π Lecture 28 β Speech Acts Theory
π Overview: This lecture introduces Speech Act Theory, which examines how people perform actions through languageβsuch as making requests, promises, or apologiesβrather than simply describing states of affairs. It explores the foundational contributions of Austin and Searle, the conditions required for speech acts to be successful, and the distinction between direct and indirect speech acts, which is crucial for understanding everyday communication and politeness strategies.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers an introduction to speech acts, including explicit and implicit performatives and constatives; Austin's Speech Act Theory with its three facets of locutionary, illocutionary, and perlocutionary acts; Searle's five-part classification of speech acts (representatives, directives, commissives, expressives, and declarations); felicity conditions that govern the success of speech acts like promises and warnings; and finally, direct versus indirect speech acts based on the relationship between sentence structure and communicative function.
π Lecture Summary
Topic β 139 Introduction to Speech Acts
Speech act theory treats utterances as actions similar to physical acts. People perform acts using languageβto give orders, make requests, give warnings, or give advice. The theory answers the question: "What do we do when using language?" Speech acts are acts of communication such as an apology, complaint, or compliment. For example, 'It's hot here' may function as a request rather than mere information about weather. Every time a speaker utters a sentence, they attempt to accomplish something with words, intending to have an effect on the listener and wanting the listener to recognize this intention. The context, called speech events, helps determine the interpretation of an utterance as performing a particular speech act.
π Definition β Explicit performatives: performative utterances that contain a performative verb that makes explicit what kind of act is being performed, and they tend to begin with a first person singular 'I' (e.g., "I promise to come").
π Definition β Implicit performatives: performative utterances in which there is no such performative verb (e.g., "I'll be there" as a promise).
π Definition β Constatives: statements that attempt to describe reality and can be judged true or false.
π‘ Why this matters: This distinction shows that language does not merely describe the world but can also change itβa key insight in pragmatics.
Topic β 140 Austin's Speech Act Theory
The work of J. L. Austin in How to Do Things with Words led philosophers to pay more attention to non-declarative uses of language. Austin introduced the notions of "locutionary act", "illocutionary act", and "perlocutionary act", which became central to the study of speech acts. For instance:
- (1) I bet you six pence it will rain tomorrow.
- (2) I apologize.
- (3) I sentence you to ten years of hard labor.
- (4) I give my word.
These sentences are not used to describe states of affairs but to perform actions: to bet, to apologize, to pass sentence, and to promise, respectively. The two key facets of a speech act are Locutionary Act and Perlocutionary Act.
π Definition β Locutionary act: the act of producing a meaningful linguistic expression (the literal meaning of the utterance).
π Definition β Illocutionary act: the intended social action performed by the utterance (e.g., promising, ordering, apologizing).
π Definition β Perlocutionary act: the actual effect the utterance has on the listener (e.g., convincing, frightening, persuading).
π Example: Saying "I apologize" β the locutionary act is uttering those words; the illocutionary act is performing an apology; the perlocutionary act is the hearer feeling appeased.
Topic β 141 Searle's Speech Act Theory
Searle (1976) proposed that all speech acts fall into five main types:
-
Representatives: commit the speaker to the truth of the expressed propositionβthey state what the speaker believes to be the case or not. Examples: asserting, concluding, statements of fact. E.g., 'The earth is flat' (statement of fact).
-
Directives: attempts by the speaker to get the addressee to do somethingβthey express what the speaker wants. Examples: requesting, questioning.
-
Commissives: commit the speaker to some future course of actionβthey express what the speaker intends. Examples: promising, threatening, offering, refusing.
-
Expressives: express a psychological state or what a speaker feels. Examples: thanking, apologizing, welcoming, congratulating.
-
Declarations: effect immediate changes in the institutional state of affairs and tend to rely on elaborate extra-linguistic institutions. Examples: marrying, declaring war, firing from employment. These speech acts change the world via their utterance.
π‘ Why this matters: Searle's classification helps analyze the different intentions and effects behind utterances, showing that language serves multiple distinct social functions.
Topic β 142 Felicity Conditions
In everyday contexts, there are general conditions on the participantsβfor example, that they can understand the language being used and are not being nonsensical. Then there are content conditions: for both a promise and a warning, the content of the utterance must be about a future event.
For a promise, the preparatory conditions are:
- First, the event will not happen by itself.
- Second, the event will have a beneficial effect.
For a warning, the preparatory conditions are:
- It is not clear that the hearer knows the event will occur.
- The speaker does think the event will occur.
- The event will not have a beneficial effect.
π Definition β Felicity conditions: the conditions that must be satisfied for a speech act to be performed successfully and appropriately.
π‘ Why this matters: These conditions explain why some utterances "work" while others failβe.g., you cannot successfully promise something that will happen anyway or that is harmful.
Topic β 143 Direct and Indirect Speech Acts
In everyday situations, speakers often do not directly express what they intend but instead formulate utterances in ways that appear more polite to hearers. Utterances can be direct speech acts or indirect speech acts.
Examples:
- Direct: Pass me the salt! (imperative used as a command)
- Indirect: Can you pass me the salt? (interrogative used as a polite request)
The distinction is based on structure vs. function:
- Whenever there is a direct relationship between a structure and a function, we have a direct speech act.
- Whenever there is an indirect relationship between a structure and a function, we have an indirect speech act.
For example:
- A declarative used to make a statement is a direct speech act, but a declarative used to make a request is an indirect speech act.
- One of the most common types of indirect speech acts in English has the form of an interrogative.
π Examples of Direct Speech Act (when a specific sentence structure performs its direct function):
- 'Did you eat the pizza?' β Interrogative β Question
- 'Eat the pizza (please)!' β Imperative β Command (Request)
- 'You ate the pizza.' β Declarative β Statement
β Key Takeaways
The most critical points from this lecture are that speech acts turn utterances into actions, with Austin's three-part distinction (locutionary, illocutionary, perlocutionary) providing the foundational framework. Searle's five categories (representatives, directives, commissives, expressives, declarations) offer a systematic way to classify speech acts based on speaker intention and effect. Felicity conditionsβincluding preparatory conditionsβdetermine whether a speech act is successfully performed; for instance, a promise requires that the event be beneficial and not happen by itself. Direct speech acts have a straightforward match between sentence structure and function, while indirect speech acts (like using a question to make a request) are a common politeness strategy. For exams, students must be able to identify and analyze examples of each type of speech act and explain why certain utterances succeed or fail under felicity conditions.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three facets of a speech act according to Austin, and how does each differ?
- Name and define the five types of speech acts proposed by Searle, giving one example of each.
- What are the preparatory conditions for a promise versus a warning, and why do they differ?
- How does a direct speech act differ from an indirect speech act? Provide an original example of each.
- What is the difference between an explicit performative and an implicit performative? Give an example of each.
π Lecture 29 β Speech Acts and Society
π Overview: This lecture explores the social and cultural dimensions of speech acts, examining how indirectness relates to politeness and how speech act realizations vary across cultures. It also discusses the limitations of speech act theory, introduces macro-functions of language (transactional vs. interactional), and provides a practical example of analyzing speech acts in text.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers social dimensions of indirect speech acts and politeness, cultural variations in speech act realizations with cross-cultural examples, limitations of speech act theory including overlap and incomplete utterances, Brown and Yule's transactional and interactional macro-functions of language, and a practical text analysis activity exploring direct/indirect speech acts and illocutionary/perlocutionary acts.
π Lecture Summary
Topic β 144 Social Dimensions
Indirect speech acts constitute one of many forms of politeness. Indirectness is so associated with politeness that directives are more often expressed as interrogatives than imperatives, especially with people one is not familiar with. For example, in many British restaurants, book shops, and petrol stations, a sign says "thank you for not smoking" β the expressive thanking speech act is used because it sounds more polite and friendly to strangers than the impersonal directive prohibiting "No smoking."
π‘ Why this matters: The choice between direct and indirect speech acts is not arbitrary but reflects social relationships and politeness strategies.
The factors that can make a speaker use indirect directives include lack of familiarity, the reasonableness of the task, the formality of the context, and social distance (difference of status, roles, age, gender, education, class, occupation, and ethnicity). Social distances can give speakers power and authority, and it is generally those of the less dominant role who tend to use indirectness.
Topic β 145 Cultural Dimensions
Speech acts and their linguistic realizations are culturally bound. The ways of expressing speech acts vary from country to country and from culture to culture. In India, for example, the expressive speech act of praising and congratulating a person on their appearance can be realized by the words: "How fat you are!" because weight is an indicator of personality and health in a country where there is malnutrition. In Britain, these words express 'deploring' or 'criticizing', since fashion, diet foods industries, and health education have conditioned many into thinking that "slim is beautiful."
π Definition β Cultural Dimensions of Speech Acts: Speech acts and their linguistic realizations vary across cultures; the same utterance can perform different speech acts in different cultural contexts.
Differences in speech acts can cause difficulties cross-culturally.
Topic β 146 Limitations of Speech Act Theory
When we try to categorize utterances in terms of speech acts, we often find that there is 'overlap' β one utterance can fall into more than one macro-class. Utterances such as 'so there you go' and 'you know' amount to filters that say very little; this lack of semantic content makes it difficult to classify them as either expressive or representative speech acts.
Another similar example is "Backchannel" and "feedback" β responses that show the hearer is listening and encouraging a speaker to continue talking, such as 'was it?' and 'oh really' β these do not fit neatly into the speech act model either.
Similarly, incomplete sentences such as 'But she didn't do the β er β no' do not fit neatly into any category. A lot of what we say in everyday speech is left unfinished either because we have no need to complete the sentence or because we are interrupted.
Topic β 147 Macro-Functions
Brown and Yule (1983) describe the 'transactional' functions and the 'interactional' function of language.
π Definition β Transactional Function: The function which language serves in the expression of content and the transmission of factual information.
π Definition β Interactional Function: The function involved in expressing social relations and personal attitudes, showing solidarity and maintaining social cohesion.
At the extreme end of the interactional is 'phatic communion' β language with no information content used purely to keep channels of communication open.
Brown and Yule pointed out that much of everyday human interaction is characterized by the primarily interpersonal rather than the primarily transactional use of language.
Topic β 148 Exploring Speech Acts
This section presents an activity: analyzing text using concepts of direct and indirect speech acts, and facets/types of speech acts (Austin and Searle). The text is from Fox Hunting Under Cover, an excerpt from a BBC thriller series:
Boss: Under cover? This isn't your private army. Is she OK? Dalziel: She is good (0.5) in fact she spent half her childhood on a horse. Boss: How do you're lying to me, Andy? Dalziel: Look, we've even given her a full story; set up a liaison point. Visitors often go on a ride with another hunt. They come for a few days, stay a local club, borrow a horse. And since hunting is about drinking as it is riding, it shouldn't be long before someone becomes indiscreet. (0.5) Boss: All right. But don't upset the locals.
Picking out examples of illocutionary and perlocutionary speech acts, direct and indirect speech acts, declaratives, representatives, etc., and inexplicit or vague language used by the author can help students in the exploration of the text.
β Key Takeaways
Students must remember that indirect speech acts are closely tied to politeness and are influenced by social distance, formality, and power dynamics. Speech acts are culturally bound β the same linguistic expression (e.g., "How fat you are!") can serve completely different speech acts (praising vs. criticizing) across cultures. Speech act theory has limitations: many utterances overlap categories, lack semantic content (filters like "you know"), are backchannel responses, or are incomplete, making classification difficult. Brown and Yule's distinction between transactional (information-focused) and interactional (social relationship-focused) functions is crucial, with phatic communion at the extreme interactional end. Most everyday interaction is primarily interpersonal rather than transactional.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Why is "thank you for not smoking" considered more polite than "No smoking" in terms of speech act theory?
- How does the cultural example of praising someone's weight in India versus Britain demonstrate that speech acts are culturally bound?
- What are the four factors, besides lack of familiarity, that can make a speaker use indirect directives?
- Why do backchannel responses like "oh really" and incomplete sentences pose a problem for speech act theory?
- What is the difference between the transactional function and the interactional function of language as described by Brown and Yule?
π Lecture 30 β POLITENESS THEORY
π Overview: This lecture introduces Politeness Theory in pragmatics, explaining how speakers manage social relationships through language. It covers the foundational concept of 'face', face-threatening and face-saving acts, positive and negative face, and the various politeness strategies speakers use to maintain social harmony. Understanding these concepts is crucial for analyzing real-world interactions and the subtle social meanings encoded in linguistic choices.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining politeness theory and the concept of 'face' as public self-image. It then explains face wants, differentiating between face-threatening acts (FTAs) and face-saving acts. Next, it details the two types of face: positive face (desire for approval) and negative face (desire for freedom). The lecture then explores different levels of directness ('off record' vs. 'bald on record') and the corresponding politeness strategies (positive and negative politeness). Finally, it concludes with specific strategies like solidarity, deference, and pre-sequences.
π Lecture Summary
Topic β 149 What is Politeness Theory?
Politeness in everyday terms refers to being tactful, modest, and nice. In pragmatics, it is defined as showing awareness and consideration of another person's face. According to Yule (2010), politeness can be seen as a fixed concept like etiquette, but within interaction, it relies on the concept of Faceβthe public self-image, the emotional and social sense of self that everyone expects others to recognize. For example, saying "I'm sorry to bother you but..." is a polite way to avoid imposition. Politeness is not just about words but also about how they are said.
π‘ Why this matters: Politeness theory provides a framework for understanding why we don't always say exactly what we mean. It explains the social function of indirectness and careful phrasing in everyday conversation.
π Definition β Face: The public self-image of a person; the emotional and social sense of self that one expects everyone else to recognize.
Topic β 150 Face Wants
People generally behave in everyday interactions as if their face wants (expectations about their public self-image) will be respected. A Face-threatening Act (FTA) is something said that represents a threat to another person's self-image, e.g., "Give me that paper." A Face-saving Act is an utterance that lessens a possible threat to another's face, e.g., "Could you pass me that paper?" The politeness strategy used when an FTA could arise depends largely on the speaker-listener relationship.
FTAs can be positive or negative and can damage either the speaker or the hearer. Positive face-threatening acts (e.g., threats, insults) directly challenge the listener's self-image by showing indifference to it. Negative face-threatening acts impinge on the listener's negative face by requiring a verbal response or action.
π Definition β Face-threatening Act (FTA): An utterance that represents a threat to another person's self-image.
π Definition β Face-saving Act: An utterance that lessens a possible threat to another person's face.
Topic β 151 Negative and Positive Face
Under politeness theory, there are two types of face. Positive face reflects the desire to have one's self-image approved of by othersβthe need to be connected, belong, and be a member of the group. Negative face (where 'negative' simply means the opposite of 'positive,' not 'bad') is the need to be independent and free from imposition. Independence refers to a person's right not to be dominated and to act with autonomy (e.g., by giving options). Involvement refers to the need to be involved with others (e.g., by agreeing). Politeness strategies differ depending on whether a speaker is dealing with another's positive or negative face. Face and politeness also vary across cultures.
π Definition β Positive Face: The desire to have one's self-image approved of by others; the need to be connected and belong.
π Definition β Negative Face: The need to be independent and free from imposition.
π Example: Independence (negative face) is shown by saying "You don't have to come if you're busy." Involvement (positive face) is shown by saying "We'd love to have you join us."
Topic β 152 Say Something: Off and On Record
When deciding to say something, a speaker can choose between two levels of directness. Off record refers to indirect statements (or 'hints') that are not directly addressed to the other person, e.g., "Uh, I forgot my pen." The listener can act as if they haven't heard. This places the burden on the speaker. Bald on-record is the most direct approach, using imperative forms, e.g., "Give me a pen." Speakers using this form assume they have power over the other person (e.g., in military contexts). Expressions like 'please' can be added as mitigating devices to soften the demand.
π Definition β Off Record: An indirect statement where the speaker's intent is not directly expressed, allowing the listener to ignore it.
π Definition β Bald On-Record: A direct statement, often an imperative, where the speaker's intent is clearly and unambiguously expressed.
π Example: Off Record: "Hmm, I wonder where I put my pen." Bald On-Record: "Lend me your pen."
Topic β 153 Positive and Negative Politeness
These are two specific strategies for performing face-threatening acts. A positive politeness strategy appeals to a common goal or friendship, e.g., "Hey, buddy, I'd appreciate it if you'd let me use your pen." It may be preceded by 'getting to know you' talk to establish common ground. This strategy is used when the speaker is at least familiar with the listener. A negative politeness strategy is used when speakers know they are impinging on a person's time and want to show respect, e.g., stopping a person on the street to ask for directions.
π Definition β Positive Politeness Strategy: A strategy that appeals to a common goal or friendship to minimize a face threat.
π Definition β Negative Politeness Strategy: A strategy used to show respect and acknowledge that one is imposing on another's time or freedom.
π Example: Positive Politeness: "We're all going to the movies. Want to come with us?" Negative Politeness: "I'm sorry to bother you, but could you please tell me the time?"
Topic β 154 Politeness Strategies
This topic outlines three broader strategies. A Solidarity strategy tends to use positive politeness, emphasizing closeness between speaker and hearer. It includes personal information, nicknames, and inclusive terms like 'we', e.g., "Come on, let's go to the party. We'll have fun." A Deference strategy tends to use negative politeness, emphasizing the hearer's right to freedom and formal politeness. It is impersonal and marked by an absence of personal claims, e.g., "There's going to be a party if you can make it." Finally, Pre-sequences are a way to avoid the risk inherent in a face-threatening act. A pre-request can test the waters to see if a request is possible, eliciting either a 'go-ahead' or a 'stop' response, e.g., "Are you busy?" (pre-request) β "Oh, sorry." (stop).
π Definition β Solidarity Strategy: A politeness strategy emphasizing closeness and shared identity, often using positive politeness.
π Definition β Deference Strategy: A politeness strategy emphasizing the hearer's independence and right to freedom, often using negative politeness.
π Definition β Pre-sequence: An utterance that precedes a face-threatening act (like a request or announcement) to check if it can be made without risk.
π Example: A Pre-request β Child: "Mom, guess what?" (pre-announcement) Parent: "Not now, I'm busy." (stop)
β Key Takeaways
Politeness in pragmatics is fundamentally about managing 'face', which is a person's public self-image comprising a positive face (desire for approval and connection) and a negative face (desire for freedom and independence). Any utterance that threatens these face wants is a face-threatening act (FTA), and speakers use various strategies to mitigate this threat. These strategies exist on a spectrum from direct (bald on-record) to indirect (off record), and from emphasizing closeness (positive politeness/solidarity) to emphasizing freedom (negative politeness/deference). The choice of strategy depends on social distance, power relations, and the degree of imposition involved in the interaction.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the key difference between 'positive face' and 'negative face'?
- Explain the difference between a 'face-threatening act' and a 'face-saving act'.
- What is the main strategic difference between using an 'off record' utterance and a 'bald on-record' utterance when making a request?
- Give one example of a 'positive politeness strategy' and one example of a 'negative politeness strategy'.
- What is the function of a 'pre-sequence' (e.g., a pre-request) in conversation?