π Lecture 27 β Economic Applications of Exact Differential Equations (Continued)
π Overview: This lecture continues exploring economic applications of differential equations, focusing on nonlinear Bernoulli equations and their solutions. It demonstrates how Bernoulli equations can be linearized and solved, applies this technique to find average cost functions, introduces qualitative analysis through phase diagrams, and applies both qualitative and quantitative methods to the Solow Growth Model.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers six main topics: understanding Bernoulli's nonlinear differential equation structure and its reduction to linear form; solving a Bernoulli equation numerically with a specific example; finding an average cost function using Bernoulli equation techniques; introducing phase diagrams for qualitative analysis of autonomous differential equations; conducting qualitative analysis of the Solow Growth Model; and performing quantitative analysis of the Solow Growth Model using a Cobb-Douglas production function to find the steady-state equilibrium.
π Lecture Summary
TOPIC 117: NON-LINEAR DIFFERENTIAL EQUATION: UNDERSTANDING BERNOULLIβS EQUATION
A Bernoulli Differential Equation is a specific nonlinear differential equation attributed to Jacob Bernoulli. Its standard form is: dy/dt + R y = T y^m, where R and T are functions of t, and m is a power not equal to 0 or 1. When m=0, the equation becomes linear (dy/dt + R y = T). When m=1, it becomes dy/dt + (R - T)y = 0, also linear. The nonlinearity arises from the y^m term.
The solution method involves reducing the Bernoulli equation to a linear differential equation. By dividing through by y^m, we get: y^(-m) dy/dt + R y^(1-m) = T. Through substitutions: Substitution-I sets z = y^(1-m), replacing the nonlinear y term with a linear z term. Substitution-II applies the chain rule since z depends on y which depends on t: dz/dt = (dz/dy) Γ (dy/dt). Differentiating z = y^(1-m) with respect to y gives dz/dy = (1 - m) Γ y^(-m). Substituting into the chain rule yields: (1/(1-m)) Γ dz/dt = y^(-m) Γ dy/dt.
π Definition β Bernoulli Differential Equation: A nonlinear differential equation of the form dy/dt + R(t) y = T(t) y^m, where m β 0 and m β 1. π Formula: dz/dt + {(1-m) Γ (R z - T)} dt = 0 β This is the linearized form after substitution, where z = y^(1-m).
TOPIC 118: NON-LINEAR DIFFERENTIAL EQUATION: BERNOULLIβS EQUATION NUMERICALLY
Solve the equation dy/dt + t y = 3t y^2. Comparing with standard form: R = t, T = 3t, m = 2. Using substitution: z = y^(1-2) = y^(-1). The linearized form is dz + {(1-m) Γ (R z - T)} dt = 0. Substituting values: dz + {(1-2) Γ (t z - 3t)} dt = 0, which simplifies to dz + (-t z + 3t) dt = 0. Converting to standard FODE form: dz/dt + (-t) z = -3t.
Using the general solution for FODE with variable coefficients: z(t) = e^(-β« u dt) (A + β« e^(β« u dt) w dt). Here, u(t) = -t and w(t) = -3t. β« u dt = -tΒ²/2. Then z(t) = e^(tΒ²/2) (A + 3 β« (-t) e^(-tΒ²/2) dt). Noting that f(x) = -tΒ²/2 and f'(x) = -t, the integral becomes β« f'(x) e^(f(x)) dx = e^(f(x)). Thus, z(t) = e^(tΒ²/2) (A + 3 e^(-tΒ²/2)) = A e^(tΒ²/2) + 3.
Since z = y^(-1), we restore y: y^(-1) = A e^(tΒ²/2) + 3, so y(t) = 1/(A e^(tΒ²/2) + 3).
π Example: Given dy/dt + t y = 3t y^2, with R=t, T=3t, m=2, the solution is y(t) = 1/(A e^(tΒ²/2) + 3).
TOPIC 119: AVERAGE COST FUNCTION USING EXACT DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS
Given: d(AC)/dQ + (1/Q) AC = (AC)Β³. This is a Bernoulli equation where y = AC, t = Q, R = 1/Q, T = 1, m = 3. Using substitution: z = (AC)^(1-3) = (AC)^(-2). The linearized form is dz + {(1-m) Γ (R z - T)} dQ = 0. Substituting: dz + [(1-3) Γ {(1/Q)z - 1}] dQ = 0, simplifying to dz - 2(1/Q)z dQ - 2 dQ = 0. Converting to standard FODE form: dz/dQ + (-2/Q)z = 2, where u(Q) = -2/Q and w(Q) = 2.
β« u(Q) dQ = β« (-2/Q) dQ = -2 ln|Q|. Using the general solution: z(Q) = e^(-(-2 ln|Q|)) (A + β« e^(-2 ln|Q|) Γ 2 dQ) = e^(2 ln|Q|) (A + 2 β« e^(-2 ln|Q|) dQ) = QΒ² (A + 2 β« Qβ»Β² dQ) = QΒ²(A + 2 Γ (-Qβ»ΒΉ)) = A QΒ² - 2Q.
Restoring AC: (AC)^(-2) = A QΒ² - 2Q, so AC(Q) = 1/(A QΒ² - 2Q)^(1/2). This solution shows a negative relationship between average cost and output (AC declines as Q increases), suggesting that AC is predominantly fixed cost, characteristic of natural monopoly.
π Formula: AC(Q) = 1/(A QΒ² - 2Q)^(1/2) β The general solution showing declining average cost with increasing output.
π‘ Why this matters: This mathematical result confirms the economic theory of natural monopoly, where high fixed costs lead to declining average costs over the range of output, a situation where a single firm can serve the entire market most efficiently.
TOPIC 120: QUALITATIVE ANALYSIS: PHASE DIAGRAM
A Phase Diagram is a qualitative tool for analyzing the dynamic properties of autonomous differential equations. An autonomous differential equation has the form dy/dt = f(y), where the derivative depends only on y, not on t. The phase diagram plots dy/dt against y on a single axis (the phase line), showing the direction of movement of y over time.
For dy/dt = y - 7: The x-intercept (where dy/dt = 0) occurs at y = 7. Before the intercept (y < 7), dy/dt < 0, so y decreases (moves leftwards). After the intercept (y > 7), dy/dt > 0, so y increases (moves rightwards). This shows repulsion from the equilibrium y=7, indicating divergence and dynamic instability (a Repellor).
For dy/dt = 4 - y/2: The x-intercept occurs at y = 8. Before the intercept (y < 8), dy/dt > 0, so y increases (moves rightwards). After the intercept (y > 8), dy/dt < 0, so y decreases (moves leftwards). This shows attraction towards the equilibrium y=8, indicating convergence and dynamic stability (an Attractor or Steady-State Equilibrium).
Verification using the FODE solution: For dy/dt + a y = b, convergence occurs if a > 0, divergence if a < 0. In the first example (dy/dt = y - 7), rewriting as dy/dt + (-1)y = -7, a = -1 < 0, confirming divergence. In the second example (dy/dt = 4 - y/2), rewriting as dy/dt + (1/2)y = 4, a = 1/2 > 0, confirming convergence.
π Definition β Phase Diagram: A graphical representation showing the qualitative behavior of an autonomous differential equation by plotting dy/dt against y, indicating whether the system converges to or diverges from equilibrium. π Definition β Repellor: An equilibrium point where the system moves away from it (divergent, unstable). π Definition β Attractor: An equilibrium point where the system moves toward it (convergent, stable, steady-state).
TOPIC 121: SOLOW GROWTH MODEL: QUALITATIVE ANALYSIS
The Solow Growth Model (attributed to Robert M. Solow) analyzes the qualitative behavior of the capital-labor ratio k. The fundamental equation is: dk/dt = s Ο(k) - Ξ» k, where s is the MPS (marginal propensity to save), Ο(k) is the production function, and Ξ» represents depreciation of capital. The term s Ο(k) represents investment, and Ξ» k represents depreciation.
Three cases occur: (1) If dk/dt > 0, then s Ο(k) > Ξ» k, meaning investment exceeds depreciation, so k increases (moves rightwards towards k*). (2) If dk/dt = 0, then s Ο(k) = Ξ» k, meaning the system is at steady-state equilibrium k*. (3) If dk/dt < 0, then s Ο(k) < Ξ» k, meaning depreciation exceeds investment, so k decreases (moves leftwards towards k*). In all cases, the system converges to the steady-state equilibrium k*, showing dynamic stability.
The phase diagram for the Solow model shows that before the x-intercept (k*), the phase line is above the axis (dk/dt > 0), and after k*, the phase line is below the axis (dk/dt < 0). This indicates attraction towards k*, confirming that Solow's model predicts convergence to a stable, steady-state equilibrium.
π Formula: dk/dt = s Ο(k) - Ξ» k β Rate of change of capital-labor ratio equals investment minus capital depreciation.
TOPIC 122: SOLOW GROWTH MODEL: QUANTITATIVE ANALYSIS
For quantitative analysis, a linearly homogeneous Cobb-Douglas production function is assumed: Q = K^Ξ± L^(1-Ξ±). Expressing in per-capita terms: Ο(k) = k^Ξ±. Substituting into the Solow equation: dk/dt = s k^Ξ± - Ξ» k, or dk/dt + Ξ» k = s k^Ξ±. This is a Bernoulli equation where y = k, R = Ξ», T = s, m = Ξ± (with Ξ± β 1).
Using substitution: z = k^(1-Ξ±). The linearized form becomes dz/dt + (1-Ξ±)Ξ» z = (1-Ξ±)s. This is comparable to the standard FODE form dy/dt + a y = b, where a = (1-Ξ±)Ξ» and b = (1-Ξ±)s.
The definite solution is: k^(1-Ξ±) = [{k(0)}^(1-Ξ±) - s/Ξ»] e^(-(1-Ξ±)Ξ» t) + s/Ξ». Here, the term {k(0)}^(1-Ξ±) - s/Ξ» is the arbitrary constant based on initial condition. The exponential expression e^(-(1-Ξ±)Ξ» t) determines dynamic stability. As t β β, e^(-(1-Ξ±)Ξ» t) β 0, so k^(1-Ξ±) β s/Ξ», which means k(t) β (s/Ξ»)^(1/(1-Ξ±)).
The exponent (1-Ξ±)Ξ» > 0 because 0 < Ξ± < 1 and Ξ» > 0. This ensures the exponential decay term diminishes to zero over time, leading to convergence. The steady-state capital-labor ratio k* = (s/Ξ»)^(1/(1-Ξ±)), which varies directly with the savings rate s and inversely with the depreciation rate Ξ».
π Example: With k(0)=100, s=0.2, Ξ±=0.7, Ξ»=0.025, the steady-state k* = s/Ξ» = 0.2/0.025 = 8. The exponential decay term causes k(t) to converge to 8 as t increases.
π Definition β Steady-State Equilibrium (k)**: The long-run equilibrium value of the capital-labor ratio in the Solow Growth Model, given by k = (s/Ξ»)^(1/(1-Ξ±)).
π‘ Why this matters: The Solow model predicts that economies with different initial capital-labor ratios will converge to the same steady-state level, implying that poorer economies (with lower k) will grow faster than richer economies, converging to a common equilibrium determined by savings and depreciation rates.
β Key Takeaways
This lecture establishes four critical concepts. First, Bernoulli differential equations (dy/dt + R y = T y^m) can be linearized through substitution z = y^(1-m), transforming nonlinear economic dynamics into solvable linear forms. Second, phase diagrams provide powerful qualitative analysis of autonomous differential equations by showing whether equilibria are attractors (convergent, stable) or repellors (divergent, unstable). Third, the Solow Growth Model's fundamental equation dk/dt = s Ο(k) - Ξ» k predicts convergence to a steady-state capital-labor ratio, demonstrated both qualitatively through phase diagrams and quantitatively through the solved Bernoulli equation. Fourth, the steady-state equilibrium k* = (s/Ξ»)^(1/(1-Ξ±)) depends directly on savings and inversely on depreciation, showing the long-run determinants of capital accumulation.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the standard form of a Bernoulli differential equation, and what condition must m satisfy for the equation to be nonlinear?
- Explain the two substitutions (Substitution-I and Substitution-II) used to linearize a Bernoulli equation.
- In the average cost problem (d(AC)/dQ + (1/Q) AC = (AC)Β³), what does the solution AC(Q) = 1/(A QΒ² - 2Q)^(1/2) imply about the relationship between average cost and output?
- Using a phase diagram, explain the difference between an attractor and a repellor equilibrium. How does the sign of dy/dt on either side of the equilibrium determine stability?
- In the Solow Growth Model, what is the steady-state capital-labor ratio k* and how is it derived from the equation dk/dt = s k^Ξ± - Ξ» k? What conditions ensure dynamic stability?
π Lecture 28 β SECOND ORDER DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS
π Overview: This lecture introduces higher-order differential equations, focusing on the second-order case (SODE). It explains how to find the particular integral (equilibrium) and complementary function (deviation from equilibrium) to form the general solution. The lecture covers the classification of SODE into homogeneous and non-homogeneous cases, their subcases, and the method for solving with distinct real roots.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining the general nth-order linear differential equation with constant coefficients. It then narrows down to the second-order differential equation (SODE) and its two main categories: homogeneous and non-homogeneous cases. Within the non-homogeneous case, three subcases are explored based on the coefficients aβ and aβ, each with its own formula for the particular integral. Finally, the concept of the complementary function is derived using an exponential trial solution, leading to the characteristic equation and its roots. The case of distinct real roots is solved with a numerical example.
π Lecture Summary
Topic 123: Higher (Second) Order Differential Equation
This section introduces the concept of rate of change of the rate of change in economic variables, which leads to second-order differential equations. It generalizes this to the nth-order linear differential equation.
π Definition β Linear Differential Equation with nth Order: An equation of the form:
dβΏy/dtβΏ + aβ dβΏβ»ΒΉy/dtβΏβ»ΒΉ + aβ dβΏβ»Β²y/dtβΏβ»Β² + β― + aβββ dy/dt + aβ y = b
where the a's are constant coefficients, b is a constant term, and the dependent variable is y. The order is n (due to the highest derivative), and the degree is linear/first degree (due to the highest power 1 of the nth derivative). This course only considers linear equations with constant coefficients and no cross-terms (products of y and its derivatives).
For n=2, this simplifies to the Standard Form of Second-Order Differential Equation (SODE):
dΒ²y/dtΒ² + aβ dy/dt + aβ y = b or yβ³(t) + aβ yβ²(t) + aβ y(t) = b
Depending on the value of b, there are two main cases:
- Homogeneous Case (
b = 0): The particular solutionyβ = 0. - Non-Homogeneous Case (
b β 0): The particular solutionyβ β 0.
Further sub-cases for each are identified based on the values of aβ and aβ.
Topic 124: Second-Order Differential Equation: Particular Integral
This section defines the particular integral (yβ) as any particular solution of the non-homogeneous equation that contains no arbitrary constants. It represents the equilibrium value of y(t). The time path is y(t) = yκ + yβ, where yκ is the deviation from equilibrium.
The lecture derives formulas for yβ for three non-homogeneous subcases:
-
Subcase I: If
aβ β 0, assume a constant solutiony = k.y = k β yβ²(t) = 0 β yβ³(t) = 0- Substituting into
yβ³(t) + aβyβ²(t) + aβy(t) = bgivesaβk = b β k = b/aβ. - π Formula:
yβ = b/aβ - π‘ Why this matters: This gives a constant equilibrium value.
-
Subcase II: If
aβ = 0andaβ β 0, the formula from Subcase I fails (divide by zero). Assumey = kt.y = kt β yβ²(t) = k β yβ³(t) = 0- Substituting into
yβ³(t) + aβyβ²(t) + 0Β·y(t) = bgivesaβk = b β k = b/aβ. - π Formula:
yβ = (b/aβ) t - π‘ Why this matters: This gives a non-constant equilibrium value that changes over time.
-
Subcase III: If
aβ = 0andaβ = 0, both previous formulas fail. Assumey = ktΒ².y = ktΒ² β yβ²(t) = 2kt β yβ³(t) = 2k- Substituting into
yβ³(t) + 0Β·yβ²(t) + 0Β·y(t) = bgives2k = b β k = b/2. - π Formula:
yβ = (b/2) tΒ² - π‘ Why this matters: This gives a quadratic equilibrium value over time.
Topic 125: Second-Order Differential Equation: Particular Integral Numerical
This section provides numerical examples for each non-homogeneous subcase.
Non-Homogeneous Subcase I: yβ³(t) + yβ²(t) - 2y = -10
- Here,
aβ = 1,aβ = -2,b = -10. Sinceaβ β 0, Subcase I applies. - π Formula:
yβ = b/aβ - π Example:
yβ = (-10)/(-2) = 5
Non-Homogeneous Subcase II: yβ³(t) + yβ²(t) = -10
- Here,
aβ = 1,aβ = 0,b = -10. Sinceaβ = 0andaβ β 0, Subcase II applies. - π Formula:
yβ = (b/aβ) t - π Example:
yβ = (-10/1) t = -10t
Non-Homogeneous Subcase III: yβ³(t) = -10
- Here,
aβ = 0,aβ = 0,b = -10. Since bothaβ = 0andaβ = 0, Subcase III applies. - π Formula:
yβ = (b/2) tΒ² - π Example:
yβ = (-10/2) tΒ² = -5tΒ²
The section concludes by noting that in the homogeneous case (b = 0), all subcases yield a particular solution of yβ = 0.
Topic 126: Second-Order Differential Equation: Standard Form & Complementary Function
This section defines the complementary function (yκ) as the general solution of the reduced (homogeneous) equation yβ³(t) + aβyβ²(t) + aβy(t) = 0. It represents the deviation of the time path y(t) from the equilibrium value at every point in time. For dynamic stability, the yκ term should disappear over time (yκ β 0), so y(t)β yβ.
To derive yκ, the lecture uses an exponential trial solution y(t) = AeΚ³α΅, as this is the only function whose derivatives are proportional to itself, allowing the homogeneous equation to be reduced to zero.
- For
y(t) = AeΚ³α΅, we have:yβ²(t) = rAeΚ³α΅yβ³(t) = rΒ²AeΚ³α΅
- Substituting into
yβ³(t) + aβyβ²(t) + aβy(t) = 0gives:rΒ²AeΚ³α΅ + aβrAeΚ³α΅ + aβAeΚ³α΅ = 0AeΚ³α΅(rΒ² + aβr + aβ) = 0SinceAeΚ³α΅ β 0, the characteristic equation is:rΒ² + aβr + aβ = 0
π Definition β Characteristic Equation: The quadratic equation rΒ² + aβr + aβ = 0 derived from the homogeneous SODE.
Using the quadratic formula, the roots (rβ, rβ) are:
π Formula: r = [-aβ Β± β(aβΒ² - 4aβ)] / 2
rβ = [-aβ + β(aβΒ² - 4aβ)] / 2andrβ = [-aβ - β(aβΒ² - 4aβ)] / 2
Two relationships to verify the roots:
- Relationship I: Sum of roots
rβ + rβ = -aβ - Relationship II: Product of roots
rβ Γ rβ = aβ
Topic 127: Second-Order Differential Equation: Distinct Real Roots
This section examines the case where the discriminant (aβΒ² - 4aβ) > 0, leading to two distinct real roots (rβ β rβ).
The complementary function for this case is:
π Formula: yκ = Aβe^(rβt) + Aβe^(rβt) where Aβ and Aβ are arbitrary constants.
Numerical Example: Solve yβ³(t) + yβ²(t) - 2y = -10 with initial conditions y(0) = 12 and yβ²(0) = -2.
- Identify coefficients:
aβ = 1,aβ = -2,b = -10. - Find Particular Integral: Since
aβ β 0, useyβ = b/aβ = (-10)/(-2) = 5. - Find Characteristic Roots:
r = [-1 Β± β(1Β² - 4(-2))] / 2 = [-1 Β± β9] / 2.rβ = (-1 + 3)/2 = 1rβ = (-1 - 3)/2 = -2
- Form Complementary Function:
yκ = AβeΒΉα΅ + Aβeβ»Β²α΅. - General Solution:
y(t) = yκ + yβ = Aβeα΅ + Aβeβ»Β²α΅ + 5. - Apply Initial Condition 1 (
y(0) = 12):12 = Aβeβ° + Aβeβ° + 5 β 12 = Aβ + Aβ + 5 β Aβ + Aβ = 7(Equation 1) - Apply Initial Condition 2 (
yβ²(0) = -2):- First find derivative:
yβ²(t) = Aβeα΅ - 2Aβeβ»Β²α΅. - At
t=0:-2 = Aβeβ° - 2Aβeβ° β -2 = Aβ - 2Aβ(Equation 2)
- First find derivative:
- Solve for Constants:
- From Equation 1:
Aβ = 7 - Aβ. - Substitute into Equation 2:
-2 = (7 - Aβ) - 2Aβ β -2 = 7 - 3Aβ β 3Aβ = 9 β Aβ = 3. - Then
Aβ = 7 - 3 = 4.
- From Equation 1:
- Definite Solution:
y(t) = 4eα΅ + 3eβ»Β²α΅ + 5.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concept is that the solution to a second-order differential equation has two components: the particular integral (yβ) representing equilibrium and the complementary function (yκ) representing deviations from it. You must know how to classify a SODE as homogeneous or non-homogeneous, then further classify it based on its coefficients to apply the correct formula for yβ. The complementary function is found by solving the characteristic equation (rΒ² + aβr + aβ = 0) derived from an exponential trial solution. For the distinct real roots case, the complementary function is Aβe^(rβt) + Aβe^(rβt), and the arbitrary constants Aβ and Aβ are determined using initial conditions.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the general form of a second-order linear differential equation?
- How do you determine which subcase (I, II, or III) to use for finding the particular integral?
- What is the characteristic equation for a SODE, and how is it derived?
- Describe the three possible natures of the roots of the characteristic equation based on the discriminant.
- In the numerical example with
yβ³(t) + yβ²(t) - 2y = -10, how were the constantsAβandAβin the complementary function solved?
π Lecture 29 β SECOND ORDER DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS (CONTINUED 1)
π Overview: This lecture completes the analysis of second-order differential equations by examining the remaining two cases of characteristic roots: repeated real roots and complex roots. Understanding these cases is critical for modeling economic systems where equilibrium paths exhibit different dynamic behaviors, such as steady convergence or oscillatory adjustment.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers three main topics: solving second-order differential equations with repeated real roots (Case II), solving second-order differential equations with complex roots (Case III), a summary table of all complementary function forms for the three root cases, and a detailed analysis of dynamic stability using the distinct real roots case as an example, demonstrating when solutions converge to or diverge from equilibrium.
π Lecture Summary
SECOND-ORDER DIFFERENTIAL EQUATION: REPEATED REAL ROOTS
For a second-order differential equation ( y''(t) + a_1 y'(t) + a_2 y = b ), the characteristic roots are found using: [ r = \frac{-a_1 \pm \sqrt{a_1^2 - 4a_2}}{2} ]
The discriminant ( (a_1^2 - 4a_2) ) determines the nature of the roots. When ( a_1^2 - 4a_2 = 0 ), we have repeated real roots. In this case, both roots are equal: ( r_1 = r_2 = r = -\frac{a_1}{2} ).
The complementary function for repeated real roots is: [ y_c = A_3 e^{rt} + A_4 t e^{rt} ] The second term ( A_4 t e^{rt} ) is needed because the two exponential terms would otherwise be identical, so we multiply by ( t ) to obtain a second independent solution.
π Definition β Repeated Real Roots: Characteristic roots where the discriminant equals zero (( a_1^2 = 4a_2 )), resulting in two identical real roots ( r_1 = r_2 ).
π Formula: General solution is ( y(t) = y_c + y_p = A_3 e^{rt} + A_4 t e^{rt} + y_p )
π Example: Solve ( y''(t) + 6y'(t) + 9y = 27 ), given ( y(0) = 5 ) and ( y'(0) = -5 ).
Step 1: Compare to standard form. Here ( a_1 = 6, a_2 = 9, b = 27 ).
Step 2: Check discriminant. ( a_1^2 - 4a_2 = 36 - 36 = 0 ). This is Repeated Real Roots.
Step 3: Calculate root. ( r = -\frac{a_1}{2} = -\frac{6}{2} = -3 ).
Step 4: Complementary function. ( y_c = A_3 e^{-3t} + A_4 t e^{-3t} ).
Step 5: Find particular integral. Since ( b = 27 ) is constant, try ( y_p = k ). Substituting: ( 0 + 0 + 9k = 27 \Rightarrow k = 3 ). So ( y_p = 3 ).
Step 6: General solution. ( y(t) = A_3 e^{-3t} + A_4 t e^{-3t} + 3 ).
Step 7: Use initial condition ( y(0) = 5 ). ( y(0) = A_3(1) + 0 + 3 = 5 \Rightarrow A_3 = 2 ).
Step 8: Derivative. ( y'(t) = -3A_3 e^{-3t} + A_4 e^{-3t} - 3A_4 t e^{-3t} ). Substituting ( A_3 = 2 ): ( y'(t) = -6 e^{-3t} + A_4 e^{-3t} - 3A_4 t e^{-3t} ).
Step 9: Use ( y'(0) = -5 ). ( y'(0) = -6(1) + A_4(1) - 0 = -5 \Rightarrow -6 + A_4 = -5 \Rightarrow A_4 = 1 ).
Step 10: Definite solution. ( y(t) = 2e^{-3t} + t e^{-3t} + 3 ).
Interpretation: The definite solution ( y(t) = 2e^{-3t} + t e^{-3t} + 3 ) converges to equilibrium at ( y_p = 3 ) as ( t \to \infty ) because ( e^{-3t} ) decays exponentially, but the term ( t e^{-3t} ) initially increases before decaying. π‘ Why this matters: This "overshoot" pattern can model economic variables that initially move away from equilibrium before converging.
SECOND-ORDER DIFFERENTIAL EQUATION: COMPLEX ROOTS
When the discriminant ( a_1^2 - 4a_2 < 0 ), we have complex roots. The roots are conjugate complex numbers of the form ( r_1 = h + vi ) and ( r_2 = h - vi ), where ( i = \sqrt{-1} ).
The real part is ( h = -\frac{a_1}{2} ) and the imaginary part is ( v = \frac{\sqrt{4a_2 - a_1^2}}{2} ).
The complementary function for complex roots can be expressed using trigonometric functions via Euler's formula: [ y_c = e^{ht} (A_5 \cos vt + A_6 \sin vt) ]
π Definition β Complex (Conjugate) Roots: Characteristic roots where the discriminant is negative (( a_1^2 < 4a_2 )), resulting in two roots of the form ( h \pm vi ) that are complex conjugates.
π Formula: Complementary function ( y_c = e^{ht} (A_5 \cos vt + A_6 \sin vt) ), where ( h = -\frac{a_1}{2} ) and ( v = \frac{\sqrt{4a_2 - a_1^2}}{2} ).
π Example: Solve ( y''(t) + 2y'(t) + 17y = 34 ), given ( y(0) = 3 ) and ( y'(0) = 11 ).
Step 1: Identify parameters. ( a_1 = 2, a_2 = 17, b = 34 ).
Step 2: Check discriminant. ( a_1^2 - 4a_2 = 4 - 68 = -64 < 0 ). This is Complex Roots.
Step 3: Compute ( h ) and ( v ). ( h = -\frac{2}{2} = -1 ). ( v = \frac{\sqrt{68 - 4}}{2} = \frac{\sqrt{64}}{2} = \frac{8}{2} = 4 ). So roots are ( r_1 = -1 + 4i ) and ( r_2 = -1 - 4i ).
Step 4: Complementary function. ( y_c = e^{-t} (A_5 \cos 4t + A_6 \sin 4t) ).
Step 5: Find particular integral. Try ( y_p = k ). Substituting: ( 0 + 0 + 17k = 34 \Rightarrow k = 2 ). So ( y_p = 2 ).
Step 6: General solution. ( y(t) = e^{-t} (A_5 \cos 4t + A_6 \sin 4t) + 2 ).
Step 7: Use ( y(0) = 3 ). ( y(0) = e^0 (A_5 \cos 0 + A_6 \sin 0) + 2 = A_5(1) + A_6(0) + 2 = 3 \Rightarrow A_5 = 1 ).
Step 8: Derivative. Using product rule: ( y'(t) = e^{-t}(-A_5 \cos 4t - A_6 \sin 4t) + e^{-t}(-4A_5 \sin 4t + 4A_6 \cos 4t) ).
Step 9: Use ( y'(0) = 11 ). With ( A_5 = 1 ): ( y'(0) = (1)(-1(1) - A_6(0)) + (1)(-4(1)(0) + 4A_6(1)) = -1 + 4A_6 = 11 \Rightarrow 4A_6 = 12 \Rightarrow A_6 = 3 ).
Step 10: Definite solution. ( y(t) = e^{-t} (\cos 4t + 3 \sin 4t) + 2 ).
Interpretation: The solution ( y(t) = e^{-t}(\cos 4t + 3 \sin 4t) + 2 ) exhibits damped oscillations β it oscillates (due to the sine and cosine terms) but the amplitude decays to zero (due to the ( e^{-t} ) term), converging to equilibrium ( y_p = 2 ). The Argand diagram graphically represents a complex number ( h + vi ) as a point in a 2D plane with coordinates ( (h, v) ) and distance from origin ( R = \sqrt{h^2 + v^2} ). π‘ Why this matters: Complex roots model economic variables that oscillate around equilibrium before settling, like exchange rates or business cycles.
SECOND-ORDER DIFFERENTIAL EQUATION: SUMMARY OF COMPLEMENTARY FUNCTION
The summary table for all three cases of the complementary function ( y_c ) for ( y'' + a_1 y' + a_2 y = b ) is:
| Condition | ( a_1^2 - 4a_2 > 0 ) | ( a_1^2 - 4a_2 = 0 ) | ( a_1^2 - 4a_2 < 0 ) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Root Nature | Distinct Real Roots | Repeated Real Roots | Complex Roots |
| Root Formula | ( r_1, r_2 = \frac{-a_1 \pm \sqrt{a_1^2 - 4a_2}}{2} ) | ( r = -\frac{a_1}{2} ) | ( r_1, r_2 = h \pm vi ), ( h = -\frac{a_1}{2} ), ( v = \frac{\sqrt{4a_2 - a_1^2}}{2} ) |
| Verification | ( r_1 + r_2 = -a_1 ), ( r_1 \times r_2 = a_2 ) | ( r_1 + r_2 = -a_1 ), ( r_1 \times r_2 = a_2 ) | ( r_1 + r_2 = -a_1 ), ( r_1 \times r_2 = a_2 ) |
| Complementary Function ( y_c ) | ( A_1 e^{r_1 t} + A_2 e^{r_2 t} ) | ( A_3 e^{rt} + A_4 t e^{rt} ) | ( e^{ht}(A_5 \cos vt + A_6 \sin vt) ) |
| Dynamic Stability | Both ( r_1, r_2 < 0 ) | ( r < 0 ) | ( h < 0 ) |
SECOND-ORDER DIFFERENTIAL EQUATION: DYNAMIC STABILITY OF DISTINCT REAL ROOTS
Dynamic stability refers to whether the solution ( y(t) ) converges to the equilibrium (particular integral ( y_p )) as time ( t \to \infty ). The deviation from equilibrium is ( y_c = A_1 e^{r_1 t} + A_2 e^{r_2 t} ). Stability depends entirely on the sign of the characteristic roots.
- If both roots ( r_1 ) and ( r_2 ) are negative (( < 0 )), then both exponential terms ( e^{r_1 t} ) and ( e^{r_2 t} ) undergo exponential decay and approach zero as ( t \to \infty ). Thus, ( y_c \to 0 ) and ( y(t) \to y_p ). This is dynamically stable (convergence).
- If either root is positive (( > 0 )), that exponential term grows without bound as ( t \to \infty ), so ( y_c \to \infty ) and ( y(t) ) diverges from equilibrium. This is dynamically unstable (divergence).
π Example (Numerical Confirmation):
| Case | Equation | Roots ( r_1, r_2 ) | ( t \to \infty ) | Dynamic Stability |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ( y(t) = 4e^{t} + 3e^{2t} + 5 ) | ( +1, +2 ) (both positive) | Both terms increase β ( y_c \uparrow \uparrow ) | Unstable (Divergence) |
| 2 | ( y(t) = 4e^{t} + 3e^{-2t} + 5 ) | ( +1 ) (positive), ( -2 ) (negative) | First term increases faster than second decays β ( y_c \uparrow ) | Unstable (Divergence) |
| 3 | ( y(t) = 4e^{-t} + 3e^{-2t} + 5 ) | ( -1, -2 ) (both negative) | Both terms decrease to zero β ( y_c \downarrow ) to 0 | Stable (Convergence) |
The numerical table in the lecture confirms this: At ( t = 0 ), all three cases start at ( y_c = 7 ). By ( t = 6 ), Case 1's deviation explodes to ( \approx 489,878 ), Case 2's to ( \approx 1614 ), but Case 3's deviation shrinks to ( \approx 0.01 ), confirming convergence. Hence, dynamic stability requires BOTH roots to be negative: ( (r_1 \text{ and } r_2) < 0 ).
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts from this lecture are: (1) When the discriminant ( a_1^2 - 4a_2 = 0 ), the solution has repeated real roots and the complementary function includes a ( t e^{rt} ) term. (2) When the discriminant is negative, the solution has complex conjugate roots ( h \pm vi ), leading to oscillatory behavior captured by ( e^{ht}(A_5 \cos vt + A_6 \sin vt) ). (3) The particular integral ( y_p ) for a constant ( b ) is found by assuming a constant solution ( y = k ). (4) Dynamic stability for distinct real roots requires that both characteristic roots be negative; if either root is positive, the system diverges from equilibrium. (5) For repeated roots, stability requires the single root ( r < 0 ); for complex roots, stability requires the real part ( h < 0 ) (damped oscillations).
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What condition on the discriminant ( a_1^2 - 4a_2 ) leads to repeated real roots, and what is the corresponding formula for the complementary function?
- For the differential equation ( y'' + 2y' + 17y = 34 ), what are the values of ( h ) and ( v ) in the complementary function ( e^{ht}(A_5 \cos vt + A_6 \sin vt) )?
- Explain why the term ( A_4 t e^{rt} ) is necessary in the complementary function for repeated real roots.
- State the condition for dynamic stability in the case of distinct real roots. What happens to the deviation from equilibrium if one root is positive and the other negative?
- In the example ( y(t) = 4e^{-t} + 3e^{-2t} + 5 ), what is the value of the deviation from equilibrium ( y_c ) as ( t \to 6 )? (Refer to the numerical table.)
π Lecture 30 β SECOND ORDER DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS (CONTINUED 2)
π Overview: This lecture completes the analysis of dynamic stability in second-order differential equations, examining the conditions under which repeated real roots and complex roots lead to convergence or divergence from equilibrium. It also introduces alternative forms for representing complex rootsβCartesian, Polar, and Exponentialβand explains how to convert between them, which is essential for solving and interpreting dynamic economic models.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers four main topics: dynamic stability analysis for the case of repeated real roots, where the role of a negative root in ensuring convergence is confirmed; dynamic stability analysis for complex roots, where the real part of the root determines convergence or divergence through a multiplier effect; the three alternative forms of representing complex roots (Cartesian, Polar, and Exponential) along with De Moivre's theorem for raising them to powers; and interconversion among these three forms using basic trigonometric relationships and the Pythagorean theorem.
π Lecture Summary
TOPIC 132: SECOND-ORDER DIFFERENTIAL EQUATION: DYNAMIC STABILITY OF REPEATED REAL ROOTS
The general solution for a second-order differential equation with repeated real roots is given by:
ν(ν) = ν¨β ν^(νν) + ν¨β ν ν^(νν) + νβ
Here, ν¨β and ν¨β are constants determined by initial conditions, and ν is the independent variable spanning (0, β). The complementary function (νπ = ν¨β ν^(νν) + ν¨β ν ν^(νν)) represents the deviation from equilibrium. Dynamic stability depends entirely on the root (ν).
If ν is negative (-ve), both exponential terms undergo exponential decay. Although the second term (ν¨β ν ν^(νν)) has an additional factor of ν, this does not reverse the decaying dynamics. As ν β β, the exponential decay dominates the linear multiplier, and the sum of the two exponential terms fades to zero, meaning νπ β 0 and the system converges to equilibrium.
π Definition β Exponential Decay: A process where a quantity decreases at a rate proportional to its current value, causing it to approach zero as time increases.
π Formula: ν(ν) = ν¨β ν^(νν) + ν¨β ν ν^(νν) + νβ
β The deviation from equilibrium (νπ = ν¨β ν^(νν) + ν¨β ν ν^(νν)) will converge to zero if and only if the root ν is negative (ν < 0).
π Example:
Two cases are compared numerically.
Case 1 (positive root): ν(ν) = 2ν^(Β³α΅) + νν^(Β³α΅) + 3
At t=0: νπ = 2+0 = 2. At t=1: 2νΒ³ β 40.2, ννΒ³ β 20.1, sum β 60.3. At t=5: 2νΒΉβ΅ β 6,538,034.7, ννΒΉβ΅ β 16,345,086.9, sum β 22,883,121.6. Both exponential terms increase β deviation increases β dynamically unstable (divergence).
Case 2 (negative root): ν(ν) = 2ν^(β»Β³α΅) + νν^(β»Β³α΅) + 3
At t=0: νπ = 2+0 = 2. At t=1: 2νβ»Β³ β 0.0996, ννβ»Β³ β 0.0498, sum β 0.1494. At t=5: 2νβ»ΒΉβ΅ β 0.0000006, ννβ»ΒΉβ΅ β 0.000002, sum β 0.000002. Both exponential terms decrease β deviation decreases β dynamically stable (convergence).
π‘ Why this matters: This confirms numerically that for dynamic stability with repeated real roots, the root must be negative, ν < 0.
TOPIC 133: SECOND-ORDER DIFFERENTIAL EQUATION: DYNAMIC STABILITY OF COMPLEX ROOTS
The general solution for a complex roots case is:
ν(ν) = ν^(νν) (ν¨β
cos(νν) + ν¨β sin(νν)) + νβ
The deviation from equilibrium is νπ = ν^(νν) (ν¨β cos(νν) + ν¨β sin(νν)). The multiplicand (ν¨β cos(νν) + ν¨β sin(νν)) produces a wave-like graph with uniform amplitude above and below equilibrium, meaning by itself it cannot cause convergence. The multiplier ν^(νν) determines dynamic stability. If ν is negative, then ν^(νν) β 0 as ν β β, mitigating the amplitude and causing damped fluctuation and convergence to equilibrium.
π Definition β Damped Fluctuation: Oscillatory behavior around an equilibrium where the amplitude of oscillation decreases over time due to a negative exponential multiplier, leading to convergence.
π Formula: ν(ν) = ν^(νν) (ν¨β
cos(νν) + ν¨β sin(νν)) + νβ
β For dynamic stability, the real part of the complex root (ν) must be negative (ν < 0). This ensures the multiplier ν^(νν) decays to zero.
π Example:
Three cases of ν(ν) = ν^(νν)(cos(4ν) + 3 sin(4ν)) + 2 are compared.
Case 1 (positive h, h=1): ν^(ΒΉΒ·ΒΉα΅) grows explosively. At t=0: νπ = 1. At t=3: amplitude ~20.1. At t=9: amplitude ~8103.1. This produces explosive fluctuation and divergence β dynamically unstable.
Case 2 (zero h, h=0): ν^(β°Β·α΅) = 1, so νπ = (cos(4ν) + 3 sin(4ν)). The amplitude remains uniform over time. At t=0: 1. At t=3: -0.8. At t=9: -3.1. This produces uniform fluctuation, neither diverging nor converging β unstable (not dynamically stable).
Case 3 (negative h, h=-1): ν^(β»ΒΉΒ·α΅) decays. At t=0: νπ = 1. At t=3: ~0.0498 Γ (-0.8) β -0.0381. At t=9: ~0.0001 Γ (-3.1) β -0.0004. This produces damped fluctuation and convergence β dynamically stable.
π‘ Why this matters: This numerically confirms that for dynamic stability with complex roots, the real part of the root (ν) must be negative: ν < 0.
TOPIC 134: ALTERNATIVE FORMS OF COMPLEX ROOTS
Complex roots can be expressed in three alternative forms. The Cartesian Form is (ν Β± νν), based on Quadrant I of cartesian coordinates with ν on the x-axis and ν on the y-axis. The Polar Form (also called Triangular Form) is {νΉ(cos ν½ Β± ν sin ν½)}, based on polar functions with angles (ν½). The Exponential Form is (νΉν^(Β±νν½)), based on the exponential function.
De Moivre's Theorem states that if a complex number has a power ν other than 1, all three forms can be rewritten:
- Cartesian Form with ν β 1: Simply raise (ν Β± νν) to the power ν.
- Exponential Form with ν β 1: (νΉ ν^(Β±νν½))^ν = νΉβΏ ν^(Β±ννν½). Here νΉ is raised to νΉβΏ and ν^(Β±νν½) is raised to ν^(Β±ν(νν½)).
- Polar Form with ν β 1: Using the Exponential form observation, νΉ is raised to νΉβΏ and ν½ becomes νν½: νΉβΏ {cos(νν½) Β± ν sin(νν½)}.
π Definition β De Moivre's Theorem: A formula for raising complex numbers to any integer power ν, such that (ν Β± νν)^ν = νΉ^ν [cos(νν½) Β± ν sin(νν½)] = νΉ^ν ν^(Β±ννν½).
π Formula:
(ν Β± νν)^ν = νΉβΏν^(Β±ννν½) = νΉβΏ{cos(νν½) Β± ν sin(νν½)}
β This provides a universal rule for raising any form of a complex number to a power.
TOPIC 135: ALTERNATIVE FORMS OF COMPLEX ROOTS: INTERCONVERSION
Interconversion among the three forms uses basic trigonometric ratios and the Pythagorean Theorem. For a vector in the complex plane with base ν, perpendicular ν, and hypotenuse νΉ:
- sin ν½ = ν/νΉ, so ν = νΉ sin ν½ and ν½ = sinβ»ΒΉ(ν/νΉ)
- cos ν½ = ν/νΉ, so ν = νΉ cos ν½ and ν½ = cosβ»ΒΉ(ν/νΉ)
- Pythagorean Theorem: νΉΒ² = νΒ² + νΒ², so νΉ = β(νΒ² + νΒ²)
π Example 6 (p-520): Find the Cartesian form of the Exponential form 5ν^(Β³Β·νΒ·ν /Β²).
Solution: From the standard form νΉν^(Β±νν½), we have νΉ = 5 and ν½ = Β³ν
/Β².
Using ν = νΉ sin ν½ and ν = νΉ cos ν½:
ν = 5 cos(Β³ν
/Β²) = 5 Γ (0) = 0
ν = 5 sin(Β³ν
/Β²) = 5 Γ (-1) = -5
Cartesian Form: ν Β± νν = 0 Β± (-5)ν = -5ν
Polar Form: {5[cos(Β³ν
/Β²) Β± ν sin(Β³ν
/Β²)]}
π Example 7 (p-520): Find Polar and Exponential forms of the Cartesian form (1 + β3 ν).
Solution: From the standard form (ν Β± νν), we have ν = 1 and ν = β3.
Using νΉ = β(νΒ² + νΒ²): νΉ = β(1Β² + (β3)Β²) = β(1 + 3) = 2
Using ν½ = sinβ»ΒΉ(ν/νΉ) = sinβ»ΒΉ(β3/2) = 60Β° (or ν
/3)
Polar Form: {2(cos 60Β° Β± ν sin 60Β°)}
Exponential Form: 2ν^(Β±ν(ν
/Β³))
π‘ Why this matters: Interconversion among the three forms is essential for solving differential equations as it allows choosing the most convenient form for analysisβCartesian for direct algebraic manipulation, Polar for visualizing magnitude and angle, and Exponential for handling powers and derivatives.
β Key Takeaways
For a second-order differential equation, dynamic stability requires the repeated real root to be negative (ν < 0) so the complementary function decays to zero despite the presence of a time multiplier. For complex roots, stability requires the real part of the root (ν) to be negative (ν < 0), causing damped fluctuation toward equilibriumβa positive ν leads to explosive fluctuation and divergence. Complex roots can be represented in three interconvertible forms: Cartesian (ν Β± νν), Polar {νΉ(cos ν½ Β± ν sin ν½)}, and Exponential (νΉν^(Β±νν½)), with De Moivre's theorem providing the formula for raising any of these forms to a power ν: νΉβΏ{cos(νν½) Β± ν sin(νν½)}. Mastery of interconversion using trigonometric ratios and the Pythagorean theorem enables seamless shifting between forms for effective analysis and solution of dynamic economic models.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- For the repeated real roots case, why does the term ν¨β ν ν^(νν) not prevent convergence even though it has a time multiplier, when ν is negative?
- In the complex roots case, what determines whether fluctuation is damped, uniform, or explosive, and what condition must be met for dynamic stability?
- Write the three alternative forms (Cartesian, Polar, Exponential) for the complex number ν = β1 + β3 ν, using the conversions provided.
- State De Moivre's theorem for raising a complex number to power ν and explain how it applies to each of the three forms.
- If the exponential form of a complex root is 3ν^(β»νν /2), what is its Cartesian form?
π Lecture 31 β A Market Model with Price Expectations
π Overview: This lecture extends the basic market model by incorporating price expectations into the demand function. It introduces a framework where current quantity demanded depends not only on current price but also on price trends (first and second derivatives of price over time). The lecture derives the general solution for the time path of price under market-clearing conditions and analyzes dynamic stability based on key parameters.
ποΈ Topics Covered
Lecture 31 covers the framework and rationale for a market model with price expectations, including how price trends are measured mathematically and how they augment the demand function. It then provides the general solution to the second-order differential equation that arises from the market-clearing condition. The lecture proceeds to examine the possible cases of complementary functions (distinct real, repeated real, and complex roots) based on the discriminant and analyzes the conditions for dynamic stability. Finally, two detailed numerical examples are solved to demonstrate the application of the model and the determination of the time path P(t).
π Lecture Summary
Topic 136: A Market Model with Price Expectations: Framework
In a simple market model, current quantity demanded (Qd) and current quantity supplied (Qs) depend only on current price (P). However, in real life, the trend of price changes can affect Qd because trends help form price expectations. These expectations influence current buying decisions.
The trend is understood from two aspects:
- Rate of change of price: Is price increasing or decreasing over time? (dP/dt)
- Slope of the rate of change: Is the rate of change itself increasing or decreasing over time? (dΒ²P/dtΒ²)
Mathematically, the trend is measured using first and second-order derivatives. The new demand and supply functions are expressed as:
Qd = f( P(t) , dP(t)/dt , dΒ²P(t)/dtΒ² ) Qs = f( P(t) , dP(t)/dt , dΒ²P(t)/dtΒ² )
This means current quantities depend on current price and the price-trend. The general equations for the price-expectations-augmented functions are:
Qd = a - bP + mP' + nP'' (where a, b > 0) Qs = -Ξ³ + Ξ΄P + uP' + wP'' (where Ξ³, Ξ΄ > 0)
Here, a, b, Ξ³, Ξ΄ are conventional parameters, while m, n, u, w are parameters generated by terms of price expectations.
The lecture assumes price expectations exist in the demand function only and not in the supply function (so u = 0, w = 0). Effect of m and n on demand: If m > 0, Qd increases because buyers expect prices to rise and buy now. If n > 0, Qd increases even faster as the rate of price increase is accelerating.
Topic 137: A Market Model with Price Expectations: Solution
Assuming market-clearing at all points in time (Qd = Qs), the equation is: a - bP + mP' + nP'' = -Ξ³ + Ξ΄P
Rearranging and normalizing by dividing by n gives the standard second-order linear differential equation form:
P'' + aβP' + aβP = b
Where:
- aβ = m/n
- aβ = -(b+Ξ΄)/n
- b = -(a+Ξ³)/n
The particular solution (Pp) is found using Case I (since aβ β 0): Pp = b / aβ = (a+Ξ³) / (b+Ξ΄)
Since all parameters are positive constants, Pp is also a constant value. This implies the model has a stationary equilibrium.
Topic 138: A Market Model with Price Expectations: Possible Cases
The nature of the complementary function (Pc) depends on the discriminant, leading to three cases:
-
Distinct Real Roots (aβΒ² > 4aβ): For this, the condition is (m/n)Β² > -4(b+Ξ΄)/n.
- Pc = Aβe^(rβt) + Aβe^(rβt)
- The general solution is P(t) = Aβe^(rβt) + Aβe^(rβt) + (a+Ξ³)/(b+Ξ΄).
-
Repeated Real Roots (aβΒ² = 4aβ): For this, the condition is (m/n)Β² = -4(b+Ξ΄)/n.
- Pc = Aβe^(rt) + Aβte^(rt), where r = -m/(2n).
- The general solution is P(t) = Aβe^(-mt/(2n)) + Aβte^(-mt/(2n)) + (a+Ξ³)/(b+Ξ΄).
-
Complex Roots (aβΒ² < 4aβ): For this, the condition is (m/n)Β² < -4(b+Ξ΄)/n.
- Pc = e^(ht) (Aβ cos ut + Aβ sin ut), where h = -aβ/2 = -m/(2n) and u = (1/2)β(4aβ - aβΒ²).
- The general solution is P(t) = e^(-mt/(2n)) (Aβ cos ut + Aβ sin ut) + (a+Ξ³)/(b+Ξ΄).
Parametric Interpretation for Dynamic Stability:
- The parameter
nplays a pivotal role. - If n > 0: Only Distinct Real Roots can exist (rβ > 0, rβ < 0), making the system dynamically unstable. It can only be stable if Aβ = 0.
- If n < 0: All three cases are possible. Dynamic stability is ensured if m < 0 (the price coefficient on the first derivative) in any of these cases.
π‘ Why this matters: The sign of n (the coefficient for the second derivative of price in the demand function) is the primary determinant of dynamic stability in this model.
Topic 139: A Market Model with Price Expectations: Numerical Examples
Example 1 (p. 530) Given: Qd = 42 - 4P - 4P' + P'', Qs = -6 + 8P, with P(0)=6, P'(0)=4.
- Comparison with standard form: a=42, b=4, Ξ³=6, Ξ΄=8, m=-4, n=1, u=0, w=0.
- Since n=1 > 0, only distinct real roots are possible, and dynamic instability is present unless Aβ=0.
- Roots are found: rβ=6, rβ=-2. The particular solution Pp = (42+6)/(4+8) = 48/12 = 4.
- The general solution is P(t) = Aβe^(6t) + Aβe^(-2t) + 4.
- Using initial conditions to find Aβ and Aβ:
- P(0)=6 => 6 = Aβ + Aβ + 4 => Aβ + Aβ = 2.
- P'(0)=4 => 4 = 6Aβ - 2Aβ.
- Solving: Aβ=1, Aβ=1.
- The definite solution is P(t) = e^(6t) + e^(-2t) + 4.
- Interpretation: Since n>0 and Aββ 0, the path is dynamically unstable due to the positive root rβ=6.
Example 2 (p. 531) Given: Qd = 40 - 2P - 2P' - P'', Qs = -5 + 3P, with P(0)=12, P'(0)=1.
- Comparison: a=40, b=2, Ξ³=5, Ξ΄=3, m=-2, n=-1, u=0, w=0.
- Since n=-1 < 0 and m=-2 < 0, dynamic stability is present.
- Test for nature of roots: (m/n)Β² = 4, -4(b+Ξ΄)/n = 20. Since 4 < 20, complex roots exist.
- Roots are: h = -1, u = 2. Particular solution Pp = 9.
- General solution: P(t) = e^(-t)(Aβ cos 2t + Aβ sin 2t) + 9.
- Using initial conditions:
- P(0)=12 => 12 = Aβ + 9 => Aβ = 3.
- P'(0)=1 => 1 = -Aβ + 2Aβ => 1 = -3 + 2Aβ => Aβ = 2.
- The definite solution is P(t) = e^(-t)(3 cos 2t + 2 sin 2t) + 9.
- Interpretation: Since n<0 and m<0, dynamic stability is present. The time path is a dampened fluctuation.
β Key Takeaways
The core of this lecture is understanding how price expectations, modeled through the first (dP/dt) and second (dΒ²P/dtΒ²) derivatives of price, modify the standard demand function. The resulting market model leads to a second-order linear differential equation for the time path of price. The dynamic stability of this model is critically determined by the signs of n and m: when n > 0, the system is generally unstable, while when n < 0 and m < 0, it is dynamically stable. The solution for the time path P(t) involves a particular solution representing the stationary equilibrium and a complementary function whose form (exponential or sinusoidal) depends on the nature of the characteristic roots. The two numerical examples illustrate how to derive the definite time path and interpret its dynamic properties based on parameter values.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- How do price expectations change the standard demand function in this model?
- What are the two aspects of a price trend considered in this framework?
- Write the standard form of the second-order differential equation obtained from the market-clearing condition.
- For dynamic stability, what must be true about the signs of parameters
nandm? - In Example 1, why is the price time path dynamically unstable?