π Lecture 23 β CURRICULUM APPROACHES IN LANGUAGE TEACHING: BACKWARD DESIGN
π Overview: This lecture examines backward design, a curriculum approach that starts with specifying learning outcomes before developing instructional processes and content. It explores how backward design contrasts with forward and central design, and discusses key applications such as competency-based instruction, needs analysis, subject-centered and learner-centered design approaches.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers backward design as a curriculum approach starting with learning outputs, the significance of needs analysis within backward design, competency-based instruction as a practical application, and contrasts subject-centered design with learner-centered design in curriculum development.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-149: Backward Design
Backward design is the third curriculum approach, which begins with a specification of learning outputs and uses these as the basis for developing instructional processes and input. Following Wiggins and McTighe (2006), this approach starts with a careful statement of desired results or outcomes, from which appropriate teaching activities and content are derived. This is a well-established tradition in general education and has re-emerged as prominent in language teaching. It was sometimes described as an 'ends-means' approach, as seen in the work of Tyler (1949) and Taba (1962), who viewed instruction as the specification of ends as a prerequisite to devising the means to reach them.
The process consists of seven steps:
- Step 1: diagnosis of needs
- Step 2: formulation of objectives
- Step 3: selection of content
- Step 4: organization of content
- Step 5: selection of learning experiences
- Step 6: organization of learning experiences
- Step 7: determination of what to evaluate and of the ways of doing it
The role of methodology was to determine which teaching methods were most effective in attaining the objectives, and a criterion-referenced approach would be used for assessment. There is no place for individually-determined learning outcomes; the outcomes are determined by the curriculum designer.
π Definition β Ends-Means Approach: An instructional design where the specification of ends (learning outcomes) is a prerequisite to devising the means (teaching methods and content) to reach them.
Topic-150: Significance of Needs Analysis within Backward Design Approach
Wiggins and McTighe (2006) criticized the use of classroom activities and processes as the starting point in instructional planning, arguing for starting with a clear description of learning outcomes. They recommend the following three steps:
- Identify desired results.
- Determine acceptable evidence of learning.
- Plan learning experiences and instruction.
The planning process begins with a clear understanding of the ends in mind. It explicitly rejects the process or activity-oriented curriculum as a starting point. It does not imply any particular pedagogical approach or instructional theory; a variety of teaching strategies can be employed, but teaching methods cannot be chosen until the desired outcomes have been specified.
Needs Analysis (identifying learning outcomes or objectives) is often seen to depend upon a systematic analysis of the learners' communicative needs. It emerged in the 1960s as part of the systems approach to curriculum development. Informal needs assessment deals with informal negotiation between class teachers and students through chats with individuals or groups to select a focus for the class.
The steps involved in needs analysis are:
- Identify learner's communicative needs.
- Develop statements of learning objectives.
- Identify linguistic content and skills needed to attain the objectives.
- Prepare course plans.
- Select materials and teaching methods.
π‘ Why this matters: Needs analysis ensures that curriculum design is responsive to actual learner requirements rather than being driven by predetermined content or activities alone.
Topic-151: Competency-based Instruction within Backward Design Approach -I
Competency-based Instruction (CpBI) is a widely used example of backward design. The starting point is a specification of learning outcomes in terms of 'competencies' β the knowledge, skills, and behaviors learners involved in performing everyday tasks and activities, which learners should master at the end of a course. Competency-based education has much in common with performance-based instruction, mastery learning, and individualized instruction. It is outcome-based and adaptive to the changing needs of students, teachers, and the community.
π Definition β Competencies: The knowledge, skills, and behaviors learners need to perform everyday tasks and activities, which differ from other goals and objectives by describing the student's ability to apply basic and other skills in situations commonly encountered in everyday life.
CpBI is based on a set of outcomes derived from an analysis of tasks typically required of students in life role situations.
Topic-152: Competency-Based Instruction within Backward Design Approach II
An example of CpBI used in developing a vocational curriculum for refugees and immigrants in the US (Mrowicki, 1986) involved the following process:
- Needs analysis.
- Identify topics for the survival curriculum (e.g., banking, health, shopping).
- Identify target tasks, design tasks.
- Identify competencies for each topic.
- Group competencies into instructional units.
- Identify the language knowledge and skills needed for each instructional unit (e.g., the 4 skills, vocabulary, and grammar).
- Choose instructional materials.
Competency-based approaches offer teachers an opportunity to revitalize education and training programs. The quality of assessment improves, as does the quality of teaching and student learning, through clear specification of expected outcomes and continuous feedback. Like other backward design approaches, CpBI makes no assumptions about teaching methods since any set of classroom activities can be used that enables students to master the desired competencies. However, since student learning is assessed on performance and demonstration of pre-specified skills, teaching is generally based on helping learners acquire communicative skills needed for specific situations, tasks, and activities.
π‘ Why this matters: CpBI focuses on demonstrable, real-world skills rather than abstract knowledge, making learning directly applicable to life situations.
Topic-153: Subject-centered Design
In this system, the main focus is on curriculum development (not human development), with subject specialists developing "high standards" for student uniformity. This reflects what society believes all students should know and be able to do at grade-level checkpoints. Teachers are told what and how to teach. The main goal and purpose is to standardize students, making them alike with a "core curriculum." A large amount of meaningless testing is imposed on teachers to inflict on students. Teachers have big classes that restrict them from forming close relationships with each child. Parents are usually not involved except to help with teacher-assigned homework. Teachers spend much time imparting the state curriculum, focusing on what students don't know and can't do. Students are required to do teacher-assigned homework and are not encouraged to ask questions. Learning merely to pass tests is shallow and temporary.
Topic-154: Learner-centered Design
The concept of learner-centeredness has been invoked with increasing frequency in recent years. The philosophy has strong links with experiential learning, humanistic psychology, and task-based language teaching. This approach places the learner at the center of the pedagogic process and sees education not as receiving information but as intelligent inquiry and thought (Gibbons, 2002). A learner-centered curriculum contains similar elements to traditional curriculum development β planning (including needs analysis, goal and objective setting), implementation (including methodology and material development), and evaluation. However, the main difference is that in learner-centered curriculum, the curriculum is a collaborative effort between teachers and learners. Therefore, learners need to be systematically taught to implement a learner-centered approach. Language programs should have dual goals: language content goals and learning process goals.
Learner-centered curriculum allows students to participate more fully in arranging their own learning experiences so that two key objectives are realized:
- Students participate in shaping the curriculum, addressing contextual issues including new situational/personal culture.
- Student involvement enables meta-learning β providing them the opportunity to learn about the design and construction of purposeful learning activities.
π Definition β Meta-learning: Learning about the design and construction of purposeful learning activities; the process of students understanding how to manage their own learning.
β Key Takeaways
Backward design is a curriculum approach that prioritizes learning outcomes as the starting point, with instructional processes and content derived from those outcomes through careful needs analysis. Competency-based instruction represents a practical application of backward design, focusing on real-world skills and performance-based assessment. While subject-centered design standardizes students through a core curriculum and top-down instruction, learner-centered design places students at the center through collaborative curriculum development and dual language and learning process goals. The critical distinction across all approaches is whether the starting point is input (forward), process (central), or output (backward), with backward design ensuring clear alignment between intended results, evidence of learning, and instructional planning.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the seven steps in backward design according to Tyler (1949) and Taba (1962)?
- How does needs analysis function differently in backward design compared to forward or central design?
- What distinguishes competencies from other types of student goals and objectives in competency-based instruction?
- What are the three steps recommended by Wiggins and McTighe (2006) for implementing backward design?
- How does learner-centered design differ from subject-centered design in terms of teacher and student roles?
π Lecture 24 β Curriculum Approaches in Language Teaching: A Flexible Model
π Overview: This lecture explores the fundamental premise that there is no single "best" approach to curriculum design in language teaching. It argues that forward, central, and backward design can all be effective in different contexts, and may even operate concurrently. The lecture critically examines several curriculum modelsβincluding Content, Objectives, Process, and New Pragmatismβand concludes with an analysis of foundational curriculum frameworks like Tyler's, Wheeler's, Kerr's, and Bruner's Spiral models.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by introducing a flexible model for ELT curriculum, arguing that forward, central, and backward designs are context-dependent rather than universally superior. It then critically examines four ELT curriculum models: Content Model, Objectives Model, Process Model, and New Pragmatism. The lecture concludes by analyzing three foundational curriculum design frameworksβTyler's linear model, Kerr's interrelated domains model, and Bruner's Spiral modelβall of which shape contemporary thinking about curriculum development in language teaching.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-155: ELT Curriculum: A Flexible Model for a Changing World
Teachers and planners often ask which approach is best, but this lecture assumes there is no best approach. Forward, central, and backward design might work well in different circumstances and might work concurrently. Design goes backwards and forwards regardless of the starting pointβa forward design has broad outcomes in mind, a central design may not specify goals in detail, and a backward design considers teaching processes when formulating outcomes.
Each approach makes different assumptions about context, including whether it is for large-scale or small-scale implementation, the role of instructional materials and tests, teachers' training level and English proficiency, the roles of teachers and learners, demands on teachers, level of teacher autonomy, and support provided for teachers.
A forward design option is preferred where a mandated curriculum is in place, teachers have little choice, rely on textbooks, have large classes, and where tests are designed centrally. Since forward design supports published materials, there is generally a wide range of teaching resources. It is also preferred where teachers have limited English proficiency and limited professional development opportunities, as specialists can handle planning.
Central design approaches do not require teachers to plan detailed learning outcomes, conduct needs analysis, or follow a prescribed syllabus, giving teachers considerable autonomy. However, method-based approaches may require teachers to understand obscure underlying theory and master difficult techniques. Post-method and learner-community approaches require high levels of professional knowledge and language proficiency, as strategies are developed according to the teacher's understanding of context.
A backward design option is preferred where a high degree of accountability is needed and resources can be committed to needs analysis, planning, and materials development. Well-developed procedures are available for implementing backward design. In large-scale national curriculum development, much activity is done by others, leaving teachers with implementation. In private institutes developing company-specific courses, a bottom-up approach by well-trained teachers may be adopted.
Topic-156: ELT Curriculum: Content Model
The central focus of this model is the content of what is to be learned by, or transmitted to, the learner. In the Classical Humanist tradition, content is a valued cultural heritage that contributes to the learner's intellectual development. From epistemological objectivism, content is knowledge identified as universal, unchanging, and absolute. This model has been dominant in Western education for centuries, derived from Aristotle and Plato.
However, Kelly (1989) points out the model is inadequate because it cannot cope with discussion of wider educational purposes, does not consider the individual learner's abilities or problems, or the complexities of the learning process itself. In ELT, this model underpins the grammar-based curriculum, where the syllabus is concerned with grammar and vocabulary. Learning experiences include drilling grammatically correct sentences, explanations of theory, memorization of vocabulary lists, and assessment based on producing grammatically accurate language.
π Definition β Content Model: A curriculum model where the central focus is the content of what is to be learned by or transmitted to the learner, based on the belief that knowledge is universal, unchanging, and absolute.
Topic-157: ELT Curriculum: Objectives Model
Reconstructionism's main purpose is to bring about social change. Its origins lie in the scientific management of education and behavioral psychology in the early 20th century, which defined learning as observable changes in behavior that could be measured.
The clearest definition of behavioral objectives has three essential characteristics:
- They must unambiguously describe the behavior to be performed.
- They must describe the conditions under which performance will occur.
- They must state a standard of acceptable performance (the criterion).
The attraction of this model is that it provides:
- Clarity of goals: Objectives are clear to both teacher and learners, facilitating selection of materials and activities.
- Ease of evaluation: Clearly specified objectives allow for easy and accurate evaluation of learner and program success.
- Accountability: In formal and business sectors, it provides clear methods for needs identification, establishing learning purpose, and providing measurable "products."
π Definition β Behavioral Objectives: Learning objectives that must unambiguously describe the behavior to be performed, the conditions under which it will occur, and the standard of acceptable performance (criterion).
Topic-158: ELT Curriculum: Process Model
From the process model perspective, the purpose of education is to enable the individual to progress towards self-fulfillment. It is concerned with developing understanding of the learning process, not just passive reception of knowledge or acquisition of specific skills.
The goals are not defined in terms of particular ends or products, but in terms of the process and procedures by which the individual develops understanding, awareness, and creates possibilities for future learning. Content is based on principles derived from research into learning development, and the overall purpose is to formulate objectives related to procedural principles.
Clark and White (2007) show that language teaching has been influenced by philosophical trends and broad educational developments, not isolated from the educational mainstream.
π‘ Why this matters: The Process Model shifts focus from what students learn to how they learn, emphasizing that understanding and awareness are more important than specific behavioral outcomes.
Topic-159: ELT Curriculum: New Pragmatism
In practice today, the claim to use a communicative syllabus or curriculum approach is often made without real agreement on what "communicative" means and without clarification of principles and processes. Dubin and Olshtain (1986) identify three areas central to a communicative curriculum:
- Sociolinguistics
- Cognitively based view of language learning
- Humanistic approach in education
Topic-160: Tyler's and Wheeler's Models
Tyler's model for curriculum designing is based on four questions:
- What educational purposes should the school seek to attain?
- What educational experiences can be provided that are likely to attain these purposes?
- How can these educational experiences be effectively organized?
- How can we determine whether these purposes are being attained?
The model is linear in nature, starting from objectives and ending with evaluation. Evaluation is terminal. Key points include:
- Objectives form the basis for selection and organization of learning experiences.
- Objectives form the basis for assessing the curriculum.
- Objectives are derived from the learner, contemporary life, and subject specialist.
- Evaluation matches initial expectations with outcomes.
Topic-161: Kerr's Model
Kerr's model divides the curriculum into four domains (Urevbu, 1985):
- Objectives
- Knowledge
- Evaluation
- School learning experiences
Key points about the model:
- The four domains are interrelated directly or indirectly.
- Objectives are derived from school learning experiences and knowledge.
Objectives are divided into three groups:
- Affective
- Cognitive
- Psychomotor
Knowledge should be:
- Organized
- Integrated
- Sequenced
- Reinforced
Evaluation is the collection of information for making decisions about the curriculum. School learning experiences are influenced by societal opportunities, the school community, pupil and teacher relationships, individual differences, teaching methods, content, and learner maturity. These experiences are evaluated through tests, interviews, assessments, and other methods. Kerr asserts that everything influences everything else, and it is possible to start analysis at any point (Urevbu, 1985).
Topic-162: Spiral Model
In the 1960s, Jerome Bruner proposed a theory of cognitive growth emphasizing environmental and experiential factors in a child's education. He suggested intellectual ability develops in stages through changes in how the mind is used. Bruner's position was that young children need to learn the underlying principles of different conceptsβthe structure of ideasβrather than memorizing facts and data.
The spiral curriculum is predicated on cognitive theory advanced by Bruner (1960), who wrote "we begin with the hypothesis that any subject can be taught in some intellectually honest form to any child at any stage of development." Even the most complex material, if properly structured and presented, can be understood by very young children.
Bruner hypothesized that human cognition occurs in three relatively discrete stages:
- Enactive β actually manipulating and interacting with objects
- Iconic β manipulating images of the objects or phenomena
- Symbolic β using symbols and abstract representation
π Definition β Spiral Curriculum: A curriculum model based on Bruner's cognitive theory where concepts are revisited at increasing levels of complexity, with the hypothesis that any subject can be taught in some intellectually honest form to any child at any stage of development.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical takeaway is that there is no single "best" approach to curriculum design; forward, central, and backward designs each suit different contexts depending on factors like teacher autonomy, class size, and resource availability. Students must remember that the Content Model focuses on transmitting fixed knowledge (grammar-based), the Objectives Model emphasizes measurable behavioral outcomes with three essential characteristics, and the Process Model prioritizes self-fulfillment and understanding over specific products. For foundational frameworks, Tyler's model is linear with terminal evaluation, while Kerr's model features four interrelated domains where everything influences everything else. Finally, Bruner's Spiral Model posits that any subject can be taught to any child at any developmental stage through the enactive, iconic, and symbolic stages of cognition.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three essential characteristics of behavioral objectives in the Objectives Model?
- Under what circumstances would a forward design approach be preferred over a backward design approach?
- What are the four domains in Kerr's curriculum model, and how are they related to each other?
- What are the three stages of cognitive development in Bruner's Spiral Model?
- According to Dubin and Olshtain, what three areas are central to the concept of a communicative curriculum?
π Lecture 25 β TYPES OF SYLLABI IN LANGUAGE TEACHING
π Overview: This lecture surveys the major types of syllabi used in language teaching, from the traditional structural syllabus to more modern approaches like task-based and lexical syllabi. Understanding these types is crucial for curriculum designers to match syllabus design with learners' needs, institutional goals, and theories of language and learning.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers seven major syllabus types: Structural Syllabus (based on grammatical forms), Situational Syllabus (organized around real-life situations), Functional/Notional Syllabus (focused on communicative functions and concepts), Skill-based Syllabus (centered on discrete language skills), Content-based Syllabus (teaching language through subject matter), Task-based Syllabus (using real-world tasks as the organizing principle), and Lexical and Cultural Syllabuses (emphasizing word chunks and cultural knowledge). Each type is examined with its underlying theories, merits, and drawbacks.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-163: Structural Syllabus
The structural syllabus is the most familiar syllabus type, based on the theory that grammatical or structural aspects of language form are the most basic or useful. Krahnke (1987) defines it as one where the content of language teaching is a collection of the forms and structures (usually grammatical) of the language being taught.
Breen (1987) sets forth three rationales for the formal syllabus: first, it is well-established and informed by a long tradition of linguistic analysis; second, it presents learners with a systematic and rule-governed subject matter, allowing them to see patterns and reduce the 'learning load'; third, because the linguistic system is analysable, these analytical categories can be incorporated into a teaching plan and may help learners uncover how the new language works.
Merits of the structural syllabus include: structure/grammar is the most general component of communicative competence; its content is relatively easy to describe (e.g., noun, verb, imperative); structural knowledge is the most measurable component of communicative competence; instruction in form can prevent later fossilization (cessation of learning); it offers a basis for providing feedback on accuracy; and it is culture-free.
Drawbacks according to Stevick (1972): it violates most types of reward needed for materials, including relevance to student's needs, completeness, authenticity, satisfaction with progress, and immediacy of use. Breen (1987) adds: there is little evidence that structural knowledge transfers to actual language use; it can mislead learners into thinking they are learning a language when they are learning facts about it; and sequencing or grading problems arise because a strictly structural syllabus prevents students from producing structures they haven't been taught.
π Definition β Structural Syllabus: a syllabus where the content is a collection of the grammatical forms and structures of the language being taught. π Formula: content = grammatical structures β learners study language forms systematically π Example: A lesson sequence teaching present tense verbs first, then past tense, then future tense, with each structure taught in isolation before moving to the next.
Topic-164: Situational Syllabus
The situational syllabus emerged as an alternative to the structural syllabus, based on the premise that language is related to the situational contexts in which it occurs. The designer predicts situations the learner will encounter and uses these as a basis for selecting and presenting language content. Unlike the structural syllabus, it offers the possibility of selecting and sequencing different real-life situations rather than grammatical items.
Alexander (1976) differentiates three types of situational syllabus based on type of information: Limbo Situation (the specific setting is unimportant, e.g., introducing someone at a stadium); Concrete Situation (information about a specific and concrete setting, e.g., ordering a meal at a restaurant); and Mythical Situation (information depends on a fictional storyline with fictional characters in a fictional place).
Merits: taps students' knowledge of the world as an aid to learning; provides realistic materials; bridges cultural gaps through conversations implied with social conventions; is manageable as a foundation to incorporate other syllabus types; and offers countless resources to avoid repetition and boredom.
Drawbacks: too much use of predetermined and artificial situations can lead to lack of transfer, as students learn pre-learned routines rather than creative uses of language. Problems include: actual patterns of native speaker use in many situations are still unknown; it is difficult to write focused and natural dialogues; content tends to become outdated; it may reflect unwanted foreign language values (not culture-free); and it presents sequencing problems like the structural syllabus.
π Definition β Situational Syllabus: a syllabus organized around the real-life situations in which the learner will use the language. π Example: A unit on "At the Restaurant" teaching phrases like "I'd like to order the steak" and "Could I have the check, please?" rather than teaching all present tense verbs first.
Topic-165: Functional/Notional Syllabus
A functional-notional syllabus is based on learning to recognize and express the communicative functions of language and the concepts and ideas it expresses. Hedge (2000) highlights that the 'communicative revolution' of the 1970s urged educators to go beyond structural analysis and consider what 'communicative ability' entailed.
Underlying theories draw on descriptions of language emphasizing functional and social aspects of competence. These syllabuses consist of a list of functions (e.g., apologizing, requesting) and notions (e.g., past time, possibility) together with the linguistic exponents required to realize them in communication. The methodology was typically still accuracy-based, representing a Type A approach where objectives are defined in advance (White, 1988). The functional view highlighted the importance of discourse in context and acknowledged that knowledge of text structure is more useful than isolated grammatically correct sentences.
Merits: learners learn to use language to express authentic communicative purposes; motivation increases through expressing own purposes, ideas, and emotions; it teaches pragmatic aspects like politeness and cultural topics like greetings; it considers learner needs and meanings; and it places students and their communicative purposes at the core of the program.
Drawbacks: functions and notions are abstract and difficult for some learners; different structures often express the same function, making progression from simple to complex difficult; it is difficult to use for creating new sentences (Raine, 2010); and there are no clear-cut criteria for grading of functions, so grading depends mainly on the material designer's intuition (White, 1988).
π Definition β Functional/Notional Syllabus: a syllabus based on the communicative functions (purposes for using language) and notions (concepts) that learners need to express. π Formula: content = functions (e.g., apologizing) + notions (e.g., past time) + linguistic exponents (e.g., "I'm sorry I was late") π Example: A unit on "Apologizing" teaching various forms like "I'm sorry," "Please excuse me," and "I apologize for" along with the notion of past time ("I'm sorry I was late").
Topic-166: Skill-based Syllabus
In a skill-based syllabus, the content of language teaching is a collection of specific abilities that play a part in using language (Richards, 2001). Skill-based syllabi group linguistic competencies (pronunciation, vocabulary, grammar, discourse) into generalized types of behavior, such as listening for the main idea, writing well-formed paragraphs, or giving effective oral presentations. Krahnke (1987) defines a skill as a specific way of using language that combines structural and functional ability but exists independently of specific settings or situations.
Underlying theories: approaching language through skills is based on the belief that learning a complex activity like "listening to a lecture" involves mastery of individual micro-skills. Brown (1995) notes that selection of skills is based on authors' perception of usefulness, while sequencing is based on chronology, frequency, or relative usefulness. The general theory is that learning complex behaviors is facilitated by breaking them down into small bits (skills), teaching the bits, and hoping learners can put them together when using language.
Merits: they focus on behavior or performance; teach skills that transfer to many situations; identify teachable and learnable units; provide a practical framework for designing courses and materials; and are most useful when learners need to master specific types of language use.
Drawbacks: Karahnke (1987) criticizes the assumption that ability to perform specific tasks is independent of overall language proficiency; Auerbach (1986) argues it may program students for particular behaviors and isolate them from broader achievements; Willis (2005) says it is not much more than a list of skills and micro-skills; and the list of skills cannot be understood in the same way by all participants.
π Definition β Skill-based Syllabus: a syllabus organized around discrete language skills (micro-skills) that together make up complex language behaviors. π Example: A course divided into units on "Listening for Main Ideas," "Scanning for Specific Information," "Writing Topic Sentences," and "Giving Oral Presentations."
Topic-167: Content Based Syllabus
Content-based instruction is an approach where teaching is organized around the content rather than around a linguistic syllabus (Richards & Rodgers, 2001). Krahnke (1987) defines it as teaching content or information in the language being learned with little or no direct effort to teach the language itself separately. It is considered a sub-category of process-oriented and analytic syllabus (Nunan, 1988). The content may come from other subjects (science, history) or from analysis of students' interests and needs (Nunan, 2004).
The rationale is that language is learned most effectively for communication in meaningful, purposeful contexts (Snow, 1988). In real life, people use language to talk about what they know, not about language itself. The integration of content provides both a motivational and cognitive basis for language learning.
Merits (Nunan, 2004): learners learn other aspects of school learning alongside language; it shares advantages of analytical syllabuses; integrates all four language skills; actively involves students; utilizes authentic tasks; and raises motivation and learner engagement.
Drawbacks: Ellis (2003) believes it may not result in high levels of grammatical and sociolinguistic accuracy; Brown (2007) argues teachers may be deterred by demands of content knowledge and feel unqualified to teach content areas; Short (1993) notes difficulty in assessment because it is hard to isolate language features from content objectives.
π Definition β Content-based Syllabus: a syllabus organized around subject matter content (e.g., science, history) rather than linguistic structures or functions. π Example: A science unit on "Photosynthesis" taught in English, where students learn English vocabulary and structures while learning the scientific process.
Topic-168: Task-Based Syllabus
The primary theory of learning underlying task-based instruction is Krashen's acquisition theory, which argues that the ability to use a language develops through exposure to the language and participation in using it (Krahnke, 1987). Nunan (2001) asserts that task-based syllabuses start with needs analysis, resulting in a list of target tasks learners need to carry out in real-life situations (e.g., job interviews, completing applications, finding one's way).
Skehan (2003) defines a task as an activity where: meaning is primary; learners are not given others' meanings to repeat; there is a relationship to comparable real-world activities; task completion has priority; and assessment is in terms of outcome. Candlin (1987) lists characteristics of a good task: promotes attention to meaning, purpose, and negotiation; encourages attention to relevant data; draws objectives from learners' communicative needs; defines a problem to be worked through; and provides opportunities for meta-communication and meta-cognition.
The psycholinguistic rationale (Ellis, 2009): learners have their own built-in syllabus directing how they learn the L2 system; the primary goal is development of implicit knowledge; implicit knowledge is best achieved through experiencing the L2 as a communicative tool; and resultant learning is incidental rather than intentional.
Merits: uses learners' real-life needs as learning experiences, providing motivation through immediacy and relevancy (Krahnke, 1987); can be a vehicle for instruction in other types of content; valuable for learners with clear, immediate needs; useful for learners not accustomed to traditional learning; helpful in ESP courses; helps learners acquire language; and grammatical and functional items reappear in diverse contexts (Nunan, 2004).
Drawbacks: ignores explicit meta-linguistic knowledge and focuses on fluency at the expense of accuracy (Nation & Macalister, 2010); requires high creativity and initiative from the teacher (Krahnke, 1987); and evaluation is difficult because the nature of tasks makes it hard to measure learning using traditional achievement tests.
π Definition β Task-based Syllabus: a syllabus organized around real-world tasks that learners need to accomplish, with language learned through completing these tasks. π Example: A unit on "Applying for a Job" where learners practice filling out application forms, participating in mock interviews, and writing cover letters, rather than studying verb tenses in isolation.
Topic-169: Lexical and Cultural Syllabus
The lexical syllabus emerged as a reaction against the traditional structural syllabus. The basic concept is that students must understand and use lexical phrases such as chunks, prefabricated patterns, and collocations. Lewis (1993) states that an important part of language acquisition is the ability to comprehend and produce lexical phrases as unanalyzed wholes, which become the raw data for perceiving patterns of language.
Criteria for selection of lexical items include: Frequency (listing most frequent expressions using language corpora); Teachability (piloting selected words and discarding those difficult to manage); Authenticity (items taken from authentic texts); Coverage (selecting generic, non-context-specific items); and Similarity (taking advantage of cognates shared by both languages, e.g., "mother" and "father" in Indo-European languages).
Merits (Sinclair & Renouf, 1988): practicality (learners benefit from common words in daily life); efficiency (offers only things worth learning); utility (focuses on function and usage of chunks, shifting from constructing messages to delivering them effectively); authenticity (all materials from authentic language use); and flexibility (independent of any methodology, can adopt any teaching practice).
Drawbacks: use of inflected forms does not correspond to natural language use; a high percentage of high-frequency words are function words not useful for negotiating intended messages; grammar is dealt with intuitively and is difficult to teach; and it is impossible to formally teach every discrete lexical item, so most acquisition must come from sources other than formal teaching (Lewis, 2002).
Cultural syllabus: Brown (2007) maintains that language and culture are intricately interwoven and cannot be separated. Stern (1983) proposes a four-dimensional model integrating: Language Syllabus (structural and functional), Communicative/Experiential Syllabus, and Culture Syllabus (socio-cultural knowledge and awareness). A cultural syllabus often addresses non-verbal and verbal components of language.
Merits (Fleet, 2006): increases communicative competence as language use must be associated with culturally appropriate behaviour (Peterson & Coltrane, 2003); allows more authentic language learning; motivates learners; and instils intercultural competence by affecting perceptions and attitudes toward the target language.
Drawback (Stern, 1992): major problems include the vastness of the culture concept, problems of goal determination and lack of accessible information, questions of syllabus design and difficulty adjusting culture's place in a language-oriented approach, and difficulty handling substantive subject-matter in a skill-oriented program.
π‘ Why this matters: The lexical and cultural syllabuses represent a shift from viewing language as a system of rules to viewing it as a collection of meaningful chunks embedded in cultural contexts, influencing modern teaching approaches like the Lexical Approach.
π Definition β Lexical Syllabus: a syllabus organized around high-frequency lexical phrases, chunks, and collocations rather than grammatical structures. π Formula: content = lexical chunks (e.g., "I'm sorry," "by the way," "on the other hand") β learners acquire patterns from these chunks π Example: A lesson teaching the phrase "I'd like to..." as a chunk for polite requests, then expanding to "I'd like to order," "I'd like to know," "I'd like to see," rather than teaching the conditional "would" as a grammatical structure first.
β Key Takeaways
The structural syllabus is the most traditional type, focused on grammatical forms, but suffers from poor transfer to real communication. The situational syllabus improves relevance by organizing content around real-life contexts but struggles with authenticity and sequencing. The functional/notional syllabus revolutionized language teaching by prioritizing communicative purposes and learner needs, yet faces grading difficulties due to abstract functions. Task-based and content-based syllabuses represent modern, process-oriented approaches that emphasize meaningful use and incidental learning, though they may neglect explicit grammar instruction. The lexical and cultural syllabuses highlight the importance of formulaic language chunks and cultural knowledge, recognizing that language and culture are inseparable.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three rationales Breen (1987) sets forth for the structural syllabus, and what is the main criticism regarding its transferability?
- How does the situational syllabus differ from the structural syllabus in terms of content organization, and what are the three types identified by Alexander (1976)?
- What is the difference between a "function" and a "notion" in a functional/notional syllabus, and why is grading problematic in this approach?
- According to Krahnke (1987), what is the primary theory of learning underlying task-based instruction, and how does a task-based syllabus differ from a structural syllabus in its starting point?
- What criteria are used for selecting lexical items in a lexical syllabus, and why does Brown (2007) argue that culture and language cannot be separated in teaching?
π Lecture 26 β Negotiated Syllabus
π Overview: This lecture explores the concept of a negotiated syllabus, where teachers and learners collaborate to make decisions about curriculum design. It examines the rationale behind this approach, provides practical examples, discusses requirements and assessment negotiation, and weighs the advantages and disadvantages of implementing such a syllabus in language teaching contexts.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture introduces the negotiated syllabus (also called process syllabus) and its foundations in humanistic methodologies, learner-centered approaches, and needs analysis. It provides a concrete example with adult graduate students, discusses Breen's framework for negotiation procedures and course planning, explores partially negotiated syllabuses, explains how assessment can be negotiated, and concludes with a comprehensive analysis of disadvantages and advantages of this approach.