π Lecture Summary
Topic-170: Introduction to Negotiated Syllabus
A negotiated syllabus involves the teacher and the learners working together to make decisions at many levels of the curriculum design process. It is also called "process syllabus" (Breen, 1987). The word "process" indicates that the important feature of this type of syllabus is that it focuses on how the syllabus is made rather than what should be in it.
Clarke (1991) sees the interest in negotiated syllabuses arising from humanistic methodologies like community language learning which are very learner-centered, needs analysis which focuses on learners' needs, work in individualization and learner autonomy, and learner strategy research which sees the learner playing a central role in determining how language is learned. Breen and Littlejohn (2000) list situations where a negotiated syllabus is almost unavoidable:
- Where the teacher and students have different backgrounds
- Where time is short and the most useful choices must be made
- Where there is a very diverse group of students and there is a need to find common ground
- Where initial needs analysis is not possible
- Where there is no course book
- Where the students' past experiences must be part of the course
- Where the course is open-ended and exploratory
π Definition β Negotiated Syllabus: A syllabus in which teachers and learners collaboratively make decisions about various aspects of curriculum design, focusing on the process of how the syllabus is created rather than predetermined content.
Topic-171: An Example of a Negotiated Syllabus
The example involves a class of adult graduate students preparing for post-graduate university study through English, coming from a wide variety of countries and disciplines.
The negotiation process proceeds as follows:
- For the first two weeks, the teacher follows a set programme involving a large variety of activities
- After two weeks, the teacher announces it is time for learners to take an active part in deciding what to do
- The teacher and class members list activities on the board, then working in small groups discuss what should be removed and added
- The next step is to rank the items and fit them into the class timetable, done in small groups and then with the whole class β during this discussion, learners negotiate with each other and with the teacher
- The resulting timetable becomes the plan for the next one or two weeks
- The teacher sometimes calls on learners to help prepare materials to cope with short preparation time
This is described as a conservative example because the class did not start with a negotiated syllabus from the very first day. The reasons include:
- Many learners came from backgrounds where teachers are highly respected and would feel uncomfortable telling the teacher what to do β the first two weeks allow learners to realize the teacher can be trusted
- Most learners had not experienced a pre-university course before, so the teacher wanted to show the range of goals and activities available
- The teacher wanted to show what they saw as important and what they taught well, hoping to influence later negotiation
- The teacher wanted to develop credibility before passing much control to the class
After trial and error, negotiation of an MA teaching methodology course was best done by presenting course members with a draft syllabus in which some items were non-negotiable, but many items and procedures were negotiable. Adding to the draft necessarily involved removing something to provide a place for the new topic. This use of a draft syllabus satisfied course members who felt uncomfortable with a completely negotiated syllabus, made negotiation more focused and efficient, and effectively dealt with the wide range of experience among course members.
π Example: A class of adult graduate students from diverse countries prepares for post-graduate study in English. The teacher follows a set programme for two weeks, then invites learners to list, discuss, rank, and schedule activities together. Groups report back, the board is revised, and the resulting timetable governs the next one to two weeks of class.
Topic-172: Requirements for a Negotiated Syllabus
Breen (1987) describes the decisions to be negotiated and the materials needed to make the syllabus work.
Negotiation procedure: How will the negotiation be carried out? When will it be done? How often will it be done? Who has the responsibility for organizing it? Who has the responsibility for checking that what is negotiated is actually done?
Course planning: participation: Who will work with whom? The range of answers includes individual work, pair work, groups working with the teacher, and the teacher working with the whole class.
Course planning: procedure: What kinds of activity will be worked on? The range of answers includes role play, information gap tasks, guided writing, extensive reading, and oral drills. Additional decisions include how long each activity will be worked on, how it will be worked on, and how the results will be assessed.
π Definition β Negotiation Procedure: The agreed-upon method for carrying out negotiations, including timing, frequency, and responsibility allocation for organizing and monitoring the negotiated decisions.
π Definition β Course Planning (Participation): Decisions about who works with whom, ranging from individual work through pairs and groups to whole-class instruction.
π Definition β Course Planning (Procedure): Decisions about what kinds of activities will be used, their duration, methodology, and assessment methods.
Topic-173: Syllabuses with Some Elements Negotiated
Breen's description represents one end of the scale. It is possible to have a syllabus where some parts or aspects are negotiated while others remain under the teacher's or curriculum designer's control (Clarke, 1989).
Possible ways of dividing up the syllabus include:
- A fixed lesson or time of the day is set aside for negotiated activities (e.g., an hour each Friday afternoon)
- One or more of the four types of decisions (participation, procedure, learning goals, evaluation) is open for negotiation β Clarke (1989) suggests teachers encourage learners to take over some assessment activity
- Classes for one or more language skills, such as free-speaking activities, are planned through negotiation
- One or more parts of the inner circle of the curriculum design diagram is open to negotiation
π‘ Why this matters: This flexible approach allows teachers to gradually implement negotiation without completely surrendering control, making it more practical and acceptable in various educational contexts and cultural settings.
Topic-174: Negotiating Assessment
Several reports focus on negotiation of assessment and evaluation because this has direct effects on goals and ways of achieving them.
Breen and Littlejohn (2000) identify four major factors affecting feedback through assessment:
- The extent to which students are aware of the criteria being used
- The relative emphasis given to what they have achieved as compared with what they have failed to achieve
- The coincidence between what the feedback focuses upon and what the students themselves have recognized as particularly difficult
- Whether or not they believe they can act on the basis of the feedback in a way that solves a recognized problem
Smith (2000) describes a very effective way of negotiating assessment where assessment includes not only the results of tests and assigned tasks, but also participation in class, homework, and class projects. The idea of a negotiated syllabus raises questions about the role of the teacher and the role of the commercially produced textbook (Richards, 1993).
π Definition β Negotiated Assessment: An approach where assessment criteria, methods, and feedback mechanisms are collaboratively determined by teachers and learners, encompassing tests, tasks, participation, homework, and projects.
Topic-175: Disadvantages and Advantages of a Negotiated Syllabus
Disadvantages are of two major types. The first results from lack of knowledge or experience with such a syllabus:
- Learners may be reluctant to negotiate because they feel it should be the teacher's expertise guiding the course (gradual introduction can provide learner training to overcome this)
- Learners may not know enough of the range of options and thus may make unimaginative choices
- Teachers may feel using a negotiated syllabus removes too much of their power and status
- Learners may find it difficult to reach agreement about what they should be doing
The second major disadvantage is that a fully negotiated syllabus requires considerable teacher skill and time in accessing and producing resources. Where there are several teachers with similar classes, this load can be partly shared.
Solutions: Breen (1987) suggests using simple questionnaires, introduced and clarified through class discussion, to gather learners' opinions on what kinds of activities should be used. Because these questionnaires are done at the local class level, changes are relatively easy to make, and learners feel their opinions are being considered and acted upon.
Advantages come largely from the syllabus's responsiveness to learners' "wants" and the involvement of the learners:
- All courses have to adjust to the reality of the teaching situation, and the negotiated syllabus gives clear recognition to this
- Involving learners in shaping the syllabus has a strong effect on motivation, satisfaction, and commitment to the course
- The course changes from being the teacher's course to the learners' course
- If negotiation is carried out in English, this may be some of the most involving meaning-focused activity in the programme
- The negotiation develops learners' awareness of the goals of language-learning activities and how these goals can be achieved, which may make them better learners
π‘ Why this matters: While negotiated syllabuses present challenges related to learner readiness and teacher workload, their benefits in terms of learner motivation, ownership, and meaningful language use make them valuable. Each disadvantage has potential solutions, and if the advantages are seen as substantial, the disadvantages need to be addressed rather than avoided.
β Key Takeaways
A negotiated syllabus, also called a process syllabus, fundamentally shifts curriculum design from teacher-determined content to collaborative decision-making between teachers and learners. The approach requires careful planning of negotiation procedures, participation structures, and activity selection, with assessment being a particularly important area for negotiation. While disadvantages include learner reluctance, limited awareness of options, teacher status concerns, and increased workload, these can be addressed through gradual introduction, draft syllabuses with non-negotiable elements, and questionnaires. The major advantages are enhanced learner motivation, ownership, satisfaction, and the development of metacognitive awareness about language learning goals and processes.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What distinguishes a "process syllabus" from traditional syllabuses, and why is the term "process" significant?
- List four situations where Breen and Littlejohn (2000) argue a negotiated syllabus is almost unavoidable.
- In the example of adult graduate students, why did the teacher choose NOT to begin with negotiation on the first day?
- What are the four major factors affecting feedback through assessment according to Breen and Littlejohn (2000)?
- State two disadvantages and two advantages of a negotiated syllabus, and explain how the disadvantage of learner reluctance can be addressed.
π Lecture 27 β Appropriate Design: Feeding and Bleeding of Course Units
π Overview: This lecture explores the principles and approaches for designing coherent language course units, focusing on how to structure, sequence, and balance learning activities. It addresses critical perspectives on material design, including the relationship between input and uptake, and emphasizes the importance of creating materials that foster independent learning and meaningful engagement.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture examines the concept of course units and their structure, including traditional unit design with presentation, controlled exploitation, free exploitation, and synthesis phases. It analyzes two key sequencing approaches: the writing-last solution and storyline solution, along with their respective criticisms. The lecture also covers coherence among course units, perspectives on materials design beyond language learning, and the crucial distinction between input and uptake in language learning materials.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-177: Appropriate Design: Feeding and Bleeding of Course Units
A course unit refers to the learning tasks included in a particular language syllabus, distinct from an individual lesson. The traditional unit structure follows four phases: Presentation (introducing new material), Controlled exploitation (guided practice), Free exploitation (independent practice), and Synthesis (integrating learned elements). Material designers must ensure exercises show coherent connection between various lessons, maintaining a clear relationship between presenting material and designing exercises.
Topic-178: Appropriate Design: Sequences of Activities in Course Units
Graham Low (2006) proposes two key approaches to sequencing activities. The first is the writing-last solution, where a unit ends with a writing task, primarily emphasizing grammatical acquisition. However, this approach can neglect listening and speaking activities. The solution involves multiple presentation designs that incorporate all four language strands: reading, writing, listening, and speaking.
The second approach is the storyline solution, which creates harmony throughout the unit by sequencing activities within a storyline situation. This approach focuses on both form and meaning of language. Designers must be aware of emotion and character elements to ensure students do not feel detached from the storyline.
π Definition β Multiple Presentation Designs: Presenting the four strands of language learning (reading, writing, listening, and speaking) throughout the course unit rather than focusing on one skill.
Topic-179: Appropriate Design: Criticism on Materials
Both writing-last and storyline solution approaches have been criticized for creating a learner-as-observer syndrome, where learners remain at the center but may not actively engage. Low (2006) states that if learners cannot relate to what is presented in a unit, they may suffer from language learning syndrome. The solution involves using models and simulations to increase student attachment to the content.
For storyline situations where students cannot identify with characters or emotions, creative exploitation techniques or role-play exercises should be employed to enhance engagement.
π Definition β Learner-as-Observer Syndrome: A condition where learners are placed at the center of instruction but remain passive observers rather than active participants, potentially hindering language acquisition.
Topic-180: Appropriate Design: Coherence of Course Units
Coherence is a systematic approach to aligning and sequencing specific ideas and determining the depth to which those ideas are examined, promoting integrated understanding in learners. Designing balance between units requires a blend of imagination, insight, understanding, and analytical reasoning. Material designers must be both critical and practical. A coherent curriculum builds ideas across time and disciplines by connecting topics and aligning instructional materials, instruction, and assessment, ensuring more student involvement.
π‘ Why this matters: Coherence ensures that students build connections between concepts rather than learning isolated skills, leading to deeper, more transferable language competence.
Topic-181: Beyond Language Learning: Perspectives on Materials Design Introduction
Pardo and Tellez (2009) define material design as: "It includes adaptation, creation of learning and teaching exercises; a task, an activity, a lesson, a unit or a module composed of several units." The main focus is on outcome β how material affects learner's perceptions and perspectives. Designers must consider how actual students will react to material and how it demonstrates learner's needs. The six areas examined under this notion are:
- General or subject knowledge
- View of what knowledge is and how it is acquired
- View of what is involved in language learning
- Role relations
- Cognitive abilities
- Values and attitudes presented in the material
Topic-182: Beyond Language Learning: Perspectives on Materials Design Input and Uptake by Learners
Understanding input and uptake is crucial in language material design. Input refers to exposure of language given to students through various sources, either written or spoken. The teacher is a primary source of input, and the classroom environment where students interact also contributes to establishing input.
Uptake refers to posing questions to students to assess what they have learned and internalized through classroom activities. Well-designed material exposes students to language modalities, enhancing both input and output (what students actually learn from activities). It also enhances stimulation and reflection in learners. Materials should be designed to create independent learners who can think clearly and question acquired knowledge.
π Definition β Input: The exposure of language given to students in the classroom through various sources, either written or spoken.
π Definition β Uptake: The process of posing questions to students to assess what they have learned and internalized through classroom activities.
π Example: A teacher presents a dialogue (input), students practice it, and then the teacher asks comprehension questions (uptake) to determine what students have actually learned from the activity.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture establishes that effective course unit design requires careful attention to structure, sequencing, and coherence. Traditional unit structure follows a presentation-controlled exploitation-free exploitation-synthesis pattern, while sequencing can follow either the writing-last or storyline approach, each with specific strengths and weaknesses. Criticisms of these approaches highlight the learner-as-observer syndrome, which can be addressed through models, simulations, role-play, and creative exploitation techniques. Coherence among units is essential for integrated understanding and requires a blend of imagination, insight, and analytical reasoning. Finally, material design extends beyond language learning to encompass learner perspectives, cognitive abilities, and values, with well-designed materials enhancing both input and uptake while fostering independent, reflective learners.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four phases of the traditional unit structure, and what does each involve?
- Compare the writing-last solution and storyline solution approaches to sequencing activities β what are their respective strengths and weaknesses?
- What is the "learner-as-observer syndrome," and what solutions does Low propose to address it?
- How does coherence among course units contribute to student learning, and what skills does a material designer need to achieve it?
- Distinguish between input and uptake in language learning, and explain how well-designed materials contribute to both.
π Lecture 28 β Appropriate Design: Internal Organization of Course Units -II
π Overview: This lecture explores how language teaching materials can serve purposes beyond language learning itself, examining the "carrier content" embedded in materials and its impact on learners. It critically analyzes how materials shape learners' perceptions of knowledge, language learning, role relations, and social values, concluding with a framework for evaluating these hidden dimensions.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture examines six key areas beyond language learning: the use of carrier content for additional learning, specialist subject knowledge integration, views about language learning presented through materials, role relations and classroom interaction frames, and the broader notion of going beyond language learning goals. It provides a set of evaluative questions for materials design and concludes with an introduction to the hidden curriculum concept in Lesson 29.
π Lecture Summary
Beyond Language Learning: Perspectives on Materials Design
Materials offer opportunities for additional learning through their carrier contentβthe thematic content used as a basis for language work. While most frequently fictional, this content can address wider educational goals by including texts about the natural world, social world, or famous people. Cook (1983) outlines possibilities for 'real content' including: i) another academic subject, ii) student-contributed content, iii) language itself, iv) literature, v) culture, and vi) 'interesting facts'. Two additional categories are proposed: 'learning itself' and 'specialist content'.
π Definition β Carrier Content: The thematic or subject matter content used as a vehicle for language work in teaching materials.
π‘ Why this matters: Carrier content determines whether learners gain only language skills or also acquire knowledge about the world, learning strategies, or professional expertise.
Beyond Language Learning: Subject Knowledge
Specialist content materials for specific purposes often fail to interest learners because they present familiar professional topics in a conventional or simpleminded manner (Hutchinson and Waters, 1984). To remedy this, materials should use content about which learners have reasonable background knowledge but with a new or unusual slant. This provides greater opportunities for additional learning outcomes through working with both language and content.
π Example: A course book for business correspondence uses simulations where learners, working in groups representing companies (e.g., a soft drinks manufacturer), make business decisions and write letters accordingly. Role cards provide specific business scenarios requiring decisions about equipment and correspondence.
Beyond Language Learning: Views about Language Learning
Stubbs (2014) argues that the selection, classification, and weighting of subjects in the school timetable defines what counts as legitimate educational knowledge. FLT materials in discrete textbooks both result from and reinforce subject divisions, explaining why much FLT material appears bland and content-less. The organization of materials and activities contributes to forming pupils' perception of the nature of school knowledge and how it is arrived at.
This is most evident in grammar teaching. Despite grammarians' discomfort with making definitive statements about grammatical explanations, most learners and teachers believe clear, unequivocal rules are possible. This image derives from the tone and organization of grammar books, which admit no suggestion that rules are mere hypotheses.
π Definition β Frame (Bernstein, 2004): The actual relationship between teachers and pupils and the range of choices they have over what is done between them. A strong frame reduces the pupil's power over what, when, and how they receive knowledge.
Beyond Language Learning: Role Relations, Opportunities, Values and Attitudes
Learner interpretation is the key variable in determining actual learning outcomes. Materials must be considered in terms of what they suggest for learning classroom roles. The crucial factor is not only how learners interpret materials but also what actually happens in the classroom.
The concept of a 'frame' (Bernstein, 2004) examines role relations suggested by materials. Stubbs (2014) relates this to the IRF discourse structure (teacher initiates/pupil responds/teacher feedback) identified by Sinclair and Coulthard (2014). Numerous language teaching materials suggest this discourse structure for classroom work.
Beyond Language Learning: Notion of Going Beyond Language Learning
Materials contribute to learners' perceptions (of knowledge, language learning, and roles), their affective and cognitive development, and their general stock of information about the world. A set of basic questions can focus the attempt to look beyond language learning:
- Do the materials extend the learner's 'general' or 'specialist' knowledge?
- What view of knowledge do the materials present?
- Do the materials develop learners' understanding of language learning?
- How do materials structure the teacher-learner relationship?
- Do materials develop learners' general cognitive abilities?
- What social values and attitudes do the materials present?
π‘ Why this matters: At the design stage, examining materials from multiple perspectives identifies aspects needing rethinking, supplementing, or abandoning, ensuring unintentional features match the expressed philosophies of designers.
Hidden Curriculum β Definitions
The hidden curriculum was introduced by Jackson (1986) in contrast with the formal curriculum, drawing attention to learning outcomes apart from those intended in the manifest curriculum. Hedge (2000) defines it as learning that goes on covertly beneath the surface of what the teacher sets out to teach, encompassing shaping of learners' perceptions about learning, their own role, the nature of the subject, and attitudes.
Farrel and Jacobs (2010) regard the hidden curriculum as "the knowledge, values, and beliefs that schools present to students." According to Wikipedia, it is a side effect of education including lessons learned but not openly intended. Barnes (1982) identifies two common characteristics: (1) they are unintended, not part of any teacher's objectives; (2) they tend to be social learning about what people expect and how to cope.
Scholars use different terms: Johnson (1989) uses 'hidden syllabus' and 'alternative curriculum' for teacher practices not conforming to official requirements. Nunan (1989) uses 'hidden agenda' to imply learners have their own agendas that determine what they take from lessons.
The working definition for language classrooms: everything carried out by the teacher and learner that is not planned or required by the official curriculum.
Hidden Curriculum in Terms of Teachers and Learners
Teachers convey socially-approved knowledge unconsciously while teaching the official curriculum. This includes social-moral habits, attitudes, informal school rules, and beliefs such as obedience, conscientiousness, punctuality, gender identity, and political awareness. Teachers reward hard-working, active learners while showing disapproval to late or lazy students, teaching students what constitutes a good pupil.
Teachers also teach in ways inconsistent with the official curriculum. Johnson (1989) notes that validation criteria from outside agencies constitute a new hidden curriculum. Pragmatic constraints include time, money, school leader values, and examination pressures. Teachers' qualifications, experience, preferred strategies, and target language proficiency also influence teaching acts.
π Example: Joseph O. Birdsong's article on teaching poetry in Nigeria shows that while the National Curriculum envisages an 'English studies' program blending language and literature, teachers avoid literature or make half-hearted attempts due to lack of confidence in handling literary texts.
Language Teachers Coping with the Hidden Curriculum
The mismatches between official and hidden curriculum cannot be eliminated completely but can be minimized. First, the hidden curriculum should be uncovered, discussed, and analyzed rather than avoided. Teachers should conduct self-examination through questions like: What must pupils do to gain my approval? What behavior do I reward or ignore?
Second, schools should provide continuous in-service teacher training to help teachers gain deep insights into the official curriculum and improve necessary knowledge and skills. Teachers should maintain an open and objective mind with the concept "Life is a learning process."
Third, a scientific, revisable, and on-going evaluation system should be constructed to evaluate both process and product in curriculum development, detecting problems with the hidden curriculum.
The existence of a hidden curriculum is a threat to successful implementation of the official curriculum. Language teachers should face it positively, uncover it, discuss it, and resolve problems it brings.
Hidden Agendas: Role of Learner in Program Implementation
Curriculum implementation involves dissemination of structured learning experiences, provision of resources, and actual execution in the classroom where teacher-learner interactions occur. Learners are critical elements, holding the key to what is actually translated and adopted from the official curriculum.
Learners influence teachers in selecting learning experiences because schools consist of multiple levels and class grades requiring preparation for disparities between slow and quick learners. The learner plays the role of exhibiting desirable discipline through maximum obedience to school rules, attending classwork, and completing assignments, tests, and examinations. For effective implementation, the learner should be physically, mentally, and emotionally available to the teacher.
Hidden Agendas: Practical Implications
Hidden agendas help teachers bridge the gap between planning, teaching, and learning objectives. Teachers should explicitly state course goals and objectives to students, and be aware of learners' perceptions and preconceptions. The curriculum should not be followed slavishly; teachers should take charge to redefine it when needed. There is no direct equation between planning and implementation of hidden curriculumβsometimes teaching must be adjusted according to needs, situations, and hidden agendas.
β Key Takeaways
Materials design must consider not just language learning but also how carrier content, subject knowledge, and organizational structure shape learners' perceptions of knowledge, learning, and social roles. The hidden curriculum operates through teachers' unconscious transmission of social values and through discrepancies between official requirements and actual classroom practices. Language teachers must actively uncover, discuss, and analyze hidden curricula through self-examination and reflection, recognizing that learners bring their own hidden agendas that influence what they take from lessons. Continuous in-service training and systematic evaluation processes help minimize mismatches between official and hidden curricula. There is no direct equation between planning and implementationβteachers must flexibly adjust teaching according to learner needs, situations, and hidden agendas.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are Cook's six categories of 'real content' that can be used in language teaching materials, and what two additional categories are proposed?
- How does Bernstein's concept of 'frame' relate to the IRF discourse structure in language teaching materials?
- What are the six basic questions used to evaluate materials beyond language learning outcomes?
- What is the working definition of the hidden curriculum in language classrooms, and what are the two common characteristics identified by Barnes?
- What three strategies can language teachers use to cope with and minimize the negative effects of the hidden curriculum?
π Lecture 29 β Curriculum Design-ENG519
π Overview: This lecture explores the evaluation of language learning tasks, classroom research limitations, and the theoretical framework for curriculum implementation. It also introduces the role of testing, monitoring, and assessment in language curriculum design, covering various test types and their practical applications for effective course delivery.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the evaluation cycle for language tasks as projected by Breen, the role of teachers in evaluating tasks, Stern's metaphor of "seeing the wood and the trees" regarding classroom research limitations, and the theoretical framework for curriculum implementation. It then shifts to testing in language curriculum design, including characteristics of tests, placement and progress testing, guidelines for monitoring and assessment, and various types of assessment such as placement, diagnostic, achievement, and proficiency assessment.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-194: Evaluation Cycle for Language Tasks
Tasks have much more efficacy in promoting knowledge, capabilities, and skills among second language learners. Dividing units into tasks is more useful for teaching better understanding of concepts. For example, rather than just teaching about verb or noun, teachers can create different tasks where students learn better while performing them. These tasks promote knowledge through language. Michael Breen (1987) considered tasks as the springboard for knowledge and capabilities. Tasks give liberty to bring in meaning-based and focused learning.
The quality of a task can be evaluated in terms of how it offers means for learning and new ways for promoting knowledge. There are different criteria of task as projected by Breen: 1) How it addresses learners' definition of progress, 2) Are learners progressive to the demands of a target language, and 3) How the tasks are open to diversity and change. Tasks can promote knowledge, skills, and capabilities only if learners are open to accept change and diversity and are more responsive towards needs, wants, and challenges.
Breen listed tasks into three different phases:
- Task as a work plan allows teachers to make groundwork to know preconceptions and past learning experiences of students, giving opportunity to see what students want in the classroom.
- Task in process creates the relationship between teacher and student during the processing of task.
- Task outcomes help to analyze what has already been learnt.
Topic-195: The Role of Teacher
A teacher plays a vital role in evaluating language learning tasks while implementing curriculum in the language classroom context. Breen lists different roles where a language instructor must look for these questions:
- To what extent was the task appropriate to learning objectives?
- To what extent was the content helpful?
- To what extent did the chosen procedure prove to be appropriate?
- What knowledge was contributed to the task?
- What was familiar?
- What was discovered?
- What do we actually do while working on a task?
- What did we discover about each other's contributions during the task?
- What did we discover about the classroom and materials?
Topic-196: Seeing the Wood and the Trees: Thoughts on LT Analysis Introduction
H.H. Stern (1983) looks at the classroom as a dynamic entity where much more is going on than expected. He draws teachers' attention to an insightful aspect that should be integral to language curriculum design. He projects that teachers often focus only on what actually takes place in the classroom and tend to overlook the significance of broader issues that occur outside the classroom.
Stern projects a metaphorical comparison that the teacher as researcher has an inability that 'we fail to notice the wood for the trees'. According to Stern, we see trees but do not distinguish between trees and wood. We look at classroom discourse but overlook the significance of broader issues outside the classroom.
Stern makes an interesting point that audiolingualism and cognitivism have changed the direction from language teaching to language learning. In the paradigm shift from language teaching to learning, instead of looking at language learning from the perspective of a method, much more focus is being paid to the learning process.
Topic-197: Limitations of Classroom Research
Classroom research is limited in terms of looking at the teacher at grass root level. Stern believes this can be seen in the perspective of changes and emphasis on language teaching analysis. For example, the method era paved the way for audiolingualism and cognitivism, shifting focus from language teaching to language learning.
The researcher believes that very few efforts have been made in implementing curriculum at classroom level, and it is the teacher who can be trusted with responsibility to ensure this implementation. The findings of classroom research can be related to:
- Policy specifications
- Theoretical approach
Topic-198: Theoretical Framework
Theoretical framework, as projected by Sterns, offers a remedy to limited classroom research regarding curriculum implementation at classroom level. Various variables are involved in this framework. The three independent levels are:
- Theoretical concepts: How groups of students make society and perceive language learning, what notions they carry towards language learning process, and what their cultural, religious, and social perspectives of language learning are. Before implementing the curriculum, teachers need to be clear about such theoretical concepts.
- Policy directives: Emphasizes looking at categories of content. Teachers need to be sure which content is related and how it can be taught in relation to other contents.
- Classroom behaviour: Revolves around two parameters: teacher talk and student talk. Student talk is more of a learner-centred teaching environment where students can speak with equal opportunity, and the teacher is not in front running the show.
Topic-199: Classroom Implementation
The metaphor of 'the wood and tree' helps to see classroom implementation β how it goes into the mind of the student and how the teacher makes practice of the curriculum offered by institutes. Before 1970, language teaching was method driven, known as the method era. With the arrival of audiolingualism and cognitivism, it moved towards communicative language teaching and the shift occurred from language teaching to language learning.
Three categories of classroom implementation:
- Teaching strategies: Originates from method debate but looks at concrete classroom activities. What strategies are being employed by teachers? There is need to adjust teaching strategy according to students' desire.
- Timing strategies: Under the direct control of the teacher, happens within the premises of the classroom.
- Social or interpersonal strategies
π‘ Why this matters: Stern's framework provides teachers with a systematic way to analyze and improve curriculum implementation by considering theoretical foundations, policy requirements, and actual classroom dynamics.
Topic-200: The Role of Testing in Language Curriculum Design
The word 'test' tends to evoke fear in most students, but tests help teachers gather information to keep students happy and progressing. Testing is useful before students get started to know what kind of course to enroll them on, and along the way to check progress and find out if the course was successful in meeting objectives.
Schools deliver courses according to student needs. One useful test before meeting the student is a self-assessment test where students analyze how good they are at various aspects of the language, usually by rating themselves from 1-5 or completing sentences. The test can be made visual using pictures of different situations (listening to lectures, using the phone) and asking students how comfortable they are. Rating systems with smiley faces and frowning faces help convey the point. The test should go from really easy to gradually more difficult, and students can stop when questions get too tough.
Topic-201: Characteristics of Tests
Some establishments offer each student an interview with a teacher, which is basically a test. Although time-consuming, it provides a real view of speaking ability, the key language skill for most people. Listening is involved as you interact with students. For example, to try a past simple check question, you casually ask: 'How did you get here today? Did it take long?'
For an interview to be effective, let everyone introduce themselves. A second teacher may assess without speaking, though this increases nervousness. Explain what will happen, personalize questions if possible, and give each student feedback at the end.
Written placement tests are very common, allowing schools to test many new students simultaneously and providing a written record for files. Disadvantages compared to oral tests include: students complain about results more and ask for retakes, students tend to cheat and have warped results due to pressure, and sometimes students don't understand instructions.
Published tests can be purchased, or sections from course books can form the test. Reading passages can be included but tests should not appear too long. Tests should have an easy marking system, usually an answer key, to cut down on administration.
Proficiency tests assess a student's ability to perform particular tasks they will have to accomplish in the future. For example, if a student has been offered a restaurant job requiring English, you design a test covering taking orders and handling complaints. It doesn't matter whether the student has taken a course before β you simply need to know how well they may handle that job.
Topic-202: Testing to Establish the Best Course
Once students are enrolled, tests can be used to map progress and measure achievements. For courses of specific length, progress tests can be built in at various stages. Progress tests serve several purposes:
- Providing motivation for students to study. Targets and deadlines help some people get in gear, but for others they can be stressful and de-motivating.
- Providing a standard level for the class so students can be moved to a different course matching their proficiency level if necessary. Test results provide evidence for decisions.
- Highlighting gaps in teaching or course materials that need filling. The danger is training the class to pass the test rather than teaching English.
The way tests are handled depends on importance and main objective. Teachers may tell students the topic and ask them to revise particular points, or decide on thorough review without giving specific details. A fun and effective way is to allow students to design the test themselves. Break them into groups, have each group construct questions, or ask each student to submit questions. As they review topics and construct questions, the topic becomes indelibly printed on their minds.
Testing carries disadvantages, so alternatives such as project work and continuous assessment may be tried. These are less pressurized for most students and remove the problem of having a bad day at test time.
A project in English allows students to express language skills and creativity simultaneously, especially appealing to younger learners on short summer courses. Students choose their own topic and find out what they need to know to achieve the task. Teachers can agree on certain required elements, for example, history/background, current situation, and future plans, pushing students to use a variety of tenses.
Continuous assessment involves recording students' progress, performances, and achievements weekly. Schools should organize sheets for ticking or grading each aspect assessed. Writing reports increases teachers' administration work considerably, but it's easier to produce a final report rather than just a test score.
π Definition β Placement assessment: assessment used to decide what level of a course a learner should enter or what class to join π Example: A placement test given to a group of new students arriving together to determine beginner, intermediate, or advanced level placement
Topic-203: Guidelines for Monitoring and Assessment
Assessment is a major source of information for course evaluation and gradual improvement. Assessment contributes significantly to the teacher's and learners' sense of achievement and is important for motivation. It is often neglected in curriculum design, making courses less effective. Curriculum design should include planning a well-thought-out programme of assessment of various kinds.
The aim is to decide what to test and how to test it. The outer circles of the curriculum design model (environment, needs, and principles) provide data to guide planning of the inner circle processes. Monitoring and assessment must take account of the environment where the course will be used, the needs of learners, and principles of teaching and learning. Monitoring and assessment can provide information about learners' present knowledge and progress, and can be a means of encouraging involvement and participation.
Topic-204: Types of Monitoring and Assessment
The purpose of monitoring and assessment in curriculum design is to ensure learners get the most benefit from the course. This involves carefully observing learners and the course, and suggesting changes to the course and its operation. Assessment may be expected as a normal part of curriculum design.
Major types of monitoring and assessment:
- Placement assessment
- Observation of learning
- Short-term achievement assessment
- Diagnostic assessment
- Achievement assessment
- Proficiency assessment
Topic-205: Placement Assessment
Placement assessment is used to decide what level of a course a learner should enter, what class to join, and whether the learner should join the course at all. Placement assessment usually occurs under environment constraints. It often must be done just before a course begins, results must be available quickly, the learners are largely unknown and may be confused about the course, and they may not perform their best on a placement test because they are unfamiliar with some aspects.
β Key Takeaways
The evaluation of language tasks involves three phases: work plan, process, and outcomes, with teachers playing a vital role in assessing task appropriateness, content helpfulness, and procedural suitability. Stern's "wood and trees" metaphor emphasizes that teachers must look beyond classroom discourse to broader issues, while his theoretical framework offers three independent levels β theoretical concepts, policy directives, and classroom behaviour β as a remedy to limited classroom research. Testing plays a crucial role in curriculum design through placement, progress, and proficiency assessments, with interviews and self-assessment tests offering valuable initial insights into student needs. Progress tests serve multiple purposes including motivation, standard level determination, and gap identification, but alternatives like project work and continuous assessment can reduce student pressure. The six major types of monitoring and assessment β placement, observation of learning, short-term achievement, diagnostic, achievement, and proficiency β must be carefully planned within the curriculum design model considering environment, needs, and principles.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three phases of task evaluation according to Breen, and what does each phase involve?
- What does Stern mean by the metaphor "failing to notice the wood for the trees" in classroom research?
- What are the three independent levels of Stern's theoretical framework for curriculum implementation?
- What are the advantages and disadvantages of oral interviews compared to written placement tests?
- What are the six major types of monitoring and assessment that can occur as part of a course?