π Lecture 34 β ACTIVITY RATIOS
π Overview: This lecture focuses on Activity Ratios (also known as efficiency or turnover ratios), which measure how effectively a firm is using its assets. It specifically examines the management of receivables, inventories, and total assets, and introduces key concepts like working capital and the liquidity of inventory.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the definition and importance of activity ratios, the concept of working capital and its quality, and a detailed analysis of inventory management. Key ratios explained include the Inventory Turnover Ratio (ITO) and the number of days required to sell inventory, with formulas and examples provided.
π Lecture Summary
[Section Heading: ACTIVITY RATIOS]
Activity Ratios, also known as efficiency or turnover ratios, measure how effectively the firm is using its assets. Some aspects of activity analysis are closely related to liquidity analysis. The focus is on how effectively the firm is managing two specific asset groups: receivables and inventories, and its total assets in general.
[Section Heading: Working Capital]
Working capital depends upon the size and nature of the business. Arithmetically, it is the difference of Current Assets and Current Liabilities. Two companies with the same working capital can have different current ratios. Similarly, two companies may have the same current ratio but different working capital.
[Section Heading: Quality of Working Capital]
The quality of working capital is further analyzed through the liquidity of its components.
(A) Liquidity of inventory: To determine how effectively the firm is managing inventory (and also to gain an indication of the liquidity of inventory), we compute the inventory turnover ratio. This ratio, like other ratios, must be judged in relation to ratios of similar firms, the industry average, or both. Generally, the higher the inventory turnover, the more efficient the inventory management of the firm and the βfresherβ more liquid, the inventory, and vice versa. It shows how quickly inventory is sold.
π Definition β Inventory Turnover Ratio (ITO): The number of times the company sells (turns over) its inventory during the year. π Formula: Inventory Turnover Ratio (ITO) = Cost of goods sold for the year / Average inventory during the year π Example: ITO = 60 / 20 = 3 times. The higher the rate, the more quickly the company sells its inventory. However, companies selling high markup items, e.g., Jewelry Stores, can operate successfully with a much lower ITO.
[Section Heading: Days required to sell inventory]
This metric measures the average number of days it takes to convert inventory into receivables.
π Definition β Days required to sell inventory: The average number of days it takes to sell the inventory on hand. π Formula: Days required to sell inventory = 365 or 300 / ITO π Example: Days required to sell inventory = 365 / 3 = 122 days (or 300 / 3 = 100 days).
β Key Takeaways
Activity ratios are crucial for assessing how efficiently a company uses its assets. Inventory turnover is a key metric; a higher turnover generally indicates better liquidity and management. The quality of working capital is influenced by how quickly inventory is sold. The formula for ITO is Cost of Goods Sold divided by Average Inventory. The number of days to sell inventory is calculated by dividing 365 or 300 by the ITO.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What do activity ratios measure in financial analysis?
- What is the arithmetic formula for working capital?
- Why is the inventory turnover ratio (ITO) important for assessing liquidity?
- A company has a Cost of Goods Sold of $500,000 and an Average Inventory of $100,000. What is its Inventory Turnover Ratio?
- Using a 365-day year, how many days does it take for this company to sell its inventory?
π Lecture 35 β Activity Ratios (Continued)
π Overview: This lecture continues the study of activity ratios, focusing on the liquidity of receivables and how quickly a company converts its credit sales into cash. It then provides a comprehensive listing of all major financial ratios used in analysis, including profitability, return, and solvency ratios, serving as a reference summary for ratio analysis.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the Receivable Turnover Ratio and the Days Required to Collect Receivables, explaining how these measure the liquidity of accounts receivable. It then presents a full catalogue of formulas for profitability ratios (gross, net, operating profit), expense ratios, return ratios (ROI, earnings per share, dividends per share), turnover ratios (capital employed, fixed assets, working capital, inventory, debtors/creditors), liquidity ratios (current, quick), and solvency/leverage ratios (debt-equity, debt service, fixed assets, proprietary).
π Lecture Summary
(B) Liquidity of Receivables: It shows have quickly Accounts Receivables are collected i.e. converted into cash. It is determined by Receivable Turnover Ratio (RTO). It is number of times βReceivablesβ are converted into cash during the year.
This section explains how to measure the speed at which a company collects money from its credit customers. The Receivable Turnover Ratio (RTO) calculates how many times during a year the companyβs average receivables are converted into cash. A higher RTO indicates better liquidity, meaning the company collects quickly. The ideal calculation uses net credit sales and a monthly average of receivables. The related measure, Days Required to Collect Receivables, converts the turnover into the average number of days it takes to collect cash.
π Definition β Receivable Turnover Ratio (RTO): The number of times accounts receivable are converted into cash during the year.
π Formula: RTO = Net Sales for the year / Average Receivables during the year (e.g., 100/10 = 10 times). Ideally: RTO = Net Credit Sales / Monthly Average of Receivables.
π Example: If net sales are 100 and average receivables are 10, then RTO = 10. The days to collect: 365 / RTO = 365 / 10 = 36.5 days, or 300 / 10 = 30 days. Normal credit terms are 30 to 60 days.
π‘ Why this matters: This ratio directly impacts a company's cash flow. A slow collection period ties up cash in receivables, increasing the need for financing.
Gross profit ratio
π Formula: Gross Profit / Net Sales Γ 100
Net Profit ratio
π Formula: Net Profit / Net Sales Γ 100
Operating Profit ratio
π Formula: Operating Profit / Net Sales Γ 100
Expenses ratios
π Formula: Individual Expenses / Net Sales Γ 100
Operating (Cost) Ratio
π Formula: Operating Cost / Net Sales Γ 100
Net Profit to net worth ratio
π Formula: Net Profit after interest and tax / Net Sales
Return on capital employed (ROI)
π Formula: Net Profit before interest, tax / Capital Employed Γ 100
Earning per share
π Formula: Net profit available for equity shareholders / Number of equity shares
Dividends per share
π Formula: Dividend amount / Number of equity shares
Capital employed turnover ratio
π Formula: Cost or Sales / Capital Employed
Fixed assets turnover ratio
π Formula: Cost of sales or Sales / Fixed Assets
Working capital turnover ratio
π Formula: Cost of sales or Net sales / Net Working Capital
Inventory turnover ratio
π Formula: Cost of goods sold / Average accounts receivables
Debtors (receivables) turnover ratio
π Formula: Annual net credit sales / Average accounts receivables
Debtors (receivables) collection period
π Formula: Accounts receivables / Average accounts receivables
Creditors turnover ratio
π Formula: Net credit purchases / Average creditors
Average credit period
π Formula: Average accounts payables / Net credit purchase per day
Current ratio
π Formula: Current Assets / Current Liabilities
Quick ratio/Acid test ratio
π Formula: Quick Assets / Current Liabilities
Debt-equity ratio
Three variations are provided:
- (i) Debt to net worth:
Total long term debt / Shareholderβs funds - (ii) External-internal equity:
External equity / Internal equity - (iii) Debt vs. funds:
Total long term debts / Total long term funds
οΆ Debt service ratio
π Formula: Earnings before interest and taxes / Fixed interest charges
οΆ Fixed assets ratio
π Formula: Net fixed assets / Long-term funds
οΆ Solvency (Debt to total funds) ratio
π Formula: Total liabilities / Total assets
οΆ Capital gearing ratio
π Formula: Equity / Fixed interest bearing securities
οΆ Proprietary ratio
π Formula: Proprietorβs funds / Total assets
β Key Takeaways
This lecture serves as a master reference for all activity, profitability, return, and solvency ratios. The key takeaway is the Receivable Turnover Ratio and its companion measure, Days to Collect, which directly assess the liquidity of a company's receivables. The full list of ratio formulas must be memorized for exam use, as they cover every major category from profitability to leverage. Understanding the difference between RTO (turnover) and collection period (days) is critical.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What does a higher Receivable Turnover Ratio indicate about a company's liquidity?
- If a company has net credit sales of 500 and average receivables of 50, what are the RTO and the approximate days to collect?
- Write the formula for Return on Capital Employed (ROI).
- What is the difference between the Debtors Turnover Ratio and the Debtors Collection Period?
- List the three variations of the Debt-Equity ratio provided in the lecture.
π Lecture 36 β Leverage/Debt Ratios
π Overview: This lecture examines solvency from the perspective of long-term creditors, focusing on the firmβs ability to meet its outside liabilities using total assets. It introduces key leverage and debt ratios, as well as coverage ratios, which are essential for assessing financial risk and creditworthiness.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the analysis of long-term solvency through ratios such as Debt-To-Total-Assets, Long Term Debt to Total Capitalization, Equity Ratio, and Debt-To-Equity Ratio. It also introduces the concept of leverage and the Interest Coverage Ratio as a measure of the firmβs ability to service its debt.
π Lecture Summary
(b) Analysis by long-term creditors
The primary interest of long-term creditors is the long-term solvency of the business and the rate of return on their loans. Solvency is the ability to meet outside liabilities from total assets. The indicators of solvency are presented as the following ratios:
i) DebtβToβTotal-Assets
This ratio is derived by dividing a firmβs total debt by its total assets. It indicates the percentage of total assets that are financed by debt.
π Definition β Debt-To-Total-Assets: A solvency ratio that measures the proportion of a company's assets that are financed by debt.
π Formula: Debt-To-Total-Assets = Total outside liabilities / Total assets
π Example: Using the given figures, Total Debt = 75, Total Assets = 200. Therefore, the ratio = 75 / 200 = 37.5%. This means 37.5% of total assets are financed by debt.
π‘ Why this matters: From a creditorβs point of view, a lower debt ratio is preferable because it indicates that shareholders have contributed the bulk of funds, providing a higher margin of protection for creditors.
In addition, a related ratio dealing only with the long-term capitalization of the firm is computed as: Long Term debt / Total Capitalization (Share capital + Fixed Liabilities) Here, total capitalization represents all long-term debt and shareholderβs equity. This ratio tells us the relative importance of long-term debt to the capital structure (long-term financing) of the firm.
Leverage
Leverage means operating a business with borrowed money. It should be used to earn a return (on assets or equity) greater than the cost of borrowing, i.e., interest. An alternate term for this is βGearingβ.
ii) Equity ratio
π Definition β Equity ratio: A solvency ratio that measures the proportion of total assets financed by stockholders' equity.
π Formula: Equity ratio = Total stockholders equity / Total assets
π Example: Total Stockholders Equity = 125, Total Assets = 200. Therefore, the ratio = 125 / 200 = 62.5%.
This ratio is the opposite of the debt ratio. A low equity ratio indicates extensive use of leverage (borrowings).
iii) Debt-To-Equity
This is the ratio of borrowed capital to shareholdersβ funds.
π Definition β Debt-To-Equity ratio: A solvency ratio that compares a company's total debt to its shareholders' equity.
π Formula: Debt-To-Equity = Total debt / Shareholdersβ equity
π Example: Total Debt = 75, Shareholders' Equity = 125. Therefore, the ratio = 75 / 125 = 0.6. This means Debt is 0.6 of Equity, which can also be expressed as a Debt to Equity Ratio of 37.5:62.5.
Creditors generally prefer this ratio to be low. The lower the ratio, the higher the level of financing provided by shareholders and the larger the creditor cushion (margin of protection) in the event of shrinking asset values or outright losses.
Depending on the purpose, preferred stock is sometimes included as debt rather than equity. The ratio of debt to equity varies according to the nature of the business and the variability of cash flows. A comparison of this ratio with similar firms gives a general indication of the credit worthiness and financial risk of the firm.
Coverage Ratio
Coverage ratios are designed to relate the financial charges of a firm to its ability to service, or cover, them. The most traditional coverage ratio is the interest coverage ratio, or times interest earned.
iv) Interest coverage ratio
π Definition β Interest coverage ratio: A metric that measures a firm's ability to meet its interest payments from its operating income.
π Formula: Interest coverage ratio = Operating income available for interest payment / Annual interest expenses
π Example: Operating Income = 25, Annual Interest Expenses = 5. Therefore, the ratio = 25 / 5 = 5 times. (Normal ratio is 3:5)
This ratio serves as a measure of the firmβs ability to meet its interest payments and avoid bankruptcy. In general, the higher the ratio, the greater the likelihood that the company can cover its interest payments without difficulty. It also sheds light on the firmβs capacity to take on new debt.
Changes in Solvency Ratios indicate changes in enterprise activities, such as its expansion or contraction.
β Key Takeaways
For the exam, you must understand that solvency ratios assess a firm's ability to meet its long-term obligations. The core ratios are the Debt-to-Total-Assets (37.5% in the example), the Equity Ratio (62.5%), and the Debt-to-Equity Ratio (0.6). A lower debt ratio and lower debt-to-equity ratio are generally viewed favorably by creditors as they indicate less financial risk and a larger creditor cushion. The Interest Coverage Ratio (5 times), a coverage ratio, measures a firmβs ability to pay interest, with a higher ratio being better. Finally, remember that leverage means using borrowed money to earn a return greater than its cost.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- From a long-term creditor's perspective, is a higher or lower Debt-To-Total-Assets ratio preferable, and why?
- Define the term "Leverage" as used in financial analysis.
- If a company has total debt of $75 and shareholders' equity of $125, what is its Debt-To-Equity ratio?
- What does the Interest Coverage Ratio of 5 (from the lecture example) indicate about the company's financial health?
- How does the concept of "Total Capitalization" differ from "Total Assets" when calculating solvency?
π Lecture 37 β Profitability Ratios
π Overview: This lecture examines profitability ratios from the perspective of common stockholders, focusing on how investors evaluate the return on their investment. It covers key metrics including return on equity, earnings per share, price-earnings ratio, dividend yield, and dividend payout ratio, explaining how these measures help assess investment soundness and company performance.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers analysis by common stockholders including Return on Common Stockholder's Equity, Earnings Per Share (with trailing, current, and forward EPS), Price-Earning Ratio, Dividend Yield for both preferred and common shares, and Dividend Payout Ratio. Each ratio is explained with formulas, calculations, and interpretations of what the numbers mean for investors.
π Lecture Summary
(C) Analysis by common stockholders
Common Stockholders are investors whose objective is to determine whether investment is sound, how the business performed, and what are future expectations. Their interest is to watch Return on their investment (ROI).
i) Return on Common Stockholder's Equity
The formula for Return on Common Stockholder's Equity (ROE) is:
Net income applicable to common stock Γ 100 / Common stockholder's equity = 20 Γ 100 / 125 = 16% or 10.4% (excluding other income)
ROE is another summary measure of overall firm performance. Return on equity (ROE) compares net profit after taxes (minus preferred stock dividends, if any) to the equity that shareholders have invested in the firm.
The ratio tells us the earning power on shareholders' book value investment and is frequently used in comparing two or more firms in an industry. A high return on equity often reflects the firm's acceptance of strong investment opportunities and effective expense management. However, if the firm has chosen to employ a level of debt that is high by industry standards, a high ROE might simply be the result of assuming excessive financial risk.
With all of the profitability ratios discussed, comparing one company to similar companies and industry standards is extremely valuable. Only by comparisons are we able to judge whether the profitability of a particular company is good or bad, and why? Absolute figures provide some insight, but it is relative performance that is most revealing.
If there are two types of Shareholders, the net income applicable to common stock = net income β preferred dividend requirement; and common Stockholders' equity = total stockholders' equity β preferred stock equity at issue price β dividend arrears, if any.
The shareholders would like to see if this rate is higher than rate of interest paid to long-term creditors or rate of dividend paid to preferred stockholders. If return on equity falls below the rate of interest, it is unfavorable from the viewpoint of common stockholders.
π Definition β Return on Common Stockholder's Equity (ROE): A profitability ratio that measures the earning power on shareholders' book value investment by comparing net profit after taxes (minus preferred dividends) to the equity shareholders have invested.
π Formula: ROE = (Net income applicable to common stock / Common stockholder's equity) Γ 100
π Example: Net income applicable to common stock = 20, Common stockholder's equity = 125. ROE = (20/125) Γ 100 = 16%. Alternatively, excluding other income: 10.4%.
π‘ Why this matters: High ROE can indicate strong investment opportunities and effective management, but may also result from excessive debt and financial risk.
ii) Earning Per Share of Common Stock
Earnings Per Share (EPS) is calculated as:
EPS = Net income applicable to common shareholders / Number of common shares outstanding = 20 / 1.25 = Rs.16 or 13 / 1.25 = Rs.10.4 (excluding other income)
Each share has a face value of Rs.100.
Decline in EPS is generally followed by decline in market value of common shares, though not necessarily to the same extent or percentage. EPS is applied to common stock. Preferred shares have fixed dividends.
There are three types of EPS numbers:
- Trailing EPS β last year's numbers and the only actual EPS
- Current EPS β this year's numbers, which are still projections
- Forward EPS β future numbers, which are obviously projections
π Definition β Earnings Per Share (EPS): The portion of a company's profit allocated to each outstanding share of common stock, calculated as net income applicable to common shareholders divided by number of common shares outstanding.
π Formula: EPS = Net income applicable to common shareholders / Number of common shares outstanding
π Example: Net income = 20, Shares outstanding = 1.25 (each share Rs.100). EPS = 20/1.25 = Rs.16 per share. Excluding other income: 13/1.25 = Rs.10.4 per share.
iv) Price-Earning Ratio (P/E)
The Price-Earning Ratio (P/E) is calculated as:
P/E = Market price per share / Earnings per share
Companies with record of rapid growth have P/E ratio of 20 to 1 or even higher.
What does P/E tell you? The P/E gives you an idea of what the market is willing to pay for the company's earnings. The higher the P/E, the more the market is willing to pay for the company's earnings. Some investors read a high P/E as an overpriced stock, and that may be the case; however, it can also indicate the market has high hopes for this stock's future and has bid up the price.
Conversely, a low P/E may indicate a "vote of no confidence" by the market, or it could mean this is a sleeper that the market has overlooked. Known as value stocks, many investors made their fortunes spotting these "diamonds in the rough" before the rest of the market discovered their true worth.
What is the "right" P/E? There is no correct answer to this question, because part of the answer depends on your willingness to pay for earnings. The more you are willing to pay, which means you believe the company has good long-term prospects over and above its current position, the higher the "right" P/E is for that particular stock in your decision-making process. Another investor may not see the same value and think your "right" P/E is all wrong.
π Definition β Price-Earning Ratio (P/E): A valuation ratio that measures what the market is willing to pay for a company's earnings, calculated as market price per share divided by earnings per share.
π Formula: P/E = Market price per share / Earnings per share
π Example: Companies with rapid growth typically have P/E ratios of 20:1 or higher.
iv) Dividend Yield
Some stockholders invest primarily to receive regular cash income in the form of dividends. Others do so to secure capital gains through rising market price of common stock.
Dividend Yield is calculated as:
Dividend yield = (Dividend per share / Market price per share) Γ 100%
Dividend Yield is anticipated annual dividend divided by the market price of the stock.
| Date | Market price | EPS | P/E | Dividend per share | Dividend yield |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 31.12.93 | 160 | 20.25 | 8 | 5 | 3.1% |
| 31.12.94 | 132 | 13.2 | 10 | 4.8 | 3.6% |
The dividend yield on a company stock is the company's annual dividend payments divided by its market cap, or the dividend per share divided by the price per share. It's often expressed as a percentage.
Preferred share dividend yield: Since payment of the dividend is stipulated by the prospectus, owners of preferred shares calculate multiple yields to reflect the different possible outcomes over the life of the security. These yields will be different from the company's point of view. The company will continue to call their security (e.g.) a 6%βwhen the stated dividend is 6% of the issue price of the share.
- Current yield is the $Dividend / Preferred share current price.
- Since the share may be purchased at a lower (higher) cost than its final redemption value, holding it to maturity will result in a capital gain (loss). The annualized rate of gain is calculated using the Present value of a dollar calculation ('PV' is the current stock price, 'FV' is the redemption value, 'n' is the number of years to redemption, solving for interest rate 'r'). The yield to maturity is the sum of this annualized gain (loss) and the current yield.
Common share dividend yield: Unlike preferred stock, there is no stipulated dividend for common stock. Instead, dividends paid to holders of common stock are set by management, usually in relation to the company's earnings. There is no guarantee that future dividends will match past dividends or even be paid at all.
The most commonly-cited figure for dividend yield is the current yield, calculated as:
Current dividend yield = Most recent full-year dividend / Current share price
Rather than use last year's dividend, some try to estimate what the next year's dividend will be and use this as the basis of a future dividend yield. Estimates of future dividend yields are by definition uncertain.
π Definition β Dividend Yield: The annual dividend payment divided by the market price of the stock, expressed as a percentage, indicating the cash return an investor receives from dividends relative to the stock price.
π Formula: Dividend yield = (Dividend per share / Market price per share) Γ 100%
π Example (Common Stock): Company paid dividends totaling $1 last year, shares currently sell for $20. Dividend yield = $1/$20 = 0.05 = 5%.
Dividend Pay Out Ratio
The Dividend Payout Ratio (DPR) is calculated as:
Annual cash dividends divided by annual earnings; or alternatively, dividends per share divided by earnings per share.
DPR = Dividends per Share / EPS
The ratio indicates the percentage of a company's earnings that is paid out to shareholders in cash.
Understanding Dividend Payout Ratio: The DPR measures what a company pays out to investors in the form of dividends.
The real question is whether a given DPR percentage is good or bad, and that is subject to interpretation.
Growing companies will typically retain more profits to fund growth and pay lower or no dividends. Companies that pay higher dividends may be in mature industries where there is little room for growth and paying higher dividends is the best use of profits (utilities used to fall into this group, although in recent years many of them have been diversifying).
Either way, you must view the whole DPR issue in the context of the company and its industry. By itself, it tells you very little.
π Definition β Dividend Payout Ratio (DPR): The percentage of a company's earnings that is paid out to shareholders in the form of cash dividends.
π Formula: DPR = Dividends per Share / Earnings Per Share (EPS)
π Example: If a company paid out $1 per share in annual dividends and had $3 in EPS, the DPR would be 33% ($1 / $3 = 33%).
π‘ Why this matters: Growing companies typically have low DPR (retaining earnings for growth), while mature companies may have high DPR. The ratio must be interpreted within industry context.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts from this lecture are: Return on Equity (ROE) measures earning power on shareholders' book value investment and can be influenced by both strong management and excessive financial risk; Earnings Per Share (EPS) comes in three forms (trailing, current, forward) and declines typically lead to falling market prices; Price-Earnings ratio reflects market expectationsβhigh P/E may indicate growth prospects or overvaluation, while low P/E may signal undervaluation or lack of confidence; Dividend Yield measures cash return to investors and differs between preferred stock (with stipulated dividends) and common stock (set by management based on earnings); and the Dividend Payout Ratio must always be interpreted within industry context since growing companies retain earnings while mature companies distribute more to shareholders.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
-
How is Return on Common Stockholder's Equity calculated, and what does a high ROE potentially indicate beyond good management?
-
What are the three types of EPS numbers, and how do they differ from each other?
-
What does the Price-Earnings ratio tell investors, and what might a high P/E versus a low P/E suggest about market sentiment?
-
How is Dividend Yield calculated for common stock, and why is there no guarantee that future common dividends will match past dividends?
-
How is the Dividend Payout Ratio calculated, and why must it be interpreted in the context of a company's industry and growth stage?
π Lecture 38 β PROFITABILITY RATIOS (Continued)
π Overview: This lecture continues the discussion of profitability ratios, examining them from the perspectives of preferred stockholders and management. It introduces key measures like return on total assets, return on investment, return on sales, and asset turnover, explaining their calculations, importance, and limitations in evaluating a company's financial performance and efficiency.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the analysis of profitability ratios from the viewpoint of preferred stockholders, including the dividend coverage ratio. It then shifts to management's perspective, detailing key profitability indicators such as return on total assets, return on investment (including simple ROI), return on sales, and asset turnover ratio, along with their applications and limitations.
π Lecture Summary
Analysis by Preferred Stockholders
If preferred stock is convertible, the interest of preferred stockholders is similar to that of common stockholders. If not, their interest is similar to that of long-term creditors. The Dividend Coverage Ratio measures the company's ability to pay preferred dividends.
π Definition β Dividend Coverage Ratio: Net income divided by the amount of annual preferred dividend. Normal Ratio: 5 to 10. π Example: If net income is $500,000 and annual preferred dividend is $100,000, the ratio is 5. This indicates the company earns five times the amount needed to pay preferred dividends.
π‘ Why this matters: Ratios should be used with other elements of financial analysis. Most important is to use common sense and judgments, and also study the industrial sector in which the company operates, relating βIndustry Sectorβ climate to current and projected economic developments.
Analysis by Management
The main concern of management is to watch the interest of all those who have provided capital to the business. For this, it has to ensure efficient use of capital and resources employed. To watch the interests and needs of customers and clients, the management has to take care of profitability, solvency, and long-term stability of the business. It would determine which operating areas have contributed to success and which have not, and take appropriate measures for improvement.
Indicators of Profitability
There is a difference between Profit and Profitability. Profit is an absolute figure whereas profitability is a ratio of profit to some other item like sales.
(i) Return on Total Assets (ROTA) π Definition β Return on Total Assets (ROTA): A measure of how effectively a company uses its assets to generate profit. Calculated by dividing operating income (income before interest and tax) by average total assets (fixed assets + current assets). π Formula: Return on Total Assets = (Operating Income / Average Total Assets) Γ 100 π Example: Operating income is 25, average assets are 200. ROTA = (25/200) Γ 100 = 12.5%. Operating income is used since interest and income taxes are factors beyond the control of management. Since operating income is earned throughout the year, it is related to the average investment in assets.
Importance of Return on Total Assets: Smart companies strictly control major purchases, attempting to limit those that will best bring a return in greater revenue. ROTA is a useful way to measure how well a company makes intelligent choices on how to spend its money on new assets.
(ii) Return on Investment (ROI) π Definition β Return on Investment (ROI): Measures the overall effectiveness of management in generating profits with available assets; the earning power of invested capital. π Formula: ROI = Operating Income / (Stockholders' Equity + Fixed Liabilities) Γ 100 π Example: Operating income is 25, Stockholders' equity + fixed liabilities is 175. ROI = (25/175) Γ 100 = 14.3%. Note: Current liabilities are excluded from the calculation since these are not βinvestmentsβ.
Simple ROI: Return on investment is frequently derived as the βreturnβ (incremental gain) from an action divided by the cost of that action. π Formula: Simple ROI = (Gains β Investment Costs) / Investment Costs π Example: A marketing program costs $500,000 over five years and delivers an additional $700,000 in increased profits. Simple ROI = ($700,000 β $500,000) / $500,000 = 40%. Simple ROI works well when gains and costs are easily known and clearly result from the action.
π‘ Why this matters: Simple ROI becomes less trustworthy as a useful metric when cost figures include allocated or indirect costs, which are probably not caused directly by the action or the investment. Business investments typically involve financial consequences extending several years, so the metric has meaning only when the time period is clearly stated.
(iii) Return on Sales (ROS) π Definition β Return on Sales (ROS): A ratio widely used to evaluate a company's operational efficiency, also known as a firm's "operating profit margin." It measures how much profit is being produced per dollar of sales. π Formula: Return on Sales = (Net Income / Net Sales) Γ 100 π Example: Net income is 20% or 13% of net sales. An increasing ROS indicates the company is growing more efficient, while a decreasing ROS could signal looming financial troubles.
When to use it: If a company is experiencing a cash flow crunch, it could be because its mark-up is not enough to cover expenses. Return on sales can help point this out, allowing for price adjustments. Trends in this figure should be monitored.
(iv) Asset Turnover Ratio π Definition β Asset Turnover Ratio: Shows the relative effectiveness of asset utilization; measures how effectively a business is using its assets to generate sales. π Formula: Asset Turnover = Net Sales / Average Total Assets π Example: Net Sales / Average Assets = 50%. It measures how many pounds in sales is generated for each pound invested in assets.
π‘ Why this matters: From an investorβs point of view, current liabilities should be deducted from the amount of assets used, as investors are concerned with returns on their investment. Therefore, the funding of current assets from current liabilities can be ignored.
β Key Takeaways
For this lecture, you must understand that the dividend coverage ratio assesses a company's ability to pay preferred dividends, while management focuses on metrics like return on total assets, return on investment, return on sales, and asset turnover to evaluate overall efficiency and profitability. Remember that return on total assets measures how effectively assets generate profit before interest and taxes, while return on investment focuses on the earnings power of capital invested by owners and long-term creditors. Additionally, return on sales indicates operational efficiency, asset turnover measures how well assets generate sales, and simple ROI must be used cautiously when costs include indirect allocations or when time periods extend beyond a single year.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- How is the dividend coverage ratio calculated, and what is its normal range?
- What is the difference between profit and profitability as explained in this lecture?
- Why is operating income used instead of net income in the return on total assets calculation?
- Under what circumstances does simple ROI become less trustworthy as a metric?
- What does a decreasing return on sales ratio over time potentially indicate about a company?
π Lecture 39 β Operating Cycle
π Overview: This lecture explains the operating cycle and cash cycle concepts, along with detailed analysis of current assets. It covers how businesses manage accounts receivable, marketable securities, receivables, and inventories to maintain liquidity and short-term debt-paying ability. Understanding these concepts is critical for evaluating a company's operational efficiency and financial health.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the operating cycle and its efficiency measurement through activity ratios, the cash cycle concept, management of accounts receivable including cash discounts and factoring, classification and analysis of current assets (cash, marketable securities, receivables, and inventories), valuation methods for inventories, and a balance sheet example showing current asset and liability proportions.
π Lecture Summary
Operating Cycle
The operating cycle represents the efficiency of the operating process, determined by activity ratios. The conversion process follows this sequence: Cash/assets β Inventory β Receivables β Cash, involving processing, sales, and collection.
Formula: Operating Cycle = Inventory sale days (average) + Receivable Collection days (average)
The shorter the operating cycle, the higher the quality of current assets and the greater the efficiency of management.
Managing Accounts Receivable
The business offers cash discount (2/10, n/30) to encourage early payment or "factors" Receivables i.e. selling Receivables to a financial institution (factor).
Cash Cycle
The cash cycle is the length of time from the actual outlay of cash for purchases until the collection of receivables resulting from the sale of goods or services.
Current assets are defined as assets that (1) are in the form of cash, (2) will be realized in cash, or (3) conserve the use of cash within the operating cycle of a business or one year, whichever is longer.
The five categories of assets usually found in current assets, listed in their order of liquidity, include: cash, marketable securities, receivables, inventories, and prepayments.
The operating cycle for a company is the time period between the acquisition of goods and the final cash realization resulting from sales and subsequent collections. For example, a food store purchases inventory and then sells the inventory for cash. The relatively short time that the inventory remains an asset of the food store represents a very short operating cycle. In another example, a car manufacturer purchases materials and then uses Labour and overhead to convert these materials into a finished car. A dealer buys the car on credit and then pays the manufacturer. Compared to the food store, the car manufacturer has a much longer operating cycle, but it is still less than a year.
Cash
Cash is a medium of exchange that a bank will accept for deposit and a creditor will accept for payment. To be classified as a current asset, cash must be free from any restrictions that would prevent its deposit or use to pay creditors classified as current. If restricted for specific short-term creditors, many firms still classify this cash under current assets, but they disclose the restrictions. Cash restricted for short-term creditors should be eliminated along with the related amount of short-term debt when determining the short-term debt-paying ability. Cash should be available to pay general short-term creditors to be considered as part of the firm's short-term debt-paying ability.
Marketable Securities
The business entity has varying cash needs throughout the year. Because an inferred cost arises from keeping money available, management does not want to keep all of the entity's cash needs in the form of cash through the year. The available alternative turns some of the cash into productive use through short-term investments (marketable securities) which can be converted into cash as the need arises.
To qualify as a marketable security, the investment must be readily marketable, and it must be the intent of management to convert the investment to cash within the operating cycle or one year, whichever is longer. The key element of this test is managerial intent.
It is to management's advantage to show investments under marketable securities, instead of long-term investments, because this classification improves the liquidity appearance of the firm. When the same securities are carried as marketable securities year after year, they are likely held for a business purpose. For example, the other company may be a major supplier or customer of the firm being analyzed. The firm would not want to sell these securities to pay short-term creditors. Therefore, to be conservative, it is better to reclassify them as investments for analysis purposes.
Investments classified as marketable securities should be temporary. Examples of marketable securities include treasury bills, short-term notes of corporations, government bonds, corporate bonds, preferred stock, and common stock. Investments in preferred stock and common stock are referred to as marketable equity securities.
Receivables
An entity usually has a number of claims to future inflows of cash. These claims are usually classified as accounts receivable and notes receivable on the financial statements. The primary claim that most entities have comes from the selling of merchandise or services on account to customers, referred to as trade receivables, with the customer promising to pay within a limited period of time, such as 30 days. The common characteristic of receivables is that the company expects to receive cash some time in the future. This causes two valuation problems:
- A period of time must pass before the receivable can be collected, so the entity incurs costs for the use of these funds.
- Collection may not be made.
Inventories
Inventory is often the most significant asset in determining the short-term debt-paying ability of an entity. Often the inventory account is more than half of the total current assets. Because of the significance of inventories, a special effort should be made to analyze properly this important area.
To be classified as inventory, the asset should be for sale in the ordinary course of business, or used or consumed in the production of goods. A trading concern purchases merchandise in a form to sell to customers. Inventories of a trading concern, whether wholesale or retail, usually appear in one inventory account (merchandise inventory). A manufacturing concern produces goods to be sold. Inventories of a manufacturing concern are normally classified in three distinct inventory accounts:
- Raw materials (inventory available to use in production)
- Work in process (inventory in production)
- Finished goods (inventory completed)
Determining valuation and liquidity is a fairly complicated problem when analyzing inventories. The basic approach to the valuation of inventory uses cost. The cost figure is often difficult to determine, especially when dealing with manufacturing inventory. Because of the concept of conservatism, the cost figure may not be acceptable if it cannot be recovered. Therefore if the market figure is below cost, the inventory is reduced to market. Inventory is stated at lower of cost or market on the financial statements.
π Definition β Lower of Cost or Market (LCM): Inventory valuation method where inventory is reported at the lower value between its historical cost and its current market replacement cost.
π‘ Why this matters: The LCM rule ensures that inventory is not overstated on the balance sheet when market prices decline, reflecting a conservative approach to asset valuation.
Balance Sheet Example
Example No. 1: Balance sheet of a business
| Assets | Liabilities & Stockholders' Equity | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Current Assets (37%) | 31,629,714 | Current Liabilities (18%) | 15,387,428 |
| (Includes subscription receivable Rs. 7,200,000) | Long-term Liabilities (12%) | 10,258,286 | |
| Fixed Assets (63%) | 53,856,000 | Stockholders' Equity (70%) | 59,840,000 |
| Total | 85,485,714 | Total | 85,485,714 |
β Key Takeaways
The operating cycle is the time from acquisition of goods to final cash collection, calculated as inventory sale days plus receivable collection days, where shorter cycles indicate better management efficiency. Current assets include cash, marketable securities, receivables, inventories, and prepayments, listed in order of liquidity. For cash to be classified as current, it must be unrestricted and available to pay general short-term creditors. Marketable securities must be readily marketable and intended for conversion to cash within the operating cycle, with managerial intent being the key classification test. Inventories for manufacturing concerns are classified into raw materials, work in process, and finished goods, and must be valued at the lower of cost or market, representing the most significant current asset for many firms.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the formula for calculating the operating cycle?
- What are the five categories of current assets listed in order of liquidity?
- What is the key element in determining whether an investment qualifies as a marketable security?
- What are the two valuation problems associated with receivables?
- What are the three inventory accounts for a manufacturing concern?