π Lecture 32 β Teaching the Nuts and Bolts of Writing II
π Overview: This lecture focuses on the foundational mechanics of writing, specifically punctuation, copying, and sentence/paragraph construction. It provides practical teaching strategies for helping students master these "nuts and bolts" to improve clarity, accuracy, and overall writing quality, from elementary to advanced levels.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers six main topics: Teaching Punctuation (I), Teaching Punctuation (II), Copying, Teaching Sentence Writing, Teaching Paragraph Construction, and Teaching Text Construction II (including both controlled and free text construction). Each topic presents specific classroom activities and techniques for developing studentsβ written accuracy and organizational skills.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-170: Teaching Punctuation (I)
Using punctuation correctly is an important skill. People judge the quality of writing not just on content, language, and handwriting, but also on punctuation use. If capital letters, commas, full stops, and sentence/paragraph boundaries are used incorrectly, it can make a negative impression and make a text difficult to understand.
While email communication may seem to require less accurate punctuation, even emails can be formal or official. Careless keyboard use may make a poor impression. To help students become good writers in English, teachers need to teach punctuation conventions from the very beginning, so that by upper-intermediate level, students can complete revision exercises with ease.
π‘ Why this matters: Punctuation is a key marker of written competence; poor punctuation can undermine the clarity and credibility of any written work.
Topic-171: Teaching Punctuation (II)
This topic offers practical ideas for helping students recognize and use punctuation correctly.
Activity 1 - Capital Letters: Elementary-level students can study a collection of words and identify which ones have capital letters, e.g., Anita, and, apple, April, Argentina, art, Australian, Andrew, act, at, in, island, I, ice, Iceland. They then work out the rule for why some words require capitals.
Activity 2 - Punctuating a Text: Students who have learned about commas, full stops, and capital letters can punctuate a short text like this:
"they arrived in Cambridge at one o'clock in the morning was cold with a bright moon making the river cam silver andrew ran to the water's edge angela hurrying to keep up with him ran straight into him by mistake and pushed him into the river"
Activity 3 - Punctuating Direct Reported Speech: Students can be shown a text and asked to identify punctuation features. A procedure involves giving students an extract (preferably from a book they are reading). For example:
βI'm sorry to keep you waiting,β a voice said. The speaker was a short man with a smiling, round face and a beard. βMy nameβs Cabinda,β he said. βPassport police.β βI can explain,β Monika said quickly. βMy hair. It's not like the photograph...β"
Students identify quotation marks, commas, apostrophes, and capital letters used in dialogue.
Topic-172: Copying
Previous copying activities involved copying single and joined-up letters, copying words from a list, and rewriting words in different columns, all to help students form letters and words from a given model.
Copying is an important real-life skill, but some students struggle. This may be due to an inability to notice key features of English spelling or difficulty with attention to detail. Computer copy-and-paste functions make matters worse by removing the need to account for how words are formed. Graeme Porte (University of Granada, Spain) found that βunderachievingβ students had great difficulty copying accurately when making notes or answering exam questions. His solution: have these students, under time pressure, copy a straightforward text set out in fairly short lines. They copied line by line, covering the whole text except the line they were working on. This focused their concentration and improved their copying accuracy.
π Definition β Copying (in writing instruction): The act of reproducing written text from a model, used not only for learning letter formation and spelling but also as a practical life skill requiring attention to detail.
Topic-173: Teaching Sentence Writing
Students need to learn and practice the art of putting words together into well-formed sentences. One method is parallel writing, where students follow a written model.
Sentence production (elementary): The most basic form of parallel writing is sentence writing used for grammar reinforcement. Students are given one or two model sentences and must write similar sentences based on given information or their own thoughts. For example, students are given information about a character and see how information is combined with and and but. They then write similar sentences about themselves.
π Definition β Parallel writing: A teaching technique where students follow a written model to produce their own sentences, paragraphs, or texts, often used for grammar reinforcement.
Topic-174: Teaching Paragraph Construction
Paragraph construction can be taught through a substitution-drill style of procedure. Students write a paragraph almost identical to one they have read, using new vocabulary within a set pattern.
Students first read a model paragraph:
"William Shakespeare is Englandβs most famous playwright. He was born in Stratford-on-Avon in 1564, but lived a lot of his life in London. He wrote 37 plays including Hamlet, Romeo and Juliet, Henry V, and Twelfth Night. He died in Stratford-on-Avon in 1616."
After ensuring understanding, students are given a table of information about Jane Austen and asked to write a similar paragraph:
- Name: Jane Austen
- Occupation: one of Englandβs most famous writers
- Date of birth: 1775
- Place of birth: Steventon, Hampshire
- Lived: Bath and Southampton (cities in the south of the UK)
- Examples of work: six novels, including Emma and Mansfield Park
- Died: 1817, Winchester
Topic-175: Teaching Text Construction II
Controlled text construction: The logical organization of ideas (coherence) applies to whole texts, not just paragraphs. This example focuses on the genre of report writing.
In Activity 1, students work out the appropriate sequence for a report's five elements, raising awareness of a typical organization. In Activity 2, students look at a particular language issue (linking words) before moving on to Stages 1-3 to write a similar report.
Free text construction: This final example uses parallel writing but allows students to decide how closely to follow the original model. Instead of being bound by the layout and construction of the original, they use it as a springboard for their imagination. Students first read a story about "Stig," a large Alsatian dog, then write their own version freely.
π Definition β Coherence: The logical organization of ideas within a text, ensuring that information flows in a clear and understandable sequence.
β Key Takeaways
Punctuation must be taught from the beginning, as it affects clarity and credibility; practical activities (identifying capital letters, punctuating texts, and handling direct speech) build this skill gradually. Copying is both a learning tool and a real-life skill, and teachers can help struggling students by having them copy line-by-line under time pressure. Parallel writing (using models) is an effective method for teaching sentence, paragraph, and text construction, and can range from highly controlled substitution drills to free, imaginative writing. The logical organization of ideas (coherence) is crucial for both paragraphs and whole texts, especially in formal genres like report writing.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are three practical classroom activities for teaching punctuation to students at different levels?
- According to Graeme Porte, what specific technique helped "underachieving" students improve their copying accuracy?
- How does the "parallel writing" technique work for teaching sentence construction at the elementary level?
- Describe the substitution-drill procedure used in Topic-174 to teach paragraph construction about Jane Austen.
- What is the difference between "controlled text construction" and "free text construction" in teaching writing?