a parking citation. In addition to "people against people" conflict, there can be conflict with wild animals, nature, the environment, or even the frontier of space.
-
The number of people involved or affected: The more people involved in a news event, be it a demonstration or a tragic accident, the more newsworthy the story is. Likewise, the number of people affected by the event, whether it's a new health threat or a new tax ruling, the more newsworthy the story is.
-
Consequence: The fact that a car hit a utility pole isn't news, unless, as a consequence, power is lost throughout a city for several hours. The fact that a computer virus found its way into a computer system might not be news until it bankrupts a business, shuts down a telephone system, or endangers lives by destroying crucial medical data at a hospital.
-
Human interest: Human-interest stories are generally soft news. Examples would be a baby beauty contest, a person whose pet happens to be a nine-foot boa constrictor, or a man who makes a cart so that his two-legged dog can move around again. On a slow news day even a story of fire fighters getting a cat out of a tree might make a suitable story. Human-interest angles can be found in most hard news stories. A flood will undoubtedly have many human-interest angles: a lost child reunited with its parents after two days, a boy who lost his dog, or families returning to their mud-filled homes.
-
Pathos: The fact that people like to hear about the misfortunes of others can't be denied. Seeing or hearing about such things commonly elicits feelings of pity, sorrow, sympathy, and compassion. Some call these stories "tear jerkers." Examples are the child who is now all alone after his parents were killed in a car accident, the elderly woman who just lost her life savings to a con artist, or the blind man whose seeing-eye dog was poisoned. This category isn't just limited to people. How about horses that were found neglected and starving, or the dog that sits at the curb expectantly waiting for its master to return from work each day, even though the man was killed in an accident weeks ago.
-
Shock value: An explosion in a factory has less shock value if it was caused by gas leak than if it was caused by a terrorist. The story of a six year-old boy who shot his mother with a revolver found in a bedside drawer has more shock (and therefore news) value than if same woman died of a heart attack. Both shock value and the titillation factor (below) are well known to the tabloid press. The lure of these two factors is also related to some stories getting inordinate attention, such as the sordid details of a politician's or evangelist's affairโwhich brings us to the final point.
-
Titillation component: This factor primarily involves gender and is commonly featuredโsome would say exploitedโduring rating periods.
๐ Definition โ News: Accurate fact or idea that will interest a large number of viewers. It is something new, fresh, unusual, unique, strange, and exclusive.
๐ Definition โ Soft news: Human-interest stories that are generally lighter in nature, often used to fill slow news days or add emotional depth to hard news stories.
๐ Definition โ Hard news: Serious, factual news stories that cover important events and developments, often involving conflict, consequence, or significant impact on the audience.
๐ Formula for Newsworthiness: A story's newsworthiness is determined by the combined presence of multiple factors such as timeliness, proximity, prominence, conflict, and consequence. The more factors present, the more newsworthy the story.
๐ Example โ Timeliness: An afternoon raid on a rock cocaine house may warrant a live ENG report during the 6 p.m. news, but the same story tomorrow will likely be unimportant unless there are major new developments.
๐ Example โ Proximity: If 15 people are killed in your hometown, it's news; if 15 are killed in a distant place like Manzanillo, it usually passes without notice.
๐ Example โ Exceptional quality: A man getting a job as a music conductor is not newsโunless that man is blind.
๐ Example โ Possible future impact: A mundane burglary at the Watergate Hotel became news when reporters Woodward and Bernstein saw its potential to bring down a U.S. President.
๐ Example โ Prominence: If a U.S. Supreme Court Justice gets married, it's news; if your next-door neighbor gets married, it probably isn't.
๐ Example โ Conflict: A civil uprising against police authority or a person fighting city hall over a parking citation are both forms of conflict that generate news interest.
๐ Example โ Number of people involved or affected: A demonstration or tragic accident involving many people is more newsworthy than one involving few.
๐ Example โ Consequence: A car hitting a utility pole isn't news unless, as a consequence, power is lost throughout a city for several hours.
๐ Example โ Human interest: A man making a cart so his two-legged dog can move around again is a soft news story with human interest.
๐ Example โ Pathos: A child alone after his parents were killed in a car accident, or a dog waiting daily for an owner who has died, are examples of pathos-driven news.
๐ Example โ Shock value: A six year-old boy shooting his mother with a revolver has more shock value than if she died of a heart attack.
๐ Example โ Titillation component: Stories involving gender, often exploited during rating periods, such as the sordid details of a politician's affair.
๐ก Why this matters: Understanding these twelve factors allows journalists to systematically evaluate and prioritize news stories, ensuring that coverage is both relevant and engaging for the audience.
โญ Key Takeaways
The lecture defines news as new, unusual, and interesting information, emphasizing qualities like accuracy, objectivity, and conciseness. The twelve factors of newsworthinessโtimeliness, proximity, exceptional quality, possible future impact, prominence, conflict, number of people involved, consequence, human interest, pathos, shock value, and titillationโare the essential criteria for judging news value. Stories become newsworthy when they combine several of these factors, and the absence of them often relegates an event to obscurity. Understanding these factors is critical for journalists to make informed editorial decisions, balancing hard news with soft human-interest pieces. The lecture also highlights that elements like conflict, consequence, and shock value can elevate a routine event into a major story.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- How does Lord Northcliffe's definition of news ("if a dog bites a man...") illustrate the concept of exceptional quality?
- Explain the difference between "proximity" and "prominence" as factors in newsworthiness, using the example of 15 deaths in a distant location.
- Why did the burglary at the Watergate Hotel eventually become a major news story, according to the lecture's discussion of "possible future impact"?
- Provide one example of a "human interest" story and one example of a "pathos" story, and explain why they are considered different categories.
- What makes the "titillation component" different from the other eleven factors, and how is it typically used in media?
๐ Lecture 17 โ Writing of the News
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the fundamentals of news writing for television, emphasizing the unique structure of news stories compared to other forms of writing. It explains the inverted pyramid style, the essential components of a news story, and the different types of news based on content. Understanding these principles is critical for producing clear, impactful broadcast news.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the factors that modify the importance of news, the radical difference between news writing and other writing forms, the inverted pyramid structure, the contents of news including the five Ws and one H, the definitions of lead, intro, credit line, and body text. It then details three types of news according to content: news based on facts, news based on statements, and news based on action. The lecture concludes with guidance on finding out the lead and a note on the complexity of a television newsroom.
๐ Lecture Summary
Factors Modifying the Importance of News
The importance of a news story is not fixed. The policy of the news medium can increase or diminish a story's importance. The class of viewers and listeners that dominates a channel's audience determines what is considered news for that medium. The amount of time available on television dictates whether a story is told briefly or in detail, altering its value. Finally, repeating the same news can sometimes decrease its importance.
๐ก Why this matters: These factors explain why a story on one channel might be a major headline, while on another it is barely mentioned. As a journalist, you must be aware of your target audience and your medium's constraints.
How to Write the News
A news story is totally and radically different from all other kinds of composition (narratives, novels, plays, films). These other forms begin with background or character introduction and reach the climax at the end. In contrast, a standard news story starts with the climax and leaves the details for later. News opens with a "bang," presenting all concrete information at the start, then describes the relevant detail.
The Inverted Pyramid
The pyramid (or upright triangle) is the style for fiction and literary writing, building up to a climax. News writing follows the inverted pyramid style, where the most important information (the climax) is presented first.
Contents of News
The core contents of any news story are defined by the five Ws and one H:
- What? What happened? What is the event?
- When? When did it occur?
- Where? The place of the incident.
- Who? The persons involved.
- Why? The reason for the issue.
- How? The sequence of the event.
Lead
The lead is the heading of the news that contains the five Ws and one H.
Intro
The intro (introduction) is the first and foremost part of the news, containing the gist of the whole story. Many features and essays also have an intro.
Credit Line
The credit line is mentioned at the start of the news and indicates the place of the news and its source (where it was obtained).
Body Text
The body text follows the intro and contains the details of the particular story.
Types of News According to Contents
News Based on Facts
The structure of fact-based news follows a hierarchy of importance:
- Leading fact (the most important fact or climax)
- Secondary fact
- Other fact
As the story proceeds, further facts and subsequent information are revealed. This type of story is not very difficult to write. The key is to judge the relative value of the data and arrange them in order of importance. The composition breaks logically at every paragraph and can be easily cut down or lengthened according to the time available.
News Based on Statement
In statement journalism, a quote or statement from a prominent personality is treated as news. The structure is:
- Lead summary of the statement (the most important part)
- Summary of the less important part
- Summary of even lesser important part
This includes speeches, views, interviews, talks, comments, and opinions based on recorded information delivered in written or verbal form.
News Based on Action
Action news is the most difficult to write. The reporter narrates the action but must keep in mind the dramatic incidents, description of persons involved, statements of eyewitnesses, and explanatory data. After the lead is written, important events are given in chronological order, followed by background and detail.
Finding Out the Lead
A reporter is constantly in search of a fact or combination that will be suitable for a lead. The lead should be clear, provocative, and simple. It should usually start with a name, a noun, or an article, and rarely with a participle, proposition, or complete passage. The "answer the five Ws technique" is followed.
๐ Example:
"Three persons (who) killed and nine injured last night (when) as a speeding truck (what) collided (why) with a coach while overtaking another bus (how) at GT road (where)."
The lecture notes that the television newsroom is more complicated than that of radio or a newspaper, as it contains editing equipment, production experts, and other technical apparatus.
โญ Key Takeaways
- News writing is fundamentally different from other writing forms; it uses the inverted pyramid style, starting with the most important information (the climax) and ending with details.
- Every news story must answer the five Ws and one H: Who, What, When, Where, Why, and How. The lead is the component that summarizes these elements.
- News can be categorized by its content into three types: fact-based (hierarchy of facts), statement-based (summary of a quote/speech), and action-based (chronological narrative with dramatic description). Action news is the most complex to write.
- The importance of a news story is not inherent; it is modified by the medium's policy, its target audience, the available airtime, and the frequency of repetition.
- A good lead must be clear, provocative, and simple, starting with a noun or name, and should immediately convey the essence of the story using the five Ws technique.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- Explain the "inverted pyramid" style of news writing and how it differs from the structure of a typical novel.
- What are the five Ws and one H that must be contained in a news story? Provide a brief example using a hypothetical event.
- Describe the three types of news based on their contents (facts, statements, action). Which type is considered the most difficult to write and why?
- List four factors that can modify or alter the importance of a news story in a television newsroom.
- What is the purpose of a "lead" in a news story? What characteristics make a lead effective?
๐ Lecture 18 โ Editing of the News
๐ Overview: This lecture focuses on the critical role of the sub-editor in the news production process. It explains that news gathering, while essential, is only the first step; the true shaping, polishing, and packaging of news for broadcast happens in the editing desk. The lecture details the sub-editor's responsibilities, the characteristics of good news, and the systematic process of editing a news story for television.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture explains the central role of the sub-editor and the editing desk as the hub of a news channel. It covers the inherent challenges of news, such as its short-lived nature and the varying quality of daily events. The lecture details the personal and professional attributes required of a sub-editor, the fundamental characteristics of a well-edited news item, and a step-by-step process for editing news copy, including the importance of accurate presentation and page formatting.
๐ Lecture Summary
Editing of the News โ The Role of the Sub-Editor
The word edit is synonymous with to prepare, correct, tidy up, check over, revise, amend, change, alter, modify, and adjust. The editing desk of a news channel is the hub and center around which all activities of news production revolve. While reporters gather news, it is in the newsroom where it is finally dressed for the bulletin. It is here that news is polished and improved, and errors are corrected. The sub-editor is the key figure in this process, shaping raw material into an attractive and pleasant form for the audience.
The sub-editor cannot control the events of the day but can control the use of news. S/he must choose enough for different bulletins, ensuring selection is not arbitrary but in line with the policy of the news channel. The quality of the final bulletin depends on the wisdom, judgment, and skill of the sub-editors. An inefficient sub-editor can nullify the efforts of a best reporter, while an efficient one can recover an indifferent and loosely worded copy.
๐ Definition โ Sub-editor: The individual responsible for selecting, correcting, polishing, and arranging news for publication or broadcast, holding the final word in the production of the news bulletin.
๐ Example: A day may be full of great events, while the next day may be insignificant from a news point of view. In both cases, the sub-editor must produce a bulletin that is as interesting as possible.
Characteristics of Good News
A good news story, as edited by the sub-editor, has specific characteristics. It is the briefest possible summary of a story and includes the five Ws and H (Who, What, Where, When, Why, and How) that are important. It should consist of one paragraph preferably but often has more. The lead must have all the main points of the story and must quickly summarize the most important fact in the first few words.
Furthermore, a good news story begins with specific, interesting, and affecting words. It is distributed into small sentences when too much information would make for an excessively long sentence. It must cite the source from where the news is generated and identify the persons mentioned. If it is a follow-up story, it must relate to the previous news. The first essential of news editing is accuracy, as a channelโs reputation for fairness and reliability rests upon this.
๐ Definition โ Five Ws and H: The fundamental elements of a news story that must be answered: Who, What, Where, When, Why, and How.
๐ Example: A lead for a story about a local event should start with a specific and interesting fact (e.g., "A fire of unknown origin destroyed the historic town hall last night...") rather than a general statement.
Process of Editing a News
The process of editing is intended to make the copy easier for the newscaster to read. The sub-editor's first step is to read the story to get the general sense. While they may mark a mistake here and there in the first reading, they reserve most of their efforts for the second reading. They should read it a third time to eliminate the possibility of oversight and to ensure the story reads coherently. Only then does the sub-editor give the headline.
Reporters should be instructed to end each page of copy on a complete paragraph. This ensures good speed and allows each page to be given to a different compositor. If the reporter has not observed this rule, the sub-editor should rewrite the copy to make each page a complete unit. The editing itself, known in journalistic terms as "Subbing", is becoming progressively more important as the speed of news coverage increases.
๐ก Why this matters: This systematic three-stage reading process is designed to catch errors at multiple levelsโfirst for general understanding, second for specific corrections, and third for overall coherence and flow.
๐ Definition โ Subbing: The journalistic term for the process of editing news copy, a task that is becoming increasingly important with faster news cycles.
๐ Example: A reporter submits a three-page story. The sub-editor reads it once to understand the event, a second time to correct spelling or factual errors, and a third time to ensure the story flows logically before writing a headline.
โญ Key Takeaways
The sub-editor is the central figure in a newsroom, acting as the final gatekeeper who shapes the bulletin through selection, correction, and arrangement, making the news digestible for the audience. A good news story is defined by its accuracy, inclusion of the five Ws and H, and a lead that immediately summarizes the most critical fact in a specific and direct manner. The editing process requires a rigorous, multi-stage reading of the copy to ensure accuracy, coherence, and readability for the newscaster, culminating in the creation of a headline. The sub-editor must possess high news sense, sound education, and knowledge of international affairs to make balanced and proportional decisions. Ultimately, the sub-editor's skill can elevate a third-rate report into a top-quality bulletin, while incompetence can ruin even the best reporter's work.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the key attributes required for a sub-editor to be effective? (Hint: They go beyond just editing text).
- Why is the editing desk described as the "hub" of a news channel?
- List the specific characteristics that define a "good news" item from the perspective of editing.
- Describe the recommended multi-stage process a sub-editor should follow when editing a news story.
- Explain the difference in outcome between an efficient and an inefficient sub-editor, as described in the lecture.
๐ Lecture 19 โ Compilation of News Bulletin
๐ Overview: This lecture explores how news is selected, categorized, and compiled for television news bulletins. It explains the changing nature of news values in the modern media landscape, breaking down the three main categories of newsโhard news, soft news, and investigative reportingโwhile emphasizing the unique constraints and opportunities of television news production.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by discussing the explosion of news media and the process of determining newsworthiness, including traditional and economic factors. It then defines and examines three broad categories of news: hard news, soft news (features), and investigative reports. For each category, the lecture explains its characteristics, format, and role within a television news bulletin, and concludes with a comparison between television and other media.
๐ Lecture Summary
Compilation of News Bulletin
The recent past has witnessed an explosion in the number of news media serving audiences worldwide, including full-time news networks, sports, financial, entertainment, historical, religious, and weather channels. More news is available now than at any other time in human history.
Before anything becomes news, it must be reportedโa rise in gasoline prices, a city council meeting, a road accident, a political gathering, a protest rallyโall must be filtered through the eyes and ears of a journalist. A reporter must be aware of qualities that characterize a news story, the types of news that exist, and the differences in how various media cover news.
From millions of things happening every day, journalists decide which few are worth reporting. Deciding what is newsworthy is not an exact science. News values are formed by tradition, technology, organizational policy, and increasingly, economics. Most journalists agree there are common elements that characterize newsworthy events: the five traditional elements of timeliness, proximity, prominence, consequence, and human interest. Now, economics plays a vital role too.
Some stories cost more to cover than othersโit is cheaper to send a reporter with a camera crew to a city council meeting than to assign a team to investigate city council corruption. Conversely, after spending a large sum of money pursuing a story, a news channel might run it even if it has little traditional news value, simply to justify its cost to management. The cost of new technology is also reflected in the types of stories covered; when TV stations went to Electronic News Gathering (ENG), stories that could be covered live became more important. Many organizations now plan their meetings and demonstrations during newscasts to enhance their chance of receiving TV coverage.
Hard News
Hard news stories make up the bulk of news reporting. They typically embody the traditional news values. Hard news consists of basic factsโthe news of important public events such as government actions, international happenings, social conditions, the economy, crime, environment, and science. Hard news has significance for a large number of people. The front sections of a newspaper or magazine and the lead stories of a radio or television newscast are usually filled with hard news.
In broadcast media, with limited time, sound, and video, telecast reporting follows a square format where the information level stays about the same throughout the story. There is usually no time for less important facts that would come in the last paragraph of a newspaper story. TV and radio news stories use either a hard lead or a soft lead. A hard lead contains the most important informationโthe basic facts of the storyโwhereas a soft lead is used to get the viewers' attention and may not convey much information. The lead is supported by the body of the story, which introduces new information and amplifies the lead. The summation, the final few sentences in the report, can personalize the main point, introduce another fact, or discuss future developments.
The broadcast or news telecast is totally different from print news: it is more informal, conversational, and simple. It is designed to complement sound bitesโthe voice of the newsmakerโor videotape segments.
๐ก Why this matters: Understanding the structure of hard news leads, bodies, and summations is essential for writing effective television news scripts that fit within strict time constraints.
Soft News
Soft news or features covers a wide territory. The one thing all soft news has in common is that it interests the audience. Features typically rely on human interest for their news value. They appeal to people's curiosity, sympathy, skepticism, disbelief, or amazement. They can be about places, people, animals, topics, events, or products. Examples include the birth of a kangaroo at the local zoo, a personality sketch of a local resident with a small part in an upcoming movie, a cook who works as a stand-up comedian, or a teenager receiving a tax refund cheque.
Features are entertaining and the audience likes them. Many television and print vehicles are based primarily on soft content. TV features are more common than radio features. In some large TV markets, one or more reporters cover nothing but features. Almost all stations have a feature file where story ideas are catalogued. If a local TV station does not have the resources to produce local features, it can turn to syndication companies that provide general interest features for a subscription fee.
Telecast features use a variety of formats. Humorous leads and delaying the main points until the end sometimes work wellโa technique often used in features. A simple narrative structure, used in everyday storytelling, can also be effective. The interview format is also popular, particularly when the feature is about a well-known personality.
Investigative Report
Investigative reports unearth significant information about matters of public importance through the use of non-routine information gathering methods. Since the Watergate affair was uncovered by a pair of Washington newspaper reporters, investigative reporting has been viewed as primarily concerned with exposing corruption in high places.
Investigative reports require a good deal of time and money. Because of these heavy investments, they are generally longer than typical telecast news items. Telecast investigative reports are usually packaged in documentaries or in 10-15 minute segments of a news magazine programme. In television and radio, investigative reporters have less time to explore background issues. Documents and records are hard to portray on television, so less emphasis is placed on them. Instead, the TV reporter must come up with interviews and other visual aspects that will illustrate the story. The length of a TV report will sometimes dictate its form.
Speed is more important for news telecast than for the press. TV is almost always first with the newsโa newspaper has to wait for the next morning to give the latest news while a television channel has several news bulletins in 24 hours. Therefore, TV deadlines are more frequent than newspaper deadlines. The modern TV reporter also uses a camera for news items.
Television was introduced to the world about thirty-five years after radio, in 1945. At most places, television developed as a sister organization to radio. Television outclassed all other media of communication in effectiveness as it illustrates and is very close to face-to-face communication, which is considered the most suitable and effective mode of communication.
โญ Key Takeaways
A student must remember that news compilation involves selecting from millions of daily events using both traditional news values (timeliness, proximity, prominence, consequence, human interest) and economic considerations. Hard news forms the backbone of bulletins with its factual, lead-driven structure designed for time-constrained broadcast. Soft news relies on human interest and entertainment value, using flexible formats like narrative or interview structures. Investigative reporting requires significant resources and is typically presented in longer formats like documentaries. Finally, television news is fundamentally different from printโit is more informal, conversational, visual, and must prioritize speed for multiple daily deadlines.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five traditional elements of news value mentioned in the lecture, and what additional factor now plays a vital role in determining newsworthiness?
- How does a hard lead differ from a soft lead in television news reporting?
- What is the primary characteristic that defines soft news or features, and what is a "feature file"?
- Why do investigative reports require more time and money, and in what formats are they typically presented on television?
- How does television news differ from newspaper news in terms of deadlines, format, and communication style?
๐ Lecture 20 โ Presentation of News Bulletin
๐ Overview: This lecture examines how television news bulletins are presented, focusing on the differences between newscasters and news anchors, the techniques used to make news engaging for viewers, and the legal and ethical considerations that guide news presentation. It matters because understanding presentation techniques is essential for effective television journalism.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers types of news telecasts and presenters, the role of news anchors in connecting stories, human-interest elements and story sequencing, legal considerations including defamation and libel, audience considerations including mealtime appropriateness, and qualifications of television news personnel in the Pakistani media context.
๐ Lecture Summary
Presentation of News Bulletin
There are many types of news telecast, each presented and prepared in different styles. The most elementary type requires television reporters to process news items to make them more worthy of watching and hearing than reading. The field distinguishes between newscasters and newsreaders, who merely read a news bulletin, and news anchors or news commentators, who take the news of the day, relate it to past and future happenings, and analyze its significance.
๐ Definition โ News Anchor/Commentator: A presenter who takes the news of the day, relates it to past and probable future events, and analyzes its significance, putting a great deal of personality into the presentation in a less formal manner.
๐ก Why this matters: The news presented by a commentator may be coloured by their own attitude or by the policy of either their station or the sponsor, if the news telecast is sponsored.
๐ Example: Viewers tuning into a programme often see anchors save their most important item for second place, unless their news is preceded by lengthy announcements. An item of national or international interest is considered most important.
The News-Anchor's Techniques
The news-anchor attempts to tie up today's story with the news of yesterday, forming a sort of 'continued story' effect which shows how yesterday's events have led to today's, and how these events may affect society and history in the future. During the programme, the news commentator includes some human-interest stories. It is good practice to insert short, bright, and fast-moving items between long news features.
The news anchor must have the sense of what will appeal to the greatest number of viewers: Weather is a subject of universal interest while a financial statement will interest only a limited class. The conversational news of the news anchor is not as immediate as that presented in press news reports. Some news anchors speak extemporary from notes, cleverly changing their pace and pitch to conform to the content of items and to mark a change of subject.
๐ Definition โ Extemporary Speaking: Speaking without preparation from notes, changing pace and pitch according to content.
๐ Example: There are news anchors who endeavour to tie items together regardless of their relationship, which sometimes results in monotony. The news anchor must not allow news items to cause alarm or anxiety for the safety of viewers' friends or relatives.
Production Resources and Background
Larger news channels maintain their own ticker service, which is used as the basis for the manuscript prepared by news producers. The great problem of the news broadcaster is that the program is a daily feature and in many instances may run three or more times a day, or on an hourly basis as is currently done. Finding material and methods of presenting material is a constant challenge.
In Pakistani electronic media, most news producers, reporters, and even anchors are formerly newspaper or radio newsmen who have developed a good sense of news values. Many news anchors have travelled extensively or acted as field reporters, giving them a background helpful in presenting a news bulletin in an impressive and interesting manner.
News Selection Criteria
The most important prerequisite for the presentation of any item to be telecast is that it be news, and that it be either significant or have human appeal. The television news editor considers whether the item will have mass appeal or whether it is unusual. If the item is not of national, international, or state interest, the telecaster considers whether it deals with the locale within the primary range of the television station. If the persons involved are of particular importance, the item has news value.
๐ Example: Many TV stations and sponsoring agencies require that their telecast combine information with entertainment, so humorous and human-interest stories are mixed together and interspersed between more significant items or used in the conclusion of the news telecast.
Avoiding Harmful Content
It is always better to avoid shocking, frightening, dreadful, and horrible news items. Stories like court trials with unpleasant angles, particularly of gender, social evils, and divorces (except of famous personalities) should be avoided. Crime should only be covered in outstanding cases and minimized. Capital punishment should only be covered if it results from trials that have been in the public eye.
This does not mean that all unpleasant cases and distasteful items are discarded; it means that as far as possible, the television reporter and producer avoids being alarmist. This is the result of television's whole-family audience.
Legal and Timing Considerations
In presentation of news bulletin, the news producer must take into consideration that they may be held for defamation, libel or slander, blasphemy, immoral telecast, contempt of court, or sedition, and must select items to avoid any such charges. The time of day when the news is to be telecast influences the selection and presentation of items.
๐ Example: Cancer, reptiles, and false teeth are not topics for mealtime news telecast.
๐ Definition โ Accuracy in News: Essential in reports of news bulletins because an inaccurate news item cannot be killed as it can be in a newspaper.
โญ Key Takeaways
A student must remember that news anchors and commentators differ from mere newscasters by adding analysis, personality, and continuity to news presentation. The news anchor must balance significance with human appeal, using techniques like the "continued story" effect and mixing short, bright items between longer features. News selection must consider mass appeal, locale, and importance of persons involved while avoiding alarmist or distasteful content due to television's whole-family audience. Legal risks including defamation, libel, blasphemy, and contempt of court must guide content selection. Finally, time of day influences appropriate topics, and accuracy is even more critical in television than print because errors cannot be corrected.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between a newscaster/newsreader and a news anchor/commentator?
- What is the "continued story" effect used by news anchors?
- Why should television news avoid shocking or alarming content?
- What legal charges must news producers consider when selecting items for a news bulletin?
- Why is accuracy even more critical in television news than in newspapers?