π Lecture 37 β PSYCHOLINGUISTICS II
π Overview: This lecture explores how the brain processes language production and comprehension, examining both normal phenomena like speech errors and serious disorders like aphasia. It matters because understanding these processes reveals how linguistic knowledge is organized in the brain and what happens when language functions break down.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers tongue tips and slips including malapropisms and spoonerisms, slips of the ear as clues to auditory processing, aphasia as impairment of language function due to brain damage, three types of aphasia (Broca's, Wernicke's, and conduction), dichotic listening as an experimental technique for measuring hemispheric specialization, and the critical period for language acquisition from birth to puberty.
π Lecture Summary
Topic- 210: Tongue Tips and Slips
The tip of the tongue phenomenon occurs when we feel a word is eluding us that we know but cannot retrieve. Studies show speakers generally have an accurate phonological outline of the word, can get the initial sound correct, and mostly know the number of syllables in the word. This experience mainly occurs with uncommon words and names, suggesting our word-storage system may be partially organized on the basis of some phonological information. Some words in the store are more easily retrieved than others.
We make mistakes in this retrieval process because there are often strong phonological similarities between the target word and what we actually produce. Examples include "fire distinguisher" for "extinguisher" and "transcendental medication" instead of "meditation." Such mistakes are referred to as malapropisms, named after a character who once suggested "we need a few laughs to break up the monogamy" (instead of "monotony").
π Definition β Malapropisms: Speech errors where a word is replaced by another word with similar phonological form but different meaning, often producing humorous results.
π Example: "Make a long shory stort" instead of "make a long story short"; "Use the door to open the key" instead of "use the key to open the door"; "a fifty-pound dog of bag food" instead of "a fifty-pound bag of dog food."
Spoonerisms are errors named after William Spooner, an Anglican clergyman, where initial sounds of words are swapped. Examples include "Black bloxes" for "black boxes," "Noman numeral" for "roman numeral," and "A tup of tea" for "cup of tea." These are treated as errors of articulation and may result from "slips of the brain" as it tries to organize linguistic messages.
π Definition β Spoonerisms: Speech errors involving the transposition of initial sounds between two words in a phrase.
Topic- 211: Slips of the Ear
Many scientists study slips of the ear for clues to how the brain tries to make sense of the auditory signal it receives. For example, the phrase "great ape" may be heard as "gray tape." A similar misunderstanding seems to be behind the child's report that in Sunday school everyone was singing about "a bear called Gladly that was cross-eyed," for "Gladly the cross I'd bear."
In this case, malapropisms (e.g., "transcendental medication") originate as slips of the ear. These humorous examples of slips may give us clues to the normal workings of the human brain as it copes with language. However, some problems with language production and comprehension are the result of much more serious disorders in brain function.
Topic- 212: Aphasia
While all of us experience "slips," some people live with them constantly. Aphasia is defined as an impairment of language function due to localized brain damage that leads to difficulty in understanding and/or producing linguistic forms. The most common cause of aphasia is a stroke; traumatic head injuries from violence or an accident may have similar effects. Those effects can range from mild to severe reduction in the ability to use language. Someone who is aphasic often has interrelated language disorders, and difficulties in understanding can lead to difficulties in production.
π Definition β Aphasia: An impairment of language function due to localized brain damage, causing difficulty in understanding and/or producing linguistic forms.
The different types of aphasia include Broca's aphasia, Wernicke's aphasia, and conduction aphasia.
Topic- 213: Types of Aphasia
The classification of different types of aphasia is usually based on the primary symptoms of someone having difficulties with language.
Broca's Aphasia or Motor Aphasia: This type is characterized by a substantially reduced amount of speech, with distorted articulation and slow, often effortful speech. It is agrammatic, meaning the speech consists entirely of lexical morphemes (e.g., nouns, verbs) with frequent omissions of functional morphemes (e.g., articles, prepositions) and inflections (e.g., plural -s, past tense -ed).
π Example of Broca's aphasia speech: "I eggs and eat and drink coffee breakfast my cheek ... very annoyance ... main is my shoulder ... aching' all round here."
The patient faces difficulty articulating single words. However, comprehension is typically much better than production.
Wernicke's Aphasia or Sensory Aphasia: The person with this type has difficulties in auditory comprehension. They produce very fluent speech but feel difficulty making sense, using very general terms.
π Example of Wernicke's aphasia speech: "I can't talk all of the things I do, and part of the part I can go alright, but I cannot tell from the other people."
The patient finds difficulty in finding the correct word, sometimes referred to as anomia.
Conduction Aphasia: This less common aphasia is associated with damage to the arcuate fasciculus. The person mispronounces words but typically does not have articulation problems. They are fluent but may have disrupted rhythm because of pauses and hesitations. Comprehension of spoken words is normally good.
π Example of conduction aphasia speech: Producing "vaysse" and "fosh" for "base" and "wash."
Language disorders described above are almost always the result of injury to the left hemisphere.
Topic- 214: Dichotic Listening
Dichotic listening is an experimental technique for testing left hemisphere dominance for syllable and word processing. This technique uses the generally established fact that anything experienced on the right-hand side of the body is processed in the left hemisphere, and anything on the left side is processed in the right hemisphere.
π Definition β Dichotic Listening: A technique that tests hemispheric specialization by presenting different auditory stimuli simultaneously to each ear and measuring which ear recognizes information more accurately.
The Right Ear Advantage is observed: the right hemisphere appears to have primary responsibility for processing many non-linguistic incoming signals. In the dichotic listening test, non-verbal sounds (e.g., music, coughs, traffic noises, and birds singing) are recognized more often via the left ear, meaning they are processed faster via the right hemisphere. The left hemisphere specializes in language sounds.
These specializations may have more to do with the type of processing rather than the type of material. Analytic processing β such as recognizing the smaller details of sounds, words, and phrase structures in rapid sequence β is done with the "left brain." Holistic processing is done with the "right brain."
π‘ Why this matters: Dichotic listening provides empirical evidence for brain lateralization of language function, showing that the two hemispheres process information differently β analytically on the left and holistically on the right.
Topic- 215: The Critical Period
The apparent specialization of the left hemisphere for language is usually described in terms of lateral dominance or lateralization (one-sidedness). Since the human child does not emerge from the womb as a fully articulate language-user, the lateralization process begins in early childhood and coincides with the period during which language acquisition takes place.
During childhood, there is a period when the human brain is most ready to receive input and learn a particular language. This is sometimes called the "sensitive period" for language acquisition, but is more generally known as the "critical period." Though some think it may start earlier, the general view is that the critical period for first language acquisition lasts from birth until puberty. If a child does not acquire language during this period, for any reason, then it is almost impossible for him/her to learn language later on.
π Definition β Critical Period: The time from birth to puberty during which the human brain is most ready to receive input and learn a language; if language is not acquired during this period, it becomes almost impossible to learn later.
Many unfortunate well-documented cases provide insight about what happens when the critical period passes without adequate linguistic input.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts from this lecture are: (1) speech errors like malapropisms and spoonerisms reveal how the brain organizes linguistic knowledge phonologically, (2) aphasia represents language impairment from localized brain damage with three main types β Broca's (agrammatic, effortful speech with better comprehension), Wernicke's (fluent but meaningless speech with poor comprehension), and conduction (mispronunciation with good comprehension), (3) dichotic listening demonstrates left hemisphere dominance for language processing through the right ear advantage and shows the left brain handles analytic processing while the right brain handles holistic processing, (4) the critical period for language acquisition extends from birth to puberty, after which successful language learning becomes nearly impossible, and (5) language disorders almost always result from injury to the left hemisphere.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the "tip of the tongue phenomenon" and what does it reveal about how words are stored in the brain?
- What are the three main types of aphasia and what distinguishes the speech patterns of each type?
- How does the dichotic listening test demonstrate left hemisphere dominance for language?
- What is the critical period for language acquisition and what happens if a child does not receive adequate linguistic input during this time?
- What is the difference between malapropisms and spoonerisms, and what do these speech errors suggest about brain processing?
π Lecture 38 β Sociolinguistics
π Overview: This lecture introduces sociolinguistics, the study of how language varies according to social and situational factors. It covers key concepts such as standard and vernacular languages, accents and dialects, pidgins and creoles, diglossia, and the relationship between language and culture. Understanding these topics is essential for recognizing how social identities and contexts shape linguistic choices.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with an introduction to sociolinguistics, defining it and outlining its social variables. It then discusses the standard language and vernacular language as varieties of a language. Next, it covers the concepts of accent and dialect within dialectology, followed by an explanation of pidgin and creole languages. The lecture proceeds to diglossia and polyglossia, and concludes with the relationship between language and culture.
π Lecture Summary
Topic- 216: Introduction
The way people talk depends on their personal and social backgrounds as well as the specifics of a speech situation. This study of variation in speech is called sociolinguistics, which is the descriptive study of the effects of different aspects of society on language use. Social variables vital to this discipline include ethnicity, religion, status, gender, level of education, and age. Sociolinguistics overlaps with pragmatics and is closely related to linguistic anthropology, but differs from the sociology of language, which focuses on language's effect on society. As language usage varies from place to place and among social classes, these variations, called sociolects, are studied in sociolinguistics.
Topic- 217: The Standard Language and Vernacular Language
Varieties of Language
A standard language is a variety used by governments, media, schools, and for international communication. Examples include British English, North American English, Australian English, and Indian English.
Standard Variety
It is an idealized variety with no specific region. It is associated with administrative, commercial, and educational centers and is used in print and mass media. It is more easily described in terms of written language (vocabulary, spelling, grammar) than spoken language.
Vernacular Language
A vernacular language is the native language or native dialect (usually colloquial) of a specific population, distinct from a literary, national, or standard variety, or a lingua franca. It is spoken by the ordinary people of a country or region.
Topic- 218: Accent and Dialect (Dialectology)
Whether we speak a standard variety or not, we all have certain accents. It is a myth that some speakers have accents while others do not.
π Definition β Accent: A manner of pronunciation peculiar to a particular individual, location, or nation. It describes aspects of pronunciation that identify where a speaker is from, regionally or socially.
π Definition β Dialect: Includes features of grammar and vocabulary as well as aspects of pronunciation. π Example: The Scottish English sentence "Ye dinnae ken whit yer haverinβ aboot" has grammatical differences (dinnae for "don't"), vocabulary differences (ken for "know", haverin' for "talking"), and pronunciation differences (whit for "what", aboot for "about").
Differences in vocabulary are often easily recognized, but dialect variations in grammatical constructions are less frequently documented. One criterion in dialectology is distinguishing between two dialects of the same language and two different languages.
Topic- 219: Pidgin and Creole
A pidgin is a simplified speech used for communication between people with different languages, developed for a practical purpose like trading. It will be described as an 'English pidgin' if English is the lexifier language, the main source of words. No same pronunciation or meaning as in the source is used.
π Example: In Tok Pisin, the word gras originates from English 'grass' but means 'hair'. It appears in mausgras ('moustache') and gras bilong fes ('beard').
Pidgins are characterized by an absence of complex grammatical morphology and a limited vocabulary. Inflectional suffixes like -s and -'s are rare, and functional morphemes often take their place. π Example: 'two books' becomes tu buk, 'the girl's place' becomes di gyal place, and 'your book' becomes buk bilong yu.
When a pidgin develops beyond a trade or contact language and becomes the first language of a social community, it is described as a creole. A creole initially develops as the first language of children growing up in a pidgin-using community and becomes more complex as it serves more communicative purposes. π Example: Tok Pisin is now a creole. Hawaii Creole English is also a creole, though locally called 'Pidgin'. French creole is used in Haiti, and English creoles are used in Jamaica and Sierra Leone.
Topic- 220: Diglossia and Polyglossia
Diglossia is a situation in which two distinct varieties of a language are spoken within the same speech community. One is a 'high' or special variety learned in school and used for important matters, while the other is a 'low' variety used for everyday conversation.
π Example: In Arabic-speaking countries, Classical Arabic is the high variety, used in formal lectures and religious discussions, while local versions like Egyptian Arabic are the low variety.
Each variety has its own fixed functions. Using the wrong variety in the wrong situation would be socially inappropriate.
Polydiglossia refers to the coexistence of two or more languages or distinct varieties of the same language within a speech community. It also refers to a person's ability to communicate in more than two languages. π Example: In the Singapore Chinese speaking community, Mandarin is used for work, while Cantonese and Hokkien are used for daily conversation among family.
Topic- 221: Language and Culture
The study of language and culture originates in the work of anthropologists. Culture is defined as 'shared beliefs, values and behaviours of a social group' (Byram, 2008). Language is 'socially acquired knowledge' and is used not just as a tool for information exchange but as a symbolic system with the power to create and shape symbolic realities (Kramsch, 2002).
Our first language is initially acquired without conscious awareness. The particular language we learn provides us with a ready-made system for categorising the world. With the words we acquire, we learn to recognise relevant category distinctions in our social world.
π Example: In native cultures of the Pacific, there were no horses, so no words for them. We must have a conceptual system that includes people, things, and ideas as distinct categories like 'dog or horse', 'rain or snow', 'father or uncle'.
According to Kramsch, language expresses, embodies, and symbolizes cultural reality.
β Key Takeaways
Sociolinguistics studies how language varies based on social factors like status, gender, and ethnicity, distinguishing between standard languages used in official contexts and vernaculars used informally. Every speaker has an accent, and dialects encompass differences in pronunciation, vocabulary, and grammar, which are the focus of dialectology. Pidgins are simplified contact languages that can evolve into creoles when they become a community's first language, gaining complexity. Diglossia describes a community using two distinct varieties of the same language for different functions, while polyglossia involves more than two languages or varieties. Finally, language is deeply intertwined with culture, both expressing and shaping our shared values, identities, and conceptual systems.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the key social variables studied in sociolinguistics?
- How does a dialect differ from an accent in linguistic terms?
- What is the fundamental difference between a pidgin and a creole language?
- Explain the concept of diglossia and give an example of a high variety and a low variety.
- According to the lecture, how does language relate to culture and our categorization of the world?
π Lecture 39 β First Language Acquisition I
π Overview: This lecture explores the remarkable process by which children acquire their first language, focusing on the developmental stages from cooing to telegraphic speech. It emphasizes that language acquisition occurs rapidly without overt instruction, driven by an innate human capacity, but also requires physical capability and social interaction opportunities. Understanding these stages is crucial for linguistics, education, and child development.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the stages of first language acquisition including cooing and babbling stages (with nasal sounds), the one-word stage (holophrastic speech), the two-word stage, telegraphic speech, and a summary discussion on social-class differences in vocabulary growth based on Hart and Risley's research. Each stage details the typical age range, phonological and lexical developments, and the increasing complexity of child utterances.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-222: Acquisition and Stages of Acquisition
The acquisition of first language is remarkable for its speed. A child becomes a sophisticated language user before starting school. Learning occurs without overt instruction, regardless of great differences in circumstances. There is an innate predisposition in the human infant to acquire languageβa special capacity for language each newborn child is endowed with. The inborn language capacity alone is not enough; the child must be physically capable of sending and receiving sound signals, and crucially, must have the opportunity to interact with others via language.
Topic-223: Cooing and Babbling
The earliest use of speech-like sounds is described as cooing, which involves sequences of vowel-like sounds, particularly high vowels similar to [i] and [u]. By four months, the child brings the back of the tongue into contact with the back of the palate, allowing velar consonants [k] and [Ι‘] to be produced. Speech perception studies show that by five months old, babies can already hear the difference between vowels [i] and [a] and discriminate between syllables like [ba] and [Ι‘a].
Between six and eight months, the child produces a number of different vowels and consonants, as well as combinations such as ba-ba-ba and ga-ga-ga. In the later babbling stage, around nine to ten months, recognizable intonation patterns appear, and variation in combinations such as ba-ba-da-da can be observed.
Common nasal sounds and syllable sequences such as ma-ma-ma and da-da-da are interpreted by parents as versions of βmamaβ and βdadaβ and repeated back to the child. This βparalanguageβ use of sound provides the child with experience of the social role of speech, as adults react to babbling as if it is the child's contribution to social interaction.
Topic-224: The One-Word Stage
Between twelve and eighteen months, the child produces a variety of recognizable single-unit utterances. This stage is characterized by speech in which single terms are uttered for everyday objects like βCookieβ, βCatβ, βCupβ, βSpoonβ (usually pronounced [pun]). Other forms such as [ΚsΓ¦] (a version of βWhatβs thatβ) show that the label βone-wordβ may be misleading; the term βsingle-unitβ would be more accurate.
Holophrastic utterances occur during this stage, where a single form functions as a phrase or sentence. These utterances seem to be used to name objects but may also be produced in circumstances suggesting the child is already extending their use. For example, an empty bed may elicit the name of a sister who normally sleeps in the bed, even in the absence of the person named. The child can refer to "Karen" and "bed" but is not yet ready to put the forms together.
π Definition β Holophrastic: A single form that functions as a phrase or sentence, describing an utterance that could be analyzed as a word, a phrase, or a sentence.
Topic-225: The Two-Word Stage
This stage begins around eighteen to twenty months, when the child's vocabulary moves beyond fifty words. By two years old, the child starts uttering a variety of combinations, similar to: "Baby chair", "mommy eat", "cat bad". The adult interpretation of such combinations is very much tied to the context of their utterance. For example, βBaby chairβ could express possession ("This is baby's chair"), a request ("Put baby in chair"), or a statement ("Baby is in the chair").
The significant functional consequence is that the adult behaves as if communication is taking place. The child not only produces speech but also receives feedback confirming the utterance worked as a contribution to interaction. By age two, the child may produce 200 or 300 distinct βwordsβ and understand five times as many.
Topic-226: Telegraphic Speech
Between two and two-and-a-half years old, the child starts a large number of utterances classified as βmultiple-wordβ speech. The salient feature is the variation in word forms that begins to appear. This stage is characterized by strings of words (lexical morphemes) in phrases or sentences such as:
- This shoe all wet
- Cat drink milk
- Daddy go bye-bye
- Sentence building capacity
- Can get the word order correct
While this telegraphic speech is being produced, grammatical inflections begin to appear, along with word forms and simple prepositions (in, on). By age two-and-a-half, the child's vocabulary expands rapidly and the child initiates more talk. By three, vocabulary grows to hundreds of words and pronunciation becomes closer to adult language forms.
π Definition β Telegraphic Speech: Strings of words (lexical morphemes) in phrases or sentences characterized by correct word order but lacking grammatical inflections and function words, similar to a telegram format.
Topic-227: Summary/Discussion
Betty Hart and Todd Risley's well-known studies suggest social-class differences in language acquisition. By age 3, children from privileged families have heard 30 million more words than children from underprivileged families. Longitudinal data on 42 families showed enormous differences in vocabulary growth rates. Children turned out to be like their parents in stature, activity level, vocabulary resources, and language interaction styles. However, other researchers note that 42 is not a very large sample, and many other questions remain. This work suggests concern about possible lasting effects of cultural differences in children's linguistic environment and socioeconomic status differences in language learning.
π‘ Why this matters: The 30-million-word gap highlights how early linguistic environment can create significant disparities in vocabulary development, potentially affecting academic success and cognitive development across socioeconomic groups.
β Key Takeaways
Students must remember the sequential stages of first language acquisition: cooing (vowel-like sounds, 4 months), babbling (consonant-vowel combinations, 6-10 months), one-word/holophrastic stage (12-18 months), two-word stage (18-20 months), and telegraphic speech (2-2.5 years). The innate language capacity alone is insufficientβphysical capability to send/receive sound signals and crucially, social interaction opportunities are required. Key developmental milestones include the appearance of velar consonants at 4 months, the production of 200-300 words by age 2, and the rapid vocabulary expansion to hundreds of words by age 3. Hart and Risley's finding that children from privileged families hear 30 million more words by age 3 than underprivileged children is critical for understanding social-class differences in language acquisition.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five main stages of first language acquisition and their approximate age ranges?
- What is the difference between "cooing" and "babbling" in terms of sound production?
- What does "holophrastic" mean, and why is the term "single-unit" considered more accurate than "one-word"?
- How does adult interpretation and feedback function during the two-word stage?
- What is the "30-million-word gap" according to Hart and Risley, and what factors might it reflect?
π Lecture 40 β First Language Acquisition II
π Overview: This lecture continues exploring how children acquire their first language, focusing on the active construction process rather than passive imitation. It examines the developmental stages of morphology, syntax, questions, and negatives, along with semantic development and overextension patterns in children's speech.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers six main topics: the acquisition process where children actively construct language rather than imitate; developing morphology including inflectional morphemes and overgeneralization; developing syntax with three identifiable stages; forming questions with Wh-forms and intonation strategies; forming negatives from simple "no/not" placement to complex auxiliary forms; and developing semantics including overextension and hyponymy acquisition patterns.
π Lecture Summary
Topic- 228: The Acquisition Process
Children actively construct language from what is said to them, rather than simply imitating adult speech. A child's linguistic production involves trying out constructions and testing whether they work. Adults do not produce many expressions that appear in children's speech, as shown by examples like "My teacher holded the baby rabbits" and "I'm going home so you won't Woodstock me." The actual use of sound and word combinations, either in interaction or wordplay, is crucial to the acquisition process.
Topic- 229: Developing Morphology
By two-and-a-half years old, children move beyond telegraphic speech and incorporate inflectional morphemes. First, the -ing form appears in expressions like "cat sitting" and "mommy reading book." Second, the -s form appears for plurals like "boys" and "cats."
The acquisition of the plural marker is accompanied by overgeneralization. Children use -s to form plurals and say "foots" and "mans." They also overgeneralize the pronunciation of the plural morpheme used in "houses" (ending in [-Ιz]), producing "boyses" or "footses." Alongside overgeneralization, irregular plurals like "men" appear, then children may produce "mens" or "two feetses."
π Overgeneralization: The application of a regular grammatical rule to irregular forms, producing non-standard forms like "goed" instead of "went."
The possessive inflection -'s appears after the plural -s, in expressions like "girl's dog" and "Mummy's book." Different forms of the verb "to be" (are, was) begin to be used. The -ed inflection for regular past tense appears, after which irregular past-tense forms like "went" may disappear temporarily, replaced by "goed" and "comed." Oddities like "walked" and "wented" persist until after age four. The regular -s marker on third person singular present-tense verbs appears first with full verbs ("comes," "looks") then with auxiliaries ("does," "has").
Great variability is observed at this stage. Individual children may produce correct forms one day and odd forms the next. The child is working out how to use the linguistic system while focusing on communication and interaction rather than correctness.
Topic- 230: Developing Syntax
Evidence against imitation as the basis of syntactic development comes from studies where children, asked to repeat sentences, would produce their own grammatical forms. For example, hearing "The owl who eats candy runs fast," a child might say "Owl eat candy and he run fast."
The development of syntax in questions and negatives shows three identifiable stages with overlapping age ranges:
- Stage 1: between 18 and 26 months
- Stage 2: between 22 and 30 months
- Stage 3: between 24 and 40 months
The overlap reflects different rates of development among children.
Topic- 231: Forming Questions
Stage 1: Children use two procedures for forming questions β add a Wh-form (Where, Who) to the beginning, or utter the expression with a rising intonation. Examples: "Where kitty?", "Doggie?", "Where horse go?", "Sit chair?"
Stage 2: More complex expressions appear, but the rising intonation strategy continues. More Wh-forms come into use. Examples: "What book name?", "You want eat?", "Why you smiling?", "See my doggie?"
Stage 3: The required movement of the auxiliary in English questions appears (e.g., "I can have..." β "Can I have...?"). However, this does not automatically spread to all Wh-question types. Some children beginning school in their fifth or sixth year may still form Wh-questions without inversion, especially with negatives (e.g., "Why kitty can't...?" instead of "Why can't kitty...?"). Continuing trouble with verb morphology also appears (e.g., "Did I caught...?" instead of "Did I catch...?"). Examples of Stage 3 questions: "Can I have a piece?", "Will you help me?", "What did you do?"
π Auxiliary inversion in questions: The grammatical rule where the auxiliary verb moves before the subject, as in "Can I have..." from "I can have..."
Topic- 232: Forming Negatives
Stage 1: Children use a simple strategy of putting No or Not at the beginning of the expression. Examples: "no mitten," "not a teddy bear," "no fall," "no sit there."
Stage 2: Additional negative forms appear β don't and can't, along with no and not, increasingly used in front of the verb rather than at the beginning. Examples: "He no bite you," "I don't want it," "That not touch," "You can't dance."
Stage 3: Incorporation of other auxiliary forms like didn't and won't, while Stage 1 forms disappear. The negative form isn't is a very late acquisition, so Stage 2 forms with "not" instead of "isn't" continue. Examples: "I didn't caught it," "He not taking it," "She won't let go," "This not ice cream."
A famous example (McNeill, 1966) shows the futility of overt adult correction:
- CHILD: "Nobody don't like me"
- MOTHER: "No, say 'nobody likes me.'"
- CHILD: "Nobody don't like me." (Eight repetitions)
- CHILD: "Oh! Nobody don't likes me."
Topic- 233: Developing Semantics
During the holophrastic stage, children use limited vocabulary to refer to many unrelated objects. The process of overextension occurs when children extend a word's meaning based on similarities of shape, sound, size, movement, and texture.
π Overextension: The process where a child extends the meaning of a word beyond its adult meaning to include objects that share some feature with the original referent.
Examples of overextension: "bow-wow" initially used for a dog, then extended to a fur piece with glass eyes, cufflinks, and a bath thermometer (meaning 'object with shiny bits'). "Ball" is extended to all round objects like lampshades, doorknobs, and the moon. "Tick tock" used for a watch, then extended to a bathroom scale with a round dial. "Fly" used for the insect, then for specks of dirt and crumbs. "Sizo" first used for scissors, then extended to all metal objects.
π‘ Why this matters: Semantic development follows a pattern of overextension initially, then gradual narrowing as more words are learned. However, overextension in production doesn't necessarily occur in comprehension β a two-year-old might use "apple" for round objects but correctly pick out an apple from a set of round objects.
In terms of hyponymy, children almost always use the middle-level term (e.g., "dog") rather than the most general term ("animal") or most specific ("poodle"). Hyponymous relations are acquired fairly late (after age five). For example, kindergarten children pointed to the same heavily laden apple tree when asked which tree has more apples AND which has less apples, disregarding the difference between "more" and "less." Distinctions between "before/after" and "buy/sell" are also later acquisitions.
By age five, the child has completed the greater part of the basic language acquisition process. This position is considered favorable for starting second language learning, yet most people don't start until much later, raising the question: if first language acquisition was straightforward and automatic, why is second language learning so difficult?
β Key Takeaways
Children actively construct language through trial and error, not passive imitation β this is proven by overgeneralization errors like "goed," "foots," and "nobody don't likes me" that adults never produce. Morphological development follows a predictable sequence: -ing first, then plural -s with overgeneralization, possessive -'s, past tense -ed with temporary loss of irregular forms, and third person -s. Syntax develops through three identifiable stages for both questions and negatives, with overlapping age ranges reflecting individual variation. Semantic development begins with overextension based on physical similarities, gradually narrowing through increased vocabulary, while hyponymous relations and subtle distinctions (more/less, before/after) are acquired after age five. By age five, basic first language acquisition is essentially complete, setting the stage for potential second language learning.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
-
What evidence from children's speech demonstrates that language acquisition is not simply imitation of adult speech?
-
Describe the order in which inflectional morphemes appear in children's speech development, and explain the phenomenon of overgeneralization using examples.
-
What are the three stages of question formation in children, and what specific linguistic changes occur at each stage?
-
How do children form negatives across the three developmental stages, and what does the famous "Nobody don't like me" exchange reveal about adult correction?
-
What is overextension in semantic development, and what physical features typically trigger overextended word meanings? Why might overextension appear in production but not comprehension?
π Lecture 41 β Second Language Acquisition/Learning
π Overview: This lecture explores the distinction between second language acquisition and learning, examining why acquiring a second language later in life is more challenging than acquiring a first language. It covers barriers to acquisition, different teaching methods, learner-focused approaches, and the components of communicative competence, providing a comprehensive understanding of how individuals develop proficiency in a second language.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining second language learning and distinguishing it from first language acquisition, then examines acquisition barriers including the critical period hypothesis and affective factors. It surveys various teaching methods such as the Grammar-Translation Method, Audio-Lingual Method, and Communicative Approaches. The focus then shifts to the learner, discussing error analysis, transfer, interlanguage, and motivation. Finally, the lecture explores the components of communicative competence: grammatical, sociolinguistic, and strategic competence.
π Lecture Summary
Topic- 234: Second Language Acquisition and Learning
A distinction is made between second language learning in a 'foreign language' setting versus a 'second language' setting, including English as a Foreign Language (EFL) and English as a Second Language (ESL). The term second language learning is used generally to describe both situations.
The term acquisition refers to the gradual development of ability in a language by using it naturally in communicative situations, whereas learning is a more conscious process of accumulating knowledge of features like vocabulary and grammar, typically in an institutional setting. Individuals whose L2 exposure is primarily a learning type of experience tend not to develop the same kind of general proficiency as those who have had more of an acquisition type of experience.
π Definition β Acquisition: the gradual development of ability in a language by using it naturally in communicative situations with others who know the language π Definition β Learning: a more conscious process of accumulating knowledge of the features, such as vocabulary and grammar, of a language, typically in an institutional setting π Example: Mathematics is learned, not acquired.
Topic- 235: Acquisition Barriers
The experience with an L2 is fundamentally different from that of L1 experience. Learners usually encounter the L2 during their teenage or adult years in a few hours each week, rather than via constant interaction. Insufficient time, focus, and incentive undermine many L2 learning attempts. Sounding like a native speaker is difficult, and very few adults seem to reach native-like proficiency even in ideal acquisition situations. Some features of an L2, such as vocabulary and grammar, are easier to learn than others such as pronunciation.
This observation is taken as evidence that, after the critical period for language acquisition has passed (around puberty), it becomes very difficult to acquire another language fully. The optimum age for learning is ten to sixteen when the flexibility of our inherent capacity for language has not been completely lost.
π Definition β Critical Period: the period after which it becomes very difficult to acquire another language fully, around the time of puberty π Example: Joseph Conrad wrote many English novels but spoke English with his Polish accent.
Topic- 236: Affective Factors
Affective factors are emotional reactions that can create a barrier to acquisition. Teenagers are typically more self-conscious than younger children. If self-consciousness is accompanied by a lack of empathy with the other culture, it may strongly inhibit the learning process. Negative feelings caused by dull textbooks, unpleasant classroom surroundings, or an exhausting schedule can also create barriers. If the learner is stressed, uncomfortable, self-conscious, or unmotivated, they are unlikely to learn very much. Children seem to be less constrained by affective factors.
π Definition β Affective Factors: emotional reactions such as self-consciousness, lack of empathy, stress, or discomfort that can create a barrier to acquisition π‘ Why this matters: Affective factors explain why motivation and emotional comfort are crucial for successful L2 learning, even when cognitive abilities are intact.
Topic- 237: Focus on Method
Despite barriers, various educational approaches have been developed. Caxton (1483) compiled the first exercise material for L2 learners in a phrase-book format.
The GrammarβTranslation Method treats L2 learning like any academic subject, using vocabulary lists and grammar rules with emphasis on memorization and written language rather than spoken language. It has its roots in the traditional teaching of Latin.
The Audio-Lingual Method emphasizes the spoken language and became popular in the mid-twentieth century. It involves systematic presentation of structures from simple to complex, with drills for repetition. The basic belief was that fluent language use is essentially a set of "habits" that can be developed with practice.
Communicative Approaches are more recent revisions that partially reacted against the artificiality of pattern practice. They emphasize the functions of language rather than the forms, based on the belief that consciously learning grammar rules will not necessarily result in ability to use the language. These approaches have coincided with materials for specific purposes like 'English for medical personnel'.
π Definition β GrammarβTranslation Method: traditional approach treating L2 learning as an academic subject with vocabulary lists, grammar rules, and emphasis on written language and memorization π Definition β Audio-Lingual Method: method emphasizing spoken language with systematic presentation of structures from simple to complex and repetitive drills π Definition β Communicative Approaches: approaches emphasizing language functions rather than forms, focusing on creating communicative experiences for L2 learners
Topic- 238: Focus on the Learner
The most fundamental change in L2 learning is the focus on the learner, shifting from concern with teacher, textbook, and method to interest in the learner and the acquisition process. One radical feature is the toleration of "errors" produced by students. Traditionally viewed negatively, errors are now seen as normal indications of the natural L2 acquisition process in action. An "error" is not something that hinders progress but a clue to active learning progress.
Transfer (or 'Cross Linguistic Influence') means using sounds, expressions, or structures from the L1 when performing in the L2. Positive transfer occurs when L1 and L2 have similar features (e.g., marking plural on nouns), allowing learners to benefit from L1 knowledge. Negative transfer (or 'interference') occurs when transferring an L1 feature different from the L2 (e.g., putting adjective after the noun), which may make the L2 expression difficult to understand. Negative transfer is more common in early stages of L2 learning.
Interlanguage refers to the language produced by L2 learners containing 'errors' that seem to have no connection to the forms of either L1 or L2.
Motivation is important for successful L2 learning. Instrumental motivation means learning the L2 to achieve some other goal (e.g., completing a graduation requirement). Integrative motivation means learning the L2 for social purposes, to take part in the social life of a community and become an accepted member.
π Definition β Transfer (Cross Linguistic Influence): using sounds, expressions, or structures from the L1 when performing in the L2 π Definition β Positive Transfer: transfer that occurs when L1 and L2 have similar features, benefiting the learner π Definition β Negative Transfer (Interference): transfer that occurs when an L1 feature is different from the L2, making expression difficult to understand π Definition β Interlanguage: the language produced by L2 learners containing 'errors' with no connection to either L1 or L2 forms π Definition β Instrumental Motivation: motivation to learn the L2 to achieve some other goal π Definition β Integrative Motivation: motivation to learn the L2 for social purposes and to become an accepted member of the community π Example of transfer: A Spanish speaker producing 'take it from the side inferior' β using the Spanish adjective inferior (=lower) and placing it after the noun. π Example of interlanguage: 'She name is Maria' β containing an error not connected to L1 or L2. π Example of overgeneralization: A Spanish L1 speaker producing 'in the room there are three womens' as an indication of natural acquisition.
Topic- 239: Communicative Competence
Communicative competence is the general ability to use language accurately, appropriately, and flexibly. It has three components. Grammatical competence involves the accurate use of words and structures. Sociolinguistic competence is the ability to use appropriate language according to the social context, requiring familiarity with the cultural context of the L2. Strategic competence is the ability to organize a message effectively and to compensate for any difficulties via strategies. In L2 use, learners inevitably experience gaps between communicative intent and ability to express that intent. Some may stop talking, while others use communication strategies. This flexibility in L2 use is a key element in communicative success.
π Definition β Communicative Competence: the general ability to use language accurately, appropriately, and flexibly π Definition β Grammatical Competence: the accurate use of words and structures π Definition β Sociolinguistic Competence: the ability to use appropriate language according to the social context π Definition β Strategic Competence: the ability to organize a message effectively and compensate for difficulties via strategies π Example of sociolinguistic competence: Knowing when to say 'Can I have some water?' versus 'Give me some water.' π Example of strategic competence: A Dutch speaker saying 'the things that horses wear under their feet, the iron things' instead of the unknown English word 'horseshoe'.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical distinction in this lecture is between acquisition (natural, gradual development through communicative use) and learning (conscious accumulation of knowledge about language), with acquisition leading to greater proficiency. The lecture emphasizes that age-related barriers exist due to the critical period hypothesis, with puberty marking a point after which full native-like proficiency becomes very difficult, though the optimum learning age is ten to sixteen. Affective factors such as self-consciousness, stress, and lack of motivation can create significant barriers to L2 acquisition regardless of cognitive abilities. The evolution of teaching methods from Grammar-Translation to Audio-Lingual to Communicative Approaches reflects a shift from grammar-focused to function-focused instruction. Finally, communicative competence comprises three essential componentsβgrammatical, sociolinguistic, and strategic competenceβall of which are necessary for successful L2 communication.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between acquisition and learning in the context of second language development?
- What is the critical period hypothesis, and what age range is considered optimum for L2 learning?
- What are affective factors, and how do they create barriers to second language acquisition?
- Compare the Grammar-Translation Method, Audio-Lingual Method, and Communicative Approaches in terms of their focus and underlying beliefs.
- What are the three components of communicative competence, and provide an example of each.