π Lecture 23 β Economic Growth (Continued)
π Overview: This lecture continues the discussion of economic growth, examining policies to increase saving rates and how to allocate investment across different capital types. It then confronts the Solow model with real-world facts, introduces the concept of convergence, and presents endogenous growth theory as an alternative framework where growth rates are determined within the model rather than externally.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers policies to increase saving rates including reducing deficits and tax incentives, then discusses allocating investment among private capital, public infrastructure, and human capital. It examines encouraging technological progress through patents and R&D incentives, presents growth empirics confronting the Solow model with facts about convergence, explains conditional convergence, and introduces endogenous growth theory including basic and two-sector models with their implications for knowledge and R&D.
π Lecture Summary
2. POLICIES TO INCREASE THE SAVING RATE
To raise the saving rate, governments can reduce the budget deficit or increase surpluses, which raises national saving. They can also increase incentives for private saving by reducing taxes that discourage saving such as capital gains tax, corporate income tax, and estate tax. Another approach is to replace the federal income tax with a consumption tax that taxes spending rather than income, and expand tax incentives for retirement accounts.
3. ALLOCATING THE ECONOMYβS INVESTMENT
In the real world, there are many types of capital divided into three categories: private capital stock, public infrastructure, and human capital (knowledge and skills workers acquire through education). The Solow model only has one type of capital, raising the question of how to allocate investment among these types.
Two viewpoints exist. The first is to equalize tax treatment of all capital types and let the market allocate investment to the type with the highest marginal product. The second is industrial policy, where the government actively encourages investment in certain capital types or industries because they may have positive externalities (by-products) that private investors don't consider.
π Definition β Industrial policy: Government actively encouraging investment in specific capital types or industries due to positive externalities.
Possible problems with industrial policy include whether the government has the ability to "pick winners" (choose industries with highest return to capital or biggest externalities), and whether politics rather than economics would influence which industries get preferential treatment.
4. ENCOURAGING TECHNOLOGICAL PROGRESS
Methods to encourage technological progress include patent laws that grant temporary monopolies to inventors, tax incentives for R&D, grants to fund basic research at universities, and industrial policy targeting specific industries key for rapid technological progress (subject to concerns about government's ability to pick winners).
GROWTH EMPIRICS: CONFRONTING THE SOLOW MODEL WITH THE FACTS The Solow model's steady state exhibits balanced growth where many variables grow at the same rate. The model predicts that Y/L and K/L grow at the same rate (g), so K/Y should be constant, which is true in the real world. It also predicts that the real wage grows at the same rate as Y/L while the real rental price is constant, which is also confirmed by real-world data.
CONVERGENCE The Solow model predicts that, other things equal, "poor" countries with lower Y/L and K/L should grow faster than "rich" ones. If true, income gaps would shrink over time and living standards would "converge." However, in the real world, many poor countries do NOT grow faster than rich ones. This doesn't mean the Solow model fails because "other things" aren't equal.
π Definition β Conditional convergence: Countries converge to their own steady states, which are determined by saving, population growth, and education.
In samples of countries with similar savings and population growth rates, income gaps shrink about 2% per year. In larger samples controlling for differences in saving, population growth, and human capital, incomes also converge by about 2% per year. This confirms the Solow model's prediction of conditional convergence.
FACTOR ACCUMULATION VS. PRODUCTION EFFICIENCY Two reasons explain why income per capita is lower in some countries: differences in capital (physical or human) per worker, and differences in the efficiency of production (the height of the production function). Studies show both factors are important. Countries with higher capital per worker also tend to have higher production efficiency. Possible explanations include that production efficiency encourages capital accumulation, capital accumulation has externalities that raise efficiency, or a third unknown variable causes both to be higher in some countries.
ENDOGENOUS GROWTH THEORY
In the Solow model, sustained growth in living standards is due to technological progress, but the rate of technological progress is exogenous (determined outside the model). Endogenous growth theory is a set of models where the growth rate of productivity and living standards is determined within the model.
A basic model The production function is: Y = A K, where A is the amount of output for each unit of capital (A is exogenous and constant). The key difference from the Solow model is that the marginal product of capital (MPK) is constant here while it diminishes in the Solow model.
π Formula: Investment = sY, Depreciation = Ξ΄K, Equation of motion: βK = sY β Ξ΄K
Dividing through by K and using Y = A K gives: ΞY/Y = ΞK/K = sA β Ξ΄
π Example: If sA > Ξ΄, then income will grow forever, and investment is the "engine of growth." The permanent growth rate depends on s, unlike in the Solow model where it does not.
π‘ Why this matters: In endogenous growth theory, policies that affect the saving rate can permanently affect the growth rate, whereas in the Solow model they only affect the level of income.
DOES CAPITAL HAVE DIMINISHING RETURNS OR NOT? Yes, if "capital" is narrowly defined (plant and equipment). Perhaps not, with a broad definition of "capital" including physical and human capital and knowledge. Some economists believe knowledge exhibits increasing returns. In the endogenous growth model, the assumption of constant returns to capital is more plausible.
A TWO-SECTOR MODEL There are two sectors: manufacturing firms that produce goods, and research universities that produce knowledge increasing labor efficiency in manufacturing. Let u = fraction of labor in research (u is exogenous).
π Definition: Manufacturing production function: Y = F[K, (1-u)EL] π Definition: Research production function: ΞE = g(u)E π Formula: Capital accumulation: βK = sY β Ξ΄K
In the steady state, manufacturing output per worker and the standard of living grow at rate ΞE/E = g(u). Key variables are: s which affects the level of income but not its growth rate (same as in Solow model), and u which affects both the level and growth rate of income.
π Example: Would an increase in u be unambiguously good for the economy? No, because while it raises the growth rate, it reduces the fraction of labor producing goods, potentially lowering current output.
THREE FACTS ABOUT R&D IN THE REAL WORLD
- Much research is done by firms seeking profits.
- Firms profit from research because new inventions can be patented, creating monopoly profits until the patent expires. There is an advantage to being first on the market with a new product.
- Innovation produces externalities that reduce the cost of subsequent innovation.
IS THE PRIVATE SECTOR DOING ENOUGH R&D? The existence of positive externalities in knowledge creation suggests the private sector is not doing enough R&D. However, there is much duplication of R&D effort among competing firms. Estimates show the social return to R&D is at least 40% per year, leading many to believe government should encourage R&D.
β Key Takeaways
Students must remember that endogenous growth theory differs from the Solow model by treating technological progress as determined within the model rather than externally, and the key distinction is that the marginal product of capital is constant (not diminishing) when capital is broadly defined. The basic endogenous growth model Y = AK shows that if sA > Ξ΄, income grows forever with the growth rate depending on the saving rate. Conditional convergence is the Solow model's correct prediction that countries converge to their own steady states determined by saving, population growth, and education, explaining why poor countries don't always grow faster than rich ones. The two-sector model shows that the fraction of labor in research (u) affects both the level and growth rate of income, while the saving rate (s) only affects the level. Finally, the social return to R&D is at least 40% per year, and positive externalities in knowledge creation suggest government encouragement of R&D may be justified despite duplication of effort.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the fundamental difference between the Solow model and endogenous growth theory regarding the marginal product of capital?
- In the basic endogenous growth model Y = AK, what condition must hold for continuous growth, and what determines the growth rate?
- What is conditional convergence, and why does it explain why some poor countries don't grow faster than rich ones?
- In the two-sector model, how does the fraction of labor in research (u) affect the economy differently from the saving rate (s)?
- What three facts about R&D in the real world does new endogenous growth theory attempt to incorporate?
π Lecture 24 β Aggregate Demand and Aggregate Supply
π Overview: This lecture introduces the Aggregate Demand-Aggregate Supply (AD-AS) model, the primary framework used by economists to analyze economic fluctuations and the effects of stabilization policies. It explains how the economy behaves differently in the short run when prices are sticky versus the long run when prices are flexible, and shows how monetary policy affects output and prices in each time horizon.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers time horizons and the distinction between sticky and flexible prices, classical macroeconomic theory regarding output determination, the model of aggregate demand and supply, the quantity equation as a basis for aggregate demand, the downward-sloping AD curve and its shifts, long-run aggregate supply as a vertical curve, long-run effects of an increase in money supply, short-run aggregate supply as a horizontal curve, short-run effects of an increase in money supply, the transition from short-run to long-run equilibrium, and a summary of the short-run and long-run effects of an increase in the money supply.
π Lecture Summary
TIME HORIZONS
The economy behaves differently depending on the time frame considered. In the long run, prices are flexible and respond to changes in supply or demand. In the short run, many prices are "sticky" at some predetermined level. This stickiness is the key reason why economic fluctuations and stabilization policies matter.
CLASSICAL MACROECONOMIC THEORY
According to classical macroeconomic theory, output is determined by the supply side: the supplies of capital and labor, and technology. Changes in demand for goods and services (consumption, investment, government spending) only affect prices, not quantities. Complete price flexibility is a crucial assumption of this theory, so classical theory applies in the long run.
WHEN PRICES ARE STICKY
When prices are sticky, output and employment also depend on demand for goods and services. This demand is affected by: fiscal policy (government spending G and taxes T), monetary policy (money supply M), and other factors like exogenous changes in consumption C or investment I.
THE MODEL OF AGGREGATE DEMAND AND SUPPLY
The AD-AS model is the paradigm that most mainstream economists and policymakers use to think about economic fluctuations and policies to stabilize the economy. It shows how the price level and aggregate output are determined and how the economy's behavior differs in the short run and long run.
AGGREGATE DEMAND
The aggregate demand (AD) curve shows the relationship between the price level and the quantity of output demanded. For an introduction to the AD/AS model, a simple theory of aggregate demand based on the Quantity Theory of Money is used.
THE QUANTITY EQUATION AS AGGREGATE DEMAND
Recall the quantity equation: M Γ V = P Γ Y and the money demand function it implies: (M/P)α΅ = k Γ Y, where V = 1/k = velocity. For given values of M and V, these equations imply an inverse relationship between P and Y.
π Definition β Quantity Equation: M Γ V = P Γ Y, where M is the money supply, V is the velocity of money, P is the price level, and Y is real output.
THE DOWNWARD-SLOPING AD CURVE
An increase in the price level causes a fall in real money balances (M/P), causing a decrease in the demand for goods and services. This creates the downward-sloping AD curve.
π‘ Why this matters: Higher prices reduce the purchasing power of money, leading to lower spending and output demanded.
SHIFTING THE AD CURVE
An increase in the money supply shifts the AD curve to the right. A decrease in the money supply would shift the AD curve to the left.
π Example: If the central bank increases M, then at any given price level P, the real money balances (M/P) are higher, increasing the demand for goods and services and shifting AD to the right.
AGGREGATE SUPPLY IN THE LONG RUN
In the long run, output is determined by factor supplies and technology: Y = F(K, L). Θ² is the full-employment or natural level of output, the level of output at which the economy's resources are fully employed. "Full employment" means that unemployment equals its natural rate. Full-employment output does not depend on the price level, so the long-run aggregate supply (LRAS) curve is vertical.
π Definition β Natural Rate of Output (Θ²): The level of output at which the economy's resources are fully employed and unemployment equals its natural rate.
LONG-RUN EFFECTS OF AN INCREASE IN MONEY
An increase in the money supply M shifts the AD curve to the right. In the long run, this increases the price level but leaves output the same (at Θ²). This demonstrates classical dichotomy and money neutrality in the long run.
π Example: The economy starts at equilibrium with price level Pβ. The central bank increases M, shifting AD from ADβ to ADβ. In the long run, the price level rises to Pβ, but output remains at Θ².
AGGREGATE SUPPLY IN THE SHORT RUN
In the real world, many prices are sticky in the short run. For now, we assume that all prices are stuck at a predetermined level in the short run and that firms are willing to sell as much as their customers are willing to buy at that price level. Therefore, the short-run aggregate supply (SRAS) curve is horizontal. The price level is fixed at a predetermined level, and firms sell as much as buyers demand.
SHORT-RUN EFFECTS OF AN INCREASE IN M
In the short run when prices are sticky, an increase in the money supply shifts the AD curve to the right. Since the price level is fixed (P), the increase in aggregate demand causes output to rise from Yβ to Yβ.
π Example: The economy is at Yβ with sticky price level P. The central bank increases M, shifting AD from ADβ to ADβ. Since prices cannot adjust, the only way to meet the higher demand is for firms to produce more, so output rises to Yβ.
FROM THE SHORT RUN TO THE LONG RUN
Over time, prices gradually become "unstuck." The adjustment process depends on the relationship between actual output Y and potential output Θ²:
- If Y > Θ² (output above potential), the price level will rise over time.
- If Y < Θ² (output below potential), the price level will fall over time.
- If Y = Θ² (output at potential), the price level will remain constant.
This adjustment of prices is what moves the economy to its long-run equilibrium.
THE SR & LR EFFECTS OF ΞM > 0
The full adjustment process for an increase in the money supply involves three stages:
- Point A: Initial equilibrium at Y = Θ² with price level Pβ.
- Point B: New short-run equilibrium after the central bank increases M. Output rises to Yβ, but the price level is still Pβ because prices are sticky.
- Point C: Long-run equilibrium. Since Yβ > Θ², prices rise over time. The SRAS curve shifts upward until the economy returns to Θ² at a higher price level Pβ.
π Example: The economy starts at A. The central bank increases M, shifting AD to ADβ. In the short run (B), output rises to Yβ at price Pβ. Since output exceeds potential, prices gradually rise, shifting SRAS upward until the economy reaches long-run equilibrium at C, where output is back at Θ² and the price level is Pβ.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concept from this lecture is the distinction between short-run and long-run macroeconomic behavior. In the long run, prices are flexible, output is determined by supply-side factors (capital, labor, technology), and changes in money supply only affect prices (money neutrality). In the short run, prices are sticky, so changes in aggregate demand (from monetary or fiscal policy) affect output and employment. The AD curve slopes downward because higher prices reduce real money balances and demand. The LRAS is vertical at the natural rate of output, while the SRAS is horizontal at a predetermined price level. An increase in the money supply raises output in the short run but only raises prices in the long run, with the transition occurring as prices gradually adjust back toward full employment.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Why is the long-run aggregate supply curve vertical, while the short-run aggregate supply curve is horizontal?
- Using the quantity equation M Γ V = P Γ Y, explain why the aggregate demand curve is downward-sloping.
- What happens to output and the price level in both the short run and long run when the central bank increases the money supply?
- If actual output (Y) is greater than potential output (Θ²), what will happen to the price level over time, and why?
- Explain the difference between classical theory (long run) and the sticky-price model (short run) regarding the role of aggregate demand in determining output.
π Lecture 25 β Aggregate Demand and Aggregate Supply (Continued)
π Overview: This lecture examines how exogenous shocksβunexpected changes in aggregate demand or supplyβtemporarily push the economy away from full-employment equilibrium. It explains the mechanics of demand shocks and supply shocks, analyzing their short-run and long-run effects on output, prices, and employment, using historical oil price shocks as real-world examples.
ποΈ Topics Covered
Shocks are defined as exogenous changes in aggregate supply or demand that temporarily push the economy away from full-employment. The lecture covers demand shocks (positive and negative) and their short-run vs. long-run adjustment paths along the AD-AS model. It then introduces supply shocks (adverse and favorable), explains the role of stabilization policy (especially monetary accommodation), and concludes with detailed case studies of the 1970s and 1980s oil price shocks, showing how they affected inflation, output, and unemployment.
π Lecture Summary
SHOCKS: exogenous changes in aggregate supply or demand
Shocks are exogenous changes in aggregate supply or demand that temporarily push the economy away from full-employment. They are the primary source of short-run economic fluctuations.
A DEMAND SHOCK
The economy begins in long-run equilibrium at point A. An increase in aggregate demand, due to an increase in the velocity of money, moves the economy from point A to point B, where output is above its natural level. As prices rise, output gradually returns to its natural rate, and the economy moves from point B to point C.
π Definition β Demand Shock: An exogenous change in aggregate demand (e.g., a change in velocity of money) that temporarily pushes output away from its natural level.
π Example: A positive demand shock (increase in V) shifts AD right β output rises above Yn in the short run, then prices rise and output returns to Yn in the long run.
THE EFFECTS OF A NEGATIVE DEMAND SHOCK
An exogenous decrease in velocity: If the money supply is held constant, then a decrease in V means people will be using their money in fewer transactions, causing a decrease in demand for goods and services. The shock shifts AD left, causing output and employment to fall in the short run. Over time, prices fall and the economy moves down its demand curve toward full-employment.
π Example: A negative demand shock (decrease in V) shifts AD left β output and employment fall in the short run; eventually, falling prices restore full-employment output.
π‘ Why this matters: The self-correcting mechanism of the economy works through price adjustments, but it can take a long timeβjustifying the need for stabilization policy.
SUPPLY SHOCKS
A supply shock alters production costs, affects the prices that firms charge (also called price shocks). Examples of adverse supply shocks:
- Bad weather reduces crop yields, pushing up food prices.
- Workers unionize, negotiate wage increases.
- New environmental regulations require firms to reduce emissions. Firms charge higher prices to help cover the costs of compliance. (Favorable supply shocks lower costs and prices)
π Definition β Supply Shock: An exogenous change in production costs that affects the prices firms charge, shifting the short-run aggregate supply curve.
π Example: An adverse supply shock shifts SRAS up (or left) β output falls (stagflation: higher prices + lower output).
STABILIZATION POLICY
Stabilization policy refers to policy actions aimed at reducing the severity of short-run economic fluctuations. Example: Using monetary policy to combat the effects of adverse supply shocks. When a central bank accommodates the shock by raising aggregate demand, the result is that P is permanently higher, but Y remains at its full-employment level.
π Definition β Stabilization Policy: Policy actions (monetary or fiscal) aimed at reducing the severity of short-run economic fluctuations.
π Example: After an adverse supply shock, the central bank can increase AD to prevent a recession, but with the trade-off of permanently higher prices.
THE 1970s OIL SHOCKS
Early 1970s: OPEC coordinates a reduction in the supply of oil. Oil prices rose 11% in 1973, 68% in 1974, and 16% in 1975. Such sharp oil price increases are supply shocks because they significantly impact production costs and prices. The oil price shock shifts SRAS up, causing output and employment to fall. In absence of further price shocks, prices will fall over time and economy moves back toward full employment. Predicted effects of the oil price shock: Inflation β, Output β, Unemployment β and then a gradual recovery.
π Example: The 1973-1975 oil price shock caused stagflationβhigh inflation and high unemployment simultaneouslyβexactly as the AD-AS model predicts for an adverse supply shock.
LATE 1970s: As economy was recovering, oil prices shot up again, causing another huge supply shock!!!
π Example: The 1979 oil shock (second OPEC crisis) repeated the pattern: oil prices surged, inflation and unemployment rose again.
THE 1980s OIL SHOCKS
1980s: A favorable supply shockβa significant fall in oil prices. As the model would predict, inflation and unemployment fell.
π Example: The 1986 oil price collapse (oil prices fell ~50%) reduced production costs, shifting SRAS down β both inflation and unemployment decreased, confirming the model's predictions for a favorable supply shock.
β Key Takeaways
Shocks are exogenous changes that temporarily push the economy away from full-employment. Demand shocks (changes in velocity, e.g.) shift the AD curve: positive shocks cause short-run output booms followed by price increases, while negative shocks cause recessions followed by falling prices. Supply shocks shift the SRAS curve: adverse shocks cause stagflation (higher prices + lower output), while favorable shocks reduce both inflation and unemployment. The economy is self-correcting in the long run through price adjustments, but stabilization policy (especially monetary accommodation) can be used to mitigate short-run fluctuations, though often with trade-offs like permanently higher prices. Historical oil price shocks from the 1970s and 1980s perfectly illustrate these dynamics: the 1973-74 and 1979 oil price increases caused stagflation, while the 1986 oil price collapse led to falling inflation and unemployment.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the key difference between a demand shock and a supply shock in terms of which curve they shift (AD vs. SRAS)?
- In the AD-AS model, what happens to output, prices, and employment in the short run and long run after a negative demand shock?
- What is "stagflation" and which type of shock typically causes it?
- When a central bank "accommodates" an adverse supply shock, what is the trade-off in terms of output and prices?
- Using the oil price shocks of the 1970s and 1980s, explain how the data confirmed the AD-AS model's predictions for both adverse and favorable supply shocks.
π Lecture 26 β KEYNESIAN THEORY OF INCOME & EMPLOYMENT
π Overview: This lecture presents the Keynesian theory of income and employment, focusing on the short run where prices are fixed and output is determined by aggregate demand. The Keynesian Cross model is introduced as a framework for understanding how planned expenditure determines equilibrium income, and the concepts of government purchases and tax multipliers are derived.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture distinguishes between long-run and short-run macroeconomic conditions, introduces the Keynesian Cross model with its components including consumption function, planned expenditure, and equilibrium condition, graphs planned expenditure and equilibrium, derives the government purchases multiplier showing why it exceeds one, analyzes the effects of tax increases, derives the tax multiplier and its properties, and finally introduces the IS curve as representing goods market equilibrium across different interest rates and output levels.
π Lecture Summary
KEYNESIAN THEORY OF INCOME & EMPLOYMENT
In the long run, prices are flexible, output is determined by factors of production and technology, and unemployment equals its natural rate. In the short run, prices are fixed, output is determined by aggregate demand, and unemployment is negatively related to output.
THE KEYNESIAN CROSS
The Keynesian Cross is the simple closed economy model in which income is determined by expenditure, presented by J.M. Keynes.
Notations:
- I = planned investment
- E = C + I + G = planned expenditure
- Y = real GDP = actual expenditure
Actual expenditure is the amount that households, firms, and the government spend on goods and services; it equals the economy's gross domestic product (GDP). Planned expenditure is the amount households, firms, and the government would like to spend on goods and services.
ELEMENTS OF THE KEYNESIAN CROSS
Consumption function: C = C(Y - T) Govt policy variables: G = G, T = T For now, investment is exogenous: I = I
Planned expenditure: E = C(Y - T) + I + G Equilibrium condition: Actual expenditure = Planned expenditure β Y = E
GRAPHING PLANNED EXPENDITURE
The planned expenditure line (E = C + I + G) is plotted with income/output (Y) on the horizontal axis and planned expenditure on the vertical axis. The slope of this line equals the MPC (Marginal Propensity to Consume).
GRAPHING THE EQUILIBRIUM CONDITION
The equilibrium condition Y = E is represented by a 45-degree line from the origin, where actual expenditure equals planned expenditure at every point.
THE EQUILIBRIUM VALUE OF INCOME
Equilibrium income occurs at the intersection of the planned expenditure line (E = C + I + G) and the 45-degree line (Y = E).
AN INCREASE IN GOVERNMENT PURCHASES
An increase in government purchases (ΞG) shifts the planned expenditure line upward by ΞG. At the initial income level Yβ, there is now an unplanned drop in inventory, so firms increase output, and income rises toward a new equilibrium.
SOLVING FOR ΞY
Equilibrium condition: Y = C + I + G In changes form: ΞY = ΞC + ΞI + ΞG Since I is exogenous: ΞY = ΞC + ΞG Because ΞC = MPC Γ ΞY: ΞY = MPC Γ ΞY + ΞG
Collect terms with ΞY on the left side: (1 - MPC) Γ ΞY = ΞG
Finally, solve for ΞY: ΞY = [1/(1 - MPC)] Γ ΞG
THE GOVERNMENT PURCHASES MULTIPLIER
The increase in income resulting from Rs.1 increase in G is known as the government purchases multiplier.
π Formula: ΞY/ΞG = 1/(1 - MPC)
π Example: If MPC = 0.8, then ΞY/ΞG = 1/(1 - 0.8) = 1/0.2 = 5. The increase in G causes income to increase by 5 times as much!
WHY THE MULTIPLIER IS GREATER THAN 1
Initially, the increase in G causes an equal increase in Y: ΞY = ΞG. But βY β βC β further βY β further βC β further βY. So the final impact on income is much bigger than the initial ΞG.
π‘ Why this matters: This explains why government spending can have a powerful effect on the economyβeach rupee spent generates additional rounds of consumption spending.
AN INCREASE IN TAXES
A tax increase reduces consumption: ΞC = -MPC Γ ΞT. This shifts the planned expenditure line downward. At the initial income level Yβ, there is now an unplanned inventory buildup, so firms reduce output, and income falls toward a new equilibrium.
SOLVING FOR ΞY
Equilibrium condition in changes: ΞY = ΞC + ΞI + ΞG I and G are exogenous: ΞY = ΞC ΞC = MPC Γ (ΞY - ΞT)
Solving for ΞY: (1 - MPC) Γ ΞY = -MPC Γ ΞT
Final result: ΞY = [-MPC/(1 - MPC)] Γ ΞT
THE TAX MULTIPLIER
The change in income resulting from a $1 increase in T is known as the tax multiplier.
π Formula: ΞY/ΞT = -MPC/(1 - MPC)
π Example: If MPC = 0.8, then ΞY/ΞT = -0.8/(1 - 0.8) = -0.8/0.2 = -4
PROPERTIES OF TAX MULTIPLIER
- Tax multiplier is negative: A tax hike reduces consumer spending, which reduces income.
- Tax multiplier is greater than one (in absolute value): A change in taxes has a multiplier effect on income.
- Tax multiplier is smaller than the govt. spending multiplier: Consumers save the fraction (1-MPC) of a tax cut, so the initial boost in spending from a tax cut is smaller than from an equal increase in G.
IS CURVE
A graph of all combinations of r and Y that result in goods market equilibrium is called the IS curve. Goods market equilibrium means actual expenditure (output) = planned expenditure.
The equation for the IS curve is: Y = C(Y - T) + I(r) + G
π Definition β IS Curve: Shows all combinations of the interest rate (r) and income (Y) such that the goods market is in equilibrium.
DERIVING THE IS CURVE
Starting from an initial equilibrium at interest rate rβ and output Yβ:
- A decrease in interest rates (βr) causes an increase in planned investment (βI)
- This shifts the planned expenditure line upward (E = C + I(rβ) + G)
- The new equilibrium occurs at a higher output level Yβ
- Plotting (rβ, Yβ) and (rβ, Yβ) gives points on the IS curve, which slopes downward
π‘ Why this matters: The IS curve shows the negative relationship between interest rates and output in the goods marketβlower interest rates stimulate investment, which increases output through the multiplier.
β Key Takeaways
The Keynesian Cross model demonstrates that in the short run with fixed prices, output is determined by planned expenditure. The government purchases multiplier equals 1/(1-MPC) and exceeds one because initial spending increases generate successive rounds of consumption. The tax multiplier equals -MPC/(1-MPC), is negative, and has a smaller absolute value than the government spending multiplier because part of any tax cut is saved. The IS curve captures all combinations of interest rates and output where the goods market is in equilibrium, sloping downward because lower interest rates stimulate investment and thus increase equilibrium output. Understanding these multipliers is essential for analyzing fiscal policy effectiveness.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the equilibrium condition in the Keynesian Cross model?
- Derive the government purchases multiplier and explain why it exceeds 1.
- What is the tax multiplier when MPC = 0.6? Show your calculation.
- Why is the tax multiplier smaller in absolute value than the government spending multiplier?
- Explain why the IS curve slopes downward. What happens to planned expenditure and output when the interest rate falls?
π Lecture 27 β IS Curveβs Slope & IS-LM Framework
π Overview: This lecture introduces the IS-LM framework, a cornerstone of macroeconomic analysis that shows the interaction between the goods market (IS curve) and the money market (LM curve). It explains the slope of each curve, how fiscal and monetary policies shift them, and how the short-run equilibrium of the economy is determined.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the negative slope of the IS curve, its relationship with the loanable funds model, and how fiscal policy (changes in G and T) shifts the IS curve. It then introduces the Theory of Liquidity Preference to explain interest rate determination in the money market, derives the positively sloped LM curve, shows how the central bank can raise interest rates by reducing the money supply, and how changes in M shift the LM curve. Finally, it defines the short-run equilibrium where both markets clear simultaneously.
π Lecture Summary
IS CURVEβS SLOPE
The IS curve is negatively sloped. A fall in the interest rate motivates firms to increase investment spending, which drives up total planned spending (E). To restore equilibrium in the goods market, output (actual expenditure, Y) must increase.
IS CURVE AND THE LOANABLE FUNDS MODEL
The IS curve can be derived from the loanable funds model. In the loanable funds model, the interest rate (r) equilibrates saving (S) and investment (I). A lower interest rate increases investment, which corresponds to a higher level of income (Y) on the IS curve. The lecture shows a two-panel diagram: panel (a) shows the loanable funds market with saving and investment curves, and panel (b) shows the resulting downward-sloping IS curve plotting r against Y.
π Definition β IS Curve: A graph of all combinations of r and Y that equate planned expenditure (E) and actual expenditure (Y) in the goods market.
FISCAL POLICY AND IS CURVE
Fiscal policy (changes in government spending G and taxes T) can shift the IS curve.
SHIFTING THE IS CURVE: ΞG
An increase in government spending (ΞG) shifts the IS curve to the right. The mechanism is: at any value of r, an increase in G raises planned expenditure (E), which then raises income (Y) through the multiplier effect. The lecture shows this with a Keynesian Cross diagram where the planned expenditure line shifts up from E = C + I(rβ) + Gβ to E = C + I(rβ) + Gβ, increasing output from Yβ to Yβ. The corresponding IS curve shifts right from ISβ to ISβ.
π Formula: ΞY = (1/(1-MPC)) Γ ΞG β The change in income equals the government spending multiplier times the change in government spending.
THE THEORY OF LIQUIDITY PREFERENCE
John Maynard Keynes presented a simple theory in which the interest rate is determined by money supply and money demand. In this theory, the interest rate adjusts to equilibrate the supply and demand for real money balances.
MONEY SUPPLY
The supply of real money balances (M/P) is fixed by the central bank and is independent of the interest rate. It is represented as a vertical line in the money market diagram.
π Formula: (M/P)Λ’ = MΜ/PΜ β The real money supply is fixed at a given level.
MONEY DEMAND
The demand for real money balances is a function of the interest rate: (M/P)α΅ = L(r). As the interest rate rises, the opportunity cost of holding money increases, so the quantity of money demanded falls. The money demand curve is downward sloping.
π Formula: (M/P)α΅ = L(r) β Demand for real money balances is a decreasing function of the interest rate.
EQUILIBRIUM
The interest rate adjusts to equate the supply and demand for money. At the equilibrium interest rate rβ, the quantity of real money balances demanded exactly equals the fixed supply.
π Formula: M/P = L(r) β In equilibrium, real money supply equals real money demand.
π‘ Why this matters: The Theory of Liquidity Preference explains how the interest rate is determined in the short run, which is essential for understanding monetary policy transmission.
HOW CENTRAL BANK RAISES THE INTEREST RATE
To increase the interest rate, the Central Bank reduces the money supply (M). By shifting the money supply curve to the left (from Mβ/P to Mβ/P), the equilibrium interest rate rises from rβ to rβ to eliminate the excess demand for money.
LM CURVE
The LM curve is a graph of all combinations of r and Y that equate the supply and demand for real money balances. When income (Y) is included in the money demand function, the equation for the LM curve becomes:
π Formula: M/P = L(r, Y) β The LM curve shows all combinations of r and Y for which the money market is in equilibrium.
DERIVING THE LM CURVE
The LM curve is derived using a two-panel diagram. Panel (a) shows the market for real money balances. An increase in income from Yβ to Yβ raises money demand, shifting the L(r) curve to the right. Since the money supply is fixed, the interest rate must rise from rβ to rβ to restore equilibrium. In panel (b), this positive relationship between income and the interest rate generates the upward-sloping LM curve.
π Example: If income (Y) rises, consumers and firms demand more money for transactions. This excess demand pushes up the interest rate until money demand falls back to equal the fixed supply.
LM CURVEβS SLOPE
The LM curve is positively sloped. An increase in income raises money demand. Since the supply of real balances is fixed, there is now excess demand in the money market at the initial interest rate. The interest rate must rise to restore equilibrium in the money market.
HOW ΞM SHIFTS THE LM CURVE
A decrease in the money supply (ΞMβ) shifts the LM curve to the left. In panel (a), reducing the money supply from Mβ/P to Mβ/P raises the interest rate from rβ to rβ at the initial income level Yβ. In panel (b), this means every level of income is now associated with a higher interest rate, so the LM curve shifts left from LMβ to LMβ.
π‘ Why this matters: Contractionary monetary policy (reducing M) shifts the LM curve up/left, raising interest rates and reducing output. Expansionary monetary policy (increasing M) shifts the LM curve down/right, lowering interest rates and raising output.
SHIFTING THE LM CURVE
Exercise Question: Suppose a wave of credit card fraud causes consumers to use cash more frequently in transactions. Use the Liquidity Preference model to show how these events shift the LM curve. Answer hint: Increased cash usage raises money demand (L(r, Y) shifts right). At the fixed money supply, this creates excess demand, pushing up the interest rate. This causes the LM curve to shift left/upward.
THE SHORT-RUN EQUILIBRIUM
The short-run equilibrium is the combination of r and Y that simultaneously satisfies the equilibrium conditions in both the goods market and the money market. This is found at the intersection of the IS curve and the LM curve.
π Formulas:
- Goods market: Y = C(Y - T) + I(r) + G
- Money market: M/P = L(r, Y)
At the intersection, the equilibrium interest rate and the equilibrium level of income are determined. The IS curve represents all points where the goods market is in balance, and the LM curve represents all points where the money market is in balance. Only at their intersection are both markets in simultaneous equilibrium.
β Key Takeaways
The IS-LM model shows the short-run interaction between the goods market (IS curve) and the money market (LM curve). The IS curve is negatively sloped because lower interest rates boost investment and output. The LM curve is positively sloped because higher income raises money demand, requiring higher interest rates to maintain equilibrium. Fiscal policy (changes in G and T) shifts the IS curve, while monetary policy (changes in M) shifts the LM curve. The goods market equilibrium condition is Y = C(Y-T) + I(r) + G, and the money market equilibrium is M/P = L(r, Y), and the short-run equilibrium is where both hold simultaneously.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Why is the IS curve negatively sloped?
- How does an increase in government spending (G) shift the IS curve, and what is the mechanism?
- According to the Theory of Liquidity Preference, how is the interest rate determined?
- Why is the LM curve positively sloped?
- What happens to the LM curve if the central bank reduces the money supply?
π Lecture 28 β IS-LM Framework (Continued) The Big Picture
π Overview: This lecture completes the IS-LM framework by showing how the goods market (IS curve) and money market (LM curve) intersect to determine equilibrium output and interest rates. It then analyzes how fiscal and monetary policies affect the economy, including the interaction between these policies and the central bank's choice of policy instrument.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers equilibrium in the IS-LM model where IS and LM curves intersect; policy analysis showing effects of increased government purchases, tax cuts, and monetary expansion; interaction between monetary and fiscal policy including three central bank responses to fiscal expansion; IS and LM shocks from exogenous changes; and the central bank's decision to target interest rates rather than the money supply.
π Lecture Summary
Equilibrium in the IS-LM Model
The IS curve represents equilibrium in the goods market, while the LM curve represents money market equilibrium where M/P = L(r, Y). The intersection of these two curves determines the unique combination of Y (output) and r (interest rate) that satisfies equilibrium in both markets simultaneously.
π Definition β Money Market Equilibrium: M/P = L(r, Y) β Real money supply equals real money demand, where demand depends on the interest rate and income.
Policy Analysis with the IS-LM Model
Policymakers can affect macroeconomic variables using fiscal policy (government spending G and/or taxes T) and monetary policy (money supply M). The IS-LM model analyzes the effects of these policies on output and interest rates.
An Increase in Government Purchases
When government purchases increase, the IS curve shifts right by 1/(1-MPC) Γ ΞG, causing output and income to rise. This raises money demand, causing the interest rate to rise. The higher interest rate reduces investment, so the final increase in Y is smaller than 1/(1-MPC) Γ ΞG.
π Formula: IS shift = [1/(1-MPC)] Γ ΞG β The multiplier effect of government spending on output
π Example: If MPC = 0.8, then 1/(1-0.8) = 5. A $100 billion increase in G shifts IS right by $500 billion, but the final Y increase will be less than $500 billion due to crowding out of investment.
A Tax Cut
Because consumers save (1-MPC) of the tax cut, the initial boost in spending is smaller for ΞT than for an equal ΞG. The IS curve shifts by [1/(1-MPC)] Γ (1-MPC) Γ ΞT = MPC/(1-MPC) Γ ΞT. The effects on r and Y are smaller for a ΞT than for an equal ΞG.
π Formula: IS shift from tax cut = [MPC/(1-MPC)] Γ ΞT β The tax multiplier, smaller than the government spending multiplier
Monetary Policy: An Increase in M
An increase in money supply (ΞM > 0) shifts the LM curve down (or to the right). This causes the interest rate to fall, which increases investment, causing output and income to rise.
π‘ Why this matters: Expansionary monetary policy lowers interest rates to stimulate investment and output, while expansionary fiscal policy raises interest rates and crowds out some investment.
Interaction Between Monetary & Fiscal Policy
In the model, M, G, and T are exogenous. In the real world, monetary policymakers may adjust M in response to changes in fiscal policy, or vice versa. Such interaction may alter the impact of the original policy change.
Central Bankβs Response to ΞG > 0
When the government increases G, there are three possible central bank responses with different outcomes:
Response 1: Hold M constant β IS shifts right, LM unchanged. Results: ΞY = Yβ - Yβ, Ξr = rβ - rβ (both positive).
Response 2: Hold r constant β IS shifts right, central bank increases M to shift LM right. Results: ΞY = Yβ - Yβ (larger than response 1), Ξr = 0.
Response 3: Hold Y constant β IS shifts right, central bank reduces M to shift LM left. Results: ΞY = 0, Ξr = rβ - rβ (largest increase in r).
π Definition β Crowding Out: The reduction in investment that occurs when increased government spending raises interest rates
π‘ Why this matters: The central bank's response determines whether fiscal expansion affects output, interest rates, or both. Holding r constant maximizes the output effect; holding Y constant eliminates it entirely.
Shocks in the IS-LM Model
IS shocks are exogenous changes in the demand for goods and services. Examples include stock market boom/crash changing households' wealth (affecting C), or changes in business/consumer confidence affecting I and/or C.
LM shocks are exogenous changes in the demand for money. Examples include a wave of credit card fraud increasing money demand, or more ATMs/the Internet reducing money demand.
π Example: A stock market boom makes consumers wealthier, increasing C, shifting IS right β higher Y and r. This raises C and lowers I (due to higher r), reducing unemployment.
π Example: After credit card fraud, consumers use more cash, increasing money demand, shifting LM left β higher r and lower Y. This lowers C and I (both fall with Y), increasing unemployment.
What is the Central Bankβs Policy Instrument?
The central bank targets the discount rate: it announces a target value and uses monetary policy to shift the LM curve as needed to attain its target rate. The central bank targets interest rates instead of the money supply for two reasons: (a) interest rates are easier to measure than the money supply, and (b) the central bank might believe that LM shocks are more prevalent than IS shocks. If so, targeting the interest rate stabilizes income better than targeting the money supply.
π Definition β Policy Instrument: The variable (typically the interest rate) that the central bank directly targets and adjusts to achieve its macroeconomic objectives
β Key Takeaways
The IS-LM model's intersection determines equilibrium output and interest rates where both goods and money markets clear. Fiscal policy shifts the IS curve, while monetary policy shifts the LM curve, but their effects are interdependent β expansionary fiscal policy raises interest rates and crowds out investment, reducing the multiplier effect. The central bank's response to fiscal policy dramatically changes outcomes: holding M constant allows partial crowding out, holding r constant maximizes output expansion, and holding Y constant neutralizes fiscal policy entirely. IS shocks come from changes in goods demand (wealth, confidence) while LM shocks come from money demand changes (financial technology, payment methods). Central banks target interest rates rather than money supply because rates are easier to measure and targeting rates better stabilizes income when LM shocks are prevalent.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What determines the unique combination of Y and r in the IS-LM model?
- Why is the final increase in Y smaller than 1/(1-MPC) Γ ΞG when government purchases increase?
- Compare the effects of a tax cut versus an equal increase in government spending on output and interest rates.
- What are the three possible central bank responses to an increase in government spending, and how do they affect the final change in output?
- Why does the central bank choose to target interest rates rather than the money supply?