π Lecture 21 β Capital Structure & Cost of Equity Modigliani and Miller Model
π Overview: This lecture explores the Modigliani and Miller (M&M) theorem on capital structure, explaining how a firm's value is independent of its financing mix under certain assumptions. It covers homemade leverage, the concept of constant WACC, business versus financial risk, and the impact of taxes on the M&M model. Understanding this theory is fundamental to modern corporate finance and capital structure decisions.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers homemade leverage, where investors can replicate corporate leverage through personal borrowing; the Modigliani & Miller Model, which states firm value is independent of financing choices; how WACC remains constant across different debt-equity combinations; the distinction between business risk and financial risk; and the M&M model when corporate taxes are introduced, showing that leverage creates a tax shield that increases firm value.
π Lecture Summary
1. Home made leverage
An investor can change the overall financial leverage to which he is exposed, by the use of personal borrowing and investing it. This is a substitution of risks that investors may undergo in order to move from overpriced shares in highly levered firms to those in un-levered firms by borrowing in personal accounts. Mainly attributed to the Modigliani-Miller Theorem, homemade leverage describes the situation where individuals borrowing on the exact same terms as large firms can duplicate corporate leverage through purchasing and financing options.
π Definition β Homemade Leverage: The process where an investor replicates the effects of corporate leverage by using personal borrowing to invest in an unlevered firm, effectively creating their own debt-equity mix.
π‘ Why this matters: If investors can create their own leverage, they will not pay a premium for a levered firm's shares, which is a key argument for why capital structure may be irrelevant.
2. Modigliani & Miller Model
A financial theory stating that the market value of a firm is determined by its earning power and the risk of its underlying assets, and is independent of the way it chooses to finance its investments or distribute dividends. A firm can choose between three methods of financing: issuing shares, borrowing and spending profits (as opposed to dispersing them to shareholders in dividends). The theorem gets much more complicated, but the basic idea is that, under certain assumptions, it makes no difference whether a firm finances itself with debt or equity.
The Modigliani-Miller theorem forms the basis for modern thinking on capital structure. The basic theorem states that, in the absence of taxes, bankruptcy costs, and asymmetric information and in an efficient market, the value of a firm is unaffected by how that firm is financed. It does not matter if the firm's capital is raised by issuing stock or selling debt. It does not matter what the firm's dividend policy is.
Merton Miller used an analogy: "Think of the firm as a gigantic tub of whole milk. The farmer can sell the whole milk as is. Or he can separate out the cream and sell it at a considerably higher price than the whole milk would bring. (That's the analog of a firm selling low-yield and hence high-priced debt securities.) But, of course, what the farmer would have left would be skim milk with low butterfat content and that would sell for much less than whole milk. That corresponds to the levered equity. The M and M proposition says that if there were no costs of separation (and, of course, no government dairy-support programs), the cream plus the skim milk would bring the same price as the whole milk."
π Definition β Modigliani-Miller Theorem (No Taxes): The proposition that in perfect markets (no taxes, no bankruptcy costs, efficient markets), the value of a firm is independent of its capital structure.
3. How WACC remains constant?
A calculation of a firm's cost of capital in which each category of capital is proportionately weighted. All capital sources - common stock, preferred stock, bonds and any other long-term debt - are included in a WACC calculation. WACC is calculated by multiplying the cost of each capital component by its proportional weight and then summing:
π Formula: WACC = (E/V) Γ Re + (D/V) Γ Rd Γ (1 β Tc)
Where: Re = cost of equity Rd = cost of debt E = market value of the firm's equity D = market value of the firm's debt V = E + D E/V = percentage of financing that is equity D/V = percentage of financing that is debt Tc = corporate tax rate
The weighted average cost of capital will be constant if the proportionate weight of all sources remains constant i.e. common stock, preferred stock, bonds and any other long term debt. And also the return on common & preferred stock and interest on debt remains constant, then WACC remains constant. When we talk about WACC remains constant we actually mean that any combination of debt & equity from 100% will not alter the overall cost of capital. That means that if you slice bread into four pieces and then each piece into two to make total of eight pieces. Now you have more pieces but not more bread.
π Example: The following table shows WACC remains constant across different capital structures:
| Item | Case 1 | Case 2 | Case 3 | Case 4 | Case 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Assets (Rs.) | 6,000,000 | 6,000,000 | 6,000,000 | 6,000,000 | 6,000,000 |
| Debt (Rs.) | 0 | 2,000,000 | 3,000,000 | 4,000,000 | 5,000,000 |
| Equity (Rs.) | 6,000,000 | 4,000,000 | 3,000,000 | 2,000,000 | 1,000,000 |
| Debt/Equity Ratio | 0 | 0.50 | 1.00 | 2.00 | 5.00 |
| Shares Outstanding | 300,000 | 200,000 | 150,000 | 100,000 | 50,000 |
| EBIT (Rs.) | 800,000 | 800,000 | 800,000 | 800,000 | 800,000 |
| EPS (Rs.) | 2.67 | 4.00 | 5.33 | 8.00 | 16.00 |
| WACC | 13.33% | 13.33% | 13.33% | 13.33% | 13.33% |
As debt increases, EPS rises (from 2.67 to 16.00) and ROE increases (from 13.33% to 30.00%), but the WACC remains constant at 13.33% in all cases because the total capitalization is always Rs. 6,000,000.
4. Business & Financial Risk
Business Risk is the risk associated with the unique circumstances of a particular company, as they might affect the price of that company's securities. Risks can fester and spread anywhere inside an organization. Many are industry-specific, such as the regulatory concerns within financial services and healthcare. Others are common to all industries, such as supply chain capacity, financial reporting reliability, human resources availability, and consumer relationship integrity.
Financial Risk is an assessment of the possibility that a given investment or loan will fail to bring a return and may result in a loss of the original investment or loan. It is the risk that a company will not have adequate cash flow to meet financial obligations, and the risk that an investment will be unable to return profit to an investor.
5. M & M Model with Taxes
A financial theory stating that the market value of a firm is determined by its earning power and the risk of its underlying assets. With taxes, the theorem changes significantly.
Proposition 1 (with taxes):
- VL is the value of a levered firm.
- VU is the value of an un-levered firm.
- TCB is the tax rate (TC) Γ the value of debt (B)
π Formula: VL = VU + TCB
This means that there are advantages for firms to be levered, since corporations can deduct interest payments. Therefore leverage lowers tax payments. Dividend payments are non-deductible.
Proposition 2 (with taxes):
- Rs is the cost of equity.
- r0 is the cost of capital for an all equity firm.
- rB is the cost of debt.
- B/S is the debt-to-equity ratio.
- Tc is the tax rate.
π Formula: Rs = r0 + (B/S) Γ (1 β Tc) Γ (r0 β rB)
The same relationship as earlier described stating that the cost of equity rises with leverage, because the risk to equity rises, still holds. The formula however has implications for the difference with the WACC.
The following assumptions are made in the propositions with taxes:
- corporations are taxed at the rate TC on earnings after interest,
- no transaction cost exist,
- individuals and corporations borrow at the same rate,
- Debt is forever.
Concluding the discussion, the after tax cash flow of two identical firms in terms of EBIT but having different capital structure β debt β equity weight age will affect the value of firm. This is because debt in capital structure provides tax shield as interest on debt is tax deductible expense. Thus tax shield increases the value of a firm: a levered firmβs value is greater than the un-levered firm.
π‘ Why this matters: With taxes, the M&M model predicts that firms should use 100% debt financing to maximize value through the tax shield, which contradicts the no-tax version and explains why real-world firms do use debt but not exclusively.
β Key Takeaways
The M&M theorem without taxes argues that firm value is independent of capital structure, as investors can create homemade leverage to replicate any corporate leverage, and WACC remains constant regardless of the debt-equity mix. However, when corporate taxes are introduced, the model changes significantly: interest payments are tax-deductible, creating a tax shield that increases the value of a levered firm by TCB. This implies that, all else equal, a levered firm is worth more than an unlevered firm, and the optimal capital structure would be 100% debt. Business risk arises from the firm's operations and industry, while financial risk arises from the use of debt financing, and the cost of equity increases with leverage to compensate shareholders for bearing additional financial risk.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is homemade leverage, and why is it important for the M&M theorem?
- According to the M&M theorem without taxes, does WACC change when a firm increases its debt-to-equity ratio? Why or why not?
- Using the data from the lecture example, calculate EPS for a firm with Rs. 6,000,000 in assets, Rs. 3,000,000 in debt at 10% interest, and 150,000 shares outstanding if EBIT is Rs. 800,000.
- What is the formula for the value of a levered firm with taxes (VL), and how does the tax shield increase firm value?
- Explain the difference between business risk and financial risk, and give one example of each.
π Lecture 22 β Problems Associated with High Gearing & Dividend Policies
π Overview: This lecture explores the challenges of high financial leverage, including bankruptcy costs and the search for optimal capital structure. It then transitions to dividend policy, examining different types of dividends, important dates, various dividend policies, and the factors influencing them, culminating in the Modigliani-Miller argument for dividend irrelevance.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by detailing problems associated with high gearing, such as direct and indirect bankruptcy costs, and how these costs offset the benefits of debt financing. It then defines the optimal capital structure as the point minimizing the weighted-average cost of capital. The second half introduces dividend policy, types of dividends (cash, stock, property), and important dividend dates. Various dividend policies (stable, constant payout, hybrid, fluctuating) are examined, followed by legal and practical factors influencing dividend policy, concluding with the M&M irrelevance theory.
π Lecture Summary
Problems associated with high gearing
Gearing describes a financial ratio comparing owner's equity to borrowed funds, measuring financial leverage. A company with high gearing is more vulnerable to business cycle downturns because it must service debt regardless of sales performance. The M&M model notes debt financing increases firm value due to the tax shield, but high gearing presents problems, primarily bankruptcy costs. As debt increases, default risk rises. The interest tax shield should outweigh bankruptcy costs for leverage to be beneficial. Direct bankruptcy costs include assets fetching less than going concern value in liquidation, plus legal and redundancy costs. These losses are borne by debt holders, who demand higher returns, driving down firm security value.
π Definition β Gearing: A financial ratio comparing owner's equity to borrowed funds, measuring financial leverage. π Formula: Debt-to-equity ratio = Total debt / Total equity β Indicates the proportion of company financing from debt versus equity. π‘ Why this matters: High gearing amplifies returns in good times but increases bankruptcy risk in downturns.
Bankruptcy Costs
Bankruptcy is a legal proceeding where a business declares inability to pay debts, allowing restructuring or absolution of debts. The argument is that expected indirect and direct bankruptcy costs offset the benefits from leverage, making the optimal leverage less than 100% debt financing. Indirect bankruptcy costs occur when a firm approaches bankruptcy under severe financial distress. Employees leave, suppliers refuse credit, and customers leave fearing the firm cannot honor warranties and after-sales service commitments. These factors reduce future cash flow and firm value.
π Definition β Bankruptcy: A legal proceeding whereby a business declares inability to pay back debts.
Optimal capital structure
Optimal capital structure is the capital structure with a minimum weighted-average cost of capital, maximizing the value of the firm's stock, but not necessarily maximizing earnings per share (EPS). Greater leverage maximizes EPS but also increases risk. The optimal structure usually involves some debt, not 100% debt. Firms should attempt to find an optimal range for the capital structure. The required rate of return on equity capital (R) can be estimated by adding a percentage to the firm's long-term cost of debt or using the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM) .
π Definition β Optimal capital structure: Capital structure that minimizes the weighted-average cost of capital and maximizes the firm's stock value. π‘ Why this matters: Finding the right debt-equity balance maximizes firm value while managing risk, as too much debt increases bankruptcy costs and too little debt forgoes tax benefits.
Dividend Policy
Dividend policy is the policy a company uses to decide how much it will pay out to shareholders in dividends. A dividend is a distribution of a portion of a company's earnings, decided by the board of directors, to shareholders. Dividends are quoted in terms of dividends per share (DPS) or as a percent of current market price called dividend yield. Economic logic and research suggest that dividend policy is theoretically irrelevant.
π Definition β Dividend policy: The policy a company uses to decide dividend payouts to shareholders. π Formula: Dividend yield = Dividends per share / Current market price β Percentage return from dividends relative to stock price.
Types of Dividends and Important Dates
Types of Dividends:
- Cash dividends (most common) are paid in cash, are taxable to recipients, and are the most common method of sharing corporate profits.
- Stock or scrip dividends (common) are paid in additional stock shares, usually in proportion to shares owned (e.g., for every 100 shares owned, a 5% stock dividend yields 5 extra shares). This is similar to a stock split, increasing total shares while lowering price per share without changing market capitalization.
- Property or dividends in specie are paid in assets from the issuing corporation or its subsidiary, often in the form of products or services, or securities of other companies.
Important Dates:
- Declaration date: The day the Board of Directors announces intention to pay a dividend, creating a liability on the company's books.
- Date of record: Shareholders registered on or before this date will receive the dividend. Registration is automatic for shares purchased before the ex-dividend date.
- Ex dividend date: Set by the exchange, usually two days before the date of record, to allow trade settlement. Purchasers buying before this date receive the dividend (trade cum dividend); purchasers on or after this date do not (trade ex-dividend).
- Payment date: The date when dividend cheques are mailed to shareholders.
π Definition β Ex dividend date: The date on or after which a stock buyer will not receive the declared dividend.
Dividend Policies
- Stable dividend per share: Implies low risk firm, looked upon favorably by investors, increases marketability of shares, and aids financial planning as cash flow can be accurately ascertained.
- Constant dividend payout: A fixed percentage of earnings (dividend per share / EPS) is paid out as dividend. Since net income is not constant, dividend amounts vary, resulting in variability of return to investors. Dividends may drop to zero in case of loss. Market price of shares will be lower.
- Hybrid dividend policy: Contains features of both stable and constant payout policies. Dividend consists of a stable base amount plus a percentage increment in high-income years. This is more flexible but increases uncertainty of future cash flow. The extra percentage is only paid when there is a high jump in income.
- Fluctuating dividends: When the firm has investment opportunities or unstable capital expenditure, dividends are a residual amount left after meeting capital expenditure.
π Example: For a hybrid dividend policy, a company might pay a stable base of $1.00 per share, plus an extra 50% of any earnings per share above $2.00. If EPS is $3.00, the dividend would be $1.00 + 0.50 Γ ($3.00 - $2.00) = $1.50 per share.
Factors Influencing Dividend Policy
Legal Rules: A. Capital Impairment Rule: Many states prohibit dividends if they impair "capital" (usually par value of common stock or par plus additional paid-in capital). Delaware allows using "fair value" rather than "book value." B. Insolvency Rule: Some states prohibit cash dividends if the company is insolvent under "fair market valuation" or "equitable" sense. C. Undue Retention of Earnings Rule: Prohibits retaining earnings in excess of present and future investment needs.
Other Issues to Consider:
- Funding Needs of the Firm
- Liquidity
- Ability to Borrow
- Restrictions in Debt Contracts (protective covenants)
- Control
Irrelevance of Dividend Policy
A. Current dividends versus retention of earnings: M&M contend that the effect of dividend payments on shareholder wealth is exactly offset by other means of financing. The dividend plus the "new" stock price after dilution exactly equals the stock price prior to the dividend distribution.
B. Conservation of value: The total-value principle ensures the sum of market value plus current dividends of two firms identical in all respects other than dividend-payout ratios will be the same. Investors can "create" any dividend policy they desire by selling shares when payout is too low or buying shares when payout is excessive.
According to M&M, in an ideal market, dividend policy is irrelevant as long as capital investments and debt policy are fixed. Dividend payments are simply financed over time by excess retained earnings and new equity financing. The value of the firm is determined only by increase in earning and investment policy. M&M assumes perfect capital markets with no transaction costs, no floatation costs, no taxes, and future profits known with certainty.
The dividend irrelevance theory simply states that the present value of dividends remains unchanged even though dividend policy may change the amount and timing of dividends.
π Definition β Dividend irrelevance: The theory that dividend policy does not affect firm value in perfect capital markets; value depends only on earnings and investment policy.
β Key Takeaways
The key takeaway is that while debt financing provides tax benefits, excessive leverage introduces bankruptcy costsβboth direct and indirectβthat offset these benefits, making the optimal capital structure a mix of debt and equity rather than 100% debt. Dividend policy involves choosing between types of dividends (cash, stock, property) and policies (stable, constant payout, hybrid, fluctuating), with important dates (declaration, record, ex-dividend, payment) defining shareholder entitlement. Legal constraints like capital impairment and insolvency rules, along with practical factors, influence dividend decisions. Critically, M&M's dividend irrelevance theory argues that in perfect markets with no taxes or transaction costs, dividend policy does not affect firm value, as investors can create their own dividend policy by buying or selling shares.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two main types of bankruptcy costs associated with high gearing, and how do they reduce firm value?
- What is the definition of optimal capital structure, and why doesn't maximizing EPS necessarily achieve it?
- List the four important dividend dates in chronological order and explain what happens on each date.
- Compare stable dividend per share policy with constant dividend payout policy in terms of risk perception and investor return variability.
- According to M&M's dividend irrelevance theory, why can't a firm increase its value by changing its dividend policy?