π Lecture 31 β BORROWING COST (IAS 23)
π Overview: This lecture explains the accounting treatment for borrowing costs incurred when funds are borrowed for the purchase, acquisition, or construction of assets. It introduces the distinction between qualifying and non-qualifying assets, and describes both the benchmark treatment and the allowed alternative treatment for capitalizing borrowing costs. Understanding this standard is critical for correctly valuing self-constructed or acquired long-term assets in financial statements.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture defines borrowing costs and qualifying assets, lists examples of each, and provides identification exercises. It then explains two accounting treatments: the benchmark treatment (expensing all borrowing costs) and the allowed alternative treatment (capitalizing costs for qualifying assets). The lecture covers specific borrowings, temporary investment income, and general borrowings with capitalization rate calculations, including multiple solved examples.
π Lecture Summary
Borrowing Costs
Borrowing costs are interest and other costs incurred by an entity in connection with the borrowing of funds.
Examples of Borrowing Costs: (a) Interest on bank overdrafts and short-term and long-term borrowings; (b) Amortization of discounts or premiums relating to borrowings; (c) Amortization of ancillary costs incurred in connection with the arrangement of borrowings (e.g. processing fee, lawyerβs consultation etc.); (d) Finance charges in respect of finance leases recognized in accordance with IAS 17, Leases; and (e) Exchange difference arising from foreign currency borrowings to the extent that they are regarded as an adjustment to interest cost.
A Qualifying Asset
A qualifying asset is an asset that necessarily takes a substantial period of time to get ready for its intended use or sale.
Examples of Qualifying Assets: a) Manufacturing plants b) Power generation facilities c) Investment properties d) Those inventories which are routinely manufactured or produced in large quantities on a repetitive basis and assets ready for their intended use or sale when acquired are not qualifying assets.
π Definition β Qualifying Asset: An asset that necessarily takes a substantial period of time to get ready for its intended use or sale.
π Example (Identifying Qualifying Assets): Identify which of the followings are qualifying assets: (a) Power plant being in the process of manufacturing. β Qualifying Asset (b) Inventories routinely manufactured; β Not Qualifying Asset (c) Asset ready for use; β Not Qualifying Asset (d) Inventories requiring a substantial period for manufacturing. β Qualifying Asset (e) Special order for a special inventory that will be manufactured in 5 months. β Qualifying Asset
Accounting for borrowing costs
1) Benchmark Treatment
Recognition: Under the benchmark treatment, borrowing costs are recognized as an expense in the period in which they are incurred regardless of how the borrowings are applied.
Disclosure: The financial statements shall disclose the accounting policy adopted for borrowing costs (e.g. Interest, markup, profit and other charges on borrowings are charged to income).
2) Allowed Alternate Treatment
Recognition: Borrowing costs shall be recognized as an expense in the period in which they are incurred, except to the extent that borrowing costs that are directly attributable to the acquisition, construction or production of a qualifying asset shall be capitalized as part of the cost of that asset.
Borrowing costs eligible for capitalization: The borrowing costs that are directly attributable to the acquisition, construction or production of a qualifying asset are those borrowing costs that would have been avoided if the expenditure on the qualifying asset had not been made. When an entity borrows funds specifically for the purpose of obtaining a particular qualifying asset, the borrowing costs that directly relate to that qualifying asset can be readily identified.
π‘ Why this matters: The choice between expensing and capitalizing can significantly impact reported profit in the period of construction and the asset's carrying value.
π Example (Benchmark vs. Allowed Alternative): Mega Limited is engaged in the production of power generation plants, which is to be used by the company. The company borrows Rs.20,000,000 @ 10% for construction of the plant. What options are available to the company under IAS-23?
Solution: Benchmark Treatment: Interest expense is recognized as an expense. Therefore, the company should recognize the interest of Rs. 2,000,000 as an expense. Allowed Alternative Treatment: Under allowed alternative treatment, the interest expense of Rs. 2,000,000 shall be capitalized in the cost of the asset.
Specific Borrowings
Where funds are borrowed specifically for a qualifying asset, the amount of borrowing cost (less temporary investment income if any) shall be capitalized as a cost of such asset.
Temporary Investment Income: When all of the borrowed funds are not utilized at once for acquisition, development or construction of qualifying asset, the unutilized amount of the borrowed fund is invested temporarily (for a little time period) in some securities. The return on such investments is known as temporary investment income.
π Formula (Specific Borrowings): Borrowing cost eligible for capitalization = (Loan Amount Γ Interest Rate Γ Borrowing Period) β Temporary Investment Income
π Example (Specific Borrowings with Temporary Investment): Swan Limited borrowed a loan from bank @ 12% per annum amounting to Rs.1,000,000 for the construction of power generation facilities. The loan was received on January 01 and utilized Rs. 300,000 on Qualifying Asset. On January 01, the company deposited the remaining amount in a bank yielding interest @ 6%. Whole of the amount is withdrawn and paid to contractor on March 01. The company returned the loan to bank after 9 months i.e. on October 01.
Hint: Borrowing period 9 months, Investment period 2 months.
Solution:
| Rs. | |
|---|---|
| Interest paid to bank (1,000,000 Γ 12% Γ 9/12) | 90,000 |
| Less: Interest income (700,000 Γ 6% Γ 2/12) | (7,000) |
| Borrowing cost eligible for capitalization | 83,000 |
| Capital expenditure (Rs. 1,000,000 + 83,000) | 1,083,000 |
General Borrowings
The amount to be capitalized shall be computed on the basis of capitalization rate, which shall be the weighted average of the borrowing costs applicable to the outstanding borrowing during the period.
π Formula (Capitalization Rate): Capitalization rate = (Total Borrowing Cost incurred / Weighted Borrowings Outstanding) Γ 100
This rate when applied on the expenditure incurred on Qualifying Asset on a time basis gives the amount of borrowing cost to be capitalized. The capitalization should not exceed the amount of borrowing costs actually incurred.
π Example 1 (General Borrowings β Loans with different start dates): MCQ (Private) Limited has the following loans outstanding as at December 31, 2005:
- Loan β 1 @ 6% (Due since opening date): Rs. 300,000
- Loan β 2 @ 8% (Taken on 1 April, 2005): Rs. 200,000
- Loan β 3 @ 9% (Taken on 1 July, 2005): Rs. 150,000
The company spent:
- January 31, 2005: Rs. 70,000
- April 1, 2005: Rs. 80,000
- December 1, 2005: Rs. 10,000
Solution: (i) Capitalization rate = 7% (W-1) (ii) Borrowing cost eligible for capitalization = Rs. 8,750 (W-2)
W-1: Capitalization Rate Calculation
| Loan | Amount Rs. | W Avg. Rs. | Rate | Interest Rs. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Loan β 1 | 300,000 | 300,000 (12/12) | 6% | 18,000 |
| Loan β 2 | 200,000 | 150,000 (9/12) | 8% | 12,000 |
| Loan β 3 | 150,000 | 75,000 (6/12) | 9% | 6,750 |
| Total | 650,000 | 525,000 | 36,750 |
Capitalization rate = Total Interest / Weighted Average Loan Γ 100 = 36,750 / 525,000 Γ 100 = 7%
W-2: Borrowing cost eligible for capitalization
| Expenditure Rs. | Incurred on | Rate | Period | Capitalization Rs. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 70,000 | Jan 31, 2005 | 7% | 11/12 | 4,492 |
| 80,000 | Apr 01, 2005 | 7% | 9/12 | 4,200 |
| 10,000 | Dec 01, 2005 | 7% | 1/12 | 58 |
| 160,000 | 8,750 |
Borrowing cost allocation:
- Total borrowing cost: Rs. 36,750
- Borrowing cost eligible for capitalization: Rs. (8,750)
- Borrowing cost chargeable as expense: Rs. 28,000
Capital Expenditure:
- Incurred cost: Rs. 160,000
- Borrowing cost eligible for capitalization: Rs. 8,750
- Total: Rs. 168,750
π Example 2 (General Borrowings β All loans due since opening date): Same company, but all loans due since opening date:
- Loan β 1 @ 6%: Rs. 300,000
- Loan β 2 @ 8%: Rs. 200,000
- Loan β 3 @ 9%: Rs. 150,000
Same expenditures.
Solution: (i) Capitalization rate = 7.31% (W-1) (ii) Borrowing cost eligible for capitalization = Rs. 9,136 (W-2)
W-1: Capitalization Rate Calculation
| Loan | Amount Rs. | Rate | Interest Rs. |
|---|---|---|---|
| Loan β 1 | 300,000 | 6% | 18,000 |
| Loan β 2 | 200,000 | 8% | 16,000 |
| Loan β 3 | 150,000 | 9% | 13,500 |
| Total | 650,000 | 47,500 |
Capitalization rate = Total Interest / Total Loan Γ 100 = 47,500 / 650,000 Γ 100 = 7.31%
W-2: Borrowing cost eligible for capitalization
| Expenditure Rs. | Incurred on | Rate | Period | Capitalization Rs. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 70,000 | Jan 31, 2005 | 7.31% | 11/12 | 4,689 |
| 80,000 | Apr 01, 2005 | 7.31% | 9/12 | 4,386 |
| 10,000 | Dec 01, 2005 | 7.31% | 1/12 | 61 |
| 160,000 | 9,136 |
Borrowing cost allocation:
- Total borrowing cost: Rs. 47,500
- Borrowing cost eligible for capitalization: Rs. (9,136)
- Borrowing cost chargeable as expense: Rs. 38,364
Capital Expenditure:
- Incurred cost: Rs. 160,000
- Borrowing cost eligible for capitalization: Rs. 9,136
- Total: Rs. 169,136
π Example 3 (General Borrowings β Mixed loan start dates): Sublime Sports Limited is manufacturing its power plants. Up-to December 31, 2003, costs totaling Rs. 500,000 incurred. Loans outstanding:
- Loan from MCB @ 9%: Rs. 500,000 (brought forward)
- Loan from HBL @ 10%: Rs. 625,000 (taken on July 1, 20x3)
- Loan from UBL @ 11%: Rs. 375,000 (brought forward)
Expenditure incurred:
- May 31, 2003: Rs. 300,000
- July 31, 2003: Rs. 200,000
Solution: (a) Capitalization rate = 9.8947% (W-1) (b) Total borrowing cost eligible for capitalization = Rs. 25,562 (W-2)
W-1: Capitalization Rate Calculation
| Loan | Principal Rs. | Period | W Avg. Loan Rs. | Rate | Interest Rs. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| MCB | 500,000 | 12/12 | 500,000 | 9% | 45,000 |
| HBL | 625,000 | 6/12 | 312,500 | 10% | 31,250 |
| UBL | 375,000 | 12/12 | 375,000 | 11% | 41,250 |
| Total | 1,500,000 | 1,187,500 | 117,500 |
Capitalization rate = 117,500 / 1,187,500 Γ 100 = 9.8947%
W-2: Borrowing cost eligible for capitalization
| Expenditure Rs. | Incurred on | Rate | Period | Capitalization Rs. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 300,000 | May 31, 2003 | 9.8947% | 7/12 | 17,316 |
| 200,000 | July 31, 2003 | 9.8947% | 5/12 | 8,246 |
| 500,000 | 25,562 |
β Key Takeaways
Borrowing costs can be expensed (benchmark treatment) or capitalized (allowed alternative) for qualifying assets that take substantial time to get ready. Qualifying assets include power plants, manufacturing facilities, and investment properties β but not routinely manufactured inventories or assets ready for immediate use. For specific borrowings, capitalize the net borrowing cost after subtracting any temporary investment income. For general borrowings, compute a capitalization rate as total interest divided by weighted average loans, then apply that rate to expenditures on a time-proportion basis. The amount capitalized can never exceed the total borrowing costs actually incurred.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is a qualifying asset under IAS 23, and what are two examples and two non-examples?
- Under the allowed alternative treatment, how is the borrowing cost calculated for a specific borrowing when unutilized funds earn temporary investment income?
- How is the capitalization rate calculated for general borrowings?
- In the general borrowing example where all loans were due since opening date (MCQ Private Limited), what was the capitalization rate and the amount of borrowing cost eligible for capitalization?
- What is the critical limitation on the amount of borrowing cost that can be capitalized?
π Lecture 32 β Excess of the Carrying Amount of the Qualifying Asset Over Recoverable Amount
π Overview: This lecture examines the standard treatment for borrowing costs under IAS-23, focusing on when capitalization begins, is suspended, and ceases. It also addresses how to handle government subsidies, modifications after completion, and assets completed in parts. Mastering these rules is essential for correctly determining the cost of a qualifying asset in financial statements.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the write-down of qualifying assets when carrying amount exceeds recoverable amount, the three conditions for commencing capitalization, treatment of government subsidies, suspension of capitalization during extended interruptions, cessation of capitalization when substantially all activities are complete, rules for minor modifications after completion, and guidance on when assets are completed in parts and each part is capable of separate use.
π Lecture Summary
Excess of the Carrying Amount of the Qualifying Asset Over Recoverable Amount
When the carrying amount or expected ultimate cost of the qualifying asset exceeds its recoverable amount or net realizable value, the carrying amount is written down or written off in accordance with other Standards. In certain circumstances, the amount of the write-down or write-off is written back as per those other Standards.
π‘ Why this matters: This ensures that assets are not carried at more than their economic value, aligning with the principle of prudence.
Commencement of Capitalization
The capitalization of borrowing costs as part of the cost of a qualifying asset shall commence when all three conditions are simultaneously met: (a) Expenditures on the asset are being incurred; (b) Borrowing costs are being incurred; and (c) Activities necessary to prepare the asset for its intended use or sale are in progress.
π Definition β Commencement of Capitalization: The date when all three conditions (expenditures incurred, borrowing costs incurred, and necessary activities in progress) are first met.
π Example (Silver Star Private Limited): The company started a power plant project on February 01 with its own funds. It took a loan on May 01, and made the first payment out of the loan on June 01. The three conditions are fulfilled only on June 01 (expenditure incurred, borrowing cost incurred, and activities in progress). Therefore, capitalization should commence on June 01.
Treatment of Subsidies by the Government
Expenditures on a qualifying asset include only those that have resulted in payments of cash, transfers of other assets, or the assumption of interest-bearing liabilities. Expenditures are reduced by any progress payments received and grants received in connection with the asset. The average carrying amount of the asset during a period, including borrowing costs previously capitalized, is normally a reasonable approximation of the expenditures to which the capitalization rate is applied in that period.
π Example (Pak Solutions Limited): The company incurred: payment to vendors for materials Rs. 500,000; depreciation of equipment Rs. 20,000; wages paid Rs. 300,000; utilities to be paid Rs. 80,000. Total expenditures = Rs. 900,000. The government granted a subsidy of Rs. 200,000. The amount on which capitalization should be made is Rs. 900,000 β Rs. 200,000 = Rs. 700,000.
Activities Encompassed
The activities necessary to prepare the asset for its intended use or sale encompass more than physical construction. They include technical and administrative work prior to commencement of physical construction, such as activities associated with obtaining permits.
Suspension of Capitalizing Borrowing Cost
Capitalization of borrowing costs shall be suspended during extended periods in which active development is interrupted. Capitalization is not suspended when a temporary delay is a necessary part of the process of getting an asset ready for its intended use or sale, e.g., the extended period during which high water levels delay construction of a bridge.
π Example (Shahid & Company): Construction started on September 30, 2006. The construction was suspended from November 01 to November 31 (i.e., one month). Construction resumed on December 01 and completed on December 31. Active development occurred from September 30 to October 31 (2 months) and then from December 1 to December 31 (1 month). Therefore, borrowing cost should be capitalized for two months (September and December) and shall remain suspended for one month (November).
Cessation of Capitalization
Capitalization of borrowing costs shall cease when substantially all the activities necessary to prepare the qualifying asset for its intended use or sale are complete.
π Example (Haroon Limited): Construction started on March 01, 2009. The asset was completed on July 31, 2009. It was put into use on September 15, and production started on November 1. The asset was ready for use on July 31, even though actual production hadn't started. Thus, capitalization of borrowing cost should cease on July 31, 2009.
Modification Work after Completion
An asset is normally ready for its intended use or sale when the physical construction of the asset is complete, even though routine administrative work might still continue. If minor modifications, such as decoration to the purchaserβs or userβs specification, are all that are outstanding, this indicates that substantially all the activities are complete.
π Example (Zeshan Limited): Production started on July 31, 2007, and completed on July 31, 2008. The works manager requested minor modifications completed on August 30, 2008. The asset was delivered on September 10, 2008, and production started on October 1, 2008. Since substantially all activities were completed on July 31, 2008, capitalization should cease on July 31, 2008. Minor modifications do not delay cessation.
Completion of Work in Parts
When the construction of a qualifying asset is completed in parts and each part is capable of being used separately while construction continues on other parts, capitalization of borrowing costs shall cease when substantially all the activities necessary to prepare that part for its intended use or sale are completed.
- Example of separately usable parts: A business centre comprising several buildings, each of which can be used individually.
- Example of asset needing full completion: An industrial plant involving several processes carried out in sequence, such as a steel mill.
π Example (Sialkot Pvt. Limited): The company contracted to build a group of factory buildings, each capable of being used separately. Since each component of the contract is capable of being used separately, borrowing costs should be capitalized based on the period of construction of each building individually.
β Key Takeaways
The critical points are: (1) Capitalization of borrowing costs begins only when all three conditions (expenditures, borrowing costs, and necessary activities) are met simultaneously, and it ceases when substantially all activities are completeβeven if minor modifications remain or actual use is delayed. (2) Government subsidies and progress payments must be deducted from qualifying expenditures when computing the amount eligible for capitalization. (3) Capitalization is suspended during extended periods of active development interruption, but not for necessary temporary delays. (4) For assets completed in parts that can be used separately, borrowing cost capitalization is applied on a part-by-part basis rather than a whole-asset basis.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three conditions that must be met for borrowing cost capitalization to commence?
- When a government grant is received for constructing a qualifying asset, how is it treated in the calculation of borrowing cost to be capitalized?
- Under what circumstances should capitalization of borrowing costs be suspended?
- An asset is physically completed on June 30, but minor decorative modifications are finished on July 15. When should capitalization cease?
- A company constructs three independent factory buildings at the same site. Should borrowing cost capitalization cease when all buildings are completed or when each individual building is completed?
π Lecture 33 β EARNINGS PER SHARE (IAS β 33)
π Overview: This lecture covers International Accounting Standard (IAS) 33 on Earnings Per Share, which provides complete guidelines for calculation and presentation of EPS. It explains both Basic EPS and Diluted EPS, with emphasis on calculating weighted average number of ordinary shares and profits available for distribution. Only listed companies need to present EPS, though non-listed companies may also do so if they follow IAS 33.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with disclosures for borrowing costs (carrying forward from previous content), then moves to the core topic of Earnings Per Share under IAS 33. It covers the formula for Basic EPS, methods for calculating weighted average number of ordinary shares, profit available for distribution to ordinary shareholders, and provides multiple solved examples demonstrating share issuance, treasury shares, and the time-weighting factor.
π Lecture Summary
Disclosures (Borrowing Costs)
Following should be disclosed in the financial statements regarding borrowing costs: (a) The accounting policy adopted for borrowing costs; (b) The amount of borrowing costs capitalized during the period; and (c) The capitalization rate used to determine the amount of borrowing costs eligible for capitalization.
Example disclosure:
- (i) Borrowing costs are recognized as an expense in the period in which these are incurred, except to the extent that borrowing costs that are directly attributable to the acquisition, construction or production of a qualifying asset is capitalized as part of the cost of that asset.
- (ii) The amount of borrowing costs capitalized during the period is Rs. 75,145.
- (iii) Capitalization rate for the year used to capitalize borrowing costs is 9.15%.
Earnings Per Share (IAS β 33)
Earnings per Share is an accounting ratio that improves comparison of the performance of different entities in the same period and of the same entity in different accounting periods.
International Accounting Standard (IAS) 33 provides complete guidelines regarding calculation and presentation of EPS. Only listed companies need to present EPS. Where a non-listed company chooses to present EPS in its financial statements, it must do so in accordance with IAS 33.
Methods for the Calculation of EPS:
- Basic EPS
- Diluted EPS
Formula for Basic βEarnings Per Shareβ:
Earnings available for distribution to ordinary shareholders Weighted Average No. of ordinary share outstanding during the period
Profits Available for Distribution to Ordinary Shareholders
This is the current year's profit figure which is obtained after subtracting all types of expenses (cost of goods sold, administrative, selling, financial and income tax expenses) out of all the incomes (revenues and gains) recognized during the year. This is also known as the profit after tax.
Weighted Average Number of Ordinary Shares Outstanding During the Year
This is the figure that needs calculation; these are the weighted average of ordinary shares that remained outstanding during the year. This figure is obtained after making certain adjustments concerning increase or decrease in the number of ordinary shares in accordance with the time period due. The time-weighting factor is the number of days the shares were outstanding compared with the total number of days in the period.
π Formula: Weighted average = Sum of (Shares outstanding Γ Fraction of period they were outstanding)
π Example 1: FS Company Limited
| Date | Details | Shares |
|---|---|---|
| Jan 1, 2007 | Opening Balance b/f | 200,000 |
| Sep 30, 2007 | Issue of ordinary share capital | 200,000 |
| Dec 31, 2007 | Closing Balance c/f | 400,000 |
Weighted average calculation:
- 200,000 (outstanding for full year) = 200,000
- 200,000 Γ 3/12 (outstanding for Oct, Nov, Dec) = 50,000
- Weighted average number of ordinary shares outstanding = 250,000
π Example 2: Jubilation Co. β With Treasury Shares Treasury shares are the company's own shares held by the company itself.
| Date | Details | Shares Issued | Treasury Shares* | Shares Outstanding |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan 1, 2007 | Balance b/f | 200,000 | 30,000 | 170,000 |
| May 31, 2007 | Fresh Issue | 80,000 | - | 250,000 |
| Dec 1, 2007 | Treasury shares | - | 25,000 | 225,000 |
| Dec 31, 2007 | Balance c/f | 280,000 | 55,000 | 225,000 |
Weighted average number of shares (Method 1):
| Shares Outstanding | Weight in months | Weighted average |
|---|---|---|
| 170,000 | 5/12 | 70,833 |
| 250,000 | 6/12 | 125,000 |
| 225,000 | 1/12 | 18,750 |
| Total | 214,583 |
Alternative calculation (Method 2):
| Number of shares | Weight in months | Weighted average |
|---|---|---|
| 170,000 | 12/12 | 170,000 |
| 80,000 | 7/12 | 46,666 |
| (25,000) | 1/12 | (2,083) |
| Total | 214,583 |
Key rule: Shares are usually included in the weighted average number of shares from the date on which the consideration is receivable, which is usually the date of issue. Ordinary shares issued as purchase consideration in an acquisition should be included as of the date of acquisition because the acquired entity's results will also be included from that date.
π Example 3: Famous Co. β Complete EPS Calculation Given:
- Issued and paid up capital: 100,000 ordinary shares of Re. 1 each
- 20,000 10% debentures of Re. 1 each
- Gross profit: Rs. 200,000
- Operating expenses: Rs. 50,000
- 10% interest on debentures paid
- Ordinary dividend declared: 40 paisa per share
- Income tax rate: 30%
Solution β Trading Results:
- Gross Profit: Rs. 200,000
- Less: Operating Expenses: (Rs. 50,000)
- Profit from operations: Rs. 150,000
- Less: Interest on debentures (20,000 Γ 10%): (Rs. 2,000)
- Profit before tax: Rs. 148,000
- Less: Income tax (30%): (Rs. 44,400)
- Profit after tax: Rs. 103,600
- Less: Ordinary dividend (100,000 Γ 0.40): (Rs. 40,000)
- Retained earnings: Rs. 63,600
EPS Calculation:
- Earnings available for ordinary shareholders = Profit after tax = Rs. 103,600
- Weighted average ordinary shares = 100,000 (no changes during year)
- Basic EPS = Rs. 103,600 / 100,000 = Rs. 1.036 per share
π Definition β Basic EPS: Earnings available for distribution to ordinary shareholders divided by the weighted average number of ordinary shares outstanding during the period.
π‘ Why this matters: EPS is the most widely used measure of a company's profitability from the perspective of ordinary shareholders and directly impacts share price valuation.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concept from this lecture is that Basic EPS is calculated by dividing profit after tax (earnings available for ordinary shareholders) by the weighted average number of ordinary shares outstanding during the period. The weighted average calculation requires time-weighting shares based on how many months they were outstanding, with treasury shares (company's own shares held) reducing the outstanding count. Shares are included from the date consideration is receivable, and for acquisition-related shares, from the acquisition date. Only listed companies are required to present EPS under IAS 33, but non-listed companies choosing to do so must follow the standard. The borrowing costs disclosure requirements were also reviewed, specifying that borrowing costs directly attributable to qualifying assets must be capitalized at the applicable capitalization rate.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the formula for calculating Basic Earnings Per Share?
- How are treasury shares treated in the calculation of weighted average number of ordinary shares?
- From what date should ordinary shares issued as purchase consideration in an acquisition be included in the weighted average calculation?
- In the Famous Co. example, what was the profit after tax and the resulting EPS?
- What three items must be disclosed in financial statements regarding borrowing costs according to the standard?
π Lecture 34 β Earnings per Share (IAS 33)
π Overview: This lecture continues the study of Earnings per Share (EPS) under IAS 33, focusing on complex scenarios where the number of ordinary shares changes during the period. It covers how to calculate EPS when shares are issued at full market price, when bonus shares are issued, and when a rights issue occurs, emphasizing the need for adjustments to ensure comparability between periods.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the calculation of weighted average number of shares for EPS when there is a fresh issue of shares at full market price, and the treatment of events that change share count without corresponding resource inflow, including bonus issues and rights issues. It explains the need for retrospective adjustment of prior period EPS in bonus issues, and the calculation of theoretical ex-rights price for rights issues.
π Lecture Summary
Solved Questions (Fresh Issue at Full Market Price)
The lecture begins with a solved example for Blue-moon Co, which issued 1,000,000 ordinary shares at full market price on September 30, 2008. To calculate EPS for 2008, we compute the weighted average number of shares by considering the time the new shares were outstanding. The new shares were outstanding for 3 months (October to December), so their weight is 1,000,000 Γ 3/12 = 250,000. The weighted average for 2008 is 8,000,000 + 250,000 = 8,250,000 shares. EPS for 2008 is Rs. 3,300,000 / 8,250,000 = 40 paisa. For 2007, the number of shares was constant at 8,000,000, so EPS is Rs. 3,280,000 / 8,000,000 = 41 paisa. Despite higher total earnings in 2008, the EPS fell because extra capital was employed for only the last 3 months. π‘ Why this matters: This demonstrates that an increase in total profit does not automatically mean a better EPS; the timing and amount of new share issuance significantly affects the denominator.
Events that cause a change in number of ordinary shares
There are events that change the number of ordinary shares without an inflow of resources. These include capitalization of reserves (bonus issue) and the bonus element in a rights issue. In these cases, adjustments must be made to the denominator of the EPS formula so that current and comparative EPS figures are meaningful and comparable.
Bonus Issue of Share Capital
A bonus issue (or scrip issue) increases the number of ordinary shares without a corresponding increase in the entity's financial resources. The total net assets and owners' equity remain the same. Because this reduces EPS compared to prior periods, the problem is solved by adjusting the number of ordinary shares outstanding before the event for the proportionate change, as if the event had occurred at the beginning of the earliest period reported.
π Definition β Bonus Issue: An issue of additional shares to existing shareholders without any payment, funded by capitalizing reserves from owners' equity.
Solved Example β Great Master Co had 400,000 shares in issue until September 30, 2009, when it made a bonus issue of 100,000 shares. Earnings were Rs. 80,000 in 2009 and Rs. 75,000 in 2008. π Adjustment: The bonus issue (100,000/400,000 = 1/4) means shares increase by 25%. For comparability, the 2008 shares are also adjusted: 400,000 Γ 1.25 = 500,000 shares. π Example:
- 2009 EPS: Rs. 80,000 / 500,000 shares = 16 paisa
- 2008 EPS (adjusted): Rs. 75,000 / 500,000 shares = 15 paisa Without adjustment, 2008 EPS would be Rs. 75,000 / 400,000 = 18.75 paisa, falsely showing 2008 was better. The correct adjusted EPS shows the companyβs earnings improved from 15 paisa to 16 paisa. The recommended approach is to use the new number of shares (500,000) for both years to avoid further adjustments in subsequent years.
Rights Issue of Share Capital
A rights issue is an issue of new shares to existing shareholders at a price below the current market value, e.g., a 1 for 3 rights issue means 1 new share for every 3 held. This contains a bonus element because shares are offered at a discount. To calculate EPS when a rights issue is made, you first compute the theoretical ex-rights price (TERP), which is the weighted average value per share after the rights issue.
π Definition β Theoretical Ex-Rights Price (TERP): The theoretical market price per share immediately after a rights issue is completed, assuming all rights are exercised.
Solved Example β Egg Co has 10,000 shares in issue on January 1, 2008. On June 30, 2008, it makes a 1 for 4 rights issue at Rs. 3 per share. The cum-rights market price is Rs. 5 per share.
π Formula: TERP = (Total value of old shares + Total proceeds from rights issue) / Total number of shares after rights issue
π Example:
- Number of existing shares: 10,000 (representing 4 blocks for the 1 for 4 issue)
- Value of existing shares: 10,000 Γ Rs. 5 = Rs. 50,000
- Number of new shares: 10,000 Γ (1/4) = 2,500
- Proceeds from rights issue: 2,500 Γ Rs. 3 = Rs. 7,500
- Total value: Rs. 50,000 + Rs. 7,500 = Rs. 57,500
- Total shares after issue: 10,000 + 2,500 = 12,500
- TERP: Rs. 57,500 / 12,500 = Rs. 4.60 per share
Alternatively, using per-share logic: (4 shares Γ Rs. 5) + (1 share Γ Rs. 3) = Rs. 23 for 5 shares β Rs. 23/5 = Rs. 4.60.
β Key Takeaways
For a fresh issue at full market price, calculate weighted average shares by weighting new shares based on the fraction of the year they were outstanding. When a bonus issue occurs, always adjust the prior period's EPS denominator by applying the bonus fraction retrospectively to ensure comparability β the easiest method is to use the post-bonus share count for both years. A rights issue contains a bonus element; you must first compute the theoretical ex-rights price to determine the bonus factor. The bonus factor is then used to adjust the number of shares outstanding before the rights issue, making the EPS figures comparable across periods. Remember that events without resource inflow fundamentally change the comparability of EPS, and IAS 33 requires retrospective restatement of prior period EPS.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Why does a bonus issue require retrospective adjustment of the prior year's EPS, while a fresh issue at full market price does not?
- For Blue-moon Co, what would the 2008 EPS be if the 1,000,000 shares were issued on July 1 instead of September 30?
- What is the theoretical ex-rights price if a company with 10,000 shares makes a 1 for 5 rights issue at Rs. 4 per share when the cum-rights price is Rs. 6?
- In the bonus issue example, why is using 500,000 shares for both years preferable to using 400,000 shares for both years?
- What is the "bonus element" in a rights issue, and why does it require an adjustment to the EPS calculation?
π Lecture 35 β Solved Questions
π Overview: This lecture covers the complete procedure for calculating Earnings Per Share (EPS), including the treatment of rights issues and diluted EPS. It provides step-by-step solutions to practical problems, demonstrating how to handle bonus elements, consideration elements, and convertible securities that may dilute EPS in the future.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with a procedural outline for calculating EPS with rights issues, then works through two detailed solved problems demonstrating the calculation of theoretical ex-rights price, bonus element, and weighted average shares for multiple years. It then introduces Diluted Earnings Per Share, explaining how convertible debentures and other potential ordinary shares affect EPS, and provides examples showing how to determine whether securities are dilutive or anti-dilutive.
π Lecture Summary
Procedure to calculate EPS
The lecture provides a systematic 5-step process. First, calculate theoretical ex-rights price by dividing the total value of shares (pre-rights market value plus rights proceeds) by total shares post-rights. Second, determine the bonus element in the rights issue, which is the difference between total rights shares and the consideration element. Third, add the bonus element to outstanding shares for both the current year and the prior year. Fourth, calculate the weighted average number of shares representing the resources/consideration element, weighted by time outstanding. Finally, calculate EPS by dividing earnings by the weighted average shares.
Solved Question β Egg Co Example
Continuing from a previous example, Egg Co had earnings of Rs. 20,000 in 2007 and Rs. 22,000 in 2008. Rights issue: 2,500 shares at Rs. 3 per share, market price Rs. 5. Theoretical ex-right price = Rs. 4.60 per share. Total investment = Rs. 7,500. Consideration element = Rs. 7,500 / Rs. 4.60 = 1,630 shares. Bonus element = 2,500 β 1,630 = 870 shares.
π Definition β bonus element: The portion of a rights issue that represents a free share distribution, calculated as the difference between total rights shares and the number that could be purchased at the theoretical ex-rights price using the actual proceeds.
For 2008: Opening balance 10,000 + bonus 870 + consideration 1,630 Γ 6/12 = 815 = weighted average 11,685 shares. EPS = Rs. 22,000 / 11,685 = Rs. 1.88. For 2007: Opening 10,000 + bonus 870 = weighted average 10,870. EPS = Rs. 20,000 / 10,870 = Rs. 1.84.
Solved Question β Three-Year EPS with Rights Issue
A company had net profits: 2006 Rs. 110,000, 2007 Rs. 150,000, 2008 Rs. 180,000. Opening shares 500,000. Rights issue: 1 new share for each 5 outstanding (100,000 shares) at Rs. 5, exercise by March 1, 2007 (10 months). Market price Rs. 11.
Theoretical ex-right price: 500,000 shares Γ Rs. 11 = Rs. 5,500,000 + 100,000 Γ Rs. 5 = Rs. 500,000 = Rs. 6,000,000 total value for 600,000 shares = Rs. 10 per share.
Bonus element: Total investment Rs. 500,000. Consideration = Rs. 500,000 / Rs. 10 = 50,000 shares. Bonus = 100,000 β 50,000 = 50,000 shares.
Schedule of weighted average shares: 2006: 500,000 + 50,000 bonus = 550,000. EPS = Rs. 110,000 / 550,000 = Rs. 0.20. 2007: 500,000 + 50,000 bonus + 50,000 Γ 10/12 = 41,667 consideration = 591,667. EPS = Rs. 150,000 / 591,667 = Rs. 0.2535. 2008: Opening 600,000, no adjustment = 600,000. EPS = Rs. 180,000 / 600,000 = Rs. 0.30.
π Example: The bonus element (50,000 shares) is added to the opening balance of all three years because it represents a free distribution to existing shareholders that affects comparability. The consideration element (50,000 shares) is weighted by 10/12 in 2007 only, since the shares were issued on March 1 and were outstanding for 10 months.
Diluted Earnings Per Share
Companies may have securities that do not currently have a claim on equity earnings but may give rise to such a claim in the future: (a) separate class of equity shares not yet entitled to dividends, (b) convertible debentures or preferred shares exchangeable for ordinary shares at a predetermined rate, (c) options or warrants. Future conversion would increase ordinary shares and dilute EPS. Diluted EPS is the EPS that would have been obtained if the dilution had already taken place.
Earnings adjustment: Basic EPS earnings should be adjusted for the post-tax effect of: (a) dividends on dilutive potential ordinary shares deducted for basic EPS, (b) interest recognized on dilutive potential ordinary shares, (c) any other changes in income or expenses from conversion.
Per share adjustment: The number of ordinary shares is the weighted average for basic EPS plus the weighted average number of shares that would be issued on conversion of all dilutive potential ordinary shares, assumed converted at the beginning of the period or actual issue date if later.
Solved Question β Diluted EPS with Convertible Debentures
Basic EPS = Rs. 1.05 per share (earnings Rs. 105,000, 100,000 ordinary shares). Company had Rs. 40,000 15% convertible debentures, convertible in two years at 4 shares per Rs. 5 of debenture (32,000 shares). Tax rate 30%. Gross profit Rs. 200,000, operating expenses Rs. 44,000, interest Rs. 6,000.
Conversion would save interest expense, increasing profit. Revised profit after conversion: gross profit 200,000 β expenses 44,000 = 156,000 operations profit β 0 interest = 156,000 profit before tax β tax 30% (46,800) = Rs. 109,200 earnings. Total shares = 100,000 + 32,000 = 132,000. Diluted EPS = Rs. 109,200 / 132,000 = Rs. 0.827. Dilution = Rs. 1.05 β 0.827 = Rs. 0.223 per share.
π‘ Why this matters: Diluted EPS shows investors what their earnings per share would be if all convertible securities were exercised, providing a more conservative and realistic view of potential ownership dilution.
Dilutive vs Anti-Dilutive Potential Ordinary Shares
Dilutive potential ordinary shares decrease EPS upon conversion. Anti-dilutive potential ordinary shares increase EPS upon conversion. According to IAS 33, potential ordinary shares should be treated as dilutive only when their conversion would decrease net profit per share from continuing operations.
Example: Basic EPS Rs. 1.022 per share based on 100,000 shares. Financial charges @25% on Rs. 40,000 debentures = Rs. 10,000. Conversion rate: 3 shares per Rs. 20 debentures = 6,000 shares. Revised earnings after conversion: Profit from operations 156,000 β 0 interest = 156,000 β tax 30% (46,800) = Rs. 109,200. Revised EPS = Rs. 109,200 / 106,000 = Rs. 1.030. Since this is higher than Rs. 1.022, there is no dilution.
π Definition β anti-dilutive: A security whose conversion would increase EPS (or decrease loss per share), and therefore should not be included in diluted EPS calculation.
The lecture explains an alternative approach: calculate individual EPS of the security. Savings from interest: Rs. 10,000 β tax (3,000) = Rs. 7,000 impact. Individual EPS = Rs. 7,000 / 6,000 shares = Rs. 1.167. Since 1.167 > 1.022 (basic EPS), this security is anti-dilutive.
Solved Question β Ali Imran Co
Ali Imran Co had 5,000,000 ordinary shares. Debentures: (a) Rs. 1,000,000 14% convertible at 2 shares per Rs. 10 (200,000 shares), (b) Rs. 2,000,000 10% convertible at 3 shares per Rs. 5 (1,200,000 shares). Earnings Rs. 1,750,000. Tax 35%.
Basic EPS = Rs. 1,750,000 / 5,000,000 = 35 paisa per share.
To determine dilutive securities: For debenture (a): savings Rs. 1,000,000 Γ 14% = Rs. 140,000 β tax 35% (49,000) = Rs. 91,000 impact. Individual EPS = Rs. 91,000 / 200,000 shares = 45.5 paisa. Since 45.5 > 35 paisa, debenture (a) is anti-dilutive and should not be included.
β Key Takeaways
The critical concept is the bonus element in rights issues: it represents free shares given to existing shareholders and must be added to outstanding shares for all comparative years to maintain consistency. For diluted EPS, only dilutive potential ordinary shares should be included β those whose conversion would decrease EPS. The test is to compare the individual EPS of the security (interest savings net of tax divided by new shares) against basic EPS; if lower, it is dilutive. Convertible debentures save interest expense (net of tax) when converted, increasing earnings, so the dilution test must account for both the earnings increase and the new shares. Finally, the weighted average for resource shares in a rights issue is based on the number of months the new shares were outstanding during the year.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the formula for calculating the theoretical ex-rights price?
- How is the bonus element in a rights issue calculated, and why must it be added to prior year share counts?
- In calculating diluted EPS, how do you determine whether a convertible debenture is dilutive or anti-dilutive?
- What adjustments must be made to earnings when calculating diluted EPS for convertible debentures?
- In the Ali Imran Co example, why was the 14% convertible debenture (a) considered anti-dilutive, and what rule from IAS 33 supports this conclusion?