π Lecture 22 β Relevance Theory
π Overview: This lecture introduces Relevance Theory, a cognitive pragmatic framework developed by Wilson and Sperber in the 1980s. It explains how hearers interpret utterances by seeking relevance, balancing contextual effects against processing effort, and addresses key concepts such as explicatures, implicatures, and the distinction between conceptual and procedural meaning.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the emergence and core ideas of Relevance Theory, its two main principles (Cognitive and Communicative), the distinction between explicatures and implicatures, the conceptualβprocedural meaning distinction introduced by Blakemore, and finally the accessibility and limitations of the theory, including its relation to contextual effects and processing effort.
π Lecture Summary
Topic β 109 What is Relevance Theory?
Relevance theory emerged in the 1980s in the collaborative work of Wilson and Sperber. It proposes that conversational implicature is understood by hearers simply by selecting the relevant features of context and recognizing whatever speakers say as relevant to the conversation. This theory is seen as a pragmatic theory because of its focus on the use of language in communication, specifically on the relationship between meaning and context. It is also a cognitive theory, in that it is concerned with the relationship between language and mind.
The core of the theory is the communicative principle of relevance. When hearers and readers make sense of a text, they interpret the connections between utterances as meaningful, making inferences by drawing on their own background knowledge of the world. The purpose of communication is not to 'duplicate thoughts' but to 'enlarge mutual cognitive environments'. The degree of relevance is governed by 'contextual effects' and 'processing effort'.
π Definition β Relevance Theory: A cognitive pragmatic theory proposing that conversational implicature is understood by hearers by selecting relevant features of context and recognizing what speakers say as relevant, balancing contextual effects against processing effort.
π Example: When a speaker says "It's raining," the hearer does not duplicate the speaker's thought but enlarges their mutual cognitive environment by inferring relevant implications (e.g., "take an umbrella") based on context.
Topic β 110 Principles of Relevance Theory
Wilson and Sperber classified Relevance theory into two main principles: Cognitive Principle and Communicative Principle of Relevance.
Any external stimulus or internal representation which provides an input to cognitive processes may be relevant to an individual at some time. Utterances raise expectations of relevance, not because speakers are expected to obey a Cooperative Principle and maxims, but because the search for relevance is a basic feature of human cognition.
Communicative Principle of Relevance is an attempt to work out one of Grice's central claims that an essential feature of most human communication, both verbal and non-verbal, is the expression and recognition of intentions. We keep on producing stimuli which gain other people's attention and thus lay the ground for communication. It is the tendency to maximize relevance that makes it possible to predict and manipulate the mental states of others, knowing your tendency to pick out the most relevant inputs.
π‘ Why this matters: These two principles establish that human cognition is inherently geared toward relevance, making communication efficient without requiring a cooperative principle like Grice's.
π Definition β Cognitive Principle of Relevance: The principle that the search for relevance is a basic feature of human cognition; utterances raise expectations of relevance because of this innate tendency.
π Definition β Communicative Principle of Relevance: The principle that communication involves expressing and recognizing intentions; speakers produce stimuli to gain attention, and the tendency to maximize relevance allows predicting and manipulating others' mental states.
Topic β 111 Explicatures and Implicatures
According to relevance theorists, the "explicature," or "explicit content", of an utterance of a sentence is a "development" of the sentence's "logical form".
An implicature is something that is built from what the speaker says in uttering the sentence. These conceptions sound similar enough, but they differ. Explicatures and implicatures (i.e. implicit premises and conclusions) are arrived at by a process of mutual parallel adjustment, with hypotheses about both being considered in order of accessibility.
Apparently both explicature and implicature sound similar, but these both are different from each other. Explicature, in simple terms, is directly conveyed content β "orally and graphologically form of an utterance." On the other hand, implicature is something which is implied in an utterance. It could mean that a speaker means one thing and conveys something else in addition. It is a hidden concept.
π Definition β Explicature: The explicitly communicated content of an utterance, developed from the sentence's logical form; the directly conveyed, oral or graphological form of what is said.
π Definition β Implicature: Something implied in an utterance, built from what the speaker says; a hidden concept where a speaker means one thing and conveys something else in addition.
π Example: If a speaker says "It's cold in here," the explicature is that the temperature is low. The implicature might be "Please close the window" β something implied but not directly stated.
Topic β 112 Conceptual and Procedural Meaning
The conceptualβprocedural distinction was introduced into relevance theory by Diane Blakemore (1987) to account for differences between regular 'content' words (such as dog, red, think or know, on the one hand) and discourse connectives (such as but, so, also, and after all, on the other). The vast majority of lexical items have conceptual meaning, including common nouns ('chair', 'water', etc.), verbs ('consider', 'leap', etc.), adjectives (e.g. 'red', 'slow', etc.), adverbs ('sadly', 'quickly', etc.), and prepositions ('behind', 'under', etc.).
Relevance theorists have claimed that words such as 'but', 'however', and inferential 'so' encode procedures. These items indicate something about the context in which they are to be processed. They guide the hearer towards intended contextual effects, and hence reduce the overall effort required to process the discourse. Two ways to distinguish between conceptual and procedural meaning (Wilson and Sperber, 1993: 16): (a) Conceptual meaning is available to consciousness, whereas procedurally encoded information is not. (b) Conceptual meaning is compositional, whereas procedurally encoded information is not.
π Definition β Conceptual Meaning: Meaning encoded by content words (nouns, verbs, adjectives, adverbs, prepositions) that represents concepts; it is available to consciousness and compositional.
π Definition β Procedural Meaning: Meaning encoded by discourse connectives (like but, however, so) that guides the hearer towards intended contextual effects by indicating how to process the context; it is not available to consciousness and not compositional.
π Example: In "It's raining, so take an umbrella," the word so has procedural meaning β it instructs the hearer to infer a cause-effect relationship, reducing processing effort by guiding interpretation.
Topic β 113 Accessibility and Limitations of Relevance Theory
The degree of relevance is related to contextual effects and processing effort. Contextual effects include such things as adding new information, strengthening or contradicting an existing assumption, or weakening old information. The more contextual effects, the greater the relevance of a fact. A new fact unconnected to anything already known is not worth processing, whereas a new fact taken with something already known is worth processing.
As far as the processing effort is concerned, the theory says that the less effort it takes to recover a fact, the greater the relevance. The speaker assumes which facts are accessible for the hearer and speaks in such a way that the hearer can make the correct inferences without too much effort. The context for the interpretation of an utterance is chosen by the hearer, and the speaker assumes that the facts are relatively accessible for the hearer. The hearer interprets what is said by finding an accessible context that produces 'the maximum amount of new information with the minimum amount of processing effort' (Trask 1999: 58).
Limitations of Relevance Theory are: This theory says nothing about interaction. It does not include cultural or social dimensions, such as age, gender, status, and nationality. An objection that one may have to Sperber and Wilson's model, as with Grice's Cooperative Principle model, is that different cultures, countries and communities have their own ways of observing, and expressing maxims.
π Definition β Contextual Effects: Changes to existing assumptions resulting from new information, including adding new information, strengthening or contradicting an existing assumption, or weakening old information; more contextual effects = greater relevance.
π Definition β Processing Effort: The cognitive work required to recover a fact or interpret an utterance; less effort = greater relevance. The hearer seeks "the maximum amount of new information with the minimum amount of processing effort."
π Example: If someone says "The train is delayed," and you already know you have a meeting, the contextual effect is strengthening the assumption "I will be late." The processing effort is low because the accessible context (meeting schedule) is used to make the inference easily.
β Key Takeaways
Relevance Theory, developed by Wilson and Sperber, replaces Grice's Cooperative Principle with the claim that the search for relevance is a fundamental feature of human cognition. It is governed by two principles: the Cognitive Principle (humans naturally seek relevance) and the Communicative Principle (speakers produce stimuli to express intentions, relying on the hearer's tendency to maximize relevance). The theory distinguishes between explicatures (explicit, developed logical form) and implicatures (implied, hidden content), and introduces the conceptual-procedural distinction where content words encode concepts and discourse connectives encode procedures that reduce processing effort. Relevance is determined by the balance of contextual effects and processing effort β the most relevant input yields maximum new information with minimum effort. However, the theory has limitations: it ignores interactional, cultural, and social dimensions such as age, gender, status, and nationality, which different communities may express differently.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two main principles of Relevance Theory, and how do they differ from Grice's Cooperative Principle?
- How do explicatures and implicatures differ in Relevance Theory? Provide an example.
- What is the conceptual-procedural distinction introduced by Diane Blakemore? Give examples of each type of meaning.
- How do contextual effects and processing effort jointly determine the degree of relevance?
- What are the main limitations of Relevance Theory regarding social and cultural dimensions?