๐ Lecture 13 โ Basic Situation of Credit Approval Process
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the foundational structure and segmentation of credit approval processes within financial institutions. It explains how banks design these processes based on customer segments, risk components, and the need to align sales and risk analysis units. The lecture emphasizes a transparent and comprehensive assessment of credit risks.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by describing the common segmentation of credit institutions based on customer demands and how this segmentation influences the design of risk analysis units. It then details the four key risk components from Basel IIโProbability of Default, Loss Given Default, Exposure at Default, and Maturityโthat determine the quality of credit risk identification. The lecture explores four factors for segmenting credit approval processes: type of borrower, source of cash flows, value and type of collateral, and amount and type of claim. Finally, it presents approaches to segmentation, including a distinction between standard and individual processes and the consideration of asset classes under Basel II.
๐ Lecture Summary
Basic Situation of Credit Approval Process
The vast majority of credit institutions serve a number of different customer segments. This segmentation is mostly used to differentiate the services offered and to individualize the respective marketing efforts. As a result, this segmentation is based on customer demands in most cases. Based on its policy, a bank tries to meet the demands of its customers in terms of accessibility and availability, product range and expertise, as well as personal customer service.
In practice, linking sales with the risk analysis units is not an issue in many cases at first. The sales organization often determines the process design in the risk analysis units. Thus, the existing variety of segments on the sales side is often reflected in the structure and process design of the credit analysis units. While classifications in terms of customer segments are, for example, complemented by product-specific segments, there appears to be no uniform model. Given the different sizes of the banks, the lack of volume of comparable claims in small banks renders such a model inadequate also for reasons of complexity, efficiency, and customer orientation.
Irrespective of a bankโs size, it is essential to ensure a transparent and comprehensive presentation as well as an objective and subjective assessment of the risks involved in lending in all cases. The criteria that have to be taken into account in presenting and assessing credit risks determine the design of the credit approval processes. If the respective criteria result in different forms of segmentation for sales and analysis, this will cause friction when credit exposures are passed on from sales to processing. A risk analysis or credit approval processing unit assigned to a specific sales segment may not be able to handle all products offered in that sales segment properly in terms of risk (e.g., processing residential real estate finance in the risk analysis unit dealing with corporate clients). Such a situation can be prevented by making the interface between sales and processing more flexible, with internal guidelines dealing with the problems mentioned here.
๐ก Why this matters: A misalignment between sales and risk analysis units can lead to ineffective risk assessment, highlighting the need for flexible interfaces and clear internal guidelines.
Accounting for Risk Aspects
The quality of the credit approval process from a risk perspective is determined by the best possible identification and evaluation of the credit risk resulting from a possible exposure. The credit risk can be distributed among four risk components which have found their way into the new Basel Capital Accord (Basel II):
a. Probability of default (PD) b. Loss given default (LGD) c. Exposure at default (EAD) d. Maturity (M)
Probability of Default
Reviewing a borrowerโs probability of default is basically done by evaluating the borrowerโs current and future ability to fulfill its interest and principal repayment obligations. This evaluation has to take into account various characteristics of the borrower (natural or legal person), which should lead to a differentiation of the credit approval processes in accordance with the borrowers served by the bank. Furthermore, it has to be taken into account that โ for certain finance transactions โ interest and principal repayments should be financed exclusively from the cash flow of the object to be financed without the possibility for recourse to further assets of the borrower. In this case, the credit review must address the viability of the underlying business model, meaning the source of the cash flows required to meet interest and principal repayment obligations has to be included in the review.
Loss Given Default
The loss given default is affected by the collateralized portion as well as the cost of selling the collateral. Therefore, the calculated value and type of collateral also have to be taken into account in designing the credit approval processes.
Exposure at Default (EAD)
In the vast majority of the cases described here, the exposure at default corresponds to the amount owed to the bank. Thus, besides the type of claim, the amount of the claim is another important element in the credit approval process. Thus, four factors should be taken into account in the segmentation of credit approval processes:
- Type of borrower
- Source of cash flows
- Value and type of collateral
- Amount and type of claim
Approaches to the Segmentation of Credit Approval Processes
The following subsections present possible segmentations to include the four factors mentioned above in structuring the credit approval process. The lending business in which banks engage is highly heterogeneous in terms of volume and complexity, making it impossible to define an optimal model. After the description of possible segmentations, two principles are dealt with that have to be included in the differentiation of the credit approval processes along the four risk components to ensure an efficient structure:
- Distinction between standard and individual processes in the various segments;
- Taking into account asset classes under Basel II
Type of Borrower
In general, type of borrower is used as the highest layer in credit approval processes. This is due to the higher priority of reviewing legal and economic conditions within the substantive credit review process. The way in which the economic situation is assessed greatly depends on the available data. The following segments can be distinguished:
- Sovereigns
- Other public authorities (e.g., regional governments, local authorities)
- Financial services providers (including credit institutions)
- Corporates
- Retail
Usually, at least the segments of corporate and retail customers are differentiated further (e.g., by product category).
Source of Cash Flows
The distinction of so-called specialized lending from other forms of corporate finance is based on the fact that the primary, if not the only source of reducing the exposure is the income from the asset being financed, and not so much the unrelated solvency of the company behind it, which operates on a broader basis. Therefore, the credit review has to focus on the asset to be financed and the expected cash flow. To account for this situation, the segmentation of the credit approval processes should distinguish between:
- Credits to corporations, partnerships, or sole proprietors; and
- Specialized lending
Credit institutions have to distinguish between the following forms of specialized lending in the calculation of regulatory capital:
- Project finance
- Object finance
- Commodities finance
- Finance of income-producing commercial real estate
This subdivision of Basel II primarily serves to determine the required capital correctly, but it can also prove useful from a procedural point of view.
Value and Type of Collateral
Value and type of collateral have a significant impact on the risk involved in lending. Of particular relevance in this context are those types of collateral which afford the lender a claim in rem on the collateral, and those product constructions under which the lender has legal and economic ownership of the asset to be financed.
Two forms of finance are particularly relevant in practice:
- Mortgage finance and
- Leasing finance
Mortgage finance and leasing are those forms of finance which often give the lender a substantial degree of control over the asset being financed. The strong legal position resulting from such collateral may warrant special treatment of the relevant forms of finance.
โญ Key Takeaways
A student must remember that the segmentation of credit approval processes is primarily driven by customer demands but must be aligned with risk analysis units to avoid friction, often requiring flexible interfaces. The core of credit risk assessment is based on the four Basel II risk componentsโProbability of Default (PD), Loss Given Default (LGD), Exposure at Default (EAD), and Maturity (M). The four critical factors for segmenting these processes are the type of borrower, source of cash flows, value and type of collateral, and amount and type of claim. Two key principles for structuring efficient processes are the distinction between standard and individual processes and consideration of Basel II asset classes. Finally, specialized lending requires a specific focus on the cash flow from the financed asset itself, not the borrowerโs broader solvency.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four risk components from Basel II that determine the quality of credit risk identification?
- What are the four factors that should be taken into account in the segmentation of credit approval processes?
- What is the key distinction between "standard and individual processes" in the context of segmenting credit approval?
- For what type of lending must the credit review focus exclusively on the cash flow of the financed asset rather than the borrower's general solvency?
- Name the five segments of borrowers used as the highest layer in credit approval processes.
๐ Lecture 14 โ Basic Situation of Credit Approval Process (Cont.)
๐ Overview: This lecture continues the exploration of the credit approval process by focusing on how the level of exposure impacts procedural design. It distinguishes between standard and individual processes, introduces the asset classes mandated by Basel II, and explains how the object of review and exposure management are handled, particularly for complex corporate groups.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the impact of the level of exposure on the credit approval process, the differentiation between standard and individual processes, the asset classes under Basel II (including the standardized and IRB approaches), and the object of review and exposure management for economic units and corporate groups.
๐ Lecture Summary
Level of Exposure
The level of exposure has a direct impact on the exposure at default (EAD). Therefore, an increase in the level of exposure should automatically trigger a more detailed credit review of the borrower. This relationship, combined with the risk minimization achieved by standardization and automation, explains why credit approval processes are often separated into low-volume and high-volume lending business. This leads to a sub-segmentation within claims segments, commonly referred to as standard process and individual process.
Standard and Individual Processes
The distinction between standard and individual processes is a common process differentiation within claims segments, not a separate segment itself. The level of engagement is the decisive element for this differentiation.
- Standard processes aim for more efficient execution. Because most segments have concentrations of specific product specifications, processes can be developed for those characteristics. They are intended only for handling certain credit products with limited features and options. Limiting the process to specific products and maximum exposure volumes allows for simplifications and automations, particularly for credit decisions by vote or highly automated decisions.
- Individual processes have an adaptive design to handle a variety of products, collateral, and conditions. This is required especially for high-volume corporate customer business, as both borrower characteristics and product specifics are very heterogeneous. Because of the higher risk involved, loans processed through an individual process should use a double vote (one from the front office and one from the back office).
Asset Classes under Basel II
The new Basel Capital Accord provides mandatory rules for regulatory capital requirements. Basel II provides two approaches for determining capital requirements: the standardized approach and the internal ratings-based (IRB) approach. The IRB approach allows a more risk-sensitive calculation based on a bank's internal estimates. The goal is to use the economic capital requirement as the yardstick for the regulatory capital requirement.
The IRB approach distinguishes the following asset classes:
- Sovereign exposures
- Bank exposures
- Corporate exposures
- Retail exposures
- Equity exposures
- Securitization
- Fixed assets
If a bank uses the IRB approach, these asset classes must be accounted for in the segmentation process. Claims on individuals belong to the retail portfolio, which can also include credits to SMEs if the total exposure per enterprise is less than one million euro and they are not treated like large enterprises. This differentiation is significant because Basel II allows a pooling approach for retail exposures, where risk parameters are derived from a pool of homogenous exposures, not an individual one. This permits the use of simplified credit rating processes.
๐ Definition โ Pooling Approach: A method for determining capital requirements for retail exposures where risk parameters are derived from a pool of homogenous exposures, not from an individual exposure.
Object of Review and Exposure Management
Credit approval processes begin for a credit applicant, but in corporate lending, it is often necessary to include multiple persons considered one economic unit, as their credit standings may mutually impact each other. Credit approval for groups of companies should focus the review on the actual risk-bearerโthe person whose legal and economic situation ultimately determines the ability to fulfill obligations.
Base II requires an assessment of the borrowerโs credit standing. In complex company networks, the link to the credit institution may go beyond pure sales contacts, leading to vague guidelines in exposure management. From a risk perspective, the overall risk of the risk-bearer should be aggregated over the bank as a whole and presented to decision makers. Internal guidelines should clearly define the risk-bearer, a classification usually based on loss-sharing arrangements or legal interdependences. It should also be stipulated whether aggregation is done by one person at the group level or in a decentralized fashion.
๐ก Why this matters: Properly identifying the risk-bearer and aggregating risk is critical for managing risk concentration in complex corporate structures, preventing a bank from being unknowingly overexposed to a single economic entity.
โญ Key Takeaways
The level of exposure is the primary driver for differentiating between standard and individual credit processes, with standard processes being more efficient for lower-risk, homogeneous products and individual processes using a double vote for higher-risk corporate loans. Basel II mandates specific asset classes (sovereign, bank, corporate, retail, equity, securitization, fixed assets) and allows for an IRB approach that is more risk-sensitive than the standardized approach. A critical concept is the pooling approach for retail exposures, which allows for simplified processes based on a pool of similar loans. For complex borrowers, the credit process must correctly identify the risk-bearer and aggregate total exposure across the bank to manage risk effectively.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the immediate impact of an increased level of exposure on the credit approval process?
- What is the primary differentiating criterion between a standard process and an individual process.
- List the seven asset classes under the Basel II IRB approach.
- Define a "pooling approach" and explain which asset class it applies to according to Basel II.
- In the context of credit approval for a group of companies, who is the "risk-bearer" and why is it important to identify them?
๐ Lecture 15 โ Object of Review and Exposure Management
๐ Overview: This lecture examines the critical aspects of credit approval processes, focusing on identifying the correct risk-bearer in complex corporate structures. It explains how Basel II requirements necessitate careful assessment of credit standing, particularly when dealing with groups of companies, and emphasizes the importance of proper exposure management and segmentation for effective risk mitigation.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the object of review and exposure management, including how credit approval processes must account for multiple natural and legal persons considered as one economic unit. It discusses Basel II requirements for assessing borrower credit standing, the classification of risk-bearers based on loss-sharing arrangements, the overview of the credit approval process including segmentation, integration of sales and IT in process design, and the critical process steps leading up to the credit review that involve data collection, checking, and passing on information.
๐ Lecture Summary
Object of Review and Exposure Management
Credit approval processes are initiated on behalf of a credit applicant. In corporate lending, it is often necessary to include several natural or legal persons in the credit rating process. This is required when these persons are considered one economic unit and would thus have a mutual impact on each other's credit standing. In practice, granting an individual loan often involves a large number of natural and legal persons, which must be borne in mind throughout the entire credit approval process, particularly during the credit review.
Credit approval for groups of companies should be designed in a manner specific to the risk involved and efficient. The review should focus on the actual risk-bearer โ that natural or legal person whose legal and economic situation ultimately determines the ability to fulfill the obligations under the credit agreement. Basel II requires the assessment of the borrower's credit standing, especially in complex and far-reaching company networks where the link to the respective credit institution may go beyond pure sales contacts (e.g., a foreign holding company and a domestic subsidiary).
๐ Definition โ Risk-Bearer: The natural or legal person whose legal and economic situation ultimately determines the ability to fulfill the obligations under the credit agreement.
From a risk perspective, the overall risk of the risk-bearer should always be aggregated over the bank as a whole and then presented to the decision makers. Internal guidelines should contain provisions that clearly define the risk-bearer. This classification is usually based on loss-sharing arrangements or legal interdependences. It should also be stipulated whether aggregation should be effected by one person in charge (at group level) in processing or risk analysis, or in a decentralized fashion by each unit itself.
๐ก Why this matters: Proper identification of the risk-bearer is essential because errors here can lead to underestimating the true credit exposure, violating Basel II requirements, and making poor lending decisions.
Overview of the Credit Approval Process
The order of subsections reflects the sequence of steps in the credit approval process, with the credit approval process for new customers serving as the general framework. Credit approval processes for existing customers are addressed explicitly if they contain process steps not found in the new customer process, at least in a similar form.
The definition of exposure segments is an important prerequisite to handle credit approval processes in a manner specific to the risk involved and efficient. Many risk mitigation measures can only take full effect if they account for the specific characteristics of the credit applicants. Therefore, the segmentation of the credit approval processes is a central component of risk mitigation.
While risk mitigation measures should be designed in accordance with the specifics of each segment, there is a uniform basic structure of these measures discussed in the following subchapters. A presentation of the specific design would only be possible with reference to a detailed definition of individual segments. Such definition is impossible due to the great heterogeneity among banks addressed by this guideline and can thus only be established for each bank separately. Thus, the following lectures will primarily discuss the basic structure of risk mitigation measures and the way in which they work.
The distinction between standard and individual processes is pointed out as this distinction is a central element in the design of credit approval processes nowadays. In case differences in process design are considered essential for the effectiveness of risk mitigation measures, this design will be described in more detail.
๐ Definition โ Exposure Segments: Categories of credit applicants defined by specific characteristics that allow credit approval processes to be handled in a manner specific to the risk involved and efficient.
Integration of Sales and IT in the Process Design
An early integration of sales and IT is an essential prerequisite for the success of a reorientation of the credit approval process. In order to facilitate their implementation, changes in processes have to be reflected in the bank's IT structure. The extensive planning and alignment effort involved in IT projects (in particular the coordination of IT interfaces to all organizational units that use data from the credit approval processes) makes it necessary to check at an early stage whether the project is feasible and can be financed.
This depiction of the credit approval processes is highly relevant not only for risk analysis and processing but has particular significance for sales. Changes in processes, in particular the introduction of mostly automated credit decisions, entail a considerable change in the user interface in sales applications. Therefore, the success of the implementation is highly dependent on the extent to which employees accept such changes.
๐ก Why this matters: Without early sales and IT integration, new credit approval processes may be technically unfeasible, financially unsustainable, or rejected by employees who must use them daily.
Process Steps Leading up to the Credit Review
The execution of the credit review is based on external and internal data on the credit applicant. Especially for extensive exposures, considerable resources may be tied up in the process of:
- Collecting the data
- Checking the data for completeness and plausibility
- Passing on the data to people in charge of handling, analyzing, and processing the exposure within the bank
These steps can also lead to a large number of procedural errors. As the data included form the basis for the credit review, errors in collecting, aggregating, and passing them on are especially relevant from a risk perspective. The subchapter thus focuses on measures to avoid such procedural errors.
๐ Definition โ Procedural Errors: Errors occurring during data collection, aggregation, and transmission that form the basis for incorrect credit reviews and are particularly relevant from a risk perspective.
โญ Key Takeaways
The most critical points from this lecture are that credit approval processes must properly identify the actual risk-bearer in complex corporate structures, especially when multiple entities form one economic unit, as Basel II requires assessment of the borrower's credit standing. Risk aggregation must be performed over the entire bank and presented to decision makers, with classification based on loss-sharing arrangements or legal interdependences. Segmentation of credit approval processes into exposure segments is a central risk mitigation measure that must account for the specific characteristics of credit applicants. Early integration of sales and IT is essential for successful implementation, as automation changes user interfaces and employee acceptance determines success. Finally, the data collection, checking, and transmission process leading up to the credit review is highly prone to procedural errors that are especially dangerous from a risk perspective because they undermine the entire review.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
-
What is the definition of a "risk-bearer" in the context of credit approval for groups of companies, and why is it important to identify them correctly?
-
On what basis should the classification of risk-bearers typically be established according to the lecture?
-
Why is the segmentation of credit approval processes into exposure segments considered a central component of risk mitigation?
-
What are the two key departments that must be integrated early in the reorientation of credit approval processes, and what challenges does this integration address?
-
What three steps in the process leading up to the credit review are most prone to procedural errors, and why are these errors especially relevant from a risk perspective?
๐ Lecture 16 โ Data Collection
๐ Overview: This lecture details the systematic process of gathering, verifying, and transferring information for credit assessment. It emphasizes the importance of structured data collection methods, preliminary reviews to filter applications efficiently, and proper handover procedures to ensure complete information flow between sales and risk analysis departments.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the data collection process for credit applicants, including standardized visit reports and mandatory data checklists. It explains the plausibility check and preliminary review system using red and yellow criteria for efficient filtering. Finally, it addresses procedures for passing on data through handover reports and interface plans between sales and risk analysis.
๐ Lecture Summary
Data Collection
The assessment of a credit applicantโs credit standing is based on different data sources and data types according to the borrower type. A bank must always be interested in having comprehensive and current data on the economic and personal situation of the borrower. The respective account manager typically coordinates the gathering of information to ensure consistent customer service, and the credit review incorporates both economic data and qualitative information concerning the borrower.
The account manager should include a complete and critical picture of the borrower. To ensure all gathered information is passed to the person in charge of the credit review, it is advisable to prepare standardized and structured reports on customer visits. This procedure has proven effective in directing conversations with customers as desired, functioning as a conversation guide, and ensures information is gathered entirely and efficiently. The layout of visit reports should be specified for each segment and included in internal guidelines.
To make sure data collected is complete, mandatory lists showing what data are required should be used. These lists must be adapted to the requirements of the credit review process conforming to the type of borrower in each case. In addition to individual borrower data, many cases require general information on the economic situation of a region or an industry, where the bank can use external sources. If a bankโs credit portfolio focuses on certain industries or regions, banks are advised to conduct their own analyses of the economic situation in these fields, particularly if external information lacks necessary detail or currency.
Plausibility Check and Preliminary Review
Before a credit exposure undergoes comprehensive credit review, the employee initially in charge should conduct a plausibility check and preliminary review. This check looks at the completeness and consistency of documents filed by the borrower to minimize process loops and the need for further inquiries with the customer. Additionally, sales should carry out an initial substantive check based on a select few relevant criteria, with objectives including creation of awareness and active assumption of responsibility for credit risk on the part of the sales department.
The preliminary check is especially significant in segments with high rejection rates, as a comprehensive credit review ties up considerable resources in these segments. The preliminary check should prevent exposures that will most likely be rejected from tying up capacities in risk analysis. The resulting reduction in cases dealt with by risk analysis allows a more detailed scrutiny of promising exposures and is thus desirable in terms of risk as well as efficiency.
In practice, the distinction between two types of check criteria has proven successful:
- Red criteria: If fulfilled, these lead to an outright rejection of the exposure, also referred to as knock-out criteria.
- Yellow criteria: If fulfilled, these require the sales staff to present a plausible and well-documented justification of the respective situation. If this justification cannot be made, the exposure also has to be rejected.
๐ก Why this matters: This two-tier system allows banks to quickly reject clearly unsuitable applications (red criteria) while giving borderline cases a chance for approval with proper documentation and justification (yellow criteria), saving significant time and resources.
Passing on Data
Making sure that information is passed on in its entirety is relevant from a risk perspective and concerns processes where the credit approval process is not concluded by the account manager. If internal guidelines provide for a transfer of responsibility, or if the credit review is conducted by two or more people, it is necessary to ensure the complete set of relevant documents is handed over. It would be advisable to prepare handover reports for this purpose.
Handover reports should fully reflect changes in responsibility in the course of the credit approval process as well as any interface occurring in the process. In practice, a modular structure has proven particularly effective for such forms. If possible, they should be kept electronically or, alternatively, as the first page of the respective credit folder.
The sales employee has to use the module (table or text module) provided for handing over the exposure to the respective process. This contains, among other things, an enumeration of the documents required for the respective risk analysis segment, forming a completeness checklist. On the one hand, this ensures a smooth transfer of documents, and on the other, it prevents incomplete files from being handed over to risk analysis. In addition, further modules such as notes taken during customer appointments should be included in the handover reports.
Furthermore, appropriate modules should be included for all other interfaces between sales and risk analysis, or between different persons in processing. To facilitate consistent application of handover reports, it would be advisable to prepare detailed interface plans, which should show the interfaces between sales and risk analysis. The internal guidelines have to stipulate the responsibilities along the interface plans in detail, which should ensure consistent application and minimize procedural risks resulting from change in responsibility (e.g., loss of documents). Furthermore, this list serves to clearly assign specific responsibilities, helping avoid errors in the credit approval process that could result from unclear responsibilities (e.g., failure to carry out a required process step).
โญ Key Takeaways
Data collection must be systematic and complete, using standardized customer visit reports and mandatory checklists adapted to borrower type. The plausibility check and preliminary review using red criteria (automatic rejection) and yellow criteria (requires justification) efficiently filters applications before full credit review, saving significant resources. Proper handover reports with a modular structure and completeness checklists ensure complete information transfer between sales and risk analysis. Detailed interface plans and clear assignment of responsibilities in internal guidelines minimize procedural risks like document loss or missed process steps. The entire process is designed to balance efficiency with thorough risk assessment, allowing more detailed scrutiny of promising exposures.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two main components of information that a credit review incorporates according to the lecture?
- What is the purpose of standardized and structured reports on customer visits, and how do they function?
- What is the difference between red criteria and yellow criteria in the preliminary review process?
- Why is the preliminary check especially significant in segments with high rejection rates?
- What two key documents are recommended for ensuring proper transfer of data between sales and risk analysis, and what do they contain?
๐ Lecture 17 โ CREDIT REVIEW AND VALUATION OF COLLATERAL
๐ Overview: This lecture examines the critical processes of credit review and collateral valuation that follow initial exposure assessment. It explains how standardized modelsโheuristic, empirical-statistical, and causalโare used to evaluate credit data, and details the two main approaches to credit decision-making: individual decisions and automated processes, with a focus on the components of a typical rating system (financial and qualitative ratings).
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by explaining the two components of a credit review: standardized models of data evaluation and documentation/evaluation of other credit assessment factors. It then categorizes and explains four types of standardized evaluation modelsโheuristic, empirical statistical, causal, and hybrid models. The lecture proceeds to cover the practical integration of these models in credit decision processes, distinguishing between individual decision-making (where standardized evaluation is complemented by further steps and collateral valuation) and mostly automated decisions. Finally, it details the components of a standardized credit review (rating), specifically the financial (quantitative) rating and the qualitative rating, and explains how they are combined into a base rating.
๐ Lecture Summary
Credit Review and Valuation of Collateral
Exposure assessment involves both the credit review and a valuation of the collateral provided by the credit applicant. These steps work together to make the risks resulting from the exposure transparent and to allow a final assessment of the exposure. The credit review itself consists of two process components: (1) standardized models of data evaluation and (2) documentation and evaluation of other credit assessment factors.
Credit reviews are increasingly marked by standardized procedures. These procedures support, and sometimes even replace, the subjective decision-making process in assessing credit standing. In practice, some credit review processes are completely based on standardized and automated models, providing no manual documentation or assessment of other factors beyond the automated output.
After establishing and assessing the risk involved in lending, the collateral offered by the applicant is examined and evaluated. The collateralized portion does not affect the applicantโs probability of default, so its impact on assessing the exposure must be dealt with independently of the credit review.
Standardized Models of Data Evaluation (Rating Models)
Many different models exist for the standardized evaluation of credit assessment data. These can be divided into three main categories: heuristic models, empirical statistical models, and causal models. In practice, hybrid models are also used, which are based on two or three of the other models.
Heuristic models attempt to take experiences and use them as a basis to methodically gain new insights. These experiences can stem from:
- Conjectured business interrelationships,
- Subjective practical experiences and observations,
- Business theories related to specific aspects.
In terms of credit review, experience from the lending business is used to predict a borrowerโs future credit standing. Heuristic models depend on the fact that the subjective experiences of the credit experts are reflected appropriately. Not only the credit assessment factors are determined heuristically, but also their impact and weighting in the final decision are based on subjective experiences.
Empirical statistical models assess a borrowerโs credit standing based on objectifying processes. Certain credit review criteria are compared against an existing database that was established empirically. This comparison enables the classification of the credit exposure. The goodness of fit of an empirical statistical model depends greatly on the quality of the database used. The database must be sufficiently large to allow significant findings, and it must represent the credit institutionโs future business adequately.
Causal models derive direct analytical links to creditworthiness based on finance theory. They do not use statistical methods to test hypotheses on an empirical basis.
Hybrid models try to combine the advantages of several systems. Empirical statistical models are used only for those assessment factors for which a sufficient database exists. Other credit assessment factors are assessed by means of heuristic systems, while causal analysis models are typically not used.
๐ก Why this matters: The choice of model directly impacts whether a credit decision relies on subjective expert judgment, objective statistical data, or theoretical financial relationships.
Individual Decision
In an individual decision process, the standardized data evaluation is complemented by further process steps to assess the credit standing. After the credit review, the collateral is evaluated. An integrated look at the detailed results leads to an individual credit decision which is not directly contingent on the results of the individual process components.
Standardized Credit Review (Rating)
A typical rating process consists of two components: (1) financial rating (or quantitative rating) and (2) qualitative rating.
Financial rating comprises an analysis of the financial data available for the credit applicant. The analysis of annual financial statements (a backward-looking approach) has a central position. Increasingly, the analysis of business planning (a forward-looking approach) is also employed. Usually, automated programs calculate indicators from the annual financial statements or the business plan. In most cases, the financial rating is carried out by credit analysts who are not related to sales in terms of organizational structure. The degree of specialization depends on the volume and complexity of each bankโs business activities.
In conventional corporate customer business, most elements of the financial rating are carried out by specialized employees. There may be additional specialized units that furnish the primarily responsible employees with certain analyses (this is a modular system). In many banks, there are units specializing in the analysis of foreign companies or real estate finance. Setting up a separate unit should be considered when the analysis requires the development of special know-how and when the number of analyses renders a complete specialization of employees feasible in terms of efficiency.
If analyses are drawn up by employees other than those primarily responsible for the credit approval process, the administrative process must be as efficient as possible. There should be a general guideline that the analysis is confirmed by the person in charge of the organizational unit supplying the module when it is handed over to the credit officer managing the exposure. The common practice of having the people in charge of every single organizational unit involved in the credit approval process also confirm the completed credit application is rejected as inefficient and unnecessary in terms of risk.
In contrast to financial rating, qualitative rating requires comprehensive knowledge of the borrower to be successful. In the course of the rating, the qualitative factors are also evaluated in a standardized fashion using one of the models described above. This is typically done by the sales employee. As qualitative rating may involve characteristics that go beyond the borrower itself (e.g., product positioning within the competitive environment), it is possible to integrate additional organizational units, such as units specializing in evaluating product markets.
Using a weighting function, the financial and qualitative ratings are combined, with the result usually referred to as base rating.
โญ Key Takeaways
The credit review process uses standardized models (heuristic, empirical-statistical, causal, or hybrid) to evaluate risk, but collateral valuation must be treated independently as it does not affect the probability of default. In an individual decision process, the standardized evaluation is complemented by further steps and collateral assessment before a final credit decision is made. A typical rating system has two components: a financial (quantitative) rating, which analyzes financial data and is usually performed by specialized analysts, and a qualitative rating, which requires deep borrower knowledge and is typically performed by sales employees. The two ratings are combined using a weighting function to produce a single base rating. Efficiency in the administrative process is critical, especially when modular specialized units contribute to the analysis.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two main process components of a credit review?
- What is the key difference between heuristic models and empirical statistical models in credit evaluation?
- Why is the valuation of collateral handled independently of the credit review?
- What are the two components of a typical rating process, and who typically performs each one?
- How are the financial rating and the qualitative rating combined to produce a final result?