π Lecture 18 β Credit Review and Valuation of Collateral (Cont.)
π Overview: This lecture continues the discussion on credit rating processes, focusing on the inclusion of internal and external information, loss-sharing arrangements for affiliated companies, and the finalization of the borrower rating. It then delves into the critical topic of collateral valuation, explaining its role in determining Loss Given Default (LGD) under Basel II and outlining the different types of collateral and principles for their valuation.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by explaining how additional information, such as a client's past conduct and industry data, is integrated into the company rating. It then details the process for handling loss-sharing arrangements within affiliated groups and finalizing the borrower rating. The summary covers rules for overriding standardized rating models and the documentation of other credit assessment factors. Finally, it provides a comprehensive introduction to the valuation of collateral, distinguishing between personal and physical collateral and outlining the general principles for establishing collateral value in a bank's collateral catalog.
π Lecture Summary
Inclusion of Additional Information & Loss-Sharing Arrangements
In the credit rating process, further information can be included beyond the standard components. This includes a bank's internal data on the applicant's past conduct, such as overdrafts, and additional details about the industry in which the company operates. The result of this process is often called a company rating.
For companies that are part of an affiliated group, it is necessary to examine possible loss-sharing arrangements. The inclusion of these arrangements helps determine risk-bearing entities and can affect the assessment of the probability of default (PD) both positively and negatively. A positive effect is the assumption of support for a company during a crisis, while a negative effect is the potential spillover of a crisis from another group member to the company.
π Definition β Loss-Sharing Arrangement: A formal or informal agreement within an affiliated group of companies that outlines how financial losses will be distributed or covered by the group's members.
Finalization of the Borrower Rating
The inclusion of loss-sharing arrangements, typically done in consultation with sales and credit analysis departments, marks the end of the rating process. The final result is the borrower rating. This final rating should be awarded and confirmed collaboratively by the primary sales and risk analysis employees responsible for the exposure, who must carry out mutual plausibility checks. External ratings should also be used in this check. If an agreement cannot be reached, the managers in charge review the exposure, but the final decision should not be left to the front office.
Overriding Rating Results & Documentation of Other Factors
Internal guidelines must contain rules for when it is permissible to manually override standardized credit rating models. This might be necessary, for example, in a financial rating where a special corporate structure prevents a meaningful ratio analysis. Any overrides must be subject to strict documentation requirements for transparency and validation, as the number of overrides is an indicator of the model's reliability.
In addition to standardized factors, employees may include further data in the credit review. These are typically documented in credit applications across five categories: Legal situation, Market situation, Economic situation, Project evaluation, and Debt service capacity. The goal is to have clear, unambiguous statements describing the impact of these factors on credit standing, often using standardized text modules and limited field sizes to prevent longwinded descriptions.
Valuation of Collateral
The valuation of collateral is an essential element in the credit approval process, impacting the overall assessment of credit risk. A key feature of a collateralized credit is not just the borrower's PD but the value of the collateral the lender can realize in case of default. This value influences the bank's loss. Under Basel II, the collateral's value is included in calculating the capital requirement via the risk component of Loss Given Default (LGD) . It is critical that collateral valuation be done independently of the borrower's PD calculation to meet Basel requirements, separating the "customer rating" (reflecting PD) from the "transaction valuation" (including collateral).
π Definition β Collateralized Credit: A loan or other exposure that is secured by an asset or a guarantee provided by the borrower or a third party, which the lender can seize and sell if the borrower defaults.
Types of Collateral
Collateral is divided into two main types: personal and physical.
- Personal Collateral: The provider is liable with his entire fortune. Examples include:
- Suretyship
- Guarantee and letter of support
- Collateral promise
- Physical Collateral: The bank receives a specific security interest in certain assets. Examples include:
- Mortgage
- Pledge of movable assets (e.g., on securities, goods, bills of exchange)
- Security assignment
- Retention of title
General Principles for Determining Collateral Value
A bank's internal collateral catalog should stipulate the type of collateral it accepts and include instructions on how to determine its collateral value. Banks should scrutinize collateral whose value is subject to strong fluctuations or is cumbersome to realize. For instance, liens are usually less problematic for their holders than assessing a guarantor's personal liability fund.
General principles for valuation include accounting for the sustainable value (the value that can reasonably be expected over the long term) and valuing the collateral based on the liquidation principle (the net value expected from a forced sale). The calculation should also include general risk deductions (haircuts) and deductions for procedural costs (e.g., time and legal costs to sell the collateral).
π‘ Why this matters: The independent and accurate valuation of collateral directly determines the LGD parameter, which, alongside PD, is a fundamental input for calculating Regulatory Capital under the Basel II IRB approach. A poorly valued collateral leads to an inaccurate capital requirement.
β Key Takeaways
The final borrower rating must be the result of a collaborative process between sales and risk, supported by plausibility checks and external ratings. All manual overrides of the rating model require strict documentation for transparency and process validation. Collateral valuation is a separate but critical process from calculating the borrower's probability of default, as it directly determines the Loss Given Default (LGD) under Basel II. Collateral is classified as either personal (liability from the entire fortune) or physical (a specific interest in an asset), and a bank's internal catalog must outline how each type is valued. The sustainable value and liquidation principle are key for determining a conservative and realistic collateral value, inclusive of mandatory haircuts and procedural costs.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the positive and negative effects of including a loss-sharing arrangement in a company rating?
- Who is responsible for confirming the final borrower rating, and what process must they follow?
- What are the five categories typically used in credit applications to document other credit assessment factors?
- According to the lecture, why must the valuation of collateral be performed independently of the calculation of the borrower's Probability of Default (PD)?
- Name two examples each of personal collateral and physical collateral, and state a general principle for determining collateral value.
π Lecture 19 β Exposure Assessment
π Overview: This lecture focuses on the final stage of credit review: assessing the borrower's creditworthiness regarding the proposed exposure. It explains how automated decision processes are used, particularly in retail and small business segments, and outlines the subsequent steps of preparing offers, making credit decisions, and documentation. Understanding this process is critical for ensuring that credit risk is accurately priced and that procedural errors are prevented.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the comprehensive evaluation of exposure risk, including the comparison of positive and negative assessment criteria. It details the use of automated decision processes in standardized retail and small business lending, the impact of the IRB approach under Basel II on credit rating and capital requirements, and the practical limitations of automated processes for small business segments. The lecture then examines the process of preparing offers, focusing on the authority to set conditions and the coordination between sales and risk analysis.
π Lecture Summary
Exposure Assessment
After reviewing the borrower rating, other credit assessment factors, and the collateral, it is possible to assess the borrowerβs creditworthiness with regard to the proposed exposure. The final assessment of the exposure risk can only be made after a comprehensive evaluation of all sub-processes of credit review. The results of the valuation of the collateral will also be included in this assessment, which must be made by the employees handling the exposure. The credit form should provide appropriate fields for this, and internal guidelines must contain clear rules on the level of detail and the form of the explanation. In practice, it is useful to compare the positive and negative assessment criteria, and the form should provide a field for a concluding summary. The assessment by the employees in charge is the basis for the subsequent credit decision, which must follow the decision-making structure stipulated in internal guidelines.
Automated Decision
In the standardized retail business, individual interventions in the credit decision process are often unnecessary, with the credit rating process being the major basis for the credit decision. As these processes are used for small credit volumes, data is often entered by a sales employee. Deviations can be found in residential real estate finance, where specialized risk analysis units can be set up. In both cases, the credit decision can be made by a single vote up to a defined volume to curb complexity and increase efficiency. Mostly automated decision processes are increasingly used in the small business segment, requiring a clear definition of the customer segment and data to derive a discriminatory analysis function. In some cases, the credit applicant enters the data (online applications), but this is limited by the database and lack of personal contact. The most important success factor is the bankβs ability to take precautions against the credit applicant entering wrong data.
Choosing a Process under the IRB Approach
As the IRB (Internal Ratings-Based) approach under Basel II provides for a calculation of the regulatory capital requirement on the basis of credit standing, the credit rating process has to be adapted to its requirements. The application of formulas to calculate the regulatory capital requirement requires banks to derive the default parameters needed to quantify risk. Both the basic and advanced IRB approaches require the calculation of the probability of default (PD) of a claim or a pool of claims. Therefore, the credit rating of individual exposures has an immediate impact on the capital requirement. The PD of retail exposures can be determined on the basis of pools of claims combining comparable individual exposures, so it is not necessary to classify every single borrower. Under Basel II, corporate exposures with a total volume of no more than β¬1m can be treated as retail exposures, theoretically allowing for a mostly automated credit decision process.
π Definition β IRB (Internal Ratings-Based) Approach: A method for calculating regulatory capital requirements based on a bank's own assessment of its credit risk, requiring the derivation of default parameters like PD.
π Formula: [PD calculation from pools of claims] β The probability of default for a group of similar exposures is determined by the historical default rate within that pool.
π Example: A bank groups 1,000 similar retail credit cards into one pool. If, historically, 20 of these cards default in a year, the PD for the entire pool is 2% (20/1000). This PD is then used to calculate the capital requirement for this pool.
Practical Limitations for Small Business Segment
In practice, the use of automated decision processes for the small business segment must be qualified for two major reasons.
- The profitability of the small business segment is highly dependent on the price structure, which is a decisive competitive factor. Therefore, it is necessary to delineate the risk associated with an exposure as precisely as possible to set a risk-commensurate price.
- Homogeneous data pools are required for the application of empirical statistical models. In practice, borrowers in the small business segment show a high degree of heterogeneity, meaning this requirement can only be met by setting up many, smaller pools of claims. The decreasing size of pools and the resulting increase in processes effectively limit the application of this method, especially for small institutions.
Preparation of Offers, Credit Decision and Documentation
After reviewing and determining the applicantβs creditworthiness, the process leading up to disbursement of the credit can be initiated. This covers all aspects from preparing an offer to actually disbursing the amount in the credit agreement. These process steps are designed to prevent procedural errors in the credit approval process, focusing on the risk-mitigating design of selected process components.
Preparation of Offers
When preparing a firm offer, costing this offer plays a central role. From a procedural point of view, special emphasis has to be placed on clearly defining the authority to set conditions and the coordination process between sales and risk analysis.
Authority to Set Conditions
The internal guidelines have to lay down the responsibility for the final decision concerning conditions. If a calculation of the conditions in line with the risk is carried out by automated systems, sales can have the sole authority to set conditions. The sales department is fully responsible for earnings and should thus have the authority to decide on the conditions. If the systems do not allow a precise calculation of the risk-adequate conditions, the person in charge of risk analysis should be included in the final decision on the conditions. The internal guidelines should contain specific instructions governing the assignment of responsibility, including an explicit definition of the escalation criteria. These should be identical for sales and risk analysis to avoid situations where people at different hierarchical levels have to decide on conditions of an individual exposure. Improper handling of this hierarchical relation may have a negative impact on the required balance in forming an opinion.
π‘ Why this matters: The design of the authority to set conditions is a critical control point. If sales has too much authority without proper risk-based pricing systems, it can lead to mispriced loans. The escalation criteria ensure a balanced decision, preventing a single person or department from overriding risk concerns.
β Key Takeaways
The final exposure assessment synthesizes all credit review components, including collateral valuation, and must be clearly documented for the credit decision. Automated decision processes are efficient for standardized retail and small-volume corporate loans but are limited by data quality and the need for homogeneous pools, especially in the heterogeneous small business segment. Under the IRB approach, the probability of default (PD) directly impacts regulatory capital, making accurate credit rating crucial. When preparing offers, the authority to set conditions must be clearly defined to balance salesβ earnings responsibility with risk analysis, using identical escalation criteria to ensure a balanced opinion.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the purpose of comparing positive and negative assessment criteria on the credit form during exposure assessment?
- What is the most important success factor for a bank when using mostly automated credit decision processes?
- Why does the probability of default (PD) have an "immediate impact" on the capital requirement under the IRB approach?
- What are the two major practical limitations that qualify the use of automated credit decision processes for the small business segment?
- Why must the escalation criteria for setting conditions be "identical for sales and risk analysis"?
π Lecture 20 β Credit Decision-Making Structure
π Overview: This lecture explains how credit decisions are formally approved after an offer is prepared, focusing on the structure of credit authority and the coordination between sales and risk analysis. It also introduces the Basel Accord's standardized approach for calculating risk-weighted assets, including specific risk weights for sovereigns, banks, and corporations, and the use of external credit assessments.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining credit authority and its role in the internal approval process, emphasizing the "four-eyes principle" and the need to separate sales from risk analysis. It then presents basic guidelines for creating a decision-making structure, subdividing credit decisions into non-standardized credits, standardized credits, and short-term overdrafts. The second major topic covers the Basel Accord & Credit Risk Management, explaining the standardized approach for risk-weighted assets, the replacement of the OECD/non-OECD distinction with external credit assessments, and the specific risk weights for sovereigns and the potential use of Export Credit Agency (ECA) risk scores.
π Lecture Summary
Credit Decision-Making Structure
The lecture outlines the formal internal approval process for individual credit exposures, which follows the agreement on specific credit exposure terms during the offer preparation. The essential risk-related issue here is credit authority, which describes the authorization granted by management to make credit decisions up to a certain amount. To comply with the four-eyes principle, this authority can usually only be exercised jointly by two or more decision makers. Critically, a credit decision should always involve people who do not belong to the sales department, a concept known as double vote. The level of authority should be commensurate with the employee's experience.
π Definition β Credit Authority: The authorization granted by management that allows discretion in making credit decisions up to a certain amount.
π Definition β Four-Eyes Principle: A risk management principle requiring that decisions be made jointly by two or more people.
π Definition β Double Vote: The practice of ensuring that a credit decision always involves people who are not part of the sales department.
Basic Guidelines Covering the Creation of a Decision-making Structure
The decision-making structure should be subdivided based on the nature of the object of the decision and its risk level. Three categories are usually formed:
- Non-standardized credits
- Standardized credits
- Short-term overdrafts (all instances in which credit lines are exceeded in the short term)
The structure may also contain specific rules on further issues, such as authority to set conditions or handle minor changes within an exposure. For non-standardized credits, it makes sense to refer to the credit risk associated with the individual exposures. The factors to be taken into account in drawing up the decision-making structure are:
- Level of exposure
- Value of collateral
- Type of borrower
- Probability of default
Basel Accord & Credit Risk Management
The lecture explains the standardized approach from the Basel Accord. Under this approach, as per the 1999 consultative paper, risk-weighted assets are calculated as the product of the amount of exposures and supervisory-determined risk weights. The risk weights are determined by the category of the borrower: sovereign, bank, or corporate. Unlike the current Accord, there is no longer a distinction based on OECD membership. Instead, the risk weights for exposures depend on external credit assessments from eligible External Credit Assessment Institutions (ECAIs). The treatment of off-balance sheet exposures remains largely unchanged.
π Definition β Standardized Approach: A method for calculating risk-weighted assets, where the risk weight is determined by an external credit assessment of the borrower.
π Definition β ECAI (External Credit Assessment Institution): A credit rating agency, such as Moody's, S&P, or Fitch, that provides credit assessments.
Sovereign Risk Weights
For sovereigns (national governments), the highest quality claims get a 0% risk weight. The assessments used should generally be the long-term domestic rating for domestic currency obligations and the foreign rating for foreign currency obligations. The risk weights for sovereigns, following the notation from the June 1999 Consultative Paper, are:
| Credit Assessment | AAA to AA- | A+ to A- | BBB+ to BBB- | BB+ to B- | Below B- | Unrated |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Risk Weight | 0% | 20% | 50% | 100% | 150% | 100% |
At national discretion, a lower risk weight may be applied to banks' exposures to the sovereign of incorporation, provided the exposure is denominated in domestic currency and funded in that currency.
To address concerns over using private credit ratings and to supplement them, the Committee explored using Export Credit Agency (ECA) risk scores. A key advantage is that ECA risk scores are available for a far larger number of sovereigns than private ECAI ratings. The OECD 1999 methodology uses an econometric model to assign country risk scores from 1 to 7. The proposed mapping of ECA risk scores to risk weights is:
| ECA Risk Score | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 to 6 | 7 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Risk Weight | 0% | 20% | 50% | 100% | 150% |
Claims on central banks are assigned the same risk weight as their sovereign governments. The Bank for International Settlements (BIS) , the International Monetary Fund (IMF) , the European Central Bank (ECB) , and the European Community receive the lowest risk weight (0%). The Committee decided not to use adherence to the IMF's Special Data Dissemination Standard (SDDS) as a pre-condition for preferential risk weights, as judging compliance is a qualitative exercise.
π Definition β Export Credit Agency (ECA): A government agency that insures country risk and sometimes commercial risk attached to the provision of export credit to foreign buyers.
π Formula: Risk-Weighted Assets = Amount of Exposure Γ Supervisory Determined Risk Weight β The total value of an asset, adjusted for its credit risk.
π Example: A bank holds a $100M bond issued by a sovereign rated "A+".
- According to the table, a "A+" rating falls in the "A+ to A-" bucket, which has a 20% risk weight.
- Risk-Weighted Assets = $100M Γ 20% = $20M.
- This means only $20M of the $100M exposure is considered "risky" for capital adequacy calculations, reflecting the sovereign's strong credit quality.
π‘ Why this matters: The shift from a simple OECD/non-OECD distinction to a more granular system based on external credit assessments (like sovereign credit ratings or ECA scores) makes the risk-weighting process far more sensitive to actual differences in credit quality. This aligns regulatory capital requirements more closely with the true economic risk of lending to different sovereigns.
β Key Takeaways
Credit authority is a critical internal control, requiring that decisions be made jointly (four-eyes principle) and with input from non-sales staff (double vote). The structure for making credit decisions should be based on the risk level and nature of the credit, considering factors like exposure amount and probability of default. The Basel Accord's standardized approach uses external credit assessments (from ECAIs or ECAs) to determine risk weights, replacing the older OECD-based system. For sovereign exposures, risk weights range from 0% for AAA-rated to 150% for below B-rated, with unrated exposures getting a 100% weight. The use of ECA risk scores is proposed as a more widely available supplement to private ratings for sovereign risk assessment.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the "four-eyes principle" and how is it applied in the context of credit decision-making authority?
- Under the standardized approach of the Basel Accord, what determines the risk weight for a sovereign exposure?
- What are the three main categories used to subdivide credit decisions in the decision-making structure described in the lecture?
- What is the primary advantage of using Export Credit Agency (ECA) risk scores over private credit ratings for assessing sovereign risk?
- According to the table of sovereign risk weights, what risk weight would be applied to an unrated sovereign exposure?
π Lecture 21 β Risk Weights for Non-Central Govt. Public Sector Entities (PSEs)
π Overview: This lecture explains how credit risk weights are assigned to Public Sector Entities (PSEs) that are not part of the central government, such as regional governments and state-owned corporations. It also details the risk weighting frameworks for Multilateral Development Banks (MDBs), banks, securities firms, and corporates, which are essential for calculating capital adequacy under Basel II.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the Basel II framework for assigning risk weights to non-central government Public Sector Entities (PSEs), categorized by their revenue-raising powers and institutional arrangements. It then examines the eligibility criteria for Multilateral Development Banks (MDBs) to receive a 0% risk weight. The lecture further explains the two options for risk weighting claims on banks, the treatment of securities firms, and the risk weighting of corporate claims based on external credit assessments.
π Lecture Summary
Claims on Domestic PSEs
Claims on domestic PSEs will be treated as claims on banks of that country. Subject to national discretion, they may also be treated as claims on the sovereigns in whose jurisdictions they are established. Non-central government PSEs range from government agencies to government-owned corporations.
To guide supervisors, PSEs are categorized by their revenue-raising powers:
- Regional governments and local authorities with specific revenue-raising powers and institutional arrangements that reduce default risk can qualify for the same treatment as claims on the central government.
- Administrative bodies and non-commercial undertakings without revenue-raising powers may not warrant sovereign treatment. If strict lending rules apply and bankruptcy is not possible, they may be treated like claims on banks.
- Commercial undertakings owned by governments that function as corporates in competitive markets may be treated as normal commercial enterprises with corporate risk weights.
π Definition β PSEs (Public Sector Entities): Non-central government entities including regional governments, local authorities, administrative bodies, and government-owned commercial undertakings.
Risk Weights for Multilateral Development Banks (MDBs)
Risk weights for MDBs are based on external credit assessments. A 0% risk weight is applied to highly rated MDBs that fulfill specific criteria.
The eligibility criteria for MDBs to receive a 0% risk weight are:
- Very high quality long-term issuer ratings, with a majority being AAA.
- Shareholder structure comprised of a significant proportion of high quality sovereigns with assessments of AA or better.
- Strong shareholder support, demonstrated by paid-in capital, callable capital, and continued contributions.
- Adequate level of capital and liquidity.
- Strict statutory lending requirements and conservative financial policies. π‘ Why this matters: A 0% risk weight significantly reduces the capital charge for banks holding these claims, encouraging investment in these institutions.
π Definition β MDBs (Multilateral Development Banks): International financial institutions that provide financial support and advice for economic development projects in developing countries. π Example: MDBs currently eligible for a 0% risk weight include the World Bank Group (IBRD and IFC), the Asian Development Bank (ADB), the African Development Bank (AFDB), and the European Investment Bank (EIB).
Risk Weights for Banks
There are two options for deciding risk weights on exposures to banks. No claim on an unrated bank may receive a risk weight less than that applied to its sovereign of incorporation.
Option 1: All banks in a given country are assigned a risk weight one category less favorable than that assigned to claims on their sovereign.
| Credit Assessment | AAA to AA | A+ to A | BBB+ to BBB | BB+ to B | Below B | Unrated |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Risk Weights | 20% | 50% | 100% | 150% | 150% | 100% |
The Committee reduced the preferential risk weight for short-term claims from original maturity of 6 months or less to 3 months or less. The committee will not retain the sovereign floor, recognizing that a bank can have a higher assessment than its home sovereign.
π Definition β Sovereign Floor: A rule that prevented an entity from receiving a risk weight better than its home country's sovereign. This was proposed in 1999 but not retained.
Risk Weights for Securities Firms
Claims on securities firms may be treated as claims on banks, provided they are subject to supervisory and regulatory arrangements comparable to the new capital adequacy framework (including risk-based capital requirements).
The Committee is no longer proposing the implementation of IOSCO's Objectives and Principles of Securities Regulation as a condition for receiving a risk weight less than 100%.
Risk Weights for Corporates
Risk weights for rated corporate claims (including insurance companies) are based on external credit assessments.
| Credit Assessment | AAA to AA | A+ to A | BBB+ to BB | Below BB | Unrated |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Risk Weights | 20% | 50% | 100% | 150% | 100% |
The Committee will not adopt the sovereign floor for corporates. The standard risk weight for unrated claims on corporates is 100%. No claim on an unrated corporate may be given a risk weight preferential to that assigned to its sovereign of incorporation.
π Example: A corporate with a credit assessment of βA+β would receive a risk weight of 50%, while a corporate rated βBBβ would receive a risk weight of 100%.
β Key Takeaways
Risk weights for non-central government PSEs depend on their revenue-raising powers and public status, potentially being treated as banks, sovereigns, or corporates. For MDBs, only those meeting stringent criteriaβincluding majority AAA ratings and strong shareholder supportβqualify for a 0% risk weight. Under Option 1 for banks, the risk weight is one category worse than the sovereignβs, with preferential treatment for claims under 3 months maturity. The sovereign floor was not adopted for banks or corporates, allowing for higher entity ratings. Unrated claims on corporates receive a 100% risk weight and are subject to the sovereign floor only for unrated entities.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the factors that determine whether a non-central government PSE can be treated as a sovereign, a bank, or a corporate for risk-weighting purposes?
- Name three MDBs eligible for a 0% risk weight and list two of the five eligibility criteria they must satisfy.
- Under Option 1 for banks, how is the risk weight for a bank with an "A+" credit assessment determined, and what is the preferential treatment for short-term claims?
- True or False: The sovereign floor was adopted, meaning no bank or corporate can have a risk weight better than its home country sovereign. Explain.
- What is the standard risk weight for an unrated corporate, and what restriction applies to this claim?
π Lecture 22 β Counterparty Risk Weightings of OTC Derivative
π Overview: This lecture addresses the removal of the 50% ceiling on counterparty risk weightings for OTC derivatives and explains the new credit conversion factors for short-term commitments and guaranteed repo-style transactions. It also details the standardized approach's stance on maturity and provides a comprehensive framework for recognizing and evaluating External Credit Assessment Institutions (ECAIs), covering the key criteria of objectivity, independence, transparency, and disclosure.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture begins by announcing the removal of the 50% ceiling on counterparty risk weightings for OTC derivatives, citing the outdated assumption that counterparties are first-class names. It then details the credit conversion factors for short-term commitments (20% for up to one year, with a 0% exception for unconditionally cancellable ones) and the 100% factor for guaranteed repo-style transactions. The lecture explains the Committee's decision not to incorporate a maturity dimension into the standardized approach to maintain simplicity. Finally, it provides an extensive overview of the recognition process and criteria for External Credit Assessment Institutions (ECAIs), including objectivity, independence, international access, transparency, and disclosure requirements.
π Lecture Summary
Counterparty Risk Weightings of OTC Derivative
The previous 50% ceiling on counterparty risk weightings for OTC derivative transactions has been removed. This change was made because the original assumption that all counterparties to these contracts are "first-class names" is no longer considered valid. Furthermore, the increased risk-sensitivity of the new standardized approach makes the ceiling unnecessary.
Credit Conversion Factor for Short term Commitments
For business commitments with an original maturity up to one year, the credit conversion factor is set at 20%. As an exception, a 0% conversion factor applies to commitments that are unconditionally cancellable or that effectively provide for automatic cancellation due to a deterioration in a borrowerβs creditworthiness, at any time by the bank without prior notice. The credit conversion factor for commitments with original maturity over one year remains 50%.
Guaranteed Repo-Style Transactions
A credit conversion factor of 100% is applied to the lending of banks' securities or the posting of securities as collateral by the bank. This includes instances arising from repo-style transactions (repo/reverse repo and securities lending/securities borrowing) where the credit-converted exposure is secured by eligible collateral. π Example: When banks, acting as agents, arrange a repo-style transaction between a customer and a third party and provide a guarantee to the customer that the third party will perform on its obligations, then the risk to the bank is the same as if the bank had entered into the transaction as principal. In such circumstances, banks must calculate capital requirements as if they were a party to the transaction.
Maturity
The Committee confirmed that while maturity is a relevant factor in credit risk assessment, it is difficult to differentiate among maturities within the standardized approach due to its broad-brush nature. The standardized approach is designed for banks of varying size and sophistication, and the costs of increasing its complexity are high. The Committee concluded that the benefits of improved risk-sensitivity would be outweighed by the costs of greater complexity. Therefore, no maturity dimension is incorporated throughout the approach. The only maturity elements are the distinction between short-term and long-term commitments, and the distinction between short-term and long-term lending between financial institutions.
External Credit Assessment
The standardized approach relies on external credit assessments to determine risk weights. Therefore, the soundness and reliability of the institutions performing these assessments (ECAls) are vitally important. This section discusses the recognition process and the criteria used for these institutions.
The Recognition Process
National supervisors are responsible for determining whether an External Credit Assessment Institution (ECAI) meets the listed criteria. Some ECAIs may be recognized on a limited basis, e.g., by type of claims or by jurisdiction. Supervisors may disclose a list of all recognized ECAIs and any restrictions on their use. The supervisory process for recognizing ECAIs should be made public to avoid unnecessary barriers to entry. The Committee emphasizes the importance of supervisors sharing their experiences with credit ratings and maintaining a dialogue with market participants.
Objectivity
The methodology for assigning credit assessments must be rigorous, systematic, and subject to validation based on historical experience. Assessments must be subject to ongoing review and responsive to changes in financial condition. Before recognition, an assessment methodology for each market segment must have been established for at least one year (preferably three), including rigorous back testing.
Independence
An ECAI must be independent and should not be subject to political or economic pressures that may influence the rating. The assessment process should be as free as possible from constraints that could arise from conflicts of interest, such as those related to the board of directors or shareholder structure.
International Access / Transparency
The individual assessments should be available to both domestic and foreign institutions with legitimate interests and at equivalent terms. Furthermore, the general methodology used by the ECAI must be publicly available.
Disclosure
An ECAI must disclose both qualitative and quantitative information. These disclosures ensure that the ratings used by banks in allocating risk weightings are compiled by reputable institutions. An absence of transparency could lead to "assessment shopping", where institutions seek more favorable assessments, leading to misleading risk exposure indicators and potentially inadequate capital requirements. Such disclosures also underpin the comparability of disclosures across banks.
β Key Takeaways
The 50% ceiling on counterparty risk weightings for OTC derivatives has been removed due to the invalidity of its original assumption and the improved risk-sensitivity of the new standardized approach. A 20% credit conversion factor applies to short-term commitments (maturity β€ 1 year), with a 0% factor for unconditionally cancellable commitments, while repo-style transactions and guarantees related to them require a 100% credit conversion factor. The Committee intentionally avoids incorporating a maturity dimension into the standardized approach to maintain simplicity, with only limited exceptions. The reliability of the standardized approach hinges on the soundness of External Credit Assessment Institutions (ECAIs), which must be recognized by national supervisors based on criteria including objectivity, independence, transparency, and disclosure. Without proper ECAI disclosure, banks may engage in "assessment shopping," leading to misleading risk exposures and inadequate capital requirements.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What was the basis for removing the 50% ceiling on counterparty risk weightings for OTC derivatives?
- What is the credit conversion factor for a business commitment with an original maturity of up to one year, and what exception exists for a 0% rate?
- According to the lecture, what credit conversion factor must be applied to a bank's guarantee of a third party's performance in an agent-arranged repo-style transaction?
- Why did the Committee decide not to incorporate a general maturity dimension into the standardized approach?
- List the four key criteria that an External Credit Assessment Institution (ECAI) must meet to be recognized by a national supervisor.