π Lecture 16 β BRANCH ACCOUNTING (Incorporation of branch) Solved Questions
π Overview: This lecture demonstrates the complete process of incorporating a branch's trial balance into the head office books, using a solved example for Murree Branch. It covers reconciliation of goods in transit, preparation of the branch's income statement and balance sheet, and the journal entries required for incorporation in the head office's books, including scenarios where the head office allocates additional expenses.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with definitions of inter-branch transfers and incorporation. It presents the trial balance of Murree Branch and provides a step-by-step solution starting with a reconciliation entry for goods in transit. It then walks through the preparation of the branch's income statement and balance sheet. Finally, it shows the corresponding journal entries in the head office's books for incorporation of net profit, assets, and liabilities, including a second scenario where the head office allocates advertisement and depreciation expenses.
π Lecture Summary
Inter branch transfers / Incorporation
Meanings: "Incorporation" means the consolidation of a branch's trial balance into the books of the head office. Note: Accounting entries for incorporation are passed in the books of head office only.
Accounting Entries for Incorporation:
- To incorporate Branch other income: Debit Branch A/C, Credit Profit & Loss A/C (income)
- To incorporate Branch Assets: Debit each individual asset account, Credit Branch A/C
- To incorporate Branch Liabilities: Debit Branch A/C, Credit each individual liability account
- Note: After these entries, the Branch Account in the head office's trial balance will have a nil balance.
Solved Question - Murree Branch
The lecture presents the Trial Balance of Murree Branch as on 31st December 2007. Key figures include: Lahore Head Office (Cr.) Rs. 3,240, Stock 1st Jan. (Dr.) Rs. 6,000, Goods received from H.O. (Dr.) Rs. 19,000, Sales (Cr.) Rs. 138,000, and Debtors (Dr.) Rs. 3,700.
Other Information:
- Closing stock at branch on 31st Dec 2007: Rs. 7,700
- Murree Branch A/c in HO books on 31st Dec: Rs. 460 (Dr.)
- On 28th Dec, HO forwarded goods worth Rs. 3,700 to the branch, which were received on 3rd Jan 2007.
Solution - Step 1: Reconciliation Entry
Since the goods were in transit at year-end, a reconciliation entry is required in the head office books.
π Definition β Goods in Transit: Goods sent by the head office to the branch that have not yet been received by the branch by the end of the accounting period.
π Formula/Journal Entry:
Goods in Transit A/c Dr. 3,700
To Murree Branch A/c 3,700
(Being goods sent to branch on 28th December, received on 3rd January, 2007)
Solution - Step 2: Branch Income Statement
The branch's income statement is prepared for the year ended 31st December 2007.
Murree Income Statement (Rs.)
- Sales: 138,000
- Goods supplied to H.O.: 6,000
- Total Revenue: 144,000
- Less Cost of Goods Sold (CGS):
- Opening Stock: 6,000
- Add Purchases: 97,800
- Add Goods received from H.O.: 19,000
- Less Closing Stock: (7,700)
- Total CGS: 115,100
- Gross Profit: 28,900
- Less Operating Expenses:
- Salaries: 4,500
- Rent: 1,960
- Sundry Office Expenses: 1,470
- Depreciation on Furniture: 400
- Total Expenses: 8,330
- Net Profit: 20,570
Solution - Step 3: Branch Balance Sheet
The balance sheet of Murree Branch as on 31st December 2007 is prepared.
| Assets | Amount (Rs.) | Liabilities | Amount (Rs.) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fixed Assets: | Head Office: | ||
| Furniture | 6,000 | Opening Balance (Cr.) | 460 |
| Current Assets: | Add: Profit | 20,570 | |
| Closing stock | 7,700 | 21,030 | |
| Debtors | 3,700 | Creditor | 1,850 |
| Goods in transit | 3,700 | ||
| Cash at bank | 1,780 | ||
| Total | 22,880 | Total | 22,880 |
π‘ Why this matters: The branch's balance sheet shows a credit balance for the Head Office account, representing the net investment by the HO in the branch.
Solution - Step 4: Incorporation Entries in Head Office Books
The following journal entries are passed in the head office books.
1. Incorporation of Branch Net Profit
Murree Branch A/c Dr. 20,570
To General Profit & Loss A/c 20,570
(Being the incorporation of branch net profit)
2. Incorporation of Branch Assets
Murree Branch Furniture A/c Dr. 6,000
Murree Branch Debtors A/c Dr. 3,700
Murree cash in transit A/c Dr. 3,700
Murree Branch Stock A/c Dr. 7,700
Murree Branch Cash A/c Dr. 1,780
To Murree Branch A/c 22,880
(Being the incorporation of branch assets)
3. Incorporation of Branch Liabilities
Murree Branch A/c Dr. 1,850
To Murree Branch Creditors A/c 1,850
(Being the incorporation of branch liability)
Scenario B: Additional Information from Head Office
If additional information is given, such as advertisement expenses allocated by HO (Rs. 1,000) and depreciation charged by HO on branch equipment @10% using straight line method, these must be recorded in both HO and branch books.
Journal Entries in Head Office Books:
Murree Branch A/c Dr. 1,000
To Advertisement A/c 1,000
Murree Branch A/c Dr. 500
To Provision for Dep. A/c 500
Journal Entries in Branch Books:
Advertisement A/c Dr. 1,000
To Head Office A/c 1,000
Provision for Dep. A/c Dr. 500
To Head Office A/c 500
Updated Branch Account (in HO books):
| Particulars | Rs. | Particulars | Rs. |
|---|---|---|---|
| Balance b/d | 460 | Balance c/f | 1,960 |
| Advertisement | 1,000 | ||
| Depreciation expense | 500 | ||
| Total | 1,960 | Total | 1,960 |
Updated Head Office Account (in Branch books):
| Particulars | Rs. | Particulars | Rs. |
|---|---|---|---|
| Balance c/f | 1,960 | Balance b/d | 460 |
| Advertisement | 1,000 | ||
| Depreciation expense | 500 | ||
| Total | 1,960 | Total | 1,960 |
Updated Income Statement (Rs.)
- Gross Profit: 28,900
- Less Operating Expenses (Salaries 4,500, Rent 1,960, Sundry Office Exp. 1,470, Dep. on Furniture 400, Advertisement on Equipment 1,000, Dep. on Furniture 500): 9,830
- Net Profit: 19,070
Updated Balance Sheet The Head Office section now includes the HO adjustments:
- Opening Balance (Cr.) 460
- Add: advertisement 1,000
- Add: Depreciation 500
- Add: Profit 19,070
- Total Head Office: 21,030
The remaining balance sheet figures remain the same, totaling 22,880.
Final Incorporation Entries in HO Books (Scenario B):
- Incorporation of branch net profit:
Murree branch A/c Dr. 19,070
To Profit & Loss A/c 19,070
- Incorporation of branch Assets:
Murree branch goods in transit A/c Dr. 3,700
Murree branch furniture A/c Dr. 6,000
Murree branch debtors A/c Dr. 3,700
Murree branch stock A/c Dr. 7,700
Murree branch cash A/c Dr. 1,780
To Murree branch A/c 22,880
- Incorporation of branch Liabilities:
Murree branch A/c Dr. 1,850
To Murree branch creditors A/c 1,850
β Key Takeaways
Incorporation is the process of consolidating the branch's trial balance into the head office's books, and all incorporation entries are made solely in the head office's books. Goods in transit at year-end require a reconciliation entry to adjust the branch account and record an asset. The branch's income statement and balance sheet must be prepared first to determine the net profit and the values of assets and liabilities to be incorporated. When the head office allocates additional expenses (like advertisement and depreciation), these are recorded in both the head office and branch books to ensure the branch account is correctly stated. After all incorporation entries are posted, the Branch Account in the head office's books will have a nil balance, and the branch's assets and liabilities are merged with the head office's records.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Explain the concept of "goods in transit" and state the journal entry required in the head office books to account for them at year-end.
- What is the purpose of the "incorporation" process in branch accounting, and in which set of books are the entries passed?
- A branch has a credit balance in its Net Profit for the year. What journal entry is passed in the head office books to incorporate this profit?
- When the head office allocates expenses to a branch, what journal entries are recorded in the branch's books and the head office's books?
- After all incorporation entries are completed, what should be the balance in the "Branch Account" in the head office's trial balance?
π Lecture 17 β Essentials of Partnership
π Overview: This lecture defines the legal concept of partnership under the Partnership Act 1932 and explains its essential elements. It covers the partnership agreement (deed), the two methods of accounting for partners' capital (fluctuating vs. fixed), and demonstrates profit distribution through detailed worked examples.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the legal definition and essential elements of partnership under the Partnership Act 1932. It then explains the contents of a partnership agreement (deed). The second half covers the two methods for maintaining partners' capital accounts: fluctuating capital and fixed capital (with a separate current account), followed by a comprehensive solved question involving interest on capital, partner salary, interest on drawings, and profit sharing.
π Lecture Summary
ESSENTIALS OF PARTNERSHIP
The law governing partnership is contained in the Partnership Act, 1932. Section 4 of the Act defines partnership as βthe relation between persons who have agreed to share the profits of a business carried on by all or any of them acting for allβ.
The essential elements of partnership are:
- There must be an agreement entered into by all the persons concerned.
- The agreement must be to share the profits of a business.
- The business must be carried on by all or any of them acting for all.
π Definition β Partnership: The relation between persons who have agreed to share the profits of a business carried on by all or any of them acting for all.
π‘ Why this matters: All three elements must be present for a partnership to exist. If any one is missing, there cannot be a partnership.
Partnership agreement
Partnership is the result of an agreement. The agreement among the partners that sets out the terms on which they have agreed to form a partnership is called a partnership agreement. It may be in writing, by words of mouth, or implied from the course of conduct. It is desirable to have it in writing to avoid future disputes. The document in writing containing the various terms and conditions is called the βpartnership deedβ.
The following clauses are normally included in a partnership agreement:
- Name of the firm.
- Nature of partnership business.
- Capital of the firm and each partnerβs contribution proportion.
- Profit and loss sharing ratio.
- Rate of interest on capital and interest on drawings.
- Amount each partner may withdraw and timing.
- Salaries and other allowances payable to partners.
- Commencement and duration.
- Whether capital accounts are fixed or fluctuating.
- Valuation of goodwill at retirement or death.
- Method of ascertaining amount due to retiring/deceased partner.
- Keeping books and preparation of balance sheet.
- Audit and appointment of auditor.
- Rights and duties of partners.
- Arbitration clause for settling disputes.
Partner`s Capital Account
There are two accounting treatments for the distribution of profit in partnership accounts:
- Fluctuating Capital.
- Fixed Capital.
Fluctuating Capital:
Under this method, all transactions (drawings, share of profit/loss, interest, salary) are recorded directly in the partnerβs capital account. The capital balance changes (fluctuates) each period.
π Example (from previous lessonβs solved question): Using the data: Aβs opening capital Rs. 110,000, Bβs opening Rs. 215,000; Profit shares: A Rs. 43,600, B Rs. 26,400; Drawings: A Rs. 30,000, B Rs. 30,000; Closing balances are calculated.
Aβs Fluctuating Capital Account:
| Particulars | A (Rs) | B (Rs) | Particulars | A (Rs) | B (Rs) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Drawings | 30,000 | 30,000 | Opening capital b/f | 110,000 | 215,000 |
| Balance c/f | 123,600 | 211,400 | Profit | 43,600 | 26,400 |
| Total | 153,600 | 241,400 | Total | 153,600 | 241,400 |
β The closing capital (Balance c/f) is A: Rs. 123,600 and B: Rs. 211,400.
Fixed Capital:
Under this method, the capital account remains constant at the amount originally contributed. A separate current account is maintained for each partner to record drawings, share of profit/loss, interest, and salary.
π Example (same data): Fixed Capital Account:
| Particulars | A (Rs) | B (Rs) | Particulars | A (Rs) | B (Rs) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Balance c/f | 100,000 | 200,000 | Opening capital b/f | 100,000 | 200,000 |
| Total | 100,000 | 200,000 | Total | 100,000 | 200,000 |
Current Account:
| Particulars | A (Rs) | B (Rs) | Particulars | A (Rs) | B (Rs) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Drawings | 30,000 | 30,000 | Opening capital b/f | 10,000 | 15,000 |
| Balance c/f | 23,600 | 11,400 | Profit | 43,600 | 26,400 |
| Total | 100,000 | 200,000 | Total | 100,000 | 200,000 |
β The closing current account balances are A: Rs. 23,600 and B: Rs. 11,400.
Balance Sheet Presentation (Ownerβs Capital):
| A (Rs) | B (Rs) | |
|---|---|---|
| Capital | 100,000 | 200,000 |
| Current A/c | 23,600 | 11,400 |
| Total | 123,600 | 211,400 |
Solved Questions
Problem: Tariq and Saeed have been in partnership for one year, sharing profits and losses in the ratio of Tariq 3/5 & Saeed 2/5. They are entitled to 5% per annum interest on capitals. Tariqβs capital: Rs. 2,000, Saeedβs capital: Rs. 6,000. Saeed is entitled to a salary of Rs. 500. Interest on drawings: Tariq Rs. 50, Saeed Rs. 100. Net profit before any distributions: Rs. 5,000 for the year ended 31 December 2007.
Solution:
Step 1: Add interest on drawings to net profit Net Profit: Rs. 5,000 Add: Interest on drawings (Tariq Rs. 50 + Saeed Rs. 100) = Rs. 150 Adjusted Net Profit: Rs. 5,150
Step 2: Deduct salary and interest on capital Less: Salary to Saeed: Rs. 500 Less: Interest on capital:
- Tariq: 5% Γ Rs. 2,000 = Rs. 100
- Saeed: 5% Γ Rs. 6,000 = Rs. 300
- Total interest = Rs. 400 Total deductions: Rs. 500 + Rs. 400 = Rs. 900
Step 3: Calculate balance of profit Balance of profit: Rs. 5,150 β Rs. 900 = Rs. 4,250
Step 4: Share the balance of profit in the profit-sharing ratio Tariqβs share: Rs. 4,250 Γ 3/5 = Rs. 2,550 Saeedβs share: Rs. 4,250 Γ 2/5 = Rs. 1,700
β Key Takeaways
A partnership requires a mutual agreement to share profits of a business where partners act for one another. The partnership deed is a formal written document outlining all terms, including profit-sharing ratio, interest on capital, salaries, and dispute resolution. There are two methods of maintaining capital accounts: fluctuating capital, where all entries go into one account, and fixed capital, where a separate current account records changes. When distributing profit, any interest on drawings is added to the net profit, then salaries and interest on capital are subtracted, and the remaining profit is shared according to the agreed ratio. Understanding the order of appropriations is critical for accurate partnership accounting.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three essential elements of a partnership as defined by the Partnership Act 1932?
- List at least five clauses that should be included in a partnership deed.
- What is the difference between fluctuating capital and fixed capital accounts?
- In the solved question, why is interest on drawings added to the net profit before distributing profit?
- If a partner is entitled to a salary, where does it appear in the profit distribution process? Is it deducted before or after the balance of profit is shared?
π Lecture 18 β Partnership Accounts (Cont.)
π Overview: This lecture discusses the accounting treatments required when changes occur in a partnership firm's constitution after formation. It specifically covers the admission of new partners, including calculations for new profit-sharing ratios, sacrifice ratios, and revaluation of assets and liabilities, with multiple solved examples.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the types of changes that can occur in a partnership firm (admission, retirement, death of a partner), with detailed focus on the admission of a new partner. Key issues addressed include change in profit sharing ratio, revaluation of assets and liabilities, and calculation of goodwill. Several solved questions demonstrate how to calculate new profit sharing ratios under different conditions and how to compute the sacrifice ratio. Journal entries for capital introduction and revaluation are also provided with an example.
π Lecture Summary
Partnership Accounts (Cont.)
This section explains that after a partnership firm is formed, changes in the constitution (Partnership deed) require different accounting treatments. These changes can occur due to admission of a new partner, retirement of an existing partner, or death of a partner.
Admission of a new partner
A new partner may be admitted for various reasons, such as personal influence, need of more capital, or special skills. At the time of admission, certain adjustments are necessary in the books of accounts, with calculation of goodwill being very important.
Admission of Partners (Issues)
- Change of profit sharing ratio
- Revaluation of assets and liabilities or revaluation of Net Assets
- Calculation of goodwill
- Accounting treatment of goodwill
Journal entries for the introduction of the capital:
- Introduction of capital by new partner in term of cash: Cash Account xxx Partnerβs Capital Account xxx
- Introduction of capital in shape of assets: Stocks xxx Furniture xxx Machinery xxx Partnerβs Capital Account xxx
The admission of a new partner may also affect: Interest on capital, Partnerβs salary, and Profit sharing ratio.
Change in profit sharing ratio: Solved Questions
This section demonstrates how to calculate new profit sharing ratios when a new partner is admitted.
Solved Question 1: Old partnerβs profit sharing ratio: A = 3/5, B = 2/5. C entered as a new partner. He will get 1/6 profit share.
Solution: Shares of A, B & C: Balance share = 1 - 1/6 = 5/6 Aβs Share = 5/6 x 3/5 = 3/6 Bβs Share = 5/6 x 2/5 = 2/6 Cβs Share = 1/6
New profit sharing ratio: 3/6 : 2/6 : 1/6 = 3 : 2 : 1
Solved Question 2: A and B are partners sharing profits in ratio of 3:2 respectively. They admit C for share of 1/4.
Solution: Share of A, B and C: Balance = 1 β 1/4 = 3/4 A = 3/4 x 3/5 = 9/20 B = 3/4 x 2/5 = 6/20 C = 1/4 x 5/5 = 5/20
New profit sharing ratios = 9 : 6 : 5
Solved Question 3: A and B are partners sharing profits in ratio of 3:2 respectively. They admit C for share of 1/4. It is further decided that the remaining share will be distributed among A and B in equally proportion.
Solution: A & B profit sharing ratio = 3:2 Offer to C = 1/4 Balance for A & B = 1 β 1/4 = 3/4 Aβs share = 3/4 x 1/2 = 3/8 Bβs share = 3/4 x 1/2 = 3/8 Cβs share = 1/4 x 2/2 = 2/8
New profit sharing ratio: A : B : C = 3 : 3 : 2
Calculation of sacrifice ratio:
On the admission of a partner in a firm, loss is suffered by old partners. The old partner may sacrifice either in their old sharing ratio or in some other ratio. Sacrifice made by the old partner can be found by deducting their new share from the old share.
π Definition β Sacrifice Ratio: The ratio in which old partners give up their share of profit in favor of the new partner. π Formula: Sacrifice Ratio = Old Ratio β New Ratio
Solved Question: A and B are partners who share the profits in the ratio of 3/5 and 2/5 respectively. They admit C into partnership and the profit sharing ratio is agreed at 3/8 : 3/8 : 2/8 respectively.
Solution: Aβs sacrifice ratio = Old ratio β New ratio = 3/5 β 3/8 = (24 - 15)/40 = 9/40 Bβs sacrifice ratio = Old ratio β New ratio = 2/5 β 3/8 = (16 - 15)/40 = 1/40
Sacrifice ratio = 9 : 1
Revaluation of Assets & Liabilities
When a new partner is admitted, he acquires ownership rights of the assets and becomes responsible for the liabilities. Therefore, it is desirable that the assets and liabilities on the date of admission should be properly valued.
Three probabilities of revaluation:
- No change in the value
- Increase in the value
- Decrease in the value
Revaluation journal entries:
Increase in assets: Assets A/c xxx Revaluation A/c xxx
Decrease in assets: Revaluation A/c xxx Assets A/c xxx
Increase in liabilities: Revaluation A/c xxx Liabilities A/c xxx
Decrease in liabilities: Liabilities A/c xxx Revaluation A/c xxx
Solved Question: Given:
- Increase in assets Rs. 10,000
- Decrease in assets Rs. 2,000
- Increase in liabilities Rs. 3,000
- Decrease in liabilities Rs. 500
Solution: Journal Entries: Increase in assets: Assets A/c 10,000 Revaluation A/c 10,000
Decrease in assets: Revaluation A/c 2,000 Assets A/c 2,000
Increase in liabilities: Revaluation A/c 3,000 Liabilities A/c 3,000
Decrease in liabilities: Liabilities A/c 500 Revaluation A/c 500
π‘ Why this matters: The Revaluation Account serves as a temporary account to record all gains and losses from asset and liability revaluation. After all entries are posted, the balance (profit or loss) is transferred to the old partners' capital accounts in their old profit-sharing ratio. This ensures the incoming partner is neither disadvantaged nor gains unfair advantage from inaccurate asset/liability values.
β Key Takeaways
The admission of a new partner is a significant event in a partnership that requires careful recalculation of profit-sharing ratios and the computation of sacrifice ratios from old partners. New profit sharing ratios are determined by first subtracting the new partner's share from 1, then distributing the remaining share among old partners according to their agreed proportions. The sacrifice ratio, calculated as old ratio minus new ratio, is essential for determining how much profit each old partner has given up for the new partner. Additionally, all assets and liabilities must be revalued at the time of admission to ensure fair treatment for both existing and incoming partners, with all revaluation gains or losses recorded through the Revaluation Account and ultimately transferred to old partners' capital accounts.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three main accounting issues that must be addressed when a new partner is admitted?
- If A and B share profits in a 3:2 ratio and admit C for 1/6 share, what is the new profit sharing ratio?
- How is the sacrifice ratio calculated for an old partner upon admission of a new partner?
- What journal entry is made when there is a decrease in the value of an asset during revaluation?
- When a new partner brings capital in the form of assets (not cash), what is the correct journal entry?
π Lecture 19 β Partnership Accounts (Cont.)
π Overview: This lecture covers the valuation and accounting treatment of goodwill in partnership firms, focusing on admission of a new partner. It explains three methods of calculating goodwill and three scenarios for recording goodwill in the books. Understanding these concepts is critical for properly handling partner admissions and ensuring fair compensation to existing partners.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the preparation of a Revaluation Account and its distribution among old partners. It then defines goodwill and its characteristics, followed by three methods of goodwill calculation: Average Profit Method, Super Profit Method, and Market Capitalization Method. Finally, it explains three accounting scenarios for goodwill treatment upon admission of a new partner: Goodwill Raised, Goodwill Raised & Written Off, and Goodwill Brought in Cash.
π Lecture Summary
Increase in liabilities / Decrease in liabilities
When assets and liabilities are revalued upon admission of a new partner, changes are recorded through the Revaluation Account. An increase in liabilities is credited to the Revaluation Account and debited to the Liabilities Account. A decrease in liabilities is debited to the Revaluation Account and credited to the Liabilities Account.
Example:
- Increase in liabilities: Dr. Liabilities A/c 3,000; Cr. Revaluation A/c 3,000
- Decrease in liabilities: Dr. Revaluation A/c 500; Cr. Liabilities A/c 500
After recording all revaluation entries, the Revaluation Account balance is transferred to the old partners' capital accounts in their old profit-sharing ratio.
Example: Revaluation Account shows a credit balance of Rs. 5,500. Partners A and B share profits in ratio 3:2.
- A's share = 5,500 Γ 3/5 = 3,300
- B's share = 5,500 Γ 2/5 = 2,200
Journal Entry:
Revaluation A/c 5,500
A's Capital A/c 3,300
B's Capital A/c 2,200
Goodwill
Goodwill may arise from attributes such as good reputation, customer relationships, strategic location, employee skills, dynamic management, product durability, effective advertising, patented processes, credit rating, training programs, and relationships with suppliers and employees. Goodwill is the aggregate of intangible attributes that contribute to the superior earning capacity of a business. It is the outcome of an impression created in the minds of customers and related persons.
π Definition β Goodwill: The aggregate of intangible attributes of a business that contribute to its superior earning capacity.
Average Profit Method for calculating goodwill
Under the Average Profit Method, average profit is calculated from past years' profits and then multiplied by a number of years' purchase (e.g., 3, 4, or 5 times) as agreed upon by the partners.
π Formula: Goodwill = Average Profit Γ Number of Years' Purchase
π Example: Goodwill is three times the average profit of the previous five years.
- Total profits = Rs. 100 (over 5 years)
- Average profit = 100 / 5 = Rs. 20
- Goodwill = 20 Γ 3 = Rs. 60
Methods to be adopted in valuing goodwill
The method adopted for valuing goodwill depends on the circumstances of each case. The partnership deed should be examined, and valuation should follow the method agreed upon by the partners.
Goodwill Calculation methods
Three methods are discussed:
- Average Profit Method
- Super Profit Method
- Market Capitalization Method
Average Profit Method
Under this method, average profit is calculated based on past few years' profits. Precautions must be taken regarding any abnormal items of profit or loss that may affect future profit. Average profit is based on the simple average method.
π Solved Problem No 1:
| Year | Profit (Rs.) |
|---|---|
| 1st | 20,000 |
| 2nd | 40,000 |
| 3rd | 50,000 |
| 4th | 70,000 |
| Total | 180,000 |
Goodwill is equal to three years' purchase of the last four years' average profits.
Calculation:
- Average profit = 180,000 / 4 = Rs. 45,000
- Goodwill = 45,000 Γ 3 = Rs. 135,000
Super Profit Method
Super Profit is the excess of actual profit (average profit) over the normal profit of an entity. A business may possess advantages enabling it to earn extra profits above what would be earned if capital was invested elsewhere with similar risks. These extra profits, called super profits, can be valued, and goodwill is the value of a few years' purchase of super profit.
Steps for calculating goodwill under Super Profit Method:
- Calculate Capital of the firm
- Calculate Normal Profit by multiplying firm's capital with normal rate of return
- Calculate Average Profit of the firm
- Calculate Super Profit = Average Profit - Normal Profit
- Multiply Super Profit by the number of years' purchase
- The product is Goodwill
π Definition β Super Profit: The excess of average profit over normal profit of a business entity.
π Formula: Goodwill = Super Profit Γ Number of Years' Purchase Where: Super Profit = Average Profit - Normal Profit And: Normal Profit = Capital Γ Normal Rate of Return
π Example:
- Capital = Rs. 200,000
- Normal rate of return = 18%
- Normal profit = 200,000 Γ 18% = Rs. 36,000
- Average profit = Rs. 45,000
- Super profit = 45,000 - 36,000 = Rs. 9,000
- Goodwill = 9,000 Γ 3 = Rs. 27,000
π‘ Why this matters: The Super Profit Method recognizes that goodwill represents the ability to earn above-average returns, making it a more refined approach than simple average profit.
Market Capitalization Method
Under this method, the value of the firm is first determined based on the market capitalization rate. Goodwill is then derived by subtracting the book value of net assets (owners' equity/capital) from this estimated market value.
π Formula: Firm Value = (Average Profit Γ 100) / Market Rate of Return Goodwill = Firm Value - Book Value of Net Assets
π Example:
- Average profit = Rs. 45,000
- Market rate of return = 18%
- Capital (net assets) = Rs. 200,000
Calculation:
- Firm Value = 45,000 / 18 Γ 100 = Rs. 250,000
- Goodwill = 250,000 - 200,000 = Rs. 50,000
Accounting treatment of goodwill
Since goodwill belongs to the old partners, adjustments must be made to their Capital accounts upon admission of a new partner so the incoming partner does not take a share of goodwill without payment. The amount paid by the incoming partner for goodwill is called premium for goodwill.
Goodwill Raised (Scenario 1)
When the incoming partner cannot bring cash as premium for goodwill, goodwill is raised in the books at its full value. The Goodwill account is debited, and the old partners' capital accounts are credited in their old profit-sharing ratio. This artificially inflates the old partners' capital accounts, ensuring they receive their share of goodwill if the business were sold.
Journal Entry:
Goodwill A/c 135,000
A's Capital A/c 81,000
B's Capital A/c 54,000
Working:
- A's share = 135,000 Γ 3/5 = 81,000
- B's share = 135,000 Γ 2/5 = 54,000
Important Notes:
- If goodwill already appears in the Balance Sheet equal to the full value, no entry is required.
- If existing goodwill is less than the calculated full value, raise goodwill for the balance amount only.
- If existing goodwill is more than the calculated full value, write off the excess:
Old partners' capital A/c Dr
Goodwill A/c Cr
Goodwill Raised & Written Off (Scenario 2)
When the incoming partner cannot bring cash for goodwill but no goodwill is to appear in the books, goodwill is first raised and then immediately written off. This is because goodwill value constantly changes and partners may not want a goodwill account in the books.
Journal Entry (Goodwill raised):
Goodwill A/c 135,000
A's Capital A/c 81,000
B's Capital A/c 54,000
Journal Entry (Goodwill written off):
A's Capital A/c 67,500
B's Capital A/c 45,000
C's Capital A/c 22,500
Goodwill A/c 135,000
Analysis of partners' benefits:
- A's benefit: Old ratio credit 81,000 - New ratio debit 67,500 = Rs. 13,500
- B's benefit: Old ratio credit 54,000 - New ratio debit 45,000 = Rs. 9,000
- Total benefit = 13,500 + 9,000 = Rs. 22,500
- C's share of goodwill = 135,000 Γ 1/6 = Rs. 22,500
Goodwill Brought in Cash (Scenario 3)
When the incoming partner brings the required premium for goodwill in cash and the money remains in the business, the premium is shared by old partners in their sacrificing ratio. The sacrificing ratio is calculated by deducting the new ratio from the old ratio for each partner. When the profit-sharing ratio between old partners does not change, the old ratio is their sacrificing ratio.
Journal Entries:
Bank A/c 22,500
C's Premium for Goodwill A/c 22,500
(Goodwill brought in cash)
C's Premium for Goodwill A/c 22,500
A's Capital A/c 13,500
B's Capital A/c 9,000
(Distribution of goodwill in sacrificing ratio)
Working:
- A's share = 22,500 Γ 3/5 = 13,500
- B's share = 22,500 Γ 2/5 = 9,000
π Definition β Premium for Goodwill: The amount paid by an incoming partner for their share of goodwill.
π Definition β Sacrificing Ratio: The ratio in which old partners give up their share of profits in favor of the new partner, calculated as Old Ratio - New Ratio.
β Key Takeaways
The three methods of goodwill valuation serve different purposes: Average Profit Method is simplest but ignores normal returns; Super Profit Method is more precise as it only values excess earnings above normal; and Market Capitalization Method values the entire firm based on market returns. When accounting for goodwill upon admission, three scenarios exist based on whether the incoming partner pays cash and whether goodwill should remain in the books. The sacrificing ratio is critical when cash is brought in, while the old ratio is used when no cash changes hands. Understanding the difference between raising goodwill, writing it off, and distributing cash premium is essential for correctly adjusting partners' capital accounts.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
-
Under the Super Profit Method, if a firm's capital is Rs. 500,000, normal rate of return is 15%, average profit is Rs. 100,000, and goodwill is valued at 4 years' purchase of super profit, what is the value of goodwill?
-
When the incoming partner brings premium for goodwill in cash, in which ratio should this premium be distributed among the old partners?
-
If existing goodwill in the Balance Sheet is Rs. 50,000 but the calculated full value of goodwill is Rs. 80,000, what entry should be passed when raising goodwill?
-
What is the difference between "Goodwill Raised" and "Goodwill Raised & Written Off" scenarios in terms of final balance sheet presentation?
-
In the Market Capitalization Method, if average profit is Rs. 60,000, market rate of return is 20%, and net assets are Rs. 250,000, what is the goodwill amount?
π Lecture 20 β Partnership Accounts (Cont.)
π Overview: This lecture addresses advanced partnership accounting scenarios, including the admission of a new partner where goodwill is raised and then immediately written off, and the distribution of profits when a new partner is admitted mid-year with salary entitlements. It also introduces the accounting procedures for the retirement of a partner, outlining the key steps from goodwill calculation to final settlement.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers four main areas. First, it details the journal entries and account preparation for admitting a new partner, Amir, including raising goodwill and revaluing assets. Second, it demonstrates the preparation of a post-admission balance sheet. Third, it solves a complex profit distribution problem involving two partners admitting a third partner mid-year, with different profit-sharing ratios and partner salaries. Finally, it introduces the step-by-step process for the retirement of a partner, including transferring the retiring partner's capital to a loan account and making a part payment.
π Lecture Summary
Goodwill Brought in Cash & Withdrawn (Scenario-4)
This section briefly reviews the journal entries for a scenario where a new partner brings in cash for their premium on goodwill, which is then immediately withdrawn by the old partners. The example shows a total goodwill premium of Rs. 22,500 being distributed to A (Rs. 13,500) and B (Rs. 9,000) in their sacrifice ratio, and then the same amounts are debited from their capital accounts and credited to the bank account.
π Definition β Premium for Goodwill: The amount paid by a new partner to old partners for their share of the firm's existing goodwill. It is typically credited to the old partners' capital accounts in their sacrificing ratio.
Solved Question: Admission of Partner (Laiquee, Imran, Ishtiaq, and Amir)
This major section solves a complete admission problem. Laiquee, Imran, and Ishtiaq (profit ratio 2:5:3) admit Amir, who brings Rs. 4,000 cash for capital. Goodwill is valued at Rs. 10,000 but is not to be brought into the business record, meaning it will be raised and then written off. The new profit-sharing ratio is 3:4:2:1. Assets are revalued: Building increases by Rs. 2,000, Machinery decreases by Rs. 500, and Stock decreases by Rs. 200.
The solution involves several steps:
- Record Amir's Capital Introduction: Rs. 4,000 cash is debited, and Amir's capital account is credited.
- Raise Goodwill: The full goodwill (Rs. 10,000) is raised as an asset, with the credit being distributed to the old partners' capital accounts in their old profit-sharing ratio (2:5:3). Laiquee gets Rs. 2,000, Imran Rs. 5,000, and Ishtiaq Rs. 3,000.
π‘ Why this matters: Since the goodwill is not to be permanently recorded, it is raised and then written off. The credit to old partners in the old ratio compensates them for the goodwill they are sacrificing.
- Record Asset Revaluation: The increase in Building (Rs. 2,000) is credited to the Revaluation account. The decreases in Machinery (Rs. 500) and Stock (Rs. 200) are debited to the Revaluation account. The net gain on revaluation is Rs. 1,300 (2,000 - 500 - 200).
- Distribute Revaluation Gain: The net gain of Rs. 1,300 is transferred to the old partners' capital accounts in their old profit-sharing ratio (2:5:3). Laiquee gets Rs. 260, Imran Rs. 650, and Ishtiaq Rs. 390.
- Write off Goodwill: The goodwill account of Rs. 10,000 is now written off against all partners' capital accounts in the new profit-sharing ratio (3:4:2:1). The journal entry is: Partner's current/capital A/c (all partners) Dr. ... To Goodwill A/c. However, the lecture text shows a different approach where the goodwill is not explicitly written off as a separate journal entry in the solution provided, which appears to be a variation or omission. The post-admission balance sheet includes Goodwill as an asset.
π Formula β New Partner's Capital: New Partner's Capital A/c = Cash brought in by new partner
π Example: Amir introduces Rs. 4,000 cash. The journal entry is: Dr. Cash A/c Rs. 4,000; Cr. Amir's Capital A/c Rs. 4,000.
π Formula β Net Revaluation Gain/Loss: Total Increases in Assets - Total Decreases in Assets. This gain/loss is then distributed to old partners in their old profit-sharing ratio.
π Example: Building increase (Rs. 2,000) - Machinery decrease (Rs. 500) - Stock decrease (Rs. 200) = Net Gain of Rs. 1,300.
- Laiquee's share: Rs. 1,300 Γ 2/10 = Rs. 260
- Imran's share: Rs. 1,300 Γ 5/10 = Rs. 650
- Ishtiaq's share: Rs. 1,300 Γ 3/10 = Rs. 390
Income Statement & Solved Question: Profit Distribution with Mid-Year Partner Admission
This section shows how to distribute a net profit of Rs. 19,000 when partner C is admitted after six months. Partners A & B (ratio 3:2) exist for the first six months. For the next six months, C is admitted with a 1/5 share, and the new ratio becomes 2:2:1. Partner A has an annual salary of Rs. 2,800, and Partner C has an annual salary of Rs. 2,400. Sales are Rs. 160,000 total (Rs. 96,000 in first 6 months, Rs. 64,000 in next 6 months).
The solution first allocates expenses (Cost of Goods Sold, Administrative, Selling & Distribution) between the two six-month periods based on sales proportion.
- First Six Months: Gross profit is Rs. 24,000 (40,000 Γ 96/160). Net profit is Rs. 12,900 (24,000 - 7,500 - 3,600).
- Next Six Months: Gross profit is Rs. 16,000 (40,000 Γ 64/160). Net profit is Rs. 6,100 (16,000 - 7,500 - 2,400).
Profit is then distributed for each period after deducting the partners' salaries.
- First Six Months (A & B only): Net profit Rs. 12,900. A's salary (half year) = Rs. 1,400. Profit share: Rs. 11,500. A gets Rs. 6,900 (3/5), B gets Rs. 4,600 (2/5). Total for A: Rs. 1,400 + 6,900 = Rs. 8,300. Total for B: Rs. 4,600.
- Next Six Months (A, B & C): Net profit Rs. 6,100. A's salary = Rs. 1,400; C's salary = Rs. 1,200. Total salaries = Rs. 2,600. Profit share: Rs. 3,500. A gets Rs. 1,400 (2/5), B gets Rs. 1,400 (2/5), C gets Rs. 700 (1/5). Total for A: Rs. 1,400 + 1,400 = Rs. 2,800. Total for B: Rs. 1,400. Total for C: Rs. 1,200 + 700 = Rs. 1,900.
π Formula β Gross Profit Allocation by Sales: (Total Gross Profit Γ Period Sales) / Total Sales
π Formula β New Profit Distribution: After deducting all salaries, the remaining profit is distributed according to the new profit-sharing ratio.
Retirement of Partner
This final section outlines the seven key steps to account for a partner's retirement.
- Calculation of goodwill
- Revaluation of goodwill/raise the goodwill
- Revaluation of net assets
- Preparation of partner's capital account
- Transfer of retiring partnerβs capital account into his loan account
- Make part payment or full payment of his loan account
- Prepare post-retirement balance sheet
The lecture provides an example of retiring Laiquee from the previous problem. His capital account balance is Rs. 5,260. This is first transferred to a loan account: Dr. Laiquee's Capital A/c Rs. 5,260; Cr. Laiquee's Loan A/c Rs. 5,260. Then, a part payment of Rs. 2,000 is made: Dr. Laiquee's Loan A/c Rs. 2,000; Cr. Cash A/c Rs. 2,000.
β Key Takeaways
When admitting a new partner, remember to first raise goodwill at its full value, crediting the old partners in their old profit-sharing ratio. Then, write off that same goodwill against all partners (including the new one) in the new profit-sharing ratio. For profit distribution with mid-year partner admissions, expenses and revenues must be allocated to each period proportionally, and partner salaries are calculated for the time they serve. The retirement of a partner requires calculating and settling their final claim, which is often done by transferring their capital balance to a loan account and making payments against it.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- In the admission problem, why was the goodwill of Rs. 10,000 distributed to old partners in the old ratio (2:5:3)?
- What is the journal entry to transfer a net loss on revaluation of assets to the partners' capital accounts?
- In the profit distribution problem, how is a partner's salary calculated when they are admitted mid-year?
- What is the purpose of transferring a retiring partner's capital account to a loan account?
- If a retiring partner is owed Rs. 10,000 and the firm pays them Rs. 3,000 in cash immediately, what would be the journal entry?