π Lecture 11 β BRANCH ACCOUNTING SYSTEM
π Overview: This lecture introduces the branch accounting system, focusing on domestic and foreign branches and their classification as dependent or independent. It provides a detailed explanation of accounting methods for retail dependent branches, particularly the debtor system, complete with journal entries, ledger formats, and solved examples to illustrate profit calculation.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by classifying branches into domestic and foreign, and further into dependent and independent categories. It then details the characteristics of independent and dependent branches, followed by an in-depth look at the three methods for accounting for retail dependent branches: the debtor system, the income statement system, and the stock and debtor system. The primary focus is on the debtor system, including its suitability, the format of the Branch Account in the head office books, and the specific journal entries required. The lecture concludes with several solved questions demonstrating the application of the debtor system.
π Lecture Summary
Classification
Branches are classified as Domestic branch or Foreign branch. They are further categorized as Dependent or Independent. Dependent branches include Retail sale branch and Wholesale branch. The accounting methods for a dependent branch include the Debtors system, the Income statement system / Final account system, and the Stock & Debtors system.
Independent Branch
An Independent Branch is a type of branch which maintains its own set of books. The method of accounting is the double entry book keeping. The branch manager of such a branch is given certain powers for decision making regarding procurement, selling, advertising, staffing, pricing, and even for purchasing of fixed assets. These branches are taken as an investment centre.
Dependent Branch
A Dependent Branch is a type of branch which does not maintain its own set of books. All records are maintained by the head office, which is concerned with the branch profits only. The branch manager of such a branch is not given decision making powers; the manager acts according to the instruction and policies directed by the head office.
Accounting system for Retail Dependent Branch
There are three methods to calculate profits of a retail dependent branch: Debtor system, Income statement system, and Stock and debtor system. The selection of method depends upon the nature of operations, size, and level of complexity of the transaction.
Debtor System
The Debtor System of accounting is suitable for small sized branches. In this system, a Branch a/c is opened for each of the branches in the main ledger of head office. Each and every transaction that is made between the head office and its branches is entered into the specific branch account. The branch accounts are maintained in such a way that these will give the amount of profits or losses of the respective branches.
The format of the Branch Account in the Books of Head Office shows the following key features:
- At the beginning of the year, the Branch a/c is debited with the opening balances of assets and credited with the opening balances of branch liabilities, resulting in an opening capital balance on the debit side.
- At the end of the year, the Branch a/c is credited with the closing balances of assets and debited with the closing balances of branch liabilities, resulting in a closing capital balance on the credit side.
- During the year, goods sent to the branch and cash sent for any purpose are debited to the Branch a/c (considered fresh capital).
- During the year, goods returned and cash received from the branch are credited to the Branch a/c (considered drawings by the head office).
π‘ Why this matters: Applying the rules of single entry accounting to this Branch a/c allows the head office to calculate the net profit or loss of the branch.
Accounting Entries in the Books of Head Office
The following journal entries are made in the head office books:
- For opening balances of assets at the branch: Debit Branch a/c, Credit Branch assets a/c (individual accounts)
- For opening balances of liabilities at the branch: Debit Branch liabilities a/c (individual accounts), Credit Branch a/c
- For goods sent to the branch: Debit Branch a/c, Credit Goods sent to branch a/c
- For return of goods by the branch: Debit Goods sent to branch a/c, Credit Branch a/c
- For remittance of cash or cheque to the branch: Debit Branch a/c, Credit Cash/Bank a/c
- For cash or cheque received from the branch: Debit Cash/Bank a/c, Credit Branch a/c
- For closing balances of assets at the branch: Debit Branch asset a/c (individual accounts), Credit Branch a/c
- For closing balances of liabilities at the branch: Debit Branch a/c, Credit Branch liabilities a/c (individual accounts)
- For closing goods sent to branch account: Debit Goods sent to branch a/c, Credit Purchases a/c
- For closing branch account into the profit and loss account:
- In case of profit: Debit Branch a/c, Credit Profit & loss a/c
- In case of loss: Debit Profit & loss a/c, Credit Branch a/c
Solved Questions
Example 1: From the given information for Sialkot Branch, a Branch a/c is prepared. This includes the treatment of opening and closing balances of stock, debtors, and petty cash, along with cash sent to the branch for salaries, rent & taxes, and petty cash, as well as cash sales and collections from debtors. The balancing figure of the account is the branch profit of 90,750 Rs.
Example 2: For Excellent Garments' Lahore Branch, a Branch a/c is prepared. In this case, the opening debtors figure was unknown and calculated from the debtors account. The branch profit was 8,360 Rs.
Example 3: For a dependent branch, a Branch a/c is prepared where the closing stock is not given directly but must be calculated using the markup percentage. The branch sells at cost plus 20%, so the cost of sales is calculated from the sales figure, and the closing stock is derived from the cost of goods available for sale. The branch profit was 6,000 Rs.
π Definition β Debtor System: A branch accounting method suitable for small branches where a single Branch Account in the head office ledger tracks all transactions and determines branch profit or loss.
π Formula β Cost of Sales (at cost): Sales (at selling price) x (100 / (100 + markup%)) β Used to find the cost of goods sold when sales are made at a markup on cost.
π Example: In the third solved question, sales are 120,000 Rs at cost plus 20%. The cost of sales is 120,000 x 100/120 = 100,000 Rs. This cost of sales is used in the calculation of closing stock: Opening Stock (30,000) + Goods Sent (90,000) - Cost of Sales (100,000) = Closing Stock (20,000 Rs).
β Key Takeaways
The lecture distinguishes between independent and dependent branches, with dependent branches being the main focus as they do not maintain their own books. For retail dependent branches, the debtor system is a key method where all transactions are recorded in a single Branch Account in the head office's books to determine profit or loss. The structure of this Branch Account requires entering opening and closing asset and liability balances to calculate the net capital introduced. It is crucial to know the specific journal entries for all inter-branch transactions, including goods sent, cash remitted, and cash received, to correctly prepare the account. When the closing stock is not provided, it must be calculated using the branch's known sales margin or markup percentage.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two main classifications of branches, and how are dependent branches further categorized?
- What is the primary difference between an independent branch and a dependent branch regarding record-keeping?
- Which of the three accounting methods for a retail dependent branch is most suitable for a small-sized branch?
- In the debtor system, how are opening balances of assets and liabilities recorded in the Branch Account?
- How would you calculate the closing stock for a branch if only the sales figure and a markup of 25% on cost were known?
π Lecture 12 β Branch Accounting System (Cont.)
π Overview: This lecture continues the study of branch accounting, focusing on the Income Statement System for calculating branch profits. It also introduces the concept of Pro-forma Invoice Price, explaining why head offices send goods at a price above cost and how to record such transactions. Understanding these systems is crucial for preparing accurate branch financial statements and maintaining internal control.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture begins with the Income Statement System, a method used to prepare a memorandum income statement for a branch to calculate net profit or loss, particularly useful for single-entry records. It provides the complete set of accounting entries required in the head office books for this system, including entries for goods sent at cost, expenses, remittances, and closing accounts. A solved example demonstrates preparing a branch profit and loss account. The lecture then shifts to Pro-forma Invoice Price, explaining its purpose (e.g., keeping profit margins secret), the concept of loading, and the modified accounting entries required when goods are sent at invoice price rather than cost. A second solved example illustrates the preparation of a branch account under this system.
π Lecture Summary
Income Statement System
The head office may prepare an Income Statement to find out the profits of a branch. This statement is merely a memorandum; its purpose is to have full information on all transactions ignored in the Debtor System. Preparing this statement uses skills learned in converting single-entry accounting to double-entry. In the Income Statement, incomes and expenses are measured on the accrual basis, and profits are determined by the matching concept. The cost of goods sold is determined considering that goods sent to the branch are equivalent to the branchβs purchases and must be included at cost. Opening and closing stocks cannot be valued above their cost.
π Definition β Memorandum Income Statement: A non-formal income statement prepared internally to track branch profitability, not part of the official double-entry system.
π‘ Why this matters: This system allows the head office to calculate branch profit accurately when the branch only keeps a sales journal and debtors ledger, providing better information for management and performance evaluation than the simpler Debtor System.
Accounting Entries in the Books of Head Office (Income Statement System)
The following journal entries are made in the head office books under the Income Statement System for a branch receiving goods at cost:
- For opening balances of assets at the branch:
- Debit
Branch a/c - Credit
Branch assets a/c (individual accounts)
- Debit
- For opening balances of liabilities at the branch:
- Debit
Branch liabilities a/c (individual accounts) - Credit
Branch a/c
- Debit
- For goods sent to the branch:
- Debit
Branch a/c - Credit
Goods sent to branch a/c
- Debit
- For return of goods by the branch:
- Debit
Goods sent to branch a/c - Credit
Branch a/c
- Debit
- For reversal of loading on (net) goods sent to branch: (Note: This would be at cost, so likely zero loading)
- Debit
Goods sent to branch a/c - Credit
Branch a/c
- Debit
- For remittance of cash or cheque to the branch for expenses:
- Debit
Branch a/c - Credit
Cash/Bank a/c
- Debit
- For cash or cheque received from the branch:
- Debit
Cash/Bank a/c - Credit
Branch a/c
- Debit
- For closing balances of assets at the branch:
- Debit
Branch asset a/c (individual accounts) - Credit
Branch a/c
- Debit
- For closing balances of liabilities at the branch:
- Debit
Branch a/c - Credit
Branch liabilities a/c (individual accounts)
- Debit
- For closing Goods Sent to Branch account:
- Debit
Goods sent to branch a/c - Credit
Purchases a/c
- Debit
- For closing Branch Account into the Profit and Loss Account:
- In case of profit: Debit
Branch a/c, CreditProfit & loss a/c - In case of loss: Debit
Profit & loss a/c, CreditBranch a/c
- In case of profit: Debit
- For abnormal loss (always at cost):
- Debit
Abnormal loss a/c (at cost) - Credit
Branch a/c - Then for insurance claim:
- Debit
Insurance claim a/c (claim admitted) - Debit
Profit & loss a/c (balance if not admitted) - Credit
Abnormal loss a/c (cost of the abnormal loss)
- Debit
- Debit
Note: No accounting entry is required for normal losses.
Solved Questions (Income Statement System)
Excellent Garments of Multan has a branch at Lahore. Goods are supplied to the branch at cost. From the following information, prepare a profit and loss account using the income statement system.
- Opening Stock: Rs. 24,000
- Closing Stock: Rs. 18,000
- Goods received from HO: Rs. 33,600
- Credit Sales: Rs. 41,000
- Cash Sales: Rs. 17,500
- Closing Debtors: Rs. 9,150
- Bad Debt: Rs. 140
- Expenses paid by Head office: Rs. 10,400
- Cash received from Debtors: Rs. 37,900
- Pilferage of goods by employees (Normal Loss): Rs. 2,000
Solution:
Income Statement of Branch (Excellent Garments) In the books of Head Office (Multan)
| Rs. | Rs. | |
|---|---|---|
| Sales | ||
| Cash sales | 17,500 | |
| Credit sales | 41,000 | 58,500 |
| Less: Cost of Goods Sold: | ||
| Opening Stock | 24,000 | |
| Add: Received From H.O. | 33,600 | |
| Less: Closing Stock | (18,000) | (39,600) |
| Gross Profit | 18,900 | |
| Less: Expenses | ||
| Expenses | 10,400 | |
| Bad debts | 140 | (10,540) |
| Net Profit | 8,360 |
Note: Pilferage of Rs. 2,000 is treated as normal loss; therefore, it is not deducted separately.
Pro-forma Invoice Price
Head office may send goods to a branch either at cost or at pro-forma invoice price. Pro-forma invoice price is higher than the cost price. Adding a reasonable profit to the cost makes the price equal to the pro-forma invoice price. The difference between cost and pro-forma invoice price is known as loading. The difference between cost and the selling price is the real profit.
π Definition β Pro-forma Invoice Price: The price at which goods are charged to the branch by the head office, typically set at cost plus a markup (profit margin).
π Definition β Loading: The difference between the pro-forma invoice price and the cost price of goods sent to a branch.
Head office sends goods at pro-forma invoice price to:
- Keep its profit margin secret from branch managers.
- Dictate pricing policy to its branches.
- Save work at the branch because prices are already decided.
Important: The method of preparing a Branch Account when goods are sent at pro-forma invoice price is the same as before, with one key exception: accounting entries for goods sent to and returned from the branch are recorded at the pro-forma invoice price. A reverse adjustment is then required for the amount of loading. Also remember that accounting entries for opening and closing stocks are recorded at cost price, not at the pro-forma invoice price.
π‘ Why this matters: The rationale for recording goods sent at invoice price but stocks at cost is that the source document for goods sent is the βpro-forma invoice,β so its price cannot be ignored. However, stock valuation is not reported via a pro-forma invoice, so it is simpler to account for stocks at cost.
Accounting Entries in the Books of Head Office (Pro-forma Invoice Price)
The accounting entries for goods sent at pro-forma invoice price are modified for entries 3, 4, and 5, as shown below. All other entries (1, 2, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12) remain the same as in the Income Statement System.
- For opening balances of assets at the branch.
- For opening balances of liabilities at the branch.
- For goods sent to the branch (at pro-forma invoice price):
- Debit
Branch a/c - Credit
Goods sent to branch a/c
- Debit
- For return of goods by the branch (at pro-forma invoice price):
- Debit
Goods sent to branch a/c - Credit
Branch a/c
- Debit
- For reversal of loading on (net) goods sent to branch (with the amount of loading):
- Debit
Goods sent to branch a/c - Credit
Branch a/c
- Debit
Solved Questions (Pro-forma Invoice Price)
Excellent Garments of Multan has a branch at Lahore. Goods are supplied to the branch at cost. From the following information, prepare a Branch Account in the books of the head office. Goods are sent to branch at pro-forma invoice price which is cost plus 20%.
(Note: The specific financial data for this example was not fully provided in the text, only the instruction to "prepare a Branch Account".)
β Key Takeaways
- The Income Statement System is used to calculate branch profit by preparing a separate memorandum income statement, using accrual and matching concepts, and requires a specific set of journal entries in the head office books.
- When goods are sent at cost, the branchβs profit or loss is accurately reflected in a simple income statement, and normal losses (like pilferage) require no accounting entry.
- Pro-forma Invoice Price is cost plus a markup (called loading) and is used to keep the head officeβs profit margin secret from the branch manager and to control pricing.
- When goods are sent at pro-forma invoice price, accounting entries for goods sent and returned are recorded at that invoice price, but opening and closing stock are always recorded at cost.
- The key adjustment for loading is made by reversing it out of the Goods Sent to Branch account (Debit Goods Sent to Branch, Credit Branch Account) to ensure the branch account ultimately reflects cost-based figures.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is a memorandum income statement in branch accounting, and why is it prepared?
- What is the accounting entry for goods sent to branch when using the Income Statement System?
- What is the difference between the pro-forma invoice price and the selling price?
- Name two reasons why a head office might send goods to a branch at a pro-forma invoice price instead of cost.
- When goods are sent at pro-forma invoice price, at what value should the closing stock be recorded in the Branch Account?
π Lecture 13 β Branch Accounting System (Cont.)
π Overview: This lecture continues the study of branch accounting, focusing on the Stock and Debtors System used for large branches. It demonstrates how to prepare a branch account in the head office books using pro-forma invoice prices, including calculations for loading, and introduces the specific ledger accounts and journal entries required under this system for enhanced internal control.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with solved examples of a branch account prepared under the basic debtor system, showing calculations for opening/closing stock at cost, debtors, and profit. It then introduces the Stock and Debtors System, explaining its purpose, the six key ledger accounts (Branch Stock, Debtors, Expenses, Adjustment, Goods Sent to Branch, and Stock Reserve), and concludes with a comprehensive table of 16 journal entries and the pro-forma ledger accounts for the head office.
π Lecture Summary
Solved Questions
The lecture starts with two worked examples applying the Debtors System. These demonstrate how to compute missing figures like opening debtors and branch profit when transactions are recorded at pro-forma invoice price.
Example 1: Given opening stock (pro-forma) Rs. 28,800, closing stock (pro-forma) Rs. 21,600, goods received (pro-forma) Rs. 40,320, cash sales Rs. 17,500, credit sales Rs. 41,000, cash from debtors Rs. 37,900, bad debts Rs. 140, and expenses paid by HO Rs. 10,400. The solution calculates:
- Opening debtors (balancing figure) = Rs. 6,200.
- Cost of stock: Opening = 28,800 x 100/120 = Rs. 24,000. Closing = 21,600 x 100/120 = Rs. 18,000. (Loading = 20% on cost).
- Loading on goods sent = 40,320 x 20/120 = Rs. 6,720.
- Branch Profit = Rs. 8,360 (balancing figure in branch account).
π Definition β Loading: The difference between the pro-forma invoice price (e.g., 120%) and the cost price (e.g., 100%), expressed as a percentage of cost. In examples, it is 20% of cost.
π Formula: Cost = Pro-forma Invoice Price Γ (100 / 120) β Converts invoice price to cost price (assuming 20% loading on cost).
Example 2: Opening stock (invoice) Rs. 3,000, goods sent Rs. 24,000, returns to HO Rs. 150, remittance Rs. 25,000, expenses Rs. 4,500, closing stock (invoice) Rs. 8,000. (Assume loading = 25% on cost).
- Cost calculations: Opening stock = 3,000 / 125 x 100 = Rs. 2,400. Closing stock = 8,000 / 125 x 100 = Rs. 6,400.
- Net goods sent (invoice) = 24,000 β 150 = Rs. 23,850.
- Loading on net goods sent = 23,850 / 125 x 25 = Rs. 4,770.
- Branch Profit = Rs. 5,420 (balancing figure). π‘ Why this matters: The same logic of calculating cost and loading is foundational for the Stock and Debtors System that follows.
Accounting Entries (For abnormal loss)
The lecture illustrates treatment for an abnormal loss (e.g., fire with insurance claim).
- Entry 1:
Abnormal Loss A/c Dr. 4,000βBranch A/c Cr. 4,000(to remove loss from branch). - Entry 2:
Insurance Claim A/c Dr. 3,500βAbnormal Loss A/c Cr. 3,500(recording expected recovery). - Entry 3:
Profit & Loss A/c Dr. 500βAbnormal Loss A/c Cr. 500(writing off unrecoverable portion).
BRANCH ACCOUNTING - STOCK AND DEBTOR SYSTEM
This system is used when goods are sent at pro-forma invoice price and the branch is large. It provides greater control by maintaining a set of centralized accounts.
Branch Stock Account
Maintained at selling price or pro-forma invoice price. It records all stock movements (goods sent, sales, returns, shortages, surpluses) at these prices, unlike traditional cost-based accounting.
Branch Debtors Account
Maintained in the traditional manner to track all transactions with credit customers (sales, receipts, returns, bad debts, discounts). It is at selling price.
Branch Expense Account
A compilation account for all branch expenses (cash-based and receivable-based like bad debts and discounts). It is closed into the Branch Adjustment Account.
Branch Adjustment Account
Replaces the branch income statement. Expenses, losses, and the margin (surplus from selling price vs. invoice price, and loading from invoice price vs. cost) are closed here. It determines the net profit or loss for the branch.
π Definition β Surplus: The difference between the selling price and the pro-forma invoice price. This is a gain for the branch (e.g., selling above invoice price). π Definition β Loading (in this context): The difference between the pro-forma invoice price and the cost price. This is the margin held by the head office.
Goods Sent to Branch Account
A supporting account recording goods sent to and returned from the branch at pro-forma invoice price. After adjusting for loading, this account is closed into the Purchases Account of the head office.
Branch Stock Reserve Account
A contra account to the Branch Stock Account. It holds the loading on the opening and closing stock balances. It is opened at the start with loading on opening stock and closed/created at period-end with loading on closing stock.
ACCOUNTING ENTRIES IN THE BOOKS OF HEAD OFFICE
The lecture lists 16 Journal Entries under the Stock and Debtors System (titles are extracted from the table):
- For Goods Sent to Branch (at Invoice) β Dr. Branch Stock A/c, Cr. Goods Sent to Branch A/c.
- For Goods Sold At Branch On Credit (at Selling Price) β Dr. Branch Debtors A/c, Cr. Branch Stock A/c.
- For Goods Sold At Branch For Cash (at Selling Price) β Dr. Branch Cash A/c, Cr. Branch Stock A/c.
- For Cash Received From Branch Debtors β Dr. Branch Cash A/c, Cr. Branch Debtors A/c.
- For Goods Returned by debtors β Dr. Branch Stock A/c, Cr. Branch Debtors A/c.
- For Goods Returned by Branch To Head Office (at Invoice) β Dr. Goods Sent to Branch A/c, Cr. Branch Stock A/c.
- For Cash Sent By Head Office to Branch For Expenses β Dr. Branch Expenses A/c, Cr. Cash A/c.
- For Bad Debts/ discount Allowed To Branch Debtors β Dr. Branch expense A/c, Cr. Branch Debtors A/c.
- For Shortage/ Shrinkage in Branch Stock β Dr. Branch Adjustment A/c, Cr. Branch Stock A/c.
- For Surplus In Branch Stock β Dr. Branch Stock A/c, Cr. Branch Adjustment A/c.
- For Closing Branch Expenses Account Into Branch Adjustment Account β Dr. Branch Adjustment A/c, Cr. Branch Expenses A/c.
- For Transfer of Opening Stock Reserve (Loading) Into The Branch Adjustment Account β Dr. Branch Stock Reserve A/c, Cr. Branch Adjustment A/c.
- For Creating Stock Reserve on Closing Balance of Stock (Loading on Closing Stock) β Dr. Branch Adjustment A/c, Cr. Branch Stock Reserve A/c.
- For Loading on Net Amount of Goods Sent to Branch β Dr. Goods Sent to Branch A/c, Cr. Branch Adjustment A/c.
- For Closing Goods Sent To Branch Account Into Purchase Account β Dr. Goods Sent To Branch A/c, Cr. Purchases A/c.
- For Closing the Branch Adjustment Account Into Profit & Loss Account β Dr. Branch Adjustment A/c, Cr. Profit & Loss A/c.
LEDGER ACCOUNTS IN THE MAIN LEDGER OF HEAD OFFICE
Pro-forma formats are provided for the Branch Stock Account (Dr: opening stock, goods sent, returns from debtors, surplus; Cr: credit sales, cash sales, returns to HO, shortage, closing stock) and the Goods Sent to Branch Account (Dr: returns and transfer to purchases; Cr: goods sent to branch and transfer to branch adjustment).
β Key Takeaways
A student must understand how to calculate cost from pro-forma invoice price using the loading percentage and how to isolate the loading on goods sent, opening stock, and closing stock. The core logic of the Stock and Debtors System is to maintain Branch Stock at selling/invoice price, which allows for the automatic detection of shortages and surpluses. You must memorize the sequence of the 16 journal entries, especially Journal 12 (transferring opening stock reserve to branch adjustment), Journal 13 (creating closing stock reserve), and Journal 14 (recording loading on net goods sent). Finally, the Branch Adjustment Account is the master account that determines branch profit after all expenses, losses, and the reversal/creation of stock reserves are passed through it.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- In the Stock and Debtors System, at what price is the Branch Stock Account maintained, and why?
- What is the difference between "Loading" and "Surplus" in the Branch Adjustment Account?
- What is the journal entry to record a shortage in branch stock at the end of the period?
- Under this system, what account finally receives the "Goods Sent to Branch Account" balance after all adjustments?
- Explain the purpose of Journal Entry 13: "Dr. Branch Adjustment, Cr. Branch Stock Reserve."
π Lecture 14 β Branch Accounting - Stock and Debtor System (Cont.)
π Overview: This lecture continues the study of the Stock and Debtor System for branch accounting, focusing on completing the accounting cycle through the Branch Adjustment Account. It presents two fully solved numerical problems that demonstrate how to record credit sales, goods returned, stock surplus/shortage, and loading calculations in the Head Office books.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the complete journal entry flow for the Stock and Debtor System, including the Branch Stock Account, Goods Sent to Branch Account, Branch Debtors Account, Branch Expense Account, and the Branch Adjustment Account. It also includes the Stock Reserve Account for loading on opening and closing stock, and the transfer of net profit or loss to the General Profit & Loss Account. Two solved questions are presented showing the practical application of these accounts for both a new branch and an existing branch.
π Lecture Summary
Branch Stock (Credit Sales) Jef(6) Branch Stock (Goods Sent) (At Invoice) Jef(1) Branch Adjustment (Loading) Jef(14) Purchases (Balancing Figure) Jef(15)
This section provides a series of journal entry references (Jef) for the key transactions in the Stock and Debtor System. Goods sent to the branch are recorded at invoice price. Credit sales are recorded by debiting Branch Debtors and crediting Branch Stock. The loading on goods sent is transferred from Goods Sent to Branch to Branch Adjustment. The balancing figure in the Goods Sent to Branch account represents the cost of goods, which is transferred to the Purchases account.
Branch Expense Account
This account records all expenses incurred by the branch. Cash expenses (Jef 7) are debited. Discount allowed and Bad debts (Jef 8) are also debited as they are expenses incurred through the Branch Debtors account. The total expenses are closed by crediting this account and debiting the Branch Adjustment Account (Jef 11).
Branch Debtors Account
This account tracks all credit customers of the branch. It starts with an Opening Balance Brought Forward. Credit sales from Branch Stock (Jef 2) are debited. Cash received from debtors (Jef 4) is credited, and Sales returns (Jef 5) are credited. Bad debts and Discount allowed (Jef 8) are credited to this account and debited to Branch Expense. The closing balance is carried forward.
Stock Reserve Account
This account is used to adjust for the loading (profit margin) included in the stock value. The opening stock reserve is brought forward at the start of the year. This opening balance is transferred to the Branch Adjustment account (Jef 12). At year-end, a closing stock reserve is created by debiting Branch Adjustment and crediting this account (Jef 13). The closing reserve is then carried forward to the next year.
π Definition β Stock Reserve: The amount of loading (unrealized profit) included in the value of closing stock. It is computed as: Closing Stock at Invoice Price Γ (Loading Percentage / 100). π Formula: Closing Stock Reserve = Closing Stock at Invoice Price Γ Loading Rate π‘ Why this matters: This reserve ensures that profit is only recognized on goods actually sold, not on unsold stock.
Branch Adjustment Account
This is the final account that determines the branch's profit or loss. It is debited with stock shortages (Jef 9) and the total branch expenses from the Branch Expense account (Jef 11). It is also debited with the closing stock reserve loading (Jef 13). On the credit side, it receives stock surpluses (Jef 10), the opening stock reserve loading (Jef 12), and the loading on goods sent from the Goods Sent to Branch Account (Jef 14). The balancing figure (Jef 16) is transferred to the Profit & Loss Account β if credit exceeds debit, it's profit; if debit exceeds credit, it's a loss.
Example: Solved Question β New Branch (Multan to Lahore)
On 1st January 2008, goods costing Rs. 132,000 were invoiced to the Lahore branch at selling price to give a 25% gross profit on selling price. Credit sales were Rs. 150,000. Goods invoiced at Rs. 2,000 were returned. Closing stock was Rs. 24,000 at selling price.
Step 1: Calculate Loading and Invoice Price
- Loading is 25% of Selling Price.
- Cost = 100% - 25% = 75% of Selling Price.
- If Cost = Rs. 132,000, then Invoice Price (100%) = 132,000 Γ (100/75) = Rs. 176,000.
Step 2: Calculate Loading on Goods Sent
- Loading = Invoice Price β Cost = 176,000 β 132,000 = Rs. 44,000.
- Note: The solution shows Rs. 43,500, which appears to be a rounding difference or a loading on net goods sent after returns.
Step 3: Prepare Accounts
Lahore Branch Stock Account
- Debit side: Goods Sent (Invoice Price) = Rs. 176,000.
- Credit side: Returns (Rs. 2,000), Credit Sales (Rs. 150,000), Closing Stock (Rs. 24,000).
Goods Sent to Lahore Branch Account
- Debit side: Returns (Rs. 2,000), Loading transferred to Branch Adjustment (Rs. 43,500), Purchases (Balancing Figure = Rs. 130,500).
- Credit side: Branch Stock Account (Rs. 176,000).
Lahore Branch Debtors Account
- Debit side: Credit Sales (Rs. 150,000).
- Credit side: Closing Balance (Rs. 150,000). (No cash received in this scenario).
Lahore Branch Adjustment Account
- Debit side: Stock Reserve (Closing Loading) (Rs. 6,000), Profit transferred to P&L (Rs. 37,500).
- Credit side: Goods Sent to Branch (Loading) (Rs. 43,500).
π Definition β Loading on Closing Stock: Stock Reserve = Closing Stock (Invoice Price) Γ 25% = 24,000 Γ 25% = Rs. 6,000. π Example: The Stock Reserve of Rs. 6,000 is the unrealized profit in the closing stock of Rs. 24,000.
Example: Solved Question β Existing Branch (Karachi to Lahore)
Ltd. has a branch in Lahore. Goods are invoiced at cost plus 33β %. The following data is given:
- Opening Branch Debtors: Rs. 6,000
- Opening Branch Stock (Invoice Price): Rs. 2,400
- Cash Sales: Rs. 3,000
- Credit Sales: Rs. 60,000
- Goods from H.O. (Invoice Price): Rs. 72,000
- Cash from Debtors: Rs. 57,600
- Discount Allowed: Rs. 1,400
- Bad Debts: Rs. 300
- Branch Expenses: Rs. 5,000
- Closing Branch Stock (Invoice Price): Rs. 12,000
Step 1: Calculate the Loading Rate
- Cost Plus 33β % means Invoice Price = Cost + (1/3) of Cost.
- Cost = 3/4 of Invoice Price = 75%.
- Loading = 1/4 of Invoice Price = 25%.
Step 2: Prepare the Branch Stock Account
- Debit: Opening Balance (Rs. 2,400), Goods Sent (Rs. 72,000).
- Credit: Cash Sales (Rs. 3,000), Branch Debtors (Credit Sales = Rs. 60,000), Closing Balance (Rs. 12,000).
- Surplus (Balancing Figure): Total Debits (74,400) β Credits (75,000) = Rs. 600 Surplus.
- Note: The surplus indicates a stock gain or an accounting error; it's credited to Branch Stock and debited to Branch Adjustment.
Step 3: Prepare the Branch Adjustment Account
- Debit Side: Discount Allowed (Rs. 1,400) + Bad Debts (Rs. 300) + Cash Expenses (Rs. 5,000) = Rs. 6,700.
- Debit Side: Closing Stock Reserve (12,000 Γ 25% = Rs. 3,000). Total Debits = Rs. 9,700.
- Credit Side: Opening Stock Reserve (2,400 Γ 25% = Rs. 600).
- Credit Side: Goods Sent to Branch (Loading on Goods Sent = 72,000 Γ 25% = Rs. 18,000).
- Credit Side: Branch Stock Surplus (Rs. 600). Total Credits = Rs. 19,200.
- Loss (Balancing Figure) = Total Debits (9,700) β Total Credits (19,200) = Rs. 500 Loss? Correction: Debits are Rs. 9,700 and Credits are Rs. 19,200. The difference is a Surplus/Profit of Rs. 9,500. Note: The solution shows a loss, but the arithmetic indicates a profit. This highlights the importance of careful checking.
Step 4: Key Calculations π Opening Stock Reserve: Rs. 2,400 Γ 25% = Rs. 600. π Closing Stock Reserve: Rs. 12,000 Γ 25% = Rs. 3,000. π Loading on Goods Sent: Rs. 72,000 Γ 25% = Rs. 18,000.
β Key Takeaways
The Stock and Debtor System uses the invoice price for all branch stock transactions, making the Branch Adjustment Account essential for extracting the true profit by isolating the loading. The Branch Stock Account tracks all stock movements at invoice price, and its balancing figure reveals either a surplus (creditable to adjustment) or a shortage (debitable to adjustment). The Stock Reserve on both opening and closing stock must be adjusted to eliminate unrealized profit from the branch's results. The net profit or loss is determined as the balancing figure of the Branch Adjustment Account and is transferred to the General Profit & Loss Account.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three main accounts prepared in the Head Office books under the Stock and Debtor System for a branch?
- If goods costing Rs. 90,000 are invoiced at a 25% profit on selling price, what is the invoice price and the loading amount?
- A branch has closing stock of Rs. 50,000 at invoice price, with a loading of 20%. What is the journal entry to record the closing stock reserve?
- In the Branch Adjustment Account, what are the typical debit and credit items?
- If the closing balance of Branch Debtors is Rs. 10,000 and credit sales during the year were Rs. 80,000, what was the cash received from debtors (assuming no discount or bad debts)?
π Lecture 15 β Branch Accounting (Cont.)
π Overview: This lecture continues the discussion on branch accounting, focusing on the wholesale branch model where the head office sells goods to branches at wholesale prices (cost plus a percentage of profit). The lecture explains how to account for unrealized profit on unsold stock and then transitions to the accounting for independent branches, covering reconciliation, adjustments, and incorporation.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with an example of branch debtors and a branch income statement showing a loss. It then explains the wholesale branch system where goods are invoiced at wholesale prices (cost plus a percentage), highlighting that the branch's profit is the difference between retail price and wholesale price, while the head office's real profit includes the wholesale markup. The key challenge is the unrealized profit in unsold branch stock, which requires a stock reserve adjustment. The lecture then introduces the accounting for independent branches, outlining the three main steps: reconciliation, adjustment, and incorporation.
π Lecture Summary
Branch Debtors Account & Branch Account
The lecture provides an example of a Branch Debtors Account and a Branch Account for a dependent branch that is treated as a cost center. The Branch Debtors Account shows opening debtors (Rs. 6,000), credit sales (Rs. 60,000 from Branch Stock A/c), cash received (Rs. 57,600), discounts (Rs. 1,400), bad debts (Rs. 300), and closing debtors (Rs. 6,700). The Branch Account summarizes all transactions: opening debtors (Rs. 6,000), opening stock at cost (Rs. 1,800), goods sent to branch at invoice price (Rs. 72,000), goods sent to branch loading (Rs. 15,000), and cash sent to branch (Rs. 15,000). On the credit side, it shows cash received (Rs. 60,600), goods returned (Rs. 0), and closing debtors (Rs. 6,700). The total debits and credits equal Rs. 94,800, but the branch shows a loss of Rs. 500.
The Branch Income Statement calculates the loss: Sales (Rs. 63,000) minus Cost of Goods Sold (Opening stock Rs. 1,800 + Goods received at cost Rs. 54,000 β Closing stock Rs. 9,000 = Rs. 46,800) gives a Gross Profit of Rs. 16,200. After deducting operating expenses (Cash expenses Rs. 15,000, Bad debts Rs. 300, Discount allowed Rs. 1,400 = Rs. 16,700), the Net Loss is Rs. 500, which is transferred to the head office Income Statement.
Whole Sale Branch
In some cases, the head office (especially manufacturing entities) sells goods to consumers through retail branches. Goods are sent to branches at wholesale prices (cost plus a percentage of profit). The branch sells these goods at retail prices which are higher than wholesale prices. The real profit earned by the branch is the difference between the retail selling price and the wholesale price. For example: cost price Rs. 100, wholesale price Rs. 160, retail price Rs. 180. The actual total profit is Rs. 180 β 100 = Rs. 80, but the branch's profit is only Rs. 180 β 160 = Rs. 20.
This system treats dependent branches as profit centers only. The real cost for the branch is the wholesale price. The main problem arises when unsold branch stock contains an element of profit (loading) that the head office has not yet realized. This unrealized profit must be reversed in the head office's books. π‘ Why this matters: Without this adjustment, the head office would overstate its profits because it has recognized a wholesale profit on goods that are still unsold at the branch.
The adjusting journal entry is:
Income Statement a/c Dr. (Wholesale price less cost price)
Stock Reserve a/c Cr.
In the balance sheet, the branch stock is shown at cost (after deducting the stock reserve).
Solved Question on Wholesale Branch
White Limited has a retail branch at Gujranwala. Goods are sold on 60% profit on cost. The wholesale price is cost plus 40%. Goods are invoiced from the Calcutta head office to the branch at wholesale price.
Given data:
| Particulars | Head Office (Rs.) | Branch (Rs.) |
|---|---|---|
| Stock on 1.1.2007 | 175,000 | - |
| Purchases | 1,050,000 | - |
| Goods sent (invoice price) | - | 378,000 |
| Expenses (Selling) | 56,000 | 7,000 |
| Sales | 1,071,000 | 350,000 |
| Stock on 31.12.2007 | 420,000 | 63,000 |
Solution: First, calculate the Gross Profit for the Head Office:
- Sales (including goods sent to branch): Rs. 1,071,000 + Rs. 378,000 = Rs. 1,449,000
- Cost of Goods Sold: Opening stock (Rs. 175,000) + Purchases (Rs. 1,050,000) β Closing Stock (Rs. 420,000) = Rs. 805,000
- Gross Profit: Rs. 1,449,000 β Rs. 805,000 = Rs. 644,000
- Less: Expenses: Rs. 56,000
- Less: Unrealized profit: Rs. 18,000
- Net Profit: Rs. 644,000 β 56,000 β 18,000 = Rs. 570,000
Next, calculate the Gross Profit for the Branch:
- Sales: Rs. 350,000
- Cost of Goods Sold: Goods received from H.O. (Rs. 378,000) β Closing stock (Rs. 63,000) = Rs. 315,000
- Gross Profit: Rs. 350,000 β Rs. 315,000 = Rs. 35,000
- Less: Expenses: Rs. 7,000
- Net Profit: Rs. 35,000 β 7,000 = Rs. 28,000
π Definition β Unrealized Profit: The profit element included in the wholesale invoice price of goods that remain unsold at the branch.
π Formula:
Unrealized profit = Branch closing stock x (Loading / (Cost + Loading))
Or
Unrealized profit = Branch closing stock x (Markup / Invoice Price)
In this case, the wholesale price is cost plus 40%, meaning for every Rs. 140 of wholesale price, the loading (profit) is Rs. 40.
Unrealized profit = 63,000 / 140 * 40 = Rs. 18,000
INDEPENDENT BRANCH
The lecture then transitions to the accounting for independent branches. There are three main steps involved:
- Reconciliation
- Adjustment
- Incorporation
Reconciliation
Reconciliation is the process of matching the balance of the Head Office Account in the books of the Branch with the balance of the Branch Account in the books of the Head Office.
Reasons of Difference: The two balances might differ due to:
- Cash in transit (cash sent by the branch but not yet received by the head office, or vice-versa)
- Goods in transit (goods sent by the head office but not yet received by the branch)
- Mistakes committed by either party
NOTE: Accounting entries for reconciliation will be passed in the books of whichever party needs to make the correction.
Accounting Entries for Reconciliation:
- Cash in transit:
Cash in transit A/c Dr.Branch A/corHead office A/c Cr.
- Goods in transit:
Goods in transit A/c Dr.Branch A/corHead office A/c Cr.
- Mistakes:
Account to be rectified Dr.Branch A/corHead office A/c Cr.- (Vice-versa for the correcting entry)
Adjustments in the Books of Both Parties
Certain information needs to be adjusted in the books of both the head office and the branch. These include:
- Allocation of head office expenses
- Depreciation on branch assets
- Inter branch transfers (goods or cash transferred from one branch to another)
Accounting Entries:
- Books of Head Office:
- Allocation of head office expense:
Branch A/c Dr.Specific Expense A/c Cr.
- Depreciation of branch assets:
Branch A/c Dr.Provision for depreciation A/c Cr.
- Inter branch transfers:
Receiving Branch A/c Dr.Transferring Branch A/c Cr.
- Allocation of head office expense:
- Books of Branch:
- Allocation of head office expense:
Specific Expense A/c Dr.Head office A/c Cr.
- Depreciation of branch assets:
Depreciation Expense A/c Dr.Head office A/c Cr.
- Allocation of head office expense:
β Key Takeaways
You must understand the difference between a dependent branch treated as a cost center and one treated as a profit center (the wholesale branch model). For the wholesale branch, the critical concept is unrealized profit on closing stock, which requires a stock reserve to be created by debiting the Income Statement. The formula Unrealized profit = (Branch closing stock x Markup) / (Cost + Markup) is essential for the exam. For independent branches, the three-step process (reconciliation, adjustment, incorporation) must be memorized, including the specific reasons for differences and the journal entries for cash/goods in transit and inter-branch transfers.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the fundamental difference between a dependent branch treated as a cost center and one treated as a profit center (wholesale branch)?
- What is the journal entry to record the unrealized profit on unsold branch stock in the head office's books, and where is the corresponding balance shown in the financial statements?
- A branch has a closing stock of Rs. 63,000, which was invoiced at cost plus 40%. Calculate the unrealized profit.
- List the three main steps involved in preparing the accounts of an independent branch.
- What are the three primary reasons for a difference between the Branch Account in the head office books and the Head Office Account in the branch books?