📘 Lecture 13 — KRASHEN’S INPUT HYPOTHESIS (MONITOR MODEL)-I
📖 Overview: This lecture introduces Stephen Krashen’s influential theory of second language acquisition, focusing on the concept of comprehensible input. It explains the internal and external factors affecting language acquisition and introduces the Natural Approach developed with Tracy Terrell, emphasizing meaningful interaction over conscious grammar learning.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers Krashen’s general theory including five hypotheses and factors, explaining the distinction between acquisition and learning. It then introduces comprehensible input as the crucial ingredient for language acquisition, outlines internal factors (age, personality, motivation, experience, cognition, native language) and external factors (culture, status, motivation, access to native speakers, curriculum). The second topic presents the Natural Approach and its implications for second language acquisition, contrasting natural methods with unnatural grammar and audio-lingual methods.
📝 Lecture Summary
Topic-051: General Theory – Five Hypotheses and Factors
Stephen Krashen, a linguist and professor emeritus at University of Southern California, is known for his theories of language acquisition and development. He introduced his famous second language acquisition theory which has been considered one of the most influential theories in second language research and teaching since the 1980s. Krashen explained that acquisition requires meaningful interaction in the target language through natural communication, where speakers focus on messages rather than form.
Krashen emphasized that language acquisition does not require extensive use of conscious grammatical rules and does not require tedious drill. The crucial and necessary ingredient is comprehensible input — input that is easy to comprehend and slightly advanced than the existing level of understanding. The best methods supply comprehensible input in low anxiety situations, containing messages students really want to hear. These methods do not force early production in the second language but allow students to produce when they are ready, recognizing that improvement comes from supplying communicative and comprehensible input, not from forcing and correcting production.
🔑 Definition — Comprehensible Input: Input that is easy to comprehend and slightly advanced than the existing level of understanding of the learner.
🔑 Definition — Acquisition (vs. Learning): Acquisition occurs through meaningful interaction and natural communication, not through conscious grammatical rules or tedious drill.
The internal factors of the hypothesis are: Age, Personality, Motivation (intrinsic), Experience, Cognition, and Native Language. The external factors include: Culture and status, Motivation (extrinsic), Access to native Speaker, Curriculum and Instructions.
💡 Why this matters: Krashen’s theory shifted focus from conscious grammar instruction to providing meaningful, comprehensible input in low-anxiety environments, fundamentally changing second language teaching approaches.
Topic-052: The Natural Approach and SLA
The concept of Natural Approach was developed by one of Krashen’s associates, Tracy Terrell (Krashen & Terrell, 1983). Ironically, the term ‘natural’ here implies that there can be unnatural methods of learning a language which according to Krashen and Terrell are grammar and audio-lingual (listen-and-drill activities in classroom) methods. Since it is a natural process, it is considered to be effortless where learning takes place with ease.
The teachers are expected to provide learners with comprehensible input and stimulating activities for meaningful learning. The environment should also be facilitating by not forcing a learner to act during the silent period.
🔑 Definition — Natural Approach: A language teaching approach developed by Krashen and Terrell that emphasizes natural communication, comprehensible input, and a low-anxiety environment, contrasting with grammar and audio-lingual methods.
🔑 Definition — Silent Period: A period in language acquisition where learners are not forced to produce language but are allowed to listen and absorb input until they are ready to speak.
💡 Why this matters: The Natural Approach rejects traditional drill-based methods, advocating for a classroom environment that mirrors natural first language acquisition processes, allowing learners to progress at their own pace without pressure.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Krashen’s Input Hypothesis emphasizes that language acquisition requires comprehensible input — language that is slightly beyond the learner’s current level but still understandable. The focus must be on acquisition (natural, communicative) rather than learning (conscious rules). The Natural Approach, developed with Tracy Terrell, rejects grammar and audio-lingual methods as unnatural and advocates for a low-anxiety environment where learners are not forced to produce language during the silent period. Internal factors (age, personality, motivation, experience, cognition, native language) and external factors (culture, status, motivation, access to native speakers, curriculum) both influence language acquisition. For exams, remember that comprehensible input in meaningful, low-anxiety contexts is the key to acquisition, not drill or grammar instruction.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What is comprehensible input according to Krashen, and why is it considered the crucial ingredient for language acquisition?
- What is the difference between acquisition and learning in Krashen’s theory?
- List the internal factors and external factors that affect second language acquisition.
- What are the unnatural methods that the Natural Approach rejects, and why?
- What is the silent period, and how should teachers respond to learners during this phase?
Here is the summary of Lecture 14, formatted exactly as requested.
📘 Lecture 14 — KRASHEN’S INPUT HYPOTHESIS (MONITOR MODEL)-II
📖 Overview: This lecture continues the exploration of Krashen’s Monitor Model, focusing on two of its central hypotheses. It first clarifies the critical distinction between language acquisition and learning, then outlines the Natural Order Hypothesis and the core mechanisms of the Input Hypothesis. Understanding these concepts is vital for grasping how second language learners internalize a new language.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture examines the Acquisition vs. Learning Hypothesis, detailing the subconscious nature of acquisition versus the formal instruction of learning, and the criticisms this distinction has faced. It then moves to the Natural Order Hypothesis, which posits a predictable sequence for grammatical structure acquisition, and concludes with the Input Hypothesis, which emphasizes the necessity of comprehensible input and provides practical techniques for teachers to make input understandable for learners.
📝 Lecture Summary
Topic-053: Acquisition vs. Learning Hypothesis
Krashen was the first to formally establish the distinction between acquisition and learning. According to this distinction, the ‘acquired system’ is the product of a subconscious process, while the ‘learned system’ results from formal instruction. Language acquisition refers to subconscious learning and involves intuition, whereas language learning focuses on the written form of language to understand its structure and rules, where form is considered more important than communication.
This distinction attracted criticism from various researchers. McLaughlin (1987) argued that Krashen’s terms were imprecise and not clear. However, Gregg (1984) countered this by suggesting that some rules can indeed be acquired through the process of learning.
🔑 Definition — Acquisition: A subconscious process of internalizing a language, similar to how a child learns their first language, focusing on meaning and communication. 🔑 Definition — Learning: A conscious process of gaining knowledge about a language's rules and structure, typically through formal instruction. 📌 Example: A child naturally picking up their mother tongue by interacting with family is an example of acquisition. A student studying grammar rules from a textbook to pass a test is an example of learning.
Topic-054: The Natural Order Hypothesis and the Input Hypothesis
The Natural Order Hypothesis refers to the idea that there is a predictable and set sequence for the acquisition of grammatical structures. This natural order of acquisition in a first language is often different from that in a second language. The hypothesis argues that explicit instructions for learning cannot change this natural order.
Krashen’s Input Hypothesis advocates that second language acquisition is highly dependent on the learner’s comprehension of the input. He suggested several techniques to make language input comprehensible for learners.
🔑 Definition — Natural Order Hypothesis: The theory that grammatical structures are acquired in a predictable sequence that cannot be altered by formal instruction. 🔑 Definition — Input Hypothesis: The theory that language acquisition occurs when learners understand language that contains structures a little beyond their current level of competence (i.e., "i+1"). 📐 Formula: Comprehensible Input = Language structures slightly above the learner's current level (i+1) → understanding this leads to acquisition. 💡 Why this matters: The Input Hypothesis shifts the focus from forcing production (speaking/writing) to ensuring learners first receive and understand meaningful language.
Techniques for Providing Comprehensible Input:
- Use expression and body language
- Provide thinking time
- Pauses between phrases
- Shorter sentences
- Stress high frequency words
- Repeat/review vocabulary
- Repeat/restate for understanding
- Be supportive
⭐ Key Takeaways
A student must remember that Krashen’s Monitor Model sharply distinguishes between subconscious acquisition and conscious learning, a distinction that has been criticized for its lack of precision. The Natural Order Hypothesis asserts that grammatical structures are learned in a fixed, unchangeable sequence. The most critical concept for exam success is the Input Hypothesis, which claims that acquisition happens only when learners receive comprehensible input—language slightly above their current level. Finally, the specific teaching techniques listed (like using body language, shorter sentences, and repetition) are the practical application of making this input understandable.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- According to Krashen, what is the fundamental difference between the "acquired system" and the "learned system"?
- Which researchers criticized the Acquisition vs. Learning distinction, and what was their specific argument?
- What does the Natural Order Hypothesis claim about the effect of explicit instruction on the order of grammar acquisition?
- What is the central premise of the "Input Hypothesis," and what is the meaning of "i+1"?
- List at least four specific techniques a teacher can use to make language input comprehensible for learners.
📘 Lecture 15 — Krashen’s Input Hypothesis (Monitor Model)-III
📖 Overview: This lecture completes the discussion of Krashen's Monitor Model by examining the Monitor Hypothesis and the Affective Filter Hypothesis. It then transitions to Communicative Language Teaching (CLT), showing how Krashen's ideas influenced this major approach, and presents key criticisms of CLT.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the Monitor Hypothesis and its three usage types (over-users, under-users, optimal users) along with conditions for applying the monitor. It then explains the Affective Filter Hypothesis and the role of motivation, attitude, self-confidence, and anxiety. The lecture concludes with an introduction to Communicative Language Teaching (CLT) based on the Input Hypothesis and communicative competence, followed by criticism regarding its success in ESL vs. EFL contexts, its neglect of accuracy, and the burden it places on teachers.
📝 Lecture Summary
Topic-055: The Monitor Hypothesis and the Affective Filter Hypothesis
Krashen's Monitor Hypothesis claims that conscious language-learning monitors the output. According to the hypothesis, learning acts as an editor or monitor in the process of language production by applying the rules consciously and minimizing errors.
The monitor hypothesis is divided into three types of users:
- Monitor over-users — individuals who constantly check their output, often leading to hesitant, non-fluent speech.
- Monitor under-users — individuals who rely primarily on acquired knowledge and rarely use the monitor, producing fluent but possibly error-filled speech.
- The optimal monitor users — individuals who use the monitor appropriately when it does not interfere with communication, balancing fluency and accuracy.
Three conditions are necessary to apply the monitor hypothesis:
- Time — learners must have sufficient time to think about and apply rules.
- Focus on form — learners must be focused on the grammatical structure of their output.
- Knowledge of rule — learners must know the rule they are applying.
🔑 Definition — Monitor Hypothesis: The hypothesis that conscious learning monitors language production by applying rules to minimize errors.
According to the Affective Filter Hypothesis, a 'filter' can affect how well we acquire comprehensible input. The 'filter' can include:
- Motivation — higher motivation lowers the filter.
- Attitude — positive attitudes lower the filter.
- Self-confidence — greater self-confidence lowers the filter.
- Anxiety — high anxiety raises the filter, blocking acquisition.
🔑 Definition — Affective Filter Hypothesis: The hypothesis that emotional variables (motivation, attitude, self-confidence, anxiety) can block or facilitate the acquisition of comprehensible input.
💡 Why this matters: Together, the Monitor Hypothesis and Affective Filter Hypothesis explain why some learners can understand input but fail to acquire language — their affective filter blocks intake — and why some learners produce accurate yet halting speech (over-users) while others produce fluent but error-filled speech (under-users).
Topic-056: Communicative Language Teaching (CLT) and Criticism
Krashen and Terrell's Natural Approach paved the way for the emergence of Communicative Language Teaching (CLT) approach. CLT was formed on the basis of the Input Hypothesis and the communicative competence; and has been widely used in language classrooms since the 1980s. It focuses on the functional aspect of language, which is communication. Dell Hymes supported CLT by proposing that for effective development of communicative competence, learners should be exposed to real-life situations.
Communicative Competence is defined as the ability to interpret and enact appropriate social behaviors, and it requires the active involvement of the learner in the production of the target language (Canale and Swain 1980; Celce-Murcia et al. 1995; Hymes 1972).
🔑 Definition — Communicative Language Teaching (CLT): An approach to language teaching that focuses on developing learners' ability to communicate meaningfully in real-life situations, based on the Input Hypothesis and communicative competence.
📌 Example: In a CLT classroom, instead of drilling grammar rules, students might role-play ordering food in a restaurant. The teacher provides comprehensible input through natural conversation and realia (menus), and students must negotiate meaning to successfully complete the transaction. Fluency and communicative success are prioritized over grammatical accuracy.
Criticism
According to Stern (1992), CLT has become more successful in ESL (English as a second language) settings, but failed to show successful results in EFL (English as a foreign language) contexts. Some CLT proponents, e.g. Littlewood, even proposed to treat it as an umbrella term, which the opponents of CLT considered the renaming of existing old approaches and nothing new or revolutionary. CLT focuses more on developing fluency while accuracy is neglected. It does overburden teachers as it demands developing a functional syllabus for effective classroom activities.
🔑 Definition — ESL vs. EFL: ESL (English as a Second Language) refers to learning English in an environment where English is the dominant language; EFL (English as a Foreign Language) refers to learning English in a non-English-speaking environment where exposure is limited.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The Monitor Hypothesis distinguishes three types of users (over-users, under-users, and optimal users) and requires three conditions (time, focus on form, knowledge of rule) for effective monitoring. The Affective Filter Hypothesis explains how motivation, attitude, self-confidence, and anxiety can either facilitate or block language acquisition. CLT emerged from Krashen's Natural Approach and emphasizes communicative competence and real-life language use. However, CLT has been criticized for being more effective in ESL than EFL contexts, for focusing too much on fluency at the expense of accuracy, and for placing excessive demands on teachers to create functional syllabi.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three types of monitor users according to Krashen's Monitor Hypothesis, and how do they differ in their use of conscious learning?
- What three conditions must be present for a learner to successfully apply the monitor to their output?
- Name the four affective variables in the Affective Filter Hypothesis and explain how each can either raise or lower the filter.
- How did Dell Hymes' concept of communicative competence support the development of Communicative Language Teaching?
- List at least two major criticisms of CLT according to Stern (1992) and other opponents.
📘 Lecture 16 — SOCIO-CULTURAL THEORY
📖 Overview: This lecture explores Socio-cultural Theory, which posits that society and culture are fundamental to cognitive development and language learning. It covers Vygotsky's ZPD, Halliday's Systemic Functional Linguistics, Schumann's Acculturation Model, and Lave & Wenger's Situated Learning, demonstrating how social interaction and cultural context shape second language acquisition.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with Vygotsky's Socio-cultural Theory and Halliday's Systemic Functional Linguistics, detailing their core concepts and characteristics. It then examines Schumann's Acculturation Model, including its stages and factors, along with criticisms. Finally, it covers Situated Learning by Lave and Wenger and Language Socialization by Ochs and Schieffelin, emphasizing learning as a social and cultural process.
📝 Lecture Summary
Topic-057: Vygotsky and M.A.K. Halliday
The Socio-cultural theory is a psychological and sociological theory developed by Lev Vygotsky, a Russian psychologist, in 1934. The theory claims that society and culture play an important role in developing one’s personality. It asserts that society supports and acts as a device for intellectual adaptation of innateness, a child is born with.
Vygotsky believed that learning takes place at two levels: through interaction with others, and integrated into the individual’s mental structure. The famous concept of Zone of Proximal Development (ZPD) introduced by Vygotsky forms the basis of socio-cultural theory, according to which a learner is provided with the social interaction as assistance in the zone to support learning.
M.A.K. Halliday, a British linguist, developed the concept of Systemic Functional Linguistics in 1960. It claims that language is a resource for making meaning. The systemic functional linguistics is based on three levels; namely, meaning (semantics), sound (phonology), and wording or lexico-grammar (syntax, morphology, and lexis). Halliday (1978) also introduced the ideational, interpersonal, and textual as basis for language metafunctions.
Characteristics of Systemic Functional Linguistics:
- Language use is functional.
- Its function is to make meanings.
- These meanings are influenced by the social and cultural context in which they are exchanged.
- The process of using language is a semiotic in nature, i.e., a process of making meaning by choosing.
🔑 Definition — Zone of Proximal Development (ZPD): The gap between what a learner can do independently and what they can achieve with guidance and social interaction.
🔑 Definition — Systemic Functional Linguistics: A theory of language that views language as a resource for making meaning, organized by three levels (semantics, phonology, lexico-grammar) and three metafunctions (ideational, interpersonal, textual).
Topic-058: Acculturation Model and Steps in Acculturation
The Acculturation Model was introduced by John Schumann, an American linguist (1986), who claimed that the extent of contact between L2 and L2 speaker affects the success of SLA. Social and psychological factors are key components of acculturation process. According to Brown (1980), the stages of acculturation in the target language are Euphoria, Culture-shock, Cultural stress, Gradual recovery, and Full-recovery.
Language shock, culture shock, culture stress, motivation, and ego permeability are the factors that are responsible for creating psychological distance as claimed by Ushioda (1993).
Domination of high culture causing low self-esteem among L2 learners and lack of explanation about the internal processes of SLA are the major points of the criticism of Acculturation Model.
🔑 Definition — Acculturation Model: A theory of SLA by John Schumann which claims that social and psychological factors, and the extent of contact between L2 learners and L2 speakers, determine success in second language acquisition.
🔑 Definitions — Stages of Acculturation (Brown, 1980):
- Euphoria: Initial excitement about the new culture.
- Culture-shock: Anxiety and disorientation from cultural differences.
- Cultural stress: Continued stress as the learner struggles to adapt.
- Gradual recovery: Increasing comfort and adaptation.
- Full-recovery: Successful integration and competence in the target culture.
📌 Example: An international student studying English in the U.S. might first feel euphoria about the new environment, then experience culture-shock from different communication norms, face cultural stress during academic demands, gradually recover by making local friends, and ultimately achieve full-recovery with fluent English and cultural competence.
Topic-059: Situated Learning and Language Socialization
Inspired by the works of Vygotsky and Dewey, Jean Lave and Etienne Wenger introduced the theory of Situated Learning as an instructional approach in the early 1990s. The theory laid down great emphasis on learning as a social process and encouraged to maximize social interaction for the purpose of meaningful learning. They proposed Legitimate Peripheral Participation, Peripherality, Full Participation, and Community of Practice as key factors of Situated Learning theory.
Elinor Ochs and Bambi Schieffelin proposed that language acquisition and culture acquisition were interdependent and that the interaction of the two processes needed to be studied toward the better understanding of both. This makes socialization a process ‘into and through’ language and discourse. Practices and communicative competence in addition to face-to-face and cultural historical approach are considered the theoretical foundations of language socialization.
🔑 Definition — Situated Learning: A theory by Lave and Wenger that emphasizes learning as a social process occurring through participation in a community of practice, moving from peripheral to full participation.
🔑 Definition — Language Socialization: A theory by Ochs and Schieffelin that posits language acquisition and culture acquisition are interdependent, making socialization a process ‘into and through’ language and discourse.
📌 Example: A medical student learning to be a doctor begins with legitimate peripheral participation (observing senior doctors), then progresses to full participation (performing procedures under supervision) within the community of practice (the hospital team), illustrating Situated Learning.
💡 Why this matters: Situated Learning and Language Socialization highlight that language is not learned in isolation but through authentic, socially embedded activities, which has major implications for classroom design and immersion programs.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The core of this lecture is that language learning is fundamentally a social and cultural process, not merely a cognitive one. Vygotsky's ZPD and Halliday's Systemic Functional Linguistics provide theoretical frameworks for how interaction and meaning-making drive learning. Schumann's Acculturation Model explicitly links SLA success to social and psychological integration into the target culture, with stages from euphoria to full recovery. Lave and Wenger's Situated Learning and Ochs & Schieffelin's Language Socialization further emphasize that learning happens through participation in authentic communities of practice. For the exam, remember the key theorists (Vygotsky, Halliday, Schumann, Lave & Wenger, Ochs & Schieffelin), core concepts (ZPD, metafunctions, acculturation stages, legitimate peripheral participation), and their applications to SLA.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two levels at which Vygotsky believed learning takes place?
- Name the three language metafunctions introduced by Halliday (1978).
- List the five stages of acculturation according to Brown (1980).
- What are the four key factors proposed by Lave and Wenger in Situated Learning theory?
- According to Ochs and Schieffelin, how are language acquisition and culture acquisition related?
📘 Lecture 17 — Basic Language Cognition (BLC) vs. Higher Language Cognition (HLC)
📖 Overview: This lecture introduces the distinction between Basic Language Cognition (BLC) and Higher Language Cognition (HLC), as proposed by Hulstijin in 2015. It explores how these constructs explain individual differences in monolingual and bilingual language proficiency, clarifies the native speaker construct in relation to BLC and HLC, and examines the factors that produce variability among language learners.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers three main topics: Basic Language Cognition theory and its components; the Native Speaker Construct and Hulstijin's five corollaries distinguishing BLC and HLC attainment in L1 and L2 learners; and the differences among language learners, including cognitive abilities, environmental factors, and the variability in L1 and L2 development outcomes.
📝 Lecture Summary
Topic-060: Basic Language Cognition
BLC Theory was proposed by Hulstijin in 2015. The theory is grounded in understanding individual differences in monolingual and bilingual people and addressing matters of L2 proficiency assessment. Hulstijin views cognition as a term referring to the neural network consisting of the representation and use of information for both knowledge and skills. Basic concerns what native speakers have in common related to language cognition, while Higher refers to extended language cognition. The core linguistic cognition includes phonetic-phonological, morphonological, morpho-syntactic, and lexical domains of linguistic knowledge. It also examines how to use language forms appropriate to the communicative situation. BLC focuses more on reading and writing rather than speech reception and speech production.
🔑 Definition — BLC (Basic Language Cognition): According to Hulstijin (2015), BLC pertains to: 1) largely implicit, unconscious knowledge in phonetics, prosody, phonology, morphology, and syntax; 2) largely explicit, conscious knowledge in the lexical domain (form-meaning mappings); combined with 3) the automaticity with which these types of knowledge can be processed.
Topic-061: Native Speaker Construct
A Native Speaker is defined as one who acquires the language as a young child and maintains it into adulthood. In linguistic terms, a native speaker is someone who has acquired BLC and who may have acquired some or many features of HLC. The term native speaker differs in the contexts of HLC and BLC. In HLC, factors such as age, intelligence, knowledge, education, professional career, and leisure time activities determine variance in individual attributes.
The development of language proficiency for both L1 and L2 learners is a gradual process in both the acquisition of BLC and the acquisition of HLC, except for issues of L2 acquisition and bilingualism which are concerned with the age factor. The empirical aspect of proficiency varies from society to society and individual to individual.
Hulstijin proposed the following corollaries:
- C1: All adult L1 learners (not suffering from cognitive impairments), regardless of differences in age and intellectual functioning, can comprehend and produce, both correctly and quickly, isolated utterances consisting of high-frequency lexical phrases and high-frequency morpho-syntactic structures.
- C2: Individual differences among adult L1 learners will be relatively large in tasks involving HLC discourse, in all four modes of language use (reading, writing, listening, and speaking), but all adult L1 learners will perform excellent in BLC tasks (i.e., conceptually simple oral tasks involving highly frequent linguistic units).
- C3: Continued language use modulates the decline in processing speed in old age, while continued use of written language is modulated by level of education, type of occupation, and interests.
- C4: Early bilinguals can attain native-speaker proficiency in more than one language as long as they minimally acquire BLC in each language.
- C5: BLC, while being attainable by late L2 learners in the domains of vocabulary and many or even most grammatical structures, will generally not be attainable in the domains of pronunciation.
💡 Why this matters: These corollaries establish clear predictions about who can achieve native-like proficiency, showing that BLC is largely universal in L1 but has a critical age-related limitation in L2 pronunciation, while HLC shows wide individual variation even among native speakers.
Topic-062: Differences Among Language Learners
Hulstijin explained that cognitive abilities and environmental factors can be viewed as distinguishing elements of language learners in HLC. Wells (1986) claimed the following factors produce variability in L1 development: 1) social background, 2) personal attributes such as gender, intelligence, personality, and learning style, 3) situation (setting, activity, number and status of participants), and 4) style of interaction (interpersonal relations, child-rearing methods). Berman (2007) and Nippold (2006) found large increases in vocabulary (including metaphors, idioms, and proverbs) and development at a more modest pace in syntax, pragmatics, and narrative skills during the years of primary and secondary education.
When examining the outcome of SLA, researchers have observed that not all L2 learners acquire the language successfully. Some of the minor differences may be due to motivation and exposure to the target language, while the major differences may be due to the quality and quantity of the input.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical distinction in this lecture is between BLC (implicit, automatic, shared by all native speakers) and HLC (explicit, varied, influenced by education and experience). All adult L1 learners achieve BLC regardless of individual differences, but only early bilinguals can achieve native-like BLC in two languages. Late L2 learners can attain BLC in vocabulary and grammar but generally fail in pronunciation. Variability among learners in HLC is driven by cognitive abilities, environmental factors, social background, and input quality/quantity, whereas variability in L1 BLC tasks is minimal among healthy adults.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- According to Hulstijin (2015), what three components does BLC consist of?
- Which corollary states that late L2 learners can attain BLC in vocabulary and grammar but generally not in pronunciation?
- What factors does Wells (1986) identify as producing variability in L1 development?
- How does the definition of "native speaker" differ between HLC and BLC contexts?
- Are all L2 learners able to acquire language successfully according to SLA research findings, and what accounts for major vs. minor differences?
📘 Lecture 18 — GENERATIVE vs. USAGE BASED SCHOOL
📖 Overview: This lecture contrasts two major schools of thought in language acquisition: the Generative School, rooted in Chomsky's theory of innate Universal Grammar, and the Usage-Based School, which argues language structure emerges from actual use. Understanding these opposing views is crucial for evaluating how children acquire grammatical rules and the roles of input, cognition, and social interaction.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by introducing the Generative School and its basis in Chomsky's Generative Grammar theory, focusing on syntactic rules like phrase structure and the deep/surface structure distinction. It then presents the Usage-Based School, emphasizing Tomasello's theory where language emerges from usage events through intention-reading and pattern-finding. Finally, it directly compares the two approaches across several key dimensions, including brain localization, children's productivity, the role of input, and the mechanisms for acquisition.
📝 Lecture Summary
Topic-063: Generative School
The Generative School of thought derived its concepts from the Generative Grammar theory of Chomsky. It focuses on the study of syntax, but does include semantics, phonology, and morphology. Generative Grammar theory provides the set of rules that can accurately predict which combinations of words make grammatically correct sentences. Transformational-Generative Grammar was driven from Generative Grammar as a process of language creativity whereby a learner can transform rules from one structure. In TG theory, phrase structure rules explain, mathematically, our knowledge to assemble the basic units of a sentence.
🔑 Definition — Phrase Structure Rules: Rules that mathematically explain our knowledge to assemble the basic units of a sentence, e.g., S --> NP + VP.
📐 Formula: S --> NP + VP → A sentence consists of a noun phrase followed by a verb phrase.
💡 Why this matters: TG theory set forth two levels of syntactic structure: deep structure (an abstract underlying structure of a sentence) and surface structure (outward form of a sentence). This distinction is fundamental to understanding how different surface forms can share a common underlying meaning.
Topic-064: Usage-Based School
The usage-based theory of language acquisition claims that language structure emerges from its use. Tomasello (2003) proposed the theory with emphasis on the usage of the language based on the cognitive skills. Lieven and Tomasello (2008, p. 168) believe that 'the child learns language from actual 'usage events', i.e., from particular utterances in particular contexts, and builds up increasingly complex and abstract representations from these.' Two key components of the usage-based approach are: meaning in use, which refers to the semantic aspect of linguistic communication, and structure emerges from use, which considers the grammatical aspect of linguistic communication.
Intention-reading and pattern-finding are two sets of cognitive skills proposed by Tomasello that reinforce usage-based theory. Tomasello (2003) explains: 'Intention-reading is what children must do to determine the goals or intentions of mature speakers when they use linguistic conventions to achieve social ends, and thereby to learn these conventions from them culturally in accordance with the functional approach mentioned above. Pattern-finding is what children must do in order to extract abstract linguistic schemas or constructions from the individual utterances in accordance with the grammatical approach mentioned above.' Therefore, this theory has two main dimensions: functional and grammatical.
🔑 Definition — Intention-reading: The cognitive skill children use to determine the goals or intentions of mature speakers when they use linguistic conventions to achieve social ends. 🔑 Definition — Pattern-finding: The cognitive skill children use to extract abstract linguistic schemas or constructions from individual utterances in accordance with the grammatical approach.
Key features of Usage-Based theory include:
- Pre-linguistic communication
- Utterances and words
- Schemas and constructions
- Schematization
- Analogy
Topic-065: Generative vs. Usage-Based School Explanation
For a better understanding of differentiation between generative and usage-based schools of thought, it is important to analyze their specific characteristics. Generativists derive their concepts from the assumption that it was impossible for a child to acquire the rules of their grammar through Behaviorism. The usage-based stance is closer to that of Cognitive Linguistics and Construction Grammar where the fundamental linguistic unit is the construction.
The differences between innate UG and usage-based accounts of L1 and L2 acquisition can be summarized as follows (James H-Y. Tai, 2014):
- At the level of brain, the UG approach assumes that linguistic representation is localized in a language-specific module with its own rules of processing. In contrast, the usage-based approach assumes 'plasticity' to a great extent. Linguistic representation in brain can change in the course of L1 as well as L2 acquisition and development.
- Children are creative and productive to start with innate UG. However, in usage-based approach, children are conservative and unproductive to start with and only gradually become productive by induction through experience.
- In the UG approach, the role of input is underdetermined because of 'poverty of the stimulus' with lack of negative evidence (ungrammatical sentences). In the usage-based approach, all linguistic structures emerge from generalization of the input through induction.
- In the UG approach, innate core grammar needs mechanisms such as maturation, triggering, and linking rules to activate it. In contrast, the usage-based approach requires children to figure out linguistic system by adaptive social-communicative behaviors.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The central debate is whether language is an innate, specialized module (Generative/UG school) or emerges from general cognitive skills and usage (Usage-Based school). The Generative School posits phrase structure rules, deep and surface structures, and relies on poverty of the stimulus to argue for innate knowledge. The Usage-Based School, led by Tomasello, emphasizes intention-reading and pattern-finding, arguing that children learn from specific usage events and gradually build abstract schemas. A critical distinction is that UG views children as initially creative and productive with an innate grammar, while the usage-based view sees them as conservative and unproductive, becoming productive only through experience. Finally, the two approaches differ on brain localization (language-specific module vs. plasticity) and the mechanism for activating grammar (maturation/triggering vs. adaptive social-communicative behaviors).
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What is the basic formula for a phrase structure rule in Transformational-Generative Grammar, and what does it mean?
- What are the two levels of syntactic structure in TG theory, and how do they differ?
- According to Tomasello, what are the two key cognitive skills children use in the Usage-Based approach to language acquisition?
- How does the role of "input" differ between the Generative/UG approach and the Usage-Based approach?
- In the context of L1 acquisition, do children start as "creative and productive" or "conservative and unproductive" according to the Generative School? According to the Usage-Based School?
📘 Lecture 19 — Communicative Competence
📖 Overview: This lecture explores the evolution of L2 proficiency models from Lado’s framework through Hymes’ communicative competence to Bachman’s Communicative Language Ability (CLA). It matters because understanding these models helps educators assess and develop learners’ real-world language use beyond mere grammatical knowledge.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by reviewing various L2 proficiency models including those by Lado, Carroll, Hymes, and Canale & Swain, covering proficiency assessment types. It then examines Dell Hymes’ communicative competence as a reaction to Chomsky’s linguistic competence. Bachman’s Communicative Language Ability is detailed, distinguishing organizational and pragmatic competence with strategic competence components. Finally, it discusses types of competencies, Savignon’s characteristics, and Munby’s approach to communicative competence.
📝 Lecture Summary
Topic-066: Reviewing L2 Proficiency Models
Proficiency has been defined by various researchers. Higgs (1984) defined it as “the ability to function effectively in the language in real-life contexts,” while Thomas (1994) considered it to correspond to “a person’s overall competence and ability to perform in L2.” Hulstijn (2011) defined language proficiency as “the extent to which an individual possesses the linguistic cognition necessary to function in a given communicative situation, in a given modality (listening, speaking, reading, or writing).” Communicative Competence refers to having mastery over language rules and the ability to use them appropriately in a specific context.
Researchers have viewed L2 Proficiency Models in multiple ways. Lado’s (1961) model focuses on intersections between four language ‘elements’ (pronunciation, grammatical structure, lexicon, and cultural meaning) and four language ‘skills’ (listening, speaking, reading, and writing). Carroll (1961) argued that L2 competence included both knowledge of the language system and facility in its use. Hymes (1972) introduced a model of communicative competence in response to Chomsky’s model of linguistic competence, emphasizing the pragmatic aspects of language use.
Canale and Swain (1980) attempted a typology where communicative L2 competence involves grammatical and sociolinguistic competence as well as strategic competence (“the compensatory communication strategies to be used when there is a breakdown in one of the other competencies” [1980, p. 27]).
Proficiency Assessment is concerned with general versus specific performances or knowledge. The types include:
- Discrete-point versus integrative assessment
- Direct versus indirect assessment
- Objective versus subjective assessment
- Group testing versus individual assessment
🔑 Definition — Proficiency: “The ability to function effectively in the language in real-life contexts” (Higgs, 1984). 🔑 Definition — Communicative Competence: Having mastery over language rules and the ability to use them appropriately in a specific context.
Topic-067: Dell Hymes’ Communicative Competence
Dell Hymes (1972) defined communicative competence as the ability to use grammatical competence in a variety of communicative situations based on grammatical competence. It is opposed to Chomsky’s concept of competence which is linguistic specific and ignores the communicative aspect. Hymes’ communicative competence comes as a reaction to Chomsky’s idea of competence. Hymes claims, “In speaking of competence, it is especially important not to separate cognitive from affective and volitive factors, so far as the impact of the theory on educational practice is concerned.”
🔑 Definition — Communicative Competence (Hymes): The ability to use grammatical competence in a variety of communicative situations, opposing Chomsky’s linguistically-specific competence.
Topic-068: Bachman Communicative Language Ability (CLA)
Lyle Bachman, one of the leading theorists in language testing, proposed Communicative Language Ability (CLA) (1990) which attempted to distinguish between ‘Knowledge’ and ‘Skills’. CLA is concerned with the knowledge and capacity to use it appropriately in a given context. Bachman classifies the component called ‘Language Competence’ in two divisions:
- Organizational Competence
- Grammatical Competence
- Textual Competence
- Pragmatic Competence
- Illocutionary Competence
- Sociolinguistics Competence
- Communicative Competence
Strategic Competence is another aspect of Language Competence proposed by Bachman with the following three components:
- Assessment component
- Planning component
- Execution component (Bachman, 1990, pp. 84-108)
🔑 Definition — Communicative Language Ability (CLA): Knowledge and capacity to use it appropriately in a given context (Bachman, 1990). 📐 Bachman’s CLA Model Structure: Language Competence = Organizational Competence (Grammatical + Textual) + Pragmatic Competence (Illocutionary + Sociolinguistic + Communicative); plus Strategic Competence (Assessment + Planning + Execution).
Topic-069: Types of Competencies
Developing communicative competencies requires specific skills. These consist of the following:
- Linguistic Competence
- Strategic Competence
- Sociolinguistic Competence
- Discourse Competence
Five characteristics of communicative competence proposed by Savignon (1883, pp. 8-9) are:
- Dynamic nature of communicative competence.
- Communicative competence applies to both written and spoken language, as well as to many other symbolic systems.
- Communicative competence is context specific.
- Competence is what one knows. Performance is what one does.
- Communicative competence is relative, not absolute.
John Munby’s (1978, pp. 22-27) approach to Communicative Competence has the following points:
- Competence and Community
- Contextual Appropriacy
- Communication Needs
🔑 Definition — Linguistic Competence: Knowledge of language rules and structures. Strategic Competence: Ability to overcome communication breakdowns. Sociolinguistic Competence: Ability to use language appropriately in social contexts. Discourse Competence: Ability to organize and connect ideas in speech or writing. 💡 Why this matters: These four competencies together form the practical skills needed for effective real-world communication, moving beyond theory into actual language use.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Students must remember that communicative competence evolved as a reaction to Chomsky’s narrow linguistic competence, with Hymes emphasizing pragmatic and social aspects of language use. Bachman’s CLA model is critical for exams, distinguishing between organizational competence (grammatical and textual) and pragmatic competence (illocutionary and sociolinguistic), with strategic competence managing breakdowns. The four types of competencies—linguistic, strategic, sociolinguistic, and discourse—are essential for developing real-world language ability. Savignon’s five characteristics highlight that communicative competence is dynamic, context-specific, relative, and applies to both spoken and written language. Proficiency assessment types (discrete-point vs. integrative, direct vs. indirect, objective vs. subjective, group vs. individual) are key for understanding how language ability is measured.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- How does Hymes’ communicative competence differ from Chomsky’s linguistic competence?
- What are the two main divisions of Bachman’s Language Competence, and what sub-competencies does each contain?
- List the four types of competencies required for developing communicative competence.
- What are the five characteristics of communicative competence according to Savignon?
- What are the four pairs of proficiency assessment types mentioned in the lecture?