π Lecture 27 β WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT
π Overview: This lecture explores the classification of working capital into temporary and permanent components, and examines how firms should finance these assets. It introduces the hedging approach to financing and analyzes the critical trade-off between risk and profitability when choosing between short-term and long-term financing sources.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers classification of working capital on a time basis (temporary vs. permanent), the short-term and long-term financing mix for residual financing requirements, the hedging approach where asset maturity matches financing maturity, the risks of short-term versus long-term financing including refinancing risk and interest cost uncertainty, and the trade-off between risk and cost that leads to conservative and aggressive financing policies.
π Lecture Summary
Classifications of Working Capital
Working capital or current assets can be classified according to components (inventory, cash, securities, receivables) or on a time basis. Temporary working capital is the amount of investment in current assets that varies according to seasonal requirements. For example, an ice cream manufacturing firm keeps maximum inventory during May-September for high sales, while during November-January sales are low and less inventory is needed. If a festival like Eid or Christmas falls in December, a temporary increase in inventory would be required to support that sale level.
Permanent working capital is the minimum investment in current assets required to support long-term minimum need. Permanent working capital resembles fixed assets in two aspects: first, the dollar investment is long-term despite the assets being called 'current'; second, for a growing firm, the need to increase minimum permanent working capital is the same as for fixed assets. However, permanent working capital differs because it is always changing constantly. Temporary working capital also comprises current assets in a constantly changing form, but because its need is seasonal, it should be financed from a source that is itself seasonal or temporary in nature.
Short Term & Long Term Mix
Investment in current assets involves a trade-off between risk and profitability. Current liabilities are not active decision variables because you cannot defer payment to creditors beyond certain limits. Accrued expenses like electricity and payroll are similarly constrained. These are termed spontaneous sources of finance. As investment in current assets grows, accounts payable and accruals also tend to grow. The key issue is how to handle assets not supported by spontaneous financingβthis is termed residual financing requirements, which is the net investment after deducting spontaneous financing.
Current Assets Financing β Hedging Approach
Under the hedging approach, each asset would be offset with a financing instrument of the same maturity. Short-term seasonal investment requirements should be financed through short-term loans, while permanent current assets and all fixed assets should be financed through long-term loans and equity. The rationale is that if long-term loans are used to finance temporary current assets, the firm will be paying interest when funds are not actually needed. Loans will only be employed during the seasonal need period.
Apart from current installments on long-term debt, a firm should not employ current borrowings during seasonal troughs. As seasonal need arises, it will borrow on a short-term basis. This loan will be paid off with cash released as the temporary assets are reduced. For example, a seasonal increase in inventory for Eid selling will be financed with a short-term loan. As inventory is reduced through sales, debtors are built up, and cash from collecting debtors repays the loan. This is known as the self-liquidating principle.
π Definition β Hedging Approach: Each asset is offset with a financing instrument of the same maturity, so short-term seasonal assets are financed with short-term loans and permanent assets with long-term loans.
π Definition β Self-Liquidating Principle: The loan to support seasonal need generates the necessary funds for repayment in the normal course of operations.
Short Term Vs Long Term Financing
Exact maturity matching of future cash flows and debt repayments is possible under certainty but not under uncertainty. Net cash flow will deviate from estimates due to business risk. The schedule of maturities of debt is significant in assessing the risk-profitability trade-off.
In general, the shorter the maturity schedule of a firm's debt, the greater the risk that the firm will default. If a firm seeks a short-term loan for capital expenditure, cash flows from the expenditure will not be sufficient in the short run to pay off the loan, creating refinancing riskβthe risk that the lender may not renew the loan at maturity. This risk could be reduced by financing the plant on a long-term basis. During bad times, creditors might regard renewal as too risky and demand immediate payment.
Apart from refinancing risk, there is uncertainty associated with interest cost. When a firm finances with long-term loans, it knows the exact interest cost over the period. With short-term loans, the interest cost is uncertain. Short-term interest rates fluctuate more than long-term rates. A firm forced to finance short-term debt in a period of high interest rates may pay an overall interest cost higher than it would have on a long-term loan.
π Definition β Refinancing Risk: The risk that a lender may not renew a short-term loan at maturity, especially during bad times.
The Risk Vs Cost Trade Off
The risk between long and short-term financing should be balanced against interest costs. The longer the maturity schedule of a loan, the more expensive the financing. The firm will be paying interest on loans when the debts are not needed. Therefore, there are cost inducements to finance on a short-term basis.
Short-term loans have greater risk but are comparatively cheap. The margin of safety depends on the variance between cash flow and debt payment, and on the risk preference of management. Under a conservative policy, the firm finances a part of its expected seasonal investment (less payables and accruals) on a long-term basis. If cash flows do not deviate from estimates, the firm pays interest on excess debt during seasonal dips. The higher the long-term loans, the more conservative the policy and the higher the interest cost.
Under an aggressive policy, the firm finances part of its permanent current assets with short-term debt. This requires that the firm must renew the debt at maturity, which represents risk. The greater the portion of permanent assets financed with short-term loans, the more aggressive the policy. The expected margin of safety can be negative, positive, or zero.
π‘ Why this matters: The choice between conservative and aggressive financing policies directly impacts a firm's liquidity risk and profitability, requiring management to balance the lower cost of short-term debt against the higher refinancing risk.
π Definition β Conservative Policy: Financing part of seasonal fund requirements on a long-term basis, resulting in higher interest cost but lower risk.
π Definition β Aggressive Policy: Financing part of permanent current assets with short-term debt, requiring renewal at maturity and involving higher risk but lower cost.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical point is that working capital has both temporary and permanent components, and the hedging approach matches financing maturity to asset maturity to avoid paying interest on unneeded funds. Short-term financing carries greater refinancing risk and interest cost uncertainty but is cheaper, while long-term financing is more expensive but reduces default risk. Conservative policy involves using more long-term debt, paying interest during off-peak periods for safety, while aggressive policy uses short-term debt for permanent assets, increasing risk and potential return. The self-liquidating principle ensures seasonal loans are repaid from cash generated by the assets they financed. The optimal policy balances risk and profitability according to management's risk preference and the variance of expected cash flows.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between temporary and permanent working capital, and how does the hedging approach finance each?
- What is the self-liquidating principle, and how does it apply to financing seasonal inventory increases?
- What is refinancing risk, and why is it greater for short-term debt used to finance long-term assets?
- Under a conservative financing policy, why does the firm pay interest on debt even when funds are not needed?
- What determines whether a firm's margin of safety under an aggressive policy is positive, negative, or zero?
π Lecture 28 β Cash Management
π Overview: This lecture examines the critical area of cash management in corporate finance, covering the dangers of overtrading and its remedies. It explores the motives for holding cash, methods for estimating optimal cash balances, and strategies for investing surplus cash, concluding with an inventory-based model for cash management.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers overtrading indications and remedies, cash management principles, cash flow problems and their remedies, motives for cash holding, estimating cash balances using the Baumol Model, investing surplus cash considering liquidity, profitability, and safety, and the inventory approach to cash management along with its demerits.
π Lecture Summary
Overtrading β Indications & Remedies
In contrast with over-capitalization, overtrading occurs when a firm tries to do too much too quickly with too little long term capital, so that it is trying to support too large a trade volume with limited capital resources. Even a firm operating in profit may find itself in serious conditions because it is in a short-of-money situation. Such liquidity troubles emerge from the fact that it does not have enough cash to pay off debt as it falls due.
The major signs leading to overtrading include: a significant increase in turnover, rapid increase in current assets, slowing stock turnover and debtors turnover, extended payment to creditors, exceeding short-term loan limits, falling current and quick ratios, and leading to a liquid deficit situation where current liabilities are greater than current assets. Overtrading takes place when a business accepts work and tries to fulfill it, but fulfillment requires greater resources of people, working capital, or net assets than the business has available. It is often caused by unforeseen events such as manufacture or delivery taking longer than anticipated, resulting in cash flow being impaired. Overtrading is a common problem for recently started businesses and rapidly expanding businesses. Cash often has to leave the business before more cash comes into it, and it doesn't take much to upset the balance.
π‘ Why this matters: A profitable company can still fail if it overtrades, because it cannot pay its immediate obligations despite having future profits.
Remedies Effective debt management and credit control can help you avoid overtrading, by ensuring that you get paid more efficiently and have the cash to pay suppliers and staff. In addition to managing debt more effectively, you should also think about changing some or all of your business practices.
Set New Payment Terms: You could renegotiate payment terms or tell customers that new terms will apply for future orders, but you should be aware that customers may object. Much will depend on the strength or weakness of your competitive position. You may lose business if your new terms are unattractive to your customers or if you are aggressive in imposing them.
Offer Discounts for Prompt Payment: This can be effective in accelerating payment, boosting cash flow, and reducing bad debts. However, there are disadvantages β it can be expensive and must be policed to ensure that customers only take discounts when they pay promptly.
Use Factoring or Invoice Discounting: Factoring involves selling your invoices to a specialist finance company which takes on the administration and cost of recovering the invoice payments. With invoice discounting, you raise a loan from a finance company against the value of your invoices, but you keep the responsibility and cost of recovering invoice payments.
Negotiate Payment Terms with Your Suppliers: You could try to negotiate different payment terms with your suppliers or you could just take longer to pay. However, this may be considered unethical, and you may find that some suppliers refuse to supply you if you habitually take too long to pay. You may therefore want to consider giving something in return for extended payment terms, such as a promise of regular orders.
Cash Management
Cash is your business's lifeblood. Managed well, your company remains healthy and strong. Managed poorly, your company goes into cardiac arrest. If you haven't considered cash management an important issue, then you're probably undermining your business's short-term stability and its long-term survival.
Cash Flow β Problems and Remedies
β’ Growth: a growing business needs to have more non-current assets and these fixed assets must be financed. β’ Seasonal business: like on Eid and religious occasions, the business activity jumps manifolds and firms need more cash to procure inventory. β’ Capital expense or one-off expenditure. β’ Losses increase the cash flow problems
Cash flow problems can be handled in the following ways: β’ Decreasing the receipt float β’ Deferring capital expenditure (capex) and developmental work β’ Accelerating cash inflows which were set for recovery at a later period β’ Liquidating investments β’ Deferring payments to creditors β’ Rescheduling loan payments β’ Planning is of immense importance especially rolling cash budgets.
Motives for Cash holding
Transactions Motive ensures that the firm has enough funds to transact its routine, day-to-day business affairs. Safety Motive protects the firm against being unable to meet unexpected demands for cash. Speculative Motive allows the firm to take advantage of unexpected opportunities that may arise.
Estimating Cash Balances
The Baumol Model The Baumol Model provides a method for determining the optimal cash balance by treating cash management like inventory management.
π Formula: ECQ = β(2 x Conversion Cost x Demand For Cash / Opportunity Cost (In Decimal Form))
Where:
- Conversion cost = cost of converting marketable securities to cash ($/conversion)
- Opportunity cost = interest earnings given up due to holding funds in a non-interest-earning cash account
Investing Surplus Cash
Companies may have surplus cash, and this leads to the question "what to do with the surplus cash?" Obviously, the "surplus" here means temporary and it should be invested in the short term for earning a return on it.
Before putting the surplus cash into any bank deposit, the firm will consider three factors:
- Liquidity β company can withdraw the money out of deposit quickly and without the loss of value.
- Profitability β the deposit must offer a good return for the risk being taken.
- Safety β there is no chance of loss of deposit.
Other factors to consider include whether to put the money in a deposit bearing a fixed or floating interest rate, the term to maturity, penalties for early liquidation of deposit in case the firm needs cash for other purposes, tax on profit, and the option of investing in the international market.
Inventory Approach to Cash Management
The answer to the question "how much cash should be held?" will vary from firm to firm. However, there are different models that can provide a relative guide as to how much cash a company should hold. We can identify two types of cost that are involved in obtaining cash. First is the fixed cost that may be in terms of issuing new shares or negotiating a new loan. Second is the cost that represents the opportunity cost of keeping the money in the form of cash. This is the variable portion of the total cost of cash holding. If you don't put the surplus money into earning, you are losing money.
The inventory approach uses the same equation as the economic order quantity (EOQ).
π Formula: Q = β(2FS / i)
Where:
- S = the amount of cash to be used in each period
- F = fixed cost of obtaining new funds
- i = interest cost of holding cash
- Q = quantity of cash to be held per period
Drawbacks of Inventory Approach:
- To predict cash requirement is not a simple task. Normally, it cannot be determined with certainty.
- There are costs associated with running out of cash which are not considered by this approach.
- The other normal cost of holding cash that increases with the amount held is ignored.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts from this lecture are the distinction between overtrading and over-capitalization, where overtrading involves rapid growth with insufficient long-term capital leading to liquidity crises. Students must remember the three motives for holding cash: transaction, safety, and speculative. The Baumol Model (ECQ) provides a formula for estimating optimal cash balances, while the inventory approach (Q = β(2FS/i)) mirrors EOQ logic for cash management. Finally, when investing surplus cash, companies must balance liquidity, profitability, and safety.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the major signs that indicate a company is overtrading?
- List five remedies a firm can use to address overtrading.
- What are the three motives for holding cash, and what is the purpose of each?
- Write the Baumol Model formula and explain what each variable represents.
- What are the three primary factors to consider before investing surplus cash?
π Lecture 29 β INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
π Overview: This lecture covers two major topics in corporate finance: the Miller-Orr Model for cash management and inventory management. Understanding these concepts helps firms optimize their cash balances and inventory levels to minimize costs and maximize efficiency in day-to-day operations.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the Miller-Orr Model of cash management including its formula and graphical interpretation, followed by an extensive discussion of inventory management including inventory costs (carrying, ordering, and shortage costs), the Economic Order Quantity (EOQ) model with its formula derivation, reorder level determination, and the impact of discounts on EOQ decisions.
π Lecture Summary
Miller-Orr Model for Cash Management
The Miller-Orr Model helps firms determine optimal cash balance limits by computing the spread between minimum and maximum cash levels. Most firms maintain a minimum amount of cash on hand to meet daily obligations or as a requirement from the firm's bank. A maximum amount is also specified to reflect the tradeoff between the transaction cost of investing in liquid assets (e.g., Money Market Funds) and the cost of lost interest if the cash is not invested.
π Definition β Spread: The difference between the minimum and maximum cash balance limits in the Miller-Orr Model.
π Formula: Spread = 3(0.75 Γ transaction cost Γ variance of daily cash flows / daily interest rate)^(1/3)
The maximum cash balance = Spread + minimum cash balance (where minimum is assumed known). The return point = minimum cash balance + Spread/3. Whenever the cash balance hits or exceeds the maximum, the firm should invest the difference between the amount available and the return point; if the minimum is reached, sufficient securities should be sold to bring it up to the return point.
π Example: When cash balance reaches point 'A' (the upper limit), the company will invest the surplus to bring down the cash balance to the return point. When cash balance touches point 'B' (the lower limit), the company would liquidate some of its securities to increase the balance back to the return point.
If variability of cash flow is high and transaction cost is high, limits will be wide apart; otherwise narrow limits suffice. If interest rates are high, narrow limits should be set. The return point is set at 1/3 of the spread between the lower and upper limit to keep interest cost as low as possible.
π‘ Why this matters: The Miller-Orr Model provides a practical framework for firms to automate their cash management decisions, reducing the need for constant monitoring while optimizing the tradeoff between liquidity and investment returns.
Inventory Management
Inventory management is the active control program which allows the management of sales, purchases and payments. Inventory management software helps create invoices, purchase orders, receiving lists, payment receipts and can print bar coded labels. A complete Inventory Management Control system contains components including Inventory Management Definition, Terms, Purposes, Definition and Objectives, Organizational Hierarchy, Planning, Controls for Inventory, and Determining Stock Levels.
Inventory Costs
Inventory costs depend on the amount of space required and how much that space costs. If every part spends an equal amount of time in inventory, then the cost of inventory can be shared equally amongst all parts.
Key cost types:
- Carrying cost: Cost of holding an item in inventory
- Ordering cost: Cost of replenishing inventory
- Shortage cost: Temporary or permanent loss of sales when demand customers don't find the product and switch to substitute products
Economic Order Quantity (EOQ)
EOQ is the amount of orders that minimizes total variable costs required to order and hold inventory. Re-order quantity is the quantity for which an order is placed when stock reaches the reorder level. By fixing this quantity, the purchaser does not need to recalculate the quantity each time material is ordered.
Two types of cost must be considered:
- Ordering Cost: The cost of placing an order with the supplier, including stationary costs, salaries of receiving and inspection staff, and salaries of those placing orders.
- Cost of Carrying Stock: The cost of holding stock in storage, including: (a) cost of operating stores (salaries, rent, stationary), (b) insurance costs, (c) interest on capital locked up in store, (d) deterioration and wastage of material.
Derivation of EOQ formula:
Total cost = Purchase cost + Order cost + Holding cost
π Formula: TC = DC + (D/Q)S + (Q/2)H
Where D = demand, C = unit cost, Q = order quantity, S = ordering cost per order, H = holding cost per unit per year
Taking the derivative and setting equal to zero:
π Formula: EOQ = sqrt(2DS/H)
π Example: If annual demand (D) is 10,000 units, ordering cost (S) is $50 per order, and holding cost (H) is $2 per unit per year, then EOQ = sqrt(2 Γ 10,000 Γ 50 / 2) = sqrt(500,000) = 707 units approximately.
Reorder Level
Reorder level is the level of material at which a purchase requisition is initiated for fresh supplies. It is fixed somewhere between the minimum level and maximum level so that new supplies will be received just before the minimum level is reached.
π Formula: Re-order Level = Maximum consumption Γ Maximum re-order period
Factors considered in fixing this level:
- Rate of consumption of the material
- Minimum level
- Delivery time (from initiating purchase requisition to receipt of material)
- Variation in delivery time
Discounts and EOQ
Discounts are reductions to a basic price. They could modify the manufacturer's list price, the retail price, or the list price. The market price (also called effective price) is the amount actually paid. The purpose of discounts is to increase short-term sales, move out-of-date stock, reward valuable customers, or encourage distribution channel members to perform a function.
π‘ Why this matters: When discounts are offered for larger order quantities, the standard EOQ must be compared with discounted quantities to determine whether accepting the discount (and ordering more than EOQ) results in lower total costs after accounting for the price reduction.
β Key Takeaways
The Miller-Orr Model provides a systematic method for cash management by establishing upper and lower limits with a return point at one-third of the spread, where the spread depends on transaction costs, cash flow variability, and interest rates. Inventory management requires balancing three types of costs: carrying, ordering, and shortage costs. The Economic Order Quantity formula (EOQ = sqrt(2DS/H)) finds the optimal order quantity that minimizes total inventory costs at the point where ordering and holding costs are equal. The reorder level is calculated as maximum consumption multiplied by maximum reorder period to ensure stock arrives before minimum levels are reached. When discounts are offered, managers must compare the total costs at EOQ versus discounted quantities to make optimal purchasing decisions.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the formula for the Miller-Orr Model spread, and what three factors influence its calculation?
- In the Miller-Orr Model, at what point (as a fraction of the spread above the minimum) is the return point set and why?
- What are the three main types of inventory costs, and what does each represent?
- Derive the Economic Order Quantity formula and explain what each variable represents.
- How is the reorder level calculated, and what four factors are considered in fixing this level?
π Lecture 30 β Inventory Management
π Overview: This lecture covers the critical aspects of inventory and debtors management in corporate finance. It explains how to minimize inventory costs through stock-out management, economic order point, and Just-In-Time systems, while also addressing the trade-offs in extending credit to debtors and designing effective credit control policies.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with inventory costs, specifically stock-out costs and safety stock levels. It then explains the Economic Order Point formula. The Just-In-Time (JIT) inventory management philosophy is introduced and compared with the EOQ model. Finally, the lecture shifts to Debtors Management and Credit Control Policy, covering terms of sale, credit analysis, collection policy, and factors influencing credit periods.
π Lecture Summary
Stock outs
The situation when a firm runs out of stock which results in shutdown or slowdown of production/sales. This approach is designed to minimize the risk of stock outs at all costs. Particularly in a manufacturing environment, stock-outs can have a disastrous effect on the production process.
There are two concepts associated with stock out cost. The first one is maximum stock levels, which is defined as the sum of reorder level and reorder quantity, from which (minimum usage x minimum lead time) is subtracted. This stock level is a signal to the management that there should not be additional investment in stocks because that is not needed and will be useless. In other words, any investment over and above this level is loss incurring.
The second is the minimum level of stock or also known as buffer stock. This level refers to a warning to the management that the stock level is approaching such a low level that could result in a stock out cost. We compute this stock level as under:
π Definition β Buffer stock: reorder level β (average usage x average lead time)
In order to avoid a stock out situation, a safety stock level should be procured and maintained. Safety stock is the minimum inventory amount needed for an item, based on anticipated usage and expected delivery time of materials. This cushion guards against an unpredicted surge in demand or delivery time.
Economic Order Point
Economic Order Point (EOP) is the level of inventory that signals the time to place re-orders of materials using the economic order quantity amount. Safety stock is considered in the calculations.
π Formula: EOP = SL + F βS x EOQ x L Where:
- S = Consumption per Period
- L = Lead Time
- F = Stock out Acceptance Factor
- EOQ = Economic Order Quantity
Just In Time (JIT)
The idea explains that inventories are kept near zero level. This means that inventory is acquired in such quantity on a daily basis that can support the daily production level. Therefore, thereβs no inventory lying in the storeroom; rather, all the inventory acquired moves to the production hall.
The philosophy is to pull inventory through the production processes on an "as-needed" basis rather than pushing inventory through the processes on an "as-produced" basis. This requires extremely accurate estimates and there is no chance of an error. For example, thereβs a high probability of running out of stock and that could be disastrous.
JIT does not necessarily mean zero inventory level. The objective is to minimize inventories but to increase productivity, quality, and flexibility.
Before considering JIT as an inventory management model, one should consider the following factors:
- JIT is possible only when vendors are located very close to the business premises or production facility.
- This means that lead time is around a couple of hours.
- It is a very sensitive issue. There is a greater probability of stock outs which may turn the overall benefits into losses.
- It may not be feasible for every business. Some businesses may maintain some inventory items on JIT and others on EOQ, etc. π‘ Why this matters: JIT is a radical departure from traditional EOQ models, focusing on reducing ordering costs to near zero rather than accepting them as fixed.
JIT & EOQ
It might seem that JIT would be in direct conflict with the EOQ model, but certainly it is not the case. A JIT system rejects the statement that ordering costs are necessarily fixed at current levels. JIT tries to push down all the inventory-related costs like ordering and set-up on a continuous basis.
By successfully reducing these ordering costs, the firm is able to reduce the total cost. How close a company comes to the JIT ideal depends on the type of production process and the nature of the supplier industries, but it is a worthy objective for most companies.
Debtors Management
There are significant funds invested in accounts receivables and there must be some trade-off between profitability and risk. The optimal level of investment should be based on the benefit resulting from a specific level of investment in debtors. As you are well aware, investment in debtors influences the cash operating cycle and therefore, debtors should be governed by a careful policy.
Extending credit to debtors is a matter to be analyzed carefully because it involves two types of costs. First, there is a chance of default in receiving payment, which results in bad debts. Secondly, the amount to be received from debtors is used to pay off creditors. If the amount is not received at the proper time, then the company has to settle creditors through loans and overdrafts, which carry a cost known as interest. The company must have clear credit standards by defining the minimum quality of creditworthiness of debtors that is acceptable to the firm.
Credit Control Policy
The following section will shed light on credit control policy and its components. a) Terms of sale b) Credit analysis c) Collection policy
Terms of sale refer to the conditions on which the company will sell its goods to the customers on cash or credit. The most important issues under these terms are the credit period and the discount level and discount period.
In order to induce debtors to settle their invoices at the earliest, the company offers a discount or reduction in the invoice amount. That discount is predominantly based on receiving the payment within a very short period of time compared with the normal credit period. For example, the normal terms representing the period and discount are described as β3/10, net 45β. This means that the credit period is 10 days.
Credit period is the length of time that is allowed to debtors to pay off their bills. It will vary business to business and firm to firm. Normally this period is between 30 to 60 days; however, 90 days credit is not very uncommon. The credit period count runs from the invoice date but can be from the point of delivery of goods.
The length of the credit period is influenced by several factors, but the most important is the buyerβs operating cycle and inventory period.
The operating cycle can be divided into two parts:
- Inventory period: the period of time it takes to procure, produce, and sell the inventory. In our example, inventory acquisition date Jan 01 to March 01 (60 days) is known as the inventory period.
- Accounts receivable period: the time to recover the sales. In our example, March 01 to April 15 (45 days) is termed as the accounts receivable period.
π Key Insight: By extending credit to a buyer, we finance a portion of the buyerβs operating cycle and shorten the buyerβs cash cycle. If the sellerβs credit extension period exceeds the buyerβs inventory period, then the seller is not only financing the buyerβs inventory purchases but also a part of the receivables as well. On the other side, if the sellerβs credit extension period exceeds the buyerβs operating cycle, then the seller is effectively financing the buyerβs needs beyond the purchase and sale of the sellerβs merchandise.
The other factors that influence the credit period decisions are:
- Perishability of goods: If the shelf life of any good is short, it has low collateral value and attracts a short credit period compared to goods having a longer life.
- Old vs. New products: A well-established product may have shorter credit period limits. New products do not have rapid turnover and often have longer credit periods associated with them. During the off-season, the credit period of well-established products is extended to long periods.
- Credit risk: If the buyer presumes greater risk, the seller will extend a short credit period.
- Size of order: A large account order normally carries longer periods because of the turnover advantage. For small orders, the customers are not important.
- Competition: If it is customary to extend large credit periods, then all the sellers will be extending the same level. This is because every seller has to attract the buyer in order to sell his product.
- Customer type: Corporate customers enjoy longer credit periods compared to individual customers due to their business credibility.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical points from this lecture are that inventory management involves a trade-off between minimizing stock-out costs and holding costs, using concepts like buffer stock and safety stock. The Economic Order Point (EOP) is a formula that signals when to reorder by incorporating safety stock, while JIT aims to minimize inventory by reducing ordering costs and relying on a close supplier relationship. For debtors management, extending credit is a financing decision that must balance profitability and risk, with bad debts and financing costs being the primary concerns. The credit control policy includes setting terms of sale like the credit period and discount (e.g., 3/10, net 45), and the optimal credit period depends on factors like the buyer's operating cycle, product perishability, and competition.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between buffer stock and safety stock, and how is buffer stock calculated?
- What does the Economic Order Point (EOP) formula calculate, and what does the "F" factor in the formula represent?
- How does the Just-In-Time (JIT) system differ from the traditional EOQ model in its view of ordering costs?
- What are the two main types of costs associated with extending credit to debtors?
- Explain what the credit term "3/10, net 45" means, and what are the two components of a buyer's operating cycle that influence the credit period?
π Lecture 31 β CREDIT POLICY
π Overview: This lecture examines the components and management of a firm's credit policy, including cash discounts, credit instruments, and the analysis of extending credit to customers. It matters because effective credit policy directly impacts a firm's cash flow, profitability, and risk of bad debts, making it a critical aspect of working capital management.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers cash discounts and their cost to sellers, including how discounts shorten the average collection period. It then discusses credit instruments like invoices and dispatch notes, followed by a detailed analysis of credit policy effects including revenue, cost, debt, and default probability. The lecture also covers evaluating client creditworthiness using financial statements and market reputation, determining optimal credit policy through cost trade-offs, and implementing collection policies with aging schedules.
π Lecture Summary
Cash Discounts
Cash discounts are offered by sellers to buyers to improve the firm's operating cycle, but this involves a cost β the discount cost for receiving early payment. The discount is conditional on payment within a stipulated period, which is much shorter than the normal credit period. For example, terms of "3/10, net 45" mean a 3% discount is available only if payment is received within the first ten days; otherwise, full invoice value is due on the 45th day. There is a cost of credit for the seller, and buyers often cannot afford to ignore the cash discount.
π Definition β Cash Discount: A reduction in the invoice price offered to buyers who pay within a specified shorter period than the normal credit period.
π Formula for Cost of Not Taking Discount:
- Step 1: Discount forgone = Invoice amount Γ Discount percentage
- Step 2: Percentage cost = Discount for gone / (Invoice amount - Discount)
- Step 3: Number of periods in a year = 365 / (Normal credit period - Discount period)
- Step 4: EAR = (1 + Percentage cost) ^ (Number of periods)
π Example: Sale terms are 2/10 net 30 for Rs. 100,000. If buyer gives up discount, they pay Rs. 100,000 on day 30 and lose Rs. 2,000 (100,000 Γ 2%). Forgoing Rs. 2,000 may look small but annualized: 2,000/98,000 = 0.020408 (for 20 days). For annual basis: 365/20 = 18.25 twenty-day periods. EAR = (1.020408)^18.25 = 44.58%. π‘ Why this matters: This shows the enormous effective cost of not taking a seemingly small discount, especially for businesses with millions in transactions.
Shortening Average Collection Period (ACP)
Discounts also shorten the average collection period (ACP) for sellers.
π Definition β Average Collection Period (ACP): The average number of days it takes a firm to collect payment from its credit customers.
π Example: A firm has a 30-day collection period and offers terms of 2/10, net 30. It estimates 50% of customers will take the discount and pay within 10 days, while 50% will pay after 30 days. New ACP = (50% Γ 10) + (50% Γ 30) = 20 days. If average sales are Rs. 2 million per month, receivables = Rs. 2,000,000 Γ (20/30) = Rs. 666,666.
Credit Instrument
The formal evidence of indebtedness is an invoice or dispatch note. When goods are dispatched, the invoice may or may not accompany the goods, but may accompany a dispatch note on which the buyer acknowledges receipt upon arrival at the buyer's premises.
Analyzing Credit Policy
When a firm allows credit, several effects must be considered:
- Revenue Effect: Allowing credit means revenues will be delayed. A firm may charge higher prices for credit sales, resulting in increased sales. Total revenues may increase, but the company receives payment late.
- Cost Effect: If the company offers cash discounts for early payment, it incurs the cost of discount, reducing profits.
- Cost of Debt: After allowing credit, the firm must arrange loans to finance short-term operations, which carry interest costs.
- Probability of Default: Increasing sales by allowing generous credit also increases the probability of default, potentially causing bad debts.
Evaluating Client Worthiness
A firm granting credit should consider the business character of the customer. Several widely used methods to evaluate creditworthiness include:
- Financial statements of the vendor
- Market reputation
- Banks
- Previous payment record
- Financial strength
- Capacity
- General economic conditions in the vendor's industry
Optimal Credit Policy
The trade-off between allowing credit or not cannot be quantified exactly, but an optimal credit policy can be outlined. The costs associated with granting credit are:
a) The return on receivables b) The losses from customer default (bad debts) c) The collection and credit management cost
If a firm has a very rigid credit policy, associated costs are low, but there will be an opportunity cost β the extra profit from sales lost because credit was declined. This opportunity cost is reduced as the credit period increases.
The total of carrying cost and opportunity cost is called the total credit cost curve. There is a point where this curve is minimized, corresponding to the optimal amount of credit or investment in receivables. If the firm extends more credit than this minimum, additional net cash flow from new customers will not cover the carrying costs. If receivables are below this level, the firm is forgoing profit opportunities.
Collection Policy
This is the last item in designing credit policy and encompasses:
- Tracking Average Collection Period (ACP), considering seasonal effects
- Aging Schedule: A compilation of accounts receivable by the age of each account
- Collection effort for overdue or delinquent accounts
To monitor unwanted stretches in ACP, firms use aging analysis. Each customer's receivable age is determined using the invoice date, normally in three or four time-based categories.
π Example: A customer account shows a debit balance of Rs. 550,000 on a specific date, broken down as:
- Days 0-30: Rs. 75,000
- Days 31-60: Rs. 150,000
- Days 61-90: Rs. 200,000
-
90: Rs. 125,000
If the firm allows 60 days credit, then Rs. 325,000 (sum of last two columns) is delinquent or overdue. This analysis helps identify overdue accounts so collection efforts can be directed.
Collection effort involves sensitive points. For major clients whose loss would be colossal, the firm should not press for recovery even if overdue. The recovery process should be handled by the sales team with a strong client relationship. For normal clients, reminders, phone calls, or representatives can be used. In extreme circumstances, the company may refuse additional supplies or initiate legal action, though significant legal costs are involved.
β Key Takeaways
You must remember that cash discounts carry a substantial effective annual cost if buyers forego them, often exceeding 44% as shown in the example, making them a powerful incentive for early payment. The optimal credit policy is found at the point where the total credit cost curve is minimized, balancing carrying costs against opportunity costs of lost sales. When analyzing credit policy, you must consider the four key effects: revenue delay, discount costs, cost of debt financing, and probability of default. Collection policy relies on monitoring ACP and using aging schedules to identify delinquent accounts, with collection efforts tailored to the customer's importance. Evaluating client creditworthiness requires checking financial statements, market reputation, banks, payment records, financial strength, capacity, and industry economic conditions.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the effective annual rate (EAR) of not taking a 2/10, net 30 discount? Show the calculation steps.
- How does offering a cash discount of 2/10, net 30 with 50% of customers taking the discount change the average collection period from 30 days?
- List the four effects that must be analyzed when a firm allows credit to its customers.
- What are the three costs associated with granting credit that determine the total credit cost curve?
- In the aging schedule example with Rs. 550,000 total, how much is delinquent if the firm allows 60 days credit, and which categories represent the overdue amount?