📘 Lecture 11 — Reading: Understanding Reading
📖 Overview: This lecture explores how to improve reading comprehension by understanding the writer’s techniques and methods. It emphasizes that reading is the most important academic skill and that poor reading can be improved through practice and awareness of rhetorical principles. The lecture also introduces comprehension approaches and the use of listing markers to understand text organization.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers vocalization as a cause of slow reading, the importance of understanding rhetoric (Why, What, How questions), the writer’s purpose (inform, persuade, entertain), attitude and tone, patterns of organization (time order, comparison/contrast, cause/effect), the role of transitions, function words vs. content words, comprehension approaches for imaginative and practical passages, seven kinds of comprehension questions, and the use of listing markers for enumeration and sequential relationships.
📝 Lecture Summary
Reading: Understanding Reading
Reading is the most important skill for academic success. Poor reading can be improved through practice. There is a relationship between reading speed and reading comprehension; reading slowly does not necessarily improve comprehension—it may actually reduce it. One cause of slow reading is vocalization—the forming of sounds of each word even without saying them aloud. Vocalization is a sign of poor reading; students should learn to read with their eyes and mind, not their lips, i.e., read silently.
Learning to recognize and understand the principles and methods of writing—rhetoric—helps improve reading. Successful readers must understand why a piece was written (Why?), what it says overall and in major sub-points (What?), and how the author organized the material (How?).
🔑 Definition — Vocalization: the forming of the sounds of each word while reading, even if not said aloud; a sign of poor reading.
The Writer’s Purpose, Attitude, and Tone
To answer Why?, remember the author has a reason for writing and works from a personal point of view. The skilled reader must recognize the writer’s PURPOSE, along with ATTITUDE and TONE—the expression of the writer’s feelings.
There are 3 common purposes of communication: to inform (gives facts about the topic), to persuade (aims to convince the reader to agree with the writer’s point of view), and to entertain (appeals to senses and imagination to amuse and delight).
ATTITUDE is the author’s approach, position, or stance toward his material, audience, and situation. For example, the writer can argue coolly and logically or angrily and heatedly; he can approach readers as friends, enemies, equals, or talk down from authority.
TONE is the voice in which the writer speaks—the language, words, and phrases chosen. Through tone, we sense wit, humor, sadness, indignation, friendliness, etc. Understanding tone is essential for comprehension; it may be evident from the first line or only after reading the entire piece.
Authors may combine different types of writing—narrate, describe, explain (exposition), or argue—in one piece. Description and narration often serve exposition or argument. Finding the underlying purpose and technique makes a successful reader.
💡 Why this matters: Recognizing purpose, attitude, and tone allows you to evaluate what you read critically and understand the writer’s intent beyond surface meaning.
The Writer’s Thesis and Supporting Details
The WHAT question leads to the author’s basic statement—his thesis statement about his subject. The thesis also indicates what the writer is NOT saying and the limitations set. A good reader reads within those boundaries.
Authors present supporting details in organized patterns. Common patterns of organization include: time order/sequences, list of items, comparison or contrast, cause and effect, definition and example. These patterns complete the writer’s main thought.
🔑 Definition — Thesis statement: the author’s basic statement about his subject that indicates what the writer is saying and the limitations he has set.
The HOW Question: Transitions and Key Words
The HOW question concerns the techniques and devices of organization. Recognition of main subdivisions, paragraph topic sentences, and transitions is key. Topic sentences are core statements that are developed with concrete details.
Transitions convey relationships between parts of a text. They are movement from or connection between one part and the next. They may be function words (small words like prepositions, conjunctions, modifiers: in, at, and, but) that establish emphasis and relationships) or content words (words central to the subject’s development).
Content words are often fully defined or assumed known by the author. Readers must understand these key words and notice how the author modifies them using synonyms (words with similar meaning) or antonyms (words in contrast).
🔑 Definition — Transitions: words and phrases that convey relationships between parts of a text, showing movement or connection between one part and the next. 🔑 Definition — Function words: small words such as prepositions, conjunctions, and modifiers (in, at, and, but) that establish emphasis and relationships. 🔑 Definition — Content words: words central to the development of the subject of a piece of writing.
An Approach to Comprehension
Comprehension exercises test understanding. Two varieties of reading materials exist: imaginative (creative writing, novel/short story extracts, poems) and practical (reports, accounts, opinions, instructions, statistics). For imaginative passages, readers must understand subtleties and implications and comment on style and word choice. For practical passages, the emphasis is on understanding the line of argument or logical step-by-step facts; readers may need to summarize points.
Kinds of Comprehension Questions
Seven kinds of questions are likely:
- Meaning: Explain the meaning of a word or phrase as used in the passage (e.g., “execute” can mean “carry into effect” not “inflict capital punishment”).
- Facts: Answer questions about what the passage actually says.
- Reading between the lines: Understand implied emotions, attitudes, and points of view (e.g., “terrorists” vs. “freedom-fighters” reflect writer’s attitude).
- Metaphorical language: Explain what a writer means by a comparison or metaphor (e.g., “bugled” suggests high-pitched, strident, triumphant sounds).
- Style: Comment on how the writer writes—variety of sentences, words chosen, literary devices—and the appropriateness and effectiveness of style to content.
- Summary: Pick out facts relevant to a particular point from the passage.
- Opinions: Comment on views expressed, say if they are convincing, give personal views, or expand on an area of experience from personal point of view.
💡 Why this matters: Understanding these question types prepares you for exams and develops critical reading skills beyond surface comprehension.
Listing Markers
When reading, recognizing how sentences combine to present information is important. Information may be linked by connective words or markers. Making a list, enumerating, and giving instructions indicate a cataloguing of what is being said. Most enumerations belong to clearly defined sets.
LISTING MARKERS include:
- 1, 2, 3, etc.
- One, two, three, etc.
- First(ly), second(ly), third(ly)
- In the first/second/third place
- Another, next, then
- Furthermore, afterwards, moreover
- Lastly/finally
- To begin/start with, and to conclude
- First and foremost, First and most important(ly), Above all (mark beginning of descending order)
- Last but not least (marks end of ascending order)
The –ly forms (firstly, secondly, etc.) are usually used when listing.
📐 Formula: Listing Markers = Words that show order/sequence in a list or enumeration → They help readers follow the cataloguing of information.
📌 Sample Paragraph: “More and more police departments have now sophisticated devices to help control the increasing crime rate. Some of these are: Firstly, a computer terminal inside a police vehicle to answer an officer’s questions; secondly, a computer-controlled display unit for displaying fingerprints; and thirdly, educational systems for police officers... First and foremost, it has data on stolen items... Second, it has information on missing persons... Last but not least, it contains information on political extremist groups...” — The markers show sequence and importance of items.
📌 Exercise: In the paragraph “What Is a Computer?”, listing marks include: First, Second, Third, and numbered items 1, 2, 3.
📌 Exercise Example: Complete paragraph with listing markers: “Any businessman thinking of buying a computer system should firstly admit he knows very little about computers... Secondly, he must realize that the computer salesman doesn’t know how his business works. Thirdly, that he should get that outside advice is a must... Next, he should try to see systems similar to ones under consideration... he should then find out what would be involved in upgrading... Last but not least, the perspective buyer should demand that every detail be covered in writing.”
⭐ Key Takeaways
A student must remember that reading comprehension improves by understanding the writer’s three key questions: Why (purpose, attitude, tone), What (thesis statement and supporting details), and How (organization patterns and transitions). Slow reading caused by vocalization hinders comprehension—read silently with eyes and mind. The writer’s purpose can be to inform, persuade, or entertain, and recognizing tone and attitude is crucial for deep understanding. Finally, listing markers (firstly, secondly, next, finally, etc.) are vital for following the order and sequence of information in any text; practicing with these will improve both reading and exam performance.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What is vocalization and why is it considered a sign of poor reading?
- Name the three common purposes of communication for a writer and briefly explain each.
- What is the difference between the writer’s attitude and the writer’s tone? Give an example of how tone might be conveyed.
- What are the seven kinds of comprehension questions mentioned in the lecture? List them.
- What are listing markers? Provide three examples of listing markers and explain what they indicate in a text.
📘 Lecture 12 — Reading: Making Inferences
📖 Overview: This lecture introduces the critical reading skill of making inferences—drawing conclusions or understanding ideas that are not directly stated in a text. It explains how readers use clues, experience, and logic to "read between the lines," a higher-level skill essential for both non-fiction and creative writing, and provides extensive practice examples.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining inference and connecting it to everyday life and reading. It then walks through specific inference exercises, including analyzing pictures and short sentences. It provides practice with passages on super-automation and a descriptive paragraph. The lecture then focuses on making inferences in literature, analyzing poems like "Sixty–Eight Birthday" and "Fog," and finally discusses how a writer reveals character through dialogue, using a passage from P.G. Wodehouse.
📝 Lecture Summary
What is an Inference
Making inferences is the act of discovering the implied or underlying ideas in writing, often described as "reading between the lines." The writer implies something indirectly, and the reader draws a conclusion. This is a higher-level skill that combines reading and strong, logical thinking.
🔑 Definition — Inference: A conclusion reached on the basis of evidence and reasoning. In reading, it is a logical jump from stated information to unstated ideas.
Inferences in Everyday Life
We constantly make inferences in daily life based on our experience and general knowledge. For example, seeing a large crowd and broken glass outside a shop might lead you to infer there has been an accident. Not all inferences will necessarily prove true; the more evidence you have, the more solid your inference is.
📌 Example: Consider a high school with policemen walking in its main hall. A logical inference is that a public examination is going on or an important function is taking place.
📌 Example: Consider a dog that shrinks or cringes when you try to pat it. A logical inference is that the dog has previously been maltreated and is afraid of people.
Practice: Inferences from Pictures and Sentences
In reading, we use the writer’s clues, our own experience, and logic to draw conclusions about what is not known.
📌 Example:
Sentence: "Sohail always sits in the last row of the classroom." Inferences to evaluate:
- a. Sohail dislikes his college courses.
- b. Sohail is unprepared for his class.
- c. Sohail feels uncomfortable sitting in the front row.
- d. Sohail is farsighted. Answer: c. Based on the information, we can only conclude that Sohail does not like sitting in the front. We don’t have enough information to know why.
📌 Example 2:
Sentence: "The Arabic language contains numerous words describing different types of camels." Most logically supported inference: d. The exact nature of camels is important to the desert way of life.
📌 Example 3:
Sentence: "A man enters his office building, marches past a group of fellow employees without returning their greetings and goes into his office, slamming the door." Most logically supported inference: c. The man is in a bad mood.
Inferences in Non-Fiction Passages
The lecture provides a passage on super-automation and asks which statements are most logically supported.
📌 Passage on Super-Automation: This passage discusses how automation is eliminating jobs not only in factories but also in offices, agriculture, and retail. It mentions the use of computers by engineers, robot fruit pickers, and laser scanning. 💡 Why this matters: This exercise trains you to avoid jumping to unsupported or weakly supported conclusions.
The statements most logically supported by the given information are:
- 2. There will be more jobs for people who run and repair electronic devices.
-
- One function of super automation is the handling and storage of information.
-
- Machines can help company employees accomplish more.
-
- Super automation has advantages and disadvantages.
Inferences in Literature
While non-fiction writers often state meaning directly, fiction or creative writers show meaning by describing a scene or situation. The reader must infer the point.
📌 Example of Non-fiction vs. Fiction:
- Non-fiction: "Henry was angry at his wife."
- Fiction: "Henry’s eyes narrowed when his wife spoke to him. He cut her off in the middle of the sentence with the words, 'I don’t have time to argue with you.'"
Poem 1: "Sixty–Eight Birthday" by James Russell Lowell
As life runs on, the road grows strange With faces new, and near the end The milestones into headstones change, ‘Neath every one a friend.
🔑 Definitions:
- Milestone: a slab of stone set up in the ground to show the distance in miles on a road.
- Headstone: a stone which marks the top end of a grave, usually having the buried person’s name on it.
Inferences from the poem:
- The speaker is sixty-eight years old, implied by the title.
- The poem compares life to a road with milestones marking the distance.
- Birthdays are like milestones that mark the years lived.
- The poem implies that life ends in death, as milestones turn into headstones.
- The final line implies that as we get older, more and more friends die.
Poem 2: "Fog" by Carl Sandburg
The fog comes On little cat feet. It sets looking ones harbor and city On silent haunches And then moves on.
Inferences from the poem:
- The way the fog moves is compared to: c. The way a cat moves.
- This comparison implies that the fog: c. moves quickly and silently.
- The comparison with the cat continues with the word: b. haunches.
- The poem implies that the fog: a. stays for a while and then leaves.
- The poem shows fog as: b. quiet.
Inferences from Dialogue
Writers, especially playwrights, reveal character through their characters' speech. Readers and audiences must "read between the lines" of the dialogue.
📌 Example from P.G. Wodehouse's Thank You, Jeeves: The dialogue shows the master (Bertie Wooster) asking verbose, nervous questions, and Jeeves responding with very short, economical answers like "No, sir." and "Indeed, sir?" 💡 Why this matters: This economy of speech implies several things: Jeeves is reserved, respectful, patient, and perhaps slightly controlling. It also suggests a master-servant relationship where Jeeves is the more intelligent and capable of the two.
⭐ Key Takeaways
An inference is a logical conclusion based on evidence and reasoning, not a wild guess. The strength of an inference depends on the amount of supporting evidence; you must avoid jumping to conclusions. This skill applies to both everyday life and reading, where you use the writer's clues, your own experience, and logic. In fiction and poetry, writers often show rather than tell, making inference essential for understanding character and theme. Finally, extensive reading is the best way to acquire and strengthen this skill.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What is the formal definition of an "inference" in the context of reading?
- According to the lecture, what two things does a reader use to draw a logical inference from a text?
- Based on the example provided, why is "Sohail is farsighted" not a logically supported inference from the sentence "Sohail always sits in the last row of the classroom"?
- In the poem "Fog," what specific action or quality of a cat is used to describe the fog's movement?
- How does the lecture suggest a fiction writer reveals a character's anger, in contrast to a non-fiction writer?
📘 Lecture 13 — Reading: Assessing the Text
📖 Overview: This lecture focuses on two critical reading skills: distinguishing facts from opinions in texts, and recognizing time sequences in scientific and technical writing. Mastering these skills allows readers to evaluate information critically and understand the chronological or logical order of events in complex materials.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture first examines how to differentiate between factual statements that can be objectively verified and opinion statements that express subjective beliefs or judgments, including the role of value-words and how opinions can be masked as facts. It then shifts to analyzing time sequences in texts, covering markers that indicate events occurring before, during, or after a given time reference, including chronological, logical, and causal sequences illustrated with examples about computer history.
📝 Lecture Summary
Distinguishing Facts from Opinions
Being able to dissociate facts from opinions is an essential first step in acquiring a critical ability. Most writers include their opinions, making their communication at least partly biased. Scientific reports try to be factual, while newspaper editorials, political speeches, and advertisements center on opinions to convince readers. A skilled reader must know the difference to evaluate what they read.
🔑 Definition — Fact: A statement that can be proved true through objective evidence, such as physical proof or witness testimony. 📌 Example: "The neem tree in our garden is 25 feet tall" can be measured and confirmed. "Pakistan won the 1992 World Cup" can be checked against sports records.
🔑 Definition — Opinion: A statement that cannot be objectively proved true or false. Opinions express beliefs, feelings, or judgments. 📌 Example: "The Alhamra Arts Council building is the most beautiful building in Lahore" — "beautiful" is a value-word that expresses personal judgment and cannot be verified objectively.
Value-words like good, bad, best, worst, terrible, better, lovely, wonderful, worse, and disgusting signal that an opinion is being expressed. For instance, "It's raining outside" is an objective, verifiable fact, but "It's bad weather" is a subjective opinion — some people consider rain good.
More Points about Fact and Opinion
i) A statement of fact can possibly be untrue — evidence may show a claimed fact is false.
ii) Opinions may be masked as facts — people sometimes present opinions using phrases like "in fact" or "the truth of the matter is." Example: "The economy, in fact, has been in worst condition for four years" appears factual but is an opinion.
iii) Value-words often represent opinions — these are subjective, not objective, and express judgment. Factual statements report observed reality; subjective statements interpret reality.
iv) Much of what we read and hear is a mixture of fact and opinion — a politician saying "My record is outstanding" uses the value-word "outstanding" which needs probing. An advertisement claiming a car "is the most economical on the road" seems factual but "economical" may be misleading if repair costs are high.
Analyzing Passages for Fact and Opinion
When reading passages, readers must be alert for opinion embedded within factual content.
📌 Example Passage about Cleopatra:
- Sentence 2: "She is one of the most interesting figures" — opinion (interesting differs per person)
- Sentence 4: "The story of how she died is very fascinating and easy to believe" — opinion
- Sentence 6: "As the Egyptian cobra was a symbol of royalty, so it was a good way for a queen to end her life" — mixture of fact and opinion
📌 Example Passage about Lovecraft and Poe:
- "Edgar Allan Poe is the greatest writer of horror stories" — opinion ("greatest" is a value-word)
- "Poe had to leave the University of Virginia because he couldn't pay his debts" — fact (verifiable)
- "Lovecraft died in the conditions of shameful neglect" — opinion ("shameful" is subjective)
💡 Why this matters: The ability to separate fact from opinion is essential for evaluating political speeches, advertisements, news editorials, and even everyday conversations critically.
The Sequences
In addition to enumeration markers (from Lesson 11), it is equally important to recognize time sequences in which events occur, especially for scheduling, recounting historical facts, routine activities, and describing experiments. Events occur either before, during, or after other events in chronological, logical, or causal sequences. Once a time-reference is established, certain adjectives and adverbials order subsequent information in relation to it.
Table 1: Previous to given time-reference (Before)
| Adjectives | Adverbials |
|---|---|
| earlier, preceding, former, previous | already, earlier/previous, prior, first, so far, before, formerly, yet, before that, up to now/then, until now/then, in the beginning, (long) ago |
📌 Examples:
- The memory storage capacity of earlier computers was not as large as these days.
- When the first digital computer was developed, the first analog computer had already been in use for some time.
- Up to now, computers have not created too much unemployment.
Table 2: Contemporary/Simultaneous time-reference (At the same time)
| Adjectives | Adverbials |
|---|---|
| contemporary, simultaneous | at present, meanwhile, in the meantime, now, when, at the same time, for the time being, at the moment |
📌 Examples:
- Computers might be used in the future as simultaneous translating machines.
- At present, computers are used for printing newspapers.
- In future, computers will probably replace most activities, but in the meantime scientists are still developing computers.
Table 3: Subsequent to time-reference (After)
| Adjectives | Adverbials |
|---|---|
| following | afterwards, after that, eventually, later, since, since then, by the time, next, by the end, soon |
📌 Examples:
- Since the development of the chip, computers have become cheaper and more compact.
- You should have a good basic understanding of computers by the time you finish this course.
- After the development of transistors, the later computers were much faster.
N.B. Time sequence is also shown by different verb tenses. 📌 Examples:
- Vannevar Bush had built the first analog computer long before Professor Aiken invented the first digital computer. (Past perfect shows earlier event)
- At the rate computer technology is growing, computers, as we know them today, will soon become obsolete. (Future tense)
Sample Paragraph: Computer History Timeline
Computers, as we know them today, haven't been around for a long time. It wasn't until the mid-1940s that the first working digital computer was completed. But since then, computers have evolved tremendously. Vacuum tubes were used in the first-generation computers at the beginning of the 1960s. By the end of the 1960s, transistors were replaced by tiny integrated circuit boards. Fourth-generation computers are now produced with circuits much smaller than before on a single chip. Soon, fifth-generation computers will be produced, better than their predecessors.
Exercise: Underline Time Relaters in a Paragraph
A paragraph about computer history is provided with time relaters to identify:
- More than 5000 years ago
- first, then
- before or after
- Since that time
- well into the 16th century
- During the 17th and 18th centuries
- not until the early 1800s
- not too long after
- A hundred years later
- until 1944
- Since then
- in the 1950s, early 1960s, mid-60s, 1970s
- now
- by the end of this decade
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts from this lecture for exam preparation are: first, a fact must be objectively verifiable while an opinion expresses subjective judgment signaled by value-words like "best," "worst," or "beautiful." Second, opinions are often masked as facts using phrases like "in fact" or "the truth is," requiring careful analysis. Third, time sequences are organized using specific time relaters that indicate events occurring before (earlier, previously), during (at present, meanwhile), or after (afterwards, subsequently) a given time reference. Fourth, verb tenses also communicate time sequence, such as past perfect for events that happened before other past events. Finally, distinguishing fact from opinion and recognizing time markers are essential for critically evaluating scientific reports, historical accounts, and even everyday reading materials.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What is the key difference between a fact and an opinion, and give one example of each from the lecture?
- List five value-words that signal an opinion is being expressed.
- How can an opinion be masked as a fact, and what phrase might be used to do so?
- Name three time relaters that indicate events occurring before a given time reference, and three that indicate events occurring after.
- In the sentence "Vannevar Bush had built the first analog computer long before Professor Aiken invented the first digital computer," what verb tense is used and what does it indicate about the time sequence?
📘 Lecture 14 — Reading: Assessing Texts
📖 Overview: This lecture explores the techniques writers use to bring characters to life in imaginative writing, examining five distinct methods of characterization. It then shifts to practical text analysis by examining how examples are signaled in academic and technical writing, particularly relevant to computer science fields.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture first examines how writers create characters through action, speech, direct statements, comparisons and associations, and association with particular points of view. It then analyzes examples from Dickens, Wodehouse, Wilson, and Blishen to illustrate each technique. The second half transitions to identifying how examples are introduced in technical texts, including explicit markers and implicit exemplification.
📝 Lecture Summary
Characters
Almost every example of imaginative writing involves people. A writer translates his vision of characters to the reader using only words, while a painter or photographer can present ideas visually. The writer achieves characterization through six methods: showing action, putting actual words into characters' mouths, using direct statements, making comparisons and associations, associating characters with one particular point of view or action, and choice of words picking out a particular feature or detail.
1. Action
Writers show character by having them perform typical actions or act in a particular way that reveals personality. An example from Charles Dickens' Great Expectations describes Pip's sister, Mrs. Gargery, cutting bread-and-butter: "My sister had a trenchant way of cutting our bread-and-butter for us that never varied. First, with her left hand she jammed the load hard and fast against her bib... Then she took some butter (not too much) on a knife and spread it on the loaf, in an apothecary kind of way, as if she were making a plaster-using both sides of the knife with a slapping dexterity... Then, she gave the knife a final smart wipe on the edge of the plaster, and then sawed a very thick round off the loaf; which she finally... hewed into two halves."
🔑 Definition — Characterization through action: Revealing personality by describing a character performing typical actions or behaving in a distinctive manner.
📌 Example: Mrs. Gargery's bread-cutting uses words like trenchant, jammed, slapping dexterity, sawed, and hewed — all suggesting a harsh, forceful, almost violent nature. The words build an impression of a stern, domineering woman who performs even simple tasks aggressively.
💡 Why this matters: The choice of verbs (not just the action itself) reveals character — "slapping dexterity" and "hewed" suggest far more than "cut neatly" would.
2. Speech
Writers indicate character through the words they put into characters' mouths. This is especially important in drama, but fiction writers use it too. An example from P.G. Wodehouse's Thank You, Jeeves shows Jeeves's speech:
"'Jeeves,' I said, 'do you know what?' 'No sir.' 'Do you know whom I saw last night?' 'no, sir.' 'J. Washburn Stoker and his daughter, Pauline.' 'Indeed, sir?' 'Awkward, what?' 'I can conceive that after what occurred in New York it might be distressing for you to encounter Miss Stoker, sir. But I fancy the contingency need scarcely arise.'"
🔑 Definition — Characterization through speech: Revealing character by what characters say and how they say it, including word choice, sentence length, and implied attitudes.
📌 Example: Jeeves's answers are very economical — mostly "No sir," "Indeed, sir?" — suggesting formality, restraint, and a servant's proper deference. Yet his longer reply ("I can conceive...") reveals his intelligence and subtle control, implying he already knows everything but will not say so directly.
3. Direct Statements
Some writers tell us about characters directly instead of showing them. They build detail on detail until we have a clear picture of appearance, habits, opinions, and life history. An example from Angus Wilson's A Little Companion describes Miss Arkwright:
"She was in no way a remarkable person. Her appearance was not particularly distinguished... She had enough personal eccentricities to fit into the pattern of English village life... She accepted her position as an old maid with that cheerful good humor and occasional irony... She attempted to counteract the inadequacy of the unmarried state by quiet, sensible and tolerant social work in the local community. She was liked by nearly everyone, though she was not afraid of making enemies where she knew that her broad but deeply felt religious principles were being opposed."
🔑 Definition — Characterization through direct statement: The writer explicitly describes a character's qualities, history, and personality rather than letting actions or speech imply them.
📌 Example: Miss Arkwright is described as unremarkable yet distinctive, tolerant yet principled, socially active yet self-deprecating. Her reported comments reveal her character: "hard work's the only excuse old maids like me have got for existing at all" and "if they've got any sense this time they'll keep the young fellows at home and put us useless old maids in the trenches."
4. Comparisons and Associations
Writers describe characters by comparing them to something else that creates an image, or by associating them with an idea or object that is significant. An example from Charles Dickens' David Copperfield describes Miss Murdstone:
"It was Miss Murdstone who arrived, and a gloomy-looking lady she was; dark, like her brother... with very heavy eyebrows, nearly meeting over her large nose... She brought with her two uncompromising hard black boxes, with her initials on the lids in hard brass nails. When she paid the coachman she took the money from a hard steel purse, and she kept the purse in a very jail of a bag which hung upon her arm by a heavy chain, and shut up like a bite. I had never... seen such a metallic lady altogether as Miss Murdstone was."
🔑 Definition — Characterization through comparison and association: Using metaphors, similes, or symbolic objects to link a character to qualities of something else (here, metal).
📌 Example: Words suggesting metal directly include hard black boxes, hard brass nails, hard steel purse, heavy chain, metallic lady. Words suggesting metal's characteristics include uncompromising, jail of a bag, shut up like a bite. This association is appropriate because Miss Murdstone is hard, cold, unyielding, and imprisoning in personality.
💡 Why this matters: The comparison is not decorative — every metallic object reinforces Miss Murdstone's unfeeling, restrictive nature.
5. Association with a Particular Point of View or Action
Characters can be easily and quickly identified by a repeated action, phrase, or viewpoint. From David Copperfield, Uriah Heep is remembered for being "ever so humble" and rubbing his hands together: "he frequently ground the palms against each other as if to squeeze them dry and warm, besides often wiping them, in a stealthy way, on his pocket handkerchief."
From Hard Times, Thomas Gradgrind is described as "A man of realities. A man of facts and calculations. A man who proceeds upon the principle that two and two are four, and nothing over... With a rule and a pair of scales, and the multiplication table always in his pocket, sir, ready to weight and measure any parcel of human nature."
🔑 Definition — Characterization through repeated identifying feature: A distinctive action, phrase, or perspective that becomes permanently associated with a character.
📌 Example: Words reinforcing Gradgrind as a man of facts include realities, facts, calculations, two and two are four, rule and a pair of scales, multiplication table, weight and measure, simple arithmetic. The word "sir" adds a tone of peremptory authority — he is someone who must be addressed formally and accepts it as his due.
6. Choice of Words and Picking Out a Particular Feature
Writers bring characters to life by selecting specific descriptive details and carefully chosen words. Examples from Edward Blishen's A Cackhanded War:
"'He was a tiny fellow, with a leathery white face under black hair, and tied to the case he'd brought were the most enormous gumboots I'd ever seen.'" "'Mrs Goss was a widow, a neat little woman of over seventy: and witchlike.'" "'He was a deeply depressed man, this farmer, who always wore a white coat and cloth cap, and was always peppered with a white-and-black bristle.'" "'He was a tall, silent, dark man, very gentle, who would tut over his machine as if it were some moody woman.'" "'On the strawstack was a boy: a short, stout boy with a kind of naked pertness about his eyes and a very runny nose.'"
🔑 Definition — Characterization through word choice and specific detail: Selecting one or two vivid, concrete features that define a character memorably.
Back to Practical Texts: Examples
The lecture shifts to how examples are introduced in academic and technical writing. Example markers include:
- For example, for instance, as an example, such as, like
- Examples of, an example of this, cases of, illustration of
- Shown by, exemplified by, illustrated by, seen in
- Namely (introduces specific items)
- N.B. (nota bene — note well)
Sample sentences:
- "The switches, like the cores, are capable of being in one of two possible states that is, on or off; magnetized or unmagnetized."
- "Computers have circuits for performing arithmetic operations such as: addition subtraction, division, multiplication and exponentiation."
- "The computer can only decide three things, namely: Is one number less than another? Are two numbers equal? Is one number greater than another?"
- "Computers can process information at extremely rapid rates; for example, they can solve certain arithmetic problems millions of times faster than a skilled mathematician."
- "Using the very limited capabilities possessed by all computers, the task of producing a university payroll, for instance, can be done quite easily."
🔑 Definition — Explicit exemplification: Using specific marker words or phrases to signal that an example follows, making the relationship between the general statement and specific instance clear.
📌 Example: Sometimes markers follow the example, separated by commas. Not all texts present examples explicitly; some implicit exemplification occurs without marker words.
⭐ Key Takeaways
You must remember the five main methods of characterization: action, speech, direct statements, comparisons/associations, and association with a repeated point of view or action, plus the sixth method of word choice and specific detail. Each example from Dickens, Wodehouse, and Wilson demonstrates a distinct technique — Mrs. Gargery's harsh verbs, Jeeves's economical speech, Miss Murdstone's metallic associations, and Gradgrind's fact-obsessed identity. For technical writing, recognize explicit example markers (for example, such as, namely) and understand that some exemplification is implicit. The key skill is analyzing how word choice, not just content, builds character.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What six methods does a writer use to bring characters to life using only words?
- How does Dickens' description of Mrs. Gargery cutting bread-and-butter reveal her character — what do words like "trenchant," "jammed," and "hewed" suggest?
- What does Jeeves's economical speech in the Wodehouse passage reveal about his character and his attitude toward his master?
- Why is the association of Miss Murdstone with metal objects (hard boxes, steel purse, heavy chain) appropriate to her character?
- List at least five explicit markers that signal an example in technical writing, and give a sentence using one of them.
📘 Lecture 15 — Evaluating Texts: Interpreting Visual Data
📖 Overview: This lecture focuses on two main skills: interpreting visual data (graphs, charts, tables, maps, and diagrams) and making comparisons in English. Understanding visuals is critical for accurate reading comprehension, while mastering comparative structures is essential for clear academic and professional communication.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with interpreting visual data including tables, graphs, and bar graphs, then moves to map reading and interpretation. The second half covers making comparisons through the formation of comparative and superlative adjectives and adverbs, including regular and irregular forms, and their use in sentences to show equivalence, non-equivalence, superlative, and parallel increase.