๐ Lesson 41 โ New Media in Mass Communication
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the concept of New Mediaโtraditional media forms transformed by digital technology. It examines how New Media differs from Old Media, its various forms, and the challenges and disadvantages it presents, particularly in journalism and business contexts.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture defines "New Media" and lists its various forms including websites, blogs, email, virtual worlds, and mobile media. It discusses how technology forces changes across mediaโnewspapers, radio, and TV adapting to each new competitor. It covers the nature of online communication, the end-user perspective on media consumption, the lack of journalistic standards in blogs, the question of whether New Media is truly new or just "old wine in new bottles," and the disadvantages of New Media for businesses.
๐ Lecture Summary
New Media in Mass Communication
New Media is a term that describes traditional forms of media that have been transformed by advancements in digital technology and digital computing. The distinction between New Media and Old Media is not about an entirely new creation, but the re-conceptualization of a current, popular source of information in a newly digital format. This relationship involves transformations of the apparatus of language, from oral communication to literacy, and from literacy to digital adaptation. New Media must be understood within established institutional practices and identity formation processes.
๐ Definition โ New Media: Traditional forms of media transformed by digital technology and digital computing.
What is classed as New Media?
The following are classified as New Media:
- Web Sites including Blogs
- CD/DVD
- Electronic kiosks
- Virtual worlds
- Interactive Television
- Internet Telephony
- Mobile
- Pod-cast
- Hypertext Fiction
Technology forcing changes
When radio came, allowing people to get news quicker than print media, newspapers turned more interpretative. When TV tried to outplay radio by showing images, radio started working on new formats of music, light discussion, and telling jokes (FM style). Now, to compete with the internet, TV is going for high-definition technology to display things in digital formats.
๐ก Why this matters: This cycle shows how each new medium forces older media to evolve, reshape their content, and adopt new formats to survive.
On-line communication
Since the Internet became a mass medium around the mid-90s, journalists and media theoreticians have tried to define online journalism. Unlike other media defined by their form (paper, sound, picture), online media are not clear about their form. Their form is limited by the computer screen or speakers, and they have a category of speedโunknown to old media which extend in real time and space. The instrument we use to receive information considerably affects how it is imparted.
๐ Concept: Online media form is limited by screen/speakers + speed โ How information is imparted depends on the receiving device.
From end usersโ perspective
A television program is the same regardless of TV screen size; a radio program does not change whether heard on a transistor or stereo; newspapers are defined in the printing house. But an Internet site must account for users accessing it through high-density networks with large screens AND those viewing on mobile phones with modest speeds like 9,600 bps. More people using mobile phones means the information market is moving to this sideโit's only a question of technological and social compromise how quickly these devices surpass short text messages for real-time audio/video content.
๐ Example: A newspaper article is fixed regardless of reader. But an internet site must serve both a user with a 15-inch screen and high-speed connection and a user on a mobile phone with 9,600 bps speed.
Blogs are not formal media
Internet blogs are not journalism because they do not require any journalistic knowledge or experience. Even if a journalist writes a blog, the product is not journalism. Journalism requires a newsroomโexperience teaches that no good result comes from something that, except for the author, is not read/seen/heard by anyone with power to stop or delay publication. New media, unfortunately, offer this possibility, and with the help of legislation (or lack of it), cultivate this "jungle."
๐ Definition โ Journalism: A profession that requires a newsroom and editorial oversightโnot something that can be done in the privacy of one's room.
Is it really new?
An article taken from a newspaper must account for printing technology and cannot be transformed for the Internet without major editorial changesโsignificant shortening, emphasizing key words, breaking into sections with hyperlinks. This task usually lacks time, people, or resources. The result is that what we see online is actually only a projection of the old media, with the only contribution being technological: now we can read favorite newspapers at the other end of the world, simultaneously with local readers. The content is the same.
๐ Example: Reading a printed newspaper in New York and reading the same newspaper online in Tokyo simultaneouslyโthe content is identical, only the delivery method is new.
Old wine in new bottle
Any form of information transfer can distribute news reports. In the early 1990s, major media had Tele-fax editions for faraway subscribers. Tele-faxes were replaced by email as it is more suitable and less expensive. However, these changes in distribution have not been accompanied by changes in journalistic expression. A long newsletter received by email is not "comfortable" to read, but nothing prevents the author from creating it that way. Unlike old media, new media have no spatial or time limitations, except transfer speedโwhich becomes a disadvantage instead of an advantage.
๐ Example: A lengthy email newsletter is possible to send easily, but uncomfortable to readโthe new technology enables it, but the content style hasn't adapted.
Disadvantages in the Use of New Media
While New Media is cited as a positive force for reaching customers, a prevalent concern is the rapid rate at which New Media changes. While improved communication is beneficial, it allows unhappy consumers to disproportionately voice concerns. Another negative result is cost-related: New Media forms are almost exclusively digital, so the cost of initial establishment and upkeep of equipment, resources, and manpower poses a significant problem for smaller businesses. This trend may lead to further corporate globalization and the downfall of smaller businesses that cannot compete.
๐ Key Disadvantages: (1) Rapid change and multiple sources of modification, (2) Unbalanced consumer complaints, (3) High cost of digital equipment and upkeep, (4) Favoring larger corporations over smaller businesses.
๐ก Why this matters: The cost barriers of New Media can create an uneven playing field, where only well-funded corporations can fully leverage digital marketing, potentially harming local competition.
โญ Key Takeaways
New Media re-conceptualizes old media in digital formats, with examples including websites, blogs, email, virtual worlds, and mobile. Technology forces older media to evolveโnewspapers became interpretative due to radio, radio adopted new formats due to TV, and TV adopted high-definition due to the internet. Online journalism lacks a clear form but is defined by screen/speakers and speed; however, most online content is just a projection of old media with the same content. Blogs are not journalism because they lack newsroom oversight and editorial control. Finally, New Media's disadvantages include rapid change, disproportionate consumer complaints, and high costs that disadvantage smaller businesses against larger corporations.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- How did radio and TV force changes in newspapers and each other?
- Why are blogs considered "not formal media" according to the lecture?
- What is the key difference between how an end user experiences a TV program versus an internet site?
- Why does the lecture argue that most online journalism is "old wine in a new bottle"?
- List at least three disadvantages of New Media for businesses.
๐ Lecture 41 โ Globalization of Media
๐ Overview: This lecture examines the phenomenon of media globalization, exploring how transnational corporations and media systems are reshaping global culture, economics, and politics. It critically analyzes the dominance of Western media giants, the commercialization of media content, and the threats to local cultures and democratic processes, while also considering potential solutions through alternative media.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers media and consumerism as a driver of globalization, the dominance of transnational corporations (TNCs) backed by governments, media centralization by top global players like Time Warner and Disney, the decline of media freedom and objectivity due to commercial values, the role of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) in facilitating penetration, and the problem of hapless media standardization along with proposed solutions through alternative non-profit media.
๐ Lecture Summary
Media and consumerism
The media and communication industries are a leading sector in facilitating overall globalization. Telecommunications is critical for global production strategies, and content industries like television, music, video, film, and the Internet promote consumerist lifestyles through advertising. This cultural preparation for consumerism is essential for opening new markets and breaking down cultural barriers. Media and communications are also powerful agents in transforming social, cultural, and political structures, impacting individual identity, cultural diversity, political participation, and the integrity of the public sphere.
๐ Definition โ Globalization: A process driven by transnational corporations expanding their activities globally, especially in economics and media, often criticized for enriching a few while impoverishing others culturally and financially.
๐ Definition โ Consumerism: A cultural orientation promoted by media industries that emphasizes the acquisition of goods and services as a primary social value, essential for opening new markets.
๐ก Why this matters: The lecture argues that media globalization is not neutralโit actively reshapes social structures, often prioritizing commercial interests over democratic values and local cultures.
Dominance of TNCs backed by governments
The globalization of media systems over the last 15 years is characterized by the domination of large countries and powerful transnational companies (TNCs). These TNCs, following market laws, affect both the media industry and media systems. This economic power is supported by political structures in large countries that oversee information and ideological orientation within nations, regions, and continents. The lecture notes that these TNCs primarily have big film and television productions.
๐ Definition โ Transnational Companies (TNCs): Large corporations that operate across national borders, dominating global markets and influencing media systems, often backed by their home governments.
Media centralization
Global media experts argue that these processes lead to general commercialization of media, affecting democracy as an idea and system of governance. Global media systems are trending toward media centralization, spearheaded by about 30 TNCs aiming to take control over media. Major players like Time Warner, Disney, Bertelsmann, Viacom, and News Corporation dominate through internal growth, acquisitions, and mergers. For example, Time Warner, the biggest media corporation, had annual income close to $25 billion, Disney had $24 billion, and News Corporation had $10 billion.
๐ Formula: Media Centralization = Internal Growth + Acquisitions + Mergers โ Concentration of power among few TNCs
๐ Example: Time Warner was created in 1989 as a result of a merger between Time Incorporated and Warner Communications Incorporated, illustrating how mergers create media giants with billions in annual revenue.
Media freedom and objectivity declining
Traditional principles of freedom of expression, truthfulness, accuracy, objectivity, and fair reporting are being undermined by the primacy of commercial values in media. Economic market relations guide TNCs to enter national and international arenas, fatally affecting media program character and structure. This results in a general trend toward entertainment and light content, creating a culture of entertainment that negatively affects program quality and promotes an elitist consumer culture. Poor and less developed regions are particularly affected, with local cultural and political landscapes being strongly influenced by wealthy countries' media systems.
๐ Definition โ Commercialization of Media: The process whereby commercial values (profit, entertainment, advertising) take precedence over journalistic principles like truth, objectivity, and public service.
IMF blamed
American professors Edward S. Herman and Robert W. McChesney argue that economic giants like the International Monetary Fund (IMF) support TNCs and their influences. Through its programs, the IMF facilitates media penetration of great powers into underdeveloped countries. The marketing โ media โ TNC โ IMF scheme operates throughout the global system, stimulating neo-liberal rules based on private investments and reduced social appropriationsโa dangerous combination in systems of extreme inequality.
๐ Definition โ Neo-liberal rules: Economic policies that promote privatization, deregulation, and free markets, which according to critics, facilitate the penetration of powerful countries' media into developing nations.
Hapless media standardization
Standardization of mediaโthrough the structure and content of programsโthreatens the particularity and sustainability of authentic national cultures. These processes result in the loss of public journalism and journalistic criticism, as journalists face the dilemma of writing truthfully versus serving the higher interests of media giants. Instead of civil journalism, what emerges is new journalism where media products are commodities, and journalists balance among neutrality, hushing up truth, and insensitivity to local and regional needs.
๐ Definition โ Media Standardization: The process where media programs across different countries become uniform in structure and content, driven by commercial interests of global media conglomerates.
How to combat the alternate media?
A solution to preserving national and media authenticity and pluralism lies in developing alternative non-profit media that would form a non-profit public sphere. Decentralization of global media and economic giants is possible through concentration of alternative media markets. These alternative media should be developed first at the local level, and then expanded to higher levels.
๐ Definition โ Alternative non-profit media: Media outlets that operate without profit motives, focused on serving public interests, preserving local culture, and providing pluralistic content.
โญ Key Takeaways
The lecture presents a critical view of media globalization, arguing that it is driven by powerful transnational corporations and wealthy nations, often supported by international institutions like the IMF. This process promotes consumerism and commercialization, undermining traditional journalistic values of truth, objectivity, and fairness while threatening local cultures and democratic governance through media centralization and standardization. Students must remember that the top TNCs like Time Warner, Disney, and News Corporation dominate global media through mergers and acquisitions, and that this concentration leads to entertainment-oriented content rather than public service journalism. The decline of media freedom and objectivity is a direct consequence of commercial values taking precedence over ethical reporting. Finally, the lecture proposes that alternative non-profit media developed at local levels could provide a counterforce to global media giants and help preserve cultural authenticity and pluralism.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the role of media and communication industries in facilitating globalization, and how do they promote consumerism?
- Name three of the largest global media TNCs mentioned in the lecture and their approximate annual incomes.
- According to Edward S. Herman and Robert W. McChesney, what role does the International Monetary Fund (IMF) play in media globalization?
- How does the commercialization of media affect journalistic principles like objectivity and truthfulness?
- What solution does the lecture propose to combat media standardization and preserve national cultural authenticity?
๐ Lecture 42 โ Media Mergence
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the historical and ongoing process by which new media technologies adopt content and formats from their predecessors, leading to media convergence. It explains how print, radio, television, and digital technologies have blended, and examines the economic drivers and future debates surrounding media mergence.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the historical amalgamation of print and electronic media, the mergence of radio and TV content, the convergence of TV and computer technologies into Internet Protocol TV (IPTV), the debate over whether televisions and computers will become a single device, the nature of programming in a converged environment, the economic reasons behind media convergence, and introduces digital cinema standards including SDTV and HDTV.
๐ Lecture Summary
From Print to Electronic Amalgamation
Print media dominated society for nearly four centuries until radio was introduced in the first quarter of the 20th century based on electromagnetic waves technology. This was the first experience of large-scale wireless communication. Radio brought listening pleasure โ music, talks, and news. However, the nature of its content โ news, talk shows, discussions, educational programmes, and comments โ was not new. It was largely the same content people already knew from print media. The only real change was the technology. Therefore, radio represented a mergence of print and electronic media as far as content was concerned.
๐ Definition โ Mergence: The process by which a new media organ adopts source material and content formats from media organs that already exist.
Radio, TV mergence
Television was also based on radio wave technology, but the ability to carry images through electromagnetic waves gave it a unique distinction in the public eye. On the content side, TV adopted many ideas from radio formats such as group discussions, musical programmes, commentary on sporting events, and the presentation of news. The changes were primarily due to the addition of images, but the core formats remained the same.
TV and computer getting one - IPT (Internet protocol TV)
In the third quarter of the 20th century, scientists successfully used digital technology to carry content that was previously only carried through analog techniques. This led to a marriage between analog and digital technologies, which is the core of modern media mergence. This new combination is exclusive because it brings together sound and images while also merging the two technologies at one point.
In the coming years, you will be able to use your computer as a TV, and a TV set could be used as a computer. Most TV sets manufactured after 2006 carry a chip that enables decoding of messages transmitted through digital technology. When we say media will converge, we mean that current television shows will merge into a hybrid with World Wide Web style content. TV shows will have other media types like text merged into them, and web pages will become temporal entities that tell a story. Both your television and computer will run a similar super browser allowing the same content to be viewed on both devices. For true convergence, the content received by both devices must be the same.
๐ Definition โ Convergence: The merging of distinct media technologies, content forms, and delivery platforms into a unified whole, such as television and the World Wide Web becoming a hybrid.
Non-convergence argues that television shows and web content will remain distinct media forms, with televisions used for watching shows and computers for browsing the web. While both may evolve, they will remain different from one another.
People will cease distinguishing between computers and televisions
The second topic for debate is whether computers and televisions as devices will merge. The argument for convergence suggests that in the future there won't be separate "televisions" and "computers," but a new device called a "viewer" that encapsulates the behavior of both. This viewer will come in different sizes and shapes but will be thought of as one item. Users would be willing to do either task โ browsing the web or watching a show โ on either device.
The non-convergence argument states that while TVs may take on some computer-like functionality and vice versa, they will fundamentally be thought of as different devices. Research and browsing will be done on a computer, and watching shows and movies will be done on a television. Since there is no technical reason why a television can't have the same functionality as a computer, it is likely that both computer-powered TVs and computers that can display television will be around.
๐ก Why this matters: The debate over whether devices will merge or remain distinct shapes product development, content production, and consumer choice in the media landscape.
Nature of program remains a question
The debate centers on what functionality the majority of televisions and computers will have and what types of media will be broadcast for a majority of broadcast hours. The main question is whether televisions and computers will become more similar on average over time, or whether they will evolve along mostly independent paths.
Economic reasons
Media convergence is an economic strategy in which communications companies seek financial benefit by making the various media properties they own work together. This strategy is a product of three elements:
- Corporate concentration: fewer large companies own more and more media properties.
- Digitization: media content produced in a universal computer language can be easily adapted for any medium.
- Government deregulation: increasingly allows media conglomerates to own different kinds of media (e.g., TV and radio stations and newspapers) in the same markets, and permits content carriage companies (e.g., cable TV suppliers) to own content producers (e.g., specialty TV channels).
The strategy allows companies to reduce labour, administrative, and material costs, use the same media content across several outlets, attract increased advertising through package deals, and increase brand recognition and brand loyalty through cross-promotion and cross-selling. At the same time, it raises barriers to newcomers seeking to enter media markets, thus limiting competition.
๐ Definition โ Media convergence (economic): An economic strategy by communications companies to reduce costs and increase profits by using digitized content across multiple owned media platforms, enabled by corporate concentration and deregulation.
Digital Cinemas
People have become increasingly interested in studying new aesthetic forms emerging from the potentials of digital media. Digital cinema can refer to many things, ranging from the use of digital cameras in film production or digital projection in film exhibition to the use of the web as a delivery system for films.
SDTV
Standard Digital Television (SDTV) refers to a digital television standard that offers a picture quality similar to analog TV but in a digital format.
HDTV
High Definition Television (HDTV) is a digital television broadcasting system with a higher resolution than standard television, providing significantly sharper and more detailed images.
โญ Key Takeaways
The key takeaway is that media mergence is a historical pattern where new technologies adopt content from older ones, as seen from print to radio and radio to TV. True convergence occurs when distinct technologies (like TV and computer) become a single device using a common super browser, while non-convergence argues they will remain separate. Economically, media convergence is driven by corporate concentration, digitization, and deregulation, allowing companies to reduce costs and maximize profits across platforms. The debate over whether devices will merge or remain distinct is central to the future of media. Digital cinema, SDTV, and HDTV represent extensions of this convergence into film and television broadcasting.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between the content of print media and the content of radio when radio was first introduced?
- What is Internet Protocol TV (IPTV) and how does it represent the mergence of TV and computer technologies?
- Explain the two opposing arguments in the debate about whether people will cease distinguishing between computers and televisions.
- List the three elements that enable media convergence as an economic strategy.
- What is digital cinema, and what are the differences between SDTV and HDTV?
๐ Lecture 43 โ Mass Media in Present Age
๐ Overview: This lecture examines the current state of all major mass media organsโbooks, newspapers, magazines, radio, film, television, and the internetโand confirms that none have been eliminated; each continues to serve a distinct role and audience. It explores how these media forms have adapted, diversified, and coexist in the modern age, producing an overall impact on common people and society at large.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by stating that all mass media organs are surviving and none have been wiped out; each has its own role and audience. It then examines books in detail, listing their many types and providing data on new titles per year by country. Moving to magazines, it catalogues a wide range of types from academic journals to women's magazines, noting their demographic specificity and interactivity. The lecture briefly discusses radio, TV, and the overall impact of mass media on politics, democracy, economics, culture, and globalization.
๐ Lecture Summary
All organs are surviving, no one wiped out, everyone has a role and its own audience/readers/users
The lecture opens with the central thesis of this lesson: despite predictions of decline or replacement, every mass mediumโbooks, newspapers, magazines, radio, film, television, and the internetโcontinues to exist and thrive. Each medium has a distinct role and attracts its own specific audience. The common man receives an overall impact from the combination of all these media.
Books โ still a charm
Books retain their appeal and are published in a vast range of categories. The lecture lists the following types: Fiction, Science, Poetry, Children/women, Travelogue, Albums/stamp collections, Text books, Politics, Economics, Medicine, History, Dictionaries, and E-books.
The lecture provides data on the number of new titles published per year, in descending order, as of 1996:
- United Kingdom (1996) 107,263, (2005) 206,000
- China (1994) 100,951 (close second)
- United States (1996) 68,175, (2005) 172,000
- Germany (1996) 71,515
- Japan (1996) 56,221
- Spain (1996) 46,330
- Russian Federation (1996) 36,237
- Italy (1996) 35,236
- France (1995) 34,766
- Netherlands (1993) 34,067
๐ Example: The United Kingdom published 107,263 new book titles in 1996, which increased to 206,000 by 2005, demonstrating the enduring and even growing popularity of books as a mass medium.
Magazine
Magazines have become highly specialized and targeted. The lecture provides an extensive list of magazine types, demonstrating their diversity: Academic journals, Architecture magazines, Art magazines, Business magazines, Car magazines, Children's magazines, Computer magazines, Health and fitness magazines, History magazines, Home and furniture magazines, Humor magazines, Inspirational magazines, Literacy, Literary magazines, Luxury magazines, Men's magazines, Music magazines, News magazines, Online magazines, Pet magazines, Politics magazines, Pornographic magazines, Pulp magazines, Railroad magazines, Regional magazines, Religion magazines, Satirical magazines, Sport magazines, Science magazines and scientific journals, Teen magazines, Wildlife magazines, and Women's magazines.
The lecture notes that magazines have become more demographic, specific, and cover niche topics like weather, trains, and flights services. They have also become more entertaining, with a talk-style format that is more attractive. A key development is interactivityโthrough telephone calls, availability free on mobile phones, and the increasing popularity of FM radio (which shares some characteristics). Magazines are also now available on the internet. ๐ก Why this matters: The fragmentation of magazine audiences into highly specific niches allows advertisers and content creators to reach very targeted groups, making the medium more efficient and personalized.
Radio
Radio continues to evolve. It offers more services related to weather, trains, and flights. It has become more entertaining and its talk-style format is more attractive. A major change is its increased interactivityโthrough telephone calls from listeners. Radio is now free on mobile phones, and FM (Frequency Modulation) radio is popular and on the rise. Radio is also available on the internet, ensuring its survival and broader reach.
TV
Television has undergone significant technological changes. The lecture lists modern developments: Flat screen, LCDs (Liquid Crystal Displays), Plasma, Digital, and IPTV (Internet Protocol Television). The number of channels is constantly increasing.
Mass media โ overall impact on people
The lecture concludes by stating that people today receive a media mix and are influenced by every category of media according to their age, education, and other factors. All mass communication organs remain intact; only their relative importance fluctuates, and none have died. Mass media have an overall impact on politics, democracy, peopleโs rights, economics, culture, globalization, conflict resolving, and bringing people closer.
โญ Key Takeaways
The single most important concept from this lecture is that no mass medium has become obsolete; all seven major organs (books, newspapers, magazines, radio, film, television, and the internet) coexist with distinct roles and audiences. Books remain a dominant force, with the UK and US showing significant increases in new titles over a decade. Magazines have diversified into highly specific niches and have become more interactive and demographically targeted. Radio has adapted through FM technology, mobile phone access, and interactivity, while TV has evolved with flat screens, digital formats, and a vast increase in channels. The overall impact of all these media collectively influences politics, culture, globalization, and democracy.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- According to the lecture, what is the status of all major mass media organs (books, newspapers, magazines, radio, film, television, internet) in the present age?
- Which country published the most new book titles in 1996, and what was its total for 2005?
- Name at least five specific types of magazines mentioned in the lecture beyond general news or entertainment.
- What two key characteristics have made radio more attractive and interactive in the modern age?
- List at least four areas of society or human experience on which the overall mass media mix has an impact, as stated in the lecture.
๐ Lecture 44 โ Criticism on Media
๐ Overview: This lecture examines the major criticisms leveled against mass media despite its beneficial roles in society. It explores how media, particularly news, faces severe criticism for concealing truth, sensationalizing issues, damaging cultural traditions, and serving vested interests rather than the public good.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers multiple criticisms of media including: concealing more than it reveals, exaggeration of issues, sensationalization of routine matters, damage to cultural and family traditions, biasness in coverage, selling out to interest groups, commercialism misleading people, unethical portrayal of killings, invasion of private life and obscenity, and blackmailing governments.
๐ Lecture Summary
Conceals more than it reveals
The foremost charge on the media, especially the news media, is that it only tells people half-truths. The better part of any story falls victim to gate-keepers or those who filter facts before passing them on to common people. At crisis times like wars or political chaos, media only tells facts which interest groups want to appear before masses. Media hardly believes or makes an effort to tell the whole truth about any matter of general interest. Leaving people guessing about the untold part of the story is considered a serious offense.
Exaggerates
It has become a habit of media to blow up out of proportion some issues of sensitive nature, creating so much panic among people and authorities that instead of finding lasting solutions, they just try to hush up the matters. Government departments and other agencies that counter these situations frequently find no way to stop media from doing so.
Sensationalize
Perhaps the most commonly leveled charge against media is its chronic approach to sensationalize matters of routine life. In a murder story, media would find some juicy thing out of nothing. A small tip from any person may make a media person build a spicy story that attracts common people. More often than not, the facts on which media builds stories prove wrong by later investigations. The film world and leading sportspersons are always worried as media would quickly fabricate a story on finding something small.
๐ Example: If a top police officer invites a noted film personality over a cup of tea, a storm is likely to be made in the media.
Damages cultural and family traditions
The way certain things appear in mass media is seen as a direct attack on people's lifestyle, belief, and normal social life. Bold pictures of women in the name of aesthetics, out of proportion images of sportspersons (especially women), behavior of characters in radio or TV drama, dances in films, and smoking and drinking actions have all invited severe disapproval. Common people argue that such media attitude is hurting cultural norms and the family set up. As a result, people do not allow certain TV channels to be tuned or some magazines to be dropped at their homes. Certain music is not liked at family gatherings, and there is always uproar when an offensive or bold billboard appears on a busy thoroughfare.
Biasness
Media bias at times is too clear to be ignored. Siding with political parties or showing disdain for certain government functionaries, at times ministers, is common. It works both sides: government-controlled media in all countries show a visible tilt towards the government while bashing the opposition, while private sector media (newspapers and TV channels) remain occupied lashing out at government actions and allowing the opposition to drag matters into public that should have been discussed in parliament. Media bias is sometimes visible on regional, ethnic, and linguistic grounds, only damaging society rather than bringing people closer.
Sold to interest groups
This is generally done covertly. Media is under fire across the world for selling space to interest groups โ political people in developing countries and economic interests in advanced countries.
Commercialism โ trend is to mislead people
Although a modern phenomenon, media largely considers its commercial interest more than what common people expect on pure professional ground. With huge money given to media through advertisements, media is molded in favor of the rich. Media cannot openly speak against individuals and corporate sector even if a scam of billions of rupees (and dollars) takes place. Land grabbers, tax evaders, and those misappropriating authority can easily gag media with currency.
Pictures of killings โ unethical
True it may be, but revealing a fact in ugly manners leaves a bad taste in the mouths of many. A large part of media blatantly refuses to follow ethics, which may cause intense pain to common people. At breakfast time when starting the day, finding the body of a slain person dipped in a pool of blood is enough to haunt you all day. Not only this, some headlines that describe crime in the most horrible way also leave a mark on the mind, which remains occupied by the ugly side of the event that could have been avoided had media followed professional ways.
Private life, obscenity
All people, including those in the hall-of-fame, have a private life. Media for its personal interest keeps peeping into the private life affairs of famous people and reports matters to the public that may ruin the lives of stars. Females at the top of show business are the most hunted targets. Media does not hesitate in playing up their images which look highly offensive when put on newspapers or magazine pages, no matter those poses were meant for a momentary demand during a shoot of feature films or commercial camerawork.
Blackmails governments
Media is blamed for blackmailing even the strongest of governments. At times, autocratic governments find no way but get blackmailed by popular media. Little wonder if there is a general perception that media stands for arm-twisting of people who are at the helm of political or financial authority.
โญ Key Takeaways
The lecture presents ten major criticisms of mass media that students must remember: media conceals more than it reveals by telling only half-truths through gate-keeping; media exaggerates and sensationalizes routine matters, often fabricating stories from small tips; media damages cultural and family traditions through bold imagery and offensive content; media shows bias on political, regional, ethnic, and linguistic grounds; media sells itself to interest groups and prioritizes commercial interests over professional ethics; media displays unethical pictures of killings and invades private lives of famous people; and media even blackmails governments. These criticisms highlight the tension between media's beneficial roles and its destructive potential in society.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is meant by the charge that media "conceals more than it reveals" and who are the gate-keepers?
- How does media sensationalize routine matters according to the lecture, and what example is given?
- On what grounds does media show biasness according to the lecture?
- How does commercialism mislead people and what does it prevent media from covering?
- What is the criticism regarding media's treatment of private life and obscenity, and who are the most targeted individuals?