π Lecture 17 β Modeling from Mass Media
π Overview: This lecture explores how individuals learn behaviors, attitudes, and emotional responses through modeling from mass media content. Drawing primarily on Albert Bandura's social cognitive theory, it examines both negative effects (such as aggression from media violence) and positive effects (such as pro-social learning from educational programming), as well as related phenomena like cultivation, social prompting, and priming effects.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers modeling from mass media as an efficient way to learn behaviors, learning from media content and emotional arousal, social construction of reality and cultivation effects, effects of viewing televised violence, pro-social learning from media, social prompting and persuasion, diffusion of innovations through symbolic modeling, recent applications of social cognitive theory, and priming effects including copycat crimes.
π Lecture Summary
Learning from Media Content and Modeling
Whenever a person sees a character on screen expressing strong emotion or performing powerful action, the viewer is affected or aroused. The viewer remembers similar experiences and emotions, and these thoughts and images serve as cues that trigger self-arousal. For example, movies like E.T., Jaws, and horror films elicit fear reactions. Such experiences of arousal are not always fleeting; several studies have shown that audience members sometimes develop lasting emotional reactions, attitudes, and behaviors after viewing emotional content that arouses them.
Social construction of reality and cultivation
Some studies show that realities depicted on television do not always reflect the true state of affairs in the real world. Some scholars believe that heavy viewing of television tends to shape or cultivate viewers' perceptions and beliefs so that they are more in line with the world portrayed on television than with the real world. Media scholars call this phenomenon the social construction of reality. Examples include overestimating the chances of being in a plane crash or being a victim of violent crime, and accepting stereotypical portrayals of men and women, especially in terms of their professions.
Effects of viewing televised or film violence
Through the years, most media effects studies have examined the negative effects resulting from the vicarious capacity of media, such as the learning of aggressive behavior by viewing televised or filmed violence. When carried to its worst extreme, the modeling of such behavior has been linked to violent and brutal "copycat" crimes such as rape and murder.
Learning good things from media
In recent years, a growing body of research examining children's television programming has yielded promising findings. These studies have shown that many children's television shows have pro-social or positive effects. Children improve literacy, science, and mathematics skills, learn positive social behavior, enhance their imaginative powers, and develop problem-solving abilities. Longitudinal studies have revealed positive effects in terms of academic achievement and reading skills, especially from viewing Sesame Street as preschoolers. The positive benefits of educational programming for children are enhanced whenever parents or caregivers view programs with the children and reinforce the messages.
Social prompting or persuasion
Advertising campaigns and other efforts of persuasion serve as excellent examples of social prompting, another form of modeled behavior. Social prompting does not involve learning new behavior, and therefore it differs from observational learning and disinhibition. Social prompting implies that a person is offered an inducement (an incentive) to act in a particular way that has already been learned. For example, most people are not inclined to try a new product unless the new product is shown to offer great benefits or inducementsβsuch as toothpaste.
π Definition β Social prompting: Offering an inducement to act in a way that has already been learned, differing from learning new behavior through observation.
Diffusion by way of symbolic modeling
One important area of media effects research involves the study of diffusion or spread of an innovationβa new technology, tool, behavior, or farming techniqueβthroughout a society or large group of people. Diffusion of innovations research examines the different strengths of media and interpersonal influences in the adoption of new behavior. Social changes have occurred due to the influences of television on elite societies of viewers who model the various behaviors, styles, and ideas that they see and learn.
Recent research
Social cognitive theory serves as the theoretical basis for many types of media effects researchβfrom media violence studies and fright reactions to media content, to effects from sexually explicit content, and effects from persuasive media messages. In recent years, social cognitive theory of mass communication has proven especially useful as the theoretical underpinning for communication campaigns and their design, for health communications, and election campaigns.
Summary
Albert Bandura's social cognitive theory serves as the basis for many other theories of media effects. It provides a framework to analyze human cognitions that produce certain behaviors and describe mental processes at work whenever a person learns. Social cognitive theory is an offshoot of Bandura's more comprehensive social learning theory, which explains behavior by examining the triadic reciprocal causation process, or the interaction among cognitive, behavioral, and environmental factors.
Cognitive traits
Social cognitive theory emphasizes the importance of several distinct cognitive traits that set human beings apart. These include the symbolizing, self-regulatory, self-reflective, and vicarious traits. The theory helps explain cultivation effects, priming effects, and pro-social effects in terms of cognition, observational learning, and modeling. The basis for many persuasion effects or social prompting from mass media can be found in social cognitive theory, which recognizes that motivations or influences to model new behavior or adopt new ideas are dynamic and usually a combination of outside factors and personal cognitions and characteristics. Diffusion of innovations, another important arm of media effects research, also finds a conceptual basis in social cognitive theory. Diffusion throughout a society is explained in terms of symbolic modeling, persuasion or social prompting, and motivation.
π‘ Why this matters: These cognitive traits explain why different people respond differently to the same media content based on their personal characteristics and mental processes.
PRIMING EFFECTS
Researchers often question whether media violence causes viewers to make associations with angry or critical thoughts stored in their own memories. Does the viewing of mediated violence and the mental associations it arouses make viewers more likely to commit acts of violence themselves? These questions relate to the psychological processes present whenever media effects occur. Priming occurs when exposure to mediated communication activates related thoughts that have been stored in the mind of an audience member. Media message content triggers concepts, thoughts, learning, or knowledge acquired in the past that are related to the message content. In this way, message content is connected, associated, or reinforced by related thoughts and concepts that it brings to mind. For a certain period after viewing such content, a person is more likely to have thoughts or memories become permanently associated with the message content, or stimulus.
π Definition β Priming: When exposure to mediated communication activates related thoughts stored in the mind of an audience member, making those thoughts more accessible.
π Example: If one views a rail accident or air accident, the viewer might recall an accident they were part of. Their interest in the news story and their reaction to it may well be affected by their existing knowledge and previous experiences. In other words, their memories primed them to react in a particular way to the story.
The priming activation may also influence a person's behavior, causing them to act or react in some way, sometimes with undesirable consequences. The most sensational example of undesirable priming, operating with social learning theory, may be that of copycat crimesβespecially murder or other violent crimes that occurred after the person was primed by a movie or program. Instances of copycat crimes are grave extremes of priming. Such cases represent a very small percentage of the population who experience priming effects so completely that they actually model or imitate the viewed behavior. Priming effects from the viewing of media violence are normally much more subtle, but even at that level they represent cause for concern.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concept from this lecture is that mass media serve as powerful models for learning both positive and negative behaviors through observational learning and modeling, as explained by Bandura's social cognitive theory. Students must understand that media can cultivate perceptions of reality that differ from actual conditions (social construction of reality), can prime related thoughts and memories that influence subsequent behavior (priming effects), and can prompt already-learned behaviors through incentives (social prompting). The diffusion of innovations demonstrates how media influence the spread of new ideas and practices throughout society via symbolic modeling. Finally, while extreme cases like copycat crimes are rare, the priming and modeling effects of media violence remain subtle but significant concerns for media effects researchers.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between social prompting and observational learning in the context of media effects?
- How does social cognitive theory explain the cultivation of perceptions that differ from reality?
- What cognitive traits does Bandura identify as distinguishing human beings in social cognitive theory, and why are they important?
- Explain the process of priming and describe how it can lead to undesirable consequences like copycat crimes.
- How does diffusion of innovations research explain social change through symbolic modeling in mass media?
π Lecture 18 β Priming Effect
π Overview: This lecture explains the Priming Effect, a media effects theory that explores how exposure to media content activates related thoughts and memories in an audience member's mind. It matters because it helps explain how media can influence not only thoughts but also subsequent behaviors, including the potential for copycat crimes, and identifies key variables that strengthen these effects.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the definition of priming, its conceptual roots in cognitive neo-association and memory networks, and several variables that enhance priming effects including perceived meaning, perceived justifiability, character identification, perceived reality, and prior experiences. It concludes with recent research trends and a summary of key concepts.
π Lecture Summary
Priming Effect
Priming occurs when exposure to mediated communication activates related thoughts that have been stored in the mind of an audience member. Media message content triggers concepts, thoughts, learning, or knowledge acquired in the past that are related to the message content. In this way, message content is connected, associated, or reinforced by related thoughts and concepts that it brings to mind. For a certain period after viewing such content, a person is more likely to have thoughts or memories become permanently associated with the message content, or stimulus.
π Example: If one views a rail accident or air accident, the viewer might recall an accident he is part of. His interest in the news story and his reaction to it may well be affected by his existing knowledge and previous experiences. In other words, his memories primed him to react in a particular way to the story.
The priming activation may also influence a personβs behavior, causing him or her to act or react in some way, sometimes with undesirable consequences. The most sensational example of undesirable priming, in this case operating with social learning theory, may be that of copycat crimes β especially murder or other violent crimes that occurred after the person was primed by a movie or program. Instances of copycat crimes are grave extremes of priming. Such cases represent a very small percentage of the population experiencing priming effects so completely that they actually model or imitate the viewed behavior. Priming effects from the viewing of media violence are normally much more subtle, but even at that level they represent cause for concern.
Conceptual Roots
Priming is based upon the concept of cognitive neo-association. This social psychological perspective attempts to explain a portion of the phenomenon of memory. To understand cognitive neo-association, one must picture the brain as a complex network or pathway that connects associated ideas, thoughts, feelings, and concepts. Memory can be described as the overall network. When a person watches a television program or reads a newspaper, the information being processed triggers or activates certain pathways throughout the network. Individual thoughts or feelings from past experiences are remembered and associated with the new information. These ideas and thoughts may stimulate other, related ideas and they may influence a personβs actions. Ideas connected to emotions trigger associated feelings and responses.
π Example: Research has shown that thinking depressing thoughts can actually cause feelings of depression, and exposure to ideas of aggression can produce feelings of anger or even aggressive acts under some circumstances. Similarly, a sad scene in a movie causes the audience to remember similar moments in their own lives and recall emotions associated with the events β a painful separation, death of a loved one, a tragic accident.
Individual differences in perceptions, of course, cause priming activation strengths to vary considerably from person to person. However, a number of media effects studies have shown strong evidence for priming, especially for the priming of ideas related to aggression. One study found that children who read comic books with violent content were more likely to have aggressive thoughts than children who read comic books with more neutral content.
π‘ Why this matters: This shows that even relatively mild media content, like comic books, can prime aggressive thoughts, establishing a cognitive link between media and real-world thinking.
Variables that Enhance Priming Effects
Modeling from mass media is an efficient way to learn a wide range of behaviors and solutions to problems that we otherwise learn slowly, or not at all, or pay too high a price to learn in the actual environment. Research has shown that there are some intervening variables that strengthen the cause-effect phenomenon when they are present:
i. The perceived meaning of the communication ii. The perceived justifiability of the witnessed aggression iii. The extent to which audiences identify with the characters iv. The perceived reality of the mediated communication v. The stimulus of prior experiences
1. Perceived Meaning
In a research experiment, first participants were angered, then shown professional prize fights and professional football. They were given the information that either they were fighting to hurt others or simply performing their professional jobs. Afterwards, they were asked to give electric shocks to those who angered them. The ones who were told that athletes were trying to hurt each other showed evidence of being 'primed' with more aggressive thoughts as they administered more punishing electrical shocks.
2. Perceived Justifiability
Research has also shown that viewers of mediated violence are also influenced in their actions by the outcomes of the situations they see. A number of studies reveal that viewers believe what happens on television or in movies could also happen to them if they behave in ways similar to the characters depicted. When viewers see aggressors suffering as a result of their behavior, they are less likely to imitate the aggressive behavior. Also, when viewers are reminded of the serious and unfortunate consequences of violence, aggression is usually restrained.
3. Character Identification
Research has shown that identification with a media character enhances priming effects. In an experiment, first participants were angered and then shown a prizefight. One group was told to think of themselves as the winner. The 2nd group was asked to think of themselves as the referee. The 3rd group did not receive any instructions. Half of each group was asked to think of the word 'hit' each time the winner punched his opponent. After the movie, each participant had the opportunity to shock the person who had angered him. The most severe punishment was administered by the group of men who had pictured themselves as the winner and had thought "hit" with each punch.
4. Perceived Reality
The perceived reality of media depictions can also intensify the strength of priming effects. Research has shown that priming effects are strongest when audiences believe they are witnessing actual rather than fictional events. For example, in one study, angered participants saw the same war film, but only half were told it was a fictional movie. The other half were led to believe that the film depicted actual combat groups. Similarly, in another study, similar results were found among three groups of 5th and 6th grade children. The first group saw a fight being reported realistically on the news. The 2nd group saw it in the context of fantasy entertainment. The 3rd group, a control, viewed it as an ordinary commercial. When tested, the first group scored significantly higher on an aggression index than the other two.
5. Memories of Prior Experiences
Another factor identified with enhancing priming effects is that of prior learning or remembered experiences. As an audience member views a violent act, he or she remembers other occasions when semantically similar thoughts or feelings cropped up. The memory reactivates a neural network and strengthens the effects of priming.
Recent Research and Future Trends
In recent years, effects scholars have continued to study priming effects, especially those that result from exposure to media violence. In the Annual Review of Sociology, it was stated that much of the evidence links mediated violence to aggressiveness or the priming of aggressive thoughts. In recent years, priming effects have been found in areas of communication research other than media violence studies, such as political communications, minority portrayals, and advertisements. The number of media effects studies based upon priming theory continues to increase as more researchers seek to identify the links between media priming and the subsequent attitudes and behaviors of audience members.
β Key Takeaways
Priming is a cognitive media effect where exposure to media activates related thoughts, memories, and feelings stored in the brain's network, based on the concept of cognitive neo-association. The effect can influence behavior, with copycat crimes being an extreme example, but most effects are more subtle. The strength of priming is not automatic; it is significantly enhanced by five key variables: perceived meaning, perceived justifiability of violence, identification with the character, perceived reality of the content, and the presence of similar prior experiences. Research on priming has expanded from media violence to include political communication and advertising, showing its broad applicability in understanding media's influence on audience cognition and behavior.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Define priming as it relates to mediated communication.
- What is the conceptual root of priming theory, and how does it describe memory?
- List the five variables that research has identified as enhancing priming effects.
- In the experiment on character identification with the prizefight, which group of participants administered the most severe punishment?
- Besides media violence, name two other areas of communication research where priming effects have been found in recent years.
π Lecture 19 β Cultivation of Perceptions of Social Reality
π Overview: This lecture explores the cultivation hypothesis, a major mass communication theory developed by George Gerbner and his associates through the Cultural Indicators Project. It explains how long-term, heavy television viewing shapes viewers' perceptions of social reality, often making them believe the world is more dangerous than it actually is. Understanding this theory is critical for analyzing media effects on public attitudes and beliefs.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the historical development of cultivation theory from the Cultural Indicators Project, its core conceptual roots including television's role as a "great storyteller," the key mechanisms of mainstreaming and resonance, theoretical developments that complicate the original hypothesis, a two-phase psychological model of the cultivation process, and the two discrete steps for performing cultivation analysis research.
π Lecture Summary
Cultivation Hypothesis
The cultivation hypothesis developed as an attempt to explain the influence of television on its viewers. It grew out of the Cultural Indicators Project, headed in the 1960s by George Gerbner, a University of Pennsylvania communication scholar. Investigators explored the relationship of long-term television viewing to the inculcation of various perceptions, values, and beliefs on the part of audiences.
Simply stated, the cultivation hypothesis proposes that over time, heavy viewers of television develop views of the world similar to what they see on television. The basic assumption underlying the cultivation or enculturation approach is that repeated exposures to consistent media portrayal and themes influence our perceptions of these items in the direction of the media portrayals. In effect, learning from the media environment is generalized, sometimes incorrectly, to the social environment.
History
Some early research studies indicated that media portrayals of certain topics could have an impact on audience perceptions, particularly if the media were the main information sources. DeFleur in 1967 found that television had a homogenizing effect on children's perceptions of occupations commonly shown on television.
The study of viewer perceptions of social reality stems from the Cultural Indicators project of George Gerbner and his associates. Since 1968 they have collected data on the content of television and have analyzed the impact of heavy exposure on the audience. Some of the many variables that have been content analyzed are the demographic portraits of perpetrators and victims of television violence, the prevalence of violent acts, the types of violence portrayed, and the contexts of violence.
They found that long-term exposure to television, in which frequent violence is virtually inescapable, tends to cultivate the image of a relatively mean and dangerous world. The basic hypothesis of cultivation analysis is that the more time one spends living in the world of television, the more likely one is to report conceptions of social reality that can be traced to television portrayals. Their findings indicated that the perceptions of reality were cultivated by television.
Conceptual Roots
Cultivation adherents argue that television as a "wholesale distributor of images" is different from other mass media. It serves as the great storyteller of our age. Programs are produced to appeal to the entire population. Even very young viewers find it easy to become enthralled by an entertaining television show. According to these researchers, the diverse publics all tend to think more alike when watching television because they all receive similar messages.
All television programs, from entertaining action programs to news programs, possess similar, repetitive patterns sometimes called myths, facts, or ideologies. These patterns are thought to influence viewers' perception of the world. Long-term exposure to these overall patterns of television programming is most likely to result in the "steady entrenchment of mainstream orientations for most viewers."
π‘ Why this matters: The theory argues that it is not any single program but the cumulative, repetitive pattern across all television content that shapes viewers' worldview over time.
Mainstreaming and Resonance
Mainstreaming is one of the principal concepts that underlie cultivation analysis; another is resonance.
Mainstreaming Mainstreaming assumes that dominant sets of attitudes, beliefs, values and practices exist within cultures. Patterns also emerge across the spectrum of television programmingβpatterns regarding outcomes to various situations, gender roles, minority representation, and so forth. These patterns result in a "mainstream set of attitudes, beliefs and values that are repetitively presented on television." Heavy television viewers tend to cultivate similar mainstream views.
π Definition β Mainstreaming: Heavy viewing may absorb or override differences in perspectives and behavior which ordinarily stem from other factors and influences. In other words, differences found in the responses of different groups of viewers, differences that usually are associated with the varied cultural, social, and political characteristics of these groups, are diminished or even absent from the responses of heavy viewers in these same groups. So mainstreaming is a leveling effect.
Heavy viewing resulting in a common viewpoint washes out differences in perceptions of reality usually caused by demographic and social factors.
Resonance Resonance occurs when real-world experience supports the distorted image of reality shown on television. Whenever direct experience is in agreement with the messages from television, the messages are reinforcedβthey resonateβand the cultivation effect is amplified.
π Definition β Resonance: When the media reinforce what is seen in real life, thus giving an audience member a "double dose," the resulting increase in the cultivation effect is attributed to resonance.
π Example: Research has shown that heavy television viewers who are most likely to fear crime are those who live in inner-city areas where crime rates are high. Their real-world experience of crime resonates with the television portrayal, amplifying the cultivation effect.
Cultivation researchers stress that the concept of cultivation assumes that television and its publics interact in a dynamic process. The extent to which a person cultivates the messages seen on television depends upon a number of factors. Some people are more susceptible to cultivation influence due to personality traits, social background, cultural mores (education), and even their past television viewing experiences.
Gerbner and his associates explained the interactive process: Although a viewer's gender, age, or class makes a difference in perspective, television viewing can make a similar and interacting difference. Viewing may help define what it means, for example, to be an adolescent female member of a given social class. The interaction is a continuous process as is cultivation, beginning with infancy and going on from cradle to grave.
Theoretical Developments
After an extensive literature review, scholars concluded that there was evidence for a link between viewing and beliefs regardless of the kind of social reality in question. However, additional research has also shown that the cultivation hypothesis may be more complicated than first thought.
There is evidence that cultivation may be less dependent on the total amount of TV viewing than on the specific types of programs viewed. Research also indicates that the cultivation effect is more pronounced among active viewers than among low-involvement viewers, and that personal experience with crime was an important mediating variable that affected the impact of TV programs on cultivating an attitude of vulnerability toward crime.
Additionally, it was found that the perceived reality of the TV content had an impact on cultivation. Similarly, other variables such as identification with TV characters, IQ, and informational needs of the viewer had differential effects. In other words, different people react in different ways to TV content, and these different reactions determine the strength of the cultivation effect.
Apart from these, there are other multivariate models of cultivation which are taken into account by researchers, including:
- Whether viewing is done to meet informational needs or as diversion
- The number of information alternatives available
Research has shown that maximum cultivation occurs among heavy viewers who watch for information, believe the content to be real, and have few alternative sources of information.
Tapper in 1995 presents a possible conceptual model of the cultivation process that is divided into two phases:
- Phase one deals with content acquisition and takes into account such variables as motives for viewing, selective viewing, the type of genre viewed, and perceptions of the reality of the content.
- Phase two is the storage phase and elaborates those constructs that might affect long-term memory.
Researchers have presented a psychological model of the cultivation process based on the notion of accessibility of information in a person's memory. They posit that human memory works much like a storage bin. When new information is acquired, a copy is placed on top of the appropriate bin. Later when information is being retrieved for decision making, the contents of the bin are searched from the top down, thus information deposited most recently and most frequently stands a better chance of being recalled.
Similarly, researchers have also reported results of empirical tests showing that the faster a person is able to make a response, the more accessible is the information retrieved. Consequently, when confronted with a social reality judgment, heavy TV viewers should be able to make judgments faster than light viewers, and their judgments should also demonstrate cultivation (e.g., soap operas).
Performing Cultivation Analysis
There are two discrete steps in performing a cultivation analysis.
Step One: Descriptions of the media world are obtained from periodic content analyses of large blocks of media content. The result of this content analysis is the identification of the messages of the television world. These messages represent consistent patterns in the portrayal of specific issues, policies, and topics that are often at odds with their occurrence in real life. The identification of the consistent portrayals is followed by the construction of a set of questions designed to detect a cultivation effect. Each question poses two or more alternatives. One alternative is more consistent with the world as seen on television, while another is more in line with the real world.
π Example: 60% of homicides are committed by strangers on television, but in real life only 16% are. The question based on this discrepancy was: Does fatal violence occur between strangers or between relatives and acquaintances? The response "strangers" was considered to be the television answer.
Step Two: Involves surveying audiences about their television exposure, dividing the sample into heavy and light viewers (4 hours a day is usually the dividing line), and comparing their answers to the questions that differentiate the television world from the real world. In addition, data are often collected on possible control variables such as gender, age, and socioeconomic status. A statistical procedure consists of correlation analysis between the amount of television viewing and scores on an index reflecting the number of television answers to the comparison questions.
In sum, cultivation has proven to be an evocative and heuristic notion. It is likely that future research will concentrate on identifying key variables important to the process and on specifying the psychological processes that underlie the process.
β Key Takeaways
Cultivation theory proposes that heavy television viewers develop perceptions of social reality that mirror television's distorted portrayals, most notably the "mean world" syndrome where the world is seen as more dangerous than it actually is. The two key mechanisms of cultivation are mainstreaming (television viewing overriding demographic differences to create a common worldview) and resonance (real-world experiences that align with television messages amplifying the cultivation effect). The cultivation effect is not uniform and depends on mediating variables such as viewing motives, perceived reality of content, personal experience, and available information alternatives. Cultivation analysis requires two steps: first, content analysis to identify television's consistent patterns, and second, audience surveys comparing heavy and light viewers' responses while controlling for demographic variables. The psychological basis for cultivation lies in the accessibility of information in memory, where frequently and recently encountered television information is more readily retrieved when making social reality judgments.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the basic premise of the cultivation hypothesis, and how does it differ from other media effects theories?
- Explain the difference between mainstreaming and resonance in cultivation theory, providing an example of each.
- What were the key findings of the Cultural Indicators Project regarding television violence and viewers' perceptions?
- Describe the two-step process for performing a cultivation analysis study.
- What mediating variables influence the strength of the cultivation effect according to later theoretical developments?
π Lecture 20 β Systems Theories of Communication Processes
π Overview: This lecture explores the application of systems theory to communication, originating from engineering and cybernetics. It explains how interconnected parts and feedback loops create holistic communication models, contrasting them with simpler linear models, and introduces key concepts like noise and redundancy from information theory. Understanding these systems is crucial for analyzing large-scale, societal-level communication effects.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining a system and its goal-directed nature, tracing its origins to electronics engineering. It then covers the rise of systems theory from cybernetics and the development of feedback loops. The mathematical theory of communication is introduced, explaining signals, noise, bits, and channel capacity. Finally, the lecture discusses the adoption of system models by mass communication theorists, replacing the transmissional model with mutual influence models.
π Lecture Summary
System
A system consists of a set of parts that are interlinked so that changes in one part induce changes in other parts. These parts can be directly linked mechanically or indirectly linked by communication technology. Because all parts are linked, a change in one element can alter the entire system. Systems can be goal-directed if they have a long-term objective. Some systems can monitor their environment and alter their operations in response to changes.
Interest in systems began with electronics engineers who developed programmable systems that could pursue goals, monitor the environment, and adjust actions to achieve those goals. These engineers focused on designing systems where communication links functioned efficiently and transmitted information accurately. For them, communication was a means to an end; if a communication link didn't work properly, the solution was to improve the technology.
π Definition β System: A set of parts that are interlinked so that changes in one part induce changes in other parts.
How it is applied to society?
In designing and engineering systems, communication problems were solved by technological change. Consequently, during the 1950s and 1960s, there was optimism that important societal-level communication problems might also be solved by improving the accuracy of message transmissions.
The rise of systems theory
After World War II, social scientists became intrigued by system notions. These models fundamentally altered how relationships between variables were understood. Most 1960s social systems theorists acknowledged that the greatest impetus toward developing systems theories came from an engineering subfield known as CYBERNETICS, the study of regulation and control in complex machines. Cybernetics investigates how communication links between the various parts of a machine enable it to perform very complex tasks and adjust to changes taking place in its external environment. Cybernetics proved especially useful for communications engineering. Communication engineers had abandoned simple, linear models of the communication process by the 1940s. A circular but evolving communication process was conceptualized in which messages come back from receivers to influence sources that, in turn, alter their messages. These circular processes are referred to as feedback loops. In these systems, an ongoing mutual adjustment is possible that ultimately leads to achieving a long-term objective or function. Complex machines rely on feedback loops as a means of making ongoing adjustments to changes caused by the environment. Feedback loops enable sources to monitor the influence of their messages on receivers, and just as importantly, receivers can, in turn, influence sources. If the effects are not what is desired, a source can alter a message until the desired feedback is obtained.
π Definition β Cybernetics: The study of regulation and control in complex machines. π Definition β Feedback Loops: Circular communication processes where messages come back from receivers to influence sources, allowing for ongoing mutual adjustment to achieve a long-term objective.
Mathematical theory of communication
Communications engineers made an important breakthrough central to the current revolution in communications technology. Accuracy in message transmission is essential for systems to operate effectively. Even minor errors can compound over time. To address this, a sophisticated system was developed. The flow was known as a signal, and each element in it was labeled an information bit. The ultimate information bit is a digital bitβone that is either present or absent. Methods of monitoring the accuracy of transmission of bits were developed. Any difference between the signal sent and the signal received was viewed as errors or noise. High levels of noise are tolerated if a message is redundant, that is, if it contains many bits that carry the same information. Every communication link can be seen as a channel, and every channel can be seen as having a certain capacity to transmit an accurate signal. It is better to have channels that can accurately transmit complex signals. When accuracy is a problem, redundancy can be increased, but this reduces efficiency because the same information is being sent more than once. For example, AM radio has static, which is thousands of erroneous bits that have entered the signal. FM signals are less subject to such errors.
π Definition β Noise: Any difference between the signal sent and the signal received, viewed as errors. π Definition β Redundancy: The presence of many bits in a message that carry the same information, which helps tolerate noise but reduces efficiency.
The trend in communication engineering has been to find ways to reduce or eliminate noise, improve efficiency, and increase channel capacity. This is the basis for digital High Definition Television (HDTV), which transmits only digital information about changes that occur between frames rather than every frame. For example, when a newscaster reads the news, only their mouth and facial expressions change, so only information about those changes is transmitted, reducing noise and improving efficiency.
Notions about signals, noise, bits, efficiency, redundancy, and channel capacity have found their way into mass communication theory.
Mathematical theory
One of the first and most important books on this topic was the Mathematical Theory of Communication written by Claude Shannon and Warren Weaver in 1949. They believed these new concepts would transform how all forms of communication were understood. Their ideas came to be referred to as information theory. In communications technology and the design of communication systems, the theory has been enormously successful. Technology based on this theory is providing the building blocks for constructing the Information Superhighways, a worldwide system of computer networks accessible to any user. Designers promised vast quantities of information at low cost, a promise that seems fulfilled. However, efficient, accurate transmission isn't enough, as the information age has been accompanied by a troubling escalation in social problems. Only recently have system theorists begun to recognize the need for more complex models that allow ongoing transformation of systems.
π Definition β Information Theory: A theory from Shannon and Weaver (1949) applying concepts like signals, noise, bits, and redundancy to all forms of communication. π Formula: (Implicit) Efficient Communication = (Accurate Signal / (Noise + Redundancy)) with optimized Channel Capacity. π Example: HDTV transmits only digital information about changes between frames (e.g., a newscasterβs changing facial expressions) rather than the entire scene (e.g., their unchanging background), thereby reducing noise and increasing channel capacity.
Adoption of system models by Mass communication theorists
Systems models replaced the Transmissional model that was implicit in most early effects research. Lasswell provided a succinct version of this model: "who says what to whom through what medium with what effect." The Transmissional model assumes a message source dominates the communication process, and the primary outcome is some sort of effect on receivers, usually one intended by the source. Influence flows in a straight line from source to receivers, ignoring the possibility that receivers might also influence the source. In contrast, communication theorists proposed new models of communication processes with feedback loops where receivers could influence sources and mutual influence was possible. Westley and Maclean in 1957 provided a good example of this type of model. Most conversations involve mutual influence: participants send out messages, obtain feedback, and then adjust their actions. The overall social environment can be understood as something created by ongoing negotiation between actors.
π Definition β Transmissional model: A linear communication model (e.g., Lasswell's) that assumes a dominant source sends a message to passive receivers with the goal of achieving a specific effect. π‘ Why this matters: This shift from the transmissional to the systems model is fundamental. It means we must consider reciprocal influence, feedback, and the complex, interconnected nature of communication, rather than seeing effects as simple, one-way impacts.
β Key Takeaways
The core of systems theory is that communication systems are composed of interlinked parts where a change in one part affects the whole. The concept of feedback loops is critical, as it transforms communication from a one-way linear process into a circular, mutually influential one. A key distinction is between the transmissional model (source-dominated) and the systems model (mutual influence). From information theory, the lecture highlights how communication engineers define and manage noise through redundancy to ensure accurate signal transmission, with the goal of improving channel capacity and efficiency, as seen in modern technologies like HDTV.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- According to the lecture, what is a system and what is its key property regarding its parts?
- How does a feedback loop fundamentally change the communication process compared to a linear model?
- In the context of the mathematical theory of communication, what is "noise" and how can "redundancy" help manage it?
- What is the primary difference between the "transmissional model" and the "systems model" of communication?
- How does the example of HDTV illustrate the engineering principles of reducing noise and improving channel capacity?
π Lecture 21 β Emergence of Critical & Cultural Theories of Mass Communication
π Overview: This lecture marks a pivotal shift from limited effects paradigms to critical and cultural theories of mass communication. It introduces systems theory as a transitional framework and then explores the emergence of microscopic interpretive and macroscopic structural approaches to understanding media's role in culture and society.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by distinguishing closed versus open systems, explaining their different communication patterns and capacities for adaptation. It then examines criticisms of systems models, particularly their status quo bias. The main focus is the emergence of critical and cultural theories, including the distinction between microscopic interpretive theories and macroscopic structural/political economy theories, and their different research questions and assumptions.