📘 Lecture 8 — SECOND LANGUAGE ACQUISITION II
📖 Overview: This lecture explores second language acquisition (SLA) beyond purely linguistic factors, emphasizing sociolinguistic influences on interlanguage variation. It covers crucial theoretical frameworks including Input, Interaction, and Output hypotheses, examines non-language factors affecting learning success, and presents an integrated model of the acquisition process from input to output.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture covers Interlanguage in Context with variation and pragmatic considerations; Input, Interaction, and Output theories including Krashen's Input Hypothesis, Swain's Output Hypothesis, and Long's Interaction Hypothesis; non-language factors beyond the domain of language such as affect, anxiety, social distance, age, aptitude, and motivation; the Lexicon including receptive vs. productive knowledge and breadth vs. depth; and finally the Integrated View of SLA with five stages from apperceived input to output.
📝 Lecture Summary
Topic-040: Interlanguage in Context
The basic premise of sociolinguistic-based SLA research is that second language data does not represent a static phenomenon. Many external variables affect learner production and the developing interlanguage system. Learners in some instances produce different forms of language.
Interlanguage Variation: ILs exhibit more variability than native languages. For example, a learner might alternate between forms to express the same language function, such as alternating between no and not ("My husband not here" vs. "No English"). Initially, the variation is non-systematic—forms are used interchangeably with no apparent difference in meaning. There is a gradual establishment of a one-to-one form-function relationship. Thus, variation is the initial step in the eventual emergence of target-like usage.
Social Interactional Approach: Learning is not an intra-psychological process situated entirely in an individual's cognition; rather, it is linked to social and local ecology. It is adaptive to a set of resources embodied in social interaction. The linguistic code cannot be understood as an isolated phenomenon outside of its social context, nor can one understand how learning takes place without the support of the social context.
Interlanguage Pragmatics: This deals with both the acquisition and use of L2 pragmatic knowledge. In learning an L2, one must learn more than just pronunciation, lexical items, and word order; one must also learn the appropriate way to use those words and sentences in the L2. Much of the work in interlanguage pragmatics has been conducted within the framework of speech acts. Miscommunication and misunderstandings occur if the form of a speech act differs from culture to culture. Pragmatics is one of the most difficult areas for L2 learners.
Topic-041: Input, Interaction, and Output
There is a distinction between Input and Intake. Input refers to what is available to the learner, whereas intake refers to what is actually internalized by the learner (Corder, 1967). For example, incomprehensible language may be related to input but is not intake because it is not integrated into the learner-language system.
🔑 Definition — Input: What is available to the learner from the environment. 🔑 Definition — Intake: What is actually internalized and integrated into the learner's language system.
Krashen's 'Input Hypothesis': The Input Hypothesis claims that exposure to comprehensible input is both necessary and sufficient for second language learning to take place. "Humans acquire language in only one way—by understanding messages or by receiving 'comprehensible input.'" Comprehensible input is slightly ahead of a learner's current state of grammatical knowledge.
📐 Formula: i + 1 → "We move from i (our current level) to i + 1 (the next level), along the natural order by understanding input containing i + 1" (Krashen, 1985, p. 2). The input activates innate mental structures of a learner.
Implications: Speaking is a result of acquisition and not its cause; if input is understood and there is enough of it, the necessary grammar is automatically provided.
Criticism: There is little empirical evidence and it is not easily testable. There is also criticism regarding sufficient quantity of the appropriate input.
Comprehensible Output Hypothesis: This refers to the need for a learner to be "pushed towards the delivery of a message that is not only conveyed but that is conveyed precisely, coherently and appropriately" (Swain, 1985, p. 249). Input alone is not sufficient for acquisition. Output may stimulate learners to move from the semantic, open-ended, non-deterministic, and strategic processing prevalent in comprehension to the complete grammatical processing needed for accurate production. Swain argues that comprehension of L2 input is often achievable by semantic/pragmatic means, making it unnecessary for the L2 listener to struggle to process unfamiliar syntax in full. The effort of composing new utterances is more likely to drive learners to form new hypotheses about target language syntax. Therefore, the acquisition of new syntactic structures is more likely to result from learners' attempts at L2 production than simply from the struggle to comprehend i+1 utterances.
💡 Why this matters: Swain's hypothesis challenges Krashen's view that input alone is sufficient, arguing that production forces deeper syntactic processing.
Long's Interaction Hypothesis: Long was critical of the descriptivism of early studies and proposed a more systematic approach to linking features of 'environmental' language and learners' L2 development. He argued this could be done in three steps:
- Show that (a) linguistic/conversational adjustments promote (b) comprehension of input
- Show that (b) comprehensible input promotes (c) acquisition
- Deduce that (a) linguistic/conversational adjustments promote (c) acquisition
Topic-042: Beyond the Domain of Language
One of the most widely recognized facts about SLA is that some individuals are more successful than others. There may be non-language factors responsible for these differences, such as age, aptitude, motivation, attitude, and socio-psychological influences. Many reasons for lack of success are not related to language or psycholinguistic factors.
-
Competence: Modern linguistics emphasizes what speakers know (competence), rather than what they actually do on some particular occasion (performance). However, it is not clear whether the competence that linguistics attempts to discover is common to all native speakers of a language.
-
Affect: Affect refers to feelings or emotions that individuals have about something. In language learning, it can refer to feelings or emotional reactions about the language, about the people who speak that language, or about the culture where that language is spoken.
-
Language Anxiety: This is an important factor affecting learning and is a matter of personality—an emotional reaction to a situation or a combination. Low levels help, whereas high levels hurt learning.
-
Social Distance: These are instances in which an L2 learner does not feel an affinity with the target language community. It results in a diminished amount of input. Learners create both psychological and social distances from L2 speakers. Schumann's (1978) Acculturation Model states that if learners acculturate, they will learn. Thus, acculturation initiates a chain reaction including contact in the middle and acquisition as its outcome.
-
Age Differences: It is commonly believed that children are better language learners than adults in the sense that they can gain mastery of an L2, whereas adults cannot.
-
Aptitude: Aptitude refers to one's potential for learning new knowledge or new skills.
-
Motivation: A social-psychological factor frequently used to account for differential success in learning an L2. It makes sense that individuals who are motivated will learn another language faster. Numerous studies show that motivation is a predictor of language-learning success.
Topic-043: The Lexicon
The lexicon may be the most important language component for learners. Of all error types, learners consider vocabulary errors the most serious. Large corpora of errors consistently indicate that lexical errors are the most common among L2 learners.
Categories of Lexical Knowledge: Some Dichotomies This deals with Production and Reception. Learners appear to have differing degrees of knowledge of their L2 lexicon. Nation (2001, p. 27) lists the following as necessary word knowledge types:
Receptive Knowledge Includes:
- Recognizing the word in writing or orally
- Knowing the general meaning
- Knowing that it is made up of component parts
- Knowing that it has a possible connotation
Productive Knowledge Involves Greater Specificity and Includes:
- Knowing how to accurately pronounce a word or correctly spell it
- Knowing the precise meaning in a variety of contexts
- Knowing the precise use of context
- Learners generally have a wider range of receptive vocabulary than productive vocabulary
- Another important distinction is between potential and real vocabulary
Knowledge and Control: Knowledge is defined as "the way in which the language system is represented in the mind of the learner." Control is "the processing system for controlling that system during actual performance."
Breadth and Depth: Breadth of knowledge refers to the number of words a learner knows (Nation, 2001; Nassaji, 2004). The depth of vocabulary knowledge is a quality measure (Meare, 1996). Both breadth and depth of knowledge play a role in comprehension.
Topic-044: The Integrated View of Second Language Acquisition
There are several approaches to acquisition, each crucial in dealing with a part of what happens in learning a second language. However, none of them alone is able to account for the total picture. The learning of an L2 is a multifaceted endeavor. One must consider what is learned and what is not learned. Learners must focus on five stages to convert input to output.
-
Apperceived Input: The first stage of input utilization. Apperception is the process of understanding by which newly observed qualities of an object are related to past experiences. It is an internal cognitive act, identifying a linguistic form as being related to some prior knowledge. It is a priming device that prepares the input for further analysis.
-
Comprehended Input: There are two differences between comprehended input and comprehensible input. First, comprehensible input is controlled by the person providing input, whereas comprehended input is learner-controlled. Second, comprehensible input in Krashen's sense is treated as a dichotomous variable (either comprehensible or not), but there are different levels of comprehension.
-
Intake: This is the process of assimilating linguistic material—the mental activity that mediates between input and grammar. This suggests that intake is not merely a subset of input. It is different from apperception or comprehension as the latter two do not necessarily lead to grammar formation.
-
Integration: After language intake, there are at least two possible outcomes, both forms of integration: (a) The development per se of one's second language grammar and storage; (b) Integration is not necessarily a one-time affair; rather, there are different levels of analysis and reanalysis from storage into grammar and within the grammar itself. The integration component does not function as an independent unit.
-
Output: The final stage. The concept of output necessitates a feedback loop to comprehended input. Learner output is often equated with their grammar, but it is not identical to one's grammar, as suggested by individual differences among learners. Learners produce different linguistic forms with varying amounts of accuracy depending on the context and the task performed.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical thing to remember is that SLA is not purely linguistic—sociolinguistic variables cause interlanguage variation, with learners alternating forms non-systematically before establishing form-function relationships. Krashen's Input Hypothesis (i+1) claims comprehensible input is necessary and sufficient, but Swain's Output Hypothesis argues production drives syntactic development, while Long's Interaction Hypothesis links conversational adjustments to comprehension and acquisition. Seven non-language factors—competence, affect, anxiety, social distance, age, aptitude, and motivation—significantly impact learner success. The lexicon involves receptive vs. productive knowledge and breadth vs. depth. Finally, the integrated model shows acquisition proceeds through five stages: apperceived input, comprehended input, intake, integration, and output, with output providing a feedback loop to earlier stages.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between interlanguage variation that is non-systematic and the eventual establishment of a one-to-one form-function relationship?
- According to Krashen's Input Hypothesis, what does "i + 1" represent, and what are the main criticisms of this hypothesis?
- How does Swain's Comprehensible Output Hypothesis differ from Krashen's Input Hypothesis regarding what drives syntactic acquisition?
- List three non-language factors beyond the domain of language that affect SLA success, and briefly explain how each influences learning.
- What are the five stages in the integrated view of SLA from input to output, and why does output provide a feedback loop to comprehended input?
📘 Lecture 9 — Methods and Approaches of Language Teaching I
📖 Overview: This lecture introduces the historical development of language teaching methods, from the dominance of Latin to modern English language teaching. It establishes the critical distinction between approach, method, technique, design, and procedure, then examines four foundational methods: Grammar Translation Method, Audio-lingual Method, Oral Approach, and Direct Method—each representing different theoretical views of language and learning.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the history and major trends of language teaching from the 15th century onward, including the rise of English as a global language and the growth of ELT institutions. It then defines key terminology: approach, method, technique, design, and procedure, explaining their hierarchical relationship. Four specific methods are examined in detail: Grammar Translation Method (GTM), Audio-lingual Method (ALM), Oral Approach (also called Structural-Situational Method), and Direct Method—each with their background, assumptions, goals, classroom practices, and critical evaluations.
📝 Lecture Summary
Topic-045: History and Major Trends of Language Teaching
Many current debates in language teaching have historical roots. Throughout history, changes in language teaching methods have reflected what kind of proficiency learners needed. Bilingualism has historically been the norm—60% of today's population is multilingual. While English is now the world's most widely studied foreign language, 500 years ago Latin held that position. In the 16th century, French, Italian, and English gained importance due to political changes in Europe, though Latin remained the classical ideal.
The history of ELT shows that during the 15th century, King Henry V proclaimed English as the official language. The 16th-century expansion of the English Empire increased interest in learning English. Early contributors included Gabriel Meurier (who wrote "A Treatise for to Learn to Speak French and English") and Jaques Bellot (who authored "The English Schoolmaster" in 1580 and "Familiar Dialogues" in 1586). In the early 20th century, ELT institutes, publishers, the BBC, and the British Council were concentrated in London. This changed with large-scale immigration to the UK during the 1960s, leading to "English for Immigrants," which by 1970 was renamed TESL (Teaching of English as Second Language). The 1970s saw English for Special Purposes emerge, and the 1960s brought ARELS as a source for ELT resources. Today, while most English language teachers worldwide are nonnative speakers (NNS), the field remains dominated by British and American interests.
Topic-046: Approach, Method, Technique, Design, and Procedure
In describing methods, the central distinction is between the philosophy of language teaching at the level of theory and principles, and the derived procedures for teaching.
Approach refers to theories about the nature of language and language learning that serve as the source of practices and principles in language teaching. An approach describes how language is used and how its constituent parts interlock, and addresses how people acquire their knowledge of language.
🔑 Definition — Theoretical Views of Language:
- Structural view: Language is a system of structurally related elements for coding meaning. The Audio-lingual Method (ALM) embodies this view.
- Functional view: Language is a vehicle for expressing functional meaning. The communicative movement subscribes to this view.
- Interactional view: Language is a vehicle for realizing interpersonal relations. This is reflected in Task-Based Language (TBL) Teaching.
🔑 Definition — Theories of Language Learning: For example, behaviorist and cognitivist views explain how people acquire language knowledge.
Design is the level of method analysis dealing with: objectives of a method, selection and organization of language content, types of learning tasks and teaching activities, roles of learners and teachers, and role of teaching materials.
Procedure refers to the actual moment-to-moment techniques, practices, and behaviors that operate in teaching. It addresses how a method realizes its approach and design in classroom behavior, and how tasks and activities are integrated into lessons. Procedure is an ordered sequence of techniques.
Technique is implementational in nature—a particular trick, stratagem, or contrivance used to accomplish an immediate objective. Techniques may be consistent with a method.
Method is the overall practical realization of an approach. Methods include various procedures and techniques. Methods are easy to follow when they have fixed procedures and clear approaches tied to them.
Topic-047: Grammar Translation Method (GTM)
GTM is also known as the classical method and is one of the oldest or traditional methods, making its origin difficult to trace. In the early 1500s, GTM was used for teaching Latin and Greek. It was popular in foreign language classrooms from the mid-19th century to the mid-20th century.
Basic Assumptions:
- A foreign language can easily be learned through translation.
- Grammar is the soul of language.
- Learning foreign languages was part of a truly liberal education.
- The structure of a foreign language can best be taught by comparing it with that of L1.
Goals of GTM:
- To learn a language in order to read its literature or benefit from mental development resulting from L2 study.
- To be able to translate from one language to another.
- L1 is maintained as the reference system in L2 learning.
- Views language learning as little more than memorizing rules.
- To learn vocabulary items and grammatical rules through memorization.
Practices and Techniques in GTM: Words are taught through bilingual word lists and dictionaries. Grammar is taught deductively—by presentation and study of grammar rules in an organized, systematic way, then practiced through translation exercises.
📌 Example — GTM Lesson Components: A typical GTM lesson includes: a reading passage, comprehension questions, antonyms/synonyms, cognates, grammar exercises, using words in sentences, memorization, composition, and summarizing.
Criticism:
- Teacher-centered and aims at improving accuracy, not fluency.
- Does not cater for the communicative aspect of language.
- Overemphasis on language as a mass of rules and vocabulary to be memorized and translated.
Topic-048: Audio-lingual Method (ALM)
Background: Before World War II, three methods existed: Modified Direct Method, Reading Approach, and Reading-Oral Approach.
ALM was introduced in the 1950s. It is contrary to GTM and is based on a solid theoretical background from behaviorist psychology (the more we practice language, the better users we will be) and structuralist linguistics (focus on phonology, morphology, and syntax). These elements help students build their own sentences. Primarily, language is speaking; writing is of secondary importance. Through learning language elements (sounds, words, grammar, sentence structures), we can build grammatically correct sentences and texts in speaking. Writing only helps reinforce learned elements.
Characteristics of ALM:
- New language items are presented in dialogues.
- Repetition of learned language structures.
- Pronunciation is important; grammatical explanation is minimal.
- Excessive use of language laboratories.
- Formation of correct sentences.
Learner Roles:
- They can be directed by skilled training techniques.
- Reactive role—they do not initiate interaction.
Teacher Roles:
- Central and active
- Model of the target language
- Monitors and controls the learning process
Role of Instructional Materials:
- Teacher-oriented
- Tape recorders, language laboratory, and audiovisual equipment are important
- Focus on positive reinforcement (stimulus-response-reinforcement)
- ALM relies heavily on drills
- Substitution is used to make learners know more linguistic items
💡 Why this matters: ALM's theoretical grounding in behaviorism makes it a clear example of how psychological theory directly shapes classroom practice.
Criticism: May not be applicable where there is: lack of necessary labs, lack of teacher expertise, little focus on real-life context, and premium on accuracy.
Topic-049: Oral Approach
The Oral Approach is also known as Structural-Situational Method and Situational Language Teaching. It emerged in Europe and the United States in the 1920s and 1930s. This method was an attempt by Harold Palmer and Hornby to present language items systematically in the classroom. Language was viewed as a system of structurally related elements—phonemes, morphemes, words, structures, and sentence types—which learners must master to encode and decode meaning.
Objectives:
- To develop oral proficiency
- Focus on vocabulary control
- Use of mother tongue is avoided
- Reading and writing are not neglected
- Grading the grammatical items
- Grammar control
Theoretical Assumptions: Speech is considered the primary element. The methodology involves three basic principles:
- Choosing lexical and grammatical items
- Organizing and sequencing content
- Techniques for presentation
Characteristics:
- Language teaching begins with spoken language
- Target language is the medium within the classroom
- New language items are introduced and practiced situationally
- Vocabulary selection is made
- Grammar items are graded—reading and writing come later
📌 Example — Techniques Used in the Classroom: Dialogues for memorization, expansion drills, repetition drills, substitution drills, transformation drills, question-answer drills, minimal-pair technique, completion drills, grammar games, and so on.
Role of a Teacher: In the presentation stage, the teacher serves as the model (creates the situation). Later, the teacher turns into a conductor.
Critical Appreciation (Advantages): It does not require many resources and is easy to understand as items are presented in real situations. It includes all major skills.
Disadvantages:
- Learner has no control over content of learning—listens to, repeats what the teacher says, responds to teachers' questions and commands.
- There is no account for the uniqueness of individual sentences.
Topic-050: Direct Method
Background: The impetus for the Direct Method (DM) came from the need to teach foreign languages to facilitate trade, commerce, travel, etc. Sauveur (1826–1907) and other believers in the Natural Method argued that a foreign language could be taught without translation or use of the learner's native language. Meaning may be conveyed directly through demonstration and action.
The German scholar Franke (1884) wrote on the psychological principles of direct association between forms and meanings in the target language and provided a theoretical justification for a monolingual approach to teaching.
Reaction to GTM: GTM was considered inadequate and ineffective in developing communicative ability. Reformists advocated an alternative method where language was presented in contexts and the mother tongue (L1) was avoided. DM was first used in France and Germany.
Objectives:
- Use of everyday vocabulary and structures
- Grammar is taught inductively
- Oral skills are developed through carefully graded programs
- Interaction between teachers and students
- L2 learning must be an imitation of L1 learning; good pronunciation is required
- Both speaking and listening skills are emphasized
- Meanings are taught through demonstration, pictures, objects, etc.
- Printed word must be kept away from L2 learner for as long as possible
- Written word must be kept away until after the printed word has been introduced
📌 Example — Classroom Technique:
- Teacher presents a short text, and students derive grammar rules on their own.
- Difficult words/phrases are explained in the target language (through paraphrase, demonstration).
- Exercises include: transposition, substitution, dictation, free composition, etc.
Critical Appreciation (Criticism):
- Difficult to implement in many L2 contexts because of the proficiency demands on teachers.
- Difficulty explaining a word in the target language and inability to grade materials.
- Fallacy of the belief that L2 can be learned on the pattern of L1 learning—far less time and opportunities are available in schools.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts to remember are the hierarchical distinction between approach (theoretical views of language and learning), method (overall practical realization), design (objectives, content, roles), and technique (moment-to-moment classroom procedures). GTM relies on translation, deductive grammar, and memorization but neglects communication; ALM is behaviorist with repetition and drilling but lacks real-life context; the Oral Approach emphasizes situational presentation and vocabulary/grammar control but gives learners no control; and the Direct Method avoids L1 entirely and teaches grammar inductively but demands high teacher proficiency. Understanding each method's theoretical basis (structural, functional, or interactional view of language) and its classroom implications is essential for comparing and evaluating language teaching approaches.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three theoretical views of language described in the lecture, and which teaching method embodies each?
- How does the Grammar Translation Method teach grammar, and what are its main criticisms?
- What theoretical frameworks (psychology and linguistics) form the basis of the Audio-lingual Method, and what is the primary focus of instruction?
- What are the three basic principles of the Oral Approach, and why is it also called "Structural-Situational Method"?
- Explain the Direct Method's view on using the mother tongue and how grammar is taught—what practical difficulties does this create?
📘 Lecture 10 — Methods and Approaches of Language Teaching II
📖 Overview: This lecture continues the exploration of language teaching methods, covering the Communicative Approach, Task-based Language Teaching, the Silent Way, the Bilingual Method, and the Post-Methods Era. It critically examines each method's principles, procedures, and limitations, ultimately arguing for a more flexible, context-sensitive approach to language teaching beyond rigid methodologies.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers five major topics: The Communicative Approach (CLT), including its origins, aims, principles, and roles of learners and teachers; Task-based Language Teaching (TBLT), as a logical development of CLT focused on tasks; The Silent Way, based on learner discovery and teacher silence; The Bilingual Method, which strategically uses the mother tongue alongside the target language; and The Post-Methods Era, which critiques the limitations of all-purpose methods and advocates for context-sensitive, principled teaching.
📝 Lecture Summary
Topic- 051: The Communicative Approach
The Communicative Approach, also known as Communicative Language Teaching (CLT), emerged in the 1970s due to a growing demand for practical communication skills in English. It represented a shift away from earlier methods that focused on the product (grammar rules and structures) and instead emphasized the process of communication. The core idea was to focus on what learners need to understand and express through the target language, rather than on accumulating grammatical items.
Major influences on CLT came from British functional linguists like Firth and Halliday, American sociolinguists like Hymes and Gumperz, and philosophers like Austin and Searle. The changing political and educational realities in Europe also played a significant role. CLT aims to make communicative competence the goal of language teaching and develops procedures for teaching the four language skills that acknowledge the interdependence of language and communication. There are two versions: strong CLT (learning to use) and weak CLT (using an L2 to learn it).
The principles of CLT state that learners learn a language through usage and communication. Authentic and meaningful communication should be the goal of classroom activities, and fluency is an important dimension of communication. Communication involves the integration of different language skills, and learning is a process of creative construction involving trial and error. Language errors are sometimes tolerated.
Halliday identified seven major functions of language: instrumental, regulatory, interactional, personal, heuristic, imaginative, and representational. Activities are based on communicative processes such as information sharing, negotiation of meaning, and interaction. Examples include completing a map or picture, dialogues, role plays, simulations, skits, improvisations, and debates.
The role of the learner in CLT is that of a negotiator between the self, the learning process, and the object of learning, and a contributor, not a passive recipient of knowledge. The teacher's roles are diverse, including facilitator between all participants, activities, and texts; participant within the learning-teaching group; organizer; guide; researcher; learner; needs analyst; and counselor. Instructional materials should be authentic and from real life, such as signs, magazines, advertisements, and newspapers, as well as graphic and visual sources like maps, pictures, symbols, graphs, and charts.
Despite its popularity, CLT has been critically noted for not being a single, uniform method but a collection of different techniques. There is no standard textbook, and virtually no formal teaching. It is difficult to implement due to its high demands on the teacher.
Topic- 052: Task-based Language Teaching (TBLT)
Task-based Language Teaching (TBLT) can be regarded as a recent version or logical development of communicative methodology. It seeks to reconcile methodology with current theories of Second Language Acquisition (SLA). TBLT makes the use of tasks the core unit of planning and instruction in language teaching, with a strong focus on classroom processes.
The assumptions of TBLT (according to Feez, 1998) are that its basic elements are purposeful activities and tasks that emphasize communication and meaning. These activities and tasks are related to learners' real-life communication needs and pedagogical purposes. Tasks in a TBLT syllabus are sequenced according to difficulty, which depends on a range of factors: the learner's previous experience, the complexity of the task, the language required, and the degree of support available.
The concept of a task is central. It is an important element in syllabus design, classroom teaching, and learner assessment. A task is an activity or goal carried out using language, such as finding a solution to a puzzle, reading a map, or giving directions. It focuses on meaning, involves two or more learners, calls upon their use of communication strategies and interactional skills, has an outcome, and resembles real-life language use. A TBLT syllabus might specify two types of tasks: real-world tasks based on needs analysis, and pedagogical tasks based on SLA theory.
Types of tasks, as described by Willis (1996), include listing, ordering and sorting, comparing, problem solving, sharing personal experiences, and creative tasks. Other categories include jigsaw tasks, information gap, decision-making, and classifications like one-way or two-way, convergent or divergent, collaborative or competitive, and simple or complex processing. The learner's role is that of a group participant, monitor, risk-taker, and innovator. The teacher's role is to be a selector and sequencer of tasks, a preparer of learners, and a facilitator of consciousness-raising. The procedure follows a sequence: pre-task, task, and post-task activities.
Critical appreciation of TBLT notes that tasks provide both input and output, and both task activity and achievement are motivational. However, task development may require considerable time, ingenuity, and resources, and many aspects of TBLT, such as the evaluation of tasks, have yet to be fully justified.
Topic- 053: The Silent Way
The Silent Way was devised by Caleb Gattegno. It is based on the premise that the teacher should be silent as much as possible in the classroom, while the learner should be encouraged to produce as much language as possible. It makes use of color charts and colored Cuisenaire rods.
The assumptions of the Silent Way are that learning is facilitated if the learner discovers or creates rather than remembers and repeats. Learning is also facilitated by accompanying (mediating) physical objects and by problem solving involving the material to be learned.
The approach to learning emphasizes grasping the "spirit" of the language, not just its component forms. The "spirit" is composed of phonological and suprasegmental elements that give the language its unique sound system and melody. It is a structural approach where the sentence is the basic unit of teaching. The teacher focuses on propositional meaning rather than communicative value and emphasizes learning grammar rules through largely inductive processes. Silence is considered the best vehicle for learning because it enables students to concentrate on the task.
The design and objectives are to give beginning-level students oral and aural facility in basic elements of the target language. The general goal is near-native fluency, including correct pronunciation and mastery of prosodic elements, along with basic practical knowledge of grammar. Simple linguistic tasks are used where the teacher models (minimally) a word, phrase, or sentence. Learners create their own utterances by combining old and new information. Charts, rods, and other aids may be used to elicit learner responses. Learners are expected to be independent, autonomous, and responsible, working cooperatively rather than competitively. The teacher is like a complete dramatist: writing the script, choosing the props, setting the mood, modeling the action, designating the players, and acting as a critic.
Topic- 054: The Bilingual Method
The Bilingual Method was developed by Dr. C. J. Dodson to improve the audio-visual method and was a reaction against the Direct Method (DM). It argues that excessive use of the DM would result in the disappearance of the vernacular. The Bilingual Method makes use of two languages: the mother tongue (L1) and the target language (TL). It can be considered a combination of the DM and the Grammar-Translation Method (GTM). L1 is used to gloss difficult words, not for translating the whole language as in GTM.
The assumptions of the Bilingual Method are that L2 may be learnt with the help of L1, provided it is not used as translation but as a means to achieve communication ends. L1 is not considered as interfering with the learning process in L2. The teacher may banish L1 from the classroom but not from the learners' mind. Language is seen as a way of making infinite use of finite means, and L1 seems to be the ideal means of getting the meaning across completely and quickly.
The procedure of the Bilingual Method aims to develop L2 spontaneously within a lesson cycle. Well-ordered activities take students to a conversational level in the shortest possible time. A teacher reads a dialogue to the class just once while students listen with their books closed. The class then repeats the lines with their books open. The principles include controlled use of the students' mother-tongue, early introduction of reading and writing, and integration of various skills.
The Bilingual Method differs from GTM in that only the teacher uses L1 to explain meaning. The pupils are given a lot of practice in the drill of sentence patterns, which is not provided in GTM. Critical appreciation notes that it is not an innovative method and is still similar to GTM due to L1 use. It makes high demands on teachers, who need proficiency in both L1 and L2. The scarcity of good teachers with excellent command of spoken and written L2 may be a difficulty in implementing this method.
Topic- 055: The Post-Methods Era
The notion of methods came under criticism in the 1990s, leading to what is called the "post-methods era". A number of limitations implicit in the notion of all-purpose methods were raised, and mainstream language teaching no longer regarded methods as the key factor in accounting for success or failure.
The criticism on methods is that they typically prescribe for teachers what and how to teach, equating good teaching with the correct use of the method. This marginalizes the role of the teacher, and learners are sometimes viewed as passive recipients of the method. The concepts of language learner-centeredness and teacher creativity remain absent. Methods are less flexible and adaptive to learners' needs and interests.
The role of contextual factors is crucial. Methods claim all-purpose solutions, useful in any context and under any circumstance, leading teachers to ignore careful consideration of the context. This context includes the cultural, political, local institutional, and classroom contexts constituted by teachers and learners. This raises issues about assumptions regarding the roles of teachers and learners that are not necessarily culturally universal, and about cultural imperialism.
There is a need for curriculum development processes. Curriculum planners debate over 'teaching method' as part of a broader set of educational planning decisions. The choice of method cannot be determined in isolation from other planning and implementation practices.
There is also a lack of research basis. Approaches and methods are often based on the assumption that the processes of L2 learning are fully understood, but much research does not support the simplistic theories and prescriptions found in some methods. Furthermore, there is a similarity of classroom practices; many of the distinctions used to contrast methods did not exist in the actual practice of classroom activities. Beyond approaches and methods, there is a need for teachers to learn how to use different approaches and methods when they might be useful. Teachers may develop their personal approach by realizing their role in the classroom and the structure of an effective lesson, the nature of effective teaching and learning and the difficulties of learners, and successful learning activities.
⭐ Key Takeaways
You must remember that CLT shifts the goal from grammatical accuracy to communicative competence, prioritizing fluency, authentic materials, and the learner's role as a negotiator. TBLT is a direct evolution of CLT, making the task the core unit of planning and emphasizing meaning-focused, real-world activities. The Silent Way and Bilingual Method are alternative approaches that highlight, respectively, the power of learner discovery with minimal teacher intervention and the strategic use of the mother tongue. Finally, the Post-Methods Era critically argues that no single method is a "magic bullet," and effective teaching requires a context-sensitive, principled, and adaptable approach that empowers both teacher and learner.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What is the main difference between the Communicative Approach (CLT) and earlier language teaching methods?
- According to the lecture, what is a task in Task-based Language Teaching (TBLT), and what are its key characteristics?
- In the Silent Way, what is the rationale for the teacher's silence, and what role does it play in student learning?
- How does the Bilingual Method differ from the Grammar-Translation Method (GTM) in its use of the learner's first language (L1)?
- What are the main criticisms of the concept of "methods" that led to the Post-Methods Era?