π Lecture Summary
Closed Versus Open Systems
Two fundamentally different types of systems can be differentiated and used to model different forms of communication. Systems can be closed and homeostatic or they can be open and dynamically balanced.
Closed systems are like simple machines that perform a task endlessly. There is limited monitoring of the external environment. The machine works well as long as all the parts interrelate in the same, unchanging manner. If a part becomes worn or a communication link frays, the system will fail. It has no capacity to adjust to problems. Communication in closed systems tends to be highly structured and predictable, often using very simple digital messages like "turn on" and "turn off."
Open systems consist of parts that interrelate in such a way that the overall system can monitor its environment and adjust to both internal and external changes. The parts can alter their functions so that if one part fails, others can adjust and take over its function. These systems are capable of growth and change over time, and their relationship to the environment can change as well. They are said to be dynamically balancedβmaintaining integrity and high organization while undergoing significant changes, combining stability with change.
π Example: A classic example of an open system is a biological organism. In our body, various organs communicate using electrical and chemical messages transmitted by the nervous and circulatory systems. The body can adapt in complex ways to the failure of some parts and changes in the external environment. Yet the body as a whole maintains its physical integrityβit can grow, change, and remain highly organized.
Systems theory had its greatest practical impact on mass communication theory several decades after the initial burst of interest in the 1960s.
Criticism of Systems Models
Systems models have a limitation that some critics find troublesome. A status quo bias in systems models can tend to concentrate our attention on observable structures and lead us to assume that the primary function of these structures is to maintain and serve the overall system. We are led to ask research questions like:
- Is a particular part doing what it should?
- Is it communicating properly?
- Is it maintaining a proper relationship to other parts?
- Is it enabling the system to operate properly?
The value of each part is assessed by its contribution to the whole. When we view a system this way, we might be concerned about communication but only in a limited way. We tend to view communication as something that merely interconnects parts, much like the nervous and circulatory systems interconnect organs in our bodies. If the system is doing what we think it should, we conclude communication must be appropriate. If we think the system is failing, we look for communication problems. But sometimes systems should fail. Sometimes systems go through necessary transformations in which existing structures break down and give way to new structures. In such cases, communication will necessarily play a very different role.
π‘ Why this matters: The status quo bias means systems theory can unintentionally support existing power structures by focusing on how well parts function within the system rather than questioning whether the system itself is just or desirable.
Summary
In the last couple of sessions, we studied two bodies of thoughtβsocial cognitive theory and system theoryβboth of which came to mass communication theory from outside the discipline and signaled an important shift in thinking about mass communication.
Emergence of Critical and Cultural Theories of Mass Communication
Before proceeding, let's briefly overview how the challenge to the limited effects paradigm came from ideas other than social cognitive learning and systems theories. As we know, limited effects theory focuses on whether media content can have an immediate and direct effect on specific thoughts and actions of individuals. Researchers typically sought evidence for these effects in experiments or through surveys.
However, there is another way of approaching the study of mass media effects. Instead of focusing on specific effects on individuals, we can focus instead on changes in culture, on how shared understandings and social norms change. Instead of trying to locate hundreds of small effects and add them all up, we can ask whether the development of mass media has profound implications for the way we create, share, learn, and apply culture.
Now we will trace the emergence of theories that directly address questions about the way media might produce profound changes in social life. These new perspectives argued that media might have the power to interfere with and modify how we make sense of our social world and ourselves. These theories are quite diverse and offer very different answers to questions about the role of media in social life. Nevertheless, in all these theories, the concept of culture is central.
Media affect society because they affect how culture is created, shared, learned, and applied. Cultural theories offer a broad range of interesting ideas about how media can affect culture and also provide many different views concerning the long-term consequences of the cultural changes affected by media.
Two Ways Used by Cultural Theorists
Now we will discuss the two widely used ways cultural theorists differentiate the various theories of media.
-
Microscopic, interpretive theories that focus on how individuals and social groups use media to create and foster forms of culture that structure everyday life.
-
Macroscopic, structural theories that focus on how social elites use their economic power to gain control over and exploit media to propagate hegemonic culture as a means of maintaining their dominant position in the social order. These are called political economy theories because they place priority on understanding how economic power provides a basis for ideological and political power.
π Definition β Hegemonic culture: Culture that is imposed by dominant social groups to maintain their power, making their worldview appear natural and universal.
Differences Between Microscopic and Macroscopic Theories
Cultural studies theories are less concerned with the long-term consequences of media for the social order and more concerned with looking at how media affect our individual lives. These theories are said to be micro-level or microscopic because they de-emphasize larger issues about the social order in favor of questions involving the everyday life of average people.
Critical theories and political economy theories by contrast are macroscopic cultural theories, which are less concerned with developing detailed explanations of how individuals are influenced by media and more concerned with how the social order as a whole is affected.
Until recently, microscopic and macroscopic theories developed in relative isolation. Theorists were separated by differences in geography, politics, and research objectives. But that may be changing, as we will discuss in coming sessions.
Microscopic cultural studies researchers prefer to understand what is going on in the world immediately around them. They are intrigued by the mundane, the seemingly trivial, and the routine. They view our experience of everyday life and of reality itself as an artificial construction that we somehow maintain with only occasional minor breakdowns. They want to know how mass media have been incorporated into the routines of daily life without creating serious disruptions. Perhaps the media do cause problems that are somehow being compensated for or concealed? If so, how is this being done? Will there be a breakdown eventuallyβor are we being systematically desensitized and trained to be aggressive? Or is everyday life being transformed in useful waysβare we becoming kinder and gentler?
Macroscopic researchers are troubled by the narrow focus of microscopic theory. These researchers demand answers to larger questions: How do media affect the way politics is conducted, the way a national economy operates, or the delivery of vital social services? Macroscopic researchers want to know if media are intruding into or disrupting large-scale social processes. For example, have media disrupted the conduct of national politics and therefore increased the likelihood that inferior politicians will be elected? Macroscopic researchers believe that such large-scale questions cannot be answered if you begin by looking at individuals.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture establishes a fundamental distinction between closed and open systems, where closed systems lack adaptive capacity while open systems are dynamically balanced and capable of growth. Systems theory's status quo bias is critically important to recognize, as it can lead researchers to focus on whether parts function properly within an existing system rather than questioning whether the system itself should change. The emergence of cultural theories represents a paradigm shift from studying immediate individual effects to examining how media transform culture, shared understandings, and social norms over time. The key division in cultural theories is between microscopic interpretive approaches that examine everyday media use and macroscopic structural/political economy approaches that analyze how elites use economic power to maintain cultural hegemony. Finally, the lecture emphasizes that these two approaches address fundamentally different research questions and cannot be reduced to one another.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the key differences between closed systems and open systems in terms of their capacity for adaptation and communication patterns?
- What is the "status quo bias" in systems models, and why do critics find it problematic?
- How do critical and cultural theories of mass communication differ from the limited effects paradigm?
- What is the distinction between microscopic interpretive theories and macroscopic structural theories in cultural studies of media?
- According to macroscopic researchers, why can large-scale questions about media's impact on politics and social services not be answered by beginning with the study of individuals?
π Lecture 22 β REVISION
π Overview: This lecture is a comprehensive revision of the entire course, Theories of Communication. It recaps foundational concepts about the nature of communication, theory building, paradigms, mass communication history, normative media theories, early powerful effects theories, the paradigm shift to limited effects, and critical/cultural perspectives. It serves as a final synthesis of all key models, thinkers, and theoretical debates.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by revisiting the nature of communication and its core conceptualizations as a process, transactional, and symbolic. It then reviews the nature of theory, paradigms (positivistic, interpretive, critical), and inductive/deductive approaches. Mass communication is defined and its historical evolution is traced, followed by normative theories (authoritarian, libertarian, Chicago School, totalitarian, development, democratic-participant). Early powerful effects theories (behaviorism, Freudianism, magic bullet, Lasswell) are contrasted with the limited effects paradigm (Lazarsfeld, Hovland, two-step flow, selective processes, Klapper). Finally, the revision covers challenging the dominant paradigm with violence research (catharsis, social learning, cultivation) and systems/critical theories.
π Lecture Summary
Understanding the nature of communication
Communication is a continuous and complex process that cannot be arbitrarily isolated. It is transactional, meaning participants constantly influence each other and are influenced by the context. It is also symbolic, which is studied through semiotics β the study of signs. A sign is a relationship between the signifier (e.g., the word "book") and the signified (the concept of a book).
π Definition β Communication: A symbolic, transactional process of creating and sharing meaning.
Understanding the nature of theory
A theory is an explanation of a phenomenon, and a paradigm is a fundamental worldview that shapes how we observe, measure, and understand social reality. There are three major paradigms:
- Positivistic perspective: Views reality as objective, governed by strict, natural, unchangeable laws, and all members of society share the same meanings.
- Interpretive perspective: Views reality as socially constructed, internally experienced, and subjective β not 'out there' but in people's minds.
- Critical perspective: Views reality as created by powerful people who manipulate and condition others to serve their own needs.
Sir Karl Popper described theories as "nets cast to catch what we call the world." There are two approaches to theory building: the deductive approach (from general to particular, testing theory) and the inductive approach (from particular to general, generating theory from observation).
A model is a consciously simplified, graphic description of a piece of reality. It shows main elements and relationships but is not explanatory by itself. Models organize concepts, explain processes, and predict outcomes. There are two kinds: structural models and functional models, and three ways of viewing communication processes: linear, interactive, and transactional.
π Definition β Paradigm: A fundamental set of assumptions and worldview that guides how reality is observed, measured, and understood.
From communication to mass communication models
The term mass communication emerged in the late 1930s. Its nature involves the communicator (organized, professional), audience (large, heterogeneous, anonymous), and the communication experience (one-way, impersonal). DeFleur and Ball Rokeach identified key developments: Age of signs and signals, Age of speech and language, Age of writing (papyrus), Age of printing (Gutenberg, 1456), with the age of mass communication ushered by widespread newspapers (1920s), radio (1920s), and TV (1940s).
Mass media includes print media, electronic media, and new media (telematic media), which combine telecommunication and information β including video games, virtual reality, and CD-ROM.
Normative Theories of Media
- Authoritarian Theory: All communication is under the control of a governing elite to protect a divinely ordained social order.
- Libertarian Theory: Arising in opposition, it argues for no laws governing media; free press means total unregulation.
- Hutchins Commission on Freedom: Emphasized an independent press that scrutinizes social institutions and provides objective, accurate news.
- Chicago School: Envisioned cities as "Great Communities" of pluralistic groups (diverse cultural and racial groups) working together.
- Totalitarian Media Theory: Calls for suppression of pluralistic groups and media control by the dominant political party to propagate a strong centralized political culture.
- Development Media Theory: Recognizes that societies transitioning from underdevelopment lack infrastructure, money, traditions, and professional skills.
- Democratic-Participant Theory: Proposed in response to new media developments and criticism of private/public media monopolies.
- Civic/Public Journalism: Actively engages community members in reporting important civic issues.
The rise of mass society
Ferdinand Tonnies distinguished between Gemeinschaft (folk society) and Gesellschaft (modern, industrial society). Emile Durkheim distinguished between mechanical solidarity (folk societies) and organic solidarity (modern societies). These theories assumed media have powerful effects, leading to theories that media could be used as powerful propaganda tools.
Powerful Effects Theories
- Behaviorism (John B. Watson): All human action is a conditioned response to external stimuli; media provides stimuli that trigger immediate responses.
- Freudianism (Sigmund Freud): The Ego (rational mind) controls the Id (selfish, pleasure-seeking self) by relying on the Superego (internalized cultural rules).
- Magic Bullet Theory (1920s): Media messages penetrate minds like bullets, instantly creating associations between strong emotions and specific concepts. Propagandists could condition people to associate good emotions with their country and bad emotions with enemies.
- Lasswell Propaganda Theory: Focused on how media could be used for systematic propaganda.
π Definition β Magic Bullet Theory: The assumption that media messages directly and uniformly affect all audience members instantly.
Paradigm Shift to Limited Effects
From 1940 to 1960, the focus shifted from powerful effects to limited effects of media. Paul Lazarsfeld's research at Princeton found that media effects are modified by interpersonal communication, leading to the Two-Step Flow Model: information flows from media to opinion leaders, then to less active sections of the population. Carl Hovland's experiments showed attitude change is complex, depending on message type (one-sided vs. two-sided), socio-economic background, and predispositions.
Collectively, these became the Selective Processes: Selective Exposure (choosing media that align with beliefs), Selective Retention (remembering information that supports existing beliefs), and Selective Perception (interpreting messages in ways that confirm existing views).
Middle-Range Theories
- Functional Analysis Approach: Practices that maintain society are Functional; disruptive practices are Dysfunctional. Society flourishes when functional practices dominate.
- Information Flow Theory: Assessed media effectiveness in transmitting information; found barriers impede information flow and even gifts couldn't guarantee accurate flow.
- Klapper's Phenomenistic Theory (Reinforcement Theory): Media rarely have direct effects; they are relatively powerless compared to social and psychological factors. The primary influence of media is to reinforce (not change) existing attitudes and behaviors.
- Diffusion of Innovation Theory (Rogers): Innovations spread in a predictable S-shaped curve pattern. Five adoption categories: Innovators, Early Adopters, Early Majority, Late Majority, Laggards.
Challenging the Dominant Paradigm: Media Violence
Growing concern about television violence led to the Surgeon General's Scientific Advisory Committee (1969), which concluded that the causal relationship between televised violence and antisocial behavior warranted immediate remedial action.
Three perspectives on media violence:
- Catharsis (Sublimation): Viewing violence purges aggressive drives, providing a harmless outlet.
- Social Learning Theory (Bandura): People learn through observation; modeling involves attention, retention, motor reproduction, and motivation.
- Social Cognitive Theory: Explains psychosocial functioning through triadic reciprocal causation β behavior, cognitive/personal factors, and environmental events interact bidirectionally. Emphasizes uniquely human capacities: symbolizing, self-regulatory, self-reflective, and vicarious capacities.
Cultivation Analysis
The Cultivation Hypothesis (George Gerbner, 1960s) proposes that heavy viewers of television develop views of the world that match what they see on TV. Mainstreaming is a leveling effect where heavy viewing washes out demographic differences. Resonance occurs when real-world experiences support TV's distorted images, amplifying the cultivation effect. Susceptibility depends on personality, social background, education, and viewing motivations.
Systems and Critical/Cultural Theories
Systems notions provide a powerful way of conceptualizing complex social systems, distinguishing between closed and open systems. The lecture concludes with the emergence of critical and cultural theories, which critique systems approaches and emphasize power, ideology, and social construction.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical points for exam preparation are: (1) Communication is a symbolic, transactional, and continuous process, not a static event. (2) Paradigms shape how we see reality β positivistic (objective), interpretive (subjective/constructed), and critical (power-driven). (3) Normative theories prescribe how media should operate, ranging from authoritarian control to libertarian freedom to social responsibility. (4) The field experienced a major paradigm shift from powerful effects (magic bullet, behaviorism, Freudianism) to limited effects (two-step flow, selective processes, Klapper's reinforcement theory, diffusion of innovation). (5) Challenging the limited effects paradigm, cultivation analysis (Gerbner) and social cognitive theory (Bandura) reasserted significant media influence through cumulative, long-term exposure and observational learning.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three points of convergence in conceptualizations of communication, and what does each mean?
- Compare and contrast the positivistic, interpretive, and critical paradigms in terms of how they view reality.
- Explain the difference between the deductive and inductive approaches to theory building.
- What is the two-step flow model, and how did it challenge the magic bullet theory?
- According to Gerbner's cultivation hypothesis, what is the difference between mainstreaming and resonance?