π Lecture Summary
THE CLASSICAL DICHOTOMY
Real variables are measured in physical units: quantities and relative prices. Examples include quantity of output produced, real wage (output earned per hour of work), and real interest rate (output earned in the future by lending one unit of output today). Nominal variables are measured in money units. Examples include nominal wage (dollars per hour of work), nominal interest rate (dollars earned in future by lending one dollar today), and the price level (amount of dollars needed to buy a representative basket of goods).
Classical Dichotomy is the theoretical separation of real and nominal variables in the classical model, which implies nominal variables do not affect real variables.
π Definition β Neutrality of Money: Changes in the money supply do not affect real variables. In the real world, money is approximately neutral in the long run.
THE OPEN ECONOMY
IMPORTS AND EXPORTS AS A PERCENTAGE OF OUTPUT
A chart shows that for countries like Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, the U.K., the U.S., and Pakistan, both imports and exports as percentages of GDP vary significantly. In an open economy, spending need not equal output and saving need not equal investment.
Preliminaries
The lecture defines notation:
C = C^d + C^f
I = I^d + I^f
G = G^d + G^f
Superscripts:
- d = spending on domestic goods
- f = spending on foreign goods
EX = exports = foreign spending on domestic goods
IM = imports = C^f + I^f + G^f = spending on foreign goods
NX = net exports (the "trade balance") = EX β IM
If NX > 0, country has a trade surplus equal to NX. If NX < 0, country has a trade deficit equal to βNX.
GDP = Expenditure on domestically produced goods and services
Y = C^d + I^d + G^d + EX
Y = (C β C^f) + (I β I^f) + (G β G^f) + EX
Y = C + I + G + EX β (C^f + I^f + G^f)
Y = C + I + G + EX β IM
Y = C + I + G + NX
THE NATIONAL INCOME IDENTITY IN AN OPEN ECONOMY
Y = C + I + G + NX
Or equivalently:
NX = Y β (C + I + G)
Where NX is Net Exports, Y is Output, and C + I + G is Domestic Spending.
NET FOREIGN INVESTMENT AND TRADE BALANCE
Starting from Y = C + I + G + NX:
Re-arranging: Y β C β G = I + NX
Recall that Y β C β G is national savings (S), which is the sum of private savings (Y β T β C) and public savings (T β G).
Hence:
S = I + NX
Or S β I = NX
S β I is the difference between domestic saving and domestic investment, referred to as Net Foreign Investment. NX is the Trade Balance.
π Definition β Net Foreign Investment = Trade Balance: S β I = NX
INTERNATIONAL CAPITAL FLOWS
Net capital outflows = S β I = net outflow of "loanable funds" = net purchases of foreign assets
Net capital outflows refer to the country's purchases of foreign assets minus foreign purchases of domestic assets. When S > I, the country is a net lender. When S < I, the country is a net borrower.
An open-economy version of the loanable funds model includes many of the same elements.
SAVING AND INVESTMENT IN A SMALL OPEN ECONOMY
The model includes:
- production function: Y = YΜ = F(KΜ, LΜ)
- consumption function: C = C(Y β T)
- investment function: I = I(r)
- exogenous policy variables: G = GΜ, T = TΜ
NATIONAL SAVING: THE SUPPLY OF LOANABLE FUNDS
S = Y β C(Y β T) β GΜ
National saving does not depend on the interest rate.
ASSUMPTIONS: CAPITAL FLOWS
- Domestic and foreign bonds are perfect substitutes
- Perfect capital mobility: no restrictions on international trade in assets
- Economy is small: cannot affect the world interest rate, denoted r*
INVESTMENT: DEMAND FOR LOANABLE FUNDS
Investment is still a downward-sloping function of the interest rate, but the exogenous world interest rate determines the country's level of investment.
CLOSED ECONOMY
In a closed economy, the interest rate would adjust to equate investment and saving: the equilibrium occurs where S = I at the closed-economy interest rate r_c.
A SMALL OPEN ECONOMY
The exogenous world interest rate r* determines investment. The difference between saving and investment (S β I) determines net capital outflows and net exports (NX).
π Formula: NX = S β I
β In a small open economy, the trade balance equals the difference between national saving and domestic investment.
π Example: If r_c > r*, then at the world interest rate, S > I, so NX > 0 (trade surplus). The country is a net lender abroad.
β Key Takeaways
The classical dichotomy separates real and nominal variables, with money being neutral in the long run. In an open economy, the national income identity becomes Y = C + I + G + NX, and rearranging shows that the trade balance NX equals the difference between national saving and domestic investment (S β I), which is also net foreign investment. For a small open economy with perfect capital mobility, the world interest rate r* is exogenous, so domestic investment is determined by r* rather than by domestic saving. The gap between saving and investment at the world interest rate determines whether the country runs a trade surplus (S > I) or deficit (S < I). Understanding these relationships is essential for analyzing how fiscal policy, trade policy, and global financial conditions affect a country's external balance.
π‘ Why this matters: The S β I = NX identity is the fundamental framework for understanding trade deficits and surpluses as reflections of national saving and investment decisions.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the classical dichotomy and what does it imply about the relationship between nominal and real variables?
- Write the open economy national income identity and derive the relationship between net foreign investment and the trade balance.
- What are the three key assumptions of the small open economy loanable funds model regarding capital flows?
- If a small open economy has a closed-economy interest rate r_c above the world interest rate r*, does it run a trade surplus or deficit? Explain why.
- What determines whether a country is a net lender or net borrower in international capital markets?
π Lecture 15 β THE OPEN ECONOMY (CONTINUED)
π Overview: This lecture continues the analysis of the open economy by examining the effects of three key economic experiments: fiscal policy at home, fiscal policy abroad, and changes in investment demand. It then introduces the nominal and real exchange rates and explains how the real exchange rate influences net exports. Understanding these relationships is crucial for predicting how domestic and foreign policies affect trade balances and capital flows.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture explores three experiments in the open economy: fiscal policy at home (which reduces saving and creates net export deficits), fiscal policy abroad (which raises the world interest rate), and an increase in investment demand (which reduces net exports). It then defines the nominal exchange rate as the relative price of domestic currency, introduces the real exchange rate as the relative price of domestic goods in terms of foreign goods, and demonstrates how the real exchange rate affects net exports through its impact on relative prices.
π Lecture Summary
THREE EXPERIMENTS
1. Fiscal Policy at Home
An increase in government spending (G) or a decrease in taxes (T) reduces national saving. In the open economy model, the supply of loanable funds (saving) shifts leftward from Sβ to Sβ. At the world interest rate (rβ*), investment (I) remains unchanged, but the reduction in saving means that net capital outflows and net exports (NX) must fall. The budget deficit created by expansionary fiscal policy leads to a corresponding net export deficit.
π Definition β Net Export Deficit: A situation where a country imports more than it exports, represented by a negative net export value (NX < 0), which mirrors the government budget deficit in this model.
π Result: ΞI = 0, ΞNX = ΞS < 0
π Example: If the government increases spending by $100 billion (ΞG = +100), national saving falls by $100 billion. Since investment is fixed at the world interest rate (ΞI = 0), net exports must also fall by $100 billion (ΞNX = β100). The budget deficit of $100 billion creates an equal trade deficit.
π‘ Why this matters: This result shows that under a small open economy with perfect capital mobility, expansionary fiscal policy does not crowd out investment but instead crowds out net exports.
2. Fiscal Policy Abroad
When a foreign country undertakes expansionary fiscal policy, it increases the world interest rate (r*) from rβ* to rβ*. This occurs because foreign governments borrow more, increasing global demand for loanable funds. For the domestic economy, the higher world interest rate reduces domestic investment (I falls along the I(r) curve). Since domestic saving (S) remains unchanged, the reduction in investment means that net capital outflows and net exports (NX) must increase.
π Definition β World Interest Rate (r):* The interest rate determined in global financial markets that small open economies take as given.
π Result: ΞI < 0, ΞNX = βΞI > 0
π Example: Suppose foreign fiscal policy raises r* from 5% to 6%. If domestic investment falls from $500 billion to $450 billion (ΞI = β50), and saving remains at $600 billion, then net exports increase from NXβ = $100 billion to NXβ = $150 billion (ΞNX = +50).
π‘ Why this matters: This demonstrates that one country's fiscal policy can have significant spillover effects on another country's trade balance through changes in world interest rates.
3. An Increase in Investment Demand
An increase in investment demand shifts the I(r) curve rightward from I(r)β to I(r)β. At the world interest rate (r*), domestic investment increases (ΞI > 0), while domestic saving (S) remains unchanged. The increase in investment is financed by borrowing from abroad, which reduces net capital outflows. Consequently, net exports (NX) fall by exactly the amount of the increase in investment.
π Definition β Investment Demand: The amount of investment spending that firms plan to undertake at each interest rate, which can increase due to technological advances, business optimism, or tax incentives.
π Result: ΞI > 0, ΞS = 0, net capital outflows and net exports fall by the amount ΞI
π Example: If a technological boom increases investment from $400 billion to $500 billion (ΞI = +100), and saving remains at $550 billion, then net exports fall from NXβ = $150 billion to NXβ = $50 billion (ΞNX = β100).
THE NOMINAL EXCHANGE RATE
e = nominal exchange rate, the relative price of domestic currency in terms of foreign currency (e.g., Yen per Dollar)
π Definition β Nominal Exchange Rate: The rate at which one country's currency can be exchanged for another country's currency.
Example (Exchange rates as of February 26, 2005):
- Euro (β¬): Rs. 78.53
- Japanese Yen (Β₯): Rs. 0.5642
- U.K. Pound (Β£): Rs. 113.99
- U.S. Dollar ($): Rs. 59.32
- UAE Dirham: Rs. 16.15
THE REAL EXCHANGE RATE
Ξ΅ = real exchange rate, the relative price of domestic goods in terms of foreign goods (e.g., Japanese Big Macs per U.S. Big Mac)
π Definition β Real Exchange Rate: The rate at which domestic goods can be exchanged for foreign goods, adjusting for price levels.
π Formula: Ξ΅ = (e Γ P) / P*
- e = nominal exchange rate (foreign currency per domestic currency)
- P = domestic price level
- P* = foreign price level
Understanding the Units of Ξ΅: Ξ΅ = e Γ P = (Yen per $) Γ ($ per unit U.S. goods) = Yen per unit U.S. goods = Units of Japanese goods per unit of U.S. goods P* Yen per unit Japanese goods
π Example: Suppose there is one good, Burger. The price of burger in Japan is P* = 200 Yen. The price in USA is P = $2.50. Nominal exchange rate, e = 120 Yen/$. Calculate the real exchange rate: Ξ΅ = e Γ P = 120 Γ $2.50 = 300 = 1.5 P* 200 Yen 200
This real exchange rate shows that to buy a U.S. burger, someone from Japan would have to pay an amount that could buy 1.5 Japanese Burgers.
π‘ Why this matters: The real exchange rate measures the true purchasing power of domestic goods in international markets, accounting for both currency values and price levels.
Ξ΅ IN THE REAL WORLD & OUR MODEL
In the real world: We can think of Ξ΅ as the relative price of a basket of domestic goods in terms of a basket of foreign goods. In our macro model, there is just one good, "output." So Ξ΅ is the relative price of one country's output in terms of the other country's output.
HOW NX DEPENDS ON Ξ΅
βΞ΅ β US goods become more expensive relative to foreign goods β βEX, βIM β βNX
π Definition β Net Exports (NX): The value of a country's exports minus the value of its imports, also equal to net capital outflow.
π Example: If the real exchange rate (Ξ΅) rises from 1.0 to 1.2, U.S. goods are 20% more expensive relative to foreign goods. U.S. exports fall (fewer foreigners buy expensive U.S. goods), while U.S. imports rise (Americans shift to cheaper foreign goods). Consequently, net exports decrease.
β Key Takeaways
- In a small open economy with perfect capital mobility, expansionary fiscal policy at home reduces national saving and creates a trade deficit of equal magnitude, since investment is fixed at the world interest rate and cannot be crowded out. 2. Fiscal policy abroad affects the domestic economy by raising the world interest rate, which reduces domestic investment and increases net exportsβdemonstrating significant international spillover effects. 3. An increase in investment demand at home reduces net exports by exactly the amount of the investment increase, as the additional investment is financed by foreign borrowing. 4. The real exchange rate (Ξ΅ = e Γ P / P*) measures the relative price of domestic goods in terms of foreign goods and directly determines net exports: a higher real exchange rate makes domestic goods more expensive, reducing net exports. 5. The nominal exchange rate is the relative price of currencies, but the real exchange rate is the key variable that affects trade flows because it adjusts for differences in price levels between countries.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
-
What happens to net exports when the home country increases government spending in a small open economy? Why?
-
How does expansionary fiscal policy abroad affect domestic investment and net exports?
-
If a technological boom increases domestic investment demand, what happens to net exports? Explain using the saving-investment diagram.
-
Calculate the real exchange rate given: e = 80 Yen/$, P = $3.00, P* = 240 Yen. What does this value mean?
-
If the real exchange rate increases (domestic goods become more expensive), what happens to exports, imports, and net exports?
π Lecture 16 β The Open Economy (Continued)
π Overview: This lecture explains how the real exchange rate (Ξ΅) is determined in an open economy through the relationship between net exports (NX) and net capital outflow (S - I). It examines how fiscal policy, investment changes, and trade policies affect the exchange rate and trade balance, and concludes by linking the real exchange rate to the nominal exchange rate and inflation.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the determination of the real exchange rate (Ξ΅) by equating net exports (NX) with net capital outflow (S - I), using supply and demand in the foreign exchange market. It introduces the net exports function (NX(Ξ΅)) and the NX curve, then analyzes four key experiments: fiscal policy at home, fiscal policy abroad, an increase in investment demand, and trade policy to restrict imports. Finally, it derives the determinants of the nominal exchange rate (e) from the real exchange rate and price levels, showing how inflation differentials drive nominal exchange rate changes.
π Lecture Summary
HOW Ξ΅ IS DETERMINED
The accounting identity states that net exports (NX) equal net capital outflow (S - I). Net capital outflow (S - I) is determined by domestic factors (saving S depends on output and fiscal policy) and the world interest rate (r*), which determines investment I. The real exchange rate Ξ΅ must adjust to ensure that net exports equal this net capital outflow: NX(Ξ΅) = S - I(r*). Since neither saving nor investment depend on Ξ΅, the net capital outflow curve (S - I) is vertical. The real exchange rate Ξ΅ adjusts to bring NX into equality with this fixed net capital outflow.
π Definition β Net Capital Outflow (S - I): The domestic supply of funds to be invested abroad; it is the difference between national saving and domestic investment. π Example: If domestic saving is $100 and domestic investment is $70, the net capital outflow is $30. This means $30 worth of domestic currency must be supplied in foreign exchange markets to be invested abroad.
SUPPLY AND DEMAND IN FOREIGN EXCHANGE MARKET
In the market for the home currency (e.g., the U.S. dollar), demand comes from foreigners who need dollars to buy the home country's net exports. Supply comes from the net capital outflow (S - I) β the dollars available to be invested abroad. The real exchange rate Ξ΅ adjusts to balance this supply and demand, ensuring NX = S - I.
π Definition β Supply of Dollars: The net capital outflow (S - I), which is the quantity of home currency supplied to the foreign exchange market for investment abroad. π Example: If U.S. net capital outflow is $50 billion, this is the supply of U.S. dollars to the foreign exchange market. Foreigners demanding dollars to buy U.S. exports must match this supply.
THE NET EXPORTS FUNCTION
The net exports function shows an inverse relationship between the real exchange rate (Ξ΅) and net exports (NX). When Ξ΅ is high, home goods become relatively expensive for foreigners, reducing exports and increasing imports, so NX falls. This is written as NX = NX(Ξ΅), where higher Ξ΅ leads to lower NX. π‘ Why this matters: This inverse relationship is the core mechanism through which the exchange rate adjusts to ensure trade balance.
THE NX CURVE
The NX curve is a downward-sloping line showing the inverse relationship between Ξ΅ and NX. When Ξ΅ is relatively low, home goods are inexpensive, so net exports are high. When Ξ΅ is relatively high, home goods become so expensive that the home country exports less than it imports (NX becomes negative).
π Definition β NX Curve: A graphical representation of the inverse relationship between the real exchange rate (Ξ΅) and net exports (NX). π Example: At Ξ΅β, NX is NXβ (positive). At Ξ΅β, where Ξ΅β > Ξ΅β, home goods are more expensive, so NX falls to NXβ (which may be negative if exports < imports).
FOUR EXPERIMENTS
1. FISCAL POLICY AT HOME
A domestic fiscal expansion (e.g., increase in government spending or tax cut) reduces national saving (S). With investment (I) unchanged, net capital outflow (S - I) decreases. This shifts the vertical supply of dollars leftward (from SββI to SββI). With lower supply, the real exchange rate rises (from Ξ΅β to Ξ΅β), making home goods more expensive and reducing net exports (from NXβ to NXβ).
π Definition β Fiscal Expansion Effect: A domestic fiscal expansion reduces national saving, reduces net capital outflow, appreciates the real exchange rate, and reduces net exports. π Formula: ΞGβ β Sβ β (S - I)β β Ξ΅β β NXβ π Example: If the U.S. government increases spending, U.S. saving falls from Sβ to Sβ. The net capital outflow curve shifts left from (SββI) to (SββI). The real exchange rate rises from Ξ΅β to Ξ΅β, causing U.S. net exports to fall from NXβ to NXβ.
2. FISCAL POLICY ABROAD
A fiscal expansion abroad (e.g., in another country) raises the world interest rate (r)**. This higher r reduces domestic investment (I) in the home country. With saving (S) unchanged, net capital outflow (S - I) increases. This shifts the vertical supply of dollars rightward. The real exchange rate falls (from Ξ΅β to Ξ΅β), making home goods cheaper and increasing net exports (from NXβ to NXβ).
π Definition β Foreign Fiscal Expansion Effect: A fiscal expansion abroad raises world interest rates, reduces domestic investment, increases net capital outflow, depreciates the real exchange rate, and increases net exports. π Formula: r*β β Iβ β (S - I)β β Ξ΅β β NXβ π Example: If Europe engages in fiscal expansion, world r* rises. U.S. investment falls from Iβ to Iβ. Net capital outflow (S - Iβ) is higher than before. The real exchange rate depreciates from Ξ΅β to Ξ΅β, and U.S. net exports rise from NXβ to NXβ.
3. AN INCREASE IN INVESTMENT DEMAND
An increase in investment demand (e.g., due to technological optimism) shifts the investment curve rightward, raising domestic investment (I). With saving (S) unchanged, net capital outflow (S - I) decreases. This shifts the vertical supply of dollars leftward. The real exchange rate rises (from Ξ΅β to Ξ΅β), making home goods more expensive and reducing net exports (from NXβ to NXβ).
π Definition β Investment Increase Effect: An increase in domestic investment reduces net capital outflow, appreciates the real exchange rate, and reduces net exports. π Formula: Iβ β (S - I)β β Ξ΅β β NXβ π Example: If U.S. firms increase investment due to new technology, U.S. investment rises from Iβ to Iβ. Net capital outflow (S - Iβ) is lower. The real exchange rate appreciates from Ξ΅β to Ξ΅β, and U.S. net exports fall.
4. TRADE POLICY TO RESTRICT IMPORTS
An import quota (limiting imports) reduces imports (IM) at any given Ξ΅, shifting the NX curve rightward (from NX(Ξ΅)β to NX(Ξ΅)β) and increasing demand for home currency (dollars). However, trade policy does not affect saving (S) or investment (I), so net capital outflow (S - I) and the supply of dollars remain fixed. With fixed supply but higher demand, the real exchange rate rises (from Ξ΅β to Ξ΅β). The net result is ΞΞ΅ > 0 (appreciation) but ΞNX = 0 (because supply is fixed; the higher Ξ΅ reduces exports, exactly offsetting the import reduction).
π Definition β Trade Policy Effect: An import quota shifts the NX curve rightward, but with a vertical net capital outflow curve, the real exchange rate appreciates while net exports remain unchanged. π Formula: PolicyβIM β NX(Ξ΅) shifts right β Ξ΅β β EXβ β ΞNX = 0 π Example: The U.S. imposes a quota on Japanese cars. At any Ξ΅, U.S. net exports increase, shifting the NX curve right. Demand for dollars rises. Since U.S. saving and investment are unchanged, the supply of dollars is fixed. The dollar appreciates (Ξ΅ rises). This appreciation reduces U.S. exports (EX) by exactly the amount of the import reduction, so net exports remain unchanged.
THE DETERMINANTS OF THE NOMINAL EXCHANGE RATE
The real exchange rate (Ξ΅) is defined as Ξ΅ = (e Γ P) / P*, where e is the nominal exchange rate, P is the domestic price level, and P* is the foreign price level. Solving for e gives: e = Ξ΅ Γ (P / P)**. The nominal exchange rate depends on the real exchange rate and the ratio of foreign to domestic price levels. In terms of growth rates, this becomes: Ξe/e = ΞΞ΅/Ξ΅ + Ο - Ο, where Ο is domestic inflation and Ο* is foreign inflation.
π Definition β Nominal Exchange Rate (e): The rate at which one country's currency trades for another's; it is determined by the real exchange rate and the ratio of price levels. π Formula: e = Ξ΅ Γ (P* / P) β The nominal exchange rate equals the real exchange rate times the foreign price level divided by the domestic price level. π Formula (Growth Rates): Ξe/e = ΞΞ΅/Ξ΅ + Ο* - Ο β The percentage change in the nominal exchange rate equals the percentage change in the real exchange rate plus the foreign inflation rate minus the domestic inflation rate.
INFLATION AND NOMINAL EXCHANGE RATES
There is a strong positive relationship between the inflation differential (Ο - Ο)* and the percentage change in the nominal exchange rate (Ξe/e). Countries with higher domestic inflation relative to foreign inflation (negative inflation differential) tend to see their currency depreciate (Ξe/e > 0, meaning more home currency per foreign currency). Countries with lower domestic inflation relative to foreign inflation (positive inflation differential) tend to see their currency appreciate (Ξe/e < 0). Data from countries like South Africa, Italy, Japan, and Switzerland confirm this relationship.
π Definition β Inflation Differential Effect: The nominal exchange rate adjusts to offset differences in inflation rates between countries. π Example: For Japan (low inflation) relative to the U.S., Ο* - Ο was negative. The Japanese yen appreciated relative to the U.S. dollar. For Italy (historically higher inflation), Ο* - Ο was positive, and the Italian lira depreciated relative to the U.S. dollar.
β Key Takeaways
The fundamental equation of the open economy is NX = S - I. Since net capital outflow (S - I) is independent of the real exchange rate, the real exchange rate (Ξ΅) must adjust to bring net exports into equality with this fixed net capital outflow. Any policy that reduces national saving or increases domestic investment will reduce net capital outflow, causing the real exchange rate to appreciate (Ξ΅β) and net exports to fall. Any policy that increases the world interest rate or reduces domestic investment will increase net capital outflow, causing the real exchange rate to depreciate (Ξ΅β) and net exports to rise. Trade policies like import quotas do not affect net exports in equilibrium because the appreciation of the exchange rate offsets the import reduction by reducing exports. Finally, the nominal exchange rate (e) is determined by the real exchange rate and the ratio of price levels, so inflation differentials between countries directly drive nominal exchange rate changes.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the accounting identity that determines the real exchange rate in an open economy? Why is the net capital outflow curve vertical?
- How does a domestic fiscal expansion affect the real exchange rate and net exports? Trace the logic step by step.
- How does a fiscal expansion abroad affect the real exchange rate and net exports in the home country? What is the key channel?
- Explain why an import quota does not change net exports in equilibrium. What happens to the real exchange rate and exports?
- Write the formula for the nominal exchange rate (e) in terms of the real exchange rate (Ξ΅) and price levels. How does this formula explain the relationship between inflation differentials and currency appreciation or depreciation?
π Lecture 17 β Issues in Unemployment
π Overview: This lecture introduces the theory of Purchasing Power Parity (PPP) and examines why it often fails in the real world. It then shifts to a detailed analysis of unemployment, defining the natural rate and presenting a first model to explain how unemployment persists even in equilibrium.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the doctrine of Purchasing Power Parity (PPP), its formula and implications, reasons why PPP does not hold in the real world, the definition and measurement of the natural rate of unemployment, a first model of the natural rate using job separation and job finding rates, and the two main reasons why unemployment exists: job search (frictional unemployment) and wage rigidity.
π Lecture Summary
Purchasing Power Parity (PPP)
Purchasing Power Parity (PPP) is a doctrine stating that goods must sell at the same currency-adjusted price in all countries. Under PPP, the nominal exchange rate adjusts to equalize the cost of a basket of goods across countries. The rationale for PPP is arbitrage, which is based on the law of one price.
π Definition β Purchasing Power Parity (PPP): A doctrine that states goods must sell at the same (currency-adjusted) price in all countries. π Formula: e x P = P* β The cost of a basket of domestic goods in foreign currency equals the cost of a basket of foreign goods in foreign currency. Solving for e gives e = P/ P*. This implies the nominal exchange rate between two countries equals the ratio of the countriesβ price levels. π Definition β Real Exchange Rate (Ξ΅): Ξ΅ = e x (P / P*). If e = P*/P, then Ξ΅ = 1, meaning the real exchange rate equals 1 under PPP. π Example: If a basket of goods costs $100 in the US (P) and β¬100 in Europe (P*), PPP implies the exchange rate e = β¬100 / $100 = 1 β¬/$. The real exchange rate Ξ΅ = 1 x ($100 / β¬100) = 1.
Does PPP Hold in the Real World?
PPP does not hold in the real world for two main reasons. First, international arbitrage is not always possible due to non-traded goods (like haircuts) and transportation costs. Second, goods of different countries are not perfect substitutes (e.g., French wine vs. Italian wine). Nonetheless, PPP remains a useful theory because it is simple and intuitive, and nominal exchange rates tend toward their PPP values over the long run.
Natural Rate of Unemployment
The natural rate of unemployment is the average rate of unemployment around which the economy fluctuates. In a recession, the actual unemployment rate rises above the natural rate. In a boom, the actual unemployment rate falls below the natural rate. The lecture provides a graph of Pakistan's unemployment rate from 2002 to 2010, showing it fluctuated between roughly 5% and 8%.
A First Model of the Natural Rate
The model uses the following notations: L = # of workers in labor force, E = # of employed workers, U = # of unemployed, and U/L = unemployment rate. L is assumed to be exogenously fixed. During any given month, s = fraction of employed workers that become separated from their jobs, and f = fraction of unemployed workers that find jobs. Both s and f are exogenous.
π Definition β Steady State Condition: The labor market is in steady state if the unemployment rate is constant, requiring s x E = f x U. This means the number of employed people who lose or leave their jobs equals the number of unemployed people who find jobs.
π Formula β Equilibrium Unemployment Rate: U/L = s / (s + f). Solving the steady state condition: f x U = s x (L β U) = s x L β s x U β (f + s) x U = s x L β U/L = s / (s + f). π Example: Each month, 1% of employed workers lose their jobs (s = 0.01) and 19% of unemployed workers find jobs (f = 0.19). The natural rate of unemployment is U/L = 0.01 / (0.01 + 0.19) = 0.01 / 0.20 = 0.05, or 5%.
π‘ Why this matters: A policy that aims to reduce the natural rate of unemployment will succeed only if it lowers s (job separation rate) or increases f (job finding rate).
Why Is There Unemployment?
If job finding were instantaneous (f = 1), all spells of unemployment would be brief, and the natural rate would be near zero. There are two reasons why f < 1: job search and wage rigidity.
Job Search & Frictional Unemployment
Frictional unemployment is caused by the time it takes workers to search for a job. It occurs even when wages are flexible and there are enough jobs to go around. Frictional unemployment exists because workers have different abilities and preferences, jobs have different skill requirements, geographic mobility of workers is not instantaneous, and the flow of information about vacancies and job candidates is imperfect.
β Key Takeaways
PPP predicts that nominal exchange rates equal price level ratios, but real-world factors like non-traded goods and transportation costs prevent it from holding in the short run. The natural rate of unemployment is the long-run average around which actual unemployment fluctuates. The steady state model shows the natural rate is determined solely by the job separation rate (s) and job finding rate (f), not by the level of employment. To reduce the natural rate, policies must lower s or raise f. Frictional unemployment arises from the time and information costs of matching workers with jobs, and persists even in flexible wage economies.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the formula for Purchasing Power Parity, and what does it imply about the nominal exchange rate?
- List two reasons why PPP does not hold in the real world.
- What does the steady state condition s x E = f x U mean in words, and what formula does it yield for the natural rate of unemployment?
- If the job separation rate is 2% and the job finding rate is 18%, what is the natural rate of unemployment?
- What is frictional unemployment, and what are two reasons it exists?
π Lecture 18 β Issues in Unemployment (Continued)
π Overview: This lecture continues the examination of unemployment, focusing on sectoral shifts as a source of frictional unemployment, the role of public policy and unemployment insurance, and the three main reasons for wage rigidity that cause structural unemployment. It provides real-world examples and data, including from Pakistan, to illustrate these concepts and their policy implications.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers sectoral shifts and their contribution to frictional unemployment, illustrated with industry shares in GDP and labor force breakup in Pakistan. It discusses public policy and job search, including unemployment insurance and its benefits. The lecture then explains why unemployment exists through job search and wage rigidity, detailing structural unemployment from real wage rigidity. It examines three reasons for wage rigidity: minimum wage laws, labor unions, and efficiency wage theory. Finally, it addresses the duration of unemployment, unemployment rates in Pakistan, and the rise in European unemployment.
π Lecture Summary
Sectoral Shifts
Sectoral shifts occur due to changes in the composition of demand among industries or regions. Example #1: Technological change increases demand for computer repair persons, decreases demand for typewriter repair persons. Example #2: A new international trade agreement causes greater demand for workers in the export sectors and less demand for workers in import-competing sectors. It takes time for workers to change sectors, so sectoral shifts cause frictional unemployment.
The lecture presents industry shares in GDP for Pakistan: In 1969-70, Agriculture was 39%, Manufacturing 16%, Other Industries 7%, and Services 38%. By 2003-04, Agriculture had fallen to 23%, Manufacturing rose to 18%, Other Industries remained at 7%, and Services increased to 52%.
The Labor Force Break up in Pakistan for 2004 shows: Agriculture 41%, Manufacturing and Mining 14%, Construction 6%, Wholesale and Retail Trade 15%, Transport 6%, Community and Social Services 16%, and Others 2%.
In a dynamic economy, smaller (though still significant) sectoral shifts occur frequently, contributing to frictional unemployment.
Public Policy and Job Search
Government programs affect unemployment. Government employment agencies disseminate information about job openings to better match workers and jobs. Public job training programs help workers displaced from declining industries get the skills needed for jobs in growing industries.
Unemployment Insurance (UI)
Unemployment Insurance (UI) pays part of a worker's former wages for a limited time after losing his/her job. UI increases search unemployment because it:
- Reduces the opportunity cost of being unemployed
- Reduces the urgency of finding work
Hence, UI reduces f (the rate of job finding). Studies: The longer a worker is eligible for UI, the longer the duration of the average spell of unemployment.
π‘ Why this matters: While UI may increase the duration of unemployment, it has benefits. By allowing workers more time to search, UI may lead to better matches between jobs and workers, which would lead to greater productivity and higher incomes.
Why Is There Unemployment?
The natural rate of unemployment: U/L = s / (s + f)
There are two reasons why f < 1:
- Job search
- Wage rigidity
Unemployment from Real Wage Rigidity
If the real wage is stuck above the equilibrium level, then there aren't enough jobs to go around. Then, firms must ration the scarce jobs among workers.
π Structural Unemployment: The unemployment resulting from real wage rigidity and job rationing is called structural unemployment.
Reasons for Wage Rigidity
- Minimum wage laws
- Labor unions
- Efficiency wages
1- The Minimum Wage
The minimum wage is well below the equilibrium wage for most workers, so it cannot explain the majority of natural rate unemployment. However, the minimum wage may exceed the equilibrium wage of unskilled workers, especially teenagers. If so, then we would expect that increases in the minimum wage would increase unemployment among these groups.
π Example: In September 1996, the minimum wage was raised from $4.25 to $4.75 in the US. Unemployment rates (3rd Quarter 1996 vs. 1st Quarter 1997): Teenagers 16.6% β 17.0%, Single mothers 8.5% β 9.1%, All workers 5.3% β 5.3%. Other studies: A 10% increase in the minimum wage increases teenage unemployment by 1-3%.
2- Labor Unions
Labor unions exercise monopoly power to secure higher wages for their members. When the union wage exceeds the equilibrium wage, unemployment results. Employed union workers are insiders whose interest is to keep wages high. Unemployed non-union workers are outsiders and would prefer wages to be lower (so that labor demand would be high enough for them to get jobs).
3- Efficiency Wage Theory
Efficiency wage theory consists of theories in which high wages increase worker productivity:
- Attract higher quality job applicants
- Increase worker effort and reduce "shirking"
- Reduce turnover, which is costly
- Improve health of workers (in developing countries)
The increased productivity justifies the cost of paying above-equilibrium wages. The result is unemployment.
The Duration of Unemployment
The data shows that more spells of unemployment are short-term than medium-term or long-term. Yet, most of the total time spent unemployed is attributable to the long-term unemployed. This long-term unemployment is probably structural and/or due to sectoral shifts among vastly different industries. Knowing this is important because it can help us craft policies that are more likely to succeed.
The lecture includes a graph showing the unemployment rate of Pakistan from approximately 1980 to 2004, with rates fluctuating between roughly 3% and 8%.
The Rise in European Unemployment
Two explanations:
- Most countries in Europe have generous social insurance programs
- Shift in demand from unskilled to skilled workers, due to technological change
This demand shift occurred in the U.S., too. But wage rigidity is less of a problem there, so the shift caused an increase in the skilled-to-unskilled wage gap instead of an increase in unemployment.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical points from this lecture are that unemployment arises from two main sources: job search (frictional) and wage rigidity (structural). Sectoral shifts, which are inevitable in a dynamic economy, cause frictional unemployment as workers move between industries or regions. Government policies like unemployment insurance, while increasing the duration of unemployment, can improve job matching and productivity. Structural unemployment is caused by real wage rigidity from three sources: minimum wage laws (affecting mainly unskilled and teenage workers), labor unions (creating insider-outsider dynamics), and efficiency wages (where higher pay increases productivity). Understanding the duration and causes of unemployment is crucial for crafting effective policy responses.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are sectoral shifts, and how do they contribute to frictional unemployment? Provide two examples.
- Explain how unemployment insurance (UI) affects the duration of unemployment and what its potential benefits are.
- What are the three main reasons for real wage rigidity that lead to structural unemployment?
- According to the lecture, what was the effect of the 1996 minimum wage increase on teenage unemployment in the US?
- Why has European unemployment risen, and how does this differ from the US experience with the same demand shift?
π Lecture 19 β Economic Growth
π Overview: This lecture introduces the Solow Growth Model, a foundational framework in macroeconomics that explains how capital accumulation, labor force growth, and technological progress interact to determine a nation's output over time. It demonstrates why some countries are rich while others remain poor and provides the benchmark against which all modern growth theories are compared.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture begins with comparative data on per capita income across countries, then introduces the Solow Growth Model as the major paradigm for understanding economic growth. It covers the model's key assumptions distinguishing it from earlier models, the production function in per-worker terms, the national income identity, consumption and saving functions, depreciation, capital accumulation dynamics, the equation of motion for capital, and the concept of the steady state where investment equals depreciation.
π Lecture Summary
ECONOMIC GROWTH PER CAPITA INCOME OF SELECTED COUNTRIES, 2004 (IN US $)
The lecture opens with a stark comparison: Norway ($43,350) vs. Nigeria ($320); United States ($37,610) vs. Pakistan ($470). These vast differences in per capita income highlight the central question of growth economics β why are some nations so much richer than others?
THE SOLOW GROWTH MODEL
Robert Solow won the Nobel Prize for his contributions to the study of economic growth. The Solow Growth Model is a major paradigm widely used in policy making and serves as the benchmark against which most recent growth theories are compared. It is designed to show how growth in the capital stock, growth in the labor force, and advances in technology interact in an economy, and how they affect a nation's total output of goods and services.
HOW SOLOW MODEL IS DIFFERENT: ASSUMPTIONS
The Solow model relaxes earlier assumptions:
- K is no longer fixed: investment causes it to grow, depreciation causes it to shrink
- L is no longer fixed: population growth causes it to grow
- The consumption function is simpler
- No G or T (only to simplify presentation; we can still do fiscal policy experiments)
- Cosmetic differences
THE PRODUCTION FUNCTION
The production function represents the transformation of inputs (labor (L), capital (K), and production technology) into outputs. In aggregate terms: Y = F (K, L)
Define per-worker variables:
- y = Y/L = output per worker
- k = K/L = capital per worker
Assume constant returns to scale: zY = F (zK, zL) for any z > 0 Pick z = 1/L. Then: Y/L = F (K/L, 1) y = F (k, 1) y = f (k) Where f (k) = F (k, 1)
π Formula: y = f(k) β Output per worker depends only on capital per worker, given constant returns to scale and fixed technology.
π Example: If an economy has K = $100 trillion and L = 200 million workers, then k = K/L = $500,000 per worker. With production function y = βk, output per worker y = β500,000 β 707 units.
The production function exhibits diminishing MPK (marginal product of capital): MPK = f(k+1) - f(k), and each additional unit of capital adds progressively less to output.
THE NATIONAL INCOME IDENTITY
Y = C + I (remember, no G) In "per worker" terms: y = c + i where c = C/L and i = I/L
THE CONSUMPTION FUNCTION
s = the saving rate, the fraction of income that is saved (s is an exogenous parameter). Note: s is the only lowercase variable that is not equal to its uppercase version divided by L. Consumption function: c = (1βs) y (per worker)
SAVING AND INVESTMENT
Saving (per worker) = sy National income identity: y = c + i Rearrange to get: i = y β c = sy (investment = saving) Using the results above: i = sy = sf (k)
π Definition β Investment per worker: i = sf(k) β In a closed economy without government, investment equals saving, which equals the saving rate times output per worker.
DEPRECIATION
Ξ΄ = the rate of depreciation = the fraction of the capital stock that wears out each period.
π Formula: Depreciation per worker = Ξ΄k β Each period, a fraction Ξ΄ of the capital per worker is lost due to wear and tear.
CAPITAL ACCUMULATION
Investment makes the capital stock bigger, depreciation makes it smaller. Change in capital stock = investment β depreciation Ξk = i β Ξ΄k Since i = sf (k), this becomes: Ξk = s f (k) β Ξ΄k
THE EQUATION OF MOTION FOR k
π Definition β Equation of Motion: Ξk = s f (k) β Ξ΄k β This is the Solow model's central equation. It determines behavior of capital over time which, in turn, determines behavior of all of the other endogenous variables because they all depend on k.
Endogenous variables determined by k:
- Income per person: y = f (k)
- Consumption per person: c = (1βs) f (k)
π‘ Why this matters: All key economic outcomes β income, consumption, living standards β flow from the behavior of capital per worker (k). If we understand how k changes, we understand economic growth.
THE STEADY STATE
If investment is just enough to cover depreciation, [sf (k) = Ξ΄k], then capital per worker will remain constant: Ξk = 0. This constant value, denoted k*, is called the steady state capital stock.
π Definition β Steady State: k* is the level of capital per worker where investment exactly equals depreciation (sf(k*) = Ξ΄k*), so capital per worker stops changing (Ξk = 0).
π Example: Suppose Ξ΄ = 0.10 (10% depreciation), s = 0.20 (20% saving rate), and f(k) = βk. At steady state: sf(k*) = Ξ΄k* β 0.20βk* = 0.10k* β βk* = 2 β k* = 4. At k*=4, output per worker y* = β4 = 2, consumption per worker c* = (1-0.20)Γ2 = 1.6.
If k < k*, then sf(k) > Ξ΄k, so Ξk > 0 and k rises toward k*. If k > k*, then sf(k) < Ξ΄k, so Ξk < 0 and k falls toward k*. The economy naturally gravitates toward the steady state.
β Key Takeaways
The Solow Growth Model's central equation Ξk = sf(k) β Ξ΄k shows that capital per worker grows when investment exceeds depreciation and shrinks when depreciation exceeds investment. The steady state (k*) is the long-run equilibrium where these forces balance. Because of diminishing returns to capital, adding more capital yields smaller increases in output, which explains why poor countries can grow faster than rich ones initially but eventually converge. The saving rate (s) determines the steady-state level of output, but not the long-run growth rate (which requires technological progress). For the exam, master how to calculate steady-state values given the production function, saving rate, and depreciation rate.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
-
What is the equation of motion for capital per worker in the Solow model, and what does each term represent?
-
If a country has a depreciation rate of 8%, a saving rate of 24%, and a production function y = βk, what is the steady-state level of capital per worker (k*)?
-
Why does the Solow production function exhibit diminishing MPK, and what implication does this have for economic growth?
-
Starting from a capital stock below the steady state, explain step-by-step how the economy moves toward k*.
-
In the Solow model, what determines the long-run level of income per capita, and what determines the long-run growth rate of income per capita?