๐ Lecture 28 โ Types of Business Organizations (Continued)
๐ Overview: This lecture continues the study of business organizations by focusing on equity valuation concepts, including book value per share for common and preferred stock. It also provides a comprehensive introduction to the nature of stock, different types of stock, shareholder rights, and the mechanisms of stock trading and financing. Understanding these concepts is crucial for analyzing a company's financial health and market position.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture begins by calculating book values per share for common and preferred stock, distinguishing them from par and market values. It then defines and explains various types of stock: common stock, preferred stock, dual class stock, treasury stock, and stock derivatives. The discussion shifts to the role and rights of shareholders, followed by an exploration of means of financing (equity, debt, trade). Finally, it covers the practical aspects of stock trading, including exchanges, arbitrage, buying methods, selling procedures, and the fundamental factors behind stock price fluctuations.
๐ Lecture Summary
Book Values of equity/share
The lecture explains how to calculate book values for both common and preferred stock. Common stockholders equity is derived by taking total stockholders' equity and subtracting the call price or redemption value of preferred stock and any dividends in arrears on cumulative preferred stock. This figure is then divided by the number of common shares to find the book value per share common stock.
๐ Definition โ Common Stockholders' Equity (for book value): Total stockholders' equity minus the call price of preferred stock and any dividends in arrears. ๐ Formula: Book Value per Share (Common) = (Total Stockholders' Equity โ Call/Redemption Value of Preferred Stock โ Dividends in Arrears) / Number of Common Shares Outstanding ๐ Example: Total Stockholders' Equity = Rs. 2,380,000; Preferred Stock (10,000 shares @ Rs. 110 call price) = Rs. 1,100,000; Dividends in Arrears = Rs. 80,000; Common Shares = 50,000. Common Stockholders' Equity = 2,380,000 - 1,100,000 - 80,000 = Rs. 1,200,000 Book Value per Share (Common) = 1,200,000 / 50,000 = Rs. 24 per share
For preferred stock, the book value per share is simply the call price or redemption value. ๐ Formula: Book Value per Share (Preferred) = Call Price / Redemption Value of Preferred Stock ๐ Example: Call Price = Rs. 1,100,000; Number of Preferred Shares = 10,000. Book Value per Share (Preferred) = 1,100,000 / 10,000 = Rs. 110
Par value, Book value, and Market value of Shares
The lecture clarifies the distinctions between par value, book value, and market value. Par value (or stated value) is the legal capital that provides a minimum cushion of equity for creditors; a dividend cannot be declared if it would cause equity to fall below this amount. It is important to note that par value, book value, and market value are all different and one does not indicate the other. For common stock, market value is heavily influenced by investors' expectations of future profitability, reflecting their confidence in management. For preferred stock, market price varies inversely with interest rates.
Types of stock
This section defines the various classifications of stock. Stock is the capital raised by a corporation through the issuance of shares. The aggregate value of issued shares is the company's market capitalization.
- Common stock (or ordinary shares) is the most usual form, typically carrying voting rights but having the lowest priority in liquidation. Dividends are paid to preferred shareholders first.
- Preferred stock has priority over common stock for dividends and assets but usually does not have voting rights. Some preferred shares may have special voting rights for extraordinary events.
- Dual class stock refers to a single company issuing shares with different classes, each having different rights regarding voting and dividends.
- Treasury stock consists of shares that a corporation has bought back from the public. These shares are considered issued but not outstanding.
- Stock derivatives are financial claims whose value depends on the price of an underlying stock. Futures and options are the main types. A call option is the right (not obligation) to buy stock in the future at a fixed price, while a put option is the right (not obligation) to sell. The Black Scholes model is a popular method for valuing stock options.
Shareholder
A shareholder (or stockholder) is an individual or company that legally owns one or more shares of stock. Shareholders are granted privileges like voting rights, the right to share in company income (dividends), and the right to a company's assets during liquidation. However, their rights are subordinate to the rights of creditors, meaning they typically receive nothing if a company is liquidated after bankruptcy. Shareholders are a subset of the broader group of stakeholders.
Shareholder rights
The lecture details the practical limitations and powers of shareholders. While owning 51% of shares gives majority control, it does not grant the right to use a company's property. Shareholders elect the board of directors, who run the company. This election is the primary mechanism for influencing company policy against underperforming management. A critical right is that owning shares does not mean assuming responsibility for company liabilities. If a company goes bankrupt, shareholders are not personally liable for its debts.
Means of financing
Companies can finance themselves through several methods:
- Equity financing: Raising capital by selling stock, which gives up ownership shares.
- Debt financing: Raising capital by issuing bonds, which avoids giving up ownership.
- Trade financing: Provided by vendors and suppliers on short-term, unsecured credit (usually 30 days), supplying major working capital.
- Customer-provided financing: Occurs when customers pay for services before they are delivered (e.g., subscriptions).
Trading
A stock exchange provides a marketplace for trading shares, bonds, and other financial products. Companies must meet listing requirements to be traded.
Arbitrage Trading
Arbitrage refers to making a profit from price discrepancies of the same stock on different exchanges. In today's electronic trading, such opportunities are very limited and disappear quickly due to market efficiency.
Buying
The most common method of buying stocks is through a stock broker. There are two main types:
- Full-service brokers: Charge more per trade but provide investment advice and personal service.
- Discount brokers: Charge less for trades but offer little or no investment advice. Other methods include buying directly from the company (after the first share) or through a Direct Public Offering (DPO). Stocks can be purchased with cash or by buying on margin, which means borrowing money from the broker against the stocks in the account, with the stocks serving as collateral. This incurs interest (typically 8-10%).
Selling
Selling stock is procedurally similar to buying. The investor aims to buy low and sell high, but may sell at a loss to avoid further loss. A transaction fee is involved. Upon selling, if the proceeds exceed the cost basis, capital gains taxes must be paid.
Stock price fluctuations
Stock prices fluctuate fundamentally due to the theory of supply and demand. The price is directly proportional to demand. The factors affecting demand are studied using fundamental analysis and technical analysis to predict price changes.
โญ Key Takeaways
A student must understand the calculation of book value per share for both common and preferred stock, recognizing that this is an accounting value distinct from par value and market value. The various types of stock (common, preferred, dual class, treasury) each confer different rights and priorities, which are critical for assessing ownership and risk. Shareholders are owners with specific rights, including electing directors and receiving dividends, but their claims are subordinate to creditors and they are not liable for company debts. Financing can be achieved through equity, debt, or trade, each with distinct implications for control and risk. Finally, stock trading involves understanding brokers, margin buying, and the fundamental role of supply and demand in price fluctuation.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- How is book value per share for common stock calculated, and what two items must be subtracted from total stockholders' equity?
- What is the primary difference in voting rights between common stock and most preferred stock?
- What is "treasury stock," and why is it considered issued but not outstanding?
- In the event of a company's liquidation, who has a higher priority claim on assets: common shareholders, preferred shareholders, or creditors?
- What is meant by "buying on margin," and what serves as collateral for the loan from the broker?
๐ Lecture 29 โ Financial Statement Analysis-FIN621 VU
๐ Overview: This lecture provides a summary review of key concepts from previous lessons, focusing on the realization principle, matching principle, adjusting entries, and closing entries. It uses example questions to test understanding of how these principles apply to revenue and expense recognition, depreciation, and the accounting cycle.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers reviews of adjusting entries and closing entries in relation to the matching principle, the debit and credit rules for revenues and expenses based on their effect on owner's equity, the nature of depreciation expense as an adjusting entry based on the matching principle, and the correct sequence of steps in the accounting cycle including the timing of adjusting and closing entries.
๐ Lecture Summary
Example โ Which of the following are based upon the realization principle and the matching principle
This section reviews that adjusting entries and closing entries are both applications of the matching principle. The accrual basis of accounting and the measurement of net income under GAAP are also based on the matching principle.
๐ Definition โ Matching Principle: The accounting principle that requires expenses to be recorded in the same accounting period as the revenues they helped generate.
Example โ Which of the following explains the debit and credit rules relating to recording of Revenues and Expenses
This section clarifies that the debit and credit rules for revenues and expenses are based on their effect on ownerโs equity. Revenues increase ownerโs equity and are therefore recorded by credits. Expenses decrease ownerโs equity and are therefore recorded by debits. The incorrect answers incorrectly associated revenues and expenses with sides of the balance sheet or income statement.
๐ Definition โ Realization Principle: The accounting principle that revenue is recognized when it is earned, regardless of when cash is received. ๐ก Why this matters: Understanding the effect of revenues and expenses on ownerโs equity is fundamental to correctly applying debit and credit rules in journal entries.
Example โ The entry to recognize Depreciation expenses
This section confirms that the entry to recognize depreciation expense is an application of the matching principle and is an adjusting entry. It is not a closing entry, and it does not involve a credit to cash or accounts payable (instead, it credits accumulated depreciation, a contra-asset account).
๐ Definition โ Depreciation: The systematic allocation of the cost of a tangible asset over its useful life.
Example โ In the accounting cycle, closing entries are made before adjusting entries
This section reviews the correct sequence of the accounting cycle. Adjusting entries are prepared before financial statements are prepared. After the adjusted trial balance is completed, financial statements may be prepared. The ownerโs equity is not up to date until the closing entries have been posted. Therefore, closing entries are made after adjusting entries, not before.
๐ Definition โ Closing Entries: Journal entries made at the end of an accounting period to transfer the balances of temporary accounts (revenues, expenses, and dividends) to permanent ownerโs equity accounts.
โญ Key Takeaways
The matching principle is the foundation for both adjusting entries (e.g., depreciation) and closing entries. Revenues and expenses are recorded based on their effect on ownerโs equity, not on which side of a financial statement they appear. Depreciation expense is always an adjusting entry, never a closing entry. The correct order in the accounting cycle is: adjusting entries, adjusted trial balance, financial statements, and then closing entries. Understanding these relationships is critical for accurate financial reporting.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- Is the depreciation expense entry a closing entry or an adjusting entry?
- Are adjusting entries prepared before or after financial statements?
- What accounting principle is the basis for both adjusting and closing entries?
- When are revenues recorded by credits and expenses by debitsโbased on their effect on what account?
- Is the ownerโs equity up to date before or after closing entries are posted?
๐ Lecture 30 โ SUMMARY
๐ Overview: This lecture provides a comprehensive review of key concepts from previous lectures in the financial statement analysis course, focusing on corporate structure, stock transactions, and the statement of cash flows. The material is presented through multiple-choice example questions designed to clarify common misunderstandings and reinforce correct accounting principles.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture revisits three major topics through example questions: the legal and financial characteristics of corporations, including stockholder liability and rights; the accounting for stock issuance, including par value, additional paid-in capital, and the impact on financial statements; and the purpose and limitations of the statement of cash flows, clarifying what it does and does not assess.
๐ Lecture Summary
(Previous Lectures)
Example 1 โ Corporate Characteristics This example tests understanding of fundamental corporate features. A corporation is a separate legal entity where stock holders are generally not liable for corporate debts beyond their investment. A statement claiming stockholders are liable only in proportion to their ownership is incorrect; this describes limited liability, but they are not personally liable for corporate debts. The statement that stockholders do not pay personal income tax on dividends is incorrect; dividends are taxable income to the recipient. The statement that fluctuations in market value of shares do not affect the stock holdersโ equity shown on the balance sheet is correct; the balance sheet records historical cost, not market value. The statement that each stockholder has the right to bind the corporation is incorrect; only authorized officers/agents have that authority.
๐ Definition โ Stock holdersโ equity: The residual interest in the assets of a corporation after deducting liabilities, representing the owners' claim; it is not affected by daily market price fluctuations. ๐ Example: A stockholder owns 10% of shares. Market price rises. The balance sheet equity remains unchanged; only the market value of the investment changes.
Example 2 โ Stock Issuance and Paid-in Capital This example tests accounting for stock issued above par value. Moosa Corporation authorized 100,000 shares of Re. 1 par value common stock. It issued 40,000 shares to Moosa at Rs. 5 per share. The par value is a nominal amount, and the excess received is recorded in additional paid-in capital. The total cash received is 40,000 ร Rs. 5 = Rs. 200,000. Par value is 40,000 ร Rs. 1 = Rs. 40,000, so additional paid-in capital is Rs. 200,000 - Rs. 40,000 = Rs. 160,000. The statement that Moosa owns 40% of stockholders' equity is incorrect; he may own 40% of shares, but equity also includes retained earnings and other accounts. The corporation should not recognize a gain; stock issuance is a capital transaction, not revenue. If retained earnings are Rs. 50,000, total paid-in capital includes common stock (Rs. 40,000) and additional paid-in capital (Rs. 160,000) = Rs. 200,000, not Rs. 250,000. The correct answer is: the additional paid-in capital account will have a Rs. 160,000 balance, regardless of profits or losses.
๐ Definition โ Additional paid-in capital: The amount received from stock issuance in excess of the par value; it is part of paid-in capital and is not affected by subsequent earnings or losses. ๐ Definition โ Par value: A nominal, legal value per share printed on the stock certificate, often set at a minimal amount. ๐ Formula: Additional paid-in capital = (Issue price - Par value) ร Number of shares issued ๐ Formula: Total cash received = Issue price ร Number of shares issued ๐ Example: 40,000 shares issued at Rs. 5, par value Re. 1. Cash = Rs. 200,000. Common stock (par) = Rs. 40,000. Additional paid-in capital = Rs. 160,000.
Example 3 โ Statement of Cash Flows This example asks which of the following is not a purpose of the statement of cash flows. The statement of cash flows helps users assess the company's ability to remain solvent (cash position), identify major sources of cash receipts, and explain why net cash flows from operating activities differ from net income. However, it is not designed to directly assess the company's profitability; profitability is assessed through the income statement. Therefore, the correct answer is "In assessing the companyโs profitability."
๐ Definition โ Statement of cash flows: A financial statement that shows the cash inflows and outflows from operating, investing, and financing activities during a period. ๐ก Why this matters: The statement of cash flows reveals a company's liquidity and cash management, which are critical for survival, but it does not measure earnings performance.
โญ Key Takeaways
A student must remember that stockholders' equity on the balance sheet is recorded at historical cost, not market value, and that shareholders do not have personal liability for corporate debts nor the right to bind the corporation. When stock is issued above par value, the excess goes to additional paid-in capital, and no gain is recognized. The statement of cash flows is essential for assessing solvency and cash sources, but it cannot directly measure profitability, which is the role of the income statement. Understanding the distinct functions of different financial statements is critical for accurate analysis.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- Does a corporation record a gain when it issues common stock at a price above par value? Explain why or why not.
- If a companyโs stock price doubles on the stock exchange, what effect does this have on the stockholders' equity section of its balance sheet?
- What is the purpose of the additional paid-in capital account, and how is it calculated?
- Name one key assessment that the statement of cash flows is not designed to help users with.
- In the Moosa Corporation example, if the company later earns a large profit, does the additional paid-in capital account balance change?
๐ Lecture 31 โ Financial Statement Analysis
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the analysis of income statements and balance sheets as essential tools for evaluating a business's performance and financial position. It explains fundamental and industry analysis, the uses and limitations of ratio analysis, and the various techniques for comparing financial data over time and between firms, highlighting critical information problems and accounting distortions.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers financial statement analysis as a process for examining relationships among financial elements, introduces fundamental analysis at company and industry levels, discusses the uses and limitations of ratio analysis for managers, credit analysts, and stock analysts, and details information problems including different accounting policies, creative accounting, outdated information, and historical costs. It also examines comparisons over timeโaddressing price changes, technology changes, accounting policy changes, and seasonal impactsโand inter-firm comparisons involving different risk profiles, capital structures, government influences, and window dressing, concluding with analysis techniques using rupee and percentage changes.
๐ Lecture Summary
Analysis of income statement and balance sheet
Financial Statements are like the Instrument panels of a business. Different usersโboth outside and internalโhave different needs, so identifying the user is important to provide relevant information. Financial statement analysis is the process of examining relationships among financial statement elements and making comparisons with relevant information. It is a valuable tool used by investors, creditors, financial analysts, and others in decision-making related to stocks, bonds, and other financial instruments. The goal is to assess past performance, current financial position, and make predictions about future performance. Investors buying stock are primarily interested in profitability and prospects for earning a return through dividends and/or increasing market value. Creditors and investors buying debt securities are more interested in liquidity and solvency: the company's short- and long-run ability to pay its debts. Analysts can compare a company's most recent financial statements with previous years and with other companies in the same industry. Three primary types of analysis are horizontal analysis, vertical analysis, and ratio analysis.
Fundamental Analysis
Fundamental analysis at company level involves analyzing basic financial variables to estimate intrinsic value. These variables include sales, profit margins, depreciation, tax rate, sources of financing, asset utilization, and other factors. Additional analysis covers the firm's competitive position, labor relations, technological changes, management, and foreign competition. The end result is an estimate of the two factors that determine a securityโs value: cash flow stream and a required rate of return (alternatively, a P/E ratio).
๐ก Why this matters: Fundamental analysis provides the foundation for valuing securities by examining the underlying business drivers rather than just market prices.
Industry analysis
Industries are analyzed through the study of sales, earnings, dividends, capital structure, product lines, regulations, innovations, and other data. This requires considerable expertise and is usually performed by industry analysts employed by brokerage firms and institutional investors.
A useful first step is to analyze industries in terms of their stage in the life cycle to assess general health and current position. A second step is to assess the industry's position in relation to the business cycle and macroeconomic conditions. A third step involves qualitative analysis of industry characteristics to assist investors in assessing future prospects.
Uses and limitations of financial analysis
Ratio analysis is used by three main groups: (1) managers, who employ ratios to analyze, control, and improve operations; (2) credit analysts (bank loan officers and bond rating analysts), who analyze ratios to ascertain a company's ability to pay debts; and (3) stock analysts, who are interested in efficiency, risk, and growth prospects.
The lecture lists several limitations:
- Large firms with multiple divisions in different industries make it difficult to develop meaningful industry averagesโratio analysis is more useful for small, narrowly focused firms.
- Most firms want to be better than average, so merely attaining average performance is not necessarily good. It's best to focus on industry leaders' ratios through benchmarking.
- Inflation may distort balance sheet valuesโrecorded values often differ substantially from "true" values, affecting depreciation charges, inventory costs, and profits.
- Seasonal factors can distort ratio analysis (e.g., inventory turnover ratios for food processors vary based on timing). This can be minimized by using monthly averages for inventory and receivables.
- Firms can employ "window dressing" techniques to make financial statements look stronger.
- Different accounting practices can distort comparisonsโinventory valuation, depreciation methods, and leasing (where leased assets often do not appear on the balance sheet) can artificially improve turnover and debt ratios.
- It is difficult to generalize whether a particular ratio is "good" or "bad"โa high current ratio may indicate strong liquidity or excessive cash; a high fixed assets turnover ratio may denote efficient asset use or undercapitalization.
- A firm may have some ratios that look "good" and others "bad," making it difficult to tell overall strength. Statistical procedures like discriminant analysis can be used to analyze the net effects of a set of ratios.
Accounting Information
- Different Accounting Policies: Choices of accounting policies may distort inter-company comparisons. For example, IAS 16 allows valuation of assets based on either revalued amount or depreciated historical cost. A business may opt not to revalue assets because doing so increases depreciation charges and reduces profit.
- Creative accounting: Businesses apply creative accounting to show better financial performance or position, which can mislead users. Under IAS 16, if an asset is revalued and there is a revaluation deficit, it must be charged as an expense in the income statement, but a revaluation surplus is credited to revaluation reserve. To improve profitability, a company may revalue only those assets that result in revaluation surplus, leaving those with deficits at depreciated historical cost.
Information problems
- Ratios are not definitive measures: They need careful interpretation. Ratios can provide clues to performance or financial situation but cannot alone show whether performance is good or badโthey require some quantitative information for informed analysis.
- Outdated information in financial statements: Figures in accounts are likely to be at least several months out of date and may not give a proper indication of current financial position.
- Historical costs not suitable for decision making: The IASB Conceptual Framework recommends historical cost accounting. Where this convention is used, asset valuations in the balance sheet could be misleading, and ratios based on this information will not be very useful for decision making.
- Financial statements contain summarized information: Ratios are based on summaries of accounting records. Through summarization, some important information may be left out. Ratios are based on summarized year-end information which may not be a true reflection of the overall year's results.
- Interpretation of the ratio: It is difficult to generalize whether a particular ratio is "good" or "bad." A high current ratio may indicate strong liquidity or excessive cash. Similarly, non-current assets turnover ratio may denote efficient asset use or undercapitalization.
Comparison of performance over time
- Price changes: Inflation renders comparisons of results over time misleading as financial figures will not have the same purchasing power. Changes may appear to show improved performance when after adjusting for inflation, a different picture emerges.
- Technology changes: When comparing performance over time, changes in technology must be considered. For meaningful ratios, the enterprise should compare its results with another of the same level of technology for a good basis of efficiency measurement.
- Changes in Accounting policy: Changes in accounting policy may affect comparison of results between different accounting years. Directors may manipulate results through policy changes, especially during sensitive periods when profits are low.
- Changes in Accounting standard: Accounting standards offer standard ways of recognizing, measuring, and presenting financial transactions. Any change in standards will affect reporting and comparison of results over time.
- Impact of seasons on trading: Financial statements are based on year-end results which may not reflect results year-round. Seasonal businesses can choose the best time to produce financial statements to show better results. For example, a tobacco growing company will show good results if accounts are produced in the selling season (good inventory, receivables, and bank balances) versus planting season (many liabilities, low cash, nil receivables).
Inter-firm comparison
- Different financial and business risk profile: No two companies are the same, even when competitors in the same industry. Ratios comparing one company to another could provide misleading information. One company may obtain bank loans at reduced rates and show high gearing, while another may not and show low gearingโan uninformed analyst might think company two is better when in fact its low gearing is because it cannot secure further funding.
- Different capital structures and size: Companies may have different capital structures. Comparing performance when one is all equity financed and another is a geared company may not be a good analysis.
- Impact of Government influence: Selective application of government incentives to various companies may distort intercompany comparison. One company may receive a tax holiday while another in the same line of business does not, making performance comparisons misleading.
- Window dressing: These are techniques applied to show a strong financial position. For example, ABC Trucking can borrow K10 Million on a two-year basis on 28th December 2006, hold the proceeds as cash, then pay off the loan on 3rd January 2007. This improves current and quick ratios and makes the 2006 balance sheet look good, but the improvement is strictly window dressingโa week later the balance sheet returns to its old position.
Ratio analysis is useful, but analysts should be aware of these problems and make adjustments as necessary. Ratio analysis conducted in a mechanical, unthinking manner is dangerous, but if used intelligently and with good judgment, it can provide useful insights into the firm's operations.
Three broad areas of evaluating a business are its solvency, stability, and profitability, which are studied through analysis of financial statements. There are four techniques of Financial Statements Analysis.
ANALYSIS TECHNIQUES
- Rupee and percentage changes: Figures of Financial Statements from one year to the next (year-to-year) are considered.
Income Statement for the year ending June, 30
| 2001 | 2002 | 2003 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Net sales | 400 | 500 | 600 |
| Cost of Goods Sold | 235 | 300 | 370 |
| Gross profit | 165 | 200 | 230 |
| Other expenses | 115 | 160 | 194 |
| Net income | 50 | 40 | 36 |
Percentage change cannot be computed for negative amount or zero amount in base year. Mere figures of rising sales are not sufficientโwe must look at the volume of sales vis-ร -vis sale price. Quarterly or monthly measurement is also done, comparing results of the current quarter or month with those of the same quarter or month in the previous year to avoid distortion by seasonal fluctuations. The size of the base amount must be reasonable (example: a 90% decline followed by a 900% increase just to get back to the starting point). Percentages become misleading when the base is small:
| 1st year | 2nd year | 3rd year | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Income | 100,000 | 10,000 | 100,000 |
| (90% decline) | (900% increase) |
โญ Key Takeaways
Financial statement analysis involves examining relationships among elements to assess past performance, current position, and future predictions, using horizontal, vertical, and ratio analysis. Ratio analysis is used by managers, credit analysts, and stock analysts, but it has significant limitations including inflation distortions, seasonal factors, window dressing, different accounting policies, and difficulties in interpreting ratios as good or bad. Information problems include outdated data, historical costs not suitable for decision making, and summarized information that may omit relevant details. When comparing performance over time, analysts must account for price changes, technology changes, accounting policy changes, and seasonal impacts; inter-firm comparisons require caution due to different risk profiles, capital structures, government influences, and the potential for window dressing. The analysis technique of rupee and percentage changes examines year-to-year figures but percentage changes become misleading with small bases and cannot be computed for negative or zero base amounts.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three primary types of financial statement analysis, and what is the overall goal of financial statement analysis?
- List and explain three major limitations or information problems that can distort ratio analysis when comparing firms.
- What is "window dressing" in the context of financial statements? Provide a specific example from the lecture.
- Explain why percentage changes in financial figures can be misleading when the base amount is small, using the income example from the lecture (100,000 to 10,000 to 100,000).
- Why might a comparison of performance between two companies in the same industry be misleading, and what are two specific factors that cause this?
๐ Lecture 32 โ Common-Size and Index Analysis
๐ Overview: This lecture explores two essential methods of financial statement analysis: vertical (common-size) analysis and horizontal (index/trend) analysis. It explains how these techniques help investors, creditors, and management evaluate a firmโs past, current, and projected performance by revealing internal structure and trends over time.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining financial statement analysis and two main comparison types โ industry comparison and trend analysis. It then introduces trend percentages (horizontal/index analysis) and component percentages (vertical/common-size analysis). Detailed explanations of vertical analysis (using a base figure like total assets or net sales) and horizontal analysis (comparing figures across years including trend analysis) are provided, concluding with a definition of common-size financial statements.
๐ Lecture Summary
Financial Statement Analysis โ Overview
Financial statement analysis is a method used by interested parties such as investors, creditors, and management to evaluate the past, current, and projected conditions and performance of the firm. Ratio analysis is the most common form, providing relative measures of the firmโs conditions and performance. Horizontal Analysis and Vertical Analysis are also popular forms. Horizontal analysis evaluates the trend in the accounts over the years, while vertical analysis (also called a Common Size Financial Statement) discloses the internal structure of the firm โ indicating the existing relationship between sales and each income statement account, the mix of assets that produce income, and the mix of sources of capital (current or long-term debt or equity funding).
When using financial ratios, a financial analyst makes two types of comparisons:
- (a) Industry comparison: The ratios of a firm are compared with those of similar firms or with industry averages or norms to determine how the company is faring relative to its competitors.
- (b) Trend analysis: A firmโs present ratio is compared with its past and expected future ratios to determine whether the companyโs financial condition is improving or deteriorating over time.
After completing the financial statement analysis, the firmโs financial analyst will consult with management to discuss plans and prospects, any problem areas identified, and possible solutions.
Trend Percentages / Horizontal Analysis / Index Analysis
This analysis considers changes in items of a financial statement from a base year to the following years to show the direction of change. This is also called horizontal analysis. In this method, the figures of various years are placed side by side in adjacent columns in the form of comparative financial statements.
Component Percentages / Vertical Analysis / Common-Size Analysis
This type of analysis indicates the relative size of each item in the Financial Statements as a percentage of the total of that Statement โ i.e., Total Assets or Total Liabilities & Shareholdersโ equity in the Balance Sheet, and Sales in the Income Statement. Such a statement is then called a common-size Financial Statement. This type of analysis technique is also called Vertical Analysis.
Vertical Analysis
When using vertical analysis, the analyst calculates each item on a single financial statement as a percentage of a total. The term vertical analysis applies because each yearโs figures are listed vertically on a financial statement. The total used by the analyst on the income statement is net sales revenue, while on the balance sheet it is total assets. This approach, also known as component percentages, produces common-size financial statements. Common-size balance sheets and income statements can be more easily compared, whether across the years for a single company or across different companies.
The financial statement item used as a base value is assigned 100%. All other accounts on the financial statement are compared to it. In the balance sheet, total assets equals 100%, with each asset stated as a percentage of total assets. Similarly, total liabilities and stockholdersโ equity are assigned 100%, with a given liability or equity account stated as a percentage of that total. For the income statement, 100% is assigned to net sales, with all revenue and expense accounts related to it. Under vertical analysis, the statements showing the percentages are referred to as Common Size Financial Statements. Common size percentages can be compared from one period to another to identify areas needing attention.
๐ Definition โ Common-Size Financial Statement: A company financial statement that displays all items as percentages of a common base figure. This type of financial statement allows for easy analysis between companies or between time periods of a company.
Horizontal Analysis
When an analyst compares financial information for two or more years for a single company, the process is referred to as horizontal analysis, since the analyst is reading across the page to compare any single line item, such as sales revenues. In addition to comparing dollar amounts, the analyst computes percentage changes from year to year for all financial statement balances, such as cash and inventory.
Alternatively, in comparing financial statements for a number of years, the analyst may prefer to use a variation of horizontal analysis called trend analysis. Trend analysis involves calculating each yearโs financial statement balances as percentages of the first year, also known as the base year. When expressed as percentages, the base year figures are always 100 percent, and percentage changes from the base year can be determined.
๐ Definition โ Horizontal Analysis: Time series analysis of financial statements covering more than one accounting period; also called Trend Analysis. It looks at the percentage change in an account over time. The percentage change equals the change over the prior year.
๐ Formula: Percentage Change = (Change in Account Balance) / (Prior Year Balance) โ This formula calculates the relative increase or decrease in a financial statement item from one year to the next.
๐ Example: If sales in 20X0 are $100,000 and in 20X1 are $300,000, there is a 200% increase.
- Step 1: Calculate the change: $300,000 - $100,000 = $200,000
- Step 2: Divide by the prior year balance: $200,000 / $100,000 = 2.00
- Step 3: Convert to percentage: 2.00 ร 100 = 200% increase.
By examining the magnitude and direction of a financial statement item over time, the analyst can evaluate its reasonableness.
โญ Key Takeaways
A student must remember that financial statement analysis uses ratio analysis, horizontal analysis, and vertical analysis. Horizontal analysis (also called trend or index analysis) compares financial data across years, calculating percentage changes from a base year, with the base year set at 100%. Vertical analysis (common-size analysis) expresses each item on a financial statement as a percentage of a base figure โ total assets for the balance sheet and net sales for the income statement. These methods allow analysts to evaluate internal structure, identify trends, and compare performance across companies or time periods effectively.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the primary difference between horizontal analysis and vertical analysis?
- In a common-size balance sheet, what is the base figure (100%) to which all other items are compared?
- How is the percentage change calculated in horizontal analysis? Provide the formula.
- If a companyโs sales are $50,000 in Year 1 and $75,000 in Year 2, what is the percentage change?
- Why are common-size financial statements useful for comparing companies of different sizes?
๐ Lecture 33 โ Ratios Analysis
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces the fundamental technique of ratio analysis for evaluating a firm's financial health, with a primary focus on the perspective of short-term creditors. It explains why short-term solvency is critical for business survival and details the key liquidity ratios used to measure a firm's ability to meet its immediate obligations.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with an introduction to ratio analysis as a financial thermometer for business health. It then focuses on the perspective of short-term creditors and their interest in a firm's ability to meet debts as they fall due. The core of the lecture covers the Liquidity Ratios, specifically the Current Ratio, the Quick (Acid-Test) Ratio, and the Cash Ratio, including their formulas, interpretations, and normal benchmarks.
๐ Lecture Summary
4. ANALYSIS BY RATIOS
Financial ratios are described as "financial temperatures" that indicate the state of a business's health. This widely-used analysis technique establishes inter-linkages between Income Statement and Balance Sheet items to draw inferences.
a) Analysis by short-term creditors
The primary interest of short-term creditors is in a firm's short-term solvencyโits ability to meet debts as they become due. This involves assessing if the entity can pay its current liabilities out of its current assets. The lecture emphasizes that without maintaining short-term debt-paying ability, a firm cannot maintain long-term solvency or satisfy its stockholders. Even a very profitable entity can become bankrupt if it fails to meet short-term obligations. Profitability does not determine short-term debt-paying ability; rather, it is determined by short-term solvency ratios.
๐ก Why this matters: This establishes that cash flow and asset liquidity are more critical for immediate survival than profitability, a key distinction for financial analysis.
๐ Definition โ Short-term solvency: The ability of a business to meet its current liabilities as they become due.
Liquidity Ratios
Liquidity Ratios measure a firmโs ability to meet short-term obligations by comparing short-term obligations to short-term resources. These ratios provide insight into both present cash solvency and the firm's ability to remain solvent in the face of adversity.
i) Current ratio
The current ratio is calculated as Current assets divided by Current liabilities. The normal ratio for this is 2:1, meaning current assets should be twice current liabilities. ๐ Formula: Current ratio = Current assets / Current liabilities โ This shows a firmโs ability to cover its current liabilities with its current assets. A higher ratio indicates a greater ability to pay bills, but it is a crude measure as it doesn't consider the liquidity of individual current asset components. A firm with cash and receivables is more liquid than one with primarily inventories. A ratio that is too high may indicate capital is not being used productively, signaling a need for financial reorganization.
ii) Quick ratio (Acid-test ratio)
The quick ratio provides a more severe test of liquidity than the current ratio. It excludes inventories and pre-paid expenses from current assets, considering only Quick Assets (cash, marketable securities, and receivables). The normal ratio is 1:1 (quick assets should equal current liabilities). ๐ Definition โ Quick Assets: Current assets excluding inventories and pre-paid expenses, consisting of cash, marketable securities, and receivables. ๐ Formula: Acid Test Ratio = (Current assets - Inventories - Prepaid Expenses) / Current Liabilities โ The current ratio measures "general liquidity," whereas the quick ratio measures "immediate liquidity." This ratio concentrates on the most liquid assets in relation to current obligations, providing a more penetrating measure of liquidity.
๐ Example: If a firm has Current Assets = $500,000 and Current Liabilities = $250,000, the current ratio is 2:1. However, if Inventories = $200,000 and Prepaid Expenses = $50,000, then Quick Assets = $500,000 - $200,000 - $50,000 = $250,000. The Quick Ratio = $250,000 / $250,000 = 1:1.
Cash Ratio
The cash ratio indicates the immediate liquidity of the firm. ๐ Formula: Cash Ratio = (Cash Equivalents + Marketable Securities) / Current Liabilities โ A high cash ratio indicates that the firm is not using its cash to its best advantage; cash should be deployed in the operations of the company.
โญ Key Takeaways
- Ratio analysis is a primary tool for assessing financial health, establishing relationships between income statement and balance sheet items.
- Short-term solvency is critical for business survival; even profitable firms can fail if they cannot meet current obligations.
- While the current ratio (normally 2:1) measures general liquidity, the quick ratio (normally 1:1) provides a more stringent test by excluding inventories.
- The cash ratio measures immediate liquidity, and a very high value may indicate inefficient use of cash resources.
- Liquidity ratios are primarily used by short-term creditors to evaluate a firm's ability to pay debts as they become due.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three liquidity ratios discussed in this lecture, and what does each measure?
- Why is the quick ratio considered a more "penetrating measure of liquidity" than the current ratio?
- What are the normal benchmarks for the current ratio and the quick ratio?
- What does a very high cash ratio indicate about a firm's operations?
- Why does the lecture state that profitability does not determine short-term debt-paying ability?