๐ Lecture 37 โ Advertising Beyond Print Media
๐ Overview: This lecture explores advertising media beyond newspapers and magazines, examining the evolution of commercial advertising through radio, television, cinema, the internet, and other unconventional platforms. It provides a comprehensive understanding of how different media channels are used to persuade target audiences and why this matters for effective marketing campaigns in modern society.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers a wide range of advertising media including wall paintings, billboards, radio, cinema, television, web banners, skywriting, and product placement in films. It then delves deeply into radio advertisingโits advantages, disadvantages, and production considerationsโfollowed by television commercials, their characteristics and techniques, including animation and humor. The discussion extends to computer and web-based advertising, unpaid/word-of-mouth advertising, methods for measuring advertising impact through rating points, and concludes with a comprehensive taxonomy of advertising forms such as advocacy, comparative, cooperative, and direct-mail advertising.
๐ Lecture Summary
Commercial Advertising Media
Moving beyond print media, humans have employed numerous methods to persuade others commercially and non-commercially. These include wall paintings, billboards, street furniture components, printed flyers, radio, cinema, television, web banners, web popups, skywriting, bus stop benches, town criers, sides of buses, taxicab doors and roof mounts, musical stage shows, subway platforms and trains, elastic bands on disposable diapers, stickers on apples in supermarkets, the opening section of streaming audio and video, posters, back of event tickets and supermarket receipts, and covert advertising.
Covert advertising, embedded in other entertainment media, is known as product placement. A more recent version appears in film, where a main character uses an item of a definite brand. For example, in the movie Minority Report, Tom Cruise's character owns a computer with the Nokia logo clearly visible, and his watch is engraved with the Bulgari logo. In I, Robot, Will Smith's character mentions his Converse shoes several times. Cadillac advertised in The Matrix Reloaded, and Omega Watches, BMW, and Aston-Martin cars are featured in recent James Bond films, most notably Casino Royale.
Radio commercial
A radio commercial (often called an advert in the UK, or a spot in the business) is a form of advertising promoting goods, services, organizations, or ideas via radio. Many commercials are produced by an outside ad agency, and airtime is purchased from a station or network in exchange for sponsorship of its programming.
Radio commercials are frequently sold in either 30 second or 60 second increments. While a :60 radio commercial is twice as long as a :30, it is rarely sold at twice the price. Most radio stations only charge 20-30% more for the longer spot.
Many commercials are professionally produced, but radio is not out of reach for small retail business owners. Most local radio stations have the ability to produce radio commercials in-house using their own announcers. At times, local radio stations will write and even produce radio commercials for local retailers at no additional cost when the merchant purchases a schedule of "spots" on the station.
๐ Definition โ First radio commercial: Credited to WEAF, New York on August 28, 1922 for the Queens Boro real estate corporation. The ten-minute live commercial was voiced by H.M. Blackwell, a representative of Queensboro.
Advertising MediaโAudio
The most common audio advertising media is FM radio. Placement of an advertisement on FM radio costs about as much as an advertisement placed in a metropolitan newspaper. However, radio is more dynamic than print because it allows the advertiser to talk with the consumer. Many small business consultants believe an entertaining and informative radio advertising campaign can be a major asset. Nonetheless, most businesses incorporate a media mix when attempting to sell products or services, utilizing radio advertising in concert with print and other advertising media. The key is to study what types of advertising best suits their products and services and use that media to spearhead their campaign.
Advantages and Disadvantages of Radio
Radio stations feature different programming emphases, from music-oriented formats (country, adult contemporary, classic rock, alternative rock) to news-or talk-oriented formats. Since these formats attract different demographic segments, business owners can reach their target audience by buying time on appropriate stations. Another major advantage is that radio advertising is inexpensive to place and produce, allowing small business owners to place ads on more than one station in a given market. Radio advertising content can be changed quickly to meet market changes, and radio reaches large numbers of commuters, income-generating people who often pay more attention to radio advertising, especially if driving alone.
Costs reflect this emphasis on reaching the commuter audience. The four time slots, or "day parts", offered by most radio stations are: morning drive, daytime, afternoon drive, and evening. The two most expensiveโbut also most effectiveโslots are the morning and afternoon drive times.
Drawbacks include competitor clutter, the cumulative costs associated with long-term radio spots, and the fleeting nature of a radio message. Additional guidelines include:
- If a celebrity sound-alike is used, include a clear disclaimer.
- When working with a station, always work with a contract.
- Treat the competition fairlyโfederal law mandates accurate depiction of competition.
- Be prepared to run an ad often; it needs to be heard on several occasions before generating a response.
- Be cautious about excessive reliance on one station; use more than one station to expand audience reach.
TV
The TV commercial is generally considered the most effective mass-market advertising format, reflected by the high prices TV networks charge for commercial airtime during popular events. The annual Super Bowl football game in the United States is known as much for its commercial advertisements as for the game itself, with the average cost of a single thirty-second TV spot reaching $2.5 million (as of 2006).
Virtual advertisements may be inserted into regular television programming through computer graphics. They are typically inserted into otherwise blank backdrops or used to replace local billboards. More controversially, virtual billboards may be inserted into the background where none existed in real-life. Virtual product placement is also possible. Increasingly, other mediums are overtaking television due to a shift towards consumer's usage of the Internet.
The vast majority of television commercials consist of brief advertising spots, ranging from a few seconds to several minutes. These have been used to sell every product imaginable, from household products to political campaigns. The effect has been so pervasive that it is considered impossible for a politician to wage a successful election campaign in the United States without airing a good television commercial.
Characteristics of commercials
Many television commercials feature catchy jingles (songs or melodies) or catch-phrases that generate sustained appeal, remaining in the minds of viewers long after the campaign. These long-lasting elements may take a place in the pop culture history of the demographic they have appeared to. Examples include:
- "Aiy Khuda meray abbu salamat rahain"
- "Yey dil mangay aur"
- "Aur sonao"
- "Talk shawk"
For catching attention, communication agencies make wide use of humour. Many psychological studies have tried to demonstrate the effect of humour and indicate how to empower advertising persuasion.
Animation is often used in commercials, varying from hand-drawn traditional animation to different forms of computer animation. By using animated characters, a commercial may have a certain appeal difficult to achieve with actors or mere product displays. An animated commercial can be very long-running, several decades in many instances. An animated character talking to a real one is now a common sight.
Computer
Advertising on the World Wide Web is a recent phenomenon. Prices of Web-based advertising space are dependent on the "relevance" of the surrounding web content and the traffic the website receives.
E-mail advertising is another recent phenomenon. Unsolicited bulk E-mail advertising is known as "spam".
Others
Some companies have proposed placing messages or corporate logos on the side of booster rockets and the International Space Station. Controversy exists on the effectiveness of subliminal advertising and the pervasiveness of mass messages.
Unpaid advertising (also called word of mouth advertising) can provide good exposure at minimal cost. Personal recommendations ("bring a friend", "sell it"), spreading buzz, or equating a brand with a common noun ("Xerox" = "photocopier", "Kleenex" = tissue, "Vaseline" = petroleum jelly) are the pinnacles of any advertising campaign. However, some companies oppose the use of their brand name to label an object.
Rating
The most common method for measuring the impact of mass media advertising is the use of the rating point (RP) or the more accurate target rating point (TRP). These measures refer to the percentage of the universe of the existing base of audience members that can be reached by each media outlet at a particular moment. The difference is that the rating point refers to the percentage to the entire universe, while the target rating point refers to the percentage to a particular segment or target. This becomes very useful when focusing advertising efforts on a particular group.
๐ Example: For an advertising campaign targeting women aged 25-45, a TV show might have an overall rating of over 10 rating points, but the same show might generate only 2.5 TRPs (target: women 25-45). This means while the show has a large universe of viewers, it is not necessarily reaching a large universe of women aged 25-45, making it less desirable for an advertiser looking for this demographic. Conversely, a TV show with a low overall rating point may be more successful when its target rating points are high.
๐ก Why this matters: TRPs allow advertisers to measure precisely whether their ad spend is reaching the right demographic, not just the largest audience.
Advertising Evaluation
Once the advertising campaign is over, companies normally evaluate it compared to established goals. An effective tactic is measuring pre-and post-sales of the company's product. Some companies divide the country into regions and run campaigns only in some areas. The different geographic areas are then compared (advertising versus non-advertising), and a detailed analysis provides an evaluation of the campaign's effectiveness. Depending on results, a company will modify future advertising efforts to maximize effectiveness.
Summary
Advertising is the paid, non-personal promotion of a cause, idea, product, or service by an identified sponsor attempting to inform or persuade a particular target audience. Advertising has evolved to take a variety of forms and has permeated nearly every aspect of modern society. Delivery mechanisms include banners at sporting events, billboards, Internet Web sites, logos on clothing, magazines, newspapers, radio spots, and television commercials. Limitations include inability to (1) focus on an individual consumer's specific needs, (2) provide in-depth information about a product, and (3) be cost-effective for small companies. Other factors like objectives, budgets, approaches, and evaluation methods must all be considered.
The late 1980s and early 1990s saw the introduction of cable television and particularly MTV, which pioneered the music video and a new type of advertising where the consumer tunes in for the advertisement. Specialty channels like QVC, Home Shopping Network, and ShopTV emerged, devoted entirely to advertising merchandise.
Marketing through the Internet led to the "dot-com" boom of the 1990s. The search engine Google revolutionized online advertising by emphasizing contextually relevant, unobtrusive ads intended to help, rather than inundate, users. This led to a plethora of similar efforts and an increasing trend of interactive advertising.
A recent advertising innovation is "guerrilla promotions", involving unusual approaches such as staged encounters in public places, giveaways of products covered with brand messages, and interactive advertising where the viewer can respond. This reflects an increasing trend of interactive and "embedded" ads, such as via product placement, having consumers vote through text messages, and innovations utilizing social networking sites.
An advertising campaign is a series of advertisement messages sharing a single idea and theme that make up an integrated marketing communication (IMC). Advertising campaigns appear in different media across a specific time frame. The critical part is determining a campaign theme, which is the central message communicated in promotional activities. Campaign themes are usually developed for substantial periods but many are short-lived due to being ineffective or market conditions.
Forms of Advertising
Advertising can take several forms:
Advocacy Advertising: Any advertisement, message, or public communication regarding economic, political, or social issues. It is designed to persuade public opinion regarding a specific issue. The ultimate goal usually relates to the passage of pending legislation. Almost all nonprofit groups use some form of advocacy advertising. Examples include the American Association of Retired Persons (AARP), Greenpeace, Mothers Against Drunk Driving (MADD), and the National Rifle Association (NRA).
Comparative Advertising: Compares one brand directly or indirectly with one or more competing brands. It is common in nearly every major industry, including airlines and automobile manufacturers. A drawback is that customers have become more skeptical about claims. Companies must be careful not to misinform the public, as incorrect or misleading information may trigger a lawsuit or regulatory action by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC).
Cooperative Advertising: A system allowing two parties to share advertising costs. Manufacturers and distributors usually use this technique. For example, a soft-drink manufacturer and a local grocery store split the cost of advertising the manufacturer's soft drinks. This is appealing to small storeowners who could not afford to advertise adequately on their own.
Direct-Mail Advertising: Includes catalogues, flyers, letters, and postcards. Advantages include detail of information, personalization, selectivity, and speed. Disadvantages include an expensive per-head price, dependence on the appropriateness of the mailing list, and being resented as "junk mail."
Informational Advertising: Used when a new product is first introduced. The emphasis is on promoting the product name, benefits, and possible uses. Car manufacturers used this strategy when sport utility vehicles (SUVs) were first introduced.
Institutional Advertising: Takes a broader approach, concentrating on the benefits, concept, idea, or philosophy of a particular industry. Companies use it to promote image-building activities, such as environmentally friendly business practices or community-based programs. It is closely related to public relations. For example, a large lumber company may develop a theme around its practice of planting trees where they have just been harvested.
Outdoor Advertising: Billboards and messages painted on the side of buildings are common forms. It is used when quick, simple ideas are being promoted. Since repetition is key, it is most effective along heavily traveled city streets when the product can be purchased locally. Only about 1 percent of advertising is conducted this way.
Persuasive Advertising: Used after a product has been introduced. The primary goal is to build selective demand for a product. For example, automobile manufacturers produce ads promoting safety features, allowing them to charge more for perceived higher quality.
Product Advertising: Pertains to non-personal selling of a specific product. An example is a regular television commercial promoting a specific soft drink, not the entire soft-drink line.
Reminder Advertising: Used for products in the mature stage of the product life cycle. Advertisements are designed simply to remind customers about the product and maintain awareness. Detergent producers spend considerable money each year promoting products to remind customers they are still available.
Point-of-Purchase Advertising: Uses displays or other promotional items near the product being sold. The primary motivation is to attract customers to the display so they will purchase the product. Stores are more likely to use these displays if they have help from the manufacturer in setting them up.
Specialty Advertising: A form of sales promotion designed to increase public recognition of a company's name. A company can have its name on items like caps, glassware, gym bags, jackets, key chains, and pens. The value varies depending on how long the items last. Most companies are successful in achieving goals for increasing public recognition and sales.
โญ Key Takeaways
Advertising has evolved far beyond print media into a multi-platform ecosystem including radio, television, cinema, the internet, and unconventional methods like product placement and guerrilla promotions. Radio advertising offers cost-effective targeting through day parts and demographic-specific programming, while television remains the most powerful format despite its high cost, as demonstrated by Super Bowl ad prices. Measuring advertising effectiveness requires understanding the distinction between overall rating points (RP) and target rating points (TRP), which focus on specific demographic segments. Advertising takes numerous formsโadvocacy, comparative, cooperative, direct-mail, informational, institutional, outdoor, persuasive, product, reminder, point-of-purchase, and specialtyโeach serving distinct strategic purposes. The key to successful advertising is matching the medium and message to the target audience through an integrated marketing communication (IMC) campaign with a clear campaign theme.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What was the first radio commercial, and when and where was it broadcast?
- What are the four "day parts" used by radio stations for advertising, and which two are most expensive?
- What is the difference between a rating point (RP) and a target rating point (TRP)?
- List and briefly describe five of the twelve forms of advertising discussed in the lecture.
- What is product placement, and provide two examples from the films mentioned in the lecture?
๐ Lecture 38 โ Advertising Objectives
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the strategic goals behind advertising campaigns, focusing on four key objectives: trial, continuity, brand switching, and switchback. It also examines how companies determine advertising budgets, select the right approach for their campaigns, and considers the broader impact of advertising on society, media, and public perception. Understanding these concepts is essential for grasping how advertising functions as a strategic business tool with significant social implications.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers four advertising objectives (trial, continuity, brand switching, and switchback) and their relationship to the product life cycle. It then explains factors influencing advertising budgets, including advertising frequency, competition and clutter, market share, product differentiation, and stage in the product life cycle. The lecture also addresses selecting the right advertising approach through frequency, media impact, media timing, and reach, concluding with an analysis of advertising's impact on society, including public perception, compensation demands, negative effects on communication media, and future trends.
๐ Lecture Summary
Advertising Objectives
Advertising objectives are the communication tasks to be accomplished with specific customers that a company is trying to reach during a particular time frame. A company usually strives to achieve one of four advertising objectives: trial, continuity, brand switching, and switchback. The selection of which objective to pursue depends on where the product is in its life cycle.
Trial
The purpose of the trial objective is to encourage customers to make an initial purchase of a new product. Companies typically employ creative advertising strategies to cut through competing advertisements. The reason is simple: without that first trial of a product by customers, there will not be any repeat purchases.
Continuity
Continuity advertising is a strategy to keep current customers using a particular product. Existing customers are targeted and are usually provided new and different information about a product designed to build consumer loyalty.
Brand Switching
Companies adopt brand switching as an objective when they want customers to switch from competitors' brands to their brands. A common strategy is for a company to compare product price or quality to convince customers to switch to its product brand.
Switchback
Companies subscribe to the switchback advertising objective when they want to get back former users of their product brand. A company might highlight new product features, price reductions, or other important product information to get former customers of its product to switchback.
Advertising Budget
Once an advertising objective has been selected, companies must set an advertising budget for each product. Developing such a budget can be difficult because brand managers want large resource allocations to promote their products. The advertising budget should be congruent with overall company objectives. Before establishing a budget, companies must consider market factors such as advertising frequency, competition and clutter, market share, product differentiation, and stage in the product life cycle.
Advertising Frequency
Advertising frequency refers to the number of times an advertisement is repeated during a given time period to promote a product's name, message, and other important information. A larger advertising budget is required to achieve high advertising frequency. Estimates suggest a consumer needs to come in contact with an advertising message nine times before it will be remembered.
Competition and Clutter
Highly competitive product markets, such as the soft-drink industry, require higher advertising budgets just to stay even with competitors. If a company wants to be an industry leader, a substantial advertising budget must be earmarked every year. Examples include Coca Cola and General Motors, which spend millions on advertising to remain key players.
Market Share
Desired market share is an important factor in establishing an advertising budget. Increasing market share normally requires a large advertising budget because competitors counterattack with their own advertising blitz. Successfully increasing market share depends on advertisement quality, competitor responses, and product demand and quality.
Product Differentiation
Product differentiation refers to how customers perceive products and is often necessary in competitive markets where customers have difficulty differentiating between products. For example, when a new laundry detergent is advertised among many existing brands, an aggressive advertising campaign is required. The advertising budget is higher to pay for the additional advertising needed to make customers aware of the product's availability and differences.
Stage in the Product Life Cycle
New product offerings require considerably more advertising to make customers aware of their existence. As a product moves through the product life cycle, fewer advertising resources are needed because the product becomes known and develops an established buyer base. Advertising budgets are typically highest during the introduction stage and gradually decline as the product matures.
Selecting the Right Advertising Approach
Once a company decides on a specific advertising campaign, it must decide what approach should carry the message. A company is interested in several areas regarding advertising, such as frequency, media impact, media timing, and reach.
Frequency
Frequency refers to the average number of times that an average consumer is exposed to the advertising campaign. A company usually establishes frequency goals, which can vary for each campaign. For example, a company might want the average consumer exposed to the message at least six times during the campaign. In a crowded and competitive market, repetition is one of the best methods to increase product visibility and sales. The more exposure a company desires, the more expensive the campaign.
Media Impact
Media impact generally refers to how effective advertising will be through various media outlets (e.g., television, Internet, print). A company must decide, based on its product, the best method to maximize consumer interest and awareness. For example, a new laundry detergent might fare better with television commercials than print ads because more consumers are likely to see them. A company like Mercedes-Benz might advertise in specialty car magazines to reach a high percentage of potential customers. A thorough analysis of each medium's strengths and weaknesses relative to cost is conducted before any money is spent.
Media Timing
Media timing involves deciding when to run advertisements. Some companies run ads during holidays to promote season-specific products. Companies must also decide whether to employ a continuous or pulsing pattern. Continuous means advertisements run on a scheduled basis for a given time period, allowing a campaign to run longer and provide more exposure over time. Pulsing means advertisements are scheduled in a disproportionate manner within a given time frame, such as running thirty-two commercials over three to six months. The pulsing strategy has the advantage of potentially spending less money over a shorter period while still gaining recognition due to the campaign's intensity.
Reach
Reach refers to the percentage of customers in the target market who are exposed to the advertising campaign for a given time period. A company might have a goal of reaching at least 80 percent of its target audience. The goal is to be as close to 100 percent as possible because the more the target audience is exposed to the message, the higher the chance of future sales.
Impact of Advertising
The impact of advertising has been a matter of considerable debate. During debates about banning cigarette advertising, cigarette manufacturers claimed that cigarette advertising does not encourage people to smoke who would not otherwise. Opponents claimed that advertising does increase consumption. According to many media sources, the past experience and state of mind of the person subjected to advertising may determine its impact. Children under the age of four may be unable to distinguish advertising from other television programs, while the ability to determine the truthfulness of the message may not develop until age eight.
Public Perception of the Medium
As advertising becomes increasingly ubiquitous in modern Western societies, the industry has come under criticism of culture jamming, which criticizes media and consumerism using advertising's own techniques. The industry is accused of being one of the engines powering a convoluted economic mass production system that promotes consumption. Media-watch-uk, a British special interest group, works to educate consumers about registering concerns with advertisers and regulators. The award-winning book, Made You Look: How Advertising Works and Why You Should Know, by Shari Graydon, provides context for these issues for young readers.
Compensation Demanded
Public interest groups increasingly suggest that access to the mental space targeted by advertisers should be taxed, as this space is currently being freely taken advantage of with no compensation paid to the public who are intruded upon. This kind of tax would act to reduce what is now increasingly seen as a public nuisance. Arkansas and Maine have considered bills to implement such taxation. Florida enacted such a tax in 1987 but was forced to repeal it after six months due to a concerted effort by national commercial interests, which withdrew planned conventions causing major losses to the tourism industry and cancelled advertising causing a loss of $12 million to the broadcast industry alone.
Negative Effects on Communication Media
An extensively documented effect is the control and vetoing of free information by advertisers. Any negative information about a company or its products often results in pressures to withdraw such information, threatening to cut ads. This behavior makes editors self-censor content that might upset their ad payers. The bigger both companies are, the bigger their relationship gets, maximizing control over single information. Advertisers may try to minimize information about or from consumer groups, consumer-controlled purchasing initiatives, or consumer-controlled quality information systems.
Another indirect effect of advertising is to modify the very nature of the communication media where it is shown. Media that get most of their revenues from publicity try to make their medium a good place for communicating ads. The clearest example is television, where this means trying to keep the public in a mental state that encourages them not to switch channels through ads. Programs that are low in mental stimulus, require light concentration, and are varied are best for long sitting times, making easier emotional jumps to ads. A simple way to understand objectives in television programming is to compare contents from channels paid and chosen by the viewer with channels that get their income mainly from advertisements.
Future
With the dawn of the Internet have come many new advertising opportunities, including pop-up, Flash, banner, adver-gaming, and email advertisements (the last often being spam). Each year, greater sums are paid to obtain commercial spots during super sporting events like cricket and football championships. Companies attempt to make these commercials sufficiently entertaining that people will want to watch them.
Another problem is people recording shows on DVRs (e.g., TiVo), which allow users to fast forward through commercials. Additionally, as more "Boxed Sets" of television shows come out, fewer people watch shows on traditional TV. However, the fact that these sets are sold means the company receives additional profits from sales. To counter this, many advertisers have opted for product placement (prizes during TV shows). Since the rise of "entertaining" advertising, some people may like an advert enough to watch it later or show a friend, though the advertising community has not yet made this easy, although some have used the Internet to widely distribute their adverts.
๐ก Why this matters: Advertising is not just about selling productsโit shapes consumer behavior, influences media content, and raises important questions about privacy, manipulation, and social responsibility that affect everyone in modern society.
โญ Key Takeaways
The four core advertising objectivesโtrial, continuity, brand switching, and switchbackโare selected based on the product's life cycle stage and target different customer behaviors. Advertising budgets are influenced by multiple factors including frequency, competition, market share, product differentiation, and product life cycle stage, with new products requiring the highest investment. The right advertising approach requires careful consideration of frequency goals, media impact across different outlets, continuous versus pulsing timing strategies, and reach targets. Advertising has significant social and ethical implications, including its impact on children's perception, the control advertisers exert over media content through financial pressure, and growing demands for compensation or taxation for the mental space advertising occupies. Future trends include Internet-based advertising formats, product placement to counter DVR usage, and the increasing need for entertaining commercials to maintain viewer engagement.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four advertising objectives, and how does the product life cycle influence which one a company selects?
- What is advertising frequency, and how many times does research suggest a consumer needs to encounter a message before remembering it?
- Explain the difference between continuous and pulsing patterns of media timing, including one advantage of each.
- How do advertisers exert control over media content, and what is an example of the economic consequences when this control is challenged?
- What are two future advertising trends mentioned in the lecture, and what problem does each address?
๐ Lecture 39 โ Media Theories
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces four major media theories that explain the relationship between media and social reality. It explores how different societies control, regulate, and view the media's role, from complete state control to absolute freedom and socially responsible models. Understanding these theories is essential for grasping how media functions in various political and cultural contexts.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining media theory and explaining media's unique dual status as both an industry and a social critic. It then examines four distinct media theories: Authoritarian Theory, which enforces state control; Libertarian Theory, which champions absolute freedom; Soviet Theory, which ties media to communist ideology; and Social Responsibility Theory, which balances freedom with obligations to society. The lecture concludes with an open debate on the ongoing criticism and evolving role of media in democratic societies.
๐ Lecture Summary
The term media theory
The media theory refers to a model that explains the relationship between media and social reality. Media holds a unique statusโfrom one way, it is like an industry which provides products and services to earn money, but from another way, media is supposed to talk about society, people, attitude, interaction, guidance, and the most crucial and sensitive function: criticism. The criticism media directs at individuals, business sectors, and governments pinches many in many ways. If media does not perform this function, it is rendered redundant.
Authoritarian Theory
Long before democratic societies could think of matters pertaining to freedom of speech, there existed a thought that the emergence of media should not challenge the writ of the government, which were more dictatorial in form. The media was forced to remain under state control. Its features include:
- Direct governmental control of the media.
- Typical to pre-democratic societies where the government consists of a very limited and small ruling-class.
- No printing that could undermine the established authority.
- No offense to existing political set up.
- The government may punish anyone who questions the state's ideology.
- Media professionals are not allowed to have any independence within the media organization.
- Registration of the media by the state.
This approach is designed to protect the established social order, setting clear limits to media freedom and ensuring that it is not the media which must talk about people and their problems in any manner.
๐ Definition โ Authoritarian Theory: A media theory where the media is forced to remain under direct state control and cannot challenge the government's writ.
Libertarian Theory
This theory is in direct contrast to the authoritarian approach. Here, media enjoys an absolute freedom of expression. Its prominent features include:
- Competitive exposure of alternative viewpoints.
- Attacks on the government's policies are accepted and even encouraged: the media acts as a watchdog.
- Journalists and media professionals ought to have full autonomy within the media organization.
- There is no explicit connection between the government and the media.
- The press is free from censorship.
- It is accountable to the law for any consequences of its activities that infringe other individualsโ rights or the legitimate claims of society.
- The protection of dignity, reputation, property, privacy, moral development of individuals, groups, minorities, even the security of the stateโno infringement accepted from media.
Such extensive freedom is also a problem: all people have the right to speak and receive information freely, but no one takes responsibility for wrongdoings. Ethics in multicultural or pluralistic societies vary from place to place, hence there is always complaint against the media of each other's society.
๐ Definition โ Libertarian Theory: A media theory where the press enjoys absolute freedom of expression, acts as a watchdog, and is free from censorship but accountable to the law.
Soviet Theory
With the revolution in Russia in 1917 and the practice of Marxism, a very different approach to deal with media appeared. The media was tied to overall communist ideas. The theory to control media possessed following features:
- Closely tied to the communist ideology.
- The media is collective agitator, propagandist and educator in the building of communism.
- No private ownership of the media.
- The government is superior to the media institutions.
- The media is supposed to be serious.
The soviet theory does not favor free expression, but proposes a positive role for the media, the society and the world.
๐ Definition โ Soviet Theory: A media theory where media is tied to communist ideology, acts as agitator, propagandist, and educator, with no private ownership and government superiority over media institutions.
Social Responsibility Theory
This theory keeps certain areas free for the Press but at the same time puts a lot of responsibility on the media. Due to its unique nature, society expects a particular role which media must play in getting rid of social evils, educating people, criticizing government policies, and exposing other wrongdoings in society. The sense of responsibility has been emphasized more in this theory as compared to any other. Its features include:
- Media has certain obligations to society.
- It must show truth, accuracy, objectivity, and balance.
- The media should be free but self-regulated (codes of conduct, and ethics).
- The media is pluralistic: it reflects diversity of society, various points of view, and acts as a forum for ideas.
- The media ownership is a public trust. The journalist is accountable to his audience/readers.
๐ Definition โ Social Responsibility Theory: A media theory emphasizing that media should be free but self-regulated, must show truth and balance, reflect diversity, and consider media ownership as a public trust.
Theories and open debate on media
Not confined to the extent of theories, the media always faces (and is open to) criticism, and social scientists keep this debate open regarding how best media could be used to improve the functioning of civil society and promotion of democratic sense and practices. In their view, if people's knowledge, understandings, capabilities, and actions are manufactured, it simultaneously follows that they can be developed, improved, and individualized in proper (ideal-democratic) circumstances. Among these circumstances, proper communication networks are inevitable.
Because of new developments, the relationship among the state, private sectors, markets, and civil society profoundly changed during the 1980s. In politically and economically advanced societies, the change is based on new information and telecommunications technologies, which affected the media industries in terms of economic restructuring and on a new social and political environment as reflected by media contents.
A basic question arises: Who gave media the right to do the things they do? Investigating wrongdoings by public officials, delving into the private lives of public figures, and reporting on the shortcomings of government and institutions are all forms of criticism media face all over the world. The purpose of this topic is to make people linked with mass media understand the relationship between media and society and how the media is understood by scholars in the society.
๐ก Why this matters: This open debate highlights that media theories are not static; they evolve with technology and society. Understanding this ongoing discussion helps us critically evaluate the media's role and its relationship with power structures.
โญ Key Takeaways
The lecture presents four foundational media theories that explain how different societies view and control media. Authoritarian Theory places media under strict state control to protect the established order, while Libertarian Theory grants absolute freedom with the media acting as a watchdog, though this can lead to accountability issues. Soviet Theory ties media entirely to communist ideology for propaganda and education with no private ownership. Social Responsibility Theory strikes a balance, allowing freedom but demanding truth, accuracy, objectivity, self-regulation, and a public trust orientation. The lecture emphasizes that media's unique dual nature as both a business and a social critic makes these theories essential for understanding ongoing debates about media's rights, responsibilities, and evolving role in democratic and non-democratic societies.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the key differences between Authoritarian Theory and Libertarian Theory regarding state control and media freedom?
- According to Soviet Theory, what three specific roles does media play in building communism?
- List four obligations that Social Responsibility Theory places on the media.
- What is the main problem with absolute freedom under Libertarian Theory, especially in multicultural societies?
- What fundamental question about media's legitimacy is raised in the concluding section of this lecture?