π Lecture 11 β Presupposition
π Overview: This lecture introduces the concept of presupposition in semantics and pragmatics, exploring how speakers and listeners rely on implicit assumptions for communication. It examines two approaches to presupposition, the problem of presupposition failure, common triggers that generate presuppositions, and the crucial role of context in determining whether presuppositions hold.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining presupposition as implicit assumptions necessary for correct utterance interpretation, then contrasts semantic and pragmatic approaches. It discusses presupposition failure and the truth-value gap problem using examples like "The King of France is bald." The lecture categorizes presupposition triggers, including factive verbs, and concludes by examining how context can cancel presuppositions through defeasibility.
π Lecture Summary
Topic β 54 Introduction
Presupposition refers to the assumptions implicitly made by speakers and listeners that are necessary for the correct interpretation of an utterance. As Leech notes, it allows us the freedom not to state everything explicitly. Speakers assume certain information is already known by their listeners, and that information is called presupposition. Presupposition is treated as a relationship between two propositions.
π Definition β Presupposition: The assumptions implicitly made by speakers and listeners that are necessary for correct interpretation of an utterance.
Topic β 55 Two Approaches to Presupposition
In the first approach (semantic), sentences are viewed as external objects. Meaning is seen as an attribute of sentences rather than something constructed by participants. We do not worry about the process of producing them or the individuality of the speaker or writer.
The second approach (pragmatic) views sentences as utterances of individuals engaged in a communication act. The aim is to develop strategies that speakers and hearers use to communicate. Presupposition is one of a number of inferences that the listener might make based on what the speaker has said. The first approach is essentially semantic and the second pragmatic.
Topic β 56 Presupposition Failure
Presupposition failure is a phenomenon that caused problems for a truth relations approach. Using a name or a definite description to refer presupposes the existence of the named or described entity. For example:
- "Ronald is a vegetarian" presupposes "Ronald exists."
- "The King of France is bald" presupposes "There is a King of France."
The problem occurs when there exists no referent for the nominal. If the presupposed sentences are false, what is the status of the original sentences? Are they false, or are they in a grey-area, neither true nor false? This requires a modified truth table:
| p | q |
|---|---|
| T β T | |
| F β T | |
| T or F β T | |
| ? (T v F) β F |
If q is false, the status of p is dubious, possibly neither true nor false. This problem is known as a truth-value gap.
π Example: "The King of France is bald" β since there is no King of France (q is false), the sentence's truth value is dubious (neither true nor false).
π‘ Why this matters: Presupposition failure challenges classical truth-conditional semantics by showing that some sentences cannot be simply evaluated as true or false.
Topic β 57 Presupposition Triggers
Presupposition triggers are the types of presupposition produced by particular words or constructions. Some triggers derive from syntactic structures. Many presuppositions are produced by the presence of certain words (lexical triggers), mostly verbs. For example, verbs like 'regret' and 'realize' are called factive verbs because they presuppose the truth of their complement clause.
π Definition β Factive verbs: Verbs that presuppose the truth of their complement clause (e.g., 'regret', 'realize').
π Example: "She regrets that she was late" presupposes that "She was late" is true.
Topic β 58 Presupposition and Context
Presuppositional behavior is sensitive to context. Levinson (1983) gives an example of time adverbial clauses. For instance, "She cried before she finished her thesis" presupposes "She finished her thesis."
However, if we change the verb, the presupposition may no longer hold: "She died before she finished her thesis" does NOT presuppose "She finished her thesis."
Why? The presupposition is cancelled by our general knowledge of the world: we know that dead people do not normally complete unfinished theses. This characteristic is known as defeasibility β the cancelling of presupposition. These examples show that presuppositional behavior is related to context.
π Definition β Defeasibility: The property of presuppositions being cancelled or suspended in certain contexts due to world knowledge or other contextual factors.
π Example:
- "She cried before she finished her thesis" β Presupposes she finished her thesis.
- "She died before she finished her thesis" β Does not presuppose she finished her thesis (defeasibility at work).
β Key Takeaways
Presupposition is a crucial concept in pragmatics that explains how communication relies on shared background assumptions. The semantic approach treats presupposition as a relationship between propositions, while the pragmatic approach views it as inferences listeners make. Presupposition failure creates truth-value gaps, as seen in the classic "King of France" example. Factive verbs like 'regret' and 'realize' are important lexical triggers that presuppose the truth of their complements. Crucially, presuppositions are defeasible β they can be cancelled by context and world knowledge, as demonstrated by the "died before finishing" example.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between the semantic and pragmatic approaches to presupposition?
- What is a truth-value gap, and how does presupposition failure create one?
- Define factive verbs and give two examples with their presuppositions.
- What is defeasibility, and how does context affect presupposition cancellation?
- Why does "She died before she finished her thesis" not presuppose "She finished her thesis"?
π Lecture 12 β Sentence Semantics - I: Situations
π Overview: This lecture explores the classification of situations through language, focusing on how semantic distinctions like actions, states, processes, tenses, and aspects shape meaning. It further examines the linguistic categories of modality, mood, and evidentiality, which allow speakers to express attitudes, influence events, and communicate the source of their information, deepening the understanding of discourse.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture introduces the classification of situations into static and dynamic types using verb categories. It then covers tense, which relates situations to time, and aspect, which views events as complete or incomplete. The discussion moves to modality, including epistemic and deontic types, and then to mood, such as indicative, potential, subjunctive, and imperative. Finally, the lecture addresses evidentiality, which communicates a speaker's attitude towards the source of information, including witness, sensory, inferential, reportative, and assumed evidentials.
π Lecture Summary
[Topic β 59 Introduction: Classifying Situations]
Language allows the speaker to classify situations by using semantic distinctions of actions, states, processes, tenses, and aspects. Two common situation types are Static and Dynamic, which create different situations with the help of lexical categories in verbs. Knows, thinks, loves, like, have, remains etc. are stative verbs and do not contain physical actions. The Dynamic type contains action verbs such as eat, drive, walk. In events, the speaker views the situation as a whole, e.g., "the mine blew up". In processes, the speaker views the internal structure of a dynamic situation, e.g., "he ran to the forest". Processes can be divided into inchoatives and resultatives.
π Definition β Static Situation: A situation type using stative verbs that do not involve physical actions, such as knowing or loving. π Definition β Dynamic Situation: A situation type using action verbs that involve physical activity or change. π Definition β Event: A dynamic situation viewed as a complete whole by the speaker. π Definition β Process: A dynamic situation where the speaker views the internal structure or unfolding of the action.
[Topic β 60 Tense and Aspect]
Tense is a category which allows a speaker to relate situations to time. For example, "they will cut the grass tomorrow" is future tense. The Aspect System allows the speaker to relate situation and time, and to view an event in various ways: as complete or incomplete. Aspects have to do not with the location of an event in time, but with its temporal distribution or contour (Saeed, 2004). For example: "She is coming." (incomplete/progressive aspect), "She has come." (complete/perfect aspect).
π Definition β Tense: A grammatical category that locates a situation in time (e.g., past, present, future). π Definition β Aspect: A grammatical category that describes the internal temporal structure of a situation, such as whether it is complete or ongoing. π Example: The sentence "She is coming" uses the progressive aspect to show an incomplete or ongoing action, while "She has come" uses the perfect aspect to show a completed action.
[Topic β 61 Modality]
Modality is a linguistic category (like aspect or tense) that modifies the meaning of the event or action we talk about to include ways to "influence" the event described. Modality may express what the speaker wants to do (give permission, describe ability, suggest, request, offer, prohibit, express desires or necessity, etc.). It also expresses whether the speaker believes, or is sure that what he or she is saying is true. There are two types of modality: Epistemic Modality expresses the degree of knowledge how sure the speaker is in his communication, and Deontic Modality shows where the verbs mark the speaker's attitude to social factors of obligation, responsibility, and permission.
π Definition β Modality: A semantic category that modifies a proposition to express the speaker's attitude, such as possibility, necessity, or permission. π Definition β Epistemic Modality: Modality that expresses the speaker's degree of certainty or belief about the truth of a proposition (e.g., "It might rain"). π Definition β Deontic Modality: Modality that expresses the speaker's attitude towards the necessity or obligation of an action (e.g., "You must go"). π‘ Why this matters: Modality allows speakers not just to describe reality, but to talk about possibilities, obligations, and their own beliefs, making communication more nuanced.
[Topic β 62 Mood]
Mood is the quality of verb which conveys a writer's attitude or feelings towards a subject (Saeed, 2004). Mood also shows the feelings of a speaker at time of speaking. For example, "it may rain tomorrow." In this example, the speaker's attitude is uncertain about the rain. There are different types of moods:
- Indicative moods express a fact, opinion, or question based on realist form.
- Potential moods: The word 'Potential' stands for probability. So, potential moods may have specific verb endings. Conditional uses infinitives with auxiliary verbs such as have, be, should, etc.
- Subjunctive moods contrast with indicative moods because there is an element of uncertainty in subjunctive moods. These are used for wishes, beliefs, exhortations, etc., e.g., "May you live long!" (Saeed, 2004).
- Imperative moods make direct commands or requests. For example, "show me the money."
π Definition β Mood: A grammatical feature of verbs that reflects the speaker's attitude or feelings towards the action or state described. π Definition β Indicative Mood: The mood used to state facts, opinions, or ask questions based on reality. π Definition β Subjunctive Mood: The mood used to express wishes, possibilities, or non-real situations, often marked by uncertainty.
[Topic β 63 Evidentiality]
Evidentiality is a semantic category which allows a speaker to communicate his/her attitude to the source of his/her information. It further allows the speaker to say whether the statement relies on personal first-hand knowledge, or was acquired from another source (Saeed, 2004). There are different types of evidentiality:
- Witness Evidentiality: when an information source is obtained from the direct observation, e.g., "I saw him breaking the window". It is usually visual information (Eyewitness).
- Sensory Evidentiality: indicates that the speaker's evidence for truth is derived from the speaker's own sensory experience.
- Inferential Evidentiality: Indicates that the speaker makes his/her statement based on a deduction from facts and not on a direct observation of the action itself (Aikhenvald, 2004, 2006).
- Reportative Evidentiality: Indicates that the information was reported to the speaker by another person. It can be quotes, rumours or a news report.
- An assumed evidential indicates that the information source is not based on a mere guess but is rather based on the general knowledge or habitual activities.
π Definition β Evidentiality: A semantic category that specifies the source of evidence for a statement (e.g., direct observation, inference, or hearsay). π Definition β Witness Evidentiality: Evidence obtained through direct, usually visual, observation. π Definition β Reportative Evidentiality: Evidence obtained from another person's report, including quotes, rumors, or news. π‘ Why this matters: Evidentiality is crucial for evaluating the reliability of information and understanding the speaker's commitment to the truth of their statement.
β Key Takeaways
A student must remember that situations are classified into static (using stative verbs) and dynamic (using action verbs) types, and dynamic situations can be viewed as whole events or as processes with internal structure. Tense links actions to time, while aspect describes the temporal contour of an action as complete or incomplete. Modality is a key category for expressing the speaker's influence or certainty, divided into epistemic (knowledge) and deontic (obligation/permission). Mood reflects the speaker's attitude and includes indicative, potential, subjunctive, and imperative forms. Finally, evidentiality is a critical semantic category that specifies the source of information, such as direct witness, sensory experience, inference, report, or general assumption.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between a static situation and a dynamic situation, and what types of verbs are associated with each?
- Explain the difference between tense and aspect, providing an example for each.
- What are the two main types of modality, and what does each express about the speaker's communication?
- List and briefly define the four types of mood discussed in the lecture.
- How does a "reportative evidential" differ from a "witness evidential"? Provide an example sentence for each.
π Lecture 13 β Sentence Semantics - II: Participants
π Overview: This lecture explores the classification and identification of participant roles in sentence semantics, focusing on how entities involved in a situation can be described through thematic roles. It introduces various thematic role types, their definitions, and addresses the theoretical problems associated with defining and delimiting these roles, which is crucial for understanding how language structures meaning.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with an introduction to classifying participants in semantic situations, discussing various labels such as participant roles, deep semantic cases, and thematic roles. It then covers five specific thematic roles: Agent, Patient, Theme, and Experiencer. Next, it introduces Beneficiary, Instrument, Location, Goal, Source, and Stimulus. The lecture proceeds to address the practical challenges of identifying thematic roles, including distinctions between Agent and Actor, Patient and Theme, and the role of Force. Finally, it discusses the fundamental problems with thematic roles, including delimitation and definition, proposing Dowty's entailment-based solution.
π Lecture Summary
Topic β 64 Introduction: Classifying Participants
A speaker faces a set of semantic choices when describing a situation, specifically how to portray the roles of any entities involved. These roles have been given various labels in semantics, including participant roles (Allan, 1986), deep semantic cases (Fillmore, 1968), semantic roles (Givon, 1990), and thematic roles (Dowty, 1991; Jackendoff, 1990).
Thematic roles were introduced in generative grammar during the mid-1960s and early 1970s. In this framework, entities are described by the action of the verb. Thematic roles can be defined as: the roles that referents of the arguments of a verb play in the event or as the state that the verb denotes. A semantic role is the underlying relationship that a participant has with the main verb in a clause.
π Definition β Semantic Role: the underlying relationship that a participant has with the main verb in a clause. π‘ Why this matters: Grammatical relations (subject, object, etc.) are morphosyntactic, whereas semantic roles (agent, patient, instrument) are conceptual notions. Semantic roles do not correspond directly to grammatical relations, meaning a subject is not always an agent.
Topic β 65 Thematic Roles β I (Agent, Patient, Theme, Experiencer)
Agent is the initiator of some action, capable of acting with volition. For example, "Rashid cooked the meat." Patient is the entity/person undergoing the effect of the main action of a verb or undergoing some change in state. For example, "John cut down these bushes." Theme is the entity (person or thing) which is changed or moved by an action of a verb, or whose location is described by the verb. For example, "the book is in the library." Experiencer is the entity which is aware of the action or state described by the predicate but which is not in control of the action or state. For example, "Kamran heard the door shut."
π Definition β Agent: the initiator of some action, capable of acting with volition. π Example: "Rashid cooked the meat." β Rashid is the Agent, as he initiated the action of cooking with volition.
π Definition β Patient: the entity/person undergoing the effect of the main action of a verb or undergoing some change in state. π Example: "John cut down these bushes." β these bushes are the Patient, as they undergo the effect of being cut.
π Definition β Theme: the entity (person or thing) which is changed or moved by an action of a verb, or whose location is described by a verb. π Example: "the book is in the library." β the book is the Theme, as its location is described.
π Definition β Experiencer: the entity which is aware of the action or state described by the predicate but which is not in control of the action or state. π Example: "Kamran heard the door shut." β Kamran is the Experiencer, as he is aware of the sound but not in control of the door shutting.
Topic β 66 Thematic Roles β II (Beneficiary, Instrument, Location, Goal, Source, Stimulus)
Beneficiary is the entity for whose benefit the action was performed. For example, "they baked me a cake." Instrument is the means by which an action is performed or something comes about. For example, "I write a letter with the pen." Location is the place where something is situated or has taken place. For example, "the baby was hiding behind the curtain." Goal is the entity towards which something is moved, either literally or metaphorically. For example, "the driver handed his license to the policeman." Source is the entity from which something moves, either literally or metaphorically. For example, "I took the pen from the drawer." Stimulus is the entity causing an effect (usually psychological) during an experience. For example, "The noise of the horn frightened the passengers."
π Definition β Beneficiary: the entity for whose benefit the action was performed. π Example: "they baked me a cake." β me is the Beneficiary, as the cake was baked for my benefit.
π Definition β Instrument: the means by which an action is performed or something comes about. π Example: "I write a letter with the pen." β the pen is the Instrument, as it is the means for writing.
π Definition β Location: the place where something is situated or has taken place. π Example: "the baby was hiding behind the curtain." β behind the curtain is the Location.
π Definition β Goal: the entity towards which something is moved, either literally or metaphorically. π Example: "the driver handed his license to the policeman." β the policeman is the Goal, as the license is moved towards him.
π Definition β Source: the entity from which something moves, either literally or metaphorically. π Example: "I took the pen from the drawer." β the drawer is the Source, as the pen moves from it.
π Definition β Stimulus: the entity causing an effect (usually psychological) during an experience. π Example: "The noise of the horn frightened the passengers." β The noise of the horn is the Stimulus, as it causes the psychological effect of fear.
Topic β 67 Identifying Thematic Roles
Some writers suggested that an Agent displays volition and is a particular type of a more general thematic role Actor, where Actor expresses the participants which perform, effect or control the situation denoted by the predicate. Actor is not necessarily an animate entity. While comparing Patient and Theme, Patient is reserved for an entity acted upon and changed by the verb's action. Theme is an entity moved in a literal and figurative sense by the action of the verb but constitutionally unchanged. For example, "Awais shattered the rock." (Patient: the rock, as it is changed) vs. "Awais throw the rock." (Theme: the rock, as it is moved but unchanged).
Sometimes a role of Force is used instead of Instrument for an inanimate entity which causes something. For example, "The wind flattened the crops." and "The sea wall was weakened by the waves." While these roles may be intuitively clear, in practice, it is sometimes difficult to know which role to assign to a particular noun phrase.
π Definition β Actor: a more general thematic role which expresses the participants that perform, effect or control the situation denoted by the predicate. π Definition β Force: a role used for an inanimate entity which causes something, used instead of Instrument.
π Example (Patient vs. Theme):
- "Awais shattered the rock." β the rock is a Patient, as it undergoes a change in state (being shattered).
- "Awais throw the rock." β the rock is a Theme, as it is moved but remains constitutionally unchanged.
π Example (Force): "The wind flattened the crops." β The wind is a Force, as it is an inanimate entity that causes the flattening.
Topic β 68 Problems with Thematic Roles
The first problem is really about delimiting particular roles. The extreme case would be to identify individual thematic roles for each verb: thus we would say that a verb like 'beat' gives two theta-roles - a 'beater' role and a 'beaten' role. The second problem: how do we define theta-roles in general? That is, what semantic basis do we have for characterizing roles? Facing both these problems, Dowty (1991) proposes a solution where theta-roles are not semantic primitives but are defined in terms of entailment of the predicate.
π‘ Why this matters: These problems highlight the difficulty in creating a universal and consistent system for thematic roles, which is essential for accurate semantic analysis.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture provides a foundational understanding of thematic roles as semantic relationships between participants and verbs, distinct from grammatical relations. Students must remember the definitions and examples for the core roles: Agent, Patient, Theme, Experiencer, Beneficiary, Instrument, Location, Goal, Source, and Stimulus. Key distinctions include the volitional nature of the Agent versus the non-volitional Actor, the change-of-state aspect of Patient versus the movement aspect of Theme, and the use of Force for inanimate causers. The lecture also highlights critical theoretical challenges, such as delimiting individual roles for each verb and defining a general semantic basis for them, with Dowty's entailment-based solution offered as a key response. Finally, it is essential to remember that thematic role assignment can be difficult in practice, despite intuitive clarity.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the fundamental difference between grammatical relations (like subject and object) and semantic roles (like agent and patient)?
- Provide a sentence and identify the Agent, Patient, and Instrument thematic roles within it.
- Explain the difference between a Patient and a Theme, using distinct example sentences that clearly illustrate the contrast.
- According to the lecture, what are the two main problems associated with defining and using thematic roles?
- How does Dowty (1991) propose to solve the problems with defining and delimiting theta-roles?
π Lecture 14 β Semantics and Grammar
π Overview: This lecture examines the relationship between semantics (meaning) and grammar (form), arguing that grammatical categories must be established independently of meaning. It explores grammatical categories like gender, number, and person, distinguishes grammar from the lexicon, discusses grammatical relations such as transitivity and voice, and introduces case grammar as a system of functional relations between nouns and verbs.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers formal grammar and its distinction from semantics, grammatical categories including gender, number, person, and count/mass nouns, the boundary between grammar and lexicon illustrated by Chomsky's famous sentence, grammatical relations involving verbs (tense, aspect, voice, transitivity, causitivity), and case grammar with Fillmore's six casesβAgentive, Instrumental, Dative, Factitive, Locative, and Objective.
π Lecture Summary
Topic β 69 Formal Grammar
Formal grammar is the study or use of rules about how words change their form and combine with other words to express meaning. In English, sequence of sounds conveys meaning differently: 'Man' /mæn/ is singular grammatically and 'Men' /men/ is plural grammatically. Most traditional grammarians assumed that grammatical categories were essentially semantic. Some linguists argued that grammar must be distinct from semantics and that grammatical categories must be wholly defined in terms of the FORM of the language (Palmer, 1976).
In English, tense is not directly related to time since the past tense may be used for future, e.g. 'If he came tomorrow'. 'Hair' is used for singular and plural as well. Therefore, basic grammatical categories may be established independently of their meaning.
π‘ Why this matters: This challenges the intuitive assumption that grammar directly reflects meaning, showing that grammatical form and semantic content can diverge systematically.
Topic β 70 Grammatical Categories
Grammar is not restricted to the study of form or function words. It is concerned, more widely, with categories such as tense, gender, number, and with syntactic functions such as subject and object, e.g. 'Ali' (Noun/Subject, etc.). These categories can be on 'phrasal level' as well, e.g. 'Ali the son of John' is a noun phrase. According to Palmer, there are two familiar grammatical categories, 'Gender' and 'Number' but English has strictly no grammatical gender at all. It has, of course, pronouns he, she, it but these are essentially the markers of sex.
Noun class includes countable and uncountable, or count and mass nouns. Examples of count nouns are a cat, a book, an apple, etc. Mass nouns may occur with no article or with some indefinite quantifiers, e.g. some butter, some milk, little water.
The category of person (first person I, we, second person you, and the third person he, she, it, they) is often closely associated with number and with gender in the verbal forms of languages. The first person relates to a speaker while the second person relates to the hearer.
π Definition β Grammatical Categories: Tense, gender, number, and personβcategories that can be established independently of meaning and apply to both words and phrases.
π Definition β Count/Mass Nouns: Count nouns can take indefinite articles (a cat) while mass nouns occur with no article or indefinite quantifiers (some milk).
Topic β 71 Grammar and Lexicon
It is irrelevant for semantics whether a grammatical category is indicated by a form of the word, by a morpheme, or the order of the words. For example, past tense is marked by the past tense morpheme (-ed) but there is no similar morpheme to indicate the future; future is marked by 'shall, will, or be going to'.
The distinction between 'Grammar and Lexicon' can be posed in terms of the distinction between 'grammatically unacceptable sentence' and 'those that are excluded on lexical grounds'. The boys are in the room is incorrect but the meaning is not vague. Chomsky invented the sentence Colorless green ideas sleep furiously, which seems faultless grammatically, yet is completely unacceptable lexically. Therefore, if a sentence conforms to grammar but be completely deviant lexically, it would seem that grammar and lexicon are distinct.
π Definition β Lexical deviance: A sentence that is grammatically well-formed but semantically anomalous because its words violate selectional restrictions.
π Example: Colorless green ideas sleep furiously β grammatically correct (Subject-Verb-Adverb structure) but lexically deviant (colors cannot be colorless, ideas cannot sleep, etc.)
Topic β 72 Grammatical Relations
Grammatical categories of the verb, tense, aspect, phase, and voice are linked with each other, and a small alteration in the order of these categories completely changes the meaning of a sentence. For example, 'John plays the piano' can be transformed into 'the piano is played by John'.
Transformation is where the grammatical categories not only affect one element (verb) but also affect the whole sentence. For example, 'He ate food' is changed into 'Food was eaten by him' (Passive). Subject and objects are marked by position: the subject precedes the verb (e.g. 'She laughed') and the object follows the verb (e.g. 'She killed a snake').
Verbs that have objects are called transitive verbs and those without objects are called intransitive verbs, e.g. He ate food (Transitive), He laughed (Intransitive). Another term called causitivity is closely related to transitivity where an actor becomes the reason for doing an action.
π Definition β Grammatical Relations: The relationships between verbs and their arguments (subject, object) marked by position and affecting sentence meaning through transformations.
π Formula: Subject + Transitive Verb + Object β Object + Passive Verb + (by Subject)
π Example: 'John plays the piano' β 'the piano is played by John'
Topic β 73 Case Grammar
A system of grammatical description based on the functional relations that noun groups have to the main verb of a sentence (Collins Dictionary Online). Palmer has given three cases β Agentive, Instrumental, and Object. Fillmore has suggested six cases β Agentive, Instrumental, Dative, Factitive, Locative, Objective.
Agentive is typically animate perceived instigator. Instrumental is inanimate force or object causally involved. Dative is animate being affected. Factitive is object resulting from the action or state. Locative is location or spatial orientation. Objective is the semantically most neutral case.
π Definition β Case Grammar: A grammatical description based on the functional relations noun groups have to the main verb; represents deep semantic roles rather than surface case markings.
π Example: In 'John opened the door with a key' β John = Agentive, a key = Instrumental, the door = Objective
β Key Takeaways
The most critical takeaway is that grammatical categories such as tense, gender, number, and person must be established independently of their meaning, since English past tense can refer to future and 'hair' can be both singular and plural. Grammar and lexicon are distinct, as proven by Chomsky's Colorless green ideas sleep furiouslyβgrammatically flawless but lexically deviant. Grammatical relations involve transformations that alter voice and meaning while maintaining core propositional content, and transitivity distinguishes verbs taking objects from those that do not. Finally, case grammar (especially Fillmore's six-case system: Agentive, Instrumental, Dative, Factitive, Locative, Objective) provides a functional framework for analyzing the semantic roles noun groups play in relation to verbs.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Why does Palmer argue that grammatical categories must be established independently of meaning? Provide one example from English.
- What is the difference between count nouns and mass nouns? Give two examples of each.
- Explain why Chomsky's sentence "Colorless green ideas sleep furiously" demonstrates the distinction between grammar and lexicon.
- What is the difference between transitive and intransitive verbs? How does causitivity relate to transitivity?
- List Fillmore's six cases in case grammar and briefly define the Agentive and Instrumental cases.
π Lecture 15 β Formal Semantics Today
π Overview: This lecture explores the diversity within formal semantics, including various theoretical approaches like Possible Worlds semantics and Davidsonian semantics. It also examines relationships between formal semantics and other varieties of semantics, related academic fields, and the social functions of language through Leech's framework.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers diversity within formal semantics including Possible Worlds semantics, Model-Theoretic Semantics, and Davidsonian approaches. It discusses relationships with other varieties of semantics such as semiotics, reference, and lexicology. The lecture also explores connections with syntax, pragmatics, philosophy of language, logic, computer science, and cognitive science. Finally, it examines Semantics and Society through Leech's five language functions and associative meaning.
π Lecture Summary
Topic β 74 Diversity within Formal Semantics
Portner (2005) has used 'Possible Worlds' as one of the most popular tools for representing diversity within semantics. Model-Theoretic Semantics is based on 'what reality is like which is useful for semantic purposes' β this includes concepts of truth, falsity, or inadmissibility. Truth-conditions of sentences are defined in terms of a model of reality appropriate to how language works, with it being a further issue how that model relates to reality itself through the "intended model" and the "intended interpretation."
Davidsonian Semanticists argue that we can do semantics without possible worlds. They agree with other formal semanticists that the meaning of a sentence consists in its truth-conditions, but think that possible worlds and the like are not the right way to think about truth-conditions. Rather, they say that it's better to simply and directly express truth-conditions with statements like: snow is white is true if, and only if, snow is white.
π Definition β Situation: A partial reality (or partial model of reality) that is less than a complete possible world, used as a basis for our notion of meaning.
Many formal semanticists have used the concept of a "situation" in their work β the idea that we want to have something less than a complete possible world to base our notion of meaning on. A semanticist talking about situations has in mind a partial reality (or partial model of reality). The role of a sentence is to classify situations according to some more general features of reality. There are constraints which relate situations of one kind to situations of another kind.
Topic β 75 Relationships with other Varieties of Semantics
Formal semantics relates to other varieties such as semiotics, reference, lexicology, etc. Not all semanticists are formal semanticists. There are perspectives on semantics within linguistics which don't accept the formal semantic-commitment to truth-conditional meaning (Portner, 2005). There are some approaches which argue as strongly as they can that the others are wrong, so that whichever theory is actually right (it's formal semantics!) will eventually be proven so. On the other hand, no approach yet invented is right, and so at some points, we should be ready to synthesize apparently incompatible ideas.
There should be more sharing of ideas at the level of individual linguistic topics. Often, advocates of one approach simply ignore the results of research in others, and this leads to the duplication of effort and to avoidable mistakes (Portner, 2005). In contrast, to suggest a case which highlights an area of relative weakness in formal semantics, it is wise for formal semanticists to remain attuned to the mass of work on lexical meaning developed within other perspectives (Portner, 2005).
Topic β 76 Relationship with other Fields
Syntax, Pragmatics, and the Philosophy of language are intellectual areas with which formal semantics makes the closest relation. New ideas in any of these fields can have a direct impact on how semanticists think about language, both in a general way and in studying a particular feature of the language (Portner, 2005). Formal semantics also has connections to three other areas of intellectual inquiry: logic, computer science, and cognitive science.
The fundamental goal of logic is to characterize valid patterns of reasoning, steps of inference which will lead from true premises to true conclusion. As human language is ambiguous and vague, logicians have developed artificial and 'logical' language. Formal semantics is linked with computer science for both intellectual and practical reasons. Cognitive Science focuses on the understanding of the human mind. The most important component disciplines of cognitive science are linguistics, psychology, neuroscience, philosophy, and computer science (Portner, 2005).
Topic β 77 Semantics and Society - I
Leech has given five functions of a language which play a major role in human society:
π Definition β Informational Function: A function linked with the subject matter.
π Definition β Expressive Function: A function used to express its originator's feelings and attitudes.
π Definition β Directive Function: A function where we aim to influence the behavior or attitudes of others, e.g. commands and requests.
π Definition β Aesthetic Function: A function for poetic expressions β the use of language for the sake of the linguistic artefact itself, and for no ulterior purpose, e.g. the message is often conceptual as with effective meaning. In aesthetic function, both the poet and the reader bring a heightened sensitivity to bear on the act of communication.
π Definition β Phatic Function: A function which keeps communication lines open, and keeps social relationships in good repair, e.g. 'to show that intentions in communication are sincere and friendly', e.g. greetings, farewells, and routine polite questions.
Topic β 78 Semantics and Society - II
According to Leech, the associative meaning of an expression has to do with individual mental understandings of the speaker. Conceptual meanings are based on the idea that the speaker wants to deliver. Two dangers can arise if attitudes and emotions are conveyed by the associative meanings of words (Leech, 1981). One is 'misconception and misunderstanding' because associative meanings tend to vary from person to person. The second danger is that if the affective meaning of the message predominates over the conceptual meaning, the listener or reader will not be able to understand what is being said.
Certain feelings may be difficult to put into words, e.g. 'I love my mother' or 'my mother is my love'. Both give different emotions.
π Definition β Euphemism (Greek: 'well-speaking'): The practice of referring to something offensive or indelicate in terms that make it sound more pleasant or becoming than it really is.
Associative engineering is also used as a positive term in advertising. When different words are used which have the same conceptual meanings, for example, one might call someone a lady rather than a woman.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding the distinction between conceptual and associative meanings helps us recognize how language choice affects perception, from personal relationships to advertising and social interactions.
β Key Takeaways
Formal semantics encompasses diverse approaches including Possible Worlds semantics, Model-Theoretic Semantics, and Davidsonian semantics, each with different perspectives on truth-conditions. Formal semantics relates to other varieties of semantics (semiotics, reference, lexicology) and fields (syntax, pragmatics, philosophy of language, logic, computer science, cognitive science), and scholars should share ideas to avoid duplication of effort. Leech's five language functions (informational, expressive, directive, aesthetic, phatic) explain how language operates in society. Associative meaning differs from conceptual meaning and can lead to misunderstanding when emotions predominate over content. Euphemism and associative engineering demonstrate how word choice shapes social perception and communication.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
-
What is the difference between Model-Theoretic Semantics and Davidsonian Semantics regarding possible worlds?
-
What are Leech's five functions of language, and what purpose does each serve in society?
-
What two dangers does Leech identify when attitudes and emotions are conveyed through associative meanings of words?
-
How does the concept of a "situation" differ from a "possible world" in formal semantics?
-
What is euphemism, and how does associative engineering function in advertising?