π Lecture 10 β Evolution of Wireless Networks (Part III)
π Overview: This lecture examines the limitations of 3G networks and introduces the vision, objectives, and architecture of 4G wireless systems. It covers the critical issues of QoS, security, and multimedia service delivery in heterogeneous network environments, concluding with an overview of wireless local and personal area network technologies.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with a review of 2.5G and 3G standards and their specifications. It then details the limitations of 3G, introduces the concept of 4G and its design objectives, and explores the major issues facing 4G including heterogeneous networks, QoS, security, and multimedia services. The convergence of cellular networks with WLANs is discussed along with applications, billing challenges, and an overview of WLAN standards including IEEE 802.11 family, WiMAX, and wireless PAN technologies.
π Lecture Summary
Review of previous lecture
The previous lecture covered 2.5G technologies including HSCSD, GPRS, EDGE, and IS-95B. It also introduced 3G standards such as UMTS/W-CDMA and CDMA2000, along with their specifications.
Limitations of 3G
The lecture identifies several key limitations of 3G systems. There is a difficulty of CDMA to provide higher data rates, alongside the need for continuously increasing data rate and bandwidth to meet multimedia requirements. Spectrum limitations and allocation issues exist, as does an inability to roam between different services. The system needs to provide a seamless transport end-to-end mechanism and introduce a better system with reduced cost.
4G
4G is designed to provide a comprehensive IP solution where voice, data, and streamed multimedia can be given to users on an "Anytime, Anywhere" basis, at higher data rates than previous generations. While no formal definition exists, certain objectives guide its development: it must be a fully IP-based integrated system providing 100 Mbit/s and 1 Gbit/s speeds both indoors and outdoors, with premium quality and high security.
4G Objectives
The objectives of 4G include creating a spectrally efficient system (in bits/s/Hz and bit/s/Hz/site). It must offer a nominal data rate of 100 Mbit/s at higher relative speeds and 1 Gbit/s while client and station are in relatively fixed positions. The system requires high network capacity with more simultaneous users per cell, smooth handoff across heterogeneous networks, seamless connectivity and global roaming across multiple networks, high quality of service for next generation multimedia support (real time audio, high speed data, HDTV video content, mobile TV, etc), interoperability with existing wireless standards, and an all IP, packet switched network.
π Definition β Global information multimedia communication village: A concept representing the convergence of high speed internet and mobility, providing integrated multimedia communication worldwide.
Convergence of High Speed Internet & Mobility a Major Driver of Future Wireless
The wireless industry has grown enormously, with over 2.5 billion subscribers to cellular services enjoying connectivity while on the move. With the growth in Internet, a wide range of services are accessed through wired infrastructure. The introduction of mobile Internet brought about by the convergence of Mobile and Internet technologies is the future objective.
4G Concept
The 4G concept states: "The user has freedom and flexibility to select any desired service with reasonable QoS and affordable price, anytime, anywhere."
π‘ Why this matters: This user-centric vision shifts from technology-driven design to service-driven design, where the network adapts to user needs rather than users adapting to network limitations.
Design Objectives
The design objectives for 4G include supporting heterogeneous networks that can operate seamlessly together, providing consistent user experience across different access technologies.
Heterogeneous Networks
Next generation systems must resolve multiple issues specific to heterogeneous networks. These include access and handover issues, location coordination and resource coordination, adding new users, QoS, wireless security and authentication, network failure backup, and pricing and billing.
Quality of Service (QoS)
Traffic generated by different services will increase traffic loads and require different quality of service (QoS) requirements (e.g., cell loss rate, delay, and jitter) for different streams (e.g., video, voice, data). Providing QoS guarantees in 4G networks is a non-trivial issue where both QoS signalling across different networks and service differentiation between mobile flows must be addressed. One of the most difficult problems is ensuring constant QoS level during handover. Depending on whether the new access router is in the same or some other sub network, we recognize horizontal and vertical handover.
π Definition β Horizontal handover: Handover where the new access router is in the same sub network. π Definition β Vertical handover: Handover where the new access router is in a different sub network.
Quality of Service (continued)
The mobile terminal cannot receive IP packets while the handover process is finished. This time is called handover latency. Handover latency has a great influence on the flow of multimedia applications in real-time. Mobile IPv6 has been proposed to reduce the handover latency and the number of lost packets. The fields "Traffic Class" and "Flow Label" in the IPv6 header enable routers to secure special QoS for specific packet series with marked priority.
MULTIMEDIA β Video Services
4G wireless systems are expected to deliver efficient multimedia services at very high data rates. There are two types of video services: bursting and streaming video services.
π Definition β Streaming: A service performed when a user requires real-time video services, in which the server delivers data continuously at a playback rate. π Definition β Bursting: A service that is basically file downloading using a buffer and is done at the highest data rate taking advantage of the whole available bandwidth.
Security
Security in wireless networks mainly involves authentication, confidentiality, integrity, and authorization for the access of network connectivity and QoS resources for the mobile nodes flow. The heterogeneity of wireless networks complicates the security issue. Dynamic reconfigurable, adaptive, and lightweight security mechanisms should be developed. AAA (Authentication Authorization Auditing) protocols provide a framework for such issues, especially for control plane functions and installing security policies in the mobile node such as encryption, decryption and filtering.
Convergence of Cellular Mobile Networks and WLANs
The convergence of cellular and WLAN offers benefits for both operators and users. For operators, benefits include higher bandwidths, lower cost of networks and equipment, use of licence-exempt spectrum, higher capacity and QoS enhancement, and higher revenue. For users, benefits include access to broadband multimedia services with lower cost where mostly needed and inter-network roaming.
Applications
Key 4G applications include Virtual Presence, which provides user services at all times even if the user is off-site. Virtual navigation provides users with access to a database of streets and buildings. Tele-geoprocessing applications combine GIS (Geographical Information System) and GPS (Global Positioning System) so users can get location by querying. Tele-Medicine and Education will support remote health monitoring of patients and provide lifelong learning opportunities. Crisis management enables restoration of communication systems within hours after natural disasters, compared to days or weeks in current systems.
Multiple Operators and Billing System
In today's communication market, an operator usually charges customers with a simple billing and accounting scheme. A flat rate based on subscribed services, call durations, and transferred data volume is usually enough in many situations. With the increase of service varieties in 4G systems, more comprehensive billing and accounting systems are needed.
WLANs
WLANs use the unlicensed Industrial Scientific and Medical (ISM) band. The ISM bands in the US are 900 MHz (902-928 MHz), 2.4 GHz (2400-2483.5 MHz), and 5.7 GHz (5725-5850 MHz).
IEEE 802.11
IEEE 802.11 is a family of standards defining Physical (Phy) and MAC layers. The original IEEE 802.11 standard supports Infrared (IR) and 2.4 GHz ISM band with 1 or 2 Mbps. IEEE 802.11b provides 11 Mbps in 2.4 GHz. IEEE 802.11a provides 54 Mbps in 5.7 GHz. IEEE 802.11g provides 54 MHz in 2.4 GHz. Other standards include IEEE 802.11i for Security, IEEE 802.11e for QoS, and IEEE 802.11f for Inter-access point protocol.
Worldwide Interoperability for Microwave Access
WiMAX is aimed at providing wireless data over long distances in a variety of ways, from point-to-point links to full mobile cellular type access. It is based on IEEE 802.16, also called wireless MAN. It serves as last mile wireless broadband access as an alternative to cable and DSL.
Wireless PAN
IEEE 802.15 standards cover wireless personal area networks. IEEE 802.15.1 or Bluetooth offers moderate data range up to 720 kbps, operates in ISM band, with 10 m to 100 m range. IEEE 802.15.2 addresses co-existence issues of IEEE 802.11 and 802.15. IEEE 802.15.3 is high rate, low power with high data rate up to 20 Mbps, designed for multimedia applications over low power devices. IEEE 802.15.4 / ZigBee offers low power with range of 100m and low rate about 20 kbps.
Summary
The next lecture will cover fundamental principles of cellular networks.
β Key Takeaways
Students must remember that 4G represents a paradigm shift to an all-IP, packet-switched architecture designed to provide 100 Mbps to 1 Gbps data rates with seamless connectivity across heterogeneous networks. The critical challenges include maintaining QoS during handovers, where handover latency directly impacts real-time multimedia applications. Security in heterogeneous environments requires AAA protocols and lightweight, adaptive mechanisms. The convergence of cellular networks with WLANs and the variety of wireless standards (802.11, WiMAX, Bluetooth, ZigBee) highlight the importance of interoperability and seamless roaming. Finally, understanding the difference between streaming and bursting video services, and the ISM frequency bands used by WLANs, is essential for exam preparation.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five main limitations of 3G networks that drove the development of 4G?
- What are the nominal data rate requirements for 4G at high relative speeds and at fixed positions?
- What is the difference between horizontal and vertical handover in 4G heterogeneous networks?
- What is handover latency and how does Mobile IPv6 address this problem?
- What are the three ISM frequency bands used in the US for WLANs, and what data rates do IEEE 802.11b and IEEE 802.11a provide?
π Lecture 11 β Fundamentals of Cellular Networks (Part I)
π Overview: This lecture introduces the foundational concept of cellular networks, focusing on how the cellular concept solved the problem of spectrum congestion and user capacity. It explains frequency reuse, the geometry of cell shapes, and how to locate co-channel cells, culminating in a practical example calculating channel allocation for different cluster sizes.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with a review of 3G limitations, 4G objectives, and convergence of cellular and WLAN. It then introduces the cellular concept as a major breakthrough, explaining how replacing a single high-power transmitter with many low-power transmitters (small cells) increases capacity. The lecture covers frequency reuse, the hexagonal cell model, system capacity equations, cluster sizes, and the method for locating co-channel neighbors. A detailed numerical example demonstrates how to calculate channels per cell for four-cell, seven-cell, and twelve-cell reuse patterns, including control channel allocation.
π Lecture Summary
Review of last lecture
The previous lecture covered the limitations of 3G, the objectives and issues of 4G, QoS, the convergence of Cellular and WLAN, billing issues, and wireless network security, multimedia services, and applications.
Introduction
Early mobile systems aimed for large coverage using a single high-power antenna, making frequency reuse impossible in the same coverage area. For example, the Bell mobile system in 1970 could support a maximum of 12 simultaneous calls over a thousand square miles. Government regulators could not allocate spectrum proportionally to the increasing demand. This made it imperative to restructure the telephone system to achieve high capacity with limited radio spectrum.
Cellular Concept
The cellular concept was a major breakthrough in solving the problem of spectrum congestion and user capacity. It offers high capacity without major technological changes by replacing a high-power transmitter (large cell) with many low-power transmitters (small cells), each providing service to a small area. Each Base Station (BS) is allocated a portion of the channels, and nearby BSs are assigned different groups of channels so that all available channels are distributed among nearby BSs. Channels may be reused as many times as necessary as long as the BSs using the same channels are not overlapping. As demand for service increases, the number of BSs can be increased with reduced transmission power, providing additional capacity with no addition to spectrum. This is the foundation of all modern wireless communication systems.
π‘ Why this matters: The cellular concept is the core innovation that allows millions of users to share the limited radio spectrum.
Frequency Reuse
Frequency reuse relies on intelligent allocation and reuse of channels. A small geographical area with an allocation of a group of channels is called a cell. BS antennas are designed to achieve the desired coverage within a cell while avoiding co-channel interference. The design process of selecting and allocating channel groups for all the cellular BSs is called frequency reuse or frequency planning.
The hexagonal shape representing a cell is a conceptual and simplistic model of coverage. The actual radio coverage is known as the footprint and is determined from field measurements and propagation prediction models. However, a regular shape is needed for systematic system design and adaptation to future growth. While a circle might be natural to represent coverage, adjacent circles cannot be overlaid upon a map without leaving gaps or creating overlapping.
Three possible choices of shapes are square, equilateral triangle, and hexagon. For a given distance between the center of a polygon and its farthest perimeter points, the hexagon has the largest area of the three. Thus, by using hexagon geometry, the fewest number of cells can cover a geographic region, and it closely approximates a circle.
Capacity of System
When using hexagon to model coverage areas, there are two types of cells:
- Center-excited Cell: BS depicted as being in the center of the cell; an omni-directional antenna is used.
- Edge-excited Cell: BS depicted on three of the six cell vertices; a sectored directional antenna is used.
Consider a cellular system which has S duplex channels available for reuse. Each cell is allocated a group of k channels (k < S). If the S channels are divided among N cells (unique and disjoint), then: π Definition β Cluster: N cells which collectively use the complete set of available frequencies.
π Formula: S = k(N)
If a cluster is replicated M times in the system, the total number of duplex channels C as a measure of capacity is: π Formula: C = M(k)(N) = M(S)
So, capacity is directly proportional to the replication factor in a fixed area. Factor N is called cluster size and is typically equal to 4, 7, or 12. If cluster size N is reduced while cell size is kept constant, more clusters are required, and more capacity is achieved. A large cluster size indicates that co-channel cells are far from each other, while a small cluster size means co-channel cells are located much closer together. The value of N is a function of how much interference a mobile or BS can tolerate. Clusters are inversely proportional to N, and capacity is directly proportional to clusters. Thus, the frequency reuse factor is given by 1/N.
In the hexagonal layout, each hexagon has exactly six equidistant neighbors, and the lines joining the centers of any cell and its neighbors are separated by multiples of 60 degrees. Therefore, only certain cluster sizes and layouts are possible.
Locating co-channel neighbors
To connect hexagons without gaps, the geometry of the hexagon is such that the number of cells per cluster N can only have values where i and j are non-negative integers: π Formula: N = iΒ² + i(j) + jΒ²
To find the nearest co-channel neighbors of a particular cell, do the following:
- Move i cells along any chain of hexagons.
- Then turn 60 degrees counter-clockwise and move j cells.
π Example: The lecture provides a diagram showing how to locate co-channel cells using the i and j values for a cluster size of N=7 (i=2, j=1).
Example
A bandwidth of 33 MHz is allocated to a particular FDD cellular system, where two 25 KHz simplex channels provide full-duplex for voice/data.
Part I: Compute the number of channels per cell if the system uses four-cell, seven-cell, and twelve-cell reuse.
Solution Part I:
- Total BW = 33 MHz
- Channel BW = 25 KHz Γ 2 = 50 KHz/duplex channel
- S = 33,000 / 50 = 660 channels
- For N = 4: k = 660 / 4 β 165 channels
- For N = 7: k = 660 / 7 β 95 channels
- For N = 12: k = 660 / 12 β 55 channels
Part II: If 1 MHz is dedicated to control channels, determine the equitable distribution of control and voice channels per cell for the above three systems.
Solution Part II:
-
Control channels (Sc) = 1000 / 50 = 20 channels
-
Voice channels (Sv) = S β Sc = 660 β 20 = 640 channels
-
For N = 4: 5 control channels + 160 voice channels per cell.
-
For N = 7: In practice, 1 control channel per cell and 4 cells with 91 voice channels + 3 cells with 92 voice channels.
-
For N = 12: In practice, 1 control channel per cell and 8 cells with 53 voice channels + 4 cells with 54 voice channels.
β Key Takeaways
The cellular concept is the foundation of all modern wireless systems, replacing a single high-power transmitter with many low-power cells to increase capacity without adding spectrum. Frequency reuse, quantified by the reuse factor 1/N, is the key mechanism, where N is the cluster size (typically 4, 7, or 12) and must satisfy the formula N = iΒ² + ij + jΒ². The hexagonal cell model is used because it provides the largest coverage area without gaps. System capacity C = MkN = MS, meaning it is directly proportional to the number of cluster replications. The numerical example demonstrates that a smaller cluster size (N=4) provides more channels per cell (165) than a larger cluster size (N=12, 55 channels), but smaller clusters increase co-channel interference.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the fundamental idea behind the cellular concept that solved spectrum congestion?
- Why is a hexagon the preferred shape for cellular coverage modeling instead of a circle or square?
- Write the formula for the number of duplex channels in a system (C) and state what each variable represents.
- For a cluster size of N=7, what are the values of i and j, and how do you use them to locate a co-channel neighbor?
- For a 33 MHz system with 50 KHz duplex channels, if 1 MHz is reserved for control channels, how many voice channels are available per cell for a seven-cell reuse pattern (in practice)?
π Lecture 12 β Fundamentals of Cellular Networks (Part II)
π Overview: This lecture continues the exploration of cellular networks, focusing on how channels are assigned to cells and how calls are handed off as users move. It explains the critical mechanisms that ensure seamless connectivity, including channel assignment strategies, handoff triggers, and practical challenges like handoff prioritization and cell dragging, which are essential for understanding real-world cellular system performance.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers Channel Assignment Strategies, including fixed and dynamic allocation; Handoff Strategies, detailing when and how handoffs occur, the evolution from 1G base station-based to 2G mobile-assisted handoff; Prioritizing Handoffs through guard channels and queuing; and Practical Handoff Considerations, including umbrella cells, cell dragging, and differences in handoff timing across 1G, 2G, and CDMA (soft handoff) systems.
π Lecture Summary
Channel Assignment Strategies
For efficient spectrum utilization, a frequency reuse scheme must balance increasing system capacity and minimizing interference. Strategies are classified as Fixed and Dynamic. In Fixed Channel Assignment Strategy, each cell is allocated a predetermined set of voice channels. A call attempt can only be served if an unused channel in that particular cell is available. If all channels are occupied, the call is blocked. A variation is the borrowing strategy, where a cell is allowed to borrow a channel from a neighboring cell if all its channels are occupied. A mobile switching center (MSC) supervises such procedures and ensures the borrowing does not disrupt or interfere with any calls in progress in the donor cell.
In Dynamic Channel Assignment Strategy, voice channels are not permanently allocated to cells. On each call request, the BS requests a channel from the MSC. The MSC allocates a channel by taking into account the likelihood of future blocking within the cell and the frequency of use of the candidate channel (reuse distance). Hence, the MSC only allocates a channel if it is not presently in use in a cell within the minimum restricted distance of frequency reuse. This reduces the likelihood of call blocking, increasing the trunking capacity of the system. However, it requires the MSC to collect real-time data on channel occupancy, traffic distribution, and RSSI of all channels, which increases storage and computational load but provides increased channel utilization and decreased call blocking.
π Definition β Fixed Channel Assignment: Each cell is allocated a predetermined set of voice channels; a call is blocked if all channels in that cell are busy. π Definition β Dynamic Channel Assignment: Voice channels are not permanently allocated; the MSC assigns a channel dynamically based on real-time traffic and interference conditions.
Handoff Strategies
Handoff occurs when a mobile user moves to a different cell while a conversation is in progress, and the MSC transfers the call to a new BS. This involves identifying the new BS and allocating new voice and control channels. Handoffs must be performed successfully, infrequently, and imperceptibly to the user. To achieve this, the designer must specify the optimum signal level at which a handoff initiates. Once a signal level is specified as the minimum usable for acceptable voice quality, a slightly stronger signal level is used as the threshold, normally taken between -90 dBm and -100 dBm. This margin, β = Pr_handoff β Pr_min, cannot be too large or too small. If β is too large, unnecessary handoffs burden the MSC. If β is too small, there is insufficient time to complete a handoff before a call is lost due to a weak signal. β must be chosen carefully to meet these conflicting requirements.
Call drops can occur due to excessive delay by the MSC from high traffic load, β being set too small for handoff time, or no channels being available on any nearby BS. A handoff decision is made when the drop in signal level is not due to momentary fading and the mobile is actually moving away from the serving BS. To ensure this, the BS monitors the signal level for a certain period of time, which depends on the vehicle speed. If the slope of the average received signal level is steep, the handoff is made quickly. In 1G, the signal level was measured by the BS and supervised by the MSC. Each BS constantly monitors the signal strength of all its reverse channels to determine the relative location of each mobile user. Additionally, a locator receiver (a spare receiver) scans and measures RSSI of mobile users in neighboring cells and reports to the MSC, which then decides if a handoff is necessary.
π Definition β Handoff: The process of transferring an ongoing call from one base station to another as a user moves between cells. π Formula: β = Pr_handoff β Pr_min β The margin between the handoff threshold signal level and the minimum acceptable signal level for voice quality.
Mobile Assisted Handoff (MAHO)
In 2G, handoff decisions are mobile-assisted. Each mobile measures the RSSI of all surrounding BSs, reports to the serving BS, and a handoff is initiated if the power of the serving BS is lesser than a nearby BS by a certain level or for a certain period of time. MAHO enables calls to be handed over between base stations at a much faster rate than in 1G. The MSC no longer constantly monitors RSSI, making this approach more suitable for microcellular environments where handoffs are frequent. An intersystem handoff occurs if a mobile moves from one cellular system to a different system controlled by a different MSC. Issues to be addressed include a local call becoming a long-distance call (roaming), determining compatibility between the two MSCs, and differing policies for managing handoff requests. Handoff is prioritized because call termination in the middle of a conversation is more annoying than being blocked on a new call attempt.
π Definition β Mobile Assisted Handoff (MAHO): A handoff strategy where the mobile station measures the signal strength of surrounding base stations and reports to the serving BS, which then decides on handoff initiation.
Prioritizing Handoffs
Two methods of handoff prioritizing are used. The guard channel concept reserves a fraction of available channels exclusively for handoff requests. This has the disadvantage of reducing total carried traffic but offers efficient spectrum utilization when dynamic channel assignment strategies minimize the number of required guard channels. The second method is queuing of handoff requests. This is possible due to the time interval that elapses when the signal level drops below the threshold until it reaches the minimum signal level. Queuing decreases the probability of forced termination due to a lack of available channels, creating a tradeoff between this decrease and total traffic. The delay time and queue size are determined from the traffic pattern. Queuing does not guarantee zero probability of call termination, as large delays will cause the signal level to drop to the minimum.
π Definition β Guard Channel Concept: Reserving a set of channels exclusively for handoff requests to reduce the probability of call termination. π Definition β Queuing of Handoff Requests: A method that stores handoff requests in a queue, taking advantage of the time between the threshold and minimum signal levels to find a free channel.
Practical Handoff Considerations
Several problems arise when designing a system for a wide range of mobile velocities. High-speed vehicles pass through a cell in a matter of seconds, and with the addition of microcells, the MSC can quickly become burdened. Pedestrian users may never need a handoff during a call. Issues include schemes to handle high-speed and low-speed users simultaneously and the ability to obtain new cell sites. Additional capacity is often provided through new cell sites, but these are difficult to obtain. An alternative is to install additional channels and base stations at the same location as an existing cell, using different antenna heights and power levels to provide large and small cells co-located at a single location, called an umbrella cell. This provides large coverage area to high-speed users (minimizing handoffs) and small coverage to slow-speed users. Speed can be estimated by the BS or MSC from RSSI.
Cell dragging is a problem in microcells due to the high signal strength of pedestrian users. It occurs in urban areas when there is a line-of-sight (LOS) path. The average signal strength does not decay rapidly even if a user travels well beyond the range of the cell. The RSSI may remain above the handoff threshold, and thus a handoff is not made. This creates potential interference since the user has traveled deep within a neighboring cell. Handoff parameters, particularly the threshold, must be adjusted carefully to avoid this. In 1G, the time to make a handoff when the signal drops below the threshold is 10 seconds, requiring β to be on the order of 6 dB to 12 dB. In 2G (e.g., GSM), MAHO determines the best handoff candidates and requires only 1 or 2 seconds, so β is usually between 0 dB and 6 dB. This provides the MSC substantial time to rescue a call in need of handoff. The IS-95 (CDMA) system provides a unique handoff capability called soft handoff. Unlike channelized (hard handoff), spread spectrum (SS) mobiles share the same channel in every cell. Thus, handoff does not assign a new channel; a different BS handles the communication task. By simultaneously evaluating the RSSI from a single user, the MSC decides which version of the signal is best. This ability to select between instantaneous received signals from a variety of BSs is called soft handoff.
π Definition β Umbrella Cell: A large cell co-located with smaller cells, designed to handle high-speed users with fewer handoffs. π Definition β Cell Dragging: A problem in microcells where a user's high signal strength prevents a timely handoff, causing potential interference as the user moves deep into a neighboring cell. π Definition β Soft Handoff: A CDMA handoff technique where the mobile communicates with multiple base stations simultaneously, and the best signal is selected, avoiding a hard channel switch.
β Key Takeaways
This lecture is critical for understanding how cellular networks manage resources and maintain calls. You must understand the core difference between fixed and dynamic channel assignment, including their trade-offs in complexity and capacity. For handoffs, the key is knowing the handoff margin (β) and its trade-off, the evolution from 1G (BS-measured) to 2G (MAHO), and the distinction between guard channels and queuing as prioritization methods. Practical issues like umbrella cells (for mixed-speed users) and cell dragging (signal propagation problem) are essential real-world challenges. Finally, the concept of soft handoff in CDMA is a fundamental difference from hard handoffs in FDMA/TDMA systems.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the primary difference between fixed and dynamic channel assignment strategies in terms of channel allocation?
- Explain the purpose of the handoff margin (β) and the consequence of setting it too large or too small.
- How does Mobile Assisted Handoff (MAHO) in 2G differ from the handoff method used in 1G systems?
- Describe the two main methods for prioritizing handoffs: guard channels and queuing. What is the primary trade-off for each?
- What are the causes and consequences of "cell dragging" in a microcellular environment?
π Lecture 13 β Fundamentals of Cellular Networks (Part III)
π Overview: This lecture covers interference and system capacity in cellular networks, focusing on co-channel and adjacent channel interference. It explains how system capacity is limited by interference and describes channel planning strategies for wireless systems, including trade-offs between capacity and transmission quality.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with a review of previous topics including channel assignment strategies, handoff strategies, and practical handoff considerations. It then covers interference and system capacity in detail, with major sections on co-channel interference and system capacity, adjacent channel interference and capacity, and channel planning for wireless systems including CDMA considerations and breathing cell phenomena.
π Lecture Summary
Last lecture review
The lecture reviews channel assignment strategies, handoff strategies including when to handoff, 1G BS-based handoff, and 2G Mobile-Assisted Handoff. Prioritizing handoff using guard channels and queuing handoff requests is reviewed. Practical handoff considerations include umbrella cell and cell dragging concepts.
Interference and system capacity
Interference sources include another mobile in the same cell, a call in progress in a neighboring cell, other BS operating in the same frequency, and another non-cellular system leaking energy into the cellular frequency band. Interference on voice channels causes cross-talk, while on control channels it leads to missed and blocked calls. Interference is a major bottleneck in increasing capacity. Two major types are co-channel and adjacent channel interference.
Co-channel interference and system capacity
Co-channel cells are cells that use the same set of frequencies, and their interference is called co-channel interference. Unlike noise, co-channel interference cannot be combated by increasing SNR. To reduce it, co-channel cells must be separated by a minimum distance. When cell size is approximately the same and BS transmit at the same power, the co-channel interference ratio is independent of transmission power and is a function of radius of cell (R) and distance between centers of nearest co-channel cell (D).
By increasing the ratio of D/R, separation between co-channel cells relative to coverage distance is increased, thus interference is reduced. The parameter Q (co-channel reuse ratio) is related to cluster size. For hexagonal geometry: Q = D/R = β(3N), where N is cluster size. A small value of Q provides larger capacity since N is smaller, while a large value of Q improves transmission quality due to smaller co-channel interference. A trade-off must be made between these two objectives.
Let iβ be the number of co-channel interfering cells. The signal-to-interference ratio (SIR) for a mobile receiver monitoring a forward channel is: S/I = S / βα΅’βββ±β° Iα΅’, where S is the desired signal power and Iα΅’ is the interference power from the i-th interfering co-channel cell.
Average received signal strength at any point decays as a power law of distance. Average received power Pα΅£ at distance d is: Pα΅£ = Pβ(d/dβ)β»βΏ where Pβ is power received at close-in reference point dβ, and n is the path loss exponent (2 to 4).
For co-channel cell interference, if Dα΅’ is the distance of the i-th interferer from the mobile, received power is proportional to (Dα΅’)β»βΏ. When transmit power of each BS is equal and path loss exponent is the same throughout coverage: S/I β (D/R)βΏ / iβ = (β(3N))βΏ / iβ
Considering only the first layer of interfering cells, which are equidistant D from the desired BS: S/I = (β(3N))βΏ / iβ This relates S/I to cluster size N, which determines overall system capacity.
For the US AMPS system, tests indicate S/I β₯ 18 dB for sufficient voice quality. Using the formula with n=4, N must be at least 6.49, so a minimum cluster size of 7 is required.
For a 7-cell cluster with hexagonal geometry, the mobile is at the boundary of the cell. The worst case S/I ratio can be approximated. In terms of co-channel reuse ratio Q: S/I = (Q - 1)β»βΏ + (Q + 0.7)β»βΏ For N=7, Q=4.6, and worst case S/I β 49.56 (17 dB), while the exact solution is 17.8 dB.
π Definition β Co-channel cells: Cells that use the same set of frequencies, causing co-channel interference. π Definition β Co-channel reuse ratio (Q): Q = D/R, where D is distance between centers of nearest co-channel cells and R is cell radius. Q = β(3N). π Formula: S/I = (β(3N))βΏ / iβ β The signal-to-interference ratio depends on cluster size N raised to the power n/2, divided by the number of interfering cells. π Example: If S/I is required 15 dB, n=4: For 7-cell reuse, Q=4.583, S/I = 1/6 Γ (4.583)β΄ = 75.3 = 18.66 dB. Since this exceeds minimum, N=7 can be used. For n=3: 7-cell reuse gives S/I = 12.05 dB (too low). Next N=12 with Q=6.0 gives S/I = 15.56 dB (acceptable). So N=12 is used.
Channel Planning for Wireless Systems
Generally, available spectrum is divided into control channels (5% of total for initiating, requesting, or paging calls) and voice channels (95% for revenue-generating traffic). Control channels are not allowed to be used as voice channels or vice versa. Control channels use more conservative frequency reuse (21-cell reuse), while voice channels use 7-cell reuse.
A key feature of CDMA systems is that cluster size N=1, so frequency reuse planning is simpler than for TDMA or 1G systems. However, most practical CDMA systems use some limited frequency reuse due to ill-behaved propagation conditions. Interfering channels on the same channel can create interference overload exceeding the dynamic range of CDMA power control, leading to dropped calls.
The most popular approach is f1/f2 cell planning, where nearest neighbor cells use different channels. This requires mobiles to make hard handoff. In CDMA, a single 1.25 MHz channel carries 64 simultaneous voice channels. CDMA has dynamic time-varying coverage depending on instantaneous number of users, known as breathing cell. The wireless engineer must carefully plan coverage and signal levels for best and worst cases. Breathing cell can lead to abrupt dropped calls.
π Definition β Breathing cell: A phenomenon in CDMA where coverage region dynamically changes depending on instantaneous number of users.
Adjacent channel interference
Adjacent channel interference results from signals adjacent in frequency, caused by imperfect receiver filters allowing nearby frequencies to leak into the passband. It is more serious if the transmitter is close to the user's receiver listening to the desired channel, called the near-far effect.
The near-far effect occurs when a nearby transmitter captures the receiver of a subscriber, or when a mobile close to the BS transmits on an adjacent channel to one being used by a weak mobile. This interference can be minimized by careful filtering and channel assignment. A cell need not be assigned channels adjacent in frequency. By keeping frequency separation large in a given cell, interference is minimized.
Channel allocation schemes sequentially assign successive channels to different cells, separating channels by as many as N. Some strategies avoid adjacent channels in neighboring cells. If reuse factor (1/N) is large (N is small), separation may not keep interference within tolerable limits.
For example, if a close-in mobile is 20 times closer to BS than another mobile and energy has leaked to the passband, S/I at BS for the weak mobile is approximately S/I = (20)β»βΏ. For n=4, this is -52 dB. If the filter has a slope of 20 dB/octave, interference must be displaced 6 times the passband bandwidth from the center to achieve 52 dB attenuation, meaning more than 6 channels separation are needed for acceptable S/I.
π Definition β Near-far effect: A condition where a nearby transmitter captures the receiver of a subscriber, or a mobile close to the BS transmits on an adjacent channel to one used by a weak mobile, causing adjacent channel interference.
β Key Takeaways
The critical relationship between co-channel reuse ratio Q = β(3N) and cluster size N determines both system capacity and signal quality, requiring careful trade-offs. The signal-to-interference ratio formula S/I = (β(3N))βΏ/iβ is essential for calculating minimum cluster sizes to meet quality requirements, with the US AMPS example showing N=7 is needed for 18 dB S/I with n=4. Adjacent channel interference from the near-far effect can cause severe degradation, requiring proper filtering and channel separation strategies. Channel planning must differentiate between control channels (conservative 21-cell reuse) and voice channels (7-cell reuse), while CDMA systems face unique challenges from breathing cell phenomena and dynamic coverage regions. The trade-off between capacity (small N) and quality (large N) is fundamental to cellular system design.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the formula relating co-channel reuse ratio Q to cluster size N in hexagonal cellular systems?
- Why can co-channel interference not be combated by increasing SNR, and how is it reduced?
- What is the minimum cluster size required for the US AMPS system to achieve 18 dB S/I with path loss exponent n=4?
- What is the near-far effect and how does it cause adjacent channel interference?
- What is the breathing cell phenomenon in CDMA systems and why does it cause abrupt dropped calls?
π Lecture 14 β Fundamentals of Cellular Networks (Part IV)
π Overview: This lecture explores trunking theory and grade of service (GOS) β the mathematical foundation for determining how many channels are needed to serve a given number of users without excessive blocking. It then covers three key techniques for improving cellular network coverage and capacity: cell splitting, sectoring, and the microcell zone concept.
ποΈ Topics Covered
Trunking and Grade of Service: measuring traffic intensity (Erlangs), types of trunked systems (blocked calls cleared vs. blocked calls delayed), and Erlang B/C formulas. Improving Coverage and Capacity: cell splitting (reducing cell radius), sectoring (using directional antennas to improve S/I and reduce cluster size), repeaters for range extension, and the microcell zone concept (distributed antennas sharing a single BS).
π Lecture Summary
Trunking and Grade of Service
Trunking allows a large user community to share a small number of channels on a per-call basis, relying on statistical behavior. Trunking theory, developed by Erlang, determines how many channels are needed for a given area and user load. There is a tradeoff between the number of available channels and the likelihood of call blocking during peak hours.
π Definition β 1 Erlang: the amount of traffic intensity carried by a completely occupied channel (e.g., one call-hour per hour, or 0.5 Erlang if occupied 30 minutes in an hour).
π Definition β Grade of Service (GOS): a benchmark measuring the ability of a user to access a trunked system during the busiest hour (typically 4-6 PM rush hours), usually given as the probability of call blocking or delay exceeding a certain queue time.
Measuring Traffic Intensity
Traffic intensity is calculated as the call request rate multiplied by the call holding time. π Formula: User traffic intensity (A_u = \lambda H) (where (\lambda) = average call request rate, (H) = average call duration or holding time). π Formula: Total offered traffic intensity for (U) users: (A = U A_u). π Formula: Traffic per channel in a C-channel system: (A_c = UA_u / C). π‘ Why this matters: Offered traffic is not necessarily carried traffic β if offered load exceeds system capacity, the carried traffic becomes limited. The maximum possible carried traffic (in Erlangs) equals the number of channels (C). AMPS is designed for a GOS of 2% blocking (2 out of 100 calls blocked).
Trunked Systems: Blocked Calls Cleared
In this system, if no channel is available, the requesting user is immediately blocked and must try later. The Erlang B formula determines the probability of call blocking (GOS) assuming Poisson-distributed call arrivals and no queuing. π Formula: Erlang B Trunking GOS β (P[blocking] = \frac{A^C / C!}{\sum_{k=0}^{C} A^k / k!}) (where (A) = total offered traffic in Erlangs, (C) = number of channels). This formula is widely provided in tabular form (Erlang B tables).
Trunked Systems: Blocked Calls Delayed
Here, a queue holds blocked calls until a channel becomes available. GOS is defined as the probability that a call is delayed longer than a specific time (t). The Erlang C formula gives the probability that a call is not immediately served. π Formula: Erlang C β (P[delay > 0] = \frac{A^C}{A^C + C! (1 - A/C) \sum_{k=0}^{C-1} A^k/k!}). π Formula: Probability of delay > t seconds: (P[delay > t] = P[delay > 0] \cdot e^{-(C - A)t / H}) (where (H) = average call holding time). π Formula: Average delay D for all calls in a queued system: (D = P[delay > 0] \cdot \frac{H}{C - A}). The average delay for a queued (delayed) call is (H / (C - A)).
Trunking Efficiency
Trunking efficiency measures how many users can be served at a given GOS with a given channel configuration. Grouping channels differently alters capacity. For example: at GOS = 0.01, 10 trunked channels can support 4.46 Erlangs, while two separate groups of 5 channels can only support 2 Γ 1.36 = 2.72 Erlangs β about 60% less traffic.
Improving Coverage and Capacity: Cell Splitting
Cell splitting increases capacity by decreasing the cell radius (R) while keeping the cell reuse ratio D/R unchanged. Congested cells are divided into smaller micro cells. Halving the radius requires approximately 4 smaller cells to replace one larger cell, increasing the number of clusters and thus capacity. π Example: To maintain equal received power at the new cell boundary, transmit power must be reduced. If path loss exponent (n = 4), the new transmitter power (P_{t2} = P_{t1}/16) (since (P_{t2}/P_{t1} = (R_2/R_1)^n = (1/2)^4)). This corresponds to a 12 dB reduction to maintain S/I requirements. Initially, fewer channels are assigned to the smaller power groups; as demand grows, more micro cells replace the old cells entirely.
Improving Coverage and Capacity: Sectoring
Sectoring keeps the cell radius unchanged but decreases the D/R ratio by using directional antennas to improve S/I, allowing a smaller cluster size (N) and thus higher capacity. π Definition β Sectoring: partitioning a cell into 3 sectors of 120Β° or 6 sectors of 60Β°, using directional antennas. Instead of interference from 6 co-channel cells (omnidirectional), only 2 sectors cause interference. π Example: With 120Β° sectoring, the worst-case S/I improves from about 17 dB to 24.2 dB. This improvement allows designers to reduce cluster size (N), thereby increasing capacity. β οΈ Drawback: Increased number of handoffs as mobiles move between sectors.
Improving Coverage and Capacity: Microcell Zone Concept
In the microcell zone concept, a single base station (BS) divides its cell into several zones, each with its own antenna (placed at the cell edges). Zones are connected to the BS via coaxial cable, fiber optics, or microwave links. The BS can assign any channel to any zone. π Key advantage: As a mobile travels from one zone to another, it retains the same channel β the BS simply switches the channel to the new zone. This eliminates the need for a new handoff. π‘ Why this matters: Co-channel interference is minimized because the large BS transmitter is replaced by several low-power zone transmitters, significantly improving S/I without increasing the number of handoffs.
β Key Takeaways
Traffic intensity is measured in Erlangs, with 1 Erlang representing a fully occupied channel. GOS for a trunked system is determined using either the Erlang B formula (for blocked calls cleared β no queue) or the Erlang C formula (for blocked calls delayed β queue provided). Grouping more channels together improves trunking efficiency. To expand system capacity, cell splitting reduces cell radius and transmitter power; sectoring uses directional antennas to improve S/I and allows a smaller cluster; and the microcell zone concept uses distributed low-power antennas to reduce interference while eliminating intra-cell handoffs. Always remember the tradeoff: sectoring increases handoffs, while microcell zones avoid them.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Define 1 Erlang and explain how it is related to channel occupancy.
- What is the fundamental difference between a "Blocked Calls Cleared" system and a "Blocked Calls Delayed" system?
- In cell splitting, if the cell radius is halved and the path loss exponent n = 4, by how many dB must the transmitter power be reduced to maintain the same received power at the new cell boundary?
- Explain the key advantage of the microcell zone concept over sectoring in terms of handoffs and co-channel interference.
- If two separate groups of 5 channels can support 2.72 Erlangs at GOS = 0.01, why can a single group of 10 channels support 4.46 Erlangs at the same GOS?