π Lecture 32 β Credit Policy and Introduction of Mergers & Acquisitions
π Overview: This lecture covers the critical financial decisions involved in managing credit policy, including the effects of discounts, credit expansion, factoring, and creditor management. It then introduces the fundamental concepts of mergers and acquisitions (M&A), focusing on the purposes of corporate combinations and the critical role of synergies in creating shareholder value.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by examining the financial impact of offering discounts to customers even when sales volume does not increase, including a numerical example of cost-benefit analysis. It then explores the risks and benefits of expanding credit periods, introduces factoring as an alternative for receivables management, and discusses key aspects of managing creditors and evaluating early payment discounts. The latter part of the lecture transitions to mergers and acquisitions, covering the purposes of corporate combinations and explaining the concept of synergies and its various sources.
π Lecture Summary
Effect of discounts β Not effecting volumes
A firm may offer discounts to customers solely to improve cash flow and reduce investment in debtors, even if sales volume does not increase. The financial viability of such a discount is evaluated by comparing the return earned on the funds released from debtors against the cost of the discount given. The net benefit is calculated by deducting the cost of discount from the return on investment on the amount of funds released.
π Definition β Discount (for early payment): An inducement offered to customers to pay earlier than the agreed credit period, surrendering some profit to improve the firm's cash flow.
π Formula: Net Benefit = Return on Investment on Funds Released β Cost of Discount
π Example: A firm offers a 2% discount, which reduces investment in debtors by Rs. 200,000. This released amount can be invested at 10% in other business areas. The net benefit, assuming sales of Rs. 500,000, is:
- Return on investment (Rs. 200,000 @ 10%): Rs. 20,000
- Cost of discount (2% of Rs. 500,000): Rs. 10,000
- Net Benefit: Rs. 10,000
Expansion of credit
Increasing the credit period for customers can lead to higher sales and profitability from those extra sales. However, it requires additional investment in debtors, which carries a cost. Furthermore, longer credit periods increase the probability of default (bad debts). The financial viability of credit expansion is computed by determining the total benefit from extra sales, then subtracting the cost of additional funds and the cost of bad debts.
π‘ Why this matters: Expanding credit involves a trade-off between potential profit from increased sales and the increased costs of financing debtors and higher bad debt risk.
Factoring
Factoring is an arrangement where a firm hires an external entity (a factor) to perform debt collection and related functions. The factor charges a fee (usually a percentage of total debtors). The factor typically advances a proportion of the amount to be collected upfront and the remainder after actual recovery, minus their commission.
Main functions of a factor include:
- Collecting accounts receivables.
- Handling invoicing and sales accounting.
- Taking over the risk of bad debts (non-recourse factoring).
- Initiating legal action against defaulters.
- Making advance payments to the seller (factor financing).
Advantages of Factoring:
- Positive effect on cash cycle (quick recovery of funds).
- Maintains optimum stock levels by providing liquidity.
- Financing is linked to sales/receivables.
- Reduces collection expenses and staff payroll costs.
- Frees management time to focus on other areas.
Disadvantages of Factoring:
- Expensive: Factor charges a hefty commission or fee.
- Adverse effect on customer loyalty: The factor's attitude may be harsh, tarnishing the company's image and leading to loss of customers and sales.
Management of creditors
Managing creditors is a critical aspect of working capital, as it is a spontaneous source of financing. Key aspects include:
- Obtaining maximum credit: Firms aim to secure as much credit as possible from vendors, which affects the operating cycle.
- Seeking extensions: During periods of low cash flow, firms may defer payments to adjust the operating cycle rather than taking loans.
- Evaluating early payment discounts: Like firms offer discounts to customers, creditors offer discounts for early payment. The firm must evaluate this by comparing the cost of paying early (e.g., cost of a loan to pay early) with the benefit of the discount. The decision is based on the level of discount, cash flow patterns, the operating cycle, and the proportion of creditors offering discounts.
MERGERS & ACQUISITIONS
Growth is essential for a company and can be internal (acquiring assets, investing in business) or external (taking over an established entity). External growth through Mergers & Acquisitions (M&A) is often pursued to create a more competitive and cost-efficient company, especially during tough economic times. The core principle is that the combined company is more valuable than the sum of its two parts.
π Definition β Synergy: The concept that the combined value and performance of two companies will be greater than the sum of the separate individual parts ("1+1=3"). It is the magic force that allows for enhanced cost efficiencies and value creation in a merger.
Synergies
Synergy takes the form of revenue enhancement and cost savings. Sources of synergy include:
- Staff reductions: Job cuts in departments like accounting and marketing, significantly reducing payroll costs.
- Economies of scale: A bigger company can save more on costs (e.g., purchasing, IT systems) and has greater negotiating power with suppliers.
- Acquiring new technology: Buying a smaller company with unique technologies provides a competitive edge.
- Improved market reach and industry visibility: Merging allows companies to reach new markets, increase sales, and have an easier time raising capital.
π‘ Why this matters: Achieving synergy is difficult and not automatic. Sometimes a merger fails, and "1+1 adds up to less than 2." Synergy may only exist in the minds of deal-makers, and if no real value is created, the market will penalize the company with a discounted share price.
β Key Takeaways
- When evaluating a discount offered to customers that doesn't increase volume, the key financial assessment is the net benefit of the return on the funds released minus the cost of the discount.
- Expanding credit involves a trade-off: increased sales and profit versus higher costs for additional investment in debtors and a greater risk of bad debts.
- Factoring is an alternative to in-house debt collection that offers quick cash flow and reduces administrative burden but is expensive and can damage customer relationships.
- In creditor management, the critical decision is whether to pay early to avail a discountβthis evaluation compares the benefit of the discount with the cost of financing the early payment.
- The fundamental purpose of mergers and acquisitions is to create value through synergy, where the combined entity is more valuable than the sum of its parts, achieved through economies of scale, staff reductions, new technology, or improved market reach.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the formula for calculating the net benefit of offering a discount to customers that does not increase sales volume?
- What are the two main types of risk associated with expanding the credit period offered to customers?
- What is factoring, and what is the main advantage and disadvantage of using it?
- In the management of creditors, what is the fundamental decision a firm must make regarding early payment discounts?
- Define synergy in the context of mergers and acquisitions, and list two sources from which it can arise.
π Lecture 38 β Currency Risks
π Overview: This lecture explores the three main types of foreign exchange risk exposure companies face when operating internationally: transaction, translation, and economic exposure. It provides practical methods for protecting against these risks, with special emphasis on hedging techniques for transaction exposure that are critical for multinational financial management.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers three types of currency risks: transaction exposure (arising from credit sales/purchases in foreign currency), translation exposure (affecting consolidated financial statements of multinational groups), and economic exposure (impacting the overall value of the firm). It then details protection methods against transaction exposure, dividing them into internal methods (invoicing in home currency, leading/lagging, multilateral netting) and external methods (forward contracts, money market hedges, currency futures, options, and swaps).
π Lecture Summary
Types Of Currency Risks
Foreign exchange risk exposure is classified into three broad categories: transaction exposure, translation exposure, and economic exposure. Each type affects different aspects of a company's operations and financial position.
Translation Exposure
When a business sells goods to a foreign customer on credit, a time gap exists between the transaction date and the payment date. During this period, exchange rates may fluctuate, resulting in exchange gain or loss. These transactions may include import or export of goods on credit terms, borrowing or investing in foreign currency, or receipt of dividend from foreign subsidiary. This type of exposure can be safeguarded by using hedging instruments.
π Definition β Translation Exposure: The risk arising from transactions where a time lag exists between the transaction date and settlement date, causing potential exchange rate fluctuations that affect the value of the transaction.
π Example: You sold goods to a foreign customer on 15 December 2005, and customer promised payment after two months. During these two months, the exchange rate may fluctuate on either side, resulting in exchange gain or loss.
Translation Exposure
When a business has several subsidiaries located in different foreign countries, it needs to consolidate its financial results of overall operations. Translation exposure affects the financials of the group when it translates its assets, liabilities, and income to home currency from various currencies.
The widely used method of protecting against translation exposure is known as balance sheet hedging. In this method, assets and liabilities are matched or offset to reduce the net effect of translation.
π Definition β Translation Exposure: The risk affecting consolidated financial statements when a multinational company translates assets, liabilities, and income from various foreign currencies into the home currency.
π‘ Why this matters: For example, a company may try to reduce its foreign currency-denominated assets if it fears a devaluation of foreign currency. At the same time, it may increase its liabilities by seeking loans in the local currency and slowing down payment to creditors. The firm may try to equate its foreign currency assets and liabilities, so it will have no net exposure to changes in exchange rates.
Economic Exposure
This type of exposure affects the value of the company. Any adverse exchange rate fluctuation will reduce the present value of all future cash flows, thus reducing the value of the company. It is difficult to measure the dollar value effect on the value of the firm.
π Definition β Economic Exposure: The risk that adverse exchange rate fluctuations will reduce the present value of all future cash flows, thereby reducing the overall value of the company.
π Example: A Pakistani firm is operating in another country through a subsidiary. Assuming the foreign country devalues its currency unexpectedly, this is bad for the home firm because every local currency unit of profit earned would now be worthless when repatriated to Pakistan. However, it could be good news if the subsidiary now finds it profitable to export goods to the rest of the world.
If a firm manufactures all its products in one country and that country's exchange rate strengthens, the firm will find its exports expensive to the rest of the world. Sales will stagnate, and the cash flow and value of the firm will deteriorate.
If a firm has decentralized production facilities worldwide and sources inputs globally, it is unlikely that all currencies would revalue simultaneously. The firm would find that while losing exports from some facilities, this would not be the case for all of them.
When borrowing in more than one currency, firms must be aware of foreign exchange risk. If a firm borrows in US dollars and the USD strengthens against the home currency, interest and principal repayments become more expensive. However, if borrowing is spread across several currencies, it is unlikely they will all move in one direction, and economic exposure is reduced considerably. Borrowing in foreign currency is justified if returns will then be earned in that currency to finance repayment and interest.
Protection against Transaction Risk
Fluctuations in foreign exchange markets do not stop. A company may have several thousand foreign currency units in payable and receivable transactions. Such payments and receipts will take place in the future, exposing the company to adverse fluctuations resulting in exchange losses.
π Example: A Pakistani enterprise is required to pay US $100,000 to a US exporter within two months. The company anticipates the dollar will strengthen against the local currency, meaning the Pakistani firm will need to spend more local currency units to buy the dollars. This risk can be reduced, if not eliminated, by hedging.
There are two types of measures to reduce transaction exposure: Internal methods (invoicing in home currency, leading and lagging, multilateral netting) and External methods (forward contract, money market hedges, currency futures, currency options, currency swaps).
Internal methods
Invoicing in home currency: This eliminates the need for currency exchange upon receipt. However, the seller would need to revise prices periodically.
- Seller can invoice in: home currency, a currency more stable than home currency, or a currency with a positive forward market
- Buyer's preferable currency is: own currency, a currency more stable than own currency, a currency the buyer has, or the currency of the industry
Leading & lagging:
- Leading refers to making payment before falling due
- Lagging means to defer or delay payment or settling payment well past the due date
If the currency of the payer is weakening against the other currency, it is beneficial to pay early. If the payer's currency is strengthening, delaying payment is financially advantageous.
π Example: If a Pak importer needs to pay an import bill and predicts that Pak rupees will weaken against the dollar in future, it is advisable to pay as early as possible. However, if Pak rupee is foreseen strengthening against the dollar, delaying payment would be advantageous.
Matching of receipts and payments: Foreign exchange exposure can be partially hedged by matching payments and receipts of the same currency.
π Example: A company will receive US $1 million during the next quarter and will need to pay US $1.2 million in the same period. The net exposure will be US $200,000, as $1 million in payments and receipts are netted off.
Matching receipts and expenditures is very useful for hedging currency exposure. It can be organized at the group level by the finance department so that currency income for one group company can be matched with the expenditure of another company. To reduce transaction exposure to the maximum level, forecasts of amount and timings of foreign currencies must be reliable.
External Hedging Methods
Forward Rate Agreements: Under this method, hedging refers to making an investment to reduce the risk of adverse price movements in an asset. Normally, a hedge consists of taking an offsetting position in a related security, such as a futures contract.
Using this method, we can fix the exchange rate now for a future transaction of the needed currency. Because spot rates change daily, fixing the exchange rate for a future date now reduces the risk significantly.
A forward contract is binding upon both parties β the currency dealer and the company/client. Both parties must honor their commitment to sell or buy the foreign currency on the specified date and amount. By hedging against the risk of an adverse exchange rate movement with a forward contract, the company also closes the opportunity to benefit from a favorable change in the spot rate.
π Example: A company estimates it will be expensive to pay US $ in three months because PKR will be weakening against US $. The company enters a contract to buy x dollars after 3 months at an exchange rate of Rs 60/US $ decided now. At maturity, both parties honor their commitments.
- If the spot rate on maturity is Rs 61/US $ (PKR weakened), the company has eliminated the loss and benefited financially.
- If the spot rate on maturity is Rs 59/US $ (contrary to estimate, local currency strengthened), the company missed the opportunity to benefit from this favorable spot rate.
For best results, one must possess knowledge of the Forex market with a vision of the future to estimate which currency will weaken against which other one. Timing of cash flow is crucial in hedging contracts.
Money Market Hedging: Money markets are wholesale (large-scale) markets for lending and borrowing money for the short term. Banks are major players in money markets, and companies seek their services to hedge against exchange rate fluctuations in the short term.
As the forward exchange rate (agreed now) is derived from spot rates using interest rates, a money market hedge can produce the same results as a forward contract.
There are two situations:
- A company is to receive money in foreign currency (FCY) at a future date and will exchange it into local currency
- A company needs to pay foreign currency (FCY) at some future date and will use local currency to buy the FCY to make payment
Scenario: Future Income in FCY: What is needed is to fix the exchange value of the future currency income. A hedge will be created by fixing the value of income now in local currency.
We can do this by: Borrowing now in foreign currency (the same that the company will receive in future). The maturity of both loan and receipt should be the same. The loan plus interest on the FCY loan should equal the amount of FCY future receipt. When the FCY receipt hits the account, the loan will be paid off. The FCY loan can be converted to local currency immediately and put into a short-term deposit to earn interest.
β Key Takeaways
The three types of currency riskβtransaction, translation, and economic exposureβaffect different aspects of a firm's operations, from individual transactions to consolidated financial statements to overall firm value. For transaction exposure, internal methods like invoicing in home currency, leading/lagging payments, and matching receipts with payments offer cost-effective protection without external costs. External hedging methods, particularly forward contracts and money market hedges, provide more formal protection by fixing exchange rates in advance, though they also eliminate the opportunity to benefit from favorable exchange rate movements. The most effective currency risk management requires reliable forecasting of both the amount and timing of foreign currency cash flows, as well as a strategic understanding of which currencies are likely to weaken or strengthen relative to each other.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
-
What are the three types of currency risk exposure, and how does each one affect a company differently?
-
Explain how the "leading and lagging" internal hedging method works from both the payer's and payee's perspective.
-
How does a forward contract protect against transaction exposure, and what is the potential downside of using this method?
-
In a money market hedge for future foreign currency income, explain the step-by-step process of borrowing, converting, and repaying.
-
Why might a company with decentralized production facilities worldwide have lower economic exposure than a company that manufactures all products in one country?
π Lecture 39 β Currency Risks
π Overview: This lecture covers methods for hedging foreign currency risk, specifically focusing on money market hedges for future payments in foreign currency and the use of currency futures contracts. It explains the mechanics of these hedging tools and demonstrates how a company can lock in exchange rates to manage transaction exposure.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the money market hedge approach for a future payment scenario, detailing the steps to fix cash flows. It then introduces currency futures, describing their standardized features, settlement procedures, and the concept of ticks. The lecture concludes with a detailed example of using currency futures to hedge a future payment in foreign currency, showing how to calculate gains and the effective exchange rate.
π Lecture Summary
Future payment situation β hedging
The lecture introduces the scenario of a firm expecting to make a future payment in a foreign currency (FCY). The goal is to hedge this exposure to lock in the exchange rate and fix the cost in local currency. Hedging is achieved by creating a position in the spot market and deposit market today that exactly matches the future liability.
Money Market Hedge β future FCY payment scenario
A money market hedge for a future payment involves using the spot market and interest-bearing deposits to create a fixed local currency cost. The mechanism ensures the company knows its exact cash outflow regardless of future exchange rate or interest rate movements.
Mechanism:
- Step 1: Determine the FCY amount to deposit today so that it grows (with interest) to exactly equal the future payment amount.
- Step 2: Buy that FCY amount at the current spot exchange rate.
- Step 3: Borrow the local currency needed for the Step 2 purchase for the duration of the hedge period.
π‘ Why this matters: The company fixes the exchange rate by acting now, eliminating uncertainty about the future cost of the foreign currency payment.
Currency Futures β features
A currency future is a standardized contract traded on an exchange, giving the buyer a binding obligation to buy a fixed amount of currency at a fixed price on a fixed future date.
- Fixed amount = contract size
- Fixed date = delivery date
- Fixed price = future price
Futures are forward contracts traded exclusively on futures and options exchanges, using standardized contracts with identical specifications for a given item (e.g., every sterling contract is the same). Settlement dates are predetermined (e.g., March, June, September, December). The price is agreed between buyer and seller and reflects the underlying item's value. Most futures are closed out before final settlement, either via cash settlement (payment in cash) or physical delivery (delivery of the underlying item). A trader buying a future has a long position; a trader selling a future has a short position. Positions can be closed at any time before settlement by taking the opposite trade.
Ticks
A tick is the minimum price movement for a contract. Each tick movement has the same money value. For example, if the US$/PKR rate moves from 60.1501 to 60.1505, it has risen four ticks. For a sterling/US$ contract with a standard size of Β£62,500 and a tick size of $0.0001, each tick is worth $6.25. A trader with a long position profits from a price increase and loses from a decrease; a trader with a short position profits from a price decrease and loses from an increase.
π Definition β Tick: The minimum price movement of a futures contract. π Formula: Ticks Moved = (Final Price β Initial Price) / Tick Size π Example: For a sterling/US$ contract (size = Β£62,500, tick size = $0.0001), if the price moves from $1.3500 to $1.3510, the number of ticks is (1.3510 β 1.3500) / 0.0001 = 100 ticks. The total monetary change is 100 ticks Γ $6.25/tick = $625. For a long position, this would be a profit of $625.
Currency Market Hedging β FCY payment in future
A company with a future FCY payment exposure can hedge by buying the currency forward using currency futures. Mechanism:
- Buy (take a long position in) futures contracts for the required FCY amount.
- When the payment is due, buy the FCY in the spot market to make the actual payment.
- Close the futures position (sell the same number of contracts).
- Any gain on the futures position can be used to offset part of the spot purchase cost; any loss increases the total cost.
Example β currency futures β Scenario - future payment in FCY
Scenario: A Pakistani company buys goods for $900,000 in December, payment due in May. Spot rate (Dec) = 60.1559 PKR/$. May futures price (Dec) = 60.1585 PKR/$. Spot rate (May) = 60.2171 PKR/$. May futures price (May) = 60.2201 PKR/$.
Hedge Strategy: Buy May futures in December, sell them in May.
Calculations:
- Cost to buy futures (Dec): $900,000 Γ 60.1585 = PKR 54,142,650
- Proceeds from selling futures (May): $900,000 Γ 60.2201 = PKR 54,198,090
- Gain on futures: 54,198,090 β 54,142,650 = PKR 55,440
- Cost to buy $900,000 spot in May: $900,000 Γ 60.2171 = PKR 54,195,390
- Net cost of payment: Spot cost β Gain on futures = 54,195,390 β 55,440 = PKR 54,139,950
- Effective Exchange Rate: Net cost / $ amount = 54,139,950 / 900,000 = 60.1555 PKR/$
π Example: The company successfully hedged, achieving an effective exchange rate of 60.1555 PKR/$, which is close to the December futures price of 60.1585 and significantly better than the May spot rate of 60.2171. The gain on the futures contract offset the weaker spot rate.
β Key Takeaways
- A money market hedge for a future payment involves borrowing local currency, converting to FCY at the spot rate, and depositing it. This locks in the exchange rate and the local currency cost.
- Currency futures are standardized, exchange-traded contracts with fixed sizes and settlement dates. They provide liquidity and transparency compared to OTC forwards.
- The tick system allows precise calculation of profit or loss on a futures position. For a long position, price increases are profitable.
- Hedging a future payment with futures involves buying futures now, closing the position when the payment is due, and buying the FCY spot. The net cost is the spot cost adjusted for the futures gain/loss.
- The effective exchange rate achieved through a futures hedge is the net cost of the currency divided by the foreign currency amount; it shows the final realized rate.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three steps in a money market hedge for a future FCY payment?
- Define a currency future and list its three key standardized features.
- A trader buys a sterling contract at 1.3500 and sells it at 1.3520. If the tick size is 0.0001 and contract size is Β£62,500, what is the profit or loss in dollars?
- Describe the steps a company should take to hedge a future FCY payment using currency futures.
- In the provided example, why was the effective exchange rate (60.1555) lower than the May spot rate (60.2171)?
π Lecture 40 β Interest Rate Risk & Forward Rate Agreements
π Overview: This lecture examines two critical financial risks: exchange rate risk for firms expecting foreign currency receipts, and interest rate risk. It explains how currency futures can hedge exchange rate exposure, compares forward contracts with currency futures, and introduces Forward Rate Agreements (FRAs) as a tool to lock in future interest rates on loans or deposits.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers hedging future FCY receipts using currency futures, including contract number calculation and net position analysis. It compares forward contracts versus currency futures across dimensions like credit risk, reversibility, contract size, and margin requirements. It then introduces interest rate risk and its sources, explains Forward Rate Agreements (FRAs) as a hedging instrument, and presents the decision rule for FRA settlement payments based on the relationship between the FRA rate and the reference rate.
π Lecture Summary
CF β Future Receipt in FCY
When a firm expects a foreign currency (FCY) receipt in the future, the risk is a fall in the exchange rate below the current spot rate. The hedge is to sell FCY futures today and close the position by buying futures later when the FCY receipt arrives. Currency futures are settled on specified dates, so timing must be considered.
If the spot rate moves adversely, the loss from unfavorable spot movement is offset by gains on futures trading. If the spot rate moves favorably, the profit from favorable spot movement is reduced by losses on futures trading. Futures contracts do not provide perfect hedges because contract sizes rarely equal the exact FCY amount involved.
The first step is calculating the number of contracts needed: divide the currency amount by the contract size. The number must be in whole contracts, resulting in an imperfect hedge.
π Definition β Currency Futures Hedge for Receipts: A strategy where a firm expecting future foreign currency receipts sells futures contracts today to lock in an exchange rate, then buys them back when the receipt arrives to close the position.
π Formula: Number of contracts = FCY Amount Γ· Contract Size
π Example: In January, a UK company sold goods worth US$1,202,500 to a US customer, payable in 3 months. Current spot rate: GBP/US$ $1.5000. April GBP futures trade at $1.4800 with contract size of GBP 62,500.
The UK seller will sell US$ using sterling futures. The $ receipt at future price: = $1,202,500 / 1.4800 = GBP 812,500
Contracts needed: 812,500 / 62,500 = 13 contracts
Overall financial position:
- Income from trading: $1,202,500
- Profit on futures selling: 400 ticks Γ $6.25 Γ 13 = $32,500
- Total value: $1,235,000
- Exchange into sterling at spot rate $1.52/GBP: $1,235,000/1.52 = GBP 812,500
- Effective exchange rate: $1,202,500/812,500 = $1.48
Forward Contract vs. Currency Futures
In currency futures, commodity exchanges are involved and credit risk is eliminated. In forward contracts, parties must confirm each other's creditworthiness.
Reversal of currency futures is simple with large buyers and sellers. Reversing forward contracts is difficult as original parties must set off the deal. Currency futures become a "commodity" where reversal does not require original parties.
No size restriction exists in forward contracts; parties can contract any amount. In currency futures, contract size is fixed and predetermined, preventing perfect hedges.
No margin is required in forward contracts, but currency futures require an initial margin.
π Definition β Forward Contract: A private agreement between two parties to exchange currency at a predetermined rate on a future date, with customizable size but counterparty credit risk.
π Definition β Currency Futures: Standardized exchange-traded contracts to buy or sell currency at a specified price on a specified future date, with no credit risk but fixed contract sizes.
Interest Rate Risk Management
Interest rate risk is the risk of incurring losses or gains due to adverse/favorable movements in interest rates. A firm expecting FCY receipts/payments may have income dependent on future interest rates. Some firm assets are sensitive to interest rates.
Firms dealing in money market hedges are most affected by interest rate variations. Banks and financial institutions have significant exposure to short-term floating interest rates.
Examples of interest rate risk:
- A company expecting surplus cash may lose interest income if short-term rates fall
- A company borrowing at variable rates faces changing interest charges
- A company invested in bonds sees value changes from interest rate fluctuations
Interest rate risk is higher when rates are extremely sensitive and future direction is unpredictable.
π Definition β Interest Rate Risk: The risk of financial loss (or gain) resulting from adverse (or favorable) movements in market interest rates affecting investments, borrowings, or asset values.
π‘ Why this matters: Interest rate fluctuations directly impact company profitability through borrowing costs, investment returns, and balance sheet valuations.
Hedging tools against interest rate risk:
- Forward Rate Agreements (FRAs)
- Interest rate futures
- Interest rate options
- Interest rate swaps
Forward Rate Agreements β FRA
A Forward Rate Agreement (FRA) is a financial instrument used to hedge against adverse interest rate fluctuations on deposits or loans starting in the near future. It resembles forward exchange rate agreements but fixes interest rates.
Features of FRAs:
- Between a bank and a client for fixing future interest rate on a notional amount of loan or deposit
- The loan/deposit is for a stated period starting on a specified future time
- The size of the notional loan or deposit is agreed between parties
- FRAs are cash settled
- At settlement date, buyer and seller must settle the contract
- An FRA for three months starting in 6 months is expressed as 6v9 FRA
The buyer of an FRA agrees to pay a fixed interest rate (FRA rate) on the notional loan/deposit and will receive interest at the benchmark rate. The seller pays interest at the benchmark rate and receives interest at the fixed rate.
π Definition β Forward Rate Agreement (FRA): A contract between a bank and a client to fix an interest rate on a notional loan or deposit for a specified future period, settled in cash based on the difference between the FRA rate and the benchmark rate at settlement.
Decision Rule
When an FRA reaches maturity (settlement date), both parties settle the contract:
-
If the FRA rate is higher than the reference rate (e.g., KIBOR), the buyer makes a cash payment to the seller. Payment equals the amount by which FRA rate exceeds reference rate.
-
If the FRA rate is lower than the reference rate, the seller makes a cash payment to the buyer. Payment equals the amount by which FRA rate is less than reference rate.
FRAs allow companies to fix future interest rates today on short-term borrowing or deposits. An effective interest rate can be fixed on future borrowing by buying an FRA, and on future deposits by selling an FRA.
Mechanism:
- Step 1: Understand the scenario β borrowing or investing? Buy FRA for borrowing, sell FRA for investing.
- Step 2: Identify a bank/vendor trading FRAs and negotiate terms (duration, amount, rate).
- Step 3: On settlement date, calculate cash payment/receipt based on prevalent rate versus FRA rate.
π Definition β FRA Decision Rule: If the FRA fixed rate exceeds the reference rate, the buyer pays the seller; if the FRA rate is below the reference rate, the seller pays the buyer. The payment equals the rate difference applied to the notional principal.
β Key Takeaways
This lecture explains two distinct risk management approaches. For foreign currency receipts, selling currency futures provides a hedge against exchange rate declines, though imperfect hedging occurs due to fixed contract sizes. The comparison between forward contracts and currency futures highlights crucial differences: futures eliminate credit risk through exchanges and are easily reversible, while forwards offer flexible sizes but require counterparty credit assessment and are difficult to reverse. Interest rate risk arises from short-term rate fluctuations affecting borrowing costs, investment returns, and bond values. Forward Rate Agreements offer a mechanism to lock in future interest rates on notional loans or deposits through cash settlement, with the decision rule determining which party pays based on whether the FRA rate is above or below the reference rate. The key distinction is that borrowing firms buy FRAs while depositing firms sell FRAs to fix their effective interest rates.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the hedging strategy for a firm expecting a future foreign currency receipt, and how does it differ from a payment scenario?
- How do you calculate the number of currency futures contracts needed to hedge a foreign currency exposure?
- List four key differences between forward contracts and currency futures.
- What is the decision rule for determining which party makes a cash payment when an FRA settles?
- If a company plans to borrow short-term funds in the future, should it buy or sell a Forward Rate Agreement? Why?
π Lecture 41 β INTEREST RATE FUTURES
π Overview: This lecture covers interest rate futures as standardized exchange-traded contracts used to manage interest rate risk. It explains how short-term interest rate futures (STIRs) and bond futures are priced, and how they can be used for hedging against rising or falling interest rates. The lecture also introduces options as a related financial instrument with key terminology.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers interest rate futures and their features, pricing of bond futures and short-term interest rate futures (STIRs), hedging strategies for borrowing and depositing scenarios using STIRs (including scenarios for rising and falling interest rates), issues making hedges imperfect (non-whole contract numbers and mismatched periods), an introduction to options and their features, and option terminology including call/put options, expiry date, strike price, and in-the-money/out-of-the-money/at-the-money concepts.
π Lecture Summary
Interest Rate Future:
Interest rate futures are contracts traded in standardized form on future exchanges, similar to currency futures. Settlement dates on future exchanges are calendar quarters. Each future contract is for a standardized quantity of underlying security, and its price is expressed in terms of the underlying item. Interest rate futures, like currency futures, may be settled before the maturity date. Short Term Interest Rate futures β STIRs are cash settled.
Long-term interest rate futures are settled through physical delivery of bonds.
STIRs: is a type of standardized interest rate future on a notional deposit (for 3 months) of a standard amount of principal.
Bond futures: these are based on a standard quantity of notional bonds. If the buyer or seller does not close their position before the final settlement date, the contract is settled through physical delivery.
Prices of interest rate future are determined as follows:
Bond futures: these are priced exactly the same way as normal bonds.
π Example: An interest rate future may be priced at 109.50 per 100 nominal value of underlying notional bonds.
Short-term interest rate futures are priced in an unusual way: the price is calculated by deducting the interest rate from 100.
π Formula: Price = 100 - Interest Rate
π Example: If the interest rate is 6%, price will be 94. If 8%, price is 92. π‘ Why this matters: This means that if interest rates rise, the price will fall, and vice versa.
Hedging with Short Term Interest Rates:
A company intends to borrow short term in the future and may be concerned about rising short-term interest rates. Or, a company planning to place an amount in a short-term deposit may anticipate a drop in deposit interest rates. The hedge is to establish a notional position to fix the interest rate in the short term.
Scenario: a firm plans to borrow in the short term and risk of rising short-term interest rates
A notional position is established with a future. If the interest rate goes up, it will earn a profit. This profit will be used to offset the higher interest rate on the loan when it is taken. On the other side, if interest rates go down, it will result in a loss with STIRs, and this will be added to the interest on loan cost when the loan will actually be taken out.
To create this hedge, a firm should sell short-term interest rate future.
- If interest rates go up, it will result in profit. Price of future will fall. The future will be closed by selling at higher prices and then buying at lower price.
- If interest rates move down, it will result in loss. Price of future will increase. The future will be closed by buying at higher price and selling at lower price.
Risk of fall in short term interest and firm plans to invest
If the short-term interest rates fall, the firm will make a profit, and this profit will be added to the interest earned by the deposit to arrive at the net return on deposit. The loss of return on deposit due to a fall in short-term interest rates is offset by the profit on futures. If interest rates go up, there will be a loss on the future contract but the same will be offset by a higher interest rate on the deposit.
The hedge can be created by buying short-term interest future.
- Future position should be closed when the actual deposit period begins by selling the same number of interest rate futures.
- If interest rates rise, price will fall, loss will incur.
- If interest rates fall, price will rise, profit will be generated.
Issues with hedging:
We can now note two important issues while deciding to hedge using STIRs:
-
A hedge can be created by buying and selling the exact number of contracts, but in real life, this is not the case, and the hedge is not perfect. If the number of contracts needed to buy or sell is not a whole number, then the company has to buy or sell to the nearest whole number. This hedge is not perfect. π Example: A hedge would need 7.6 contracts to be bought or sold, and you cannot trade this number because contracts are available in whole numbers. The firm will be buying or selling seven or eight contracts.
-
If the intended loan or deposit period is less than three months or longer than three months, a different situation will arise. In these situations, where the STIR contract is for less than three months' interest rate, the hedge will be created by adjusting the number of futures contracts required by a factor of X/3, where X is the planned borrowing or investment period.
Options:
An option is a contract that confers a right to buy or sell a specific quantity or asset β but not the obligation β at an agreed price on or before a specified future date.
Options are available for commodities (like wheat, coffee, sugar, etc.) and financial assets like currency or bank deposits.
Features of Options:
- It is a contractual agreement.
- The holder of an option exercises their right only if it is in their favor.
- The option writer is the seller and must honor their side of the contract (sell or buy at the agreed price).
- Options, like futures, are standardized transactions in terms of size & duration.
- Options are exchange traded.
- These agreements are easy to buy & sell.
- Options are either call options or put options.
- The option purchase price is called the option premium.
- A call option gives its holder a right (not obligation) to buy the underlying item at the specified price.
- A put option gives its holder a right (not obligation) to sell the underlying item at the specified price.
Expiry date:
Each option has an expiry date, and the holder must exercise their right before this date; otherwise, it will lapse.
Strike or exercise price:
The price mentioned in the option at which the holder exercises their right is known as the exercise or strike price.
Options pricing
The strike price may be higher, lower, or equal to the current market price of the underlying item.
π Example: A call option gives the right to its holder to buy X number of shares of Y company at Rs 10 per share, and the current price could be greater than Rs. 10/-, less than Rs. 10/-, or exactly Rs 10/- per share.
- If the strike price is more favorable than the current market price of the underlying asset or item, the option is termed βin-the-money.β
- If the strike price is not favorable compared to the current market price of the underlying asset or item, the option is called βout-of-the-money.β
- If the strike price and current market price are equal, it is known as βat-the-money.β
An option holder will only exercise their option if it is βin-the-moneyβ.
β Key Takeaways
The price of a short-term interest rate future (STIR) is calculated by deducting the interest rate from 100, creating an inverse relationship where prices fall when interest rates rise. To hedge against rising interest rates when planning to borrow, a firm should sell STIR futures; to hedge against falling interest rates when planning to deposit, a firm should buy STIR futures. A key distinction between futures and options is that an option confers a right but not an obligation to buy or sell, while a future is an obligation. The right to buy in an option contract is a call option, and the right to sell is a put option. An option is only exercised if the strike price is more favorable than the current market price, a state known as being "in-the-money."
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- If the short-term interest rate is 4%, what is the price of a STIR future?
- To hedge against the risk of rising short-term interest rates when a firm plans to borrow in the future, should it buy or sell STIR futures?
- What is the key difference between a futures contract and an options contract in terms of obligation?
- Define a "call option" and the "option premium."
- If a put option has a strike price of $50 and the current market price of the underlying asset is $45, is the option "in-the-money," "out-of-the-money," or "at-the-money"?