π Lecture 36 β Research in Pragmatics
π Overview: This lecture explores how pragmatic hypotheses are formulated, tested, and investigated through empirical research. It covers the complete research process from data collection and transcription to identifying investigable topics and practical approaches for conducting pragmatic analysis. The lecture emphasizes the importance of rigorous methodology in studying real-world language use.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the nature of pragmatic investigation including hypothesis formation and testing, methods for collecting data for pragmatic analysis with attention to experimental design and ethical considerations, transcription conventions for conversation analysis, a range of investigable topics such as conversational strategies and intercultural pragmatics, and practical guidance for learning pragmatics through hands-on data-driven analysis.
π Lecture Summary
Topic β 181 The Nature of Pragmatic Investigation
In linguistic investigation, a favored method is to frame and test hypotheses. For example, when someone says to a two-year-old "Why don't you use your spoon?" and the child obligingly picks up the spoon, it can be hypothesized that two-year-olds can understand indirect speech acts. This demonstrates how observable behavior can lead to testable hypotheses.
The research method involves following specific procedures: (1) framing a testable hypothesis suggested by observation, (2) designing an experiment to collect data testing this hypothesis, (3) collecting the data under experimental conditions, (4) quantifying the data to determine whether the hypothesis is proved, and (5) considering implications and whether follow-up experiments would be useful.
Very often, empirical research tries to determine whether there is a significant association, as opposed to a chance association, between two variables. For example, researchers may investigate whether there is a significant association between age and understanding of indirect speech acts as demonstrated by compliance with indirect requests.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding how to move from observation to testable hypothesis is fundamental to conducting credible pragmatic research.
Topic β 182 Collecting Data for Pragmatic Analysis
Data collection typically involves elicited data through carefully designed experiments. All non-relevant variables must be eliminated to ensure you measure what you intend to measure. For instance, if a linguist measured two-year-olds' responses to indirect requests only to realize afterwards that the results reflected how palatable the requests were, the experiment would be invalid.
Several important considerations arise when collecting data. Recording natural conversations with friends who know they are being taped often yields anything but natural conversation. There is also an ethical issue β researchers must not use data provided by informants without their consent.
Other important points include conducting a pilot study to determine whether the data is (a) audible and transcribable, and (b) useful for the intended purpose. One solution is to record data on video, though this is usually impractical. Another option is noting the opening words of each speaker, which can be a foolproof method.
π Definition β Elicited data: Data collected through carefully designed experiments that control for non-relevant variables to measure specific phenomena.
Topic β 183 Transcription of Conversation
Conventional transcriptions of conversations use standard orthographic script rather than phonemic transcription. They show how items like 'and' and 'your' are actually spoken since their realization may vary. You might expect to indicate hesitations (e.g., 'er' and 'umm'), fillers and uptake signals (e.g., 'uh-uh' and 'yeah'), and audible breathing ((hh) for out-breath and (hh) for indrawn breath).
A more difficult issue is representing intonation and pitch. The easiest solution for distinctive pitch prominence is marking it by capitalizing the appropriate segment (e.g., you WHAT). More important in many ways is marking features of conversational sequences. For instance, you will always need to mark pauses in the talk.
The widely used convention uses parentheses, with the length of pause indicated in tenths of seconds. For example, '(2.5)' represents a pause of two-and-a-half seconds. Short pauses can be marked with parentheses and points: '(.)' equals a one-syllable length pause, and '(..)' equals a two-syllable length pause. Another sequencing phenomenon that needs to be marked is the overlap of two speakers.
π Formula for pause notation: (2.5) = 2.5 second pause; (.) = one-syllable pause; (..) = two-syllable pause
Topic β 184 Investigable Topics
Many areas can be investigated in pragmatics. Conversational strategies examine how turn-taking works β according to what principles and by what means does the speaker select the next speaker? Who self-selects at TRPs (Transition Relevance Places) and with what effects? What are the mechanics of interruption? Is topic a viable unit of analysis? Units of conversation include insertion sequences, adjacency pairs, and pre-sequences.
Activity types and the institutional use of language involve examining the structure and pragmatic properties of seminars, interviews, and talk types like telephone conversations, ordering sequences in restaurants, and contributions to radio phone-ins. Researchers investigate to what extent these speech events are goal-oriented and how talk is constrained by allowable contributions.
Focusing on power and distance involves studying relation indicating devices (Matsumoto, 1988) β how speakers encode these relationships and how speakers get their own way. Face work examines how speakers use politeness strategies to acknowledge the face wants of others.
Intercultural pragmatics investigates how members of different cultural groups accommodate and react to socio-pragmatic differences. Context research asks whether external social structure determines talk organization or whether context is created by the talk itself. Folk views of talk investigate the extent to which people's beliefs about pragmatic uses of language (politeness, interruption, etc.) are oriented to in actual talk.
π Definition β Adjacency pairs: Paired utterances in conversation where the first part requires a specific second part (e.g., question-answer, greeting-greeting).
Topic β 185 Learning by Doing
Grundy made comments about ways of learning pragmatics by doing data-driven pragmatic analysis. Students' work consists of recording naturally occurring data such as conversations, meetings talk, institutional talk, media talk, an instruct sequence, classroom talk, or an interview β whatever interests them.
Students may select two minutes of this recording and describe both the distal context and the immediate talk context in which it occurs. If the data are transcribable and analyzable, students move to the next stage β actually transcribing it. They bring their data to class to try out suggestions from classmates and get feedback. When their approach is decided, they write about the analytic parameters they intend to use.
π Example: A student recorded a mother/small child exchange in which the child was complaining vigorously about having to leave a place she was visiting earlier than she had expected in order to go back home.
π‘ Why this matters: Hands-on analysis of authentic data is the most effective way to understand how pragmatic principles operate in real communication.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture emphasizes that pragmatic research requires moving from observation to testable hypothesis through careful experimental design. Data collection must control for non-relevant variables and adhere to ethical standards of informed consent. Transcription conventions are essential for representing conversational features including pauses, hesitations, overlaps, and intonation. A wide range of investigable topics exist including turn-taking, institutional language, power relations, face work, intercultural differences, and the relationship between context and talk. Most importantly, the most effective way to learn pragmatics is through hands-on analysis of naturally occurring data, following a systematic process from recording to transcription to analysis.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
-
What are the four steps involved in investigating a pragmatic hypothesis according to the lecture?
-
Why is it important to eliminate non-relevant variables when collecting data for pragmatic analysis?
-
How are pauses of different lengths represented in conversation transcription conventions?
-
What is the difference between investigating conversational strategies and investigating activity types in institutional language use?
-
According to Grundy's approach, what should students do after recording naturally occurring data and before writing their analysis?
π Lecture 37 β KEY TERMS IN PRAGMATICS
π Overview: This lecture introduces key concepts in pragmatics, focusing on how meaning is determined beyond grammar and literal interpretation. It covers ambiguity, disambiguation, vagueness, referential vs. attributive uses, argumentation theory, the code model, communicative competence, demonstratives, and ellipsis. Understanding these terms is essential for analyzing how context, speaker intention, and shared knowledge shape communication.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers ten main topics: Ambiguity, Disambiguation, and Vagueness (Topic 186); Attributive Concept and Argumentation Theory/Referential/Attributive Distinction (Topic 187); Code Model (Topic 188); Communicative Competence (Topic 189); Demonstrative (Topic 190); and Ellipsis (Topic 191). Each topic defines a key pragmatic term and provides examples to illustrate how meaning is conveyed beyond literal word meaning.
π Lecture Summary
Topic β 186 Ambiguity, Disambiguation and Vagueness
Ambiguity is a sequence of linguistic signs (written, spoken, or signed) that is assigned more than one meaning by the grammar. Ambiguous expressions have more than one meaning in the language. There are two main types: Structural ambiguity is due to the syntactic structure of the utterance, as in "They are fighting fish" (Nicholas Allott, 1988), which could mean either fish that are fighting or fish that are meant for fighting. Lexical ambiguity occurs when one form corresponds to more than one word with different meanings, like the word bank in "I pass the bank on the way to work" (financial institution or river bank).
Disambiguation is the process of selecting the intended sense of an ambiguous word, phrase, or sentence from among the senses allowed by the grammar. This process is largely unconscious and automatic, which is why most ambiguity goes unnoticed by the speaker or hearer.
Vagueness refers to a meaning that is not clearly defined. Much attention has focused on vague predicates. For example, it has been argued that the predicate bald is vague. If someone says 'John is bald', we may not know whether the proposition expressed by the utterance is true or false, even though we know all the relevant facts.
π Definition β Structural ambiguity: ambiguity arising from the syntactic structure of an utterance rather than individual word meanings. π Example: "They are fighting fish" β could mean (a) they are fish that are currently fighting, or (b) they are fish bred for fighting.
π Definition β Lexical ambiguity: ambiguity arising when a single word form corresponds to multiple distinct meanings. π Example: "I pass the bank on the way to work" β bank could mean a financial institution or the side of a river.
π Definition β Vagueness: a meaning that is not clearly defined or precisely bounded. π Example: "John is bald" β Even knowing all facts, we may not agree on whether the statement is true because bald has no clear cutoff point.
Topic β 187 Attributive Concept and Argumentation Theory/Referential/Attributive Distinction
In relevance theory, attributive use of a concept is where a word or phrase is used to express a concept that a speaker attributes to someone else and which she need not endorse herself. A concept used in this way is sometimes called an attributive concept. Attributive use is a type of interpretive use: specifically, it is interpretive use in which there is attribution of a thought or utterance to another. For example, 'An amazing thought entered into my brain' β Amazing is an attribute of thought.
Argumentation Theory is the systematic study of discourse that is intended to persuade rationally, including the study of logical arguments and fallacies and their uses. Argumentation theory is a sub-field of pragmatics since persuading by the use of arguments is one use of language, e.g., Media communication. Argumentation theorists also investigate normative as well as descriptive aspects of language use.
Referential/Attributive Distinction is a distinction between two apparently different ways of using definite descriptions, made by the philosopher Keith Donnellan (Allott, 1988). One way of using a definite description is to talk about whichever individual (or individuals, for plural definite descriptions) satisfies the material in the nominal restrictor. This is the attributive use. Another way of using a definite description is to pick out and talk about a certain individual (or individuals, for plural definite descriptions). This is the referential use.
π Definition β Attributive concept: a concept used to express a thought attributed to someone else, which the speaker may not endorse. π Example: "An amazing thought entered into my brain" β Amazing expresses the attribute the speaker attributes to the thought, possibly quoting someone else's evaluation.
π Definition β Argumentation Theory: the systematic study of discourse intended to persuade rationally, including logical arguments and fallacies.
π Definition β Referential/Attributive Distinction: a distinction between using a definite description to talk about whoever fits the description (attributive) versus using it to pick out a specific individual (referential). π‘ Why this matters: This distinction helps analyze how definite descriptions function differently in different contexts, e.g., "Smith's murderer is insane" β attributive (whoever murdered Smith) vs. referential (a specific person we know is Smith's murderer).
Topic β 188 Code Model
Code Model is a model of communication according to which communication involves the transmission of meaning β the message β by encoding it in language or some other codes. The transmitter encodes and transmits the message as a linguistic signal, which the receiver then decodes.
According to the model, a coding/decoding process will lead to perfect transmission of the message if the code is shared, encoding and decoding are carried out successfully, and the signal is not degraded by noise or interrupted (Allott, 1988). The terms message, signal, transmitter, and receiver are from information theory. For example, a speaker says 'Tree'. The hearer would encode it into 'Stem, branches, leaves and other parts of a tree'. Encoding can also be on the sentence level.
π Definition β Code Model: a model where communication is the encoding and decoding of a message via a shared code. π Formula: Transmitter β Encodes Message β Linguistic Signal β Receiver Decodes β Original Message (if code is shared, no noise) π Example: Speaker says "Tree" β Hearer decodes to "Stem, branches, leaves" β Successful only if both share the same code for tree.
Topic β 189 Communicative Competence
Communicative Competence is the ability to communicate in a language. It includes competence with the grammatical forms of the language and the ability to put forms of the language to use in communication (Allott, 1988). This term was invented by the anthropologist and sociolinguist Dell Hymes.
Now a popular notion in applied linguistics and language teaching, where the aim is to teach not just grammar and speech sounds, but also strategies for communicating in that language. This teaching tends not so much to be concerned with pragmatics in a narrow sense (implicatures, reference assignment, etc.) as with teaching social conventions about how the language is used (Allott, 1988).
A speaker should have the competence to talk to a lady, old man, or a professional differently. This is communicative competence β how perfectly you answer after analyzing the situation!
π Definition β Communicative Competence: the ability to communicate effectively, combining grammatical knowledge with knowledge of social conventions for language use. π‘ Why this matters: Knowing grammar alone is not enough; one must also know when, how, and to whom to say things β crucial for real-world communication and language teaching.
Topic β 190 Demonstrative
A group of indexical words or phrases that are used to refer include this, that, these, and those (in English). These words are used to make demonstrative phrases, for example, this pen, that car, these keys, those penguins (Allott, 1988). Demonstratives are often accompanied by a gesture that demonstrates the object referred to, pointing, or gazing at the object, e.g., 'that boy'.
As with other indexicals, the referent of a demonstrative must be worked out to know what proposition the speaker is expressing. The particular demonstrative used restricts the search for referents in subtle ways. If there is one book on a table, the speaker may refer to it with 'this book' or 'that book'. But if it is the nearer of two, then 'this book' is preferred, except if both books are nearer the hearer, when again 'that book' is acceptable.
In English and other languages, the demonstratives encode a two-way proximal/distal distinction, but other languages have a three-way or four-way distinction. For space deixis, demonstratives are frequently used for discourse deixis, as in: "I am glad you told me that" and "This is what I'll be talking about today".
π Definition β Demonstrative: indexical words (this, that, these, those) used to refer, often with a gesture. π Example: "That boy" β requires context (pointing or shared visual field) to identify which boy is meant.
π Definition β Proximal/Distal Distinction: the encoding of nearness (proximal: this) vs. distance (distal: that) in demonstratives. π Example: Two books on a table β the nearer book is called this book; the farther is that book.
Topic β 191 Ellipsis
When linguistic material is missing from the pronounced form of a phrase or sentence, that phrase/sentence is said to be (syntactically) elliptical. For example, Mary kicked John, and Jane, Bill. Here the verb 'kicked' has been ellipted. In the next two examples the ellipted material is in brackets: 'Jane fought because Mary did (fight)'; 'She has stopped now but I don't know why (she stopped).'
Recovery of elided elements is necessary to work out what proposition is being expressed by an utterance of a sentence (Allott, 1988). The missing material is recovered from the linguistic antecedent. This is usually regarded as a task for parsing and thus in a sense pre-pragmatic.
There may be more than one possible reconstruction, as in the following example: John noticed that Mary left and Jane did too. Selection of the speaker's intended sense in such examples is a pragmatic task: a form of disambiguation. There is also 'semantic' or 'pragmatic' ellipsis. The questions in brackets illustrate in what way the meaning seems unspecific: [Marvellous! (what is marvellous?)], [The door is open. (which door?)], [He finished his book. (finished doing what with it?)], [On the top shelf. (what is on the top shelf?)]
π Definition β Ellipsis: the omission of linguistic material from the pronounced form, recoverable from context or antecedent. π Example: "Mary kicked John, and Jane, Bill" β kicked is ellipted in the second clause; full form: "Mary kicked John, and Jane kicked Bill."
π Example: "John noticed that Mary left and Jane did too" β ambiguous: did Jane notice, or did Jane leave? Pragmatic disambiguation is needed.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts for exam preparation from this lecture are: understanding the three related but distinct phenomena of ambiguity (multiple grammatical meanings), disambiguation (selecting the intended meaning), and vagueness (indeterminate meaning boundaries). The referential/attributive distinction is a key analytical tool for definite descriptions, while the code model presents a foundational but simplified view of communication. Communicative competence combines grammatical knowledge with social conventions for appropriate language use. Finally, demonstratives and ellipsis both require context-dependent recovery of referents or missing material, demonstrating the central pragmatic principle that meaning often goes beyond what is explicitly said.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between structural ambiguity and lexical ambiguity? Provide one example of each.
- Explain the referential/attributive distinction for definite descriptions as proposed by Keith Donnellan.
- What are the four conditions required for perfect communication according to the Code Model?
- How does communicative competence differ from mere grammatical competence, and who coined this term?
- In the sentence "John noticed that Mary left and Jane did too," what makes ellipsis a pragmatic (rather than purely syntactic) task?
π Lecture 39 β KEY TERMS IN PRAGMATICS-II
π Overview: This lecture explores advanced pragmatic terminology and concepts, including folk pragmatics, formal and experimental approaches, cognitive pragmatics, and various figures of speech. It also covers neo-Gricean principles and key theoretical notions like linguistic underdeterminacy, manifestness, and misfire. Understanding these terms is essential for analyzing how meaning is constructed, conveyed, and interpreted in real communication.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers twenty key terms in pragmatics organized into distinct topics: folk pragmatics, formal and experimental pragmatics, cognitive pragmatics, fragments, metaphor and synecdoche, hyperbole and irony, the I-Principle and M-Principle, the Q-Principle and R-Principle, the linguistic underdeterminacy thesis, manifestness and markedness, misfire, and prosody and tautology. Each term is defined and explained with examples from pragmatic theory.
π Lecture Summary
Topic β 192 Folk Pragmatics
Folk pragmatics is modeled on folk physics and folk psychologyβpre-theoretical expectations about how things work. Folk psychology involves pre-theoretical expectations about how behavior relates to thoughts and aims. One important source of evidence about folk beliefs is how we talk about communication in ordinary language. Everyday vocabulary is rich with words like topic, interruption, say, and means, as in "Did you mean that?"
The vocabulary for talking about communication varies across languages. For example, positive feedback through short words or encouraging noises is important in conversation across all languages and cultures. Systematic investigation in pragmatics often begins with folk words and transforms them into technical terms.
Topic β 193 "Formal" and "Experimental Pragmatics"
Formal Pragmatics is the study of pragmatic phenomena using techniques and notations from logic and mathematics. It is largely an extension of formal, model-theoretic semantics into the domain of more context-sensitive elements of speaker meaning. Formal pragmatics and dynamic approaches to semantics like Discourse Representation Theory are closely related. So far, work in formal pragmatics has only been concerned with a subset of pragmatic topics, particularly those at the semantic-pragmatics interface, including definiteness and indefiniteness, presupposition, scalar implicature, conventional implicature, and focus.
Formal pragmatics serves two important functions in Habermas's philosophy. First, it is the theoretical underpinning of the theory of communicative action, a crucial element of his theory of society. Second, it contributes to ongoing philosophical discussions regarding truth, meaning, rationality, and action.
Experimental Pragmatics involves the application of experimental techniques, largely from psycholinguistics, to areas of interest in pragmatics. Techniques include on-line measures like eye-tracking and timed responses to stimuli, and off-line measures like choosing the best sentence to describe a scene from a set of candidates. Experimental pragmatics is a very recent development, although existing psycholinguistic work on disambiguation, semantic illusions, and other aspects of interpretation is relevant.
Topic β 194 Cognitive Pragmatics
According to Bruno G. Bara (2010), Cognitive pragmatics focuses on the mental states and mental correlates of the participants in a conversation. The mental processes of human communication are based on three fundamental concepts: cooperation, sharedness, and communicative intention. These three fundamentals were proposed by Grice in 1975, though each has since been refined by other scholars.
The cooperative nature of communication is justified by the evolutionary perspective through which cooperative reasoning underlying a conversation is explained. Sharedness accounts for the possibility of comprehending non-standard communication such as deceit, irony, and figurative language. According to Nicholas Allott (1988), the role of language is to allow the communication of thoughts. For cognitive linguists, language and the way we think are not to be artificially separated, and the study of language is expected to yield insights into cognition in general: "language is a window into the mind" (Fauconnier).
Topic β 195 Fragment
Linguistic material that is less than a complete sentence is called a fragment. Many utterances are fragments. For example: "Over here!", "Water!", "On the second shelf down, behind the jam.", "Nice one!", and in dialogue: A: "How many cats do you have?" B: "Five."
Fragments are generally, although not always, linguistic constituents: preposition phrases, noun phrases, and so on. Uttering a non-constituent is usually strange, such as "*shelf down" or "*cats do you." Fragments can be used to express complete propositions. For example, a speaker uttering "On the top shelf" might mean "The jar is on the top shelf." In response to "Where are you going?" the answer can be "to school." In response to "Did you eat something?" the answer can be "ate nothing." It is controversial whether fragments are sometimes or never syntactically elliptical. Example: "Are you writing something?" β "A letter to my friend."
Topic β 196 Metaphor and Synecdoche
Metaphor is a type of figurative speech. Typically, a metaphor ascribes to an entity a property that it does not, strictly and literally speaking, possess, although not all metaphors fit this definition. Metaphors are not restricted to any particular type of word or phrase. The metaphorical element of a sentence can be a noun phrase, as in "John is an iceberg." Verbs can also be used metaphorically, as in "Flintoff drilled the ball to the boundary."
Synecdoche is a figure of speech in which an expression that denotes the part of something is used to refer to the whole. For example, "mouth" in "I've got six hungry mouths to feed." Another example is "willow" for cricket bat in phrases like "to wield the willow."
The term "synecdoche" is sometimes also regarded as including the use of an expression denoting a smaller class to refer to a larger class, and the converse situation. This is a very broad definition since it would include obvious metaphors such as "that animal" for "that man." Many cases of polysemy are regarded as related through synecdoche. One example is the two senses of "chicken": the type of bird, and the meat.
π Definition β Synecdoche: a figure of speech where a part of something is used to refer to the whole (or a smaller class for a larger class).
Topic β 197 Hyperbole and Irony
Hyperbole is a figure of speech also known as an overstatement, in which a speaker expresses an exaggerated meaning beyond what their words carry in themselves. Intuitively, this is a very common figure of speech. People often say "I am starving" when they mean they are merely rather hungry. "It's miles and miles" is a common way of complaining about even quite short distances. On a Gricean analysis, hyperbole is a blatant violation of the first maxim of quality. For example, the speaker is not literally starving. In the second example, the destination might be in the next street, but the speaker is exaggerating.
Irony is a figure of speech seen in examples like: Alistair (stepping out into heavy rain): "Another lovely day!" The classical conception of irony is that it is a figure of speech in which the speaker means the opposite of what her words mean. However, this condition is neither necessary nor sufficient for irony. For example, someone sees a car with a broken window and, attempting to draw attention to it ironically, says, "Look! That car hasn't got a broken window."
π Definition β Hyperbole: a figure of speech involving exaggeration that goes beyond literal truth (overstatement). π Definition β Irony: a figure of speech where the speaker's intended meaning contrasts with the literal meaning of the words (traditionally the opposite).
Topic β 198 I-Principle and M-Principle
In neo-Gricean pragmatics, the I-principle or Informativeness-principle is one of a small number of principles that govern communicative behaviour. The I-principle enjoins speakers to say as little as necessary (while bearing in mind the opposing Q-principle). If a speaker's utterance appears to be governed by the I-principle, then the hearer can take it that the speaker expressed herself economically. The hearer can interpret the utterance as implicating information that is more specific than what is said, along stereotypical or expected lines.
When marked expressions are used, the M-principle comes into play. In neo-Gricean pragmatics, the M-principle or Manner principle is one of a small number of heuristics governing communicative behaviour. A brief formulation is: Speaker: Do not say things in an abnormal way without reason. Addressee: What is said in an abnormal way indicates an abnormal situation.
π Definition β I-Principle: say as little as necessary; the hearer can infer more specific, stereotypical information. π Definition β M-Principle: abnormal expressions indicate abnormal situations.
Topic β 199 Q-Principle and R-Principle
In neo-Gricean pragmatics, the Q-principle or Quantity Principle is one of a small number of principles thought to govern communicative behaviour and the production of implicatures. The Q-principle is: Make your contribution sufficient; Say as much as you can (Given R). The Q-principle is intended to subsume Grice's first maxim of quantity and his first and second manner maxims. It enjoins the speaker to maximize the amount of information encoded and is described as a lower-bounding principle, responsible for implicatures.
In neo-Gricean pragmatics, the R-principle or Relation-principle is one of the small set of principles governing communicative behaviour. On one formulation: Make your contribution necessary; Say no more than you must (given the Q-principle). The R-principle enjoins the speaker to minimize the amount of linguistic material uttered, or more generally to minimize the effort involved in speech. It is described as an upper-bounding principle.
π Definition β Q-Principle: say as much as you can (sufficient information); lower-bounding principle. π Definition β R-Principle: say no more than you must (minimize effort); upper-bounding principle.
Topic β 200 Linguistic Under-Determinacy Thesis
The linguistic underdeterminacy thesis (also called semantic underdeterminacy thesis or underdeterminacy thesis) is used for several distinct but related hypotheses. One hypothesis is that no sentences, or very few, encode a unique proposition: there are no "eternal sentences," or only a small proportion of sentences are "eternal." A second version is that in all or most cases when a sentence is uttered, what is encoded by the sentence falls short of the proposition expressed by the speaker. Both claims are controversial.
There is general agreement that for a hearer to arrive at the proposition expressed, reference must be assigned to indexicals and ambiguities must be resolved, as in: "I decided to sell the bat here last week." The linguistic underdeterminacy thesis claims that even abstracting away from indexicals and ambiguity, the proposition expressed by the speaker goes beyond the linguistic meaning of the sentence. On this view, sentences uttered must be enriched by pragmatic inference to arrive at the proposition expressed. In either case, the proposition expressed cannot be read off the sentence utteredβit must be inferred partly on the basis of the sentence, background knowledge, and other clues to the speaker's intentions.
π Definition β Linguistic Underdeterminacy Thesis: the claim that what is linguistically encoded by a sentence falls short of the proposition expressed; pragmatic inference is needed to reach full speaker meaning.
Topic β 201 Manifestness and Markedness
In relevance theory, manifestness is the degree to which an assumption is accessible in a context on the basis of perception or inference. An assumption is manifest to a given individual whether or not they are capable of entertaining that assumption as true or falseβthe assumption need not actually be true; false assumptions can be entertained as true. Manifestness is a weaker notion than knowledge. It is a matter of degree: the more likely an assumption is to be entertained, the more highly manifest it is.
Mutual-manifestness refers to a shared cognitive environment in which it is manifest which people share. Mutual manifestness plays a role in relevance theory analogous to the role that some other pragmatic theorists have assigned to mutual knowledge. It explains how speaker and hearer can coordinate on an interpretation of an utterance.
Markedness is the extent to which an item in a language is out-of-the-ordinary. Unmarked items are normal, whereas marked items are relatively unusual. For example, the word "kine" is marked, while "cattle" is relatively unmarked. The idea that some linguistic items are more natural and common than others was an important feature of the linguistic theory of Roman Jakobson. In pragmatics, it has been argued that an utterance containing marked items should have a marked meaning.
π Definition β Manifestness: the degree to which an assumption is accessible in a context (weaker than knowledge). π Definition β Mutual-Manifestness: a shared cognitive environment where assumptions are manifest to all participants. π Definition β Markedness: the degree to which a linguistic item is unusual or out-of-the-ordinary.
Topic β 202 Misfire
In Austin's work, a misfire is one of the two ways in which a speech act can be unsuccessful. According to speech-act theory, there are felicity conditions on speech acts. If certain conditions are not met, then no speech act is performed. The relevant conditions are: (1) There is a conventional procedure with a conventional effect; (2) the participants and situation are appropriate according to that procedure; and (3) the procedure is carried out correctly and completely.
Consider this example: "The tailor pressed one suit in the municipal court." The reader may think suit refers to a piece of clothing, but here it refers to a legal action. Another example: "Stolen gun found by the victim." Here the reader interprets that the gun was found beside the victim (not that the victim found it, which was the intended meaning). Despite such possibilities, misfires are rare, and normally speakers can convey the meanings they intend with remarkable consistency.
π Definition β Misfire: a speech act that fails to be performed because felicity conditions are not met.
Topic β 203 Prosody and Tautology
Prosody refers to variation in the rhythm, stress, and intonation of speech at the level of utterances, rather than at the lexical level. The interaction of prosody with syntactic structure and its effect on interpretation are not well understood in general. For example, the difference in stress between "REcord" (noun) and "reCORD" (verb) is not a prosodic difference. However, the difference in stress positions in the following examples is prosodic: Alice eats GRASS. vs. Alice EATS grass.
Tautology is a statement that expresses a proposition that is necessarily true. For example: "2 + 2 = 4," "War is war," "If it rains, it rains." Since tautologies are necessarily true, it is hard to see how uttering one can be informative, relevant, or cooperative. Yet people do utter tautologies and are understood. An utterance of "War is war" might implicate that terrible things inevitably happen during wartime. However, what is communicated by a tautology can vary widely. For instance: Archie: "Can I borrow your pen?" Brenda: "Here you are. It's only a biro, though." Archie: "A pen is a pen." Here the tautology implicates that any pen, including Brenda's biro, will do for the task. The challenge is to show how such disparate implicatures can be derived.
π Definition β Tautology: a statement that expresses a necessarily true proposition. π Definition β Prosody: variations in rhythm, stress, and intonation at the utterance level.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture presents a comprehensive set of advanced pragmatic terms that every student must master for exam purposes. Key distinctions include the difference between formal pragmatics (using logic and mathematics) and experimental pragmatics (using psycholinguistic techniques), as well as the three fundamentals of cognitive pragmatics: cooperation, sharedness, and communicative intention. Students must understand the neo-Gricean principles (I, M, Q, and R principles) and how they govern implicature production. The linguistic underdeterminacy thesis is crucialβit asserts that sentences do not fully encode propositions and require pragmatic enrichment. Finally, the various figures of speech (metaphor, synecdoche, hyperbole, irony) and key notions (fragments, misfire, prosody, tautology, manifestness, and markedness) must be defined precisely with examples.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
-
What is the difference between formal pragmatics and experimental pragmatics, and what techniques does each use?
-
Define the I-principle and M-principle in neo-Gricean pragmatics. How do they interact in communication?
-
What does the linguistic underdeterminacy thesis claim, and why is it important for understanding speaker meaning?
-
Explain the difference between manifestness and mutual-manifestness in relevance theory.
-
What is a misfire in speech act theory? Provide the conditions that must be met for a speech act to be successful.