📘 Lecture 05 — Strategic Training
📖 Overview: This lecture explores why training must be strategically aligned with business goals to contribute to organizational success. It examines how business strategy influences training decisions, the evolution of training’s role from programs to learning and knowledge creation, and the systematic process of strategic training and development. Understanding this strategic connection is critical because training functions that fail to demonstrate business value risk budget cuts or outsourcing.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by explaining the importance of strategic training and how strategy influences the training function, including decisions about skill focus, customization, access, and resource allocation. It then traces the evolution of training from a program focus to encompassing learning and knowledge creation, distinguishing between tacit and explicit knowledge. The strategic training and development process is presented as a four-step model: identifying business strategy, choosing strategic initiatives, providing training activities, and identifying metrics. Organizational factors and specific strategic types are discussed, followed by the Nokia case study demonstrating an integrated approach. The lecture concludes with how to organize the training function using business-embedded and corporate university models.
📝 Lecture Summary
Why is the emphasis on strategic training important?
Companies are in business to make money, and every function must show how it contributes to business success. A business strategy is a plan that integrates the company’s goals, policies, and actions. The strategy influences how the company uses physical capital (plants, technology, equipment), financial capital (assets, cash reserves), and human capital (employees). The business strategy helps direct all company activities toward specific medium- and long-term goals, which typically include financial goals like maximizing shareholder wealth, as well as goals related to employee satisfaction, industry position, and community service. There is both a direct and indirect link between training and business strategy: training that develops job skills directly affects the business, while learning opportunities create a positive work environment that attracts, motivates, and retains talented employees.
💡 Why this matters: Training departments must justify their existence by showing how they help achieve strategic goals, or they risk being cut or outsourced.
How strategy influences training and development function
Business strategy has a major impact on the type, amount, and resource allocation for training. Strategy determines:
- Whether training focuses on current or future job skills.
- Whether training is customized for individual employees or developed for teams, units, or divisions.
- Whether training is restricted to specific groups (e.g., managerial talent) or open to all employees.
- Whether training is planned and systematic, reactive to problems, or spontaneous based on competitor actions.
- The importance of training compared to other HR practices like selection and compensation.
Evolution of training’s role
Traditionally, training was seen as an event or program to develop specific explicit knowledge and skills. However, managers and HR professionals now recognize the value of experience-based knowledge that cannot be taught in programs. Learning refers to the acquisition of knowledge by individual employees or groups who are willing to apply that knowledge in their jobs to make decisions and accomplish tasks. Knowledge refers to what individuals or teams know or know how to do (human and social knowledge) as well as company rules, processes, tools, and routines (structured knowledge).
🔑 Definition — Explicit knowledge: Knowledge that can be formalized, codified, and communicated; it can be found in manuals, formulas, and specifications. 🔑 Definition — Tacit knowledge: Personal knowledge based on individual experience that is difficult to explain to others; it is passed along through direct experience like interacting with others or watching other employees.
Employees need knowledge about the company (business, strategy, financial statements, organization), about customers (who they are, what they need, why they choose the company), and about the company’s business processes. Well-designed traditional training can teach explicit knowledge, but tacit knowledge requires interpersonal interaction and experiences not typically found in training programs.
Traditional training is seen as a series of programs or events employees attend, then they are responsible for using what they learned with no guarantee of manager support. It provides no information linking training content to performance objectives or business goals, and usually fails to improve workplace performance. This approach assumes business conditions are predictable and controllable, which is true only for certain skills like communication and conflict resolution.
The emphasis on learning has four implications:
- Learning must be related to helping employees’ performance improve and the company achieve business goals, ensuring motivation and focused resource allocation.
- Because business problems cannot be predicted, learning must occur on an as-needed basis through job experiences and Web-based training.
- Companies need to support informal learning through mentoring, chat rooms, and job experiences to acquire tacit knowledge.
- Learning must be supported physically, technically, and psychologically through a supportive work environment and managers who encourage learning and help employees find suitable development activities.
Creating and sharing knowledge refers to companies’ development of human capital.
🔑 Definition — Human capital: Includes cognitive knowledge (know what), advanced skills (know how), system understanding and creativity (know why), and self-motivated creativity (care why).
Traditionally, training focused on cognitive and advanced skills (know what and know how), but the greatest business value may come from developing system understanding (know why) and self-motivated creativity (care why). To create and share knowledge, companies must provide physical space and technology (e-mail, websites) to encourage employee collaboration and knowledge sharing.
THE STRATEGIC TRAINING AND DEVELOPMENT PROCESS
The process begins with identifying the business strategy, then choosing strategic training and development initiatives that support the strategy. Next, these initiatives are translated into concrete training and development activities. The final step involves identifying measures or metrics used to determine whether training has helped contribute to goals related to the business strategy.
Identify the Company’s Business Strategy Three factors influence the company’s business strategy. First, the company’s mission (reason for existing, specifying customers served and what the company does), vision (picture of the future the company wants to achieve), values (what the company stands for), and goals help determine the strategy. Second, a SWOT analysis (strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, threats) involves analyzing the operating environment to identify opportunities and threats, as well as internal analysis of strengths and weaknesses including people, technology, and financial resources. Third, the company must consider its competition.
Table 1 shows three decisions a company must make about how to compete:
- Where to compete? — In what markets (industries, products)?
- How to compete? — On what differentiating characteristic (cost, quality, reliability, delivery, innovativeness)?
- With what will we compete? — What resources will allow us to beat the competition?
Companies often neglect the “with what will we compete” decision, resulting in failure to reach goals. This includes deciding how human, physical, and financial capital will be used. To use human capital for competitive advantage requires linking HR practices (including training) to the business strategy.
The lecture presents the Nokia Corporation case study. Nokia’s business strategy is to build trusted customer relationships by offering compelling consumer solutions combining mobile devices with context-enriched services. Nokia’s vision is a world where everyone can be connected. The “Nokia way” consists of Nokia values, organizational competencies, and operations/processes for operational efficiency, resulting in a flat, networked company emphasizing speed and flexibility. Nokia’s values include “engaging you,” “achieving together,” “passion for innovation,” and “very human.” Continuous learning goes beyond formal training; employees support each other’s growth through idea exchange. Top management is committed to continuous learning, with business group presidents acting as “owners” of global management and leadership programs. They appoint “godfathers” from their management teams who participate actively and design program content. Programs involve action learning—strategic projects participants complete, with top managers reviewing and taking action on recommendations.
The value of continuous learning translates into personal and professional growth opportunities including self-development, coaching, training, management training, a vibrant internal job market, and performance management. Nokia’s Investing in People (IIP) process involves twice-yearly discussions between employees and managers, consisting of objective setting, coaching and achievement review, competence analysis, and a personal development plan, all supported electronically.
Identify Strategic Training and Development Initiatives That Support the Strategy Strategic training and development initiatives are learning-related actions a company should take to help achieve its business strategy. These vary by company depending on industry, goals, resources, and capabilities. They provide a road map to guide specific training activities and show how the training function will add value.
Table 2 shows strategic training initiatives and their implications. Key initiatives include:
- Diversify the learning portfolio — Provide learning opportunities beyond traditional programs, including informal on-the-job learning, new job experiences, personalized learning with mentors and coaches, and technology-based training.
- Expand who is trained — Recognize that employees need as much or more training than managers because they are the customer’s primary point of contact. Companies also train suppliers to ensure quality standards.
- Accelerate the pace of employee learning — Quickly identify training needs and provide effective training using electronic performance support systems (EPSS) that give employees immediate access to information, advice, and guidance.
- Improve customer service — Employees must be knowledgeable about products or services, have customer service skills, and understand what decisions they can make.
- Provide development opportunities — Ensure employees believe they have opportunities to grow and learn new skills, which is important for attracting and retaining talent.
- Capture and share knowledge — Ensure important knowledge is not lost when employees leave, and give employees access to others’ knowledge to quicken response times and improve quality.
- Align training with strategic direction — Identify needed employee capabilities and determine whether training programs are improving them.
- Create a supportive work environment — Provide tangible support (time, money, work areas for discussion) and psychological support (manager and peer encouragement for training and learning).
Table 3 shows questions companies must answer to identify strategic training initiatives. Trainers need to read annual reports, strategic plans, earnings releases, and analyst reports. They may invite managers to present on business strategy and, in multi-division companies, must understand each business including how it measures effectiveness, monitors performance, and what challenges it faces.
Provide Training and Development Activities Linked to Strategic Training and Development Initiatives After choosing strategic initiatives, companies identify specific training and development activities that will enable these initiatives to be achieved. These activities include developing initiatives related to new technology use in training, increasing access for certain employee groups, reducing development time, and developing new or expanded course offerings.
Organizational Factors Influencing Training
The lecture references organizational factors including the roles of employees and managers, top management support for training, integration of business units, staffing and human resource planning strategy, degree of unionization, and manager, trainer, and employee involvement in training.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical concept is that training must be strategically linked to business goals rather than existing as isolated programs. You must understand the evolution from program-focused training to a broader emphasis on learning and knowledge creation, and the critical distinction between explicit knowledge (teachable in manuals) and tacit knowledge (learned through experience and interaction). The strategic training and development process follows four steps: identify business strategy, choose strategic initiatives, provide linked training activities, and measure results with metrics. The Nokia case demonstrates how continuous learning, action learning, top management involvement, and integrated performance management systems support business strategy. Finally, strategic training initiatives include diversifying learning portfolios, expanding who is trained, accelerating learning, improving customer service, providing development opportunities, capturing knowledge, aligning with strategy, and creating supportive work environments.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five ways business strategy influences the training and development function?
- Distinguish between explicit knowledge and tacit knowledge, and explain how each is best acquired by employees.
- List and explain the four steps in the strategic training and development process model.
- What are the three decisions a company must make about how to compete according to Table 1, and which one do companies often neglect?
- Describe at least four strategic training and development initiatives from Table 2 and explain how each supports business strategy.
📘 Lecture 6 — Strategic Training (continued)
📖 Overview: This lecture continues the discussion on strategic training by focusing on how organizations identify and collect metrics to demonstrate training success, including the balanced scorecard approach. It also explores the various organizational characteristics that influence training, such as employee and manager roles, top management support, business conditions, and other HRM practices. Understanding these factors is critical for aligning training with business strategy and ensuring its effectiveness.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the process of identifying and collecting metrics to show training success, including outcome measures and the balanced scorecard. It then examines organizational characteristics that influence training, specifically the roles of employees and managers, top management support, integration of business units, business conditions, and other human resource management practices like staffing and human resource planning.
📝 Lecture Summary
Identify and Collect Metrics to Show Training Success
How does a company determine whether training contributes to business goals? This involves identifying and collecting outcome measures, or metrics. The metrics used to identify training success include trainees’ satisfaction, changes in knowledge, skill, ability, or attitudes (cognitive and skill-based outcomes), and business-related outcomes. Business-related outcomes should be directly linked to the business strategy and can evaluate customer service, employee satisfaction, turnover, product defects, or patents.
🔑 Definition — Metrics: Outcome measures used to determine training success or effectiveness.
The balanced scorecard is a process used to evaluate all aspects of the business from the perspective of internal and external customers, employees, and shareholders. It considers four perspectives: customer, internal, innovation and learning, and financial. Metrics used to assess training’s contribution include employees trained (employees trained divided by total employees), training costs (total training costs divided by number of employees trained), and training costs per hour (total training costs divided by total training hours).
📐 Formula: Training costs per hour = Total training costs ÷ Total training hours → This measures the cost efficiency of training delivery.
📌 Example: Ingersoll Rand University (IRU) uses metrics such as expected benefits, one-time versus ongoing costs, and employee participation rates. IRU offered Lean Six Sigma workshops and demonstrated savings of hundreds of thousands of dollars by reducing vendor delivery costs by 76 percent. This shows the process of identifying and collecting metrics is related to training evaluation.
💡 Why this matters: Showing that training directly relates to the company’s “bottom line” (e.g., increased service, sales, product quality) is the most convincing evidence of the value of training!
Organizational Characteristics that Influence Training
The amount and type of training, as well as the organization of the training function, are influenced by employee and manager roles, top management support, the degree of integration of business units, global presence, business conditions, other HRM practices (staffing and HR planning), unionization, and involvement by managers, employees, and HR staff.
Roles of Employees and Managers
The roles of employees and managers influence the focus of training. Traditionally, employees performed jobs as directed, but with the emphasis on intellectual capital and high-performance work systems using teams, employees now perform roles like hiring and scheduling. Team members need training in interpersonal problem solving and team skills (e.g., conflict resolution, feedback). If responsible for quality, they need training in statistical process control techniques. Companies may adopt skill-based pay systems, where pay rates depend on the number of skills employees are competent in.
🔑 Definition — Skill-based pay systems: Compensation systems where employees’ pay rates are based on the number of skills they are competent in, rather than the skills used for their current jobs.
Managers in traditional environments are expected to: manage individual performance, develop employees, plan and allocate resources, coordinate interdependent groups, manage group performance, monitor the business environment, and represent their work unit. Regardless of level, all managers serve as spokespersons. Line managers spend more time on individual performance and employee development, while midlevel managers and executives focus on planning, coordination, and group performance.
In high-performance work systems (teams), managers’ roles include managing alignment, coordinating activities, facilitating decision-making, encouraging continuous learning, and creating trust. Managers need training in “people skills” (negotiation, sensitivity, coaching, conflict resolution, communication) to succeed in a team environment, as a lack of these skills is linked to career failure.
Top Management Support
The CEO plays a key role in determining the importance of training and learning. The CEO’s responsibilities include:
- Providing a clear direction for learning (vision).
- Providing encouragement, resources, and commitment for strategic learning (sponsor).
- Taking an active role in governing learning, including reviewing goals and measuring effectiveness (governor).
- Developing new learning programs (subject-matter expert).
- Teaching programs or providing resources (faculty).
- Serving as a role model for learning (learner).
- Promoting commitment to learning in speeches and reports (marketing agent).
Integration of Business Units
The degree of integration of a company’s units affects training. In a highly integrated business, employees need to understand other units, services, and products. Training likely includes rotating employees between jobs in different businesses to gain an understanding of the whole business.
Business Conditions
Business conditions significantly influence training. When unemployment is low or businesses are growing rapidly, companies struggle to attract and retain qualified employees. Training is key to preparing employees, motivating them, and retaining them. Employees rate working with good colleagues, challenging assignments, and career growth opportunities as top reasons for staying.
In an unstable or recessionary environment (with mergers, acquisitions, or disinvestment), training may be abandoned or become short-term, focusing only on correcting skill deficiencies. Employees who remain may need new skills for changed responsibilities.
In companies experiencing growth, there are many opportunities for lateral moves and promotions, so employees are excited about development activities.
During revitalization and redirection periods, earnings are often flat, and fewer incentives (promotions, salary increases) are available. Training focuses on ensuring employees are available for vacated positions and helping them avoid skill obsolescence.
🔑 Definition — Skill obsolescence: The condition where an employee’s skills are no longer current or valuable to the organization.
Other Human Resource Management Practices
HRM practices include investments in staffing, performance management, training, and compensation. The type and resources devoted to training are influenced by the strategy adopted for staffing (determining how many employees are needed, recruiting, selecting) and human resource planning.
⭐ Key Takeaways
This lecture emphasizes that training success must be demonstrated through concrete metrics, particularly the balanced scorecard approach which considers customer, internal, innovation, and financial perspectives. Organizational characteristics—especially the evolving roles of employees and managers, the critical support of top management, and prevailing business conditions—directly shape training strategies. Managers in team environments require strong people skills, and training programs must adapt to economic cycles, from growth to recession. Ultimately, aligning training with broader HRM practices like staffing is essential for attracting, developing, and retaining talent.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four perspectives of the balanced scorecard, and give one example metric for each?
- List the three types of metrics that might be used to assess training’s contribution to the balanced scorecard.
- What are the six key roles of a manager in a traditional work environment?
- What are the seven responsibilities of a CEO in supporting training and learning?
- How do business conditions (e.g., growth vs. recession) affect the focus and availability of training?
📘 Lecture 7 — Strategic Training (continued)
📖 Overview: This lecture explores how a company's staffing strategy—decisions about where to find employees, how to select them, and the desired mix of skills—directly influences training priorities. It introduces a framework for classifying companies based on their assignment and supply flow decisions, and examines how different business strategies shape training needs.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers two main dimensions of staffing strategy: assignment flow (how promotion decisions are made) and supply flow (internal vs. external labor markets), which combine to create four company types. It then examines how different business strategies—concentration, internal growth, external growth, and disinvestment—lead to distinct training practices, supported by a research-based table linking strategy to training implications.
📝 Lecture Summary
Staffing Strategy
Staffing strategy refers to the company's decisions regarding where to find employees, how to select them, and the desired mix of employee skills and statuses (temporary, full-time, etc.). For example, one staffing decision a company must make is how much to rely on the internal labor market (within the company) or external labor market (outside the company) to fill vacancies. Two aspects of a company's staffing strategy influence training: the criteria used to make promotion and assignment decisions (assignment flow) and the places where the company prefers to obtain human resources to fill open positions (supply flow). Companies vary in the extent to which they make promotion and job assignment decisions based on individual performance or group or business-unit performance. They also vary in the extent to which their staffing needs are met by relying on current employees (internal labor market) or employees from competitors and recent entrants like college graduates (external labor market).
The interaction between assignment flow and supply flow results in four distinct types of companies: fortresses, baseball teams, clubs, and academies. Each company type places a different emphasis on training activities. For example, some companies (such as medical research companies) emphasize innovation and creativity, and are labeled baseball teams. Because it may be difficult to train skills related to innovation and creativity, they tend to handle staffing needs by luring employees away from competitors or hiring graduating students with specialized skills. The figure can be used to identify development activities that support a specific staffing strategy. For example, if a company wants to reward individual employee contributions and promote from within (the bottom right quadrant), it needs to use lateral, upward, and downward moves within and across functions to support the staffing strategy. Another staffing strategy is deciding what skills new employees will be expected to possess and what skills the company will develop through training.
🔑 Definition — Staffing Strategy: The company's decisions regarding where to find employees, how to select them, and the desired mix of employee skills and statuses. 🔑 Definition — Assignment Flow: The criteria used to make promotion and assignment decisions (individual vs. group/unit performance). 🔑 Definition — Supply Flow: The places where the company prefers to obtain human resources to fill open positions (internal vs. external labor market). 🔑 Definition — Baseball Teams: Company type characterized by an emphasis on innovation and creativity, often relying on external labor markets.
Training Needs in Different Strategies
Table 1 below describes four business strategies—concentration, internal growth, external growth, and disinvestment—and highlights the implications of each for training practices. Each strategy differs based on the goal of the business. A concentration strategy focuses on increasing market share, reducing costs, or creating and maintaining a market niche for products and services. An internal growth strategy focuses on new market and product development, innovation, and joint ventures. An external growth strategy emphasizes acquiring vendors and suppliers or buying businesses that allow the company to expand into new markets.
Preliminary research suggests a link between business strategy and the amount and type of training. Training issues vary greatly from one strategy to another. Divesting companies need to train employees in job-search skills and focus on cross-training remaining employees who may find themselves in jobs with expanding responsibilities. Companies focusing on a market niche (a concentration strategy) need to emphasize skill currency and development of their existing workforce. New companies formed from a merger or acquisition (external growth) need to ensure that employees have the skills needed to help the company reach its new strategic goals. Also, for mergers and acquisitions to be successful, employees need to learn about the new, merged organization and its culture. The organization must provide training in systems such as how the phone, e-mail, and company intranet work. Managers need to be educated on how to make the new merger successful (e.g., dealing with resistance to change).
🔑 Definition — Concentration Strategy: A business strategy focusing on increasing market share, reducing costs, or creating and maintaining a market niche. 🔑 Definition — Internal Growth Strategy: A business strategy focusing on new market and product development, innovation, and joint ventures. 🔑 Definition — External Growth Strategy: A business strategy emphasizing acquiring vendors and suppliers or buying businesses to expand into new markets. 🔑 Definition — Disinvestment Strategy: A business strategy focused on divesting or downsizing, requiring job-search and cross-training for employees. 💡 Why this matters: Understanding which business strategy a company is pursuing helps HR professionals design training programs that directly support strategic goals, ensuring training investments are aligned with organizational direction.
| Business Strategy | Strategic Goal | Implications for Training |
|---|---|---|
| Concentration | Increase market share, reduce costs, maintain market niche | Emphasize skill currency and development of existing workforce |
| Internal Growth | New market/product development, innovation, joint ventures | Train for new skills and innovation capabilities |
| External Growth | Acquiring vendors/suppliers, buying businesses to expand | Ensure employees have skills for new strategic goals; train on merged culture and systems; educate managers on change management |
| Disinvestment | Divesting or downsizing | Train employees in job-search skills; cross-train remaining employees for expanded responsibilities |
| (This table is a faithful reproduction of the concepts in Table 1 from the lecture text) |
⭐ Key Takeaways
The lecture's core message is that staffing strategy and business strategy are inseparable from training strategy. Staffing decisions—specifically assignment flow (individual vs. group performance) and supply flow (internal vs. external labor market)—create four company types (fortresses, baseball teams, clubs, academies), each requiring a different training emphasis. Furthermore, four business strategies (concentration, internal growth, external growth, and disinvestment) each demand distinct training responses: concentration requires skill currency; internal growth needs innovation training; external growth requires cultural integration and systems training; and disinvestment needs job-search and cross-training. A critical takeaway is that training must be tailored to support specific strategic goals, as one-size-fits-all training is ineffective. Finally, the lecture emphasizes that training needs vary greatly across strategies, and HR professionals must analyze the business context to design relevant development activities.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two dimensions of staffing strategy that influence training, and how do they interact?
- Name the four types of companies resulting from the interaction of assignment flow and supply flow.
- What training implications are associated with the concentration business strategy?
- Why is cross-training especially important for companies pursuing a disinvestment strategy?
- What training must be provided for mergers and acquisitions to be successful, according to the lecture?
📘 Lecture 8 — Models of Organizing the Training Department
📖 Overview: This lecture examines five distinct structural models used to organize training departments within organizations. Understanding these models is critical because how a training department is structured directly impacts its ability to contribute to business strategy, align with organizational goals, and deliver effective learning solutions. The lecture concludes with the emerging trend toward blended models that combine centralized efficiency with business-embedded responsiveness.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture covers five models for organizing the training department: the faculty model, customer model, matrix model, corporate university model, and business-embedded model. It also discusses centralized vs. decentralized training structures, provides detailed examples from companies like Boeing, Wyeth, Toyota, McDonald's, and Caterpillar, and highlights the emerging trend of combining the business-embedded model with centralized training functions.
📝 Lecture Summary
Centralized Training
Centralized training means that training and development programs, resources, and professionals are primarily housed in one location, and decisions about training investment, programs, and delivery methods are made from that department. Boeing found several advantages to centralizing its previously decentralized training, including ownership of training to one organization and elimination of course and program variation and duplication. Wyeth uses a centralized training function to ensure consistent selling skills across 140 countries, replacing four different selling models with one consistent approach.
🔑 Definition — Centralized Training: A structure where training and development programs, resources, and professionals are primarily housed in one location, with decisions made from that department. 📌 Example: Boeing moved from decentralized training (due to many geographic locations) to centralized training, gaining advantages like eliminating program duplication and course variation.
Advantages of centralized training include driving stronger alignment with business strategy, developing a common set of metrics or scorecards, streamlining processes, and gaining cost advantages in purchasing from vendors. Centralized training also helps companies better integrate programs for developing leaders and managing talent during times of change. The key to success is that top managers believe they are in control of the training function and that it is aligned with business strategy. However, centralized training functions must remain in touch with the unique needs of the functions and divisions they serve.
Faculty Model
Training departments organized by the faculty model resemble the structure of a college. The training department is headed by a director with a staff of experts who have specialized knowledge of a particular topic or skill area. These experts develop, administer, and update training programs. For example, sales trainers are responsible for sales skills training (cultivating clients, negotiating a sale, closing a sale), and computer experts provide training on topics such as using e-mail and the World Wide Web.
🔑 Definition — Faculty Model: A training department structure where a director leads a staff of subject-matter experts who develop, administer, and update training programs based on their specialized knowledge. 📌 Example: In a faculty model, sales trainers handle all sales skills training (cultivating clients, negotiating, closing), while computer experts handle software and email training.
The faculty model has strengths: training staff are clearly experts in their areas, and the department's plans are easily determined by staff expertise. Content and timing of programs are determined primarily by when they are available and the expertise of the trainers. However, disadvantages include that the training function may develop expertise that does not meet organizational needs, trainers may be unaware of business problems or unwilling to adapt materials, resulting in demotivated trainees who fail to learn because course content lacks meaning. Needed programs may not be offered because trainers lack expertise in certain areas. To overcome these disadvantages, managers need to frequently survey training's customers and expert trainers must adapt course materials to be meaningful.
💡 Why this matters: The faculty model can create a disconnect between training content and actual business needs, leading to wasted resources and poor learning outcomes.
The Customer Model
Training departments organized according to the customer model are responsible for the training needs of one division or function of the company. For example, trainers might be responsible for programs related to information systems, marketing, or operations. Trainers might also be human resource generalists whose responsibilities include a broad range of HR functions such as training, performance management, hiring, and benefits.
🔑 Definition — Customer Model: A training department structure where trainers are responsible for the training needs of one specific division or function of the company. 📌 Example: A single trainer might handle all training, performance management, hiring, and benefits for the marketing division.
This model overcomes a major problem of the faculty model: training programs are developed more in line with the particular needs of a business group rather than based on the expertise of the training staff. Selection, training, compensation, and development are all based on a common set of competencies, integrating training with other HR responsibilities. Trainers are expected to be aware of business needs and update courses accordingly. If needs change, trainers may use outside experts. Materials are likely to be meaningful to trainees.
Disadvantages include: trainers must spend considerable time learning the business function before being useful; a large number of programs covering similar topics may be developed by customers, varying greatly in effectiveness; it may be difficult for the training director to ensure a common instructional design process or consistent quality philosophy. This model is unattractive to trainers who consider presentation and teaching their primary job function. In this model, trainers are often employees from the functional area (e.g., manufacturing engineers) who have great functional expertise but lack training in instructional design and learning theory, resulting in courses that are meaningful but poorly designed.
Matrix Model
In the matrix model, trainers report to both a manager in the training department and a manager in a particular function. The trainer has the responsibility of being both a training expert and a functional expert. For example, sales trainers report to both the director of training and the marketing manager.
🔑 Definition — Matrix Model: A training structure where trainers have dual reporting relationships to both a training department manager and a functional manager. 📐 Structure: Trainer → Training Director AND Functional Manager (e.g., Marketing Manager) 📌 Example: A sales trainer in the matrix model reports to both the Director of Training and the Marketing Manager.
One advantage is that it helps ensure training is linked to business needs. Another advantage is that the trainer gains expertise in understanding a specific business function. Because the trainer also reports to the training director, it is likely the trainer will stay professionally current (e.g., up-to-date on new training delivery mechanisms). A major disadvantage is that trainers likely will have more time demands and conflicts because they report to two managers.
Corporate University Model (Corporate Training Universities)
The corporate university model differs from other models in that the client group includes not only employees and managers but also stakeholders outside the company, including community colleges, universities, high schools, and grade schools. Training functions organized by this model tend to offer a wider range of programs and courses. Important culture and values also tend to be emphasized more often. This model centralizes training to make sure that "best training practices" are disseminated across the company and enables control of costs by developing consistent training practices and policies.
🔑 Definition — Corporate University Model: A training structure where the client group includes employees, managers, and external stakeholders, offering a wide range of programs that emphasize culture and values while centralizing best practices.
University of Toyota, a division of Toyota Motor Sales, developed a single set of development standards, benchmarks, purchasing specifications, and best practices housed on e-Source, its Web site. Vendors are required to visit e-Source to bid on e-learning projects, and courses not meeting specifications are revised at the vendor's expense. Caterpillar University comprises six colleges: leadership, marketing and distribution, technology, business and business processes, Six Sigma, and product support. Deans report to the university president, and the CEO and vice presidents provide policy guidance and approve budgets. Hamburger University (McDonald's) teaches core values of quality, service, cleanliness, and value. It transitioned from lecture format to more interactive learning in classes of 25-35 students, accommodating how Generation Y students learn. E-learning delivers basics, while classroom instruction and simulations help application. Learners receive headphones for translation services, and the university includes a simulated kitchen and drive-thru window.
Creating a corporate university involves nine steps: (1) senior and business managers form a governing body to develop a vision; (2) the vision is linked to business strategy; (3) the funding method is decided (charging business units and/or corporate budget); (4) the degree of centralization is determined (many centralize learning philosophy, core curriculum, and policies while local units handle specialized curriculum and delivery); (5) customer needs are identified (employees, managers, suppliers, external customers); (6) products and services are developed using service teams; (7) learning partners are chosen (suppliers, consultants, colleges); (8) a technology strategy is developed; (9) learning is linked to performance improvement.
Business Embedded Model
The business-embedded (BE) model is characterized by five competencies: strategic direction, product design, structural versatility, product delivery, and accountability for results. Strategic direction includes a clearly described goal and customer focus that includes customizing training and continuously improving programs. A BE training function views trainees, managers (who send employees), and senior-level managers (who allocate money) as customers.
🔑 Definition — Business-Embedded (BE) Model: A training structure characterized by strategic direction, product design, structural versatility, product delivery, and accountability for results, with a strong customer focus at all levels. 📌 Example: A BE function views trainees, the managers who send them, and the senior managers who fund training as distinct customer groups with different needs.
The most noticeable difference between a BE function and a traditional training department is its structure. Traditional training departments operate with a fixed staff of trainers and administrators performing specific functions, often taking a "silo" approach focusing only on their particular responsibilities. In BE training functions, all persons involved in the training process communicate and share resources. Trainers responsible for developing materials, delivering instruction, and supporting trainees work together to ensure learning occurs. The number of trainers varies according to demand. Trainers have specialized competencies but can also serve as internal consultants providing a wide range of services (needs assessment, content improvement, program customization, results measurement).
Current Practice: Business-Embedded Model with Centralized Training
Because many companies recognize training's critical role in contributing to business strategy, there is an increasing trend for the training function to be organized by a blend of the BE model with centralized training that often includes a corporate university. This approach allows companies to gain the benefits of centralized training while ensuring training can provide programs, content, and delivery methods that meet the needs of specific businesses.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The structure of a training department has critical consequences for how training contributes to business strategy. Five distinct models exist—faculty, customer, matrix, corporate university, and business-embedded—each with unique strengths and weaknesses regarding alignment with business needs, trainer expertise, and organizational responsiveness. The corporate university model is uniquely positioned to serve external stakeholders and centrally disseminate best practices while emphasizing organizational culture and values. The business-embedded model represents the most customer-focused approach, with trainers acting as internal consultants who communicate and share resources rather than working in silos. The current best practice trend is a blended approach combining the business-embedded model with centralized training (often including a corporate university), which balances strategic alignment with responsiveness to specific business unit needs.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five models of organizing the training department discussed in this lecture?
- What are the key advantages and disadvantages of the faculty model of training organization?
- How does the matrix model address the weaknesses of both the faculty and customer models?
- What are the nine steps involved in creating a corporate university from scratch?
- How does the business-embedded model differ from a traditional training department in terms of structure and customer focus?