π Lecture 29 β IS-LM Framework and Aggregate Demand
π Overview: This lecture bridges the IS-LM model (which assumes a fixed price level) with the Aggregate Demand (AD) curve, showing how changes in the price level shift the LM curve and affect output. It explains how monetary and fiscal policies shift the AD curve, and analyzes the short-run and long-run effects of IS shocks and monetary policy changes.
ποΈ Topics Covered
Deriving the AD curve from the IS-LM model, showing the inverse relationship between price level and output; monetary policy effects on the AD curve; fiscal policy effects on the AD curve; short-run and long-run equilibrium in the IS-LM and AD-AS frameworks; analyzing short-run and long-run effects of an IS shock; analyzing short-run and long-run effects of a change in the money supply (ΞM).
π Lecture Summary
DERIVING THE AD CURVE
The Aggregate Demand (AD) curve captures the relationship between the price level (P) and output (Y). When the price level changes, it shifts the LM curve, affecting the interest rate (r) and therefore investment (I) and output (Y).
π Definition β Aggregate Demand (AD) curve: A curve that shows the relationship between the price level and the quantity of output demanded.
π Intuition for slope of AD curve: P β β (M/P) β β LM shifts left β r β β I β β Y β. This inverse relationship gives the AD curve its downward slope.
π Example: When the price level rises from Pβ to Pβ, real money balances (M/P) fall. This shifts the LM curve leftward from LM(Pβ) to LM(Pβ), increasing the interest rate from rβ to rβ. Since investment is inversely related to the interest rate, output falls from Yβ to Yβ, tracing out the downward-sloping AD curve.
MONETARY POLICY AND THE AD CURVE
The central bank can increase aggregate demand through expansionary monetary policy. An increase in the money supply (M) shifts the LM curve to the right at each price level, lowering the interest rate and increasing investment and output.
π Definition β Monetary policy: Actions by the central bank that affect the money supply and interest rates.
π Effect: M β β LM shifts right β r β β I β β Y β at each value of P. This shifts the AD curve to the right (from ADβ to ADβ).
π Example: Starting at equilibrium with LM(Mβ/Pβ), an increase in the money supply to Mβ shifts LM to LM(Mβ/Pβ). The interest rate falls from rβ to rβ, investment rises, and output increases from Yβ to Yβ at the same price level Pβ. The AD curve therefore shifts rightward.
FISCAL POLICY AND THE AD CURVE
Expansionary fiscal policy (increasing government spending G or decreasing taxes T) increases aggregate demand. A tax cut increases consumption (C), shifting the IS curve to the right, which increases output at each price level.
π Definition β Fiscal policy: Government decisions about spending and taxation.
π Effect: T β β C β β IS shifts right β Y β at each value of P. This shifts the AD curve to the right.
π Example: A tax cut increases disposable income, raising consumption. The IS curve shifts rightward, causing the interest rate to rise from rβ to rβ and output to increase from Yβ to Yβ at the same price level Pβ. The AD curve shifts rightward.
IS-LM AND AD-AS IN THE SHORT RUN & LONG RUN
The force that moves the economy from the short run to the long run is the gradual adjustment of prices. In short-run equilibrium, if output (Y) differs from the natural rate (Θ²), the price level will adjust over time.
π Definition β Natural rate of output (Θ²): The level of output the economy produces when all prices are fully flexible and resources are fully employed.
π Price adjustment rule:
- If Y > Θ² β Price level will rise over time
- If Y < YΜ β Price level will fall over time
- If Y = YΜ β Price level remains constant
THE SR AND LR EFFECTS OF AN IS SHOCK
A negative IS shock (such as a decrease in consumer confidence or investment) shifts the IS curve leftward and the AD curve leftward, causing output to fall below its natural rate in the short run.
Short Run Impacts:
- Y β (positive because Y moved)
- P 0 (prices are sticky in the SR)
- r β (positive ΞY leads to a rise in r as IS slides along the LM curve)
- C β (positive ΞY increases consumption: C = C(Y-T))
- I β (since r increased, investment decreased)
Long Run Impacts:
- Y 0 (rising P shifts LM left, returning Y to Y* as required by long-run LRAS)
- P β (to eliminate excess demand at Pβ)
- r β (reflecting leftward shift in LM due to +ΞP)
- C 0 (since both Y and T are back to initial levels)
- I ββ (since r has risen even more due to +ΞP)
π Example: A negative IS shock shifts ISβ to ISβ and ADβ to ADβ. In the new short-run equilibrium, Y < YΜ . Over time, P gradually falls, which causes the Short-Run Aggregate Supply (SRAS) curve to move down. The fall in P increases real money balances (M/P), which causes the LM curve to shift down. This process continues until the economy reaches a long-run equilibrium with Y = YΜ .
ANALYZE SR & LR EFFECTS OF ΞM
When the central bank increases the money supply (M), it has different effects in the short run and long run.
Short Run Impacts:
- Y β (positive because Y moved)
- P 0 (prices are sticky in the SR)
- r β (positive ΞY leads to a decrease in r as LM slides along the IS curve)
- C β (positive ΞY increases consumption: C = C(Y-T))
- I β (since r decreased, investment increased)
Long Run Impacts:
- Y 0 (rising P shifts LM left, returning Y to Y* as required by long-run LRAS)
- P β (to eliminate excess demand at Pβ)
- r 0 (leftward shift in LM due to +ΞP restores r to its original level)
- C 0 (since both Y and T are back to initial levels)
- I 0 (since Y or r has not changed)
π‘ Why this matters: The only long-run impact of an increase in the money supply is an increase in the price level. This demonstrates the principle of monetary neutrality β in the long run, changes in the money supply only affect nominal variables (like the price level), not real variables (like output or the real interest rate).
β Key Takeaways
The AD curve is derived from the IS-LM model and shows an inverse relationship between the price level and output β a higher price level reduces real money balances, raising interest rates and lowering investment and output. Both expansionary monetary policy (increasing M) and expansionary fiscal policy (increasing G or decreasing T) shift the AD curve to the right, increasing output at every price level. The key difference between short-run and long-run analysis is price flexibility: in the short run, prices are sticky, so changes in policy affect real output; in the long run, prices adjust fully, returning output to its natural rate. For an IS shock, output eventually returns to Θ², but the interest rate changes permanently. For a monetary policy shock, all real variables return to their original levels in the long run, with only the price level increasing β demonstrating monetary neutrality.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Explain the intuition for why the AD curve is downward sloping. What happens to the interest rate and investment when the price level rises?
- How does expansionary monetary policy shift the AD curve? What happens to the LM curve and the interest rate?
- How does expansionary fiscal policy shift the AD curve? What happens to the IS curve and the interest rate?
- What are the short-run and long-run effects of a negative IS shock on output, the price level, the interest rate, consumption, and investment?
- What are the short-run and long-run effects of an increase in the money supply on output, the price level, the interest rate, consumption, and investment? Why is money said to be neutral in the long run?
π Lecture 30 β The Mundell-Fleming Model
π Overview: This lecture introduces the Mundell-Fleming model, which extends the IS-LM framework to a small open economy with perfect capital mobility. It explains how fiscal, monetary, and trade policies affect output and exchange rates under both floating and fixed exchange rate systems, highlighting key differences from closed economy analysis.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the derivation and intuition of the IS* curve for goods market equilibrium and the LM* curve for money market equilibrium in a small open economy. It then presents equilibrium in the Mundell-Fleming model, distinguishes between floating and fixed exchange rate systems, and analyzes the effects of fiscal policy and monetary policy under floating exchange rates, including the crowding out mechanisms.
π Lecture Summary
THE MUNDELL-FLEMING MODEL
The Mundell-Fleming model portrays the relationship between the nominal exchange rate and the economyβs output. It is an extension of the IS-LM model. The key assumption of this model is the small open economy with perfect capital mobility, which implies that the domestic interest rate equals the world interest rate: r = r* (given).
IS* CURVE: GOODS MARKET EQUILIBRIUM
Goods market equilibrium is represented by the IS curve*. The equation is: Y = C(Y - T) + I(r*) + G + NX(e) Where e = nominal exchange rate = foreign currency per unit of domestic currency (e.g., 110 yen per dollar). The IS* curve is drawn for a given value of r*.
π Definition β Nominal Exchange Rate (e): The price of domestic currency in terms of foreign currency (e.g., 110 yen per dollar).
π‘ Why this matters: The IS* curve slopes downward because an increase in e (appreciation) causes a decrease in net exports (NX), which leads to a decrease in output (Y).
π Formula: IS* equation: Y = C(Y - T) + I(r*) + G + NX(e) β This equation shows that in a small open economy, output depends on consumption, investment at the world interest rate, government spending, and net exports which are a function of the exchange rate.
π Example: If e rises from 110 to 120 yen per dollar, domestic goods become more expensive for foreigners. This reduces NX, which in turn reduces Y. This relationship gives the IS* curve its negative slope.
LM* CURVE: MONEY MARKET EQUILIBRIUM
The LM curve* equation is: M/P = L(r*, Y). The LM* curve is drawn for a given value of r*. It is vertical because given r*, there is only one value of Y that equates money demand with supply, regardless of e.
π Definition β LM* Curve: The set of combinations of e and Y where money supply equals money demand at the world interest rate.
π Example: Since r is fixed at r*, the level of output Y is uniquely determined by the money market equilibrium condition. A change in e does not affect money demand or supply, so the LM* curve is vertical at that Y.
EQUILIBRIUM IN THE MUNDELL-FLEMING MODEL
Equilibrium occurs at the intersection of the IS* and LM* curves. This determines the equilibrium exchange rate and the equilibrium level of income. At this point, both the goods market and the money market are in simultaneous equilibrium.
FLOATING & FIXED EXCHANGE RATES
In a system of floating exchange rates, e is allowed to fluctuate in response to changing economic conditions. In contrast, under fixed exchange rates, the central bank trades domestic for foreign currency at a predetermined price. The lecture analyzes fiscal and monetary policy under both systems.
π Definition β Floating Exchange Rate: A system where the exchange rate is determined by market forces without central bank intervention.
π Definition β Fixed Exchange Rate: A system where the central bank commits to buying or selling domestic currency at a predetermined price to maintain a specific exchange rate.
FISCAL POLICY UNDER FLOATING EXCHANGE RATES
The model equations are: Y = C(Y - T) + I(r*) + G + NX(e) M/P = L(r*, Y)
At any given value of e, a fiscal expansion (increase in G or decrease in T) increases Y, shifting the IS* curve to the right.
π Example: Suppose the government increases G. At the initial exchange rate eβ, this raises Y, shifting IS* right from ISβ to ISβ. The new equilibrium is at eβ > eβ, but Y remains at Yβ.
Results: Ξe > 0 (appreciation), ΞY = 0.
LESSONS ABOUT FISCAL POLICY
In a small open economy with perfect capital mobility, fiscal policy is utterly incapable of affecting real GDP. The βcrowding out effectβ works differently here than in a closed economy.
In a closed economy, fiscal policy crowds out investment by causing the interest rate to rise. In a small open economy, fiscal policy crowds out net exports by causing the exchange rate to appreciate.
MONETARY POLICY UNDER FLOATING EXCHANGE RATES
An increase in M shifts the LM* curve right because Y must rise to restore equilibrium in the money market.
π Example: Suppose the central bank increases the money supply M. The LM* curve shifts right from LMβ to LMβ. The new equilibrium is at eβ < eβ (depreciation) and Yβ > Yβ.
Results: Ξe < 0 (depreciation), ΞY > 0 (increase in output).
LESSONS ABOUT MONETARY POLICY
Monetary policy affects output by affecting one (or more) of the components of aggregate demand.
In a closed economy: βM β βr β βI β βY In a small open economy: βM β βe β βNX β βY
π‘ Why this matters: Expansionary monetary policy does not raise world aggregate demand; it shifts demand from foreign to domestic products. Thus, the increases in income and employment at home come at the expense of losses abroad.
β Key Takeaways
The Mundell-Fleming model is the essential framework for understanding how macroeconomic policies affect small open economies with perfect capital mobility. Under floating exchange rates, fiscal policy is completely ineffective at changing output because it only appreciates the exchange rate and crowds out net exports. Monetary policy, by contrast, is highly effective because it depreciates the exchange rate and boosts net exports. The model clearly demonstrates that the transmission mechanisms of policy differ fundamentally between closed and open economies due to the interest rate parity condition (r = r*). Crucially, expansionary monetary policy in a small open economy is a "beggar-thy-neighbor" policy that boosts domestic output at the expense of foreign economies.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the key assumption of the Mundell-Fleming model regarding capital mobility and interest rates?
- Why is the LM* curve vertical in the Mundell-Fleming model?
- Under floating exchange rates, what happens to output and the exchange rate when a government increases its spending?
- In a small open economy with floating exchange rates, what is the transmission mechanism of expansionary monetary policy? (Start with βM)
- How does the "crowding out" effect of fiscal policy differ between a closed economy and a small open economy?
π Lecture 31 β The Mundell-Fleming Model (Continued)
π Overview: This lecture continues the analysis of the Mundell-Fleming model by examining trade policy under floating exchange rates, then introduces fixed exchange rate systems. It compares how fiscal, monetary, and trade policies affect output and exchange rates under both regimes, and concludes by incorporating interest-rate differentials into the model.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers trade policy under floating exchange rates and its lessons, fixed exchange rate systems with equilibrium comparisons, fiscal and monetary policy effectiveness under fixed rates, trade policy under fixed rates, a summary table of policy effects across regimes, and an extension of the model to include interest-rate differentials from country risk and expected exchange rate changes.
π Lecture Summary
Trade Policy Under Floating Exchange Rates
At any given value of e (exchange rate), a tariff or quota reduces imports, increases NX (net exports), and shifts the IS* curve to the right. This causes the exchange rate to appreciate (from eβ to eβ), but output remains unchanged at Yβ.
π Definition β IS* curve: The relationship between the exchange rate and income in an open economy under the Mundell-Fleming model, where goods market equilibrium holds.
Lessons About Trade Policy
Import restrictions cannot reduce a trade deficit. Even though NX is unchanged, there is less trade: the trade restriction reduces imports, but exchange rate appreciation reduces exports. Less trade means fewer gains from trade. Import restrictions on specific products save jobs in domestic industries that produce those products, but destroy jobs in export-producing sectors. Hence, import restrictions fail to increase total employment. Worse yet, import restrictions create "sectoral shifts," which cause frictional unemployment.
Fixed Exchange Rates
Under a system of fixed exchange rates, the country's central bank stands ready to buy or sell the domestic currency for foreign currency at a predetermined rate. The central bank shifts the LM* curve as required to keep e at its pre-announced rate. This system fixes the nominal exchange rate. In the long run, when prices are flexible, the real exchange rate can move even if the nominal rate is fixed.
The lecture presents two cases: a. The Equilibrium exchange rate is greater than the fixed exchange rate b. The Equilibrium exchange rate is less than the fixed exchange rate
Fiscal Policy Under Fixed Exchange Rates
Under fixed exchange rates, a fiscal expansion would raise e. To keep e from rising, the central bank must sell domestic currency, which increases M (money supply) and shifts LM* right. Results: Ξe = 0, ΞY > 0. Under floating rates, fiscal policy is ineffective at changing output. Under fixed rates, fiscal policy is very effective at changing output. LM shifts out!
π Formula: Fiscal expansion β eβ β Central bank sells domestic currency β Mβ β LM* shifts right β Yβ
Monetary Policy Under Fixed Exchange Rates
An increase in M would shift LM* right and reduce e. To prevent the fall in e, the central bank must buy domestic currency, which reduces M and shifts LM* back left. Results: Ξe = 0, ΞY = 0. Under floating rates, monetary policy is very effective at changing output. Under fixed rates, monetary policy cannot be used to affect output.
Trade Policy Under Fixed Exchange Rates
A restriction on imports puts upward pressure on e. To keep e from rising, the central bank must sell domestic currency, which increases M and shifts LM* right. Results: Ξe = 0, ΞY > 0. Under floating rates, import restrictions do not affect Y or NX. Under fixed rates, import restrictions increase Y and NX. But these gains come at the expense of other countries, as the policy merely shifts demand from foreign to domestic goods.
M-F: Summary of Policy Effects
| Policy | Type of Exchange Rate Regime | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Floating | Fixed | |||||
| Impact on Y | e | NX | Y | e | NX | |
| Fiscal Expansion | 0 | β | β | β | 0 | 0 |
| Monetary Expansion | β | β | β | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Import Restriction | 0 | β | 0 | β | 0 | β |
Interest-Rate Differentials
There are two reasons why r (domestic interest rate) may differ from r* (world interest rate):
- Country risk: The risk that the country's borrowers will default on their loan repayments because of political or economic turmoil. Lenders require a higher interest rate to compensate them for this risk.
- Expected exchange rate changes: If a country's exchange rate is expected to fall, then its borrowers must pay a higher interest rate to compensate lenders for the expected currency depreciation.
Differentials in the M-F Model
The model is modified as: r = r* + ΞΈ Where ΞΈ (theta) is a risk premium. Substitute the expression for r into the IS* and LM* equations:
- Y = C(Y - T) + I(r* + ΞΈ) + G + NX(e)
- M/P = L(r* + ΞΈ, Y)
π Definition β ΞΈ (risk premium): The additional interest rate above the world rate required to compensate lenders for country risk or expected depreciation.
The Effects of an Increase in ΞΈ
An increase in ΞΈ causes:
- IS* shifts left, because ΞΈβ β rβ β Iβ (investment falls)
- LM* shifts right, because ΞΈβ β rβ β (M/P)α΅β (money demand falls), so Y must rise to restore money market equilibrium
The exchange rate falls (depreciates). The fall in e is intuitive: An increase in country risk or an expected depreciation makes holding the country's currency less attractive.
π Example: If investors believe a country's currency will depreciate by 5% next year, they will demand a higher interest rate (r = r* + 5%) to compensate. This expected depreciation becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy as the actual exchange rate falls. The increase in Y occurs because the boost in NX (from the depreciation) is even greater than the fall in I (from the rise in r).
π‘ Why this matters: Expected depreciation is a self-fulfilling prophecy β if investors believe a currency will fall, their actions cause it to actually fall.
β Key Takeaways
Under floating exchange rates, fiscal policy has no effect on output (crowded out by exchange rate appreciation), while monetary policy is very effective. Under fixed exchange rates, the opposite holds: fiscal policy is very effective (because the central bank must increase money supply to maintain the peg), while monetary policy cannot affect output (any attempt is offset by interventions to maintain the fixed rate). Trade policy under floating rates cannot reduce a trade deficit or increase output, but under fixed rates, import restrictions do increase Y and NX, though at the expense of other countries. The Mundell-Fleming model can be extended to include interest-rate differentials through a risk premium ΞΈ, where increased country risk or expected depreciation shifts IS* left and LM* right, causing currency depreciation but potentially increasing output if the boost from NX outweighs the fall in investment.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Why does fiscal policy have zero effect on output under floating exchange rates but increase output under fixed exchange rates?
- What is the mechanism by which a central bank maintains a fixed exchange rate when there is upward pressure on the currency?
- What are the two reasons why a country's interest rate might differ from the world interest rate?
- Under which exchange rate regime can monetary policy effectively change output, and why?
- What happens to IS* and LM* curves when the risk premium ΞΈ increases, and what is the net effect on output and the exchange rate?
π Lecture 32 β The Mundell-Fleming Model (Continued) & The Three Models of Aggregate Supply
π Overview: This lecture completes the study of the Mundell-Fleming (M-F) model by examining why income might not rise after depreciation, analyzing the South East Asian crisis, and comparing floating vs. fixed exchange rates. It then derives the Aggregate Demand (AD) curve from the M-F model and introduces the three models of Aggregate Supply β the sticky-wage, imperfect-information, and sticky-price models β all of which yield the same short-run supply equation.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture first explores reasons income may not rise after a currency depreciation, including central bank intervention and import price effects. It presents data on the South East Asian crisis and compares floating vs. fixed exchange rate arguments. The M-F model is extended to derive the AD curve by allowing price level changes, then shows the transition from short run to long run. The concept of a large open economy is introduced as a middle ground. Finally, three models of aggregate supply are presented: the sticky-wage model, imperfect-information model, and sticky-price model, all implying the same relationship between output, the natural rate, and unexpected price level changes.
π Lecture Summary
WHY INCOME MIGHT NOT RISE?
After a depreciation of the domestic currency (which should boost net exports and income), income might not rise because of three possible shifts. The central bank may try to prevent the depreciation by reducing the money supply. The depreciation might boost the price of imports enough to increase the price level (which would reduce the real money supply). Consumers might respond to the increased risk by holding more money. Each of these would shift LM* leftward, reducing income instead of increasing it.
π Definition β LM*: The LM* curve represents equilibrium in the money market in the Mundell-Fleming model under a floating exchange rate, showing combinations of income and the exchange rate where money supply equals money demand.
THE SOUTH EAST ASIAN CRISIS
The lecture presents data showing the severity of the 1997-98 Asian financial crisis. For example, Indonesia experienced a -59.4% exchange rate change (depreciation against the U.S. dollar) from July 1997 to January 1998, a -32.6% stock market change, and a -16.2% change in nominal GDP from 1997-98. Thailand saw a -48.3% exchange rate change, -25.6% stock market change, and -1.2% GDP change. In contrast, the U.S. had a 2.7% stock market increase and 2.3% GDP growth, with no exchange rate change listed.
FLOATING VS. FIXED EXCHANGE RATES
Arguments for floating rates include that they allow monetary policy to be used to pursue other goals such as stable growth and low inflation. Arguments for fixed rates include that they avoid uncertainty and volatility, making international transactions easier, and they discipline monetary policy to prevent excessive money growth and hyperinflation.
MUNDELL-FLEMING AND THE AD CURVE
Previously, the M-F model assumed a fixed price level. To derive the AD curve, we now consider the impact of a change in P (the price level). The M-F equations are rewritten as: (IS*) Y = C(Y β T) + I(r*) + G + NX(Ξ΅) (LM*) M/P = L(r*, Y) Earlier, NX could be written as a function of e (the nominal exchange rate) because e and Ξ΅ (the real exchange rate) move in the same direction when P is fixed.
π Formula: Ξ΅ = e Γ (P/P*), where P* is the foreign price level. The real exchange rate measures the price of domestic goods relative to foreign goods.
DERIVING THE AD CURVE
The AD curve has a negative slope because: As P increases, M/P (real money balances) decreases, causing LM* to shift left. This increases Ξ΅ (the real exchange rate), which reduces NX (net exports), and thus reduces Y (income). This is shown graphically: LM*(Pβ) lies to the left of LM*(Pβ), at a higher Ξ΅β and lower Yβ, and the corresponding AD curve slopes downward from (Pβ, Yβ) to (Pβ, Yβ).
FROM SHORT RUN TO THE LONG RUN
If Yβ < YΜ (the natural rate of output), there is downward pressure on prices. Over time, P will move down, causing M/P to increase, which reduces Ξ΅, increases NX, and increases Y until the economy returns to YΜ at the long-run equilibrium. This transition is shown graphically: as P falls from Pβ to Pβ, the SRAS curve shifts from SRASβ to SRASβ, and output moves from Yβ back toward YΜ along the AD curve.
π‘ Why this matters: This mechanism explains how an economy self-corrects from short-run fluctuations to long-run equilibrium through price adjustment.
LARGE: BETWEEN SMALL AND CLOSED
Many countries β including the U.S. β are neither closed nor small open economies. A large open economy is in between the polar cases of closed and small open. Consider a monetary expansion: Like in a closed economy, ΞM > 0 reduces r (the interest rate), which increases I (investment) β though not as much. Like in a small open economy, ΞM > 0 reduces Ξ΅ (the real exchange rate), which increases NX β though not as much. The IS* curve shows the new equilibrium at a higher Yβ.
THREE MODELS OF AGGREGATE SUPPLY
All three models imply the same equation: Y = YΜ + Ξ±(P β Pα΅) Where: Y is aggregate output, YΜ is the natural rate of output, Ξ± is a positive parameter, P is the actual price level, and Pα΅ is the expected price level.
1- THE STICKY-WAGE MODEL
Assumes that firms and workers negotiate contracts and fix the nominal wage before they know what the price level will turn out to be. The nominal wage, W, they set is the product of a target real wage, Ο, and the expected price level: W = Ο Γ Pα΅.
- If P = Pα΅: The real wage (W/P) equals Ο, unemployment and output are at their natural rates.
- If P > Pα΅: Real wage is less than its target, so firms hire more workers and output rises above its natural rate.
- If P < Pα΅: Real wage exceeds its target, so firms hire fewer workers and output falls below its natural rate.
π Definition β Real wage: W/P, the purchasing power of nominal wages in terms of goods and services.
This model implies that the real wage should be counter-cyclical β it should move in the opposite direction as output over the course of business cycles. In booms, when P typically rises, the real wage should fall. In recessions, when P typically falls, the real wage should rise. This prediction does not come true in the real world.
π‘ Why this matters: The failure of the counter-cyclical real wage prediction is a weakness of the sticky-wage model, motivating alternative models of aggregate supply.
β Key Takeaways
The AD curve derived from the Mundell-Fleming model slopes downward because a higher price level reduces real money balances, appreciates the real exchange rate, reduces net exports, and lowers income. The transition from short run to long run involves price adjustment that restores output to its natural rate. All three aggregate supply models β sticky-wage, imperfect-information, and sticky-price β imply the same short-run relationship: output deviates from the natural rate only when the actual price level differs from the expected price level. The sticky-wage model specifically predicts a counter-cyclical real wage, which is not empirically observed. Understanding the distinction between small open, large open, and closed economies is essential for applying macroeconomic models to different countries.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What three factors can prevent income from rising after a currency depreciation in the Mundell-Fleming model, and how does each shift the LM* curve?
- How does an increase in the price level (P) affect the real exchange rate (Ξ΅), net exports (NX), and income (Y) when deriving the AD curve from the M-F model?
- In the sticky-wage model, what is the formula for the nominal wage (W) set by firms and workers, and what happens to output when P > Pα΅?
- What is the common equation implied by all three models of aggregate supply, and what does each variable represent?
- Why does the prediction of a counter-cyclical real wage in the sticky-wage model fail to match real-world data?
π Lecture 33 β Three Models of Aggregate Supply (Continued)
π Overview: This lecture continues the examination of models explaining the short-run aggregate supply curve, focusing on the imperfect-information model and the sticky-price model. Understanding these models is crucial for grasping why output can deviate from its natural rate in the short run when the actual price level differs from the expected price level.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the second and third models of aggregate supply: the imperfect-information model, which is based on supplier confusion between relative and overall price changes, and the sticky-price model, which is based on firms setting prices in advance due to menu costs and contracts. For the sticky-price model, the lecture details the derivation of the overall price level and the aggregate supply curve, concluding with a note on the pro-cyclical real wage implication.
π Lecture Summary
2- THE IMPERFECT-INFORMATION MODEL
This model assumes all wages and prices are perfectly flexible and all markets clear. Each supplier produces one good but consumes many goods. The key assumption is that each supplier knows the nominal price of the good she produces but does not know the overall price level. The supply of each good depends on its relative price: the nominal price of the good divided by the overall price level. Since the supplier doesn't know the price level at the time of her production decision, she uses the expected price level, Pα΅.
Suppose P rises but Pα΅ does not. The supplier thinks her relative price has risen (her good is now more valuable compared to others), so she produces more. With many producers thinking this way, output (Y) will rise whenever the actual price level (P) rises above the expected price level (Pα΅).
π Definition β Relative price: The nominal price of a good divided by the overall price level; what the good is truly worth in terms of purchasing power. π Formula: Y = YΜ + Ξ± (P - Pα΅) β This is the short-run aggregate supply curve, showing output deviates from its natural rate when actual prices differ from expected prices.
3- THE STICKY-PRICE MODEL
Reasons for sticky prices include long-term contracts between firms and customers, menu costs (the costs of changing prices, like printing new menus), and firms not wishing to annoy customers with frequent price changes. The model assumes firms set their own prices (e.g., as in monopolistic competition). An individual firmβs desired price is:
p = P + a(Y - YΜ ) where a > 0
This means a firm wants to set a higher nominal price when the overall price level (P) is higher or when aggregate output (Y) is above its natural rate (YΜ ), as demand for its product is higher.
Suppose two types of firms:
- Firms with flexible prices set prices as above: p = P + a(Y - YΜ ).
- Firms with sticky prices must set their price before they know how P and Y will turn out: p = Pα΅ + a(Yα΅ - YΜ α΅).
Assuming firms with sticky prices expect that output will equal its natural rate (Yα΅ = YΜ α΅), their formula simplifies to: p = Pα΅.
To derive the aggregate supply curve, we first find an expression for the overall price level. Let s denote the fraction of firms with sticky prices. Then, the overall price level (P) is a weighted average:
P = s Γ Pα΅ + (1 - s) Γ [P + a(Y - YΜ )]
The price set by sticky price firms + The price set by flexible price firms
Now, solve for P:
- Subtract (1 - s)P from both sides: sP = sPα΅ + (1 - s)[a(Y - YΜ )]
- Divide both sides by s: P = Pα΅ + [(1 - s)a / s] Γ (Y - YΜ )
This equation shows:
- High Pα΅ β High P: If firms expect high prices, firms who must set prices in advance will set them high. Other firms respond by setting high prices.
- High Y β High P: When income is high, the demand for goods is high. Firms with flexible prices set high prices. The greater the fraction of flexible price firms (smaller s), the bigger the effect of a change in Y on P.
Finally, derive the AS equation by solving for Y:
Y = YΜ + Ξ± (P - Pα΅) , where Ξ± = s / [(1 - s)a]
π‘ Why this matters: In contrast to the sticky-wage model, the sticky-price model implies a pro-cyclical real wage. Suppose aggregate output/income falls. Firms see a fall in demand for their products. Firms with sticky prices reduce production, and hence reduce their demand for labor. The leftward shift in labor demand causes the real wage to fall (a fall in the real wage accompanies a fall in output, hence pro-cyclical).
β Key Takeaways
Both the imperfect-information and sticky-price models lead to the same short-run aggregate supply equation: Y = YΜ + Ξ±(P - Pα΅), showing output deviates from its natural rate when actual prices differ from expected prices. The imperfect-information model relies on suppliers misperceiving changes in the overall price level as changes in their relative price. The sticky-price model explains price stickiness through menu costs and contracts, where a fraction of firms set prices in advance based on expectations. The derived price level equation shows that higher expected prices or higher output leads to a higher actual price level. A key difference between models is the implication for the real wage: the sticky-wage model implies a counter-cyclical real wage, while the sticky-price model implies a pro-cyclical real wage.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- In the imperfect-information model, what key information does a supplier lack when making a production decision?
- In the sticky-price model, what are two reasons given for why firms might have "sticky" prices?
- In the derivation of the sticky-price model, what does the variable "s" represent?
- Write down the final formula for the short-run aggregate supply curve derived from the sticky-price model.
- How does the sticky-price model's implication for the cyclical behavior of the real wage differ from that of the sticky-wage model?
π Lecture 34 β Inflation, Unemployment, and the Phillips Curve
π Overview: This lecture explores the relationship between inflation and unemployment through the Phillips Curve framework. It derives the modern Phillips Curve from the aggregate supply model, explains how expectations and supply shocks affect this relationship, and examines the policy trade-offs between inflation and unemployment in the short run versus long run.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers deriving the Phillips Curve from the SRAS model, the relationship between the Phillips Curve and SRAS, adaptive expectations and inflation inertia, two causes of inflation (cost-push and demand-pull), graphing and shifting the Phillips Curve, the sacrifice ratio for disinflation, rational expectations theory, the natural rate hypothesis, and the alternative hypothesis of hysteresis.
π Lecture Summary
Inflation, Unemployment, and the Phillips Curve
The Phillips curve states that inflation (Ο) depends on expected inflation (Οα΅), cyclical unemployment (the deviation of the actual unemployment rate from the natural rate), and supply shocks (Ξ½). The equation is: Ο = Οα΅ β Ξ²(u β uβΏ) + Ξ½, where Ξ² > 0 is an exogenous constant.
π Definition β Phillips Curve: A curve that shows the short-run trade-off between inflation and unemployment. π Formula: Ο = Οα΅ β Ξ²(u β uβΏ) + Ξ½ β Inflation equals expected inflation minus Ξ² times cyclical unemployment plus supply shocks. π‘ Why this matters: This relationship is central to macroeconomic policy, showing that policymakers face a trade-off between inflation and unemployment in the short run.
Deriving the Phillips Curve from SRAS
Starting from the aggregate supply equation (1) Y = Θ² + Ξ±(P β Pα΅), we can derive the Phillips Curve. First, rewrite as (2) P = Pα΅ + (1/Ξ±)(Y β Θ²). Then add a supply shock Ξ½: (3) P = Pα΅ + (1/Ξ±)(Y β Θ²) + Ξ½. Subtract last year's price level Pββ from both sides: (4) (P β Pββ) = (Pα΅ β Pββ) + (1/Ξ±)(Y β Θ²) + Ξ½. The left side is inflation Ο, and the right side has expected inflation Οα΅: (5) Ο = Οα΅ + (1/Ξ±)(Y β Θ²) + Ξ½.
Using Okun's law, which relates output and unemployment, we can write (6) (1/Ξ±)(Y β Θ²) = βΞ²(u β uβΏ). Substituting into equation 5 gives (7) Ο = Οα΅ β Ξ²(u β uβΏ) + Ξ½.
π Definition β Okun's Law: The empirical relationship stating that for every 1% increase in the unemployment rate above the natural rate, real GDP falls by approximately 2%. π Formula: (1/Ξ±)(Y β Θ²) = βΞ²(u β uβΏ) β Output gap is proportional to cyclical unemployment. π‘ Why this matters: This derivation shows how the Phillips Curve is directly linked to the aggregate supply model, connecting price level movements to unemployment fluctuations.
The Phillips Curve and SRAS
The SRAS curve states that output is related to unexpected movements in the price level: Y = Θ² + Ξ±(P β Pα΅). The Phillips curve states that unemployment is related to unexpected movements in the inflation rate: Ο = Οα΅ β Ξ²(u β uβΏ) + Ξ½. Both represent the same economic relationship from different perspectivesβone focusing on output and price level, the other on unemployment and inflation.
Adaptive Expectations
Adaptive expectations is an approach that assumes people form their expectations of future inflation based on recently observed inflation. A simple example: Οα΅ = Οββ (expected inflation equals last year's actual inflation). Then the Phillips curve becomes: Ο = Οββ β Ξ²(u β uβΏ) + Ξ½.
Inflation Inertia
In this form, the Phillips curve implies that inflation has inertia. In the absence of supply shocks or cyclical unemployment, inflation will continue indefinitely at its current rate. Past inflation influences expectations of current inflation, which in turn influences the wages and prices that people set.
Two Causes of Rising and Falling Inflation
Cost-push inflation is inflation resulting from supply shocks. Adverse supply shocks typically raise production costs and induce firms to raise prices, "pushing" inflation up. Demand-pull inflation is inflation resulting from demand shocks. Positive shocks to aggregate demand cause unemployment to fall below its natural rate, which "pulls" the inflation rate up.
π Definition β Cost-push inflation: Inflation caused by negative supply shocks that raise production costs. π Definition β Demand-pull inflation: Inflation caused by positive demand shocks that pull unemployment below its natural rate.
Graphing the Phillips Curve
In the short run, policymakers face a trade-off between Ο and u. The short-run Phillips Curve shows this inverse relationship. The curve crosses the natural rate of unemployment (uβΏ) at the level of expected inflation plus supply shocks (Οα΅ + Ξ½).
Shifting the Phillips Curve
People adjust their expectations over time, so the trade-off only holds in the short run. An increase in Οα΅ shifts the short-run Phillips Curve upward, meaning that at any given unemployment rate, inflation will be higher.
The Sacrifice Ratio
To reduce inflation, policymakers can contract aggregate demand, causing unemployment to rise above the natural rate. The sacrifice ratio measures the percentage of a year's real GDP that must be foregone to reduce inflation by 1 percentage point. A typical estimate is 5.
If policymakers wish to reduce inflation from 6 to 2 percent (a 4-point reduction) and the sacrifice ratio is 5, then reducing inflation requires a loss of 4 Γ 5 = 20 percent of one year's GDP. This could be achieved as a 20% GDP reduction for one year, 10% for each of two years, or 5% for each of four years. The cost of disinflation is lost GDP, which can be translated into unemployment using Okun's law.
π Definition β Sacrifice Ratio: The percentage of annual GDP lost to reduce inflation by 1 percentage point. π Formula: GDP loss = (inflation reduction) Γ (sacrifice ratio) β For a 4-point reduction with ratio 5: loss = 20% of one year's GDP. π Example: Reducing inflation from 6% to 2% with sacrifice ratio 5 means losing 20% of one year's GDP, achievable by reducing GDP by 5% for four consecutive years.
Rational Expectations
Rational expectations is an alternative way of modeling expectations where people base their expectations on all available information, including information about current and prospective future policies. This contrasts with adaptive expectations which rely only on past inflation.
Painless Disinflation?
Proponents of rational expectations believe that the sacrifice ratio may be very small. Suppose u = uβΏ and Ο = Οα΅ = 6%, and the central bank credibly announces it will reduce inflation from 6 to 2 percent as soon as possible. If the announcement is credible, then Οα΅ will fall, perhaps by the full 4 points. Then, Ο can fall without an increase in u.
π Definition β Rational Expectations: The theory that people optimally use all available information, including information about current and future policies, to form their expectations.
The Natural Rate Hypothesis
Our analysis is based on the natural rate hypothesis: Changes in aggregate demand affect output and employment only in the short run. In the long run, the economy returns to the levels of output, employment, and unemployment described by the classical model.
An Alternative Hypothesis: Hysteresis
Hysteresis is the long-lasting influence of history on variables such as the natural rate of unemployment. Negative shocks may increase uβΏ, so the economy may not fully recover. The skills of cyclically unemployed workers deteriorate while unemployed, and they cannot find a job when the recession ends. Cyclically unemployed workers may lose their influence on wage-setting; insiders (employed workers) may then bargain for higher wages. The cyclically unemployed "outsiders" may become structurally unemployed when the recession ends.
π Definition β Hysteresis: The theory that the natural rate of unemployment depends on the history of actual unemployment, so temporary shocks can permanently affect the natural rate.
β Key Takeaways
The Phillips CurveβΟ = Οα΅ β Ξ²(u β uβΏ) + Ξ½βis derived directly from the SRAS model and shows the short-run trade-off between inflation and unemployment. This trade-off can shift due to changes in expected inflation and supply shocks, meaning the Phillips Curve is not stable in the long run. The sacrifice ratio quantifies the GDP cost of reducing inflation, typically estimated around 5% of GDP per percentage point reduction. Rational expectations theory suggests that if disinflation policy is credible, inflation expectations can adjust quickly, potentially achieving painless disinflation. The natural rate hypothesis states that in the long run, the economy returns to its natural rate of unemployment regardless of demand-side policies, though hysteresis challenges this by suggesting that cyclical unemployment can become structural.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three forces that determine inflation according to the modern Phillips Curve?
- How is the Phillips Curve derived from the aggregate supply equation?
- What is the difference between cost-push inflation and demand-pull inflation?
- If the sacrifice ratio is 5, what GDP loss is required to reduce inflation from 8% to 3%?
- How do adaptive expectations and rational expectations differ in their implications for disinflation policy?