📘 Lecture 26 — The Writing Styles: Descriptive and Persuasive Writings
📖 Overview: This lecture explores two fundamental writing styles essential for journalistic and academic work: descriptive writing, which paints vivid pictures through sensory details, and persuasive writing, which aims to convince an audience of a particular viewpoint. Mastering these styles enables writers to engage readers emotionally and logically, making their work more impactful and memorable.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with descriptive writing, defining it, providing examples, and outlining its key characteristics including sensory details, figurative language, precise language, and organization. It then covers the dos and don’ts of description, focusing on dominant impression, “show, don’t tell,” observation, using all five senses, and strong verbs. The second half shifts to persuasive writing, explaining persuasion, creating a thesis through topic selection and position, supporting the thesis with premises and rhetorical tactics (logos, ethos, pathos), understanding the audience, addressing alternative perspectives, traditional structure, common techniques, visual appeals, and four rhetorical devices.
📝 Lecture Summary
DESCRIPTIVE WRITING
Descriptive writing is the act or art of writing to describe places, people, objects, sounds, tastes, smells, or anything that can be captured in words. A descriptive writer is like a painter, using colourful adjectives and adverbs to render description so precisely that the reader sees, hears, smells, tastes, or touches the object exactly as the writer intends. The writer does not tell the reader that the flower is beautiful; they show the flower is beautiful, making the reader feel part of the writer's experience.
A good example of descriptive writing in modern literature is the Hobbit series by J. R. R. Tolkien. For instance, instead of saying, “He bit into the apple and it tasted good,” descriptive writing would convey: “He slowly closed his teeth on the ripe, succulent, ruby colour apple. The crunch of his teeth piercing the apple’s skin was deafening and the sweet juices of the apple ran down his chin. The taste of the meat was as sweet as candy and he felt euphoric.”
Descriptive writing is used in all modes of writing (Expository, Narrative, and Persuasive) to create a vivid and lasting impression. Examples include stories, poems, essays, and reports.
Characteristics of Good Descriptive Writing
-
Includes many vivid sensory details that paint a picture and appeal to all of the reader's senses of sight, hearing, touch, smell, and taste when appropriate. It may also paint pictures of the feelings the person, place, or thing invokes in the writer.
-
Often makes use of figurative language such as analogies, similes, and metaphors to help paint the picture in the reader's mind.
-
Uses precise language. General adjectives, nouns, and passive verbs do not have a place in good descriptive writing. Use specific adjectives and nouns and strong action verbs to give life to the picture.
-
Is organized. Some ways to organize descriptive writing include chronological (time), spatial (location), and order of importance. When describing a person, you might begin with a physical description, followed by how that person thinks, feels, and acts.
DOS’ AND DON’TS OF DESCRIPTION
Dominant Impression
The key element in writing a memorable description is the point of view of the writer. The dominant impression is the way the writer feels about the object of the description. For instance, a writer may regard a place as hospitable and inviting, or as cold and forbidding. In conveying the chosen dominant impression, the writer must both select details carefully and present them with the impression in mind. All good descriptions are crafted with steady attention to the dominant impression.
"Show, Don’t Tell"
This is the fundamental principle of descriptive writing. ‘Telling’ the reader about something comes off as flat, vague, and not particularly memorable; ‘showing’ the reader the object, describing it in such a way as to paint it in words and bring it to life, renders the object far more vivid, visible, and active.
Telling is summarizing. For example: "It was a nice room, a warm room. It was a happy place to be." The reader cannot see or feel the room.
Showing presents details. For example: “Sunlight pours through the window, pooling on the down comforter which lies across the bed. A block of light also angles across the wall opposite the bed, highlighting the pale orange color of the room. A thick red carpet sprawls over the floor, a corner of it lit too by a sunbeam; the room’s windows admit the sun along two walls, and tiny dust motes hover in the bright streaks which glaze the room.” Here the writer never says "warm" but demonstrates the quality through details.
Observation
It isn’t possible to create a unique description without first taking time to observe. The writer seeks not only the general details but the specific details which make the object unique. For example, instead of just noting an apple is red and round, observe: “The apple has two leaves still attached to the stem; it doesn’t stand straight when resting on a tabletop, on its left side a streak of yellow shines underneath the red, a small bruise hangs just below the apple’s crown on its back side.”
Using All Five Senses
The best descriptive writing evokes objects through more than just sight. The more a writer can capture an object through senses such as sound, smell, touch, and even taste, the more vivid and unique the description becomes.
Strong Verbs
Good descriptive writing employs the use of strong, specific verbs, avoiding the verb ‘to be’. For example, "The sunlight was on the propane tank" becomes "The sunlight stretched over the propane tank." The more unexpected the verb, the more specific and memorable a sentence will be.
- Example: "We had a really nice dinner" becomes "We enjoyed a tasty meal."
- Example: "The street was empty and full of shadows" becomes "The street lay empty, full of shadows."
- Example: "The children had a great time at the circus" becomes "The children shared a thrilling night at the circus."
Place Description
The goal is to be able to offer the reader a portrait of the object that evokes the dominant impression the writer wishes to create. Writers are usually aiming not only to render a clear portrait but also to evoke a feeling.
Descriptions of People
As with place, descriptions of people aim to portray basic features and personality. This is done through the details the writer chooses to focus on, rather than through telling. The writer never says "he was quite uptight" but attempts to array details to convey this impression.
A Master at Work
George Orwell's “Shooting an Elephant” demonstrates masterful description, drawing on the sense of touch, hearing, and sight: “When I pulled the trigger I did not hear the bang or feel the kick—one never does when a shot goes home—but I heard the devilish roar of glee that went up from the crowd. In that instant, in too short a time, one would have thought, even for the bullet to get there, a mysterious, terrible change had come over the elephant. He neither stirred nor fell, but every line of his body had altered. He looked suddenly stricken, shrunken, immensely old, as though the frightful impact of the bullet had paralyzed him without knocking him down. At last, after what seemed a long time—it might have been five seconds, I dare say—he sagged flabbily to his knees. His mouth slobbered ....”
PERSUASIVE WRITING
WHAT IS PERSUASION?
The art of persuasion is the art of finding the best available means of moving a specific audience in a specific situation to a specific decision. Persuasive writing analyzes the various sides of an issue while arguing a viewpoint.
CREATING A THESIS
The foundation of a persuasive paper is the thesis (often called a claim). To create an effective thesis, you must select an appropriate topic and decide on your position.
SELECT A TOPIC
Persuasive writing addresses topics that are controversial or stimulate discussion. To select a topic, consider what issues you feel strongly about and what topic you would like to learn more about. Once selected, write down everything you know, then research the issue thoroughly to become an expert and understand all sides.
DECIDE ON A POSITION
The position you decide upon becomes your thesis statement or claim. This claim will set limits on your topic and allude to the organization of your paper. Be sure your thesis is arguable. Avoid arguing about:
- Indisputable facts (e.g., heart disease is deadly)
- Preferences (e.g., some people don't like to scuba dive)
- Religion and other deep-rooted beliefs (these are beyond empirical analysis)
SUPPORTING YOUR THESIS
After deciding on a claim, identify premises to support the thesis. These premises will be stated in your thesis statement in the order they will be addressed. Use the persuasive techniques of logos, ethos, and pathos.
DEVELOP PREMISES
Premises are the evidence that supports your thesis and make up the bulk of your paper. For example, if arguing that the US should not trade with countries that commit human rights violations, premises might be: (1) Trading philosophically encourages further violations. (2) US industries would exploit people. (3) The violating country will be harmed by lack of trade and stop exploiting workers.
THE TACTICS OF RHETORIC
- Logos: Appeal to reason by using facts, statistics, research, and logical arguments. This is the most convincing technique in academic writing.
- Ethos: Appeal to the credibility or character of the author or quoted people. Use credible sources and prove your own credibility with good academic writing and tone.
- Pathos: Appeal to emotion, values, and beliefs. Include personal stories and use appropriate word choice to emphasize emotion. In academic writing, this technique should be used with care.
Pathos Principle 1: Know your Audience.
- They are concerned about local issues and local people (make local arguments).
- They make decisions with both their minds and hearts (appeal to both).
- They feel financially pressured (show how programs save or bring money).
Pathos Principle 2: Know what moves your Audience.
- Ask what they commonly want and what your program’s results are.
- Give information short and simple, with facts and figures that prove help.
Ethos Principle 1: Write like a Professional.
- To be trusted, your readers must believe you are competent. Ensure data, names, spelling, and grammar are correct.
Ethos Principle 2: Write like a Person.
- Never talk down to or over the heads of your audience. Tell your story simply, aiming for a 10th-grade level. Use simple familiar words, avoid jargon and acronyms, use short simple sentences, and show rather than tell.
Logos Principle 1: Make your argument clear.
- Answer the basic questions (5W’s & 1H). State activities and results plainly, choose clear words, a common vocabulary, active verbs, and concrete nouns, adjectives, and adverbs.
Logos Principle 2: Organize your argument.
- An organized argument guides an audience through your reasoning process, offers a clear explanation of each argued point, and demonstrates the credibility of the writer.
UNDERSTANDING YOUR AUDIENCE
You must understand your audience to support your thesis in a manner convincing to them. Ask:
- What is the audience’s knowledge level?
- What is their attitude towards the topic?
- What are their values and beliefs?
These questions help establish a professional and reasonable tone. Assume your audience is intelligent—never sound condescending—but thoroughly explain concepts.
LOOK AT ALTERNATIVE PERSPECTIVES
Addressing alternative perspectives is essential. This can be done just after the introduction, just before the conclusion, or throughout the paper. Alternative perspectives should be treated fairly—think about what others believe and why. From there, you can either refute (show why your view is stronger) or concede (agree and acknowledge complexity), then follow with a strong point. Always build on common ground.
TIPS
- Use third person rather than first or second person.
- Use examples and vivid descriptions rather than telling your reader what to feel.
- Avoid absolutes and hasty generalizations such as always, never, or all people.
- Use evidence that is recent, relevant, and impartial.
- Follow basic essay format with introduction, body paragraphs, and conclusion.
- Include proper in-text citations and a Works Cited/Bibliography/References page.
TRADITIONAL STRUCTURE IN PERSUASIVE WRITING
The traditional parts that strengthen an argument include:
- Exordium (introduction)
- Narration (background statement of facts)
- Partition (forecast of topics)
- Conformation (body of the text)
- Refutation (discussion of alternatives)
- Peroration (conclusion; often helpful to tie back to the introduction)
COMMON TECHNIQUES
- Emphasizing benefits while ignoring drawbacks
- Writing in active voice rather than passive voice
- Writing in short sentences and shorter words
- Creating a list of 'For and Against' points
- Capturing the reader's interest from the first sentence
- Using connectives e.g., Furthermore, Moreover, Therefore
- Making opposing facts seem like problems
- Using a lively anecdote
- Asking rhetorical questions
- Using "in fact" and "indeed" to strengthen viewpoint
- Using "however" to offer a contrasting viewpoint
- Ending with a positive and interesting statement
Visual Appeals
Visual appeals can add to the effectiveness of the written word. Complementing visuals can help strengthen arguments and improve visual rhetoric by making the page more appealing and accessible.
FOUR RHETORICAL DEVICES
-
PARALLEL STRUCTURE: Using similar grammatical structures for effect.
- Example: Churchill’s speech: “We shall not flag or fail. We shall go on to the end. We shall fight in France. We shall fight on the seas and oceans...”
-
TRIADS: Grouping ideas in threes for impact.
- Example: Martin Luther King’s “I Have a Dream” speech: “...we will be able to speed up that day when all of God’s children, black men and white men, Jews and Gentiles, Protestants and Catholics, will be able to join hands...”
-
ANTITHESIS: Juxtaposing contrasting ideas for emphasis.
- Example: President Kennedy’s Inaugural Address: “Ask not what your country can do for you; ask what you can do for your country.”
- State motto: Live Free or Die.
-
RHETORICAL QUESTIONS: Questions asked to make a point, not to get an answer.
- Example: Patrick Henry’s speech: “Is life so dear, or peace so sweet, as to be purchased at the price of chains and slavery? Forbid it, Almighty God! I know not what course others may take, but as for me, give me liberty, or give me death!”
⭐ Key Takeaways
This lecture equips you with two distinct but complementary writing styles. For descriptive writing, always remember the cardinal rule: show, don’t tell—use vivid sensory details, strong verbs, and precise language to paint a picture for your reader, focusing on a dominant impression. For persuasive writing, the foundation is a clear, arguable thesis supported by logical premises and the three rhetorical appeals of logos (reason), ethos (credibility), and pathos (emotion). Crucially, a successful persuasive argument requires understanding your audience and fairly addressing alternative perspectives, while employing devices like parallel structure, triads, antithesis, and rhetorical questions for added impact. Finally, for journalistic writing, remember that descriptive elements can powerfully enhance persuasive pieces, and visual appeals can strengthen your written argument.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What is the fundamental difference between "showing" and "telling" in descriptive writing, and why is "showing" more effective?
- List and explain the four key characteristics of good descriptive writing as outlined in the lecture.
- What are the three tactics of rhetoric (logos, ethos, pathos), and which one is considered the most convincing technique in academic writing?
- What is the purpose of addressing alternative perspectives in persuasive writing, and what are the two possible ways to handle them?
- Name all four rhetorical devices discussed in the lecture and provide a brief example for each.
📘 Lecture 27 — Research Writing and Documenting Sources
📖 Overview: This lecture outlines the systematic steps of research writing, from topic selection to final proofreading. It explains why global citation formats like APA and MLA are essential for academic credibility, and provides detailed instructions on how to properly cite sources using both styles, including reference pages and parenthetical citations.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the 11-step research writing process, the rationale for using global citation formats (APA, MLA), and the two main components of APA style (reference page and parenthetical citations). It then provides the same detailed treatment for MLA style, including works cited pages and parenthetical citations, with numerous examples of how to handle various source types and special citation situations.
📝 Lecture Summary
Research Writing Steps
Research writing follows a systematic 11-step process. First, select a topic and then frame a central research question with a set of sub-questions. Next, survey the topic broadly and locate materials for your research. You should then re-evaluate your topic and research strategy based on what you find. After gathering sources, evaluate your sources for credibility and relevance, then work with your sources by taking notes and organizing information. From there, develop your thesis and supporting argument, then use sources fairly and accurately by integrating and citing your sources. Finally, revise your work and edit and proofread before submission.
💡 Why this matters: Following a structured research process prevents common pitfalls like choosing an unmanageable topic or committing unintentional plagiarism.
Why Use Global Format (APA, MLA etc.)?
Global formats serve four critical purposes. First, they allow readers to cross-reference your sources easily — this cross-referencing system enables researchers to locate your source material for their own projects. Second, they provide consistent format within a discipline — using standard APA or MLA properly helps you communicate effectively with other researchers who use these formats. Third, gives you credibility as a writer — proper use of global format demonstrates accountability to source material. Fourth, protects yourself from plagiarism — plagiarism is a serious offense in university, professional, and intellectual circles and may result in punishments.
APA Style: Two Main Concerns
APA style has two main concerns: the Reference Page and Parenthetical Citations. Most citations should contain the author's name, title of work, and publication information.
🔑 Definition — Reference Page: A list at the end of the paper containing full bibliographic information for all sources cited.
📐 Format: Author. (Year). Title of work. Location: Publisher
Reference Examples:
📌 Example (Generic): O'Connor. (1990). Express Yourself in Written English. Illinois: NTS
📌 Example (Book): Shay, J. (1994). Achilles in Vietnam: Combat trauma and the undoing of character. New York: Touchstone.
📌 Example (Magazine Article): Klein, J. (1998, October 5). Dizzy days. The New Yorker, pp. 40-45.
📌 Example (Web Page): Poland, D. (1998, October 26). The hot button. Roughcut. Retrieved October 28, 1998, from http://www.roughcut.com
📌 Example (Newspaper Article): Tommasini, A. (1998, October 27). Master teachers whose artistry glows in private. New York Times, p. B2.
📌 Example (No known author): Cigarette sales fall 30% as California tax rises. (1999, September 14). New York Times, p. A17.
When Should You Use Parenthetical Citations?
You should use parenthetical citations in three situations. First, when quoting any words that are not your own — quoting means to repeat another source word for word, using quotation marks. Second, when summarizing facts and ideas from a source — summarizing means to take ideas from a large passage of another source and condense them using your own words. Third, when paraphrasing a source — paraphrasing means to use the ideas from another source but change the phrasing into your own words.
Most citations should contain the author's name, publication year, and page number.
🔑 Definition — Parenthetical Citation: A brief reference within the text that directs readers to the full citation in the reference list.
📌 Example: "Seek first to understand, then to be understood." (Covey, 1992, p. 45)
Handling Quotes in Your Text
The author's last name, publication year, and page number(s) of quote must appear in the text. You can integrate the author's name into the sentence or place it in parentheses.
📌 Example (Author integrated): Caruth (1996) states that a traumatic response frequently entails a "delayed, uncontrolled repetitive appearance of hallucinations and other intrusive phenomena" (p. 11).
📌 Example (Author in parentheses): A traumatic response frequently entails a "delayed, uncontrolled repetitive appearance of hallucinations and other intrusive phenomena" (Caruth, 1996, p. 11).
Handling Parenthetical Citations (Special Cases)
Sometimes additional information is necessary for proper citation:
- More than one author with the same last name: (H. James, 1878); (W. James, 1880)
- Two or more works in the same parentheses: (Caruth, 1996; Fussell, 1975; Showalter, 1997)
- Work with six or more authors: (Smith et al., 1998)
- Specific part of a source: (Jones, 1995, chap. 2)
- No known author — use abbreviated version of title: Full title: "California Cigarette Tax Deters Smokers"; Citation: ("California," 1999)
- Personal communication: (C. E. Koop, personal communication, May 16, 1998)
- General reference to a website: (http://www.bartleby.com)
📌 Example integrating multiple citations: Recently, the history of warfare has been significantly revised by Higonnet et al. (1987), Marcus (1989), and Raitt and Tate (1997) to include women's personal and cultural responses to battle and its resultant traumatic effects. Feminist researchers now concur that "It is no longer true to claim that women's responses to the war have been ignored" (Raitt & Tate, p. 2). However, Tylee (1990) further criticizes Fussell, arguing that his study "treated memory and culture as if they belonged to a sphere beyond the existence of individuals or the control of institutions" (p. 6).
CROSS-REFERENCING: USING MLA FORMAT
MLA style has two parts: the Works Cited Page and Parenthetical Citations. Most citations should contain the author's name, title of work, and publication information.
Works Cited Examples:
📌 Example (Book): Byatt, A. S. Babel Tower. New York: Random House, 1996.
📌 Example (Magazine Article): Klein, Joe. "Dizzy Days." The New Yorker 5 Oct. 1998: 40-45.
📌 Example (Web Page): Poland, Dave. "The Hot Button." Roughcut 26 Oct. 1998. Turner Network Television. 28 Oct. 1998 <www.roughcut.com>.
📌 Example (Newspaper): Tommasini, Anthony. "Master Teachers Whose Artistry Glows in Private." New York Times 27 Oct. 1998: B2.
📌 Example (No known author): "Cigarette Sales Fall 30% as California Tax Rises." New York Times 14 Sept. 1999: A17.
📌 Example (TV Interview): McGwire, Mark. Interview with Matt Lauer. The Today Show. NBC. WTHR, Indianapolis. 22 Oct. 1998.
📌 Example (Personal Interview): Mellencamp, John. Personal interview. 27 Oct. 1998.
Keys to Parenthetical Citations (MLA)
Most citations should contain the author's name and page number.
📌 Example: "Seek first to understand, then to be understood" (Covey 45).
📌 Example (Author integrated): Wordsworth stated that Romantic poetry was marked by a "spontaneous overflow of powerful feelings" (263).
Handling Parenthetical Citations: Special Cases (MLA)
- More than one author with same last name: (W. Wordsworth 23); (D. Wordsworth 224)
- More than one work by same author: (Joyce, Portrait 121); (Joyce, Ulysses 556)
- Different volumes of multivolume work: (1: 336)
- Citing indirect sources: (Johnson qtd. in Boswell 2:450)
- No known author — use abbreviated title: Full title: "California Cigarette Tax Deters Smokers"; Citation: ("California" A14)
- Source is one page or web page with no pagination: (Poland)
Handling Long Quotations (MLA)
For long quotations (more than four lines), indent the entire passage and do not use quotation marks. The parenthetical citation goes after the final period.
📌 Example: David becomes identified and defined by James Steerforth, a young man with whom David is acquainted from his days at Salem House. Before meeting Steerforth, David accepts Steerforth's name as an authoritative power:
There was an old door in this playground, on which the boys had a custom of carving their names. . . . In my dread of the end of the vacation and their coming back, I could not read a boy's name, without inquiring in what tone and with what emphasis he would read, "Take care of him. He bites." There was one boy—a certain J. Steerforth—who cut his name very deep and very often, who I conceived, would read it in a rather strong voice, and afterwards pull my hair. (Dickens 68)
For Steerforth, naming becomes an act of possession, as well as exploitation. Steerforth names David for his fresh look and innocence, but also uses the name Daisy to exploit David's romantic tendencies (Dyson 122).
⭐ Key Takeaways
The research writing process consists of 11 sequential steps, from topic selection through final proofreading, and following this structure ensures thorough and ethical scholarship. Global citation formats like APA and MLA are essential because they enable cross-referencing, provide discipline-consistent formatting, establish writer credibility, and protect against plagiarism. APA style requires both a Reference Page (listing full publication details) and parenthetical citations (containing author, year, and page number) throughout the text. MLA style similarly requires a Works Cited page and parenthetical citations (containing author and page number), with both styles having specific rules for handling special cases like multiple authors, no known authors, and personal communications. The key difference between APA and MLA is that APA includes the publication year in parenthetical citations while MLA typically does not, and their formatting of source entries differs in punctuation and order of elements.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
-
What are the four reasons for using global citation formats like APA or MLA?
-
In APA style, what three pieces of information must a standard parenthetical citation contain?
-
How do you cite a source with no known author in both APA and MLA styles?
-
According to MLA guidelines, how should you handle a long quotation that exceeds four lines?
-
What is the difference between quoting, summarizing, and paraphrasing, and why must all three be cited?
📘 Lecture 28 — Summary and Précis Writing
📖 Overview: This lecture defines and distinguishes between summaries, paraphrases, and interpretative critiques in journalistic writing. It provides detailed characteristics of good summaries, step-by-step instructions for writing them, and multiple examples to illustrate the concepts. Understanding these distinctions is essential for accurate and ethical reporting and academic writing.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with a graphic representation differentiating summaries, paraphrases, and interpretations. It defines each genre with key characteristics including use of reported speech, inclusion of outside information, and length relative to original texts. A table compares the three genres, followed by a detailed example of an original text with its summary, paraphrase, and interpretative critique. The lecture then presents characteristics of good summaries (proper citation, thesis statement, supporting ideas, grammar, and length) and provides step-by-step instructions for writing summaries. It concludes with multiple summary examples showing effective versus ineffective summaries.
📝 Lecture Summary
Summary and Précis Writing
A summary is an abridgement expressing the main ideas of a text passage through reported speech. A successful summary is not an exposition of the writer's own opinions, but a distillation of the essential points in an original text.
Three points should be kept in mind: (1) summaries are shorter than original texts, (2) they contain the main ideas of a text, and (3) they are in reported speech.
A paraphrase attempts to express the same ideas of an original text in different words. Different wordings naturally result in slightly different shades of meaning. However, successful paraphrases achieve nearly the same meaning as an original text. No attempt at brevity is made in paraphrasing. Indeed, if extensive circumlocution is used, a paraphrase may be longer than its original text.
An interpretative critique evaluates some (or all) of the issues raised in a text. Successful interpretative critiques offer new critical perspectives regarding some (or all) of the ideas stated in an original passage by introducing information outside of the original text passage.
🔑 Definition — Summary: An abridgement expressing the main ideas of a text passage through reported speech; shorter than the original text, contains main ideas only, and uses reported speech.
🔑 Definition — Paraphrase: An attempt to express the same ideas of an original text in different words; no attempt at brevity is made, and it may be longer than the original.
🔑 Definition — Interpretative Critique: An evaluation of some or all issues raised in a text, offering new critical perspectives by introducing information outside the original text.
Genre Information Table
| Genre | Information outside original text? | Reported Speech? | Length |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Summary | No | Yes | Shorter than original text |
| 2. Paraphrasing | Yes | No (unless in original text) | Yes and No (both possible) |
| 3. Interpretative critique | Yes | No | Any length possible |
📌 Example — Original Text: "I am a Taiwanese man, but I have lived in Canada for several years now. I am surprised at how Canadian society respects the rights of women, both at work and home. Personally I believe women in Canada are better off than women in Taiwan. However, some of my female friends in Canada miss the good old days when women were treated in different ways. You see, in the past, gentlemen followed different rules of behavior. They would open the doors for ladies, pull out chairs for ladies to sit down, stand up when a lady left the table, and offer to pay the bill at restaurants. Now, however, most Canadians believe that men and women should be considered equal. For example, women now generally have to pay for their own meals." [133 words]
📌 Example — Summary: "This text describes the experience of a Taiwanese man who has lived in Canada for several years. He considers Canadian women better off than Taiwanese. However, he notes some Canadian women feel nostalgic about the days when they received special courtesies. For example, formerly men opened doors for women or paid for their meals. At this time, most Canadians endeavor to treat men and women equally. Women today therefore are expected to cover the cost of their own meals." [78 words]
📌 Example — Paraphrase: "I'm Taiwanese and have lived in Canada for several years. The way Canadians respect women's rights, both at work and home, is surprising. My opinion is that Canadian women are better off than Taiwanese. Some women in Canada whom I know miss the days when they were treated differently. Behavior standards differed in the past. At one time, men opened doors for women, pulled out chairs for them, and offered to pay their bills when dining out. Now, however, most Canadians believe men and women should be regarded as equals. As a result, women now must generally pay for their own meals." [103 words]
📌 Example — Interpretative Critique: "I think that men and women should be treated equally. In Taiwan this is rarely the case, so in many ways Canadian women are luckier than Taiwanese. Though men often pay for women's meals in Taiwan, they also earn more than women, which is unfair. Most women appreciate courtesies such as having doors opened for them. However, a more pressing need is gender equality - especially in the workplace. Men and women doing the same work should get the same pay. In the future, I hope Taiwanese women will have the same rights as Canadian women." [95 words]
Characteristics of Good Summary
A good summary has the following characteristics:
Proper Citation: The summary begins by citing the title, author, source, and, in the case of a magazine or journal article, the date of publication and the text.
Thesis Statement: The overall thesis of the text selection is the author's central theme. There are several aspects to an effective thesis statement:
- It comprises two parts: a) The topic or general subject matter of the text, and b) The author's major assertion, comment, or position on the topic.
- This central theme is summarized clearly and accurately in a one-sentence thesis statement.
- The thesis statement does not contain specific details discussed in the text.
- The thesis statement is stated at the beginning of the summary.
Supporting Ideas: The author supports his/her thesis with supporting ideas. Use the following basic guidelines:
- Cover all of the author's major supporting ideas.
- Show the relationships among these ideas.
- Omit specifics, such as illustrations, descriptions, and detailed explanations.
- Indicate the author's purpose in writing: to inform, to persuade, or to entertain. If the passage is a persuasive piece, report the author's bias or position on the issue.
- Omit all personal opinions, ideas, and inferences. Let the reader know that you are reporting the author's ideas.
Grammar and the Mechanics of Writing: The following are particularly important:
- Restate the ideas in your own words as much as possible. Avoid direct quotations.
- Use transitional words for a smooth and logical flow of ideas.
- Edit and rewrite your work.
- Check your grammar, punctuation, and spelling.
Length: The length of a summary depends on how long the original document is.
💡 Why this matters: A properly structured summary allows readers to quickly grasp the essential content of a source without reading the original. Mastering these characteristics ensures your summaries are accurate, objective, and useful for both academic and professional purposes.
Steps in Writing a Summary
Step 1 — Read the Article Step 2 — Reread the Article
- Divide the article into segments or sections of ideas. Each segment deals with one aspect of the central theme. A segment can comprise one or more paragraphs. Note: news magazine articles tend to begin with an anecdote. This is the writer's lead into the article, but does not contain the thesis or supporting ideas. Typically, a feature lead does not constitute a segment of thought.
- Label each segment. Use a general phrase that captures the subject matter of the segment. Write the label in the margin next to the segment.
- Highlight or underline the main points and key phrases.
Step 3 — Write One-Sentence Summaries
- Write a one-sentence summary for each segment of thought on a separate sheet of paper.
Step 4 — Formulate the Thesis Statement
- Formulate a central theme that weaves the one-sentence segment summaries together. This is your thesis statement.
- In many articles, the author will state this directly. You may wish to take his direct statement of the thesis and restate it in your own words. Note: In news magazine articles, the thesis is often suggested through the article's title and sub-title.
- In other articles, you may have to write your own one-sentence thesis statement that summarizes this central theme.
Step 5 — Write Your First Draft
- Begin with a proper citation of the title, author, source, and date of publication of the article summarized.
- Combine the thesis statement and your one-sentence segment summaries into a one-to-two-paragraph summary.
- Eliminate all unnecessary words and repetitions.
- Eliminate all personal ideas and inferences.
- Use transitions for a smooth and logical flow of ideas.
- Conclude with a "summing up" sentence by stating what can be learned from reading the article.
Step 6 — Edit Your Draft Check your summary by asking the following questions:
- Have I answered who, what, when, why, and how questions?
- Is my grammar, punctuation, and spelling correct?
- Have I left out my personal views and ideas?
- Does my summary "hang together"? Does it flow when I read it aloud?
- Have someone else read it. Does the summary give them the central ideas of the article?
Step 7 — Write Your Final Draft
Example of Summary Writing
Original Passage I: "Height connotes status in many parts of the world. Executive offices are usually on the top floors; the underlings work below. Even being tall can help a person succeed. Studies have shown that employers are more willing to hire men over 6 feet tall than shorter men with the same credentials. Studies of real-world executives and graduates have shown that taller men make more money. In one study, every extra inch of height brought in an extra $1,300 a year. But being too big can be a disadvantage. A tall, brawny football player complained that people found him intimidating off the field and assumed he 'had the brains of a Twinkie.'" (p. 301) — Locker, K. O. (2003). Business and administrative communication (6th Ed) St. Louis, MO: Irwin/McGraw-Hill.
Main points identified:
- Topic sentence: "Height connotes status in many parts of the world."
- Main point: "Even being tall can help a person succeed."
- Main point: "Executive offices are usually on the top"
- Main point: "being too big can be a disadvantage"
📌 Example — Summary A (Too Brief): "Throughout the world, being tall will lead to professional success. In fact, research shows that employers are more likely to hire taller men and to pay them more, as compared to shorter men with the same qualifications (Locker, 2003)." Critique: This summary is too brief. Further, it changes the meaning slightly, giving the impression that being tall guarantees success.
📌 Example — Summary B (Too Long): "In most countries, height suggests status. For instance, higher executives normally use top floors of office buildings. Further, research shows that men over six feet tall are more likely to be hired than those shorter than them but with the same qualifications. Taller men also receive greater incomes, possibly as much as $1,300 a year more than that only one inch shorter than them. However, as a tall and muscular football player points out, a disadvantage to being tall is that some individuals may perceive you as threatening or even dumb (Locker, 2003)." Critique: This summary is too long. Instead of focusing on the main points, it includes all of the details that are in the original passage.
📌 Example — Summary C (Most Effective): "Though height may connote slowness to some people, in the business world, it is almost universally associated with success. For example, taller men are more likely to be hired and to have greater salaries. Further, those in top positions within a company are more likely to work on the top floors of office buildings (Locker, 2003)." Critique: This summary is the most effective. In addition to including all of the main points, it leaves out the unimportant details.
⭐ Key Takeaways
A summary must use reported speech, be shorter than the original, and contain only the main ideas without personal opinions or outside information. In contrast, a paraphrase restates ideas in different words without shortening them, and an interpretative critique evaluates the text by introducing external information. When writing summaries, always begin with proper citation and a clear thesis statement that captures the author's central theme and position. Cover all major supporting ideas while omitting specific illustrations and detailed explanations, and use your own words with smooth transitions. The seven-step process — reading, segmenting, writing one-sentence summaries, formulating a thesis, drafting, editing, and finalizing — ensures a balanced summary that is neither too brief nor too detailed.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three essential characteristics that define a summary, and how do they differ from those of a paraphrase?
- In the genre information table, which two genres allow information from outside the original text, and which genre requires reported speech?
- What are the two components of an effective thesis statement in a summary, and where should this statement be placed?
- According to the seven steps for writing a summary, what should you do after writing a one-sentence summary for each segment of thought, and what typically does not constitute a segment of thought in news magazine articles?
- Why was Summary A ("Throughout the world, being tall will lead to professional success...") considered too brief in the example, and what specific error did it make regarding the original text's meaning?