📘 Lecture 1 — Reconceiving the Challenge of Change: The Importance of Individual Development
📖 Overview: This lecture redefines the challenge of change, arguing that it is not simply about learning new coping skills but about growing our mental complexity to match the world's increasing demands. It introduces an updated, research-based view of adult mental development, showing that our capacity can grow throughout life through distinct, qualitative plateaus. Understanding this is crucial for leaders seeking to develop themselves and their organizations for long-term success.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by redefining the challenge of change as a mismatch between the complexity of the world and our own mental capacity, arguing that true development, not just coping, is required. It then presents an updated view of adult mental development, contrasting the old assumption of a flat trajectory after age 20 with new longitudinal research showing a lifelong, upward-sloping curve with significant individual variation. Finally, it introduces the concept of three qualitatively different plateaus in adult mental complexity—the Socialized Mind, the Self-Authoring Mind, and the Self-Transforming Mind—each representing a distinct way of knowing and understanding the world.
📝 Lecture Summary
Reconceiving the Challenge of Change
The lecture begins by asserting that a leader's distinct advantage will be the ability to develop themselves, their people, and their teams. Human capability is the critical variable, but it is a mistake to see it as a fixed resource to be found "out there." Instead, leaders should ask how to make their setting the most fertile ground for the growth of talent. The challenge of change is frequently misunderstood as a need to better "cope" with complexity.
💡 Why this matters: Coping involves adding new skills while remaining the same person; this is learning, not development. In reality, the experience of complexity signals a mismatch between the world's demands and our own capacity. The only logical solution is to increase our own mental capacity, as reducing the world's complexity is impossible.
An Updated View of Age and Mental Complexity
This section corrects a widespread misconception that mental development ends in one's twenties, similar to physical development. Old graphs showed an upward sloping line until the twenties and a flat line thereafter (Figure 1). However, thirty years of longitudinal research—analyzing transcripts of hundreds of people re-interviewed at intervals—has produced a new graph (Figure 2).
🔑 Definition — Mental Complexity: The capacity of a person's mind to understand and handle more complex information, perspectives, and demands.
📐 Formula: The Development Hypothesis: Mismatch = World's Complexity > Person's Mental Complexity → To reduce the mismatch, we must increase the person's mental complexity.
📌 Example: The research shows that for a large sample, mental complexity has a mildly upward-sloping curve with age, but there is considerable variation within any age. For instance, six people in their thirties (bolded dots) could all be at different levels of mental complexity, and some could be more complex than a person in her forties.
The individual trajectory of development (Figure 3) shows:
- There are qualitatively distinct levels ("plateaus") representing different ways of knowing the world.
- Development occurs in periods of stability and change, not continuously.
- The intervals between transformations to new levels ("time on a plateau") get longer and longer.
- The line gets thinner, representing fewer people reaching the higher plateaus.
Three Plateaus in Adult Mental Complexity
This section provides a quick overview of three qualitatively different plateaus seen in adults (Figures 4 & 5). These are not about intelligence but about the structure of how one makes meaning of the world.
The first plateau is the Socialized Mind. At this stage, a person is fundamentally shaped by the expectations and definitions of their surroundings—their family, work team, or culture. They lack a coherent, internal "self" to vet these external demands, making them highly susceptible to influence and authority. Their identity is tied to fulfilling the expectations of the groups they belong to.
The second plateau is the Self-Authoring Mind. Here, a person has developed an internal "voice" or internal compass—a personal ideology, value system, or set of standards. Instead of being authored by external expectations, they author their own direction. They can take a stand, set boundaries, and make independent decisions, even when they conflict with external pressures.
The third plateau is the Self-Transforming Mind. At this advanced stage, a person can not only author their own internal system but can also step back and reflect on it. They see their internal system as a system, with inherent limitations and biases. They are able to recognize the blind spots in their own worldview and are open to re-authoring it by integrating the perspectives of other systems. They are comfortable with contradiction and seek to evolve their identity.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical lesson is that the challenge of change is fundamentally a challenge of personal development, not just coping or skill acquisition. Development means growing your mental complexity to better match the world's demands, and contrary to old beliefs, this capacity can increase significantly throughout adulthood. The path of development follows distinct, qualitative plateaus—from a Socialized Mind dependent on others, to a Self-Authoring Mind that creates its own direction, to the rarer Self-Transforming Mind that can reflect on and evolve its own system. Leaders must understand these levels to foster growth in themselves and others, as the key to success in a complex world is cultivating internal capacity, not just external skills.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What is the key distinction between "learning to cope" and "development" as presented in the lecture?
- According to the new longitudinal research, what does the graph of mental complexity across adulthood look like, and what have we learned about individual variation?
- What are the three distinct plateaus of adult mental development, and what is the core "way of knowing" for each?
- How does the experience of "overwhelming complexity" get redefined in this lecture?
- Why is a leader's ability to develop their own mental capacity considered more important than simply finding talented people?
📘 Lecture 2 — Reconceiving the Challenge of Change: The Importance of Individual Development (Continued)
📖 Overview: This lecture continues exploring how different levels of mental complexity—the socialized, self-authoring, and self-transforming minds—handle information flow in organizational settings. It presents research evidence linking higher mental complexity to superior work performance and leadership effectiveness, while also revealing a critical gap: most adults operate below the level their jobs now demand. The lecture introduces the Subject-Object Interview (SOI) as a tool for assessing mental complexity and distinguishes between technical and adaptive challenges, arguing that many organizational change efforts fail because leaders mistakenly apply technical solutions to adaptive problems.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture examines how the socialized mind, self-authoring mind, and self-transforming mind each send and receive information differently, with profound consequences for organizational behavior. It presents Keith Eigel's study correlating mental complexity with work competence among CEOs and middle managers, describes the Subject-Object Interview assessment methodology, analyzes shifts in demands on subordinates (from socialized to self-authoring) and leaders (from self-authoring to self-transforming), presents meta-analytic data showing most adults are not at the self-authoring level, and concludes with Ronald Heifetz's distinction between technical and adaptive challenges.
📝 Lecture Summary
HOW INFORMATION IS SENT AND RECEIVED
THE SOCIALIZED MIND The socialized mind sends information based on what it believes others want to hear. This aligns with findings from groupthink studies. When receiving information, the socialized mind is highly sensitive—it picks up far beyond the required message and invests close attention in imagined subtexts. Such a person may read hidden meanings into routine communications.
SELF-AUTHORING MIND The self-authoring mind sends information strategically—it says what will make people follow and what needs to be heard to advance its own plan. Its goal is to "get behind the wheel and drive." When receiving information, it creates a filter: first priority goes to information that was actively sought; second priority goes to information relevant to the plan. There is no third priority—anything else is simply ignored or dismissed.
SELF-TRANSFORMING MIND The self-transforming mind also has a filter, but differs in a critical way. While it values its own stances, it remains wary about any single stance. It recognizes that it lives in time and the world is in motion. When communicating, it does not merely advance its own agenda—it actively looks for modification and expansion of that agenda. It seeks information that may lead itself or its team to enhance, refine, alter the original design, or make it more inclusive.
💡 Why this matters: Each successive level of mental complexity can perform the mental functions of the prior level plus additional ones, meaning higher levels outperform lower levels in real organizational contexts.
MENTAL COMPLEXITY AND PERFORMANCE
Keith Eigel assessed the mental complexity of 21 CEOs of large, successful companies (each an industry leader with average gross revenue over $5 billion) using the Subject-Object Interview (SOI). For comparison, he also assessed promising middle managers nominated by those same CEOs. Results showed a clearly discernible upward slope: increased mental complexity and work competence are correlated. This finding has been replicated in various fine-grained studies of leaders assessed on particular competencies.
🔑 Definition — Subject-Object Interview (SOI): A ninety-minute interview that assesses mental complexity by distinguishing thoughts/feelings we can look at (take as object) from those that "have us" (are subject to). Greater complexity means being able to take more as object, making the blind spot (what is subject) smaller.
📌 Example of SOI process: The interviewer hands the subject ten index cards with cues: Angry, Anxious/Nervous, Success, Strong Stand/Conviction, Sad, Torn, Moved/Touched, Lost Something/Farewells, Change, Important. The interviewee makes notes about recent experiences for each cue, then the interviewer probes the whys behind the whats to discover the underlying principle governing what the person can and cannot see. The interview can identify five different transitional places between any two mindsets with high inter-rater reliability.
SHIFTS IN THE DEMANDS ON FOLLOWERS AND LEADERS
On subordinates (followers): Yesterday's world required people to be good team players, pull their weight, be loyal, and follow directions conscientiously. The socialized mind was perfectly adequate. Today, most organizations need workers who operate at the self-authoring mind level—capable of independent direction, self-motivation, and taking initiative.
On leaders: Organizational theorist Chris Argyris highlights the insufficiency of traditional managerial effectiveness. Yesterday's leaders could focus on developing worthy goals, cultivating alignment, keeping performance within specified ranges, and advocating for positions with strength. Today's leaders must not only run but reconstitute their organizations—its norms, missions, and culture—in a fast-changing environment. This requires the self-transforming mind level.
📐 Formula for the shift: Yesterday → Today
- Followers: Socialized mind → Self-authoring mind
- Leaders: Self-authoring mind → Self-transforming mind
Two large meta-analyses (using the Washington University Sentence Completion Test (SCT) and the Subject-Object Interview) reveal:
- In a majority of respondents, mental complexity is not as far along as the self-authoring mind.
- The percentages of people beyond the self-authoring plateau are quite small.
- The gap between what we expect of people's minds and what they actually are is large.
- IQ has only modest correlation with mental complexity; a person with an IQ of 125 can be at any of the three plateaus.
💡 Why this matters: This means most workers are expected to be self-authoring, but most are not—creating a fundamental mismatch between job demands and actual capability.
MENTAL COMPLEXITY AND "TECHNICAL" VERSUS "ADAPTIVE" CHALLENGES
Ronald Heifetz distinguishes between two kinds of change challenges:
🔑 Definition — Technical challenge: A change requiring known skills and proven routines. The necessary skill set is well understood, and training processes are well practiced. Example: learning to remove an inflamed appendix or land a plane with a stuck nose wheel. Success does not require mental growth.
🔑 Definition — Adaptive challenge: A change requiring transforming one's mindset to a more sophisticated stage of mental development. Success demands personal growth, not just new technical skills.
The biggest error leaders make, according to Heifetz, is applying technical means to solve adaptive challenges. This misdiagnosis prevents the very changes leaders want to bring about. The implication: we must find adaptive (nontechnical) means of supporting ourselves and others to meet adaptive challenges.
💡 Why this matters: Complexity is about the relationship between the world's demands and our own mental complexity. When mental complexity lags behind demand complexity, we are "in over our heads." The next question becomes: can we actually incubate and accelerate mental complexity?
⭐ Key Takeaways
The three mindsets—socialized, self-authoring, and self-transforming—handle information flow differently, with the self-transforming mind uniquely capable of seeking modification to its own agenda. Research confirms that higher mental complexity correlates with superior work performance for both CEOs and middle managers, as shown in Eigel's study of 21 large-company leaders. However, meta-analyses reveal a troubling gap: the majority of adults operate below the self-authoring mind level, while modern organizations increasingly demand this level from workers and even higher levels from leaders. This mismatch explains why many change efforts fail—leaders misdiagnose adaptive challenges (which require personal transformation) as technical ones (which only require new skills). The Subject-Object Interview provides a reliable method for assessing mental complexity by probing what people can take as object versus what they remain subject to.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- How does the self-transforming mind differ from the self-authoring mind when receiving information?
- What did Keith Eigel's study of 21 CEOs demonstrate about the relationship between mental complexity and work competence?
- What are the ten cues used in the Subject-Object Interview, and what does the interviewer probe beyond the initial "whats"?
- According to the meta-analyses presented, what percentage of people reach the self-authoring mind plateau or beyond?
- What is the critical difference between a technical challenge and an adaptive challenge, and what mistake does Heifetz say leaders commonly make?
📘 Lecture 3 — Forces Affecting Working and Learning
📖 Overview: This lecture introduces the key forces influencing how people work and learn in modern organizations. It explains why training and development are critical for business survival and competitiveness in a global economy, and introduces foundational concepts like human capital, intangible assets, and the learning organization.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the major forces affecting working and learning including globalization, economic cycles, the increased value of intangible assets and human capital, the focus on linking training to business strategy, changing workforce demographics and diversity, talent management, and new technology. It also explains concepts such as knowledge workers, employee engagement, continuous learning, and provides detailed examples of intangible assets like human, customer, social, and intellectual capital.
📝 Lecture Summary
THE FORCES INFLUENCING WORKING AND LEARNING
Multiple forces are shaping how we purchase products, learn, communicate, and what we value at work. These forces—including globalization, demographic changes, new technologies, and economic changes—affect individuals, communities, businesses, and society. To survive, companies must address these forces, with training playing an important role.
Key forces include: Economic cycles, Globalization, Increased value placed on intangible assets and human capital, Focus on link to business strategy, Changing demographics and diversity of the work force, Talent Management, Customer service and quality emphasis, New technology, and High-performance work systems.
Globalization
Every business must be prepared to deal with the global economy. Global business expansion has been made easier by technology. The Internet allows data and information to be instantly accessible and sent around the world. The Internet, e-mail, and video conferencing enable business deals to be completed between companies thousands of miles apart.
Many companies enter international markets by exporting products overseas, building manufacturing facilities or service centers in other countries, entering alliances with foreign companies, and engaging in e-commerce. Developing nations such as Taiwan, Indonesia, and China may account for over 60 percent of the world economy by 2020.
Economic cycles
The term business cycle (or economic cycle) refers to economy-wide fluctuations in production, trade, and economic activity over several months or years in an economy organized on free-enterprise principles.
The business cycle is the upward and downward movements of levels of GDP (gross domestic product) and refers to periods of expansions and contractions in the level of economic activities (business fluctuations) around its long-term growth trend. These fluctuations typically involve shifts between periods of relatively rapid economic growth (an expansion or boom) and periods of relative stagnation or decline (a contraction or recession). Business cycles are usually measured by considering the growth rate of real gross domestic product. Despite being termed cycles, these fluctuations can prove unpredictable.
Increased Value Placed on Intangible Assets and Human Capital
Today more companies are interested in intangible assets and human capital as a way to gain a competitive advantage. Training and development can help a company’s competitiveness by directly increasing the company’s value through contributing to intangible assets.
A company’s value includes three types of assets critical for providing goods and services: financial assets (cash and securities), physical assets (property, plant, equipment), and intangible assets. Intangible assets consist of human capital, customer capital, social capital, and intellectual capital.
🔑 Definition — Human Capital: The sum of the attributes, life experiences, knowledge, inventiveness, energy, and enthusiasm that the company’s employees invest in their work.
🔑 Definition — Intellectual Capital: The codified knowledge that exists in a company.
🔑 Definition — Social Capital: Relationships within the company, including corporate culture, management philosophy, informal networking systems, and coaching/mentoring relationships.
🔑 Definition — Customer Capital: The value of relationships with persons or other organizations outside the company for accomplishing company goals (e.g., relationships with suppliers, customers, vendors, government agencies).
📌 Example — Intangible Assets Categories:
- Human Capital: Tacit knowledge, education, work-related know-how, work-related competence
- Customer Capital: Customer relationships, brands, customer loyalty, distribution channels
- Social Capital: Corporate culture, management philosophy, management practices, informal networking systems, coaching/mentoring relationships
- Intellectual Capital: Patents, copyrights, trade secrets, intellectual property
Intangible assets are equally as valuable as financial and physical assets but they are nonmonetary and cannot be touched. Training and development have a direct influence on human and social capital by affecting education, work-related know-how, competence, and work relationships. Training can indirectly influence customer and social capital by helping employees better serve customers and create patents and intellectual property.
💡 Why this matters: Intangible assets contribute to a company's competitive advantage because they are difficult to duplicate or imitate. The value of intangible assets and human capital has three important implications: (1) A focus on knowledge workers, (2) Employee engagement, and (3) An increased emphasis on adapting to change and continuous learning.
Focus on Knowledge Workers
One way a company can increase its intangible assets, specifically human capital, is by focusing on attracting, developing, and retaining knowledge workers.
🔑 Definition — Knowledge Workers: Employees who contribute to the company not through manual labor but through what they know, perhaps about customers or a specialized body of knowledge.
Employees cannot simply be ordered to perform tasks; they must share knowledge and collaborate on solutions. Knowledge workers contribute specialized knowledge that their managers may not have, such as information about customers. Knowledge workers have many job opportunities and if they choose, they can leave a company and take their knowledge to a competitor.
Employee Engagement
To fully benefit from employees’ knowledge, a management style focusing on engaging employees is required.
🔑 Definition — Employee Engagement: The degree to which employees are fully involved in their work and the strength of their commitment to their job and the company.
Engaged employees give companies a competitive advantage including higher productivity, better customer service, and lower turnover. Training and development provides employees with opportunities for personal growth and helps provide the company with knowledge and skills needed for competitive advantage. Using flexible training delivery methods like online learning helps build employee commitment.
Change and Continuous Learning
Companies need to be able to adapt to change. Change refers to the adoption of a new idea or behavior by a company. Technological advances, workforce changes, government regulations, globalization, and new competitors all require companies to change. Change is inevitable as products, companies, and entire industries experience shorter life cycles.
A learning organization embraces a culture of lifelong learning, enabling all employees to continually acquire and share knowledge. Employees need financial, time, and content resources (courses, experiences, development opportunities) to increase their knowledge. Managers take an active role in identifying training needs and ensuring employees use training in their work. For a learning organization to succeed, teams must collaborate to meet customer needs, and managers must empower employees to share knowledge, identify problems, and make decisions.
Focus on Link to Business Strategy
Given the important role of intangible assets and human capital in competitiveness, managers see training and development as a means to support a company’s business strategy—its plans for meeting broad goals such as profitability, market share, and quality. Managers expect training professionals to design learning activities that help the company successfully implement its strategy and reach business goals.
Changing Demographics and Diversity of the Work Force
Companies face several challenges from increased demographics and diversity of the work force. Population is the single most important factor in determining the size and composition of the labor force, which is composed of people who are either working or looking for work.
Increase in Ethnic and Racial Diversity: Companies must address race, gender, ethnicity, and nationality issues and develop training programs to help immigrants acquire technical and customer service skills.
Aging Work Force: The labor force continues to age. The 55 years and older segment is expected to grow by approximately 47 percent between 2006–2016. Older individuals are leading healthier, longer lives, and the high cost of health insurance and decrease in health benefits cause many to keep working. Despite myths, worker performance and learning in most jobs is not adversely affected by aging. Older employees are willing and able to learn new technology.
Because of this diversity, employees will not hold similar work values. To maximize motivation and commitment, employees should be given opportunities to develop skills, meet interests, and balance work and non-work activities.
📌 Example — Using Diversity for Competitive Advantage:
- Cost: Companies that handle diversity well create cost advantages
- Employee Attraction and Retention: Best reputations for managing diversity attract women and minorities
- Market Share: Cultural sensitivity improves marketing efforts
- Creativity: Diversity of perspectives improves creativity
- Problem-solving: Heterogeneous groups produce better decisions
- Flexibility: Greater adaptability in rapidly changing markets
To successfully manage a diverse workforce, managers need training in: communicating effectively with diverse backgrounds; coaching employees of different ages, backgrounds, ethnicities, and abilities; providing unbiased performance feedback; recognizing generational differences; and creating an inclusive creative environment.
Talent Management
🔑 Definition — Talent Management: The process of attracting, retaining, developing, and motivating highly skilled employees and managers.
Talent management is increasingly important due to changes in demand for certain occupations, skill requirements, anticipated retirement of baby boomers, and the need to develop managerial talent with leadership skills. Opportunities for career growth, learning, and development, and performing exciting, challenging work are among the most important factors determining employee engagement and commitment.
New Technology
Technology has reshaped how we play, communicate, plan our lives, and where we work. The Internet has created a new business model—e-commerce, where business transactions and relationships can be conducted electronically. Over 79 percent of adults go online spending an average of 11 hours a week on the Internet. Technology continues to impact all economic sectors, with robotics, computer-assisted design, radio frequency identification, and nanotechnology transforming manufacturing. Technology has also made equipment easier to operate, helping companies cope with skill shortages and allowing older workers to postpone retirement.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts from this lecture are: (1) Training and development directly contribute to a company's intangible assets—human capital, social capital, customer capital, and intellectual capital—which provide sustainable competitive advantage because they are difficult to imitate. (2) Multiple forces including globalization, economic cycles, workforce demographics, and new technology are reshaping how organizations must approach learning and development to survive. (3) Companies must focus on attracting and retaining knowledge workers, fostering employee engagement, and creating learning organizations that embrace continuous change and lifelong learning. (4) Workforce diversity requires targeted training in new skills like cross-cultural communication, unbiased performance feedback, and generational awareness to turn diversity into competitive advantage. (5) Talent management—attracting, developing, retaining, and motivating skilled employees—is essential for organizational success, and training must be directly linked to business strategy.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three types of company assets, and which type does training and development most directly influence?
- Define human capital and explain why intangible assets provide a competitive advantage that is difficult for competitors to duplicate.
- What is a learning organization, and what role do managers and employees play in making it successful?
- List four ways that workforce diversity can provide a competitive advantage for companies.
- How does technology impact working and learning, and what is the relationship between the Internet and e-commerce?
📘 Lecture 4 — Introduction to Training and Development
📖 Overview: This lecture introduces the fundamental concepts of training and development, distinguishing training from education and development while emphasizing the strategic importance of high-leverage training. It presents the systematic training design process (ADDIE model) as a framework for creating effective training programs that link directly to business goals and performance improvement.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the definition and purpose of training, the essential components of training and development, distinctions between training versus education and training versus development, objectives of T&D, the concept of high-leverage training and continuous learning, the shift toward performance-focused training, and the seven-step training design process based on Instructional System Design (ISD), including its assumptions and criticisms.
📝 Lecture Summary
Training refers to a planned effort by a company to facilitate employees’ learning of job-related competencies
These competencies include knowledge, skills, or behaviors that are critical for successful job performance. The goal of training is for employees to master the knowledge, skill, and behaviors emphasized in training programs and to apply them to their day-to-day activities. For a company to gain a competitive advantage, its training has to involve more than just basic skill development. That is, to use training to gain a competitive advantage, a company should view training broadly as a way to create intellectual capital. Intellectual capital includes basic skills (skills needed to perform one’s job), advanced skills (such as how to use technology to share information with other employees), an understanding of the customer or manufacturing system, and self-motivated creativity. Traditionally, most of the emphasis on training has been at the basic and advanced skill levels.
🔑 Definition — Training: a planned effort by a company to facilitate employees’ learning of job-related competencies (knowledge, skills, or behaviors) critical for successful job performance.
Essential components of T&D
- There should be need identification.
- The improvement in skills, behaviours or abilities, that should come from the process of learning.
- The learning process must lead to a change.
Difference between training and education
| Training | Education |
|---|---|
| Narrow perspective | Broad perspective |
| Application | Theoretical definition |
| Job experience | Classroom Learning |
| Specific tasks | General concepts |
Difference between Training & Development
- Development includes all those activities that are given as learning opportunities to help employees grow.
- Training is targeted towards a particular job or skill.
Objectives of training and development
- Develop the competencies of employees and improve their performance.
- Help the employees grow so that the future human resource needs of the organization can be met from within the organization.
- Reduce the learning time for employees starting in new jobs or appointments, transfers or promotions, and ensure that they become competent as quickly and economically as possible.
High-leverage training
Many companies have adopted a broader perspective known as high-leverage training. High-leverage training is linked to strategic business goals and objectives, uses an instructional design process to ensure that training is effective, and compares or benchmarks the company’s training programs against training programs in other companies. High-leverage training practices also help to create working conditions that encourage continuous learning. Continuous learning requires employees to understand the entire work system, including the relationships among their jobs, their work units, and the company. Employees are expected to acquire new skills and knowledge, apply them on the job, and share this information with other employees. Managers take an active role in identifying training needs and help to ensure that employees use training in their work. To facilitate the sharing of knowledge, managers may use informational maps that show where knowledge lies within the company (for example, directories that list what individuals do as well as the specialized knowledge they possess) and use technology such as groupware or the Internet that allows employees in various business units to work simultaneously on problems and share information.
💡 Why this matters: High-leverage training transforms training from a routine activity into a strategic tool that directly supports competitive advantage and business performance.
Performance-focused training
The emphasis on high-leverage training has been accompanied by a movement to link training to performance improvement. Companies have lost money on training because it is poorly designed, because it is not linked to a performance problem or business strategy, or because its outcomes have not been properly evaluated. Companies have been investing money into training simply because of the belief that it is a good thing to do. The perspective that the training function exists to deliver programs to employees without a compelling business reason for doing so is being abandoned. Today, training is being evaluated not on the basis of the number of programs offered and training activity in the company but on how training addresses business needs related to learning, behavior change, and performance improvement. Training is becoming more performance-focused — used to improve employee performance, which leads to improved business results. Training is seen as one of several possible solutions to improve performance. Other solutions include actions such as changing the job or increasing employee motivation through pay and incentives.
Today there is a greater emphasis on:
- Providing educational opportunities for all employees, which may include training programs, support for courses outside the company, self-study, and learning through job rotation.
- Performance improvement as an ongoing process that is directly measurable rather than a one-time training event.
- Demonstrating to executives, managers, and trainees the benefits of training.
- Learning as a lifelong event in which senior management, trainer managers, and employees have ownership.
- Training being used to help attain strategic business objectives, which help companies gain a competitive advantage.
The training design process (Figure 8)
The training design process refers to a systematic approach for developing training programs. Figure 1 presents the seven steps in this process:
Step 1 is to conduct a needs assessment, which is necessary to identify whether training is needed.
Step 2 is to ensure that employees have the motivation and basic skills necessary to master the training content.
Step 3 is to create a learning environment that has the features necessary for learning to occur.
Step 4 is to ensure that trainees apply the training content to their jobs. This step involves having the trainee understand how to manage skill improvement as well as getting co-worker and manager support.
Step 5 is to develop an evaluation plan. Developing an evaluation plan includes identifying what types of outcomes training is expected to influence (for example, learning, behavior, skills), choosing an evaluation design that allows you to determine the influence of training on these outcomes, and planning how to demonstrate how training affects the “bottom line” (that is, using a cost-benefit analysis to determine the monetary benefits resulting from training).
Step 6 is to choose the training method based on the learning objectives and learning environment. This step may include a traditional training method of face-to-face interaction with a trainer or e-learning using CD-ROM or Web-based training.
Step 7 is to evaluate the program and make changes in it or revisit any of the earlier steps in the process to improve the program so that learning, behavior, change, and the other learning objectives are obtained.
Instructional System Design (ISD)
The training design process shown in Figure 1 is based on principles of Instructional System Design (ISD). ISD refers to a process for designing and developing training programs. There is not one universally accepted instructional systems development model. The training design process sometimes is referred to as the ADDIE model because it includes: Analysis, Design, Development, Implementation, and Evaluation.
In Figure 1:
- Step 1 (needs assessment) and Step 2 (ensuring readiness) relate to Analysis.
- Steps 3, 4, and 5 (learning environment, transfer of training, evaluation plan) are Design issues.
- Step 6 (selecting and using a training method) relates to Implementation.
- Step 7 (monitoring and evaluating) relates to Evaluation.
Regardless of the specific ISD approach used, all share the following assumptions:
- Training design is effective only if it helps employees reach instructional or training goals and objectives.
- Measurable learning objectives should be identified before the training program begins.
- Evaluation plays an important part in planning and choosing a training method, monitoring the training program, and suggesting changes to the training design process.
Criticisms of the ISD model
Some training professionals argue that the ISD model is flawed for several reasons:
- In organizations, the training design process rarely follows the neat, orderly, step-by-step approach.
- Some organizations require trainers to provide detailed documents of each activity, adding time and cost to developing a training program.
- The ISD implies an end point: evaluation. However, good instructional design requires an iterative process of design, execution, evaluation, and reconsideration of the needs that the program was designed to meet as well as the learning environment, the transfer of training, and all the other activities.
Despite these criticisms, the ISD model can be considered a set of general guidelines that trainers need to follow to ensure effective training.
Flexibility and technology in training design
The training design process should be systematic yet flexible enough to adapt to business needs. Different steps may be completed simultaneously. Designing training unsystematically will reduce the benefits that can be realized. For example, choosing a training method before determining training needs or ensuring employees’ readiness for training increases the risk that the method chosen will not be the most effective one. Also, training may not even be necessary and may result in a waste of time and money if employees already have the knowledge, skills, or behavior they need but simply are not motivated to use them.
The introduction of new technologies such as podcasting highlights a shift from trainees having to learn from an instructor in one location to trainees learning independently and not being bound to learn in the workplace. Still, good training design requires determining the trainees’ needs, identifying resources so that trainees can learn what they need to know, and providing them with access to reference materials and knowledge bases when they encounter problems, issues, or questions on the job.
Web-based training example
The development of a Web-based training program focusing on teaching managers skills needed to run effective business meetings provides a good example of use of the instructional design process:
- Needs assessment involved determining that managers lacked skills for conducting effective meetings and identifying the type of meetings managers were involved in. The process involved interviewing managers and observing meetings. It also identified the most appropriate training method.
- Because managers were geographically dispersed and had easy access to computers, and because the company wanted a self-directed, self-paced program, Web-based training was chosen as the appropriate method.
- Readiness for training was ensured by confirming that managers could access the Web and were familiar with Web tools (e.g., Web browsers).
- Creating a positive learning environment on the Web involved clearly stating program objectives, providing exercises and feedback (e.g., asking trainees to prepare a meeting outline and providing feedback on correctness), and building in assessment tests that allowed trainees to skip ahead or return to earlier material based on test scores.
- Evaluation included a test of meeting skills that managers completed both before and after the program, with results stored in a data bank for comparison.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts from this lecture are: (1) Training is a planned effort to facilitate job-related competencies (knowledge, skills, behaviors) aimed at creating intellectual capital. (2) High-leverage training links directly to strategic business goals and uses systematic instructional design, representing a shift from training as a routine activity to a performance-improvement tool. (3) The training design process follows the ADDIE model (Analysis, Design, Development, Implementation, Evaluation) with seven sequential steps beginning with needs assessment and ending with program evaluation. (4) Training must be distinguished from education (narrow vs. broad perspective, application vs. theory) and from development (training targets specific jobs; development includes broader learning opportunities for growth). (5) The ISD model provides essential guidelines but must be applied flexibly, as rigid step-by-step application can add unnecessary time and cost, and good design requires an iterative rather than linear approach.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three essential components of training and development?
- How does training differ from education in terms of perspective and focus?
- What is high-leverage training, and how does it differ from traditional approaches to training?
- List the seven steps of the training design process and identify which ADDIE phase each step belongs to.
- What are the three main criticisms of the Instructional System Design (ISD) model?