π Lecture 17 β Securities Market Line & Capital Asset Pricing Model β CAPM
π Overview: This lecture explains how risk is rewarded in financial markets through the Security Market Line (SML) and introduces the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM) as a tool for determining required returns on assets. It also demonstrates how to identify overvalued and undervalued stocks by comparing their expected returns and risk levels using the reward-to-risk ratio.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the Security Market Line (SML) which shows the relationship between beta and expected return, the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM) which derives the theoretical required return for an asset, and methods for calculating whether stocks are overvalued or undervalued based on their expected returns and beta values. It includes detailed examples of portfolio construction with different assets and risk-free assets, and explains why reward-to-risk ratios must equalize in efficient markets.
π Lecture Summary
SECURITIES MARKET LINE
The Security Market Line (SML) tells us how risk is rewarded in the market. In a market where expected return (Er) on an asset A is 18% with a beta of 1.5 and risk-free rate (Rf) is 8%, we can create portfolios combining the asset with risk-free assets. A risk-free asset has a beta of zero because it has no systematic risk.
When we invest 30% in asset A and 70% in the risk-free asset, the expected return on the portfolio is: π Formula: E(r) = %a Γ E(r)A + %b Γ Rf = 30% Γ 18% + (1 - 0.30) Γ 8% = 5.40 + 6 = 11.40%
π Formula for portfolio beta: Bp = %a Γ Ba + %b Γ Bb = 0.30 Γ 1.50 + 70% Γ 0 = 0.45
If an investor borrows at the risk-free rate and increases investment in stock A to 150% (implying -50% in risk-free asset): E(r) = 1.50 Γ 18% + (-0.50) Γ 8% = 27% - 4% = 23% Bp = 1.5 Γ 150% + (100-150) Γ 0 = 2.25
π Example: The slope of the curve is constant at all investment levels: Slope = (ERa - Rf) / Beta = (18% - 8%) / 1.5 = 6.67
| % Investment in Stock A | Portfolio ER | Portfolio Beta | Curve Slope |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 8.00 | 0 | - |
| 25 | 10.50 | 0.3750 | 6.67 |
| 50 | 13.00 | 0.7500 | 6.67 |
| 75 | 15.50 | 1.1250 | 6.67 |
| 100 | 18.00 | 1.5000 | 6.67 |
| 125 | 20.50 | 1.8750 | 6.67 |
| 150 | 23.00 | 2.2500 | 6.67 |
Now consider another asset B with expected return of 14% and beta of 1.10, with Rf still 8%. Investing 30% in asset B: Erp = 0.30 Γ 14% + 0.70 Γ 8% = 4.2 + 5.6 = 9.80% Bp = 0.30 Γ 1.10 + 0.70 Γ 0 = 0.33
π Example: The reward-to-risk ratio for stock B is: (ERa - Rf) / Beta = (14% - 8%) / 1.10 = 5.45
Stock A offers a reward-to-risk ratio of 6.67%, while stock B offers only 5.45%. In an efficient market, this situation will not persist. More investors will invest in stock A, pushing up its price and reducing returns, while investment in stock B will decrease, lowering its price and increasing returns. This continues until: Era - Rf/Ba = Erb - Rf/Bb
π‘ Why this matters: The reward-to-risk ratio must be the same for all stocks in an efficient market, regardless of how many assets are available. The relationship between beta and required return is plotted on the Securities Market Line (SML), which shows expected return as a function of Ξ². The SML intercept is the risk-free rate, and the slope is (Erm - Rf).
CAPITAL ASSET PRICING MODEL
The Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM) is a model that derives the theoretical required return (discount rate) for an asset in a market, given the risk-free rate available to investors and the risk of the market as a whole.
π Formula: E(ri) = Rf + Ξ²i(Erm - Rf)
Where:
- Ξ² (Beta) is the measure of asset sensitivity to movement in the overall market; betas exceeding one signify more than average riskiness, betas below one indicate lower than average.
- (Erm - Rf) is the market premium, the historically observed excess return of the market over the risk-free rate.
Once the expected return is calculated using CAPM, future cash flows can be discounted to their present value using this rate to establish the correct price for the asset. A more risky stock will have a higher beta and be discounted at a higher rate; less sensitive stocks have lower betas and are discounted at a lower rate.
CAPM tells us three things:
- Time value of money: The risk-free rate (Rf) is the rate when you donβt take risk β it represents just waiting for money
- Reward for risk: (Erm - Rf) represents reward for taking average systematic risk in addition to waiting
- Systematic risk: Measured by beta, it measures the systematic risk present in an asset or portfolio relative to the average asset
Calculating Over/Under Valued Stocks
An asset is overvalued if its price is much higher given its expected return and risk. An asset is undervalued if its price is much lower given its expected return and risk.
π Example: Given two stocks with risk-free rate of 7%:
| Stock | ER | Beta | Reward-to-Risk Ratio |
|---|---|---|---|
| ABC | 15% | 1.5 | 5.33 |
| XYZ | 11% | 0.9 | 4.44 |
Slope of SML:
- ABC: (15% - 7%) / 1.5 = 5.33
- XYZ: (11% - 7%) / 0.9 = 4.44
XYZ offers an insufficient expected return given its level of risk relative to ABC. XYZ's expected returns are very low and its price is high β therefore XYZ is overvalued relative to ABC. In an efficient market, XYZ's price will fall. ABC is undervalued, and its price will rise.
β Key Takeaways
The Security Market Line (SML) plots the relationship between beta and required return, where the intercept is the risk-free rate and the slope is the market risk premium. In efficient markets, the reward-to-risk ratio (ER - Rf)/Beta must equalize across all assets; if it doesn't, arbitrage opportunities exist. CAPM provides the theoretical required return formula E(ri) = Rf + Ξ²i(Erm - Rf), where beta measures systematic risk relative to the market. Stocks are overvalued when their expected return is too low for their risk level (high price), and undervalued when expected return is too high for their risk level (low price). The reward-to-risk ratio comparison is the key method for identifying mispriced securities.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the equation of the Security Market Line and what does each component represent?
- Why must the reward-to-risk ratio be the same for all stocks in an efficient market?
- How do you calculate portfolio beta when combining a risky asset with a risk-free asset?
- Using CAPM, if the risk-free rate is 7%, market return is 15%, and a stock has beta of 1.2, what is its required return?
- How can you determine whether a stock is overvalued or undervalued using beta and expected return data?
π Lecture 18 β COST OF CAPITAL & CAPITAL STRUCTURE
π Overview: This lecture introduces the fundamental concepts of cost of capital and capital structure, explaining how firms determine the required return on their investments. It covers the key components of capital, methods for calculating cost of equity (dividend growth model and SML), cost of debt, and cost of preferred stock, which are essential for making sound capital budgeting decisions.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers cost of capital and capital structure definitions, components of capital including ordinary shares, preference stock, loans, bonds and leases. It then details the cost of equity calculation methods including the dividend growth model and security market line approach, discusses estimating growth rates, and explains the cost of debt and preferred stocks calculations. The lecture also briefly covers methods of raising long-term capital including IPOs and rights issues.
π Lecture Summary
COST OF CAPITAL
The required return is necessary to make a capital budgeting project worthwhile. Cost of capital includes the cost of debt and the cost of equity. It determines how a company can raise money through stock issues, borrowing, or a mix of both. This is the rate of return that a firm would receive if it invested its money someplace else with similar risk.
π‘ Why this matters: The cost of capital serves as the benchmark discount rate for evaluating all investment projects.
CAPITAL STRUCTURE
Capital structure of a typical company may consist of ordinary shares, preference stock, short term and long term loan, bonds, and leases. These components have their own cost, and when we add all individual components' cost after adjusting with the weight age of each, the resultant value is known as weighted average cost of capital (WACC). WACC is used as the discount rate to find the present value of future cash flows from a project. If WACC is incorrect, it may lead to serious consequences.
COST OF EQUITY
The return that stockholders require for a company is called cost of equity. The traditional formula is the dividend capitalization model. A firm's cost of equity represents the compensation that the market demands for owning the asset and bearing the risk of ownership.
Simple example: If you require a 10% return on stock A trading at $10 with a $0.30 dividend, you need a $1.00 total return. The stock must appreciate by $0.70, which combined with the $0.30 dividend gives your 10% cost of equity.
Dividend Growth Model: Assuming dividends grow at a constant rate (growth rate = g), price per share Po (current price) is: Po = Do x (1 + g) / Re β g Or Po = D1 / Re β g
Where D1 is dividend after period 1 and Re represents return on equity.
Rearranged to calculate Re: π Definition β Re = D1 / Po + g
This equation requires three variables: current price Po, dividend in period 0 (Do), and growth rate (g).
Estimating g (growth rate): The most complex variable is determining "g". Po and Do can be obtained easily from internal or external sources. Statistical techniques using historical data, specifically trend and regression analysis, can be used to forecast g.
Advantages of Dividend Growth Model:
- Very simple to understand and use
Disadvantages of Dividend Growth Model:
- Only applicable to firms that pay dividends regularly
- Unrealistic assumption of constant dividend growth
- Estimated cost of equity is very sensitive to the estimated growth rate
- Does not take into account risk level (no adjustment for uncertainty)
Security Market Line (SML) Approach: The SML approach tells us that the required rate of return on a risky investment depends on three things:
- The risk free rate, Rf
- Market risk premium, (Erm β Rf)
- Systematic risk of the asset known as beta, B
π Formula: Ere = Rf + Be x (Erm β Rf) Where:
- Ere = expected return on equity
- Be = Beta of equity
π Advantages of SML:
- Explicitly adjusts for risk
- Applicable to companies beyond those with steady dividend growth
π Disadvantages of SML:
- Heavily relies on accurate estimates of market risk premium and beta coefficient
- Inaccurate estimates lead to incorrect cost of equity
Both dividend model and SML consider past data to predict the future, but economic conditions in the future may differ.
Ways to Build Long-Term Capital:
- Venture capital
- Issuing shares to public β IPOs
- Subsequent issue of shares β right issue
- Private placement of shares
- Bank loans
- Debt instruments
- Leases
Issues Relating to Equity Capital:
- Company must be listed on stock exchange
- Must be registered with Security & Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP)
- Company issues prospectus
- Underwriting the share issue
- Underwriter: firm acting as intermediary between issuing company and public
- Services: devising method for issuing shares, setting price of new shares, marketing/selling securities
- Underwriters may buy securities at lower price and sell to public; take up under-subscribed shares
- Underwriters often form a syndicate to share risk
COST OF DEBT
Debt component of capital may include preferred stocks, loans from financial institutions with varying terms and costs (fixed or floating interest rate), bonds, and leases.
The effective rate a company pays on its current debt can be measured in before-tax or after-tax returns. Since interest expense is deductible, the after-tax cost is seen most often. This measure helps give investors an idea of the company's riskiness, as riskier companies generally have a higher cost of debt.
π Formula: After-tax cost = Before-tax rate x (1 - marginal tax rate)
Example: If a company's only debt is a bond paying 5%, before-tax cost = 5%. With 40% marginal tax rate, after-tax cost = 5% x (1-40%) = 3%.
To find the total cost of debt, calculate the cost of each class of debt and then find the weighted average.
COST OF PREFERRED STOCK
Preferred stocks carry fixed dividend every period with no variation. Dividend from preferred stock is essentially a perpetuity.
π Formula: Rp = D / Po
π Example: If dividend is Rs 3.50 per share and current market price is Rs 40: Rp = 3.50 / 40 = 8.75%
β Key Takeaways
The cost of capital represents the required return for projects and is essential for capital budgeting decisions. The dividend growth model (Re = D1/Po + g) is simple but limited to dividend-paying firms with an assumption of constant growth. The SML approach (Ere = Rf + Be x (Erm - Rf)) explicitly adjusts for risk and is applicable to all firms, but requires accurate estimates of market risk premium and beta. Cost of debt is calculated on an after-tax basis because interest is tax-deductible, while preferred stock cost is simply its perpetual dividend divided by current price. Both equity cost estimation methods rely on historical data, which may not perfectly predict future conditions.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three variables needed to calculate cost of equity using the dividend growth model?
- What are the main disadvantages of the dividend growth model compared to the SML approach?
- How do you calculate the after-tax cost of debt, and why is this calculation important?
- What is the formula for calculating cost of preferred stock, and why is it considered a perpetuity?
- What services does an underwriter provide when a company issues new shares?
π Lecture 19 β Cost of Debt & Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC)
π Overview: This lecture explains how companies calculate the cost of debt from various sources (bonds, loans, leases) and how to combine it with the cost of equity to determine the overall Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC). Understanding WACC is crucial because it serves as the discount rate for evaluating investment projects and making capital budgeting decisions.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers Venture Capital as an alternative financing source for startups, then moves to calculating the Cost of Debt from bonds using weighted average methods based on market values. It explains the tax deductibility of interest and the after-tax cost of debt formula. Finally, it introduces the Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) formula and demonstrates its application in capital budgeting decisions, with an example showing how to use WACC as the discount rate for project evaluation.
π Lecture Summary
Venture Capital
Venture capital is capital provided by outside investors for financing new, growing, or struggling businesses. These investments are high risk but offer potential for above-average returns. A venture capitalist (VC) is a person who makes such investments, while a venture capital fund is a pooled investment vehicle (often a partnership) that invests third-party financial capital in enterprises too risky for standard capital markets or bank loans.
Because VCs have strict requirements, entrepreneurs often seek initial funding from angel investors, who are more willing to invest in highly speculative opportunities. Many startups also practice "bootstrapping" β self-financing until they can credibly approach outside capital providers. In asset-intensive industries (e.g., mining, manufacturing), businesses may more cheaply raise debt financing rather than venture capital.
Key factors to consider before raising capital through venture capital include: limited market access, reliance on personal contacts, high expense, risk of losing management control, no physical collateral required, need for financially strong VCs, importance of VC's track record and skill set, value of VC's contacts, and the necessity of finalizing an exit strategy.
π‘ Why this matters: Venture capital is an alternative source of financing, but it comes with significant trade-offs that entrepreneurs must carefully evaluate before pursuing this option.
Cost of Debt β Bonds
A company may have several bond issues outstanding. To calculate the cost of debt, we first compute the cost of each class of debt, then calculate a weighted average using each component's proportion of total debt.
Example with Four Bond Issues:
| Bond Issue | Book Value (BV) | % of BV | Market Value (MV) | % of MV | YTM | Cost (BV Γ YTM) | Cost (MV Γ YTM) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| D | 500.00 | 0.33 | 501.50 | 0.35 | 6.24% | 2.09 | 2.18 |
| F | 496.00 | 0.33 | 440.50 | 0.31 | 8.36% | 2.78 | 2.56 |
| R | 200.00 | 0.13 | 206.90 | 0.14 | 7.31% | 0.98 | 1.05 |
| T | 297.00 | 0.20 | 287.40 | 0.20 | 7.90% | 1.57 | 1.58 |
| Total | 1,493.00 | 1,436.30 | 7.42% | 7.37% |
The weighted average cost of bond debt is 7.37% using market values. Using market values is preferred because they reflect the current risk level in prices.
Similarly, for loans, we calculate a single rate, but normally using book values of debt.
π Definition β After-tax Cost of Debt: The cost of debt adjusted for the tax deductibility of interest payments.
π Formula:
After-tax cost of debt = Interest rate Γ (1 - Tax rate)
π Example: If interest rate = 10% and tax rate = 20%:
After-tax cost of debt = 10% Γ (1 - 0.2) = 10% Γ 0.8 = 8%
π‘ Why this matters: Interest paid on loans, bonds, and leases is tax deductible, whereas dividends paid to preference shareholders are NOT tax deductible. This tax shield reduces the effective cost of debt.
Weighted Average Cost of Capital
Once individual component costs are calculated, we compute the overall Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) by finding the weight of each component in the overall capitalization and multiplying by its cost.
π Definition β WACC: A calculation of a firm's cost of capital in which each category of capital (common stock, preferred stock, bonds, and other long-term debt) is proportionately weighted.
π Formula:
WACC = (E/V) Γ Re + (D/V) Γ Rd Γ (1 - Tc)
Where:
- Re = cost of equity
- Rd = cost of debt
- E = market value of the firm's equity
- D = market value of the firm's debt
- V = E + D
- E/V = percentage of financing that is equity
- D/V = percentage of financing that is debt
- Tc = corporate tax rate
A company's assets are financed by either debt or equity. WACC is the average of the costs of these sources, each weighted by its respective use. This shows how much interest the company pays for every dollar it finances.
Capital Budgeting
A firm's WACC is the overall required return on the firm as a whole and is often used internally to determine the economic feasibility of expansionary opportunities and mergers. It is the appropriate discount rate for cash flows with risk similar to that of the overall firm.
Popular capital budgeting methods include net present value (NPV), internal rate of return (IRR), discounted cash flow (DCF), and discounted payback period. The discount rate used to find the present value of future cash flows is normally the WACC.
β οΈ Important Caveat: WACC is only appropriate as the discount rate if the proposed project has the same risk level as existing projects. If risk levels differ, using WACC would be misleading.
π Example β WACC in Capital Budgeting:
A company intends to undertake a project that will yield after-tax savings of Rs. 4 million at the end of year one, with these savings estimated to grow at 6% thereafter. The company has:
- Debt-equity ratio = 0.5 (meaning D/E = 0.5, so D/V = 1/3 and E/V = 2/3)
- Cost of equity (Re) = 25%
- Cost of debt (Rd) = 11%
- Tax rate = 40%
- Project has same risk level as existing business
Step 1: Calculate WACC
WACC = (2/3 Γ 25%) + (1/3 Γ 11% Γ (1 - 0.40)) WACC = 16.67% + (1/3 Γ 11% Γ 0.60) WACC = 16.67% + (1/3 Γ 6.6%) WACC = 16.67% + 2.2% WACC = 18.86%
Step 2: Calculate Present Value of savings (growing perpetuity formula)
PV = Benefit / (WACC - g) PV = 4,000,000 / (0.1886 - 0.06) PV = 4,000,000 / 0.1286 PV = Rs. 31,104,199/-
Since the project's present value of benefits exceeds its cost (positive NPV), the project can be undertaken.
β Key Takeaways
- Bond cost calculation uses weighted averages based on market values (not book values) because market values reflect current risk levels; the weighted average cost of bond debt in the example was 7.37% using market values.
- Interest on debt is tax deductible, creating a tax shield that reduces the effective cost β the after-tax cost of debt formula is the interest rate multiplied by (1 minus the tax rate), for example 10% Γ (1 - 0.2) = 8%.
- WACC combines all capital sources (debt and equity) proportionally using the formula (E/V)ΓRe + (D/V)ΓRdΓ(1-Tc), representing the average return required by all capital providers.
- WACC serves as the discount rate for capital budgeting decisions (NPV, IRR, DCF), but only when the proposed project has the same risk level as the existing firm; using WACC for projects with different risk profiles would be misleading.
- Market values should be used for both debt and equity in WACC calculations rather than book values, as they better represent current economic reality and risk levels.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between venture capital and angel investors, and what is "bootstrapping"?
- Why are market values preferred over book values when calculating the weighted average cost of bond debt?
- Calculate the after-tax cost of debt if the interest rate is 12% and the corporate tax rate is 35%.
- Write the complete WACC formula and explain what each variable represents.
- A company has a WACC of 15% and is evaluating a project with after-tax cash flows of Rs. 2 million growing at 5% perpetually. If the project has the same risk as the firm, what is its present value? Should the company proceed if the project costs Rs. 15 million?
π Lecture 20 β Capital Structure and Financial Leverage
π Overview: This lecture explores the appropriate use of WACC as a discount rate for project evaluation, emphasizing the risks of applying a firm's overall WACC to projects with different risk profiles. It introduces the Pure Play method for estimating a project-specific cost of capital and begins a detailed discussion on capital structure, financial leverage, and their impact on shareholder returns.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the conditions under which WACC is appropriate as a discount rate, the problems caused by using WACC for projects with different risk levels, and the Pure Play approach for deriving a project-specific beta and WACC by un-gearing industry betas. It then introduces the concepts of capital structure, capital restructuring, financial leverage, and demonstrates through an example how financial leverage magnifies both EPS and ROE for shareholders.
π Lecture Summary
WHEN TO USE WACC
Using WACC as the discount rate for a proposed project is only feasible if the project falls within the firm's existing activities. For example, if an oil manufacturing company plans to establish another production facility, the existing WACC can be used. However, if the same firm sets up a new spinning unit, using the existing WACC would be fatal and inappropriate.
WACC of a company reflects its level of risk and is only appropriate if the intended investment is a replica of the companyβs existing activities, having the same level of risk. Using WACC when the project has a different risk level leads to incorrect rejections or incorrect acceptances.
For a company with two strategic units, one with lower risk than the other, using WACC to allocate resources will end up putting lower funds to the high-risk division and larger funds to the low-risk division. When a firm has more than one line of business, the overall WACC is the sum of different costs of capital. The riskier division would tend to get the major chunk of resources, while the one with huge profit potential may end up with insufficient resources.
Pure Play
Using WACC blindly can lead to severe problems. Because we cannot observe the returns of these investments, there is generally no direct way of coming up with the beta. The approach must be to find a project or another firm in the industry in which the proposed project falls. We can use the beta of that firm along with the D/E ratio prevalent in that industry.
Once we have the beta and D/E of the firm or industry that resembles our project, we can estimate the exact beta and D/E of the proposed project. For example, if the industry has a beta of 1.7 and D/E ratio of 40:60, and we intend to finance the new project through equity only, we can calculate the exact beta, which will be used to calculate the new project's WACC. This process may involve un-gearing and re-gearing.
π Definition β Un-gearing: The process of removing the financial risk element from a geared beta to find the asset beta (unlevered beta).
π Formula to un-gear equity Beta:
Un-geared beta = Gbeta x (E / (E + D(1-t)))
Where:
- Gbeta = Geared beta (1.7 in our example)
- E = Weight of equity in capital structure
- D = Weight of debt in capital structure
- T = Tax rate
π Example:
If the industry geared beta is 1.7, D/E ratio is 40:60, and tax rate is not provided (assume 0 for simplicity), and the new project will be all equity financed, we un-gear the beta.
Plugging in values: Un-geared beta = 1.7 x (60 / (60 + 40(1-0))) = 1.7 x (60/100) = 1.7 x 0.6 = 1.02
π‘ Why this matters: This un-geared beta of 1.02 represents the pure business risk of the project without financial risk, and since the project is all equity, this beta is used as the WACC discount rate.
Capital Structure & Financial Leverage
Capital structure refers to the combination of financing through equity and loans or debt. If management decides to issue new shares and pay off bond debt to reduce the debt-equity ratio, activities like this are known as capital restructuring. This is a change of investment source leaving the firmβs assets unchanged.
The value of the firm is maximized when WACC is at its lowest level. WACC is the discount rate appropriate to evaluate cash flows; the lower the discount rate, the higher the present value of cash flow. A firm must choose the capital structure so that the WACC is minimized.
π Definition β Financial Leverage: The amount of debt in the capital structure of a firm. The more debt in the capital structure, the greater the financial leverage.
Financial leverage magnifies the payoffs to shareholders, meaning it increases profit and loss with a greater percentage than a percentage change in sales. It may be possible that financial leverage does not affect the cost of capital, in which case the firm's capital structure becomes irrelevant.
π Example of Financial Leverage Impact on EPS and ROE:
Scenario 1: All Equity Financed
- Total assets: Rs. 6.0 million, financed by 200,000 shares of Rs. 20 each
- EBIT Year 1: Rs. 800,000; Year 2: Rs. 1.20 million
- EPS Year 1: Rs. 800,000 / 200,000 = Rs. 2.67 per share
- EPS Year 2: Rs. 1,200,000 / 200,000 = Rs. 4.00 per share
- ROE Year 1: (800,000 / 6,000,000) = 13.33%
- ROE Year 2: (1,200,000 / 6,000,000) = 20%
Scenario 2: With Debt (D/E ratio of 1)
- Assets remain Rs. 6.0 million: Rs. 3 million equity, Rs. 3 million debt at 10% interest
- Shares now: Rs. 3,000,000 / Rs. 20 = 150,000 shares
- Interest expense: Rs. 3,000,000 x 10% = Rs. 300,000
- EPS Year 1: (800,000 - 300,000) / 150,000 = 500,000 / 150,000 = Rs. 3.33 per share
- EPS Year 2: (1,200,000 - 300,000) / 150,000 = 900,000 / 150,000 = Rs. 6.00 per share
- ROE Year 1: (500,000 / 3,000,000) = 16.67%
- ROE Year 2: (900,000 / 3,000,000) = 30%
Financial leverage can also increase losses. If EBIT is not enough, it magnifies losses. At an EBIT of Rs. 600,000, EPS is Rs. 2. If EBIT is less than the break-even point (BE), it represents the negative impact of debt. If EBIT is to the right of the BE point, it increases returnsβpositive financial leverage.
β Key Takeaways
WACC is only an appropriate discount rate when the proposed project has the same risk profile as the firm's existing operations; using it otherwise leads to incorrect resource allocation. The Pure Play method allows firms to estimate a project-specific cost of capital by un-gearing the beta of a comparable industry or firm to remove financial risk. Financial leverage, defined as the proportion of debt in the capital structure, magnifies both EPS and ROE for shareholders, but also amplifies losses when EBIT falls below the break-even point. The firm's goal is to minimize WACC to maximize firm value, and capital restructuring changes the debt-equity mix without altering the firm's assets.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Under what specific condition is a firm's existing WACC appropriate for discounting a new project's cash flows?
- What is the "Pure Play" method, and why is it necessary when a firm evaluates a project outside its current line of business?
- What is the formula for un-gearing an equity beta, and what does the "un-geared beta" represent?
- How does financial leverage magnify both positive and negative returns to shareholders?
- In the example provided, calculate the EPS if EBIT is Rs. 500,000 for both the all-equity and debt-financed scenarios.