📘 Lecture 20 — Economic Growth (Continued) Moving Towards the Steady State
📖 Overview: This lecture continues the analysis of economic growth by examining how an economy moves toward its steady state. It explains the dynamics of capital accumulation, provides a numerical example of approaching the steady state, and analyzes the impact of changes in the saving rate on long-run capital and income levels.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the Solow model diagram illustrating how investment and depreciation determine capital accumulation, the definition and identification of the steady state, a numerical example with a Cobb-Douglas production function showing the transition path, solving algebraically for steady-state values, and analyzing the effects of an increase in the saving rate. It concludes with international evidence linking investment rates to income per person.
📝 Lecture Summary
Moving Towards the Steady State
The Solow model shows that the change in capital per worker (Δk) equals investment (sf(k)) minus depreciation (δk). When the capital stock per worker (k) is below its steady-state level (k*), investment exceeds depreciation, causing k to increase. When k is above k*, depreciation exceeds investment, causing k to decrease. The economy always moves toward the steady state.
🔑 Definition — Steady state: The level of capital per worker where investment equals depreciation, so the capital stock does not change over time (Δk = 0).
📌 Example: In the diagram, starting from k₁ (below k*), investment (sf(k)) is greater than depreciation (δk), so Δk is positive. Capital per worker rises from k₁ to k₂ and continues rising until reaching k*.
The Steady State
At the steady state capital stock (k*), the level of investment (i*) exactly equals depreciation (δk*). Because investment replaces worn-out capital, the capital stock per worker remains constant. This is represented graphically where the investment curve (sf(k)) intersects the depreciation line (δk).
💡 Why this matters: The steady state is the long-run equilibrium of the Solow model. All economies tend toward their steady state, regardless of their starting point.
A Numerical Example
The aggregate production function is Y = F(K, L) = K¹/²L¹/². Dividing by L gives the per-worker production function: y = f(k) = k¹/².
Parameters: saving rate (s) = 0.3, depreciation rate (δ) = 0.1, initial capital per worker (k) = 4.0.
📐 Formula: Per-worker production function: y = k¹/² → output per worker equals the square root of capital per worker.
📐 Formula: Equation of motion: Δk = s f(k) − δk → change in capital per worker equals saving per worker minus depreciation per worker.
📌 Example — Approaching the Steady State:
- Year 1: k = 4.000, y = √4 = 2.000, c = (1−0.3)×2 = 1.400, i = 0.3×2 = 0.600, δk = 0.1×4 = 0.400, Δk = 0.600 − 0.400 = 0.200
- Year 2: k = 4.200, y = √4.2 = 2.049, c = 1.435, i = 0.615, δk = 0.420, Δk = 0.195
- ... Year 25: k = 7.351, y = 2.706, Δk = 0.080
- ... Year 100: k = 8.962, y = 2.994, Δk = 0.002
- ∞: k* = 9.000, y* = 3.000, c* = 2.100, i* = 0.900, δk* = 0.900, Δk = 0.000
Exercise: Solve for the Steady State
Given s = 0.3, δ = 0.1, y = k¹/²:
At the steady state, Δk = 0, so s f(k*) = δ k*.
Substituting: 0.3√k* = 0.1 k* → 3 = k*/√k* = √k* → k* = 9.
Therefore: y* = √k* = √9 = 3, and c* = (1−s)y* = 0.7×3 = 2.1.
💡 Why this matters: These are the precise long-run values the economy in the numerical example is approaching.
An Increase in the Saving Rate
An increase in the saving rate (from s₁ to s₂) shifts the investment curve upward from s₁f(k) to s₂f(k). At the old steady state (k₁*), investment now exceeds depreciation, so the capital stock begins to grow. The economy moves to a new, higher steady state (k₂*).
📌 Example: If a country increases its saving rate, its investment rises, causing the capital stock to grow until a new steady state with higher capital per worker is reached.
📐 Prediction — Higher saving rate: Higher s ⇒ higher k*, and since y = f(k), higher k* ⇒ higher y*. Thus, the Solow model predicts that countries with higher rates of saving and investment will have higher levels of capital and income per worker in the long run.
📌 Example — International Evidence: A scatter plot of income per person in 1992 (log scale) against investment as a percentage of output (average 1960–1992) shows a clear positive relationship. Countries like the U.S., Japan, and Singapore, with high investment rates, have high income per person. Countries like Chad, Uganda, and Cameroon, with low investment rates, have low income per person.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The steady state is the long-run equilibrium where investment equals depreciation (Δk = 0), and capital per worker stops changing. The equation of motion Δk = sf(k) − δk governs the transition to the steady state from any starting point. A higher saving rate unambiguously increases the steady-state levels of capital per worker, output per worker, and consumption per worker (since output increases). The numerical example demonstrates the gradual, asymptotic approach to the steady state over many years. The positive correlation between investment rates and income per person across countries provides empirical support for the Solow model's central prediction.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- Using the equation of motion, explain what happens to capital per worker (k) when it is initially below the steady state (k*). What about when it is above k*?
- Given y = k¹/², s = 0.2, and δ = 0.05, solve for the steady-state values of k*, y*, and c*.
- On a Solow diagram, show and explain the effect of a decrease in the saving rate on the steady-state capital stock.
- In the numerical example, why does Δk become smaller each year as the economy approaches the steady state?
- What is the key prediction of the Solow model regarding saving rates and long-run income levels, and what international evidence supports this prediction?
📘 Lecture 21 — Economic Growth (Continued)
📖 Overview: This lecture continues the analysis of economic growth by introducing the Golden Rule level of capital, which determines the steady state that maximizes consumption per person. It then extends the basic Solow model by incorporating population growth as a key factor affecting long-run capital and income levels across countries.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the Golden Rule level of capital stock, how to find it by maximizing consumption where MPK equals the depreciation rate, the transition to the Golden Rule steady state from conditions of too much or too little capital, and the limitations of the basic Solow model in explaining sustained growth. It then introduces population growth as a source of growth, defines break-even investment, derives the new equation of motion for capital per worker, and examines the impact of population growth on steady-state outcomes and the Golden Rule condition.
📝 Lecture Summary
THE GOLDEN RULE
Different values of the saving rate s lead to different steady states. To determine which is “best,” we focus on economic well-being, which depends on consumption. The “best” steady state has the highest possible value of consumption per person: c* = (1–s) f(k*). An increase in s leads to higher k* and y*, which may raise c*, but it also reduces consumption’s share of income (1–s), which may lower c*. So we must find the s and k* that maximize c*.
🔑 Definition — Golden Rule: the steady state value of k that maximizes consumption per person.
THE GOLDEN RULE LEVEL OF CAPITAL STOCK
kgold = the Golden Rule level of capital, the steady state value of k that maximizes consumption. To find it, first express c in terms of k*: c* = y* – i* = f(k*) – i* = f(k*) – δk*
In general: i = Δk + δk; in the steady state: i* = δk* because Δk = 0. Then, graph f(k*) and δk*, and look for the point where the gap between them is biggest. The gap c* = f(k*) – δk* is biggest where the slope of the production function equals the slope of the depreciation line: MPK = δ.
📐 Formula: c = f(k) – δk*** → Consumption per person in steady state equals output per person minus depreciation per person. 📐 Formula: MPK = δ → The Golden Rule condition where the marginal product of capital equals the depreciation rate.
THE TRANSITION TO THE GOLDEN RULE STEADY STATE
The economy does NOT have a tendency to move toward the Golden Rule steady state. Achieving the Golden Rule requires that policymakers adjust the saving rate s. This adjustment leads to a new steady state with higher consumption. But what happens to consumption during the transition?
Starting with too much capital: If k* > kgold, then increasing c requires a fall in s. In the transition to the Golden Rule, consumption is higher at all points in time. Output Y, consumption C, and investment i all adjust downward over time from t0 onward.
Starting with too little capital: If k* < kgold, then increasing c requires an increase in s. Future generations enjoy higher consumption, but the current one experiences an initial drop in consumption. Investment i rises initially, then declines as the economy approaches the new steady state, while consumption C initially falls, then rises above its original level.
💡 Why this matters: The transition path shows that policies to achieve the Golden Rule involve intergenerational trade-offs—current generations may sacrifice consumption for the benefit of future generations.
POPULATION GROWTH
The basic Solow model cannot explain sustained economic growth. It simply says that high rates of saving lead to high growth temporarily, but the economy eventually approaches a steady state. We need to incorporate two sources of growth to explain sustained economic growth: population growth and technological progress.
Assume that the population—and labor force—grow at rate n (n is exogenous): ΔL/L = n Suppose L = 1000 in year 1 and the population is growing at 2%/year (n = 0.02). Then ΔL = nL = 0.02 × 1000 = 20, so L = 1020 in year 2.
🔑 Definition — Break-even investment (δ+n)k: the amount of investment necessary to keep capital per worker k constant. Break-even investment includes: δk to replace capital as it wears out, and nk to equip new workers with capital (otherwise, k would fall as the existing capital stock would be spread more thinly over a larger population of workers).
THE EQUATION OF MOTION FOR k
With population growth, the equation of motion for k is: Δk = s f(k) – (δ+n)k Where s f(k) = actual investment and (δ+n)k = break-even investment.
📐 Formula: Δk = s f(k) – (δ+n)k → The change in capital per worker equals actual investment minus break-even investment.
THE IMPACT OF POPULATION GROWTH
An increase in the population growth rate from n₁ to n₂ shifts the break-even investment line upward, from (δ+n₁)k to (δ+n₂)k. The steady-state capital per worker falls from k₁* to k₂*.
📌 Example: A country with a higher population growth rate n will have a higher break-even investment line, leading to a lower steady-state level of capital per worker k* and, since y = f(k), a lower steady-state level of output per worker y*.
Prediction: Higher n ⇒ lower k*, and since y = f(k), lower k* ⇒ lower y*. Thus, the Solow model predicts that countries with higher population growth rates will have lower levels of capital and income per worker in the long run.
THE GOLDEN RULE WITH POPULATION GROWTH
To find the Golden Rule capital stock with population growth, we express c* in terms of k*: c* = y* – i* = f(k*) – (δ+n)k*
c* is maximized when: MPK = δ + n Or equivalently: MPK – δ = n
In the Golden Rule Steady State, the marginal product of capital net of depreciation equals the population growth rate.
📐 Formula: MPK = δ + n → The Golden Rule condition with population growth: the marginal product of capital equals the sum of depreciation rate and population growth rate. 📐 Formula: MPK – δ = n → In the Golden Rule steady state, the marginal product of capital net of depreciation equals the population growth rate.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The Golden Rule level of capital maximizes steady-state consumption and occurs where MPK equals the depreciation rate (without population growth) or MPK equals δ+n (with population growth). The economy does not automatically move to the Golden Rule; policymakers must adjust the saving rate, which creates transition dynamics where consumption may initially fall if the economy starts with too little capital. The basic Solow model cannot explain sustained growth, so population growth is introduced as an additional factor—higher population growth reduces steady-state capital and income per worker. Finally, with population growth, the Golden Rule condition becomes MPK = δ + n, meaning net MPK equals the population growth rate.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What condition defines the Golden Rule level of capital in the basic Solow model (without population growth)?
- If an economy has too much capital relative to the Golden Rule level, what happens to consumption during the transition if policymakers reduce the saving rate?
- What two components make up break-even investment when population growth is included in the Solow model?
- According to the Solow model, what is the predicted relationship between a country's population growth rate and its long-run income per worker?
- How does the Golden Rule condition change when population growth at rate n is introduced into the model?
📘 Lecture 22 — Economic Growth (Continued)
📖 Overview: This lecture continues the Solow growth model by introducing technological progress, which allows for sustained growth in output per worker. It derives the golden rule for capital accumulation with technological progress and discusses policy implications for promoting economic growth.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture introduces labor-augmenting technological progress into the Solow model, defines the steady-state growth rates for key variables with technological progress, develops the Golden Rule with technological progress, and discusses four policy questions for promoting growth including evaluating the saving rate using empirical estimates.
📝 Lecture Summary
Technological Progress in the Solow Model
A new variable E = labor efficiency is introduced. Technological progress is assumed to be labor-augmenting: it increases labor efficiency at the exogenous rate g. The production function is rewritten as Y = F(K, L × E), where L × E = the number of effective workers. Increases in labor efficiency have the same effect on output as increases in the labor force. Notations include y = Y/LE = output per effective worker and k = K/LE = capital per effective worker. The production function per effective worker is y = f(k), and saving and investment per effective worker is s y = s f(k). The break-even investment (δ + n + g)k is the amount of investment necessary to keep k constant, consisting of δk to replace depreciating capital, nk to provide capital for new workers, and gk to provide capital for new "effective" workers created by technological progress. The change in capital per effective worker is Δk = s f(k) - (δ + n + g)k.
🔑 Definition — Labor-augmenting technological progress: Technological progress that increases labor efficiency at an exogenous rate g, having the same effect on output as increases in the labor force.
📐 Formula: Δk = s f(k) - (δ + n + g)k → The change in capital per effective worker equals saving/investment minus break-even investment.
📌 Example: If δ = 5%, n = 2%, and g = 1%, then break-even investment is (0.05 + 0.02 + 0.01)k = 0.08k. This means 8% of capital per effective worker must be invested just to keep k constant.
Steady-State Growth Rates in the Solow Model with Technological Progress
The steady-state growth rates are: Capital per effective worker (k) grows at 0%, Output per effective worker (y) grows at 0%, Output per worker (Y/L) = y × E grows at g, and Total output (Y) = y × E × L grows at n + g.
| Variable | Symbol | Steady-State Growth Rate |
|---|---|---|
| Capital per effective worker | k = K/(L×E) | 0 |
| Output per effective worker | y = Y/(L×E) | 0 |
| Output per worker | Y/L = y×E | g |
| Total output | Y = y×E×L | n + g |
The Golden Rule with Technological Progress
To find the Golden Rule capital stock, consumption per effective worker c* is expressed in terms of k*: c* = y* - i* = f(k*) - (δ + n + g)k*. c is maximized when MPK = δ + n + g*, or equivalently MPK - δ = n + g. In the Golden Rule Steady State, the marginal product of capital net of depreciation equals the population growth rate plus the rate of tech progress.
🔑 Definition — Golden Rule capital stock (with technological progress): The steady-state level of capital per effective worker that maximizes consumption per effective worker, achieved when MPK - δ = n + g.
📐 Formula: MPK - δ = n + g → The marginal product of capital net of depreciation equals the sum of population growth rate and technological progress rate.
💡 Why this matters: This condition tells us whether an economy is saving too much or too little for maximum long-run consumption.
Policies to Promote Growth
Four policy questions are addressed: (1) Are we saving enough? Too much? (2) What policies might change the saving rate? (3) How should we allocate investment between privately owned physical capital, public infrastructure, and human capital? (4) What policies might encourage faster technological progress?
1. Evaluating the Rate of Saving
Use the Golden Rule to determine whether the saving rate and capital stock are too high or too low by comparing (MPK - δ) to (n + g). If (MPK - δ) > (n + g), the economy is below the Golden Rule steady state and should increase s. If (MPK - δ) < (n + g), the economy is above the Golden Rule steady state and should reduce s.
To estimate (MPK - δ), three facts about an economy are used:
- k = 2.5 y: the capital stock is about 2.5 times one year's GDP
- δk = 0.1 y: about 10% of GDP is used to replace depreciating capital
- MPK × k = 0.3 y: capital income is about 30% of GDP
To determine δ, divide fact 2 by fact 1: δk/k = 0.1y/2.5y → δ = 0.1/2.5 = 0.04 To determine MPK, divide fact 3 by fact 1: MPK × k/k = 0.3y/2.5y → MPK = 0.3/2.5 = 0.12 Hence, MPK - δ = 0.12 - 0.04 = 0.08
Real GDP grows an average of 3%/year, so n + g = 0.03. Thus, in this economy, MPK - δ = 0.08 > 0.03 = n + g
📌 Example: Using empirical data from a typical economy:
- Capital stock = 2.5 × GDP
- Depreciation = 0.1 × GDP → δ = 0.04
- Capital income = 0.3 × GDP → MPK = 0.12
- MPK - δ = 0.08, n + g = 0.03
- Since 0.08 > 0.03, the economy is below the Golden Rule steady state.
Conclusion: The economy is below the Golden Rule steady state. If we increase the saving rate of this economy, the economy will have faster growth until it reaches a new steady state with higher consumption per capita.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Technological progress is labor-augmenting and grows at rate g, making output per worker grow at rate g in steady state — resolving the Solow model's inability to explain sustained growth. The break-even investment now includes δk, nk, and gk to maintain capital per effective worker constant. The Golden Rule condition becomes MPK - δ = n + g, which determines the optimal saving rate for maximum consumption. Using empirical estimates (k = 2.5y, δk = 0.1y, MPK×k = 0.3y), we can compute MPK - δ = 0.08 and compare it to n + g = 0.03. When MPK - δ exceeds n + g, the economy is below the Golden Rule steady state and should increase saving to achieve higher consumption per capita.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What is the break-even investment in the Solow model with technological progress, and what three components does it consist of?
- What are the steady-state growth rates for capital per effective worker, output per worker, and total output?
- What is the Golden Rule condition for maximizing consumption with technological progress?
- Using empirical estimates (k = 2.5y, δk = 0.1y, MPK×k = 0.3y), calculate MPK - δ and determine whether the economy should increase or decrease saving.
- If MPK - δ = 0.08 and n + g = 0.03, is the economy above or below the Golden Rule steady state, and what happens if the saving rate is increased?