π Lecture 12 β GENDER AND FAMILY RELATIONS
π Overview: This lecture examines how gender shapes family relations, focusing on the transition to parenthood and the deeply gendered experiences of motherhood and fatherhood. It explores the impact of dual-earner families on children, analyzes family structures across diverse cultural groups in the United States, and concludes with the gendered dimensions of divorce and single-parent households. Understanding these dynamics is crucial for recognizing how taken-for-granted family practices produce and reinforce gender inequalities.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers gender and family relations beginning with the parenthood transition, examining motherhood through functionalist, conflict, and feminist theoretical lenses. It then analyzes fatherhood, including the good-provider and involved-father models. The topic of parents as dual earners is explored, addressing concerns about employed mothers and child care outcomes. The lecture provides a comprehensive multicultural perspective on families, profiling African American, Latino (Puerto Rican, Mexican American, Cuban American), Asian American, and Native American families. Finally, it addresses divorce and single-parent families, focusing on gender differences in adjustment and the feminization of poverty.
π Lecture Summary
Topic 42: Gender and family relations
Womenβs destiny is received through messages about love, marriage and motherhood. As Simone de Beauvoir declared in The Second Sex (1953), this destiny is difficult "to reconcile with the will to succeed." Most people eventually become parents and are propelled into parenthood by the gendered processes of love, cohabitation, and marriage. Parenthood is structured by gender beliefs and produces powerful gender outcomes. These beliefs are so embedded in family practices that the differences and inequalities they produce are largely taken for granted. Challenges to taken-for-granted definitions about the family provoke contentious debates with profound consequences for public policy on divorce, child custody, benefits for single parents, cohabitating couples, and gay and lesbian families. Political rhetoric often highlights beliefs that changing the traditional family structure leads to disastrous social consequences, while other views celebrate family diversity and the creation of new roles.
π‘ Why this matters: The lecture establishes that narrow views of gender severely restrict opportunities for exploration and growth for both children and their parents.
Topic 43: The Parenthood Transition; Motherhood
The transition from couple dyad to family triad is momentous. The first child brings numerous changes that affect the marriage and alter the couple's lifestyle. New parents report enormous joy tempered with increased marital tension. Socialization for parenthood is based on one's own family experiences, involvement with others' children, formal classes, folklore, and parenting manuals. Gender is a key factor in accounting for the anticipation gap between expectation and reality.
Early sociological work focused on parenthood as crisis, where first-time parents encounter anxiety, uncertainty, loss of confidenceβeven shock. Traditional gender roles can drive a wedge between new parents; when women do virtually all infant care and added housework, men tend to maintain prefatherhood roles, often retreating to workplace roles and becoming emotionally distanced. The crisis of parenthood is eased when gender roles are more flexible. This view has been largely replaced with the perspective that parenthood is a normal developmental stage, where disorganization gradually gives way to new routines, joy, and gratification.
Motherhood
The belief that a woman's ultimate fulfillment is as a mother is a powerful socialization message. The motherhood mandate issues a command to females of all ages, instructing them that motherhood demands selfless devotion to children and subordination of one's own life to their needs. This mandate instills guilt in women who have small children and work outside the home, regardless of whether employment is personally rewarding or financially necessary.
The notion of a maternal instinct is not empirically supported, but the view that all females want to become mothers and that the mother's role "comes naturally" stubbornly persists. Ideal mothers are expected to enjoy the work of mothering regardless of how demanding it is. Exclusive devotion to mothering is believed to be good for children and promotes a husband's happiness.
π Definition β Motherhood Mandate: The cultural command that women should devote themselves selflessly to child-rearing and subordinate their own lives to the needs of children and family. π Definition β Motherhood Mystique: The glorification of the mothering role, where mothers take credit for children's accomplishments but are also more likely to assume the burden of blame for what goes wrong.
Functionalism offers support for the motherhood mandate, arguing it is essential for social equilibrium. Mothers are both biological reproducers and social reproducersβas a child's primary socializer, a mother provides the necessary ingredients for maintaining society. Functionalism assumes the traditional division of labor with nonoverlapping gender roles within a patriarchal family is the most efficient and least contentious arrangement.
Conflict Theory focuses on the motherhood mandate as contributing to the social powerlessness experienced by women. Because a woman's earnings alter power relations within the family, men evoke the motherhood mandate to ensure women concentrate energies on domestic roles. Careers and personal growth are impeded when family responsibilities intrude in the workplace. From this perspective, not until as many men as women truly want to stay home with children can women achieve real economic parity.
Feminism affects notions about motherhood. Women who hold traditional gender role orientations desire larger families compared to less traditional women. College women who identify with feminism are less interested in motherhood or intend to delay it until established in careers. However, feminism and motherhood are not incompatible. Feminist mothers are realistic about gendered pitfalls but believe motherhood offers opportunities for assertiveness, learning new skills, and ensuring feminist principles are passed to the next generation.
Topic 44: The Parenthood Transition; Fatherhood
American fathers are cast into primary breadwinning roles and viewed as more peripheral in nurturing and child care compared to mothers. This is different from colonial fathers, who were expected to provide for economic needs as well as moral and spiritual developmentβthey were nurturers as much as mothers. Public policy and legislation reinforce the emphasis on the father's role as the economic provider. Increases in divorce and cohabitation have undermined father-child relationships, and nonresident fathers are increasingly absent.
π Definition β Good-Provider Model: A model of fatherhood that encourages men to work more hours to financially support their families. π Definition β Involved-Father Model: A model of fatherhood that encourages men to work fewer hours to spend more time actively parenting their children.
Contemporary dads exhibit both models. The "forces pulling women out of the home are stronger than the forces pulling men into it" (Gerson, 2009:327). As first-time parents, men adapt more easily to fatherhood than women do to motherhood. Husbands' personal goals do not change substantially, and they are less ambivalent about parenting responsibilities. However, fathers see themselves as less competent than mothers in daily child care and largely surrender actual responsibility to their wives. A father's time is spent more on recreational activities than on children's ongoing physical upkeep. The existing gender gap in housework is associated with traditional gender ideology and increases with the birth of the first child.
Regarding children's development, the father's effect is often unheeded compared to the mother's. Fathers send highly important early messages, especially regarding gender roles. These messages are powerful because fathers have less contact and quality of interaction with their children. Fathers are more likely than mothers to take gender into account when delegating chores, showing affection, and disciplining. They are likely to use harsher discipline on sons, believing it enhances masculinity.
A fatherhood mandate has not been adopted by young men to allow them to move toward androgynous, flexible gender roles. Functionalists would support a fatherhood mandate that moves beyond the provider role. The involved-father model appears to be gaining prominence and may signal a crack in a masculine ethic that deters men from more meaningful parent-child relationships.
Topic 45: Parents as Dual Earners
The entry of women into paid employment significantly altered family structure and function. Paid employment benefits women socially and psychologically, especially when work is challenging and meaningful. Dual-earning couples are more likely to have egalitarian marriages than those with a full-time homemaker wife. However, the cost for women involves maintaining responsibilities at home when husbands do not share household and child care chores equally. Mothers, but not fathers, adjust their time use at work and in the home to accommodate these demands.
The dual-earner family is now the normative family. There are more dual-earning nuclear families with children than one-earner nuclear families. Because women are traditionally responsible for child care, all eyes turn to them when questions arise about how children are affected when both parents work outside the home. It is wives, not husbands, who reap society's disapproval if children suffer.
Children of Employed Women
Some writers assert that a positive, sustained relationship with a caregiver is essential to healthy emotional development, and a mother must be that caregiver. They argue that "paid strangers" (day care workers) will teach babies "values, fears, beliefs and behaviors." These messages ignore damages to children of parents who do not have the option of working for pay and tell fathers they cannot love their children as much as mothers.
The Child Care Issue: There is near consensus by developmental psychologists that surrogate child care is not the major risk factor for children of dual-earner couples. The key problem is poor quality care. An enriched group child care experience can stimulate moral development and prosocial behavior of infants and preschoolers. Poor children or children from troubled families may have resources in child care centers that are absent in their homes.
Children's Time with Parents: There are no significant differences in the home environment or development of children in two-parent households with employed mothers versus non-employed mothers. Working mothers with a college education spend significantly more time with their children than women who do not work outside the home. Employed mothers also spend more time with children than employed fathers. Consistent with conflict theory, fathers take on more responsibility for their children when their wives spend more time at work. The ratio of "father care" to "mother care" rises when wives contribute a greater share to household income.
Adolescents: Research does not warrant the conclusion that maternal employment adversely affects adolescents. While adolescents express desire for mothers to be home more, children's appreciation for their employed mothers' talents and accomplishments grows over time. Daughters especially want to follow in the professional footsteps of their mothers. Children of dual earners have less traditional gender role attitudes than children from single-earner homes.
Topic 46: Families in multicultural perspective
The multicultural heritage of the United States is reflected in its families. To account for gender patterns in minority families, the multiple risks and experiences from their unique cultural histories must be considered.
African American Families
Contrary to stereotypes, two parents are present in over half of African American families, and over half of fathers work full-time. The other half are female-headed households (90% single-parent women). Key factors in these patterns are the legacy of slavery and economic oppression rooted in discrimination. African American females have a longer legacy of paid employment essential to family stability.
African American families demonstrate flexibility in defining family boundaries, creating networks of fictive kinβwhere friends "become" family. Women-centered networks of "bloodmothers" and "other-mothers" share mothering responsibilities, bringing support that benefits all household members. This offers children a diversity of parenting models with more multifaceted nurturing. Working-class and middle-class married couples tend to be more egalitarian than white couples, and African American husbands appear more willing than white husbands to take responsibility for child rearing.
Latino Families
Latinos share a heritage of Spanish colonialism and connection to the Catholic Church. Key values related to gender and family include:
- Family relations characterized by respect and honor
- Familism: A strong cultural value emphasizing the family and its collective needs over personal and individual needs
- Familism is strongly gendered
π Definition β Machismo: Derived from the Spanish word "macho" (male), it includes virility, sexual prowess, and the physical and ideological control of women. π Definition β Marianismo: From the Virgin Mary's name Maria, it includes beliefs in women's spiritual and moral superiority, glorification of motherhood, and acceptance of a difficult marriage.
Puerto Rican Families have the lowest income of any Latino group. Women head half of all Puerto Rican households. About half of all heterosexual couples form consensual unions, different from cohabitation, which are recognized as informal marriage. From a social constructionism view, this definition of family is normative and accepted.
Mexican American Families confront gender roles tied to marianismo-machismo and familism. Recent research challenges the model of the all-dominant male; families are not as patriarchal as assumed, and there is a trend toward gender equity. Joint decision making is more apparent, especially when women are employed outside the home.
Cuban American Families enjoy the highest standard of living of all Latino groups. Cuban American families are demographically more similar to European Americans, with fewer children, stronger economic standing, and more likely to be headed by a married couple.
Asian American Families
This is the fastest growing racial minority. Key patterns include collectivistic kinship traditions where personal needs are sacrificed for family needs. Extended families are normative, and children are socialized to be obedient, with conformity expected much more for girls than for boys. Marriages are commonly orchestrated by kin. These traditions emphasize female subordination to all males and older females in a patriarchal family structure. Education is the key for Asian American women to challenge such subordination.
Native American Families
About one-third of Native American households are female-headed, most in poverty. Colonialism accompanied by Christianity altered ancient tribal patterns, particularly gender roles. Many tribal units were matrilineal (family name traced through mother's line) and matrilocal (couple moving into bride's home at marriage). Complementarity, balance, and gynocratic (female-centered) egalitarianism existed. With European contact, women were stripped of these roles. The U.S. government pursued a policy of "cultural genocide." However, ancient customs were not eradicated. Women retain spiritual, economic, and leadership roles. Unlike other groups, a return to cultural traditions among Native Americans may signal more, rather than less, egalitarianism.
Topic 47: Divorce- Single parent families
An enduring marriage is not necessarily a successful one. The two intersecting factors that most consistently predict divorce are age and social class. Teenage marriages and cohabitants of lower SES are most likely to dissolve. The divorce rate steadily increased through the last century, peaking in the 1980s, then decreasing modestly since.
Gender and Adjustment in Divorce
Divorce is strongly gendered in its differential impact.
Gender Role Beliefs and Emotional Well-Being: Women tend to adjust better to divorce than men. However, both men and women who are nontraditional in gender role orientation adjust better than those who are traditional. Women with higher self-esteem and independence opt out of unsatisfactory marriages faster. The powerful emotional toll of motherhood ideology works against a woman's well-being. Men who adjust better are likely to be connected to a new partner and quickly reestablish their preferred gender role pattern.
Age: Younger people rebuild their lives better after divorce. The spouse who first sought the divorce adjusts more readily. Women are more likely to initiate divorce than men.
Employment: Most women are employed and may have financial latitude to end an unhappy marriage. For dual-earner couples, housework, rather than income, fuels marital problems. The most dissatisfied couples are those where wives want joint decision making and household task sharing, but husbands prefer a traditional patriarchal style.
Single-Parent Families
In 2012, 64% of children lived with two parents. Poverty risk in single-parent homes increases dramatically in female householder families that are African American or Latino. Single-parent mothers outnumber single-parent fathers four to one. The poverty is triple for African American children compared to white children.
Mothers and the Single-Parent Household: Economic vulnerability is a way of life. Female-headed families are the fastest-growing family type. The financial burdens fuel the feminization of povertyβthe distinctive character being that a woman has the economic responsibility for children. Money is the key factor affecting depression, self-esteem, and child outcomes.
Fathers and the Single-Parent Household: Custodial fathers have more social support and fewer problems adjusting than custodial mothers. Fathers are usually better educated and occupy higher-level occupations. Financial strength is a key reason why fathers are increasingly awarded sole custody. Single fathers adapt well to household tasks and are meaningfully involved with their children, but they still must deal with gender role stereotyping assuming they cannot be as competent as women.
β Key Takeaways
This lecture demonstrates that gender profoundly shapes every aspect of family life, from the transition to parenthood through divorce and single parenting. The motherhood mandate enforces selfless devotion to children, creating guilt for employed mothers, while fatherhood remains tied to breadwinning despite the emergence of the involved-father model. Dual-earner families are now normative, and research shows no developmental harm to children from employed mothersβthe key factor is child care quality. Family structures vary significantly across racial and ethnic groups, with African American fictive kin networks, Latino familism and gendered marianismo/machismo, Asian American patriarchal collectivism, and Native American historical matrilineal traditions all shaping gender roles differently. Divorce is strongly gendered, with women facing economic devastation (the feminization of poverty) but often better emotional adjustment, while men face different challenges.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the motherhood mandate, and how do functionalist, conflict, and feminist perspectives differ in their analysis of it?
- Explain the difference between the "good-provider model" and the "involved-father model" of fatherhood.
- According to research, what is the key factor affecting children's outcomes in dual-earner families, and what does research say about the "suffering children" theme?
- How do African American families demonstrate flexibility in family boundaries, and what is the significance of fictive kin and "other-mothers"?
- What is the feminization of poverty, and how does gender explain the different economic and emotional outcomes for single-parent mothers versus single-parent fathers?
π Lecture 13 β Men and Masculinity
π Overview: This lecture examines the social construction of masculinity, the norms that define masculine gender roles, and how these expectations impact men's lives. It explores hegemonic masculinity, multiple masculinity norms, stereotypes about men, fatherhood, and how masculinity shapes men's experiences across the life course, including retirement, midlife, and widowhood.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers five main topics: Men and Masculinity (including definitions and hegemonic masculinity), Masculinity Norms (including antifeminine, success, toughness, aggression, sexual prowess, and tenderness norms), Stereotypes about men and masculinity (including their positive and negative consequences), Masculinity and Fatherhood (including images of fatherhood and socialization), and Men at Middle Age and in Later Life (including retirement, midlife crisis, and widowhood experiences for both men and women).
π Lecture Summary
Topic 48: Men and Masculinity
Definitions of masculinity have remained remarkably consistent over time. All sociological perspectives highlight how masculine role ideals have been adapted to the lives of contemporary men. Although definitions may be consistent, masculinity is enacted in myriad ways.
Hegemonic Masculinity
The notion of hegemonic masculinity asserts that a number of competing masculinities are enacted according to particular places (contexts) and particular times. The characteristics of masculinity that become the idealized norm are those acted out by the most powerful men. The taken-for-granted statuses are likely to be those men who are white, middle class, and heterosexual. In this process, all other masculine styles are rendered inadequate and inferior. A good example of enactment of hegemonic masculinity is demonstrated by the gun culture of the United States.
Hegemonic masculinity harms men in subordinate statuses (men of color, poor men, nonheterosexuals) because it narrows their options to choose other enactments of masculinity. It also harms women because it positions masculinity in opposition to women. The key is to recognize who has the power in a given situation to determine what is a dominant masculinity and what is a subordinate one. Hegemonic masculinity of the white, middle-class, heterosexual variety not only is the dominant form, but also, in relation to women, is masculinity.
π Definition β Hegemonic Masculinity: The form of masculinity that becomes the idealized norm, enacted by the most powerful men (white, middle-class, heterosexual), rendering all other masculine styles inadequate and inferior.
Topic 49: Masculinity Norms
Decades of research demonstrate that there are a number of ways masculinity (manliness) can be "successfully" acted out. These different enactments can be subsumed under categories that serve as both traditional and emerging norms of masculinity. Most of these informal rules have become institutionalized norms (also referred to as standards, markers, or themes) that have strengthened over the decades.
Antifeminine Norm
This powerful norm stigmatizes all stereotyped feminine characteristics and the qualities associated with them, including openness in expressing emotions related to vulnerability. It is so closely tied to every other norm of masculinity that it may be viewed as the overarching norm that literally defines masculinity. Males are socialized to adamantly reject all that is considered feminine. Men dichotomize gender more often and more strenuously than women. Women and anything perceived as feminine are less valued than men and anything perceived as masculine. Acceptance of the antifemininity norm and the traditional scripts it includes comes with huge costs.
π Definition β Antifeminine Norm: The overarching masculinity norm that stigmatizes all stereotyped feminine characteristics and qualities, including emotional openness related to vulnerability.
Interpersonal Relations
Beliefs about feminine behavior disallow many men from revealing insecurities and vulnerabilities to others who could help them cope with difficult life situations. Restraints in emotional openness are associated with suicide; Type A behavior; heart disease; and stress-related conditions such as ulcers, stroke, back pain, and tension headaches. Concealing emotions also inhibits development of the repertoire of interpersonal skills essential for successful relationships. Intimate friendships between males are discouraged.
Boys of all ages learn quickly that gestures of intimacy with other males are discouraged and that expressions of femininity, verbally or nonverbally, are not tolerated. Male role modelsβfathers, teachers, brothers, school athletes, peersβprovide the cues and the sanctions to ensure compliance. The "boy code" is monitored carefully by other boys. Anger is accepted, but displays of "soft" emotion are swiftly censured. The culturally inbred antifemininity norm keeps teenage boys from expressing feelings toward other boys on pain of being ridiculed as "sissies" at best or "fags" at worst.
To bolster their formative masculinity, boys strictly segregate themselves from girls in school. Male camaraderie occurs in male-only secret clubs, fraternal organizations, the military, sports teams, or the neighborhood bar. Men rarely talk about friendship in these groups. The antifemininity norm blocks the expression of the deepest feelings of affection between men and reinforces stereotypes about homosexuality.
Men may be considered superior over women, but at the enormous expense of remaining psychologically defensive and insecure. Males of all ages are more likely to express feelings of uncertainty and anxiety to females, but the healthiest men are those who have an array of both male and female friends. Overall, men's endorsement of the antifemininity norm's quest for invulnerability has the opposite effect: It makes them more vulnerable than less vulnerable.
Success Norm
This norm suggests that men are driven to succeed at all costs. Also referred to as the status norm, men need to be looked up to, and prestige is associated with the belief that money makes the man. Manliness is tied to career success and the ability to provide for a family in his breadwinner role. The positive "good provider" role is salient in this norm, but it comes with more than an economic price. Because prestige is gained from their work outside rather than inside the home, competency as a parent is less important than competency in the world of paid labor.
π Definition β Success Norm: The masculinity norm that drives men to succeed at all costs, tying manliness to career success, breadwinning ability, and prestige associated with financial achievement.
Gendered Occupations
In the workplace, men are threatened by women's competence and their entry into traditional masculine occupations, thereby kindling controversy about what constitutes a "man's" job. Men who succeed in feminine jobs are frequently viewed as less competent than those who succeed in masculine jobs. An influx of women in an occupation decreases its attractiveness to men. From a symbolic interaction and social constructionism view, a labeling cycle producing a self-fulfilling prophecy occurs: The job is "feminized," men desert it; working conditions deteriorate, and pay decreases.
In the bleakest recession years, men flocked to female jobs as nurses, caseworkers, elementary school and preschool teachers, and even nannies. Men reported that even with lowered pay, working with children and in caregiving roles offered flexibility, satisfaction, and a belief that they were "making a difference." However, masculinity's stubborn success norm erodes these beliefs. Conflict theory suggests that one reason married men embrace the breadwinner role is that it entitles them to privileges in the home, including less housework, more time for leisure and recreation, and more services provided to them by wife and children.
Intellectual Success
In addition to economic success, males are expected to demonstrate intellectual superiority over women. Although one-third of wives outearn their husbands, men believe that a husband should outearn his wife and that her career success is less important than his. Men are threatened by female coworkers who are promoted over them, and husbands are threatened by wives who are equal or above them occupationally. Gender-related attitudes for men are reemphasizing work roles for men and maternal roles for women.
Toughness Norm
As embodied in war and sports, the toughness norm of masculinity tells men and boys to be strong, confident, self-reliant, brave, and independent. Any male must express confidence in his ability to carry out tasks that appear insurmountable. He must do so with a sense of stoicism that shows he is in command of the situation. The opposite of the tough male is the "wimp." Men may be labeled wimps for crossing boundaries and relating to their partners, wives, and children in "sensitive" ways.
In the strongly gendered world of oil rig crews, tough guy behavior can be personally harmful as well as dysfunctional and dangerous. Displays of risk-taking and masculine strength interfere with safety and performance. Beginning with the police shooting of unarmed African American teenager Michael Brown, events in Ferguson, Missouri spotlight the ongoing challenge African American males in particular confront in navigating masculinity norms. Compared to white males, when a toughness norm is enacted, the consequences can be deadly.
π Definition β Toughness Norm: The masculinity norm requiring men to be strong, confident, self-reliant, brave, independent, and stoic, with any behavior associated with anxiety being its antithesis.
Aggression Norm
As a key marker of manliness, aggression is associated with risk, lack of compromise, and unbending will in the face of adversity. Guns are a powerful symbol of masculinity. Abundant research indicates that males who adhere to traditional masculinity norms are more aggressive. Masculinity ideology is a better predictor of aggression than is gender. Boys learn early that turning the other cheek is less respected than fighting one's way out of a difficult situation.
Functionalists emphasize that by socializing boys into masculinity with the aura of violence and aggression surrounding it, the soldier role, which they may eventually assume, will be easier to accept. In this view, the aggressive masculinity needed in wartime is latently functional. Such views are linked to the antifemininity norm. Toughness, the repression of empathy, less remorse for "accidental" violence, and less concern for moral issues are deemed essential for winning. The problem with this view is that aggression and masculinity become inextricably linked and carry over into the nonwar existence of men.
π Definition β Aggression Norm: The masculinity norm that associates manliness with risk, lack of compromise, unbending will, and the use of force, often reinforced through media glorification of violence and revenge.
Sexual Prowess Norm
The theme of sexuality permeates a norm that may be referred to popularly as "macho man." In this image, men are primarily sexual beings living with ongoing heightened interests in sexuality. Men are judged according to their sexual ability and sexual conquest. Male sexual identity is experienced as sensation and action. Sexual harassment is dismissed as harmless fun rather than as sexual domination or exploitation.
This form of sexual identity is reinforced by essentialist beliefs that masculinity is biologically rather than socially constructed. An "impotent" man is cast into a stigmatized, demeaned category. Media depict a man's sexual performance as a way to confirm his masculinity, with success in sex linked to success in life. When boys and men rely on sexuality to define masculinity, their vulnerability inevitably increases. They gain a measure of respect for sexual talk and bravado of the locker room, but at the same time, they understand that they can never live up to the sexualized selves they present to others.
π Definition β Sexual Prowess Norm: The masculinity norm portraying men as primarily sexual beings who are judged according to their sexual ability and conquest, with male sexual identity experienced as sensation and action.
Tenderness Norm
This emerging norm is characterized by those men who reject a rigid cultural construction of masculinity that disallows them from displaying sensitivity or tenderness to others. Tenderness masculinity encompasses beliefs that expressions of sensitivity are beneficial to men, both personally and socially. Referred to positively as "sensitive guys," men accepting this norm strive for more emotional openness with men and more egalitarian relationships with women.
Because tenderness masculinity allows for less emotional restriction, it is the healthiest of the masculinity norms. Although "anger-out" is masculinity's accepted emotional display, it is the least healthy for men and is socially unproductive. If forgiveness is viewed as feminine, then men also tend to reject it. The tenderness norm is emerging, but it competes with the more powerful aggression and antifeminine norms. When images of tenderness masculinity make their way into the media, they are undermined by the more normative images.
π Definition β Tenderness Norm: The emerging masculinity norm characterized by rejection of rigid cultural constructions of masculinity, allowing for displays of sensitivity, emotional openness, and more egalitarian relationships.
Topic 50: Stereotypes about men and masculinity
Gender stereotypes are commonly held beliefs about males, females, and the transgender. Stereotypes about men include: Men don't cry; Men are brave; Men are strong; Men are bold and courageous; Men are capable.
These stereotypes bring responsibility: Men are heads of family; Men earn for the family; Man is the provider; Men are the protectors; Men should be able to solve every problem; Men are strong.
Consequences of male stereotypes:
- Positive: Self-fulfilling prophecy; Positive self-image; High self-esteem
- Negative: Burden of responsibility; Psychological problems
π Definition β Gender Stereotypes: Commonly held beliefs about males, females, and the transgender that carry both positive consequences (self-fulfilling prophecy, positive self-image) and negative consequences (burden of responsibility, psychological problems).
Topic 51: Masculinity and Fatherhood
Can men have it all? Femininity norms have been flexible enough to accommodate women with aspirations for career, marriage, and children. Masculinity norms have not. The success and toughness norms dictate that men take on the responsibilities of parenthood primarily through their breadwinning roles.
Like women, men envision the American Dream in terms of successful marriage, satisfying career, contented spouse, and happy children. However, men willingly abdicate the daily household and child care responsibilities to their wives. Contrary to common belief, men do not "have it all."
Images of Fatherhood
Fatherhood means more than paternity. The word fathering is associated with sexual and biological connotations. The word mothering is associated with nurturance. The biological father who takes his provider role seriously has met the necessary criterion for masculinity. Employed fathers are viewed more positively than stay-at-home fathers (SAHFs); employed mothers are viewed more negatively than homemakers. In families where men are SAHFs and women are breadwinners, ceding control of parenting to men is difficult.
Complete role reversal is rare. However, despite beliefs about essentialism, SAHFs have high levels of psychological well-being, adjustment, and life and relationship satisfaction. Demeaning stereotypes of bumbling men who do not know how to hold a baby, soothe a sobbing child, or buy groceries persevere and serve to lower the skill level that men need to succeed in domestic roles. Some men use the bumbling father stereotype as a strategy to get out of performing certain tasks.
Regardless of whether he is "playing dumb" to get out of household work, masculinity's antifemininity norm bolsters his behavior. Men who freely choose to take care of their own children as househusbands or SAHFs, who take on equal partnering with their wives, who take care of others' children, or who are early childhood educators are suspect in their masculinity.
Socialization
Although fathers have fewer expectations built into their roles regarding socialization of their children, the child-nurturing roles they do take on are extremely important. Strong fatherβinfant attachment and involvement of fathers with their young children are linked to a child's personality adjustment, positive peer relationships, level of self-esteem, and overall sense of well-being. In homes where fathers are absent or gone much of the time, children are at greater risk for maladaptive psychological, social, and development outcomes.
Decades of research on the aspirations that fathers hold for their children remain remarkably consistent. In all social classes, fathers are stricter in gender-typed intentions of their children than mothers, and they give sons less latitude than daughters in experimenting with different gender role definitions. Fathers pay close attention to the potential for their sons to be breadwinners and good providers but believe their daughters can use a degree "to fall back on."
Topic 52: Men at Middle Age and in Later Life
Sociological perspectives on the life course highlight the process of continuing socialization in the roles people play over a lifetime and the ages associated with those roles.
Retirement
The transition to retirement requires major adjustments in all segments of life. Men undergo a profound shift in identity and ideas about masculinity. The provider-role script and success norms associated with masculinity sharpen an already strong American work ethic from which identity and self-esteem are gained.
Data suggest that retirement satisfaction is based on the same factors for women and men. Women restructure their domestic lives and spend more time with family and on home-related activities. Men take on more extradomestic roles and activities. Gender is less of a predictor of life satisfaction at retirement than are income and health.
Midlife as Crisis
Do men have a midlife crisis? Variously referred to as the male climacteric, male menopause, or midlife crisis, men may present symptoms of night fears, sweats and chills, and depression. These are linked to hormonal changes, such as a sharp drop in testosterone level. Unlike women who experience noticeable changes heralding the cessation of menses, in normal aging for men, the changes are subtle. Older men retain their interest in sex, but sexual performance becomes less predictable. Gender scripts linking masculinity to sexual prowess remain.
Professionals are now viewing these symptoms as normal to the aging process. The appearance of symptoms prompts many men to engage in a review of their lives, make choices, and alter life paths. Others suggest that this stage produces psychological turmoil for men who make unwise decisions that are maladaptive for themselves and their families.
Women at Midlife
For women, the depression that supposedly occurs when the last child is launched is referred to as the empty nest syndrome. Research shows, however, that the empty nest syndrome is largely a myth. Women tend to experience an upturn in psychological well-being when children are launched. Women generally seek expanded roles in a society increasingly receptive to women like themselves.
Men at Midlife
Men may have a more difficult time with the empty nest than women. Some evidence suggests that men's increased depression at midlife is linked to their regrets about career priorities that distanced themselves from their children. Grandchildren provide a sense of biological continuity; emotional self-fulfillment; and a way for men to be free of the competition, arguments, and power struggles they experienced in their workplaces.
Men at midlife often begin to reintegrate the masculine and feminine traits that were separate for most of their lives. Traditional masculinity is tempered by a more well-rounded personality. Women approach midlife differently than men. Men seek greater interdependence at old age, whereas women seek greater autonomy. At this stage, men become more nurturing; women, more independent.
Widowhood
Compared to widows, widowers are much more likely to remarry; thus, among the elderly, the large majority of widows reside alone. Social isolation and loneliness are frequent outcomes of widowhood. Suicide rates among the elderly have increased since the 1980s, and they remain the highest of all age groups. Men account for the large majority of all suicides, and white males in their eighties have the highest suicide rates of all races and both genders.
Widows: The death of a spouse has a profound and devastating effect on the surviving partner, but becoming a widow is a qualitatively different experience than becoming a widower. Older women are more likely to form their identity around marriage, so losing a spouse literally means loss of a central life role. Widows are likely to experience a sudden decrease in standard of living. However, many widows cope with the crisis reasonably well, adapt as necessary, and productively map out the rest of their lives.
Widowers: The role of widower is more vague than that of widow. Masculinity norms earlier in life prevented interpersonal skill building. Lacking the strategies for either preserving or reestablishing intimate relationships, widowers find themselves with reduced social contacts. Traditional norms of masculinity may prevent them from talking out their grief with others. When ongoing relationships and customary responsibilities are shattered, anomie (normlessness) can follow. This pattern helps explain the high suicide rate of elderly males. On the other hand, marriage prospects remain bright for widowers.
π Definition β Anomie: A state of normlessness that can follow when ongoing relationships and customary responsibilities are shattered, helping explain the high suicide rate of elderly males.
π Key Distinction: Widows vs. Widowers
- Widows: Form identity around marriage; experience loss of central life role; decreased standard of living; limited remarriage prospects
- Widowers: Vague role; reduced social contacts due to lack of interpersonal skills; better financial position; higher remarriage rates
β Key Takeaways
The most critical understanding from this lecture is that masculinity is not a single, fixed identity but is enacted through multiple competing normsβantifeminine, success, toughness, aggression, sexual prowess, and emerging tendernessβwith hegemonic masculinity representing the dominant form enacted by white, middle-class, heterosexual men. The antifeminine norm operates as the overarching norm that literally defines masculinity by stigmatizing all feminine characteristics, leading to significant psychological costs including restricted emotional expression, increased stress-related illness, and higher suicide risk among men. Masculinity norms profoundly shape men's life experiences across the life course, from childhood socialization through fatherhood, retirement, midlife, and widowhood, with men who adhere most strongly to traditional norms experiencing the greatest psychological vulnerability. The success and toughness norms create a double bind where men are expected to be breadwinners and providers but are denied meaningful participation in domestic and nurturing roles, leading to regrets about career priorities that distanced them from their children. The emerging tenderness norm offers a healthier alternative that allows for emotional openness and egalitarian relationships, but it remains subordinate to more powerful traditional norms.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is hegemonic masculinity and which groups typically enact the dominant form?
- How does the antifeminine norm function as the overarching masculinity norm, and what are its psychological consequences?
- According to conflict theory, why do married men embrace the breadwinner role?
- How do men's and women's experiences of widowhood differ, and why do elderly widowers have the highest suicide rates?
- What is the empty nest syndrome, and why is research showing it is largely a myth?