📘 Lecture 23 — HISTORY OF TELEVISION
📖 Overview: This lecture provides a comprehensive history of television, from its conceptual origins in the 19th century to its technological evolution into black-and-white and color systems. It explores the contributions of key inventors, the development of transmission standards, and the profound cultural impact of television as a medium, making it essential for understanding modern broadcasting.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the early history of television including key discoveries like selenium and the cathode-ray tube, the work of John Logie Baird, the era of black & white transmission and the impact of World War II, the development of color television by RCA and CBS, the nature of early television programs, the cultural revolution brought about by TV, and finally a detailed breakdown of the three main transmission standards (NTSC, SECAM, PAL) with a global country-by-country chart.
📝 Lecture Summary
Early History
The invention of television is a complex story, not attributable to a single inventor but to a series of successive and independent developments. While John Logie Baird is generally credited as the creator, the journey began much earlier. In 1869, French artist Albert Robida envisioned home viewing. The discovery of selenium in 1817 by Berzelius was crucial; its photosensitive properties, noted by Joseph May in 1873, allowed for the conversion of light waves into electrical impulses. Shelford Bidwell demonstrated silhouette transmission in 1881, and Paul Nipkov’s disc scanner used a selenium cell but lacked amplification. Karl Ferdinand Braun introduced the cathode-ray tube in 1897, and Dr. Ambrose Fleming patented the two-diode thermionic valve in 1901. Significant progress occurred in 1923 when scientists transmitted shadows, leading to Baird demonstrating a mechanically scanned television system in 1924 and a real image of a dummy's head in 1925.
🔑 Definition — Selenium: A metalloid in the oxygen group discovered in 1817, whose photosensitive properties were key to converting light into electrical impulses for early television.
The Black & White Images
After key patents were filed, the world saw an explosion of interest in black and white (B/W) programs, which typically consisted of filmed music, live chats, announcements, and news. Due to the limited transmission range of early TV signals, only urban populations could initially enjoy this new medium.
The World War II
The outbreak of World War II temporarily halted progress on TV transmissions and technological improvement. However, limited-scale B/W transmissions continued and had a powerful influence, bringing images of war-ravaged sites directly to the public. The principle of “seeing is believing” helped people understand the war’s progress, such as the defeat of German armies and the advance of allied forces.
Color Television
The earliest recorded proposal for a color television system was a German patent from 1904. In 1925, Zworykin filed a patent for an all-electronic color system, though neither was immediately successful. In 1940, CBS researcher Peter Goldmark invented a mechanical color system based on John Logie Baird’s 1928 designs, which the FCC authorized as the national standard in 1950. This system was ultimately bulky and incompatible with B/W sets. The Korean War halted color TV production, giving RCA time to design a superior, compatible system. RCA’s system received FCC approval in late 1953, and sales began in 1954. That same year, RCA introduced its 21” color TV, though actual sales to the public were very low. The 1950s was an exciting decade for TV, seeing the explosion of B/W, the launch of electronic color and remote controls, and the introduction of transistorized television.
💡 Why this matters: The competition between CBS and RCA for the color TV standard shows how technical compatibility and market factors are just as important as pure invention.
Nature of Programs
Television initially took most of its program patterns from radio. The classification of its early transmission content included: News, Music, Films, Comedy shows, Live shows, and Sports.
The Cultural Revolution
The introduction of TV broadcast brought significant changes to the lifestyle of societies worldwide. Key factors that helped TV broadcast spread and effect these changes included: Tourism, Languages, Immigration policies, and Education.
The Transmission Systems
When TV transmission was introduced in different countries during the 1940s and 1950s, various technical advancements led to different systems. There are currently three main television standards used throughout the world:
🔑 Definition — NTSC (National Television Standards Committee): The oldest existing standard, developed in the USA and first used in 1954, consisting of 525 horizontal lines and 60 vertical lines of display.
🔑 Definition — SECAM (Système Électronique pour Couleur avec Mémoire): Developed in France and first used in 1967, a 625-line vertical, 50-line horizontal display standard.
🔑 Definition — PAL (Phase Alternating Line): Developed by German engineer Walter Bruch and Telefunken, patented in 1963, with its first commercial application in August 1967. It uses a 625/50-line display as an alternative to NTSC, and its proponents call it "Perfection At Last."
The lecture provides an extensive chart mapping each country to its signal type. For example, the United States and Japan use NTSC M; France uses SECAM L; Germany and the United Kingdom (PAL I) use PAL variants; and Pakistan uses PAL B.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The invention of television was not a single event but a culmination of many discoveries, most notably selenium’s photosensitive properties and the cathode-ray tube. While John Logie Baird is a key figure, the medium’s development was a global effort. The transition from black-and-white to color television involved fierce competition, with RCA’s compatible system eventually winning out over CBS’s incompatible mechanical design. The three main global transmission standards—NTSC, SECAM, and PAL—originated from different countries and remain in use today. Finally, television’s impact extended beyond technology, sparking a cultural revolution by influencing tourism, language, immigration, and education.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What was the significance of the element selenium in the early history of television?
- Who is generally considered the creator of television, and what was his key early demonstration?
- Which company, RCA or CBS, won the competition to set the national color television standard in the US, and why was their system preferred?
- Name the three main television transmission standards used worldwide and state their country of origin.
- List four types of programs that early television borrowed from radio.
📘 Lecture 24 — Pakistan Television (PTV)
📖 Overview: This lecture traces the establishment and evolution of Pakistan Television (PTV) from its inception in 1964. It covers the challenges of setting up the first TV station, the excitement of early broadcasts, key historical milestones including the 1965 war coverage and the 1973 microwave network, and the cultural impact of PTV dramas. Understanding PTV’s development is essential for grasping the history of electronic media in Pakistan.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the background of radio stations inherited at partition and the global context of television. It then details the establishment of PTV’s first station in Lahore in 1964, the public excitement and viewing habits, the limited broadcast timings, and the unique feature of live transmission. Key historical events covered include PTV’s role during the 1965 war, the 1973 national microwave network, the 1974 Lahore Islamic Summit coverage, the transition to color broadcast, and subsequent developments like the Federal TV Centre and PTV World. The lecture concludes with a discussion of PTV’s famous dramas.
📝 Lecture Summary
Radio stations were inherited by Pakistan at the time of partition of the subcontinent in 1947, only three in number – Lahore, Peshawar and Dhaka.
At partition in 1947, Pakistan inherited only three radio stations in Lahore, Peshawar, and Dhaka. Meanwhile, the world, especially the West and USA, was already familiar with black & white television broadcast. From the early 1960s, there was talk of starting television in Pakistan. The main obstacle was not money but the non-availability of technical staff. Finally, on November 26, 1964, the country’s first TV station was set up in Lahore. Though much of the world had advanced to color transmission, PTV started as a B/W (black and white) version. The staff showed great determination to make it a success.
💡 Why this matters: The delayed arrival of television in Pakistan was not due to lack of funds but a shortage of trained technical personnel, highlighting a key infrastructure challenge.
The Excitement
Watching moving images at home was a treat. Only the rich could initially afford a TV set, which became a status symbol. Relatives and neighbors would gather before the broadcast. Women finished cooking early, and students did homework before the TV played its signature tune and showed its insignia. The first sight of the announcer was cheered. These moments remain unforgettable for those who witnessed them.
Timing
In the early days, TV broadcast was limited to five hours, from 6 pm to 11 pm, with one weekly holiday on Monday. People sat from the signature tune, and hardly anyone moved until the national anthem marked the end of transmission. Few had TV sets, making it a privilege to possess one.
Live Broadcast
The most prominent feature of PTV’s early years was live transmission because it lacked recording facilities. Not only news, but talks, plays, and music were also broadcast in real time. It was a unique experience for directors, producers, performers, and technical staff. Kanwal Naseer and Tariq Aziz would read news, rushing from Radio Pakistan to PTV’s new building across the road.
PTV in 1965 War
The September 1965 war with India was a testing time. PTV Lahore’s OB (Outside Broadcast) teams went to the borders and captured incredible images of warring action. People saw Pakistan Army’s jawans invading Indian posts and capturing enemy land. With Madam Noor Jahan’s spirited national songs in the backdrop, PTV’s showings fueled national passion for defense.
1973 National Microwave Network
A major breakthrough in 1973 connected all TV stations in the country by a microwave network, enabling live telecast of different programs. This saved PTV time and money.
Lahore Islamic Summit 1974
PTV managed extensive live coverage of various events of the Lahore Islamic Summit 1974, shown on the national hook-up. The Karachi and Rawalpindi stations (functioning since 1967) were linked. PTV made the whole nation feel involved in the summit events — from the Shalimar Gardens civic reception to prayers at Badshahi Mosque, from the public meeting at Qaddafi Stadium (addressed by Libya’s President Col. Qaddafi) to business meetings at the Punjab Assembly floor.
Coloured Broadcast
In the mid-1970s, talks began about doing away with B/W transmission. One reason was that globally, TV transmission was becoming colored, and companies stopped making parts for B/W equipment. Regular color transmission started from February 18, 1982.
More Developments
- 1987: Federal TV Centre at Islamabad commissioned.
- 1992: Second TV channel for education commissioned.
- 1996: Local area transmission from 4 stations started and extended to 3 more stations.
- 1998: Transmission of PTV World programmes started.
- 1998: Up to 6 production centres (Lahore, Karachi, Quetta, Peshawar, Islamabad-I & Islamabad-II). 35 rebroadcast stations for PTV-1; 16 rebroadcast stations for PTV-2.
- PTV-1: Area covered: 38%, population covered: 86.48%
- PTV-2: Area covered: 24.19%, population covered: 55.83%
Dramas – the source of strength to PTV
PTV excelled in broadcasting various programs, but its dramas earned it extraordinary glory. Notable dramas include:
- Parchhaian
- Aik muhabbat sua afsanay
- Shama
- Waris
- Alpha Bravo Charlie
- Tanhayian
- Alif noon
- Sona chandi
- Khuda ki basti
- Dhoop kinaray
⭐ Key Takeaways
The establishment of PTV in 1964 marked a pivotal moment in Pakistan’s media history, overcoming a shortage of technical staff to launch from Lahore. Early broadcasts were limited to five hours daily with live transmission due to no recording facilities. PTV played a heroic role during the 1965 war by capturing border action. The 1973 microwave network revolutionized national connectivity, and the 1974 Lahore Islamic Summit coverage showcased PTV’s organizational capability. Color transmission began in 1982, and PTV dramas like Waris, Dhoop Kinaray, and Alpha Bravo Charlie became cultural landmarks. By 1998, PTV-1 covered 86.48% of the population.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- On what date and in which city was Pakistan’s first TV station established?
- What was the most prominent feature of PTV’s early broadcasts, and why?
- What major breakthrough occurred in 1973 that connected all TV stations in Pakistan?
- From what date did regular color transmission begin on PTV?
- Name at least three famous PTV dramas mentioned in the lecture.
📘 Lecture 25 — Broadcasting Laws
📖 Overview: This lecture examines the legal framework governing mass communication, particularly broadcasting, in Pakistan. It explains why media cannot be left completely free and must operate under a system of checks and balances, tracing the historical development of press and broadcasting laws from the 19th century to the present day, with special focus on the Constitution of 1973 and the establishment of PEMRA.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the rationale for media regulation, historical press and broadcasting laws in the subcontinent including the Registration of Books and Newspaper Act 1867 and various emergency acts, Article 19 of the Constitution of 1973 guaranteeing freedom of speech with reasonable restrictions, the Press Council of Pakistan as a regulatory body, the Freedom of Information Ordinance 2002, and the comprehensive establishment and mandate of the Pakistan Electronic Media Regulatory Authority (PEMRA) including its licensing categories and pre-conditions for broadcasters.
📝 Lecture Summary
Laws
The lecture begins by establishing that mass communication cannot be granted absolute freedom, as this would result in societal distortion rather than welfare. The freedom of expression, while potentially working against governments, was recognized by colonial powers as needing regulation. Therefore, all media taking messages to masses were brought under a system of checks and balances to prevent exploitation that could harm society. In the early days of mass communication, when only print media existed, laws required obtaining a license from a suitable authority to start any media venture, and media outlets had to regularly appear before this authority if complaints of misuse arose.
💡 Why this matters: Understanding the balance between freedom and regulation is fundamental to comprehending all media laws that follow.
🔑 Definition — License: A formal permission obtained from a regulatory authority to operate a media venture, subject to ongoing compliance and oversight.
Laws in the 19th century
The press in the subcontinent came under heavy laws, sometimes so strict that ordinary communication was difficult to deliver. The subcontinent experienced the worst kind of press restrictions in the name of press laws. Since electronic media and broadcast on radio and TV are improved forms of mass communication, even stricter laws were legislated to regulate these new approaches. However, not all laws are draconian in nature; many are useful in regulating mass communication business. Problems occur in implementation and interpretation of certain laws, which often open debates on freedom of expression through mass media.
Key historical laws mentioned include:
- The Registration of Books and Newspaper Act, 1867
- The Press (Emergency Power) Act, 1931
- The States (Protection Against Disaffection) Act, 1922
- The Foreign Relations Act, 1932
- The Criminal Law Amendment Act, 1932
- The States Protection Act, 1934
- The Post Office Act, 1898
- The Official Secret Act
- The Press and Publication Act of 1963
Constitution of 1973
Article 19 of the Constitution of 1973 reads as follows: "Every citizen shall have the right of freedom of speech and expression, and there shall be freedom of the press, subject to any reasonable restrictions imposed by law in the interest of the glory of Islam or the integrity, security, or defense of Pakistan or any part thereof, friendly relations with foreign states, public order, decency or morality or in relation to the contempt of court, defamation or incitement to an office."
🔑 Definition — Article 19: The constitutional provision guaranteeing freedom of speech and press to every citizen, subject to reasonable restrictions for national security, Islamic values, public order, decency, and morality.
Press Council of Pakistan
The law states that the Code dealing with issues such as morality, plagiarism, fairness, accuracy, privacy, sensationalism, confidentiality, and privilege will allow journalists to operate "in accordance with the canons of decency, principles of professional conduct and precepts of freedom and responsibility, to serve the public interest by ensuring an unobstructed flow of news and views to the people envisaging that honesty, accuracy, objectivity and fairness shall be the guidelines for the press while serving the public interest."
The Council will be an independent corporate entity with its own staff, secretariat, and budget, financed through an annual governmental grant-in-aid, other grants and donations, and such fees as it may levy from registered newspapers and news agencies. This council is considered to be a euphemistic connotation of censorship.
🔑 Definition — Press Council of Pakistan: An independent regulatory body for print media, financed by government grants and levies on registered newspapers, tasked with ensuring professional conduct and ethical standards in journalism.
Freedom of Information Ordinance 2002
The Freedom of Information Ordinance introduced in 2002 contains some positive features acknowledging citizens' right to know. However, the 21st day time frame for the release of information and inclusion of courts and tribunals among those requiring disclosure mars its true spirit. Large amounts of information are not subject to disclosure under the ordinance, largely undermining the public's right to know. Instead of applying to all records held by public bodies, the ordinance provides a restrictive list of public records subject to disclosure.
🔑 Definition — Freedom of Information Ordinance 2002: A law acknowledging citizens' right to access information, but criticized for its restrictive 21-day time frame and limited scope of records subject to disclosure.
PEMRA
By the late 1990s, Pakistan's establishment realized it needed to counter the cultural threat from Hindi channels available through satellite receivers by encouraging private TV networks, as the state-owned PTV was failing to attract audiences wanting more openness in entertainment and current affairs. This led to the promulgation of an ordinance in 1997 to set up a regulator for electronic media. The Federal Cabinet in January 2002 formally approved an ordinance to create an autonomous regulatory authority for independent electronic media. Initiating in April 2000 as RAMBO (Regulatory Authority for Media Broadcast Organizations), it was later renamed PEMRA (Pakistan Electronic Media Regulatory Authority). PEMRA was established on March 1st, 2002 through an ordinance to induct and facilitate the private sector into electronic media.
PEMRA has been made responsible for formulating technical standards and scrutinizing technical feasibility for broadcasting services including radio, television, satellite broadcasting, cable television, Multi-channel Multi-point Distribution Service (MMDS) and Local Multi-point Distribution Service (LMDS).
According to the PEMRA Ordinance 2002, the Authority has been mandated to:
- Improve the standards of information, education and entertainment.
- Enlarge the choice available to the people of Pakistan in the media.
- Facilitate the devolution of responsibility and power to the grassroots by improving the access of the people to mass media at the local and community level.
- Ensure accountability, transparency and good governance by optimizing the free flow of information.
PEMRA has been formed to provide project management guidelines and action plans to the private sector interested in establishing radio, television and cable TV stations.
The Authority has been empowered to issue licenses for broadcast and CTV stations in the following categories:
- International scale stations
- National scale stations
- Provincial scale stations
- Local Area or Community based stations
- Specific and specialized subject stations
- Cable television network stations
The law lays down stringent and subjective pre-conditions for eligibility of a license. A broadcaster or CTV operator issued a license must guarantee:
- Respect the sovereignty, security and integrity of Pakistan.
- Respect the national, cultural, social and religious values and the principles of public policy as enshrined in the Constitution.
- Ensure that programs and advertisements do not encourage violence, terrorism, racial, ethnic or religious discrimination, sectarianism, extremism, militancy or hatred, or contain pornography or other material offensive to commonly accepted standards of decency.
The ordinance provided for the appointment, by the president, of a chairman who had to be a retired judge of the Supreme Court and six members, including information and communication secretaries and 4 representatives of the public with an acknowledged record of work in radio, television, print media and/or public service.
The Electronic Media Regulatory Authority Ordinance is also considered arbitrary and in violation of international standards for free flow of information, retaining the infamous system of licensing without defining eligibility in unambiguous terms. The obligation imposed on private television channels to telecast programs mandated by the authority appears to be a device to commission them for official propaganda. The ordinance is also silent on the decades-old demand for freeing Pakistan Broadcasting Corporation and Pakistan Television Corporation from official control.
The then government could not institute the regulatory authority initially. After the military coup of 1999, General Musharraf took over as Chief Executive and was favorably disposed to allowing private TV channels, as advisors like Javed Jabbar were ardent supporters of freeing the media.
PEMRA, initially, was placed under the direct control of the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, raising concerns whether it would function as a neutral regulator or become another means for the Ministry to safeguard state-owned PTV and PBC. However, later, the authority in terms of administrative hierarchy was placed under the Establishment Division. PTV and PBC continue to be outside the regulatory jurisdiction of PEMRA.
PEMRA has been mandated to:
- Improve the standards of information, education and entertainment.
- Enlarge the choice available to the people of Pakistan in the media for news, current affairs, religious knowledge, art, culture, technology, science, economic development, social sector concerns, music, sports, drama and other subjects of public and national interest.
The PEMRA Ordinance 2002 allows the establishment of an umbrella body that will issue licenses to broadcasters labeled as broadcast media operators. The move is meant to bring transparency and an invisible system of accountability through media available at local community, provincial, national, and international levels. This spells competition not only for the three state-controlled channels in the country but also for those from across the border that beam programs into Pakistan.
🔑 Definition — PEMRA (Pakistan Electronic Media Regulatory Authority): The autonomous regulatory authority established on March 1, 2002 to regulate all electronic media in Pakistan, including radio, television, satellite broadcasting, and cable television, by issuing licenses and setting technical and content standards.
📐 Formula: PEMRA licensing categories → International → National → Provincial → Local/Community → Specialized Subject → Cable TV Networks
⭐ Key Takeaways
The lecture establishes that media regulation exists to balance freedom of expression with societal welfare, preventing exploitation while allowing information flow. Article 19 of Pakistan's Constitution provides the fundamental framework for this balance, granting freedom of speech and press subject to reasonable restrictions for Islam, national security, public order, and morality. PEMRA, established in 2002 after evolving from RAMBO, is the key regulatory body for electronic media, issuing licenses across six categories from international to community level. The historical development of media laws from the 1867 Registration Act to the 2002 PEMRA ordinance shows a continuous tension between government control and media freedom. Students must remember that while PEMRA aims to improve standards and enlarge media choice, it has been criticized for retaining censorship elements, keeping PTV and PBC outside its jurisdiction, and lacking clear eligibility definitions for licenses.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the six categories of licenses that PEMRA is empowered to issue for broadcast and cable TV stations?
- According to Article 19 of the Constitution of 1973, what are the specific grounds on which reasonable restrictions can be imposed on freedom of speech and press?
- What was the original name of the regulatory authority before it was renamed PEMRA, and when was it established?
- What three specific guarantees must a broadcaster or CTV operator provide when applying for a license under the PEMRA Ordinance?
- Why was the Freedom of Information Ordinance 2002 criticized for undermining the public's right to know, despite being a positive step?
📘 Lecture 26 — Replicas of Radio Broadcast
📖 Overview: This lecture examines how early television broadcasting in Pakistan was essentially a visual replica of radio broadcasting. It explores how the lack of trained television staff, equipment, and production techniques led to TV programs—from news reading to dramas and children's shows—being direct copies of their radio counterparts, with only the added element of visibility.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the staffing challenges when TV began in Pakistan in 1964, the borrowing of radio production patterns for news reading, discussion/talk shows, dramas, musical evenings, and children's programs. It highlights how radio station staff were hired to work in TV, bringing radio techniques—including microphone handling, dialogue delivery, and program formats—directly into the visual medium, creating an imitation of radio broadcast on screen.
📝 Lecture Summary
The TV seemed an advanced visual-form of radio broadcast
In its early days, television in almost all countries appeared as an advanced visual form of radio broadcast. In the US, TV programs looked similar to radio programs with the only difference being that viewers could see the talent and the surroundings.
In Pakistan, radio broadcast had matured with popular programs like radio dramas, talk shows, news, and musical programs. The production setup was well-established, and radio station workers were familiar with the specific techniques of broadcasting.
With TV broadcast starting in November 1964 from Lahore, some broadcasting patterns developed at the radio station were borrowed almost identically. Interestingly, the building where the TV station was first housed was across the road from the Lahore radio station building. Later, when the TV station building was ready, it was again adjacent to the radio station building. This proximity meant that many radio staff members were engaged in TV broadcast, moving between stations multiple times a day, giving TV broadcast a "color" of radio broadcast.
The Staff
Hardly trained staff was available to run a TV station, especially on the programming side. On the technical or ENG side—cameramen, lighting directors, set designers—were available. But to manage programs, TV had to rely on people trained in radio broadcast.
Over time, staff required to operate a TV broadcasting house from all aspects have been trained at the academy set up in the early seventies in Islamabad. This academy also provides training to in-service staff on new experimentation in TV production. Foreign qualified and locally experienced people manage matters at the academy.
💡 Why this matters: The reliance on radio-trained staff meant that the fundamental approach to television programming was shaped by radio thinking, leading to programs that looked like "radio with pictures" rather than truly visual productions.
News Reading
Since airing news was the foremost thing in early TV broadcast, people trained in reading news for the visual medium were not available. Services of radio newscasters were hired. They would rush from the radio station building to the TV station studio, get their makeup done—a very different experience—and read news in almost the radio style.
In the early days of TV, there was hardly any footage of news-related events available. The news reading was a simple replica of radio news with the only difference being that viewers could see the broadcaster—and discuss their face and gestures during reading, making it difficult for viewers to maintain the rapt attention they gave to radio news.
🔑 Definition — Radio style news reading: News delivery that focuses solely on voice and diction without visual elements such as footage, graphics, or teleprompter-based eye contact, as was common in radio broadcast.
Discussion / Talk Shows
The visualizing of a talk show or discussion program was not different from what radio listeners were familiar with. An anchor person was there to guide and facilitate participants, who sat across a table. Since microphones were not available as they are today, one microphone would move from one speaker to another to keep the voice intact for recording.
If another speaker chipped in while the microphone was elsewhere, viewers could see them making observations but could not get the words uttered. Today, one can hear even minute remarks made by a speaker during a discussion, giving more scope to understand what is happening and what others are thinking when a speaker is talking.
Programming
The replica problem was not limited to current affairs shows; the issue was the same with the programming side of TV broadcast.
Dramas
If you listen to the sound-track of an early TV drama, you may feel like listening to a radio drama. The sequence of the play, the dialogue delivery, the diction, and the speech treatment—all had come from radio plays. Mostly, radio drama producers/directors had gotten jobs with TV because no trained people were available who knew electronic media techniques and the use of devices like microphones, amplifiers, consoles, and recording panels.
Since radio drama producers were "diehard in their trade," it was a big ask for them to produce a TV drama as we know it today. Even the musical effects during a drama would fully match those given in a radio drama.
Musical Evenings
Music programs have always been a source of entertainment in electronic media. Radio had brought music to every household through various programs—from a single singer at a studio to music concerts. When it came to TV broadcast, the style of presentation remained almost an imitation of radio broadcast.
The visual and non-visual mixed up badly in early TV broadcast. The only difference was that viewers were watching what would have been happening at a radio station but had remained out of sight because the visual medium was not available.
Children's Show
Among programs that appeared as a ditto copy of a radio program was the children's weekly show. Almost the same sitting arrangement—one uncle or aunt talking to kids, making them say poems, jokes, or answer questions by coming to the mike. By seeing such a program, a radio listener would think, "Well, this was how a radio children's program would have been recorded."
The same had been the case with programs meant for women, farmers, forces, and others. In most cases, the program was being conducted by the person doing almost the same program on radio.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical point from this lecture is that early Pakistani television was fundamentally a visual copy of radio, because trained television personnel did not exist and radio professionals were hired to fill all program-related roles. This meant that news reading, talk shows, dramas, musical evenings, and children's programs all followed radio formats—with the only addition being the visibility of the talent. The physical proximity of radio and TV stations in Lahore (first across the road, then adjacent) facilitated this transfer of staff and techniques. While technical staff like cameramen and lighting directors were available, programming expertise came entirely from radio, leading to programs that were reproductions rather than original creations for the visual medium. The training academy set up in Islamabad in the early 1970s eventually helped build a dedicated television workforce.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
-
Why did early Pakistani TV programs resemble radio broadcasts so closely?
-
What was the specific problem with news reading in early TV, and how did radio newscasters struggle with the transition?
-
How did the physical location of the Lahore TV station contribute to the "replica" phenomenon?
-
What was the microphone problem in early TV talk shows, and how did it affect viewer understanding?
-
Name any three types of programs that were direct copies of radio programs, and explain what made them identical.
📘 Lecture 27 — New Script Writing and Direction Techniques
📖 Overview: This lecture examines the fundamental shift from radio-based script writing and direction techniques to those required for television, a visual medium. It explains how TV forced new approaches to news, drama, commentary, and talk shows, while also transforming the role of the director. Understanding these differences is critical for effective broadcast communication.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by establishing the historical context of TV's evolution from radio, then systematically compares script writing for TV vs. radio across multiple formats: TV Script basics, News Script, Drama Script, Running Commentary, and Talk Shows. It concludes with a detailed discussion of the changed role of Direction in television, focusing on visual elements like lighting, color, and body language rather than purely audio concerns.
📝 Lecture Summary
New Script Writing and Direction Techniques
Though gradually, TV programs started showing their own identity. As criticism intensified that TV was strictly following radio broadcast, TV managers thought seriously to transform the radio broadcast to a TV broadcast. It was a heroic effort by some TV producers to show imagination with very little support in equipment, finances, and expertise, and take TV broadcast to a more meaningful level quickly. Since TV is a visual medium, it is more difficult to handle. The techniques applied in radio broadcast, particularly in writing script and directing different programs, are totally different for a TV broadcast.
TV Script
Script is always linked with the medium through which a message has to be carried. For print medium, a script gives full details of an action so a reader understands what the script writer intends. On radio, the demand of the script is different; since a listener is not seeing a performer or surroundings, they are made to understand with the help of script.
For TV, there is hardly a need to put in words things which viewers can see. For example, a chair in a room: the viewer knows 'this' means chair. But for a radio script, you must say why this 'chair' is put in this room, as listeners need to know what 'this' means.
In the early days of TV broadcast, most script writers had come from radio, leading to problems in description of feelings and objects. On TV you can show a person feeling a headache, but on radio you must mention the same in words. You need to say "what a beautiful red curtains these are" for a radio play. On TV you may simply say "what a beautiful curtain these are"—the viewers know the color by seeing them.
News Script
Very soon it was realized that the news script for radio would no longer serve the purpose of news casting on television. In typical TV news, the news reader may assume silence for more than 10 seconds while footage runs to explain the event. On radio, a silence of more than three seconds may cause panic at the central control room.
Although an attempt is made to make news reading as objective as possible and sans sentiments, in practice it is difficult to execute. Now, on TV newsreel broadcasters are allowed to pass a light smile to support certain news like victory of country's cricket team against arch rival. Or cutting down petrol prices or news of rain after a long summer spell may also accompany some facial expression.
Drama Script
More than any other area of TV broadcast, it is drama script which is drastically different from the one meant for radio. There is always some scene, objects, or action which do not need a verbal expression to explain them, making matters rather easy for the script writer. Although it may cause some problems as well, for there may be something—a picture, wall-hanging, or telephone—which the writer would not suggest, but due to insistence of the set designer, these props have to be put there. Sometimes this leads to disputes between the playwright and other staff engaged in making TV drama.
Running Commentary
The area generally ignored while finding points of difference for a talk on radio and TV is the running commentary on games like hockey and cricket. For radio, the commentator has to give the fullest description of the game—and continue to speak even when the game is stopped for some reason. On TV it is altogether different. For the most thrilling event in a game, which people are seeing themselves, a commentator is required to utter very particular remarks which he thinks may not be occurring to common viewers. There is no need to get louder with the pacing up of the action, and absolutely no need to pass remarks which in any manner are contrary to what most people can see on the screen. For instance, there is no room to say that it was a case of clear LBW (Leg Before Wicket), when one can see there was much doubt in giving an LBW decision.
Gestures replace words in Talk Shows
Talk shows are common for both broadcasts—radio as well as TV. But the script which the two talents would follow is different. On radio, if the anchorperson wants someone to speak, they would ask the speaker to say, reply, or comment. On a similar talk show on TV, the anchorperson may be turning their face to a speaker and with the gesture of hands may urge the speaker to say something. There are many other things which a TV compere doesn't need to explain, but a radio talent would need to explain those in words so listeners may know what is in the surrounding, especially if a talk show is arranged outside the studio.
Direction
A sea change has been observed in the area of direction with the arrival of TV broadcast. A director at a radio drama studio is more concerned about the speech, distance of a performer from the mikes, and the sound effects given at a very appropriate moment for conveying the total impact of the scene.
At a TV broadcast it is much different. A director is more concerned about the entry of a performer, their facial expression, body language, and movement of hands and head as the performer delivers dialogue. The sound effects are required, but more than the sound effects, the director is more anxious about the lighting arrangement—for a gloomy scene or to show cheerfulness, different lighting effects are required. Any unbalanced lighting may spoil the whole scene.
The color scheme of the set and contrast ratio of light, which may highlight the color arrangement, is also very much in the view of the director who has to notice whether the light-color combination is in keeping with the demand of the scene and the story, or if it negates it. To control shadows of the performers acting under artificial lights at a studio is a hell of a lot of a problem, a director has to fight again and again.
💡 Why this matters: The lecture concludes by returning to a core question—whether it is easy or difficult to communicate in a visual medium—showing that TV direction is far more complex than radio due to the sheer number of visual elements that must be simultaneously controlled.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical transformation from radio to TV is that TV's visual nature reduces the need for verbal description of objects and actions but greatly increases the complexity of production. In news, TV allows for silence during footage and permits facial expressions that radio could never convey. For drama, the visual medium eases the script writer's burden but can create conflicts with set designers over props. In commentary and talk shows, TV relies on gestures and visual cues that must be verbalized for radio audiences. Finally, the director's role shifts from focusing on audio clarity and sound effects to managing lighting, color schemes, body language, and shadow control, making TV direction a significantly more demanding craft.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- Why was there a problem in the description of feelings and objects in early TV scripts, and what specific example illustrates this difference between radio and TV?
- How long can a TV news reader remain silent while footage runs, and why is this impossible for a radio broadcaster?
- What is the key difference in how a commentator should behave during a thrilling moment in a game on TV versus on radio?
- How does a TV talk show anchor urge a speaker to comment, and how would this differ for a radio anchor?
- What are the three main visual elements a TV director must manage that a radio director does not need to worry about?