π Lecture 28 β IAS β 37 PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT ASSETS
π Overview: This lecture provides a comprehensive explanation of IAS 37, which governs the recognition, measurement, and disclosure of provisions, contingent liabilities, and contingent assets. It distinguishes between provisions created to reduce assets (like depreciation and doubtful debts) and provisions created to recognize liabilities for probable losses, clarifying how uncertain obligations and potential assets should be treated in financial statements to ensure transparency and reliability.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the definition and types of provisions, the concept of liability and its three components (present obligation, past event, probable outflow), and the distinction between legal and constructive obligations. It then explains contingent liabilities and contingent assets, comparing liabilities, accruals, and provisions through a detailed tabular analysis. The session also addresses the recognition criteria for provisions (present obligation, probable outflow, reliable estimate) and contingent liabilities, measurement using the "best estimate" approach with examples, and the requirements for reviewing and using provisions.
π Lecture Summary
Provision
A provision is created for two motives: one to reduce assets and second to create a liability against losses. Provisions created for reduction in assets include provision against receivables (also known as contra to receivables β provision for doubtful debts) and provision against the expiry of economic benefits of fixed assets (provision for depreciation/amortization). IAS 37 does not address provisions created to reduce the carrying amount of assets; it only addresses the provision created to recognize a liability against probable losses.
Liability
A liability is a present obligation of the entity arising from past events, the settlement of which is expected to result in an outflow from the entity of resources embodying economic benefits. The definition can be divided into three parts:
- Present obligation
- Arising from the past event
- Probable outflow of resources in future
Obligation Event
An obligating event is an event that creates a legal or constructive obligation that results in an entity having no realistic alternative but to settle that obligation.
π Definition β Legal Obligation: A legal obligation derives from: a) a contract (through its explicit or implicit terms); b) legislation; or c) other operations of law.
π Definition β Constructive Obligation: A constructive obligation derives from an entity's actions where: a) by an established pattern of past practice, published policies or a sufficiently specific current statement, the entity has indicated to other parties that it will accept certain responsibilities; and b) as a result, the entity has created a valid expectation on the part of those other parties that it will discharge those responsibilities.
Contingent Liability
A contingent liability is: a) A possible obligation that arises from past events and whose existence will be confirmed only by the occurrence or non-occurrence of one or more uncertain future events not wholly within the control of the entity; or b) A present obligation that arises from past events but is not recognized because: i) it is not probable that an outflow of resources embodying economic benefits will be required to settle the obligation; or ii) the amount of the obligation cannot be measured with sufficient reliability.
Contingent Assets
A contingent asset is a possible asset that arises from past events and whose existence will be confirmed only by the occurrence or non-occurrence of one or more uncertain future events not wholly within the control of the entity.
Treatment of Liabilities, Accruals & Provisions
Liabilities can be categorized as: 1) Certain liability (e.g., Creditors against supplies); 2) Virtually certain liability (e.g., Accruals against expenses); and 3) Uncertain liability (e.g., Provision against expected losses).
| Category | Liabilities (certain) | Accruals (virtually certain) | Provisions (uncertain) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Status | Present obligation | Present obligation | Present obligation |
| Arising from | Past events | Past events | Past events |
| Outflow of resources | Probable | Probable | Probable |
| Measurement of amount | Certain | Virtually certain | Uncertain (reliable estimate possible) |
| Accounting treatment | Dr. Purchases, Cr. Creditors | Dr. Expense, Cr. Accrual/Owings | Dr. Loss (Expenses), Cr. Provision for the Loss |
π Definition β Virtually certain: Something that involves a minor degree of estimation. An example is the amount payable in Utility Bills β the expense on the bill is for one month, but the meter is read a couple of days after the month, including charges for extra days.
Identifying Contingent Liabilities
The following table helps identify whether an obligation is a contingent liability in accordance with IAS 37:
| Case 1 | Case 2 | Case 3 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Status | Possible obligation | Present obligation | Present obligation |
| Arising from | Past events | Past events | Past events |
| Outflow of resources | Will be confirmed upon future events, not in entity's control | Probable | Not probable |
| Amount | a) Future events not remote; b) Future events remote | Cannot be measured reliably | a) Probability not remote; b) Probability remote |
| Accounting treatment | a) Disclosed in notes; b) Not disclosed | Disclosed in notes | a) Disclosed in notes; b) Not disclosed |
Accounting Requirements for Recognizing Liabilities and Assets
Recognizing liabilities and assets means to record relevant accounting heads in the books of accounts. The following table explains how different types of liabilities and assets are treated:
| Stage | Liabilities | Assets |
|---|---|---|
| Certain | Recognize | Recognize |
| Virtually certain (Accruals/Owings) | Recognize | Recognize |
| Uncertain (Probable/Provision) | Recognize | Do not recognize β Disclose only |
| Contingent | Do not recognize β Disclose only | Do nothing |
| Remote | Do nothing | Do nothing |
π Definition β Do nothing: The event is to be ignored while preparing financial statements. Even a disclosure is not required in the notes to the accounts.
Recognizing Different Transactions/Events in Accordance with IAS 37
| Expense/Loss (Status) | Measurement | Status/Recognize as | Accounting Entry |
|---|---|---|---|
| Present obligation (Certain) | Based on invoice/supporting docs | Liability | Dr. Expense, Cr. Payable |
| Present obligation (Virtually certain) | Based on invoice/supporting docs | Accrued liability | Dr. Expense, Cr. Accrual/Owings |
| Present obligation (Uncertain, amount reliably estimated, probable outflow) | Reliable estimate | Provision liability | Dr. Expense (Loss), Cr. Provision for loss |
| Present obligation (Uncertain, cannot be reliably estimated, probable outflow) | Cannot be reliably estimated | Contingent liability | No entry β Disclose only |
| Present obligation (Uncertain, no probability of outflow) | Not applicable | Contingent liability | No entry β Disclose only |
| Possible obligation (Possible outflow based on future events) | Uncertain | Contingent liability | No entry β Disclose only |
| Remote obligation | Uncertain | No recognition | No entry β No disclosure |
Provisions and Other Liabilities
Provisions can be distinguished from other liabilities because there is uncertainty about the timing or amount of future expenditure. Trade payables are liabilities for goods/services received and invoiced or formally agreed. Accruals are liabilities for goods/services received but not yet paid, invoiced, or formally agreed. Although estimation is sometimes necessary for accruals, the uncertainty is generally much less than for provisions. Accruals are often reported as part of trade and other payables, whereas provisions are reported separately.
Relationship between Provisions and Contingent Liabilities
This Standard distinguishes between: a) Provisions β recognized as liabilities (assuming reliable estimate) because they are present obligations and probable outflow of resources is required. b) Contingent liabilities β not recognized because they are either: i) possible obligations (not yet confirmed whether present obligation exists); or ii) present obligations that do not meet recognition criteria (no probable outflow or no reliable estimate).
RECOGNITION
Provisions: A provision shall be recognized when: a) the entity has a present obligation (legal or constructive) as a result of a past event; b) it is probable that an outflow of resources embodying economic benefits will be required to settle the obligation; and c) a reliable estimate can be made of the amount. If these conditions are not met, no provision shall be recognized.
Present Obligation: In rare cases, a past event is deemed to give rise to a present obligation if, taking account of all available evidence, it is more likely than not that a present obligation exists at the balance sheet date. Where it is more likely than not, the entity recognizes a provision (if other criteria are met). Where no present obligation exists, the entity discloses a contingent liability, unless the possibility of outflow is remote.
Past Events: A past event leading to a present obligation is an obligating event. For an event to be obligating, the entity must have no realistic alternative to settling the obligation. This is the case only where: a) settlement can be enforced by law; or b) in case of constructive obligation, the event creates valid expectations that the entity will discharge the obligation.
Probable Outflow of Resources: For recognition, there must be probability of outflow. An outflow is regarded as probable if the event is more likely than not to occur (probability > 50%). Where not probable, the entity discloses a contingent liability unless the possibility of outflow is remote.
Reliable Estimate: The use of estimates is essential and does not undermine reliability. This is especially true for provisions, which by nature are more uncertain than most balance sheet items.
Contingent Liabilities: An entity shall not recognize a contingent liability. It is disclosed unless the possibility of outflow is remote. Contingent liabilities are assessed continually β if outflow becomes probable, a provision is recognized in the period the change in probability occurs (except in extremely rare cases where no reliable estimate can be made).
π Example-1 (Extract from Notes): a) Guarantees issued by banks on behalf of the company. b) Claims against the company were not acknowledged as debt by the company. As the management is confident the matter will be settled in their favor, no provision has been made for the disputed liabilities.
Contingent Assets: An entity shall not recognize a contingent asset. Contingent assets usually arise from unplanned events giving rise to possible economic benefits (e.g., a legal claim where outcome is uncertain). They are not recognized because this may result in recognizing income that may never be realized. However, when realization is virtually certain, the asset is not contingent and recognition is appropriate. A contingent asset is disclosed where an inflow of economic benefits is probable.
π Example-2: The company has filed a suit against SA Ltd. claiming damages of Rs. 600,000. Legal advisors believe the company will win the case. (This would be disclosed as a contingent asset if probable.)
MEASUREMENT
Best Estimate: The amount recognized as a provision shall be the best estimate of the expenditure required to settle the present obligation at the balance sheet date. Estimates are determined by management judgment, supplemented by experience and expert reports, considering evidence including events after the balance sheet date.
π Formula (Expected Value): Expected value = Ξ£ (Probability Γ Estimated Cost)
π Example-3 (Warranty Provision): An entity sells goods with a 6-month warranty for manufacturing defects. If minor defects in all products β repair cost Rs. 1 million. If major defects in all products β repair cost Rs. 4 million. Past experience: 75% no defects, 20% minor defects, 5% major defects.
Calculation: Expected value = (75% Γ Rs. 0) + (20% Γ Rs. 1,000,000) + (5% Γ Rs. 4,000,000) = Rs. 0 + Rs. 200,000 + Rs. 200,000 = Rs. 400,000
The entity recognizes a provision of Rs. 400,000.
π‘ Why this matters: This expected value approach allows companies to estimate uncertain obligations probabilistically, providing a reasonable and systematic basis for recognizing provisions.
CHALLENGES IN PROVISION
A provision shall be reviewed at each balance sheet date and adjusted to reflect the current best estimate. If it is no longer probable that an outflow will be required, the provision shall be reversed.
USE OF PROVISIONS
A provision shall be used only for expenditures for which it was originally recognized. Setting expenditures against a provision originally recognized for another purpose would conceal the impact of two different events.
Solved Question
A damage claim of Rs. 15 million for breach of contract has been served on the company. Legal counsel views it as probable that damages will be awarded to the plaintiff. The company makes a provision of Rs. 15 million.
Next year: The case is decided in favor of the plaintiff. The company has to pay Rs. 12 million.
Accounting treatment: The provision of Rs. 15 million is utilized for the actual payment of Rs. 12 million. The excess of Rs. 3 million (Rs. 15 million - Rs. 12 million) is reversed as income in the next year's financial statements.
β Key Takeaways
This lecture establishes the critical distinction between certain, virtually certain, uncertain (provisions), and contingent liabilities, each with specific recognition and disclosure requirements under IAS 37. A provision must be recognized only when there is a present obligation from a past event, a probable outflow of resources, and a reliable estimate of the amount β crucially, an outflow is probable when it is "more likely than not" to occur (greater than 50% probability). Contingent liabilities are never recognized but must be disclosed unless the possibility of outflow is remote, and contingent assets are never recognized but disclosed only when probable. The "best estimate" for measuring provisions uses expected value when there is a range of possible outcomes, as demonstrated in the warranty example, and provisions must be reviewed and adjusted at each balance sheet date.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
-
What are the three criteria that must ALL be met for a provision to be recognized under IAS 37?
-
Explain the difference between a legal obligation and a constructive obligation, providing one example of each.
-
In the warranty example, if past experience showed 70% no defects, 25% minor defects (cost Rs. 1 million), and 5% major defects (cost Rs. 5 million), what is the expected value of the provision?
-
When should a contingent liability be disclosed in the notes to the financial statements, and when should it be completely ignored ("do nothing")?
-
If a company initially recognized a provision of Rs. 15 million for a lawsuit but the case was settled for Rs. 12 million, how should the excess of Rs. 3 million be treated in the financial statements?
π Lecture 29 β IAS 8 ACCOUNTING POLICIES, CHANGES IN ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES AND ERRORS
π Overview: This lecture covers IAS 8, which governs how entities select and apply accounting policies, and how they account for changes in those policies and estimates, as well as corrections of prior period errors. Understanding this standard is crucial for ensuring consistency, comparability, and faithful representation of financial statements across periods.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with definitions of key terms: accounting policies, changes in accounting estimates, materiality, prior period errors, retrospective application, retrospective restatements, and prospective application. It then details the selection and application of accounting policies, including when to refer to Standards, Interpretations, and the Framework. The lecture explains when changes in accounting policies are permitted and how to apply them, including full worked examples on retrospective application and restatement of income statements and retained earnings for correcting prior period errors.
π Lecture Summary
LESSON # 29 IAS 8 ACCOUNTING POLICIES, CHANGES IN ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES AND ERRORS
This standard applies to selecting and applying accounting policies, and accounting for changes in those policies, changes in accounting estimates, and corrections of prior period errors.
DEFINITIONS:
Accounting policies: These are the specific principles, bases, conventions, rules and practices applied by an entity in preparing and presenting financial statements.
Change in accounting estimate: It is an adjustment of the carrying amount of an asset or a liability, or the amount of the periodic consumption of an asset, that results from the assessment of the present status of, and expected future benefits and obligations associated with, assets and liabilities. Changes in accounting estimates result from new information or new developments and, accordingly, are not corrections of errors.
π Example-1: English Limited acquired an asset. The company estimates its useful life 5 years i.e. future economic benefits shall be drawn from the asset in next 5 years. This is an accounting estimate. After 2 years, the company estimates its remaining useful life 4 years. There is a change in total useful life of the asset in the third year. This change is a change in accounting estimate.
Material: a) Omissions or misstatements of items are material if they could, individually or collectively, influence the economic decisions of users taken on the basis of the financial statements. b) Materiality depends on the size and nature of the omission or misstatement judged in the surrounding circumstances. c) The size or nature of the item, or a combination of both, could be the determining factor.
π Example-2 (Materiality): Ihsan Sports Private Limited is finalizing its financial statements for the year ended 30th June 2004. Draft financials: Sales Rs. 200,000,000; Gross profit Rs. 50,000,000; Net profit Rs. 20,000,000. a) Omitted sales of June: Rs. 10,000,000. b) Omitted stationery purchase on 30th June: Rs. 5,000.
Solution: Omitted sales are 5% of total sales and 50% of net profit, so it is material. Stationery is 0.0025% of sales and 0.025% of net profit, so it is immaterial.
Prior period errors: These are omissions from, and misstatements in, the entityβs financial statements for one or more prior periods arising from a failure to use, or misuse of, reliable information. Such errors include: mathematical mistakes, mistakes in applying accounting policies, oversights, misinterpretations of facts, and fraud.
Retrospective application: This is applying a new accounting policy to transactions, other events and conditions as if that policy had always been applied (i.e., the effect of the change for prior periods is calculated).
Retrospective restatements: This is correcting the recognition, measurement and disclosure of amounts of elements of financial statements as if a prior period error had never occurred (i.e., correction is made by restating the previous income statement and opening balance of previous periodsβ retained earnings).
Prospective application: This involves: a) Applying the new accounting policy to transactions, other events, and conditions occurring after the date the policy is changed; and b) Recognizing the effect of the change in accounting estimates in the current and future periods affected by the change.
ACCOUNTING POLICIES:
Selection and Application of Accounting Policies: When a Standard or Interpretation specifically applies to a transaction, the policy must be determined by applying that Standard. In the absence of a specific standard, management must use its judgment to develop a policy that provides information that is relevant and reliable (i.e., faithful representation, substance over form, neutral, prudent, and complete in all material respects).
In making this judgment, management must refer to sources in descending order:
- Requirements and guidance in Standards and Interpretations dealing with similar issues.
- The definitions, recognition criteria, and measurement concepts in the Conceptual Framework.
Consistency of Accounting Policies: An entity must select and apply accounting policies consistently for similar transactions, unless a Standard specifically requires or permits different policies for different categories.
CHANGES IN ACCOUNTING POLICIES:
An entity shall change an accounting policy only if the change: a) Is required by a Standard or an Interpretation; or b) Results in the financial statements providing reliable and more relevant information.
π Example-4 (Change in policy): i. Lasani Private Limited changes from LIFO to FIFO/Weighted Average (as required by revised IAS-2). This is a change required by a standard. ii. Pak Limited changes revenue recognition from "on dispatch" to "on approval" due to unreliable courier service. This provides more reliable and relevant information.
The following are NOT considered changes in accounting policies: a) Applying a policy for transactions that differ in substance from previous ones (e.g., borrowing costs for qualifying assets first time). b) Applying a new policy for transactions that did not occur previously or were immaterial.
The initial application of a policy to revalue assets (per IAS 16 or IAS 38) is treated as a revaluation, not under this standard.
APPLYING CHANGES IN ACCOUNTING POLICIES:
Retrospective Application: When a change in accounting policy is applied retrospectively, the entity shall adjust: a) The opening balance of each affected component of equity for the earliest prior period presented; and b) The other comparative amounts disclosed for each prior period presented, as if the new policy had always been applied.
π Solved Question (Aslam Engineering Ltd β Retrospective Application): Aslam Engineering Ltd changed its policy to expense borrowing costs instead of capitalizing them. In previous periods, Rs. 2,600 (2003) and Rs. 5,200 (before 2003) were capitalized. Tax rate: 30%. 2004 profit before interest & tax: Rs. 30,000; Interest expense: Rs. 3,000 (for 2004 only); Tax: Rs. 8,100. 2003 reported profit before interest & tax: Rs. 18,000; Interest: Rs. 0; Tax: Rs. 5,400; Profit: Rs. 12,600. 2003 opening retained earnings: Rs. 20,000; closing: Rs. 32,600.
Extract from Income Statement (Restated):
| 2004 (Rs.) | 2003 (Restated) (Rs.) | |
|---|---|---|
| Profit before interest & tax | 30,000 | 18,000 |
| Interest expense | (3,000) | (2,600) |
| Profit before tax | 27,000 | 15,400 |
| Income tax (30%) | (8,100) | (4,620) |
| Profit | 18,900 | 10,780 |
Statement of Retained Earnings (Extract):
| (Rs.) | |
|---|---|
| Balance at 31 Dec 2002 | 20,000 |
| Effect of change in accounting policy (Net of tax) | (3,640) |
| Balance at 31 Dec 2002 (Restated) | 16,360 |
| Profit for the year ended 31 Dec 2003 (Restated) | 10,780 |
| Balance at 31 Dec 2003 | 27,140 |
| Profit for the year ended 31 Dec 2004 | 18,900 |
| Balance at 31 Dec 2004 | 46,040 |
| π‘ Why this matters: The effect of the change (de-capitalization of Rs. 5,200 + Rs. 2,600 = Rs. 7,800; less tax effect of Rs. 2,340; net effect = Rs. 5,460) leads to an opening retained earnings adjustment of Rs. 5,460, but the solution shows a different adjustment (Rs. 3,640) due to a possible calculation error in the text, but the principle of retrospective restatement is clearly demonstrated. |
π Solved Question (Servis Shoes Limited β Voluntary Change): Servis Shoes Ltd changed revenue recognition from "on dispatch" to "on acknowledgment" due to dishonest employees causing shortages. Decrease in sales for prior years due to this change: Rs. 9,000, decrease in profit before tax: Rs. 3,000. For 2005: goods dispatched but not yet acknowledged: Rs. 1,500 (included in current P&L). For 2004: this amount was Rs. 1,000. Tax rate: 30%.
Profit & Loss Account (Restated):
| 2005 (Rs.) | 2004 (Restated) (Rs.) | |
|---|---|---|
| Sales (W-1) | 74,500 | 71,750 |
| Cost of sales | (49,667) | (47,833) |
| Gross profit (1/3 of sales) | 24,833 | 23,917 |
| Operating expenses | (7,500) | (7,750) |
| 17,333 | 16,167 | |
| Income Tax @ 30% | (5,200) | (4,850) |
| Net profit | 12,133 | 11,317 |
Statement of Retained Earnings (Extract) (Restated):
| (Rs.) | |
|---|---|
| Balance as at 31.3.2003 (W-2) | 5,400 |
| Profit for the year 2004 (restated) | 11,317 |
| 16,717 | |
| Dividend | (8,050) |
| Balance as at 31.3.2004 | 8,667 |
| Profit for the year 2005 | 12,133 |
| 20,800 | |
| Dividend | (10,250) |
| Balance as at 31.3.2005 | 10,550 |
(W-1) Adjusted sales for: 2005: 75,000 - 1,500 + 1,000 = 74,500; 2004: 72,750 - 1,000 = 71,750 (W-2) Opening retained earnings for 2003 were Rs. 7,500. The effect of the change on prior years' profits before tax was Rs. 3,000, thus a net decrease of Rs. 2,100 after tax (3,000 * 70%). So, opening retained earnings for 2003 (restated) = 7,500 - 2,100 = 5,400.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical points for the exam are: (1) Accounting policy changes are applied retrospectively, adjusting the opening balance of retained earnings for the earliest period presented and restating comparatives as if the new policy always applied. (2) Changes in accounting estimates are applied prospectively, affecting only the current and future periods. (3) Prior period errors are corrected through retrospective restatement, requiring a restated opening retained earnings and restated comparative financial statements. (4) A change in accounting policy is only allowed if required by a standard or if it provides more reliable and relevant information. (5) Materiality is a key concept: omissions or misstatements that could influence user decisions are considered material and must be corrected.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- An entity changes its depreciation method from straight-line to reducing balance. According to IAS 8, is this a change in accounting policy or a change in accounting estimate?
- How is a change in accounting policy applied when there is no specific transitional provision in the Standard?
- A company discovers a mathematical error from 3 years ago that overstated its profit for that year. How should this be corrected in the current year's financial statements?
- What is the key difference between "retrospective application" and "prospective application"?
- An entity voluntarily changes its inventory valuation method. What should be adjusted in the financial statements to reflect this change?
π Lecture 30 β IAS 8 ACCOUNTING POLICIES, CHANGES IN ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES AND ERRORS
π Overview: This lecture focuses on how to account for changes in accounting estimates and correction of prior period errors under IAS 8. It distinguishes between retrospective application (for policy changes and errors) and prospective recognition (for estimate changes), providing worked examples for depreciation estimate changes and inventory error corrections.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the definition and sources of accounting estimates (e.g., doubtful debts, useful lives), the prospective recognition requirement for changes in estimates, a solved example on changing a depreciable asset's useful life and residual value, the nature and retrospective correction of prior period errors, and a detailed solved example on correcting an inventory overstatement error with comparative restatement and tax effects.
π Lecture Summary
CHANGES IN ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES:
Due to business uncertainties, many financial statement items cannot be measured with precision but only estimated based on the latest reliable information. Examples of items requiring estimation include: doubtful debts, inventory obsolescence, the fair value of financial assets/liabilities, the useful lives and consumption patterns of depreciable assets, and warranty obligations.
π Definition β Change in accounting estimate: An adjustment of the carrying amount of an asset or liability, or the amount of periodic consumption, that results from the assessment of the present status and expected future benefits/obligations associated with that asset or liability.
The effect of a change in an accounting estimate is recognized prospectively, meaning it is applied from the date of the change forward. It is included in profit or loss: a) In the period of change only, if the change affects only that period (e.g., change in bad debt estimate). b) In the period of change and future periods, if the change affects both (e.g., change in asset useful life).
To the extent a change in estimate gives rise to changes in assets, liabilities, or equity items, it is recognized by adjusting the carrying amount of the related item in the period of change.
π‘ Why this matters: Unlike changes in accounting policy, changes in estimates are NOT applied retrospectively. You do not restate prior periods β you simply adjust the current and future period calculations.
π Prospective Recognition Rule: Change is applied to transactions, other events, and conditions from the date of the change in estimate.
π Example β Bad Debts: A change in the estimate of bad debts affects only the current periodβs profit or loss and is recognized in the current period only.
π Example β Depreciable Asset: A change in the estimated useful life of a depreciable asset affects depreciation expense for the current period AND all future periods during the assetβs remaining useful life. The effect on future periods is recognized as expense in those future periods.
Solved Example β Change in Useful Life and Residual Value
Scenario: Idrees Sports Private Limited purchased an asset with:
- Cost Price = Rs. 2,500,000
- Estimated useful life = 10 years
- Estimated residual value = Rs. 100,000
In the third year, the company re-estimates:
- Useful life = 6 years total (from original purchase)
- Residual value = Rs. 220,000
The company uses straight-line depreciation.
Required: Account for this change in accounting estimate in the financial statements for the third year.
Solution β Extract from Cost of Goods Sold Statement:
| Rs | |
|---|---|
| Manufacturing Expenses β Depreciation (W-2) | 300,000 |
Note: This change in accounting estimate has been accounted for prospectively.
Working (W-1): Calculation for Years 1 & 2
| Year | Cost (Rs) | Depreciable Amount (Rs) | Depreciation Rate (W-3) | Depreciation Amount (Rs) | Book Value (Rs) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2,500,000 | 2,400,000 | 10% | 240,000 | 2,260,000 |
| 2 | 2,400,000 | 10% | 240,000 | 2,020,000 |
Working (W-2): Calculation from Year 3 Onward (Prospective)
| Year | Carrying Amount (Rs) | Depreciable Amount (Rs) | Depreciation Rate (W-4) | Depreciation Amount (Rs) | Book Value (Rs) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | 2,020,000 | 1,800,000 | 16.67% | 300,000 | 1,720,000 |
| 4 | 16.67% | 300,000 | 1,420,000 | ||
| 5 | 16.67% | 300,000 | 1,120,000 | ||
| 6 | 16.67% | 300,000 | 820,000 | ||
| 7 | 16.67% | 300,000 | 520,000 | ||
| 8 | 16.67% | 300,000 | 220,000 |
Calculation of Depreciable Amount (Year 3 onward): Carrying Amount (2,020,000) β Residual Value (220,000) = Rs. 1,800,000
Working (W-3): Depreciation Rate in First Two Years Depreciation Rate = 1 / Estimated Useful Life Γ 100 = 1/10 Γ 100 = 10%
Working (W-4): Depreciation Rate from Third Year Depreciation Rate = 1 / Estimated Useful Life Γ 100 = 1/6 Γ 100 = 16.67%
Key Point: Notice that you do NOT go back and correct the depreciation for Years 1 and 2. You take the current book value (Rs. 2,020,000), subtract the new residual value (Rs. 220,000), and depreciate the remaining amount (Rs. 1,800,000) over the remaining useful life (6 years total β 2 years already used = 4 years remaining? No β the problem states the estimate is for a total 6-year useful life from the start, meaning the remaining life is 6 β 2 = 4 years. The depreciation rate is calculated as 1/6 = 16.67% per year on the depreciable amount).
Disclosure Requirements: An entity shall disclose:
- The nature and amount of the change in accounting estimate that has an effect in the current period or is expected to have an effect in future periods.
- If it is impracticable to estimate the future effect, that fact must be disclosed.
ERRORS
π Definition β Prior period errors: Omissions from, and misstatements in, the entityβs financial statements for one or more prior periods arising from a failure to use or misuse of reliable information that was available when the statements were authorized for issue.
Key Characteristics: a) Errors can arise in recognition, measurement, presentation, or disclosure of financial statement elements. b) Financial statements do NOT comply with IFRSs if they contain material errors or immaterial errors made intentionally to achieve a particular presentation. c) Current period errors discovered in that period are corrected before the financial statements are authorized for issue. d) Material prior period errors discovered in a subsequent period are corrected in the comparative information presented.
Correction Method (Retrospective Restatement): If it is not impracticable, an entity shall correct prior period errors retrospectively in the first set of financial statements authorized for issue after their discovery by: a) Restating the comparative amounts for the prior period(s) presented in which the error occurred; OR b) If the error occurred before the earliest prior period presented, restating the opening balances of assets, liabilities, and equity for the earliest prior period presented.
Solved Example β Correction of Prior Period Error (Inventory Overstatement)
Scenario: During 2008, Saleem Co discovered that products sold during 2007 were incorrectly included in inventory at 31 December 2007 at Rs. 6,500.
2008 Data:
- Sales: Rs. 104,000
- Cost of goods sold (COGS): Rs. 86,500 (includes Rs. 6,500 error in opening inventory)
- Income taxes: Rs. 5,250
2007 Reported Data:
| Rs | |
|---|---|
| Sales | 73,500 |
| Cost of goods sold | (53,500) |
| Profit before income taxes | 20,000 |
| Income taxes (30%) | (6,000) |
| Profit | 14,000 |
Other Information:
- 2007 opening retained earnings: Rs. 20,000
- 2007 closing retained earnings: Rs. 34,000
- Income tax rate: 30% for both 2007 and 2008
- Share capital: Rs. 50,000 (no other equity components)
Solution β Saleem Coβs Extract from Income Statement (Restated):
| 2008 (Rs) | 2007 (Restated) (Rs) | |
|---|---|---|
| Sales | 104,000 | 73,500 |
| Cost of goods sold | (80,000) | (60,000) |
| Profit before income taxes | 24,000 | 13,500 |
| Income taxes (30%) | (7,200) | (4,050) |
| Profit | 16,800 | 9,450 |
Explanation of Adjustments:
For 2007 (Restated):
- The error overstated ending inventory for 2007 by Rs. 6,500.
- Ending inventory becomes opening inventory for the next period. An overstatement of opening inventory overstates COGS.
- Correction to 2007 COGS: Original COGS (53,500) + Error (6,500) = Rs. 60,000
- Correction to 2007 Profit before tax: Original (20,000) β Error (6,500) = Rs. 13,500
- Correction to 2007 Income tax: 30% of 13,500 = Rs. 4,050
- Correction to 2007 Profit: 13,500 β 4,050 = Rs. 9,450
For 2008:
- The 2007 ending inventory error (Rs. 6,500) was included in 2008βs opening inventory.
- 2008 reported COGS was Rs. 86,500 (including the Rs. 6,500 error).
- Correction to 2008 COGS: 86,500 β 6,500 = Rs. 80,000
- Correction to 2008 Profit before tax: (104,000 β 80,000) = Rs. 24,000
- Correction to 2008 Income tax: 30% of 24,000 = Rs. 7,200
- Correction to 2008 Profit: 24,000 β 7,200 = Rs. 16,800
β Key Takeaways
Changes in accounting estimates are accounted for prospectively β current and future periods are adjusted, but prior periods are never restated. In contrast, prior period errors are corrected retrospectively by restating comparative amounts and adjusting retained earnings. The solved depreciation example shows how to calculate the new carrying amount, subtract the new residual value, and depreciate over the remaining useful life using the new rate. The inventory error example demonstrates how an overstatement of ending inventory leads to an overstatement of opening inventory in the next period, requiring restatement of both periods' COGS, profit before tax, income tax, and profit. Always consider the tax effect when correcting errors, as shown by the 30% tax rate adjustment in the example.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
-
What is the fundamental difference between how changes in accounting estimates and correction of prior period errors are applied in financial statements?
-
In the Idrees Sports example, why is the depreciation for years 1 and 2 (Rs. 240,000 each) not changed even though the useful life estimate changed from 10 years to 6 years?
-
In the Saleem Co example, explain why the 2008 COGS decreases by Rs. 6,500 while the restated 2007 COGS increases by the same amount.
-
What disclosures are required for a change in accounting estimate that affects both the current period and future periods?
-
If a change in accounting estimate gives rise to a change in an asset's carrying amount, how should this be recognized according to IAS 8?